๐ Lecture 30 โ TEACHING READING IN A LANGUAGE CLASSROOM
๐ Overview: This lecture addresses the crucial role of reading instruction in second and foreign language curricula, emphasizing that reading is not a skill easily acquired by learners. It explores reading and viewing as multifaceted comprehension processes, examines theoretical models of reading, and provides practical strategies and frameworks for effective classroom instruction to develop students' language skills and strategic competence.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing reading and viewing as language skills, defining them as processes of meaning-making through print and multimodal media. It then examines three main groups of reading models: top-down, bottom-up, and interactive models, along with sociocultural perspectives and critical pedagogy. Factors affecting reading and viewing success are analyzed, including text, reader/viewer, and social context variables. Finally, the lecture discusses effective instruction, metacognitive development, and practical classroom strategies such as the K-W-L procedure.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-146: Introduction to Teaching Reading in a Language Classroom
Reading is a commonly offered skill in many second and foreign language curricula, yet it is not a skill easily acquired by learners (Nuttall, 1996). Teachers' instruction is crucial for students' success, especially when considering reading's role in developing other language skills like speaking, listening, vocabulary, and writing. Traditional reading lessons seldom blend reading into viewing and vice versa to make lessons dynamic and interactive. A framework for instruction takes an inclusive approach, bringing forth theoretical perspectives and practical strategies such as activating schemata, previewing, predicting, skimming, scanning, reading and linking, viewing and connecting, and packaged procedures like D-R-T-A and K-W-L.
Reading is understood as a process of deriving meaning from printed words, sentences, paragraphs, or a whole text. Viewing is defined as the viewer's effort for meaning-making through non-print-based media, typically involving computers, smartphones, or other digital tools for acquiring and processing information presented in multi-modalities (concurrent video, audio, and images mingled with words), requiring multiliteracy skills. Both readers and viewers must be strategic in their processing, guided by rich metacognitive knowledge (Zhang, 2010).
Meaning-making in reading or viewing is determined and affected by three important variables:
- Text characteristics (including multimodal texts, images, visuals, and sounds)
- Reader/viewer characteristics
- Social context
Contemporary approaches examine reading and viewing from sociological and cultural perspectives, where critical reading and viewing become essential. Four important views on reading, known as 'models of reading', are taken into consideration to organize classroom activities.
Topic-147: Views on Reading and Viewing: Classroom Activities
During the era of behaviorism, especially in the USA and Canada, reading was once banned as a research agenda for psychologists because the reading process was considered too mentalistic to measure. Theoretical models thrived after behaviorism declined with three main groups: Top-Down, Bottom-Up, and Interactive models.
Top-Down and Bottom-Up Models
Top-down models view reading as a meaning-driven or reader-driven process. As Goodman (1996) states, reading is 'a psycholinguistic guessing game', where much of the meaning resides in the reader, who must interpret the text using existing schematic knowledge. This view is widely shared among L2 researchers because non-decoding factors contribute to reading success (Yorio, 1971; Zhang, Gu, and Hu, 2008).
Bottom-up models view reading as a process where the reader goes through the text in a linear fashion, starting from the smallest unit in print. This process is mainly text-bound, with meaning becoming self-evident as soon as words are decoded. Bottom-up and top-down models represent two polarities of reading models (Ehrich et al., 2013).
๐ Definition โ Top-Down Model: A model of reading where meaning is reader-driven; the reader interprets the text using existing schematic knowledge and prior experiences. ๐ Definition โ Bottom-Up Model: A model of reading where the reader processes text linearly, starting from the smallest units (words/letters), with meaning emerging from successful decoding.
Interactive Models
Stanovich's (2000) 'interactive-compensatory model' argues that both top-down and bottom-up processes are important in learning to read. Skilled readers possess accurate and automatic perceptual abilities in word recognition, so they do not usually need to guess. Poor readers, however, usually guess, and their guessing is frequently short-circuited by limited linguistic proficiency (Yorio, 1971). This creates a 'short-circuit effect' for L2 learners whose linguistic proficiency is too low for efficient reading. Interactive models have been advocated for L2 reading instruction (Carrell, 1988). The central issue of whether reading in a foreign/second language is a reading problem or a language problem has been extensively debated. Research now shows it is both: not only a language/linguistic problem but also a reading problem (Grabe & Stoller, 2011).
