π Lecture 7 β The Direct Method
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Direct Method as a reaction to the failure of the Grammar Translation Method, emphasizing spoken language use over grammatical analysis. It covers the method's principles, strengths and weaknesses, opportunities and threats, its applicability in the Pakistani context, and sample classroom activities. Understanding this method is crucial for comparing historical language teaching approaches.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the Direct Method and its historical context, aims, and key principles such as no translation and primacy of spoken word. It then analyzes the method's strengths (e.g., practical goals, immersion) and weaknesses (e.g., prohibition of mother tongue). Next, it explores opportunities for learners and threats to effective implementation. Finally, it discusses the Direct Method's limited use in Pakistan and provides a step-by-step guide for conducting sample activities.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-031: What is the Direct Method?
By the end of the 19th century, the Grammar Translation Method (GTM) failed to meet societal needs, leading to the creation of the Direct Method, which stressed the ability to use language rather than analyze it. Established in Germany and France around 1900, it contrasts with GTM and other approaches. It was adopted by international language schools like Berlitz and Inlingua in the 1970s and the U.S. Foreign Service Institute in 2012.
Proponents opposed teaching formal grammar, knowing language learning was more than rules and translation skills. The spoken word was given primacy; the printed word was kept away until a good grasp of speech was achieved. Material was presented orally with actions and pictures, and the mother tongue was never used. Culture was considered important.
Aims of the Direct Method:
- Build a direct way into the target language, linking experience and language.
- Help students learn to communicate in the target language.
- Have learners experience the new language as they did their mother tongue, without considering it.
So DMT believes in:
- No translation
- Concepts taught via objects or context
- Oral training helping reading, writing, listening, and speaking simultaneously
- Grammar taught indirectly
Ways to achieve these aims include:
- Question/answer exercises
- Dictation
- Reading aloud
- Self-correction
- Conversation practice
- Paragraph writing
Topic-032: Strengths and Weaknesses of the Direct Method
Practical goals and immersion into a foreign environment, with a focus on speaking and listening, are major strengths. The greatest weaknesses are the underestimated role of reading and writing and the counterproductive prohibition of using the mother tongue.
π Strengths:
- Wide use of authentic materials
- Presenting language items in dialogues, not isolation
- Natural order of skills: listening, speaking, reading, writing
- Speech and listening comprehension taught
- Correct pronunciation and grammar emphasized
- Students taught to ask and answer questions from inception
π Weaknesses:
- Underestimated role of reading and writing
- Counterproductive prohibition of using mother tongue
- Overestimated role of mechanical drilling where meaning is often irrelevant
- Lack of flexibility
Topic-033: The Direct Method: Opportunities and Threats
Learners have opportunities to activate all channels of perception, and language acquisition is facilitated by enormous authentic input. These opportunities include facilitating understanding of language, establishing bonds between contexts, improving fluency of speech, aiding reading, and developing language sense. The method is full of activities, emphasizes the target language, develops the four skills in a natural sequence, and makes use of audio-visual aids.
π Opportunities:
- Facilitates understanding of language and inhibits mother tongue interference
- Establishes bond between contexts
- Improves fluency and aids reading
- Improves development of language sense
- Full of interesting and exciting activities
- Develops listening, speaking, reading, and writing in natural sequence
- Brings words from passive to active vocabulary
Threats include a lack of explicit rules leading to misinterpretations, time-consuming drilling, and ignoring systematic written work and reading activities. It supports only limited vocabulary, may only profit the clever child, needs skilled teachers, and does not suit individual needs in large classes. It is inconvenient in huge classes and ignores reading and writing aspects.
π Threats:
- Lack of explicit rules causes misinterpretations
- Time-consuming drilling
- Ignores systematic written work and reading activities
- Supports only limited vocabulary
- Only suits clever children
- Needs skilled teachers
- Inconvenient in large classes
Topic-034: Direct Method and Pakistani Context
The Direct Method was an answer to dissatisfaction with the older GTM, which focuses on the written language through direct translations. However, in Pakistan, GTM is still widely used, and the Direct Method is used in a very restricted sense. The nature and degree of practices differ between public sector and private sector education. For future use, possibilities exist for the Direct Method, but there is a need for proper teacher training.