๐ Formula: Interactive-Compensatory Model: Top-down processing + Bottom-up processing โ Reading comprehension (especially for beginning/bilingual readers)
Use of Reading/Viewing Strategies
Pressley and Afflerbach (1995) define reading strategies as readers' deliberate and effortful mental or physical problem-solving moves in approaching a text for comprehension. Strategic reading comprehension is more often associated with top-down and interactive reading models.
Sociocultural Perspectives on Reading and Viewing
Sociocultural perspectives stress the importance of sociocultural contexts in which reading and viewing take place. Learners' lived experiences shape their interpretation or comprehension of texts. According to Heath (1996), reading and viewing are multi-literacy practices and as 'literacy events' carry social meanings that cause human development and social change.
Critical reading and viewing pedagogy invites learners to approach learning materials with an attitude to question the text and its author. Teachers ask learners to consider the text with reference to author, purpose, intended audiences, context, and promotion of cultural practices. As Luke and Freebody (1997) argue, no text is neutral. Different ideologies and political motifs drive writers to compose, so dialogic interactions with students are recommended so students can become critical readers who do not accept ideas as presented.
Topic-148: Factors Affecting Reading and Viewing Success in a Language Classroom
Three important variables affect reading or viewing in both L1 and L2 contexts:
- Text characteristics โ vary according to different text types. Narrative texts have organizational structure (orientation, events description, complication, resolution, conclusion) and linguistic features (dominant past tense, descriptive adjectives, action verbs, use of indirect/direct speech). Expository texts have structures like compare-contrast, problem-solution, listing, and cause-effect.
- Reader/viewer characteristics โ diverse metacognition, repertoires of reading/viewing strategies, lived experiences, social and world knowledge, linguistic proficiency, reading competencies, gender, attitudes toward reading/viewing, and socioeconomic backgrounds.
- Social context โ different sociocultural contexts require different reading/viewing strategies. Readers and viewers derive meanings based on their cultural models and knowledge.
๐ก Why this matters: Teachers' instruction must account for this diversity when designing lesson plans, as the same text will be approached differently by different readers.
Topic-149: Effective Instruction in Reading and Viewing: A Language Classroom
Teachers' explicit delivery with sufficient scaffolding makes a difference in helping students read/view and learn in both L1 and L2. Educational psychologists devise approaches and test them through control and experimental groups to examine pedagogical interventions (Zhang, 2008). Much progress has been made in L1 and L2 reading instruction research (Pressley, 2007; Bernhardt, 2005; Debarera et al., 2014), but relatively little about instruction in viewing.
Research-Informed Pedagogical Recommendations
Strategies-based reading instruction has been the major trend in educational psychology. Social constructivism has been incorporated into L2 reading instruction (Zhang, 2008). Social constructivists argue that meaning is constructed through dialogue, and learning occurs within the learner's Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD) through the co-construction of knowledge (Vygotsky, 1986).
๐ Definition โ Zone of Proximal Development (ZPD): The level beyond the current competence of the learner where learning takes place through co-construction of knowledge and dialogue.
Topic-150: Teaching Reading and Viewing Inside and Outside the Classroom
Developing Metacognitively-Strong Readers and Viewers
Self-Regulated Learning (SRL) has become an accepted pedagogical approach in reading/viewing based on learners' knowledge, experiences, strategies, and metacognitive instruction. SRL regards two main domains of human cognition:
- Personal beliefs โ including learners' self-efficacy, task value, and motivation (prerequisites for self-regulation)
- Cluster of variables โ including goal-setting, strategy selection, strategy use and monitoring, self-evaluation of progress, and success of strategy choice, use, and monitoring
A Proposed Pedagogical Cycle for Teaching Reading and Viewing
Modern technologies require developing highly competent skills and strategies for dealing with digital texts. The concept of reading and literacy is no longer confined to printed texts. The Internet requires understanding intertextuality and multimodality โ texts presented with sound, pictorial images, video clips, animations, and multi-layered links.
A reading/viewing lesson serves purposes at two levels:
- Meaning-focused lesson: Progression from micro-level comprehension to macro-level comprehension (or opposite)
- Language acquisition-focused lesson: Emphasis on intensive study of text including word recognition, syntactic parsing, vocabulary/word study, paraphrasing, and translation practice
Teaching Reading and Viewing in the Classroom
Many useful strategies are organized into pre-reading/viewing, during-reading/viewing, and post-reading/viewing stages. The K-W-L chart is a typical procedure:
๐ K (What I already know) โ Pre-reading activity generating ideas, vocabulary, and key issues students know ๐ W (What I want to know) โ Students use strategies like note-taking, summarizing, reading/viewing and connecting, monitoring comprehension; they anticipate and predict what will appear in the text ๐ L (What is learned) โ Post-reading activity consolidating strategies and comprehension
The K-W-L chart is useful for both expository texts and narrative texts as well as content-area knowledge.
๐ Example โ K-W-L Procedure:
- Teacher distributes chart with three columns: K, W, L
- Pre-reading: Students list what they already know about the topic (K)
- During-reading: Students list what they want to know, make predictions, and justify their ideas (W)
- Post-reading: After finishing reading, students list what they have learned (L)
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points to remember are that reading and viewing are complex meaning-making processes affected by text characteristics, reader/viewer characteristics, and social context. Three main reading models exist: top-down (reader-driven/meaning-driven), bottom-up (text-bound/decoding-driven), and interactive (combining both), with the interactive-compensatory model being most relevant for L2 learners who face a short-circuit effect from limited linguistic proficiency. Sociocultural perspectives and critical pedagogy require questioning texts and authors, recognizing that no text is neutral. Effective instruction utilizes explicit strategies instruction, social constructivist approaches within the ZPD, and procedures like K-W-L chart (what I Know, Want to know, Learned) for pre/during/post reading stages. Finally, self-regulated learning (SRL) incorporating metacognition, self-efficacy, goal-setting, and monitoring is essential for developing competent readers and viewers in today's multimodal digital environment.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main groups of reading models, and how do they differ in their view of the reading process?
- What is the 'short-circuit effect' in L2 reading, and which model does it relate to?
- According to sociocultural perspectives, why is it important for students to read/view texts critically rather than accept them as neutral?
- What are the three variables affecting reading and viewing success, and what does each include?
- Explain the three stages of the K-W-L procedure and which reading stage (pre/during/post) each corresponds to.
๐ Lecture 31 โ Teaching Writing in a Language Classroom
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the historical development of writing instruction approaches and presents a comprehensive framework for teaching academic writing in second language classrooms. It introduces the socio-cognitive approach as a practical pedagogy that combines genre awareness with explicit training in thinking processes, coherence strategies, and self-editing techniques.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five major topics: an introduction to teaching writing tracing paradigm shifts from controlled composition to genre approaches; writing competence and long-term memory focusing on paraphrase, lexical variety, passive voice, and argument structuring; the writing process as both linear and recursive nonlinear activity; technologies for enhancing writing instruction including online tools and peer assessment software; and pedagogical principles of the socio-cognitive approach emphasizing macro-rhetorical goals, coherence features, and self-editing strategies.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-151: Introduction to Teaching Writing in a Language Classroom
Many pre-service teachers are trained as English language teachers rather than writing teachers, often learning through imitation of their own teachers or senior colleagues. A systematic understanding of different approaches to academic writing is beneficial. From the mid-1940s to mid-1960s, controlled composition was widely practiced, aiming to improve accuracy through repetition and imitation based on a behaviorist view that this leads to habit formation. An example is giving sample sentences of a chosen structure and asking students to write more sentences following that pattern.
In the mid-1960s, teachers adopted a rhetorical function approach, shifting focus from sentence-level accuracy to discourse-level purposes such as description, comparison, and contrast. Since the 1970s, the process approach gained popularity, encouraging students to focus on macro-level communicative purposes and letting ideas decide the form of writing. The genre approach was introduced to help students master language, text structure, and discourse practices for specific kinds of communication through reading model texts and guided practice. Understanding the genre approach depends on three traditions: English for Specific Purposes (UK), New Rhetoric (USA), and Systemic Functional Linguistics (Australia), which differ in both form and function (Hyon, 1996).