Topic-035: Direct Method Sample Activities
Here are key steps and aspects for conducting activities using this method:
- SHOW β Point to a visual aid or use gestures to ensure understanding.
- SAY β Teacher verbally introduces the element with care and enunciation.
- TRY β Student makes various attempts to pronounce the new element.
- MOLD β Teacher corrects the student if necessary, showing proper shaping of lips, tongue, and relationship to teeth.
- REPEAT β Student repeats each element 5-20 times.
- SAY & REPEAT β Teacher states a phrase; student repeats 5-15 times.
- ASK & REPLY IN NEGATIVE β Teacher uses the element in negative situations (e.g., "Are you the President?"); student says "No."
- INTERROGATIVES β Teacher provides examples using the 5 "w"s (Who, What, Where, Why, When) or "How" with random variations.
- PRONOUNS WITH VERBS β Using visuals or gestures, teacher covers all pronouns with random variations.
- STUDENT-LED LIMITS β Teacher observes the student to know when mental "saturation" is reached, indicating no more elements should be taught.
- REVIEW β Teacher uses random, arbitrary sequencing, possibly with visuals, changing names and words the student knows.
- OBSERVATION and Notation β Teacher maintains a "Special Attention List" of words/phrases most difficult for that student.
β Key Takeaways
The Direct Method was a radical shift from the Grammar Translation Method, prioritizing spoken language and immersion while explicitly forbidding the use of the mother tongue and formal grammar instruction. Its core strengths lie in practical communication and authentic input, but its major weaknesses include the underestimated role of reading/writing and a counterproductive ban on L1 use. In the Pakistani context, GTM remains dominant, and the Direct Method is applied very restrictively, requiring significant teacher training for wider adoption. The sample activities provide a structured, step-by-step approach for teachers to implement the method, emphasizing visual aids, repetition, and careful observation of student saturation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What were the main reasons for the failure of the Grammar Translation Method that led to the creation of the Direct Method?
- List the four core beliefs of the Direct Method regarding translation, concepts, oral training, and grammar.
- Identify two major strengths and two major weaknesses of the Direct Method.
- Explain why the Direct Method is described as having "counterproductive prohibition of using mother tongue" as a weakness.
- According to the lecture, what is the current status of the Direct Method in the Pakistani educational context?
π Lecture 08 β AUDIO-LINGUAL METHOD
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Audio-lingual Method, a language teaching approach that emerged in the United States in the late 1950s as a response to the need for more effective foreign language instruction. It examines the historical context, theoretical foundations in structural linguistics and behavioral psychology, syllabus design, classroom procedures, and the eventual decline of the method due to theoretical and practical criticisms.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the background of the Audio-lingual Method, tracing its origins to the U.S. government's response to the launch of Sputnik and the National Defense Education Act. It then details the theoretical principles behind the method, including its theories of language, language learning, and language teaching. The lecture further discusses the contents of the method, its objectives, syllabus, and specific classroom procedures, including input modifications and interactional activities. Finally, it provides a critical assessment of the method's decline, citing Chomsky's critique and the emergence of alternative approaches.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-036: Background of Audio-lingual Method
The Audio-lingual Method emerged in the United States toward the end of the 1950s, prompted by the launch of the first Russian satellite in 1957, which highlighted the need for a radical change in foreign language teaching. The U.S. government, through the National Defense Education Act (1958), provided funds for language study, teaching materials, and teacher training. Language teaching specialists drew on earlier army programs (the Army Specialized Training Program or ASTP) and the Aural-Oral or Structural Approach, adding insights from behaviorist psychology. This combination of structural linguistic theory, contrastive analysis, aural-oral procedures, and behaviorist psychology led to the Audio-lingual Method. The term "Audio-lingualism" was coined by Professor Nelson Brooks in 1964. The method claimed to have transformed language teaching from an art into a science and was widely adopted in North American colleges.
π Definition β Audio-lingual Method: A language teaching method based on structural linguistics and behavioral psychology that emphasizes the systematic teaching of listening and speaking through dialogue memorization and pattern drilling.
Topic-037: Theoretical Principles Behind Audio-lingual Method
The fundamental principles of language-centered pedagogy, including the Audio-lingual Method, are drawn from structural linguistics and behavioral psychology.
Theory of Language: Language-centered pedagogists believed language is a system of systems consisting of hierarchically linked building blocks: phonemes, morphemes, phrases, clauses, and sentences. Structural linguists viewed language as auralβoral, emphasizing listening and speaking, and considered speech as primary. Every language was seen as unique, with a finite number of structural patterns that could be analyzed, described, and taught.
Theory of Language Learning: The theory of language learning was derived from behaviorism, which viewed all learning as a mechanism of stimulus, response, and reinforcement. The key assumptions included: language learning is the same as learning any other skill (like riding a bicycle); it is a process of mechanical habit formation through repetition; habit formation occurs by means of analogy rather than analysis; learning is linear and incremental, with discrete items mastered one at a time; and items should be introduced in carefully constructed dialogues.
Theory of Language Teaching: Language teaching is a mirror image of its theory of learning. The teacher serves as a model providing linguistic input and later acts as a manipulator of questions and cues to elicit correct responses. Pattern practice was considered the most important aspect of teaching, as it "capitalizes on the mind's capacity to perceive identity of structure where there is difference in content and its quickness to learn by analogy" (Brooks, 1964). Learners "require drill, drill, and more drill" (Hockett, 1959).
Approach β Theory of Language Underlying Audio-lingualism: Structural linguistics emerged as a reaction to traditional grammar, which was linked to philosophy and mentalism. The scientific approach involved collecting examples of speech and analyzing them according to different levels of structural organization. Language was viewed as a system of structurally related elements for encoding meaning. An important tenet was that speech is language, and it assumed priority in teaching. William Moulton (1961) proclaimed: "Language is speech, not writing. A language is a set of habits... Teach the language, not about the language."
Theory of Learning of Audio-lingualism: Behavioral psychology, particularly the work of B.F. Skinner, claimed to have tapped the secrets of all human learning. To the behaviorist, learning depends on three elements: a stimulus that elicits behavior; a response triggered by the stimulus; and reinforcement that marks the response as appropriate and encourages repetition. Language mastery is represented as acquiring a set of appropriate language stimulus-response chains. Key learning principles included: foreign language learning is mechanical habit formation; skills are learned more effectively if presented in spoken form first; analogy provides a better foundation than analysis; and meanings are learned only in a linguistic and cultural context.
Topic-038: Contents in Audio-lingual Method
Language-centered methods adhere to the synthetic approach to syllabus design, where content is defined in terms of discrete items of grammatical and lexical forms. The syllabus designer selects and sequences phonological, lexical, and grammatical elements. Selection and gradation are the two main challenges. For selection, criteria include frequency (items learners encounter most), range (spread of an item across texts), and availability (necessity and appropriateness). For gradation, criteria include complexity (easy to difficult), regularity (regular to irregular), and productivity (more useful to less useful). Critics have questioned the psychological reality of these linguistic categories, but some sort of selection and sequencing is necessary.
Topic-039: Objectives, Syllabus and Classroom Procedures in Audio-lingual Method
Objectives: Brooks distinguishes between short-range and long-range objectives. Short-range objectives include training in listening comprehension, accurate pronunciation, recognition of speech symbols, and ability to reproduce these symbols in writing. These imply control of structures, acquaintance with vocabulary, and meaning. Long-range objectives are language as the native speaker uses it, with a focus on oral proficiency equated with accurate pronunciation and grammar.
The Syllabus: Audio-lingualism uses a linguistic or structure-based syllabus containing key items of phonology, morphology, and syntax. A lexical syllabus of basic vocabulary items is also specified. Language skills are taught in the order: listening, speaking, reading, and writing. Listening is viewed as training in aural discrimination of basic sound patterns. When reading and writing are introduced, students read and write what they have already learned orally.
Procedure: Teaching involves extensive oral instruction with little grammatical explanation. Key procedures include: modeling of all learning by the teacher; subordination of the mother tongue; early training of ear and tongue; learning structure through pattern practice; gradual substitution of graphic symbols for sounds; and summarizing structural principles only after they are familiar. In a typical lesson: (1) Students hear a model dialogue, repeat each line, and memorize it; (2) The dialogue is adapted to students' interests; (3) Key structures are selected for pattern drills; (4) Students refer to textbooks for follow-up reading/writing; (5) Follow-up activities may occur in the language laboratory.