A common underlying objective across approaches is ensuring students recognize what they write to accomplish deliberate functions. A practical approach manifests a socio-cognitive pedagogy that explicitly trains students in thinking processes conducive to developing and expressing ideas considering their audiences.
Second Language Writing
Crossley et al. (2014) suggest that successful writing cannot be defined through a single set of predefined features; rather, it has multiple profiles. Some successful writers compose longer essays with more infrequent vocabulary and fewer grammatical, spelling, and punctuation errors, while others produce essays with more syntactically complex sentences and better control of text cohesion. Besides accuracy, students should consider stylistic factors such as choice of words, sentence complexity, text cohesion, and essay length. Achieving good composition is complex for both native and non-native speakers.
Widdowson (1983) noted that mastery of words requires discipline even if one is familiar with them. Teaching writing effectively requires teachers to be explicitly aware of the skills and processes involved, treating writing as a profession to be attained with discipline and hard work. Leki (1992) stated that "even in one's native language, learning to write is something like learning a second language. No one is born with writing proficiency."
Topic-152: Writing Competence and LTM
Writing competence is composing an effective piece of written work to fulfill a specific purpose. When students become aware of the purpose, audience, and context of writing, they can employ academic discourse skills for effective implementation.
Paraphrase and Direct Quotation
Paraphrase is presenting an original writer's ideas with different word choices and rearrangements of word/sentence order from an original text. Direct quotation is used when students want to retain the original wordings. Students must be explicitly taught that while paraphrasing, the meaning conveyed by the original author must be apprehended in real essence and not distorted. Whenever paraphrasing or directly citing, students need to acknowledge the original source both in the body of the essay and the reference list, including the author's last name, year of publication, and page numbers if available. Direct quotations should be placed in quotation marks. Students should be taught reasons to cite or paraphrase: to define key terms, establish common ground, back up their own position, or substantiate opinions on a particular topic.
Lexical Variety
Lexical variety refers to "interesting word choice or effective use of vocabulary in writing" (Ferris, 2014, p. 89). It is an important part of successful writing because it can make an essay sophisticated and interesting. Texts with greater lexical variety tend to score higher and leave a better impression. Students can consult a built-in thesaurus and dictionary in word processing software, maintaining a consistent level of formality. However, lexical variety alone is insufficient; content, development of ideas, quality of argumentation, correct grammar, and mechanics are equally important.
๐ Definition โ Lexical variety: interesting word choice or effective use of vocabulary in writing that makes an essay sophisticated and leaves a better impression on readers.
Use of Passive Voice
The passive voice can be preferred for two reasons in academic writing. First, appropriate use enables writers to focus on a specific object for its importance, away from the actors who play a secondary role. Ferris (2014) draws attention to the experiment as a cornerstone of noteworthy results, independent of the actors who carried it out. Second, the passive voice lets writers deliberately distance themselves from their statements, increasing the statements' objectivity, which is significant in scientific writing.
Thinking Processes: Information Focused Approach vs. Knowledge Transformation Approach
The information-focused approach vs. the knowledge transformation approach (Bereiter & Scardamalia, 1987) explains differences in thinking processes of novice vs. experienced writers during different stages of composition. The information-focused approach is often used by novice writers who note down all facts about a topic without establishing a focused macro rhetorical goal before starting to write.
In the planning stage, novice writers ask what they know about the topic and whether they have sufficient points, while experienced writers are concerned about the rhetorical situation (purpose, audience, context) and use strategic thinking to guide inclusion or rejection of materials. In the organization stage, novice writers present information chronologically, while experienced writers consider how organization helps fulfill their rhetorical goal and anticipate reader expectations. In the writing/revising stage, novice writers have difficulty deciding what to say next, re-read previous sentences, and are concerned about grammar and spelling mistakes. Experienced writers refer to the macro rhetorical goal, anticipate reader expectations, and re-organize or re-write texts in larger units (e.g., paragraphs) guided by the macro rhetorical goal.