Input Modifications: The method adheres almost exclusively to form-based input modifications. Manipulating input involves selecting grammatical items, grading them, and making them salient through teacher-fronted instruction. Paulston and Bruder (1975) suggested three types of drills: mechanical drills (automatic, one correct response), meaningful drills (habit formation with more than one correct response), and communicative drills (transferring patterns to communicative situations, though still a cue-response pattern).
Interactional Activities: Interaction is characterized by three Psβpresentation, practice, and production. At the presentation stage, linguistic items are introduced through carefully constructed dialogues. At the practice stage, learners practice through mechanical, meaningful, or communicative drills with substitution tables. At the production stage, learners role-play dialogues and talk about selected topics in controlled contexts.
Types of Learning and Teaching Activities: Dialogues and drills form the basis of classroom practices. Brooks (1964) includes 12 types of drills: repetition, inflection, replacement, restatement, completion, transposition, expansion, contraction, transformation, integration, rejoinder, and restoration.
Learnerβs Roles: Learners are viewed as organisms that can be directed to produce correct responses. They play a reactive role, responding to stimuli with little control over content, pace, or style. They are not encouraged to initiate interaction to avoid mistakes.
Teacherβs Role: The teacher's role is central and activeβa teacher-dominated method. The teacher models the target language, controls the direction and pace, and monitors performance. The teacher must introduce the four skills in order, use English selectively, model language behavior, teach spoken language in dialogue form, direct choral responses, teach structure through pattern practice, and establish a "cultural island."
The Role of Instructional Materials: Instructional materials are primarily teacher-oriented. A student textbook is often not used in the elementary phase. The teacher has a teacher's book with structured sequences. Tape recorders and audiovisual equipment have a central role, providing accurate models. A language laboratory is considered essential for further drill work and controlled practice.
Topic-040: Decline of Audio-lingual Method: A Critical Assessment
Audio-lingualism reached its peak in the 1960s but faced criticism on two fronts. The theoretical foundations were attacked as unsound by Noam Chomsky, who rejected structural linguistics and behaviorist theory. Chomsky argued that "Language is not a habit structure" and that ordinary linguistic behavior involves innovation and formation of new sentences. His theory of transformational grammar proposed that language derives from innate aspects of the mind. Practitioners also found that students could not transfer skills to real communication and found the procedures boring. This led to the proposal of cognitive code learning theory by John B. Carroll (1966), which allowed for conscious focus on grammar and acknowledged abstract mental processes. In the 1970s and 1980s, several alternative methods emerged, including Total Physical Response, the Silent Way, and Counseling-Learning, followed by Communicative Language Teaching, the Natural Approach, and Task-Based Teaching.
π‘ Why this matters: The Audio-lingual Method's decline demonstrates the importance of aligning language teaching methods with current theories of both language and learning. Its failure to produce communicative competence led to a paradigm shift toward more communicative and learner-centered approaches.
β Key Takeaways
The Audio-lingual Method was a systematic, scientifically-claimed approach that emerged from a combination of structural linguistics and behavioral psychology, emphasizing habit formation through dialogue memorization and pattern drilling. Its core principle was that language learning is a mechanical process of stimulus-response-reinforcement, with speech considered primary and skills taught in a rigid sequence of listening, speaking, reading, and writing. The method's theoretical foundations were challenged by Noam Chomsky's transformational grammar, which argued that language involves creativity and abstract rules rather than habit formation, leading to the method's decline. Despite its shortcomings, the Audio-lingual Method represents a milestone as the first method based on well-articulated theories of language and learning, though it failed to produce communicative competence in real-world situations. Critically, students often could not transfer skills acquired through audio-lingual procedures to real communication, and many found the experience boring and unsatisfying.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What historical event prompted the U.S. government to invest in foreign language teaching, leading to the Audio-lingual Method?
- According to behaviorist learning theory, what are the three crucial elements in learning, and how do they apply to language learning?
- What was Noam Chomsky's main criticism of the Audio-lingual Method's theory of language learning?
- List the four language skills in the order they are taught in the Audio-lingual Method, and explain why this order is important.
- What are the three types of drills suggested by Paulston and Bruder, and how do they differ from each other?