๐ Definition โ Macro rhetorical goal: something that a writer wants to achieve in his/her overall essay (Chandrasegaran & Schaetzel, 2004, p. 46).
Structuring and Developing Argument at the Macro and Micro Levels
The Toulmin Model of Argumentation highlights how to structure arguments at the micro level. Its elements include: (i) claim โ a statement the arguer wants to show is true; (ii) data โ evidence offered in support of the claim; (iii) warrant โ an assumption that underlies the claim; (iv) backing โ evidence for the warrant; (v) qualifier โ something that limits the applicability or scope of the claim; and (vi) reservation โ a statement or situation that renders the claim invalid (Toulmin, 1958). Teachers need to explicitly teach students how to structure and develop arguments at both macro and micro levels.
Topic-153: Writing Process and LTM in a Classroom
Traditionally, writing teachers explain the writing process as a linear process (Grabe & Kaplan, 1996). Paltridge et al. (2009) identifies four distinct sub-processes: (1) conceptualizing โ generating and selecting ideas, then organizing them in an ordered way; (2) formulating โ putting ideas into sentences; (3) revising โ rewriting and improving the essays; (4) reading โ reading the essay's instruction, gathering information, and re-reading to ensure answering the prompts.
However, the linear process model may oversimplify the writing process, being inflexible and limiting exploration. Recently, scholars suggest writing is a recursive, nonlinear activity. Clark and Ivaniฤ (1991) identify 16 equally important and inter-related stages of the writing process, including: accumulating knowledge and opinions; deciding how to take responsibility; analyzing the assignment; planning; establishing goals and purposes; establishing writer identity; drafting; considering constraints of time and space; formulating the writer's own ideas; experiencing panic, pain, and anguish; experiencing pleasure and satisfaction; revising; considering the reader; clarifying writer commitment; putting knowledge of the language to use; and making the copy neat.
Topic-154: The Use of Technologies to Enhance the Teaching of Writing
The Australian 'teaching and learning cycle' for genre instruction outlines three distinct stages: modeling, joint construction of text, and independent construction of text (Cope & Kalantzis, 1993).
At the modeling stage, teachers introduce the text type, purpose, audience, context, vocabulary, grammar, and organizational structure. For example, when teaching a complaint letter, teachers can jumble paragraphs and ask students to rearrange them following the situation-problem-solution-evaluation structure. Teachers may introduce the Michigan Corpus of Upper-Level Student Papers (http://micuspelicorpora.info) for students to learn about features of academic writing.
At the joint negotiation of text stage, teachers include activities such as class discussions and role plays to help students brainstorm ideas. Using tools like Weebly (http://education.weebly.com) or Wikipedia (http://www.wikipedia.org), teachers and students co-construct an essay. Teachers may also use Google Docs (http://www.google.com/docs) to give quick written feedback.
At the independent construction of text stage, students independently compose their own essays. When the first draft is completed, students may use an automated essay system (e.g., Criterionยฎ https://www.ets.org/criterion) for feedback on mechanics and grammar. Teachers then conduct in-class trained peer review sessions. Trained peer review feedback can positively affect post-revision drafts and revision types (Min, 2006). Teachers may use peer assessment software (e.g., Perceptive: http://www.peerceptiv.com) to implement peer review activity. Computer-mediated feedback solves the need to "save face" and allows anonymized feedback. Students are more likely to give honest feedback and pay more attention to their writing when perceiving a broad readership.
Enhancing Second Language Writing Performance
Students determined to improve their academic writing quality must be prepared to change their habitual approach to writing (Chandrasegaran, 2001, p.6). Some students need to move away from the information-focused approach and adopt an alternative approach emphasizing awareness of purpose and audience. Recent research indicates the socio-cognitive approach to writing can be effective in enhancing student performance in writing English as a second language.
Using a Socio-Cognitive Approach to Writing
The cognitive approach to teaching writing focuses on idea generation and planning strategies but neglects socio-cultural factors such as target readers' possible reactions. The genre approach focuses on rhetorical moves and organization structure rather than thinking processes involved in enacting discourse moves. The prescriptive nature of the genre approach may inhibit creativity.
Chandrasegaran (2013) suggests a socio-cognitive approach that takes into account socio-cultural contexts, thinking processes in enacting each genre practice, and reader expectations. Studies show positive results. Graham et al. (2005) found that third-grade struggling students explicitly taught thinking processes and genre structure wrote "longer, more complete, and qualitatively better" narratives and persuasive writing. Chandrasegaran and Yeo (2006) found that ninth-grade students in Singapore showed improvement in writing narratives in terms of setting the rhetorical goal.
Thinking processes embedded in knowledge transformation are important in implementing the socio-cognitive approach. These thinking processes determine what information should be included to fit the macro rhetorical goal.
Understanding Features That Make a Text Coherent
Coherence has five common features (Lee, 2002): (1) Macrostructure โ the outline of a text (e.g., for a complaint letter: situation-problem-solution-evaluation; for a story: onset-complication-resolution); (2) Information structure โ presenting old (given) information before introducing new information (e.g., "Peter has two children. They are John and Mary"); (3) Proposition development โ stating propositions with elaboration of ideas (e.g., "Free public transport is good to the residents" needs support like "With money saved on transport, residents can now spend more money on other goods and services"); (4) Cohesive devices โ pronouns, conjunctions, repetition, superordinate/hyponymy, and synonyms/antonyms; (5) Meta-discourse markers โ used to help readers organize, interpret, and evaluate information, including logical connectives (therefore, but), sequencers (firstly, finally), certainty markers (certainly, no doubt), and hedges (can, may, it could be the case that).
๐ Definition โ Coherence: the linking of ideas in a text at a discourse level to create meanings for readers, encompassing five features: macrostructure, information structure, proposition development, cohesive devices, and meta-discourse markers.
Adopting Good Editing Strategies
Ferris (2014) suggests useful editing strategies: (1) finish writing early to allow sufficient time for editing; (2) read the composition aloud to detect problematic sentences containing missing words or unneeded repetitions; (3) use a word processor's editing tools to check for grammatical, spelling, and typographical errors; (4) keep a log book to track recurring errors and address a few at a time, reviewing appropriate grammar rules if necessary.
Topic-155: Pedagogical Principles of the Socio-Cognitive Approach to Academic Writing
The process-oriented approach and genre approach have not included the setting of the macro-rhetorical goal in writing and have not emphasized thinking processes involved in genre-practice enactment. For every essay, only one macro rhetorical goal should be included because it specifies the angle and directs the path of the whole essay.
Four pedagogical principles are suggested:
1. Teachers need to explain the purpose of writing to the students
- Ensure students understand that establishing the macro rhetorical goal is essential
- Ensure students recognize the functions of academic writing
- Plan activities requiring identification of purpose at modeling, joint construction, and independent writing stages
2. Writing lessons would address the knowledge-transformation approach to writing
- Teach the knowledge-transformation approach with a focus on establishing the macro-rhetorical goal
- Explicitly teach thinking processes in planning, organizing, writing, and revising
- Create class activities raising awareness of differences between information-focused and knowledge-transformation approaches
3. Second language writers' writing performance can be enhanced by understanding coherence in a broader sense
- Teach features of a coherent text at a discourse level
- Highlight differences between meta-discourse markers and cohesive devices
- Encourage self-editing through reading aloud and using a coherence checklist
- Plan peer review activities focusing on coherence development and macro-rhetorical goals
4. Writing is a complex activity
- Teach that writing is a non-linear process involving many stages
- Recognize difficulties students encounter such as setting the macro rhetorical goal, establishing writer identity, and considering the reader
- Plan group activities heightening awareness of writing's nature
Traditional approaches (controlled composition, rhetorical function, process, genre) have strengths but may not be sufficiently effective as writing pedagogy. They do not consider reader expectations, socio-cultural factors, and key thinking processes. The socio-cognitive approach highlights explaining the purpose of writing in terms of social impact โ students write to fulfill a social function. For example, writing a story functions to entertain readers or make them admire the characters.
When students plan, organize, write, and revise, they need to ensure relevant information helps achieve the macro-rhetorical goal. Students must learn to make a text coherent through understanding macrostructure, information structure, proposition development, and appropriate use of meta-discourse markers. Writing teachers should emphasize that a good piece of writing cannot be produced in one draft; it must go through multiple revisions.