π Lecture 9 β Total Physical Response Method
π Overview: This lecture introduces Total Physical Response (TPR), a language teaching method developed by James Asher that coordinates speech and action through physical motor activity. It explains the theoretical foundations of TPRβincluding the bio-program for language learning, brain lateralization, and stress reductionβand details its practical application in the classroom, including objectives, syllabus design, learner and teacher roles, and specific teaching procedures.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers five main topics: the background of Total Physical Response Method, including its origins and influences from developmental psychology and humanistic pedagogy; the approach and theory behind TPR, including the bio-program, brain lateralization, and reduction of stress; the objectives, syllabus, and learning activities in TPR; the roles of learners, teachers, and materials in TPR; and a detailed procedure illustrating a TPR classroom lesson with review, new commands, role reversal, and reading/writing activities.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-041: Background of Total Physical Response Method
Total Physical Response (TPR) is a language teaching method built around the coordination of speech and action; it attempts to teach language through physical (motor) activity. It was developed by James Asher, a professor of psychology at San Jose State University, California, and draws on several traditions, including developmental psychology and humanistic pedagogy, as well as on language teaching procedures proposed by Harold and Dorothy Palmer in 1925. In a developmental sense, Asher sees successful adult second language learning as a parallel process to a childβs first language acquisition. He claims that speech directed to young children consists primarily of commands, which children respond to physically before they begin to produce verbal responses. He feels that adults should recapitulate the processes by which children acquire their native language. Asher shares with the school of humanistic psychology a concern for the role of affective (emotional) factors in language learning. A method that is undemanding in terms of linguistic production and that involves game-like movements reduces learner stress, he believes, and creates a positive mood in the learner, which facilitates learning.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the background of TPR reveals why it is fundamentally different from grammar-translation or audio-lingual methodsβit prioritizes physical action and emotional safety as the foundation for language acquisition.
Topic-042: Approach & Theory behind Total Physical Response Method
TPR reflects a grammar-based view of language. Asher states that "most of the grammatical structure of the target language and hundreds of vocabulary items can be learned from the skillful use of the imperative by the instructor" (1977, p. 4). He views the verb, and particularly the verb in the imperative, as the central linguistic motif around which language use and learning are organized. Asher sees a stimulus-response view as providing the learning theory underlying language teaching pedagogy. TPR can also be linked to the "trace theory" of memory in psychology (e.g., Katona 1940), which holds that the more often or the more intensively a memory connection is traced, the stronger the memory association will be and the more likely it will be recalled. Retracing can be done verbally (e.g., by rote repetition) and/or in association with motor activity. Combined tracing activities, such as verbal rehearsal accompanied by motor activity, increase the possibility of successful recall.
In addition, Asher has elaborated an account of what he feels facilitates or inhibits foreign language learning. For this dimension of his learning theory, he draws on three rather influential learning hypotheses:
- There exists a specific innate bio-program for language learning, which defines an optimal path for first and second language development.
- Brain lateralization defines different learning functions in the left- and right-brain hemispheres.
- Stress (an affective filter) intervenes between the act of learning and what is to be learned; the lower the stress, the greater the learning.
The Bio-Program: Asher's Total Physical Response is a "Natural Method", in as much as Asher sees first and second language learning as parallel processes. He sees three processes as central:
- Children develop listening competence before they develop the ability to speak. At the early stages of first language acquisition, they can understand complex utterances that they cannot spontaneously produce or imitate.
- Children's ability in listening comprehension is acquired because children are required to respond physically to spoken language in the form of parental commands.
- Once a foundation in listening comprehension has been established, speech evolves naturally and effortlessly out of it.
- Parallel to the processes of first language learning, the foreign language learner should first internalize a "cognitive map" of the target language through listening exercises. Listening should be accompanied by physical movement. Speech and other productive skills should come later. Asher bases these assumptions on his belief in the existence in the human brain of a bio-program for language, which defines an optimal order for first and second language learning.
π Definition β Bio-program for language: "A reasonable hypothesis is that the brain and nervous system are biologically programmed to acquire language in a particular sequence and in a particular mode. The sequence is listening before speaking and the mode is to synchronize language with the individual's body." (Asher 1977, p. 4)
Brain lateralization: Asher sees Total Physical Response as directed to right-brain learning, whereas most second language teaching methods are directed to left-brain learning. Drawing on the works by Jean Piaget, Asher holds that the child language learner acquires language through motor movementβa right hemisphere activity. Right-hemisphere activities must occur before the left hemisphere can process language for production. Similarly, the adult should proceed to language mastery through right-hemisphere motor activities, while the left hemisphere watches and learns. When a sufficient amount of right-hemisphere learning has taken place, the left hemisphere will be triggered to produce language and to initiate other, more abstract language processes.