Students should adopt self-editing strategies including reading aloud, planning and finishing writing early, and revising both surface-level errors (grammar, mechanics) and discourse-level issues (presentation of self, tone, development of ideas, contextualization, use of persuasive language and evidence). Self-editing results in student ownership of and responsibility for learning (Swaffield, 2011). Students also benefit from trained peer feedback reviews (Min, 2006), which lead to better texts, improved peer talk, and enhanced critical thinking and revision ability.
๐ก Why this matters: The socio-cognitive approach represents a significant shift from treating writing as merely producing correct texts to understanding it as a socially situated cognitive activity where writers must think about purpose, audience, and rhetorical goals throughout the entire writing process.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture traces the evolution of writing instruction from controlled composition through rhetorical function, process, and genre approaches to the contemporary socio-cognitive approach. Writing competence requires understanding not just grammar and vocabulary but also discourse-level skills including paraphrase techniques, lexical variety, appropriate passive voice use, and argument structuring at both macro and micro levels using the Toulmin Model. Writing is a recursive, nonlinear process involving 16 inter-related stages rather than a simple linear sequence. The socio-cognitive approach emphasizes establishing a single macro-rhetorical goal that directs all stages of writing and considers reader expectations, socio-cultural context, and explicit thinking processes in planning, organizing, writing, and revising. Effective writing instruction must also teach coherence through five features (macrostructure, information structure, proposition development, cohesive devices, and meta-discourse markers) and train students in self-editing strategies and peer feedback techniques.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four traditional approaches to teaching writing discussed in the lecture, and what period does each emphasize?
- According to the Toulmin Model of Argumentation, what are the six elements for structuring arguments at the micro level?
- What is the difference between the information-focused approach and the knowledge transformation approach in terms of how novice and experienced writers handle the planning stage?
- What are the five features of coherence according to Lee (2002), and how does a meta-discourse marker differ from a cohesive device?
- What are the three stages of the Australian 'teaching and learning cycle' for genre instruction, and what technology tools can be used at each stage?
๐ Lecture 32 โ INTEGRATING LANGUAGE SKILLS
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the concept of integrating the four primary language skillsโlistening, speaking, reading, and writingโin language teaching. It critiques the traditional separation of skills, tracing its historical roots, and provides theoretical and practical justifications for an integrated approach, along with concrete microstrategies and exploratory projects for classroom implementation.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture defines what integrating language skills means, contrasting it with the traditional practice of skill separation that is a remnant of the 1950s and 60s audio-lingual era. It explains the theoretical and experiential need for integration, detailing how each skill reinforces the others. The lecture then provides two detailed microstrategies for integration using a newspaper advice column and reality TV, followed by exploratory projects using sitcoms and radio broadcasts. It concludes by emphasizing that integration is natural to language communication and encourages teachers to go beyond textbook limitations.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-156: What does Integrating Language Skills Mean?
The primary language skillsโlistening, speaking, reading, and writingโare naturally connected in everyday conversation. It is artificial and tiresome to separate them, yet many language schools and curricula do this, offering classes like โBeginning Readingโ or โAdvanced Writing.โ Curriculum designers and textbook writers often talk about specific reading strategies, listening strategies, speaking strategies, and writing strategies. However, Oxford (2001, p. 19) notes that many strategies, such as paying selective attention, self-evaluating, asking questions, analyzing, synthesizing, planning, and predicting, are applicable across all skill areas. In practice, teachers and learners in a classroom rarely use only one skill, inevitably following an integrated approach even when a class is supposed to focus on one specific skill.
๐ Definition โ Integrating Language Skills: The practice of combining listening, speaking, reading, and writing in language instruction, reflecting their natural interconnectedness in real-world communication. This contrasts with teaching skills in isolation.
๐ก Why this matters: Recognizing that language use is holistic challenges the traditional, often artificial, classroom separation of skills.
Topic-157: A History of Skill Separation
Skill separation is a remnant of a previous era with little empirical or experiential justification, rooted in the audio-lingual