Reduction of Stress: An important condition for successful language learning is the absence of stress. First language acquisition takes place in a stress-free environment, according to Asher; whereas the adult language learning environment often causes considerable stress and anxiety. The key to stress-free learning is to tap into the natural bio-program for language development and thus to recapture the relaxed and pleasurable experiences that accompany first language learning. By focusing on meaning interpreted through movement, rather than on language forms studied in the abstract, the learner is said to be liberated from self-conscious and stressful situations and is able to devote full energy to learning.
π‘ Why this matters: The three hypothesesβbio-program, brain lateralization, and stress reductionβform the complete theoretical scaffold for TPR. They explain why the method uses commands and physical response, why it delays speaking, and why it creates a low-anxiety environment.
Topic-043: Objectives Syllabus and Learning Activities in Total Physical Response Method
Objectives: The general objectives of Total Physical Response are to teach oral proficiency at a beginning level. Comprehension is a means to an end, and the ultimate aim is to teach basic speaking skills. A TPR course aims to produce learners who are capable of an uninhibited communication that is intelligible to a native speaker. Specific instructional objectives are not elaborated, for these will depend on the particular needs of the learners. Whatever goals are set, however, must be attainable through the use of action-based drills in the imperative form.
Syllabus: The type of syllabus Asher uses can be inferred from an analysis of the exercise types employed in TPR classes. This analysis reveals the use of a sentence-based syllabus with grammatical and lexical criteria being primary in selecting teaching items. Unlike methods that operate from a grammar-based or structural view of the core elements of language, Total Physical Response requires initial attention to meaning rather than to the form of items. Grammar is thus taught inductively. Asher also suggests that a fixed number of items be introduced at a time, to facilitate ease of differentiation and assimilation. "In an hour, it is possible for students to assimilate 12 to 36 new lexical items depending upon the size of the group and the stage of training." (Asher 1977, p. 42) A course designed around Total Physical Response principles, however, would not be expected to follow a TPR syllabus exclusively.
Learning Activities: Imperative drills are the major classroom activity in Total Physical Response. They are typically used to elicit physical actions and activity on the part of the learners. Conversational dialogues are delayed until after about 120 hours of instruction. Other class activities include role plays and slide presentations. Role plays center on everyday situations, such as at the restaurant, supermarket, or gas station.
Topic-044: Role of Learners Teachers and Material in Total Physical Response Method
Learners in Total Physical Response have the primary roles of listener and performer. They listen attentively and respond physically to commands given by the teacher. Learners are also expected to recognize and respond to novel combinations of previously taught items. They are required to produce novel combinations of their own. Learners monitor and evaluate their own progress. They are encouraged to speak when they feel ready to speakβthat is, when a sufficient basis in the language has been internalized.
The teacher plays an active and direct role in Total Physical Response. It is the teacher who decides what to teach, who models and presents the new materials, and who selects supporting materials for classroom use. Asher recommends detailed lesson plans: "It is wise to write out the exact utterances you will be using and especially the novel commands because the action is so fast-moving there is usually not time for you to create spontaneously" (1977, p. 47). Asher stresses, however, that the teacher's role is not so much to teach as to provide opportunities for learning. The teacher has the responsibility of providing the best kind of exposure to language so that the learner can internalize the basic rules of the target language. Thus the teacher controls the language input the learners receive, providing the raw material for the "cognitive map" that the learners will construct in their own minds. The teacher should also allow speaking abilities to develop in learners at the learners' own natural pace. In giving feedback, the teacher should follow the example of parents giving feedback to their children. At first, parents correct very little, but as the child grows older, parents are said to tolerate fewer mistakes in speech. Similarly, teachers should refrain from too much correction in the early stages and should not interrupt to correct errors, since this will inhibit learners. As time goes on, however, more teacher intervention is expected, as the learners' speech becomes "fine-tuned."
Materials and realia play an increasing role in later learning stages. For absolute beginners, lessons may not require the use of materials, since the teacher's voice, actions, and gestures may be a sufficient basis for classroom activities. Later, the teacher may use common classroom objects, such as books, pens, cups, furniture. As the course develops, the teacher will need to make or collect supporting materials to support teaching points. These may include pictures, realia, slides, and word charts. Asher has developed TPR student kits that focus on specific situations, such as the home, the supermarket, the beach. Students may use the kits to construct scenes (e.g., "Put the stove in the kitchen").
Topic-045: Procedure in Total Physical Response Method
Asher (1977) provides a lesson-by-lesson account of a course taught according to TPR principles, which serves as a source of information on the procedures used in the TPR classroom. The course was for adult immigrants and consisted of 159 hours of classroom instruction. The sixth class in the course proceeded in the following way:
Review: This was a fast-moving warm-up in which individual students were moved with commands such as:
- Pablo, drive your car around Miako and honk your horn.
- Jeffe, throw the red flower to Maria.
- Maria, scream.
- Rita, pick up the knife and spoon and put them in the cup.
- Eduardo, take a drink of water and give the cup to Elaine.
New commands: These verbs were introduced:
- Wash your hands / your face / your hair
- Look for a towel / the soap / a comb
- Hold the book / the cup / the soap
- Comb your hair / Maria's hair / Shirou's hair
- Brush your teeth / your pants / the table
Other items introduced were:
- Rectangle: Draw a rectangle on the chalkboard. Pick up a rectangle from the table and give it to me. Put the rectangle next to the square.
- Triangle: Pick up the triangle from the table and give it to me. Catch the triangle and put it next to the rectangle.
- Quickly: Walk quickly to the door and hit it. Quickly, run to the table and touch the square. Sit down quickly and laugh.
- Slowly: Walk slowly to the window and jump. Slowly, stand up. Slowly walk to me and hit me on the arm.
- Toothpaste: Look for the toothpaste. Throw the toothpaste to Wing. Wing, unscrew the top of the toothpaste.
- Toothbrush: Take out your toothbrush. Brush your teeth. Put your toothbrush in your book.
- Teeth: Touch your teeth. Show your teeth to Dolores. Dolores, point to Eduardo's teeth.
- Soap: Look for the soap. Give the soap to Elaine. Elaine, put the soap in Ramiro's ear.
- Towel: Put the towel on Juan's arm. Juan, put the towel on your head and laugh. Maria, wipe your hands on the towel.
Next, the instructor asked simple questions which the student could answer with a gesture such as pointing:
- Where is the towel? [Eduardo, point to the towel!]
- Where is the toothbrush? [Miako, point to the toothbrush!]
- Where is Dolores?
Role reversal: Students readily volunteered to utter commands that manipulated the behavior of the instructor and other students.
Reading and writing: The instructor wrote on the chalkboard each new vocabulary item and a sentence to illustrate the item. Then she spoke each item and acted out the sentence. The students listened as she read the material. Some copied the information in their notebooks.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point from this lecture is that Total Physical Response is built on the principle of coordinating language with physical movement, derived from the belief that first language acquisition occurs through listening and physical response to commands before speaking emerges naturally. The three theoretical pillarsβthe bio-program (listening before speaking), brain lateralization (right-hemisphere motor activity precedes left-hemisphere language production), and stress reduction (low-anxiety environments facilitate learning)βinform every aspect of TPR practice. The method uses imperative drills as its core activity, with a sentence-based syllabus where grammar is taught inductively through meaning-focused action. Learners are listeners and performers who speak only when ready, while the teacher acts as the primary director of input, providing novel commands and delaying correction. The detailed procedure from Asher's 159-hour course demonstrates the standard sequence: review, new commands with physical response, simple gesture-based questions, role reversal (student commands), and reading/writing.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three learning hypotheses that Asher draws upon for his theory of what facilitates or inhibits foreign language learning?
- According to the bio-program hypothesis, what is the optimal sequence for language acquisition, and what mode of learning does it require?
- How does Asher explain the role of brain lateralization in TPR, and why does he believe right-hemisphere activity must come before left-hemisphere processing?
- What is the primary role of the learner in TPR, and when are learners encouraged to begin speaking?
- Describe the five-step procedure demonstrated in Asher's sixth class, including the type of activities used in each step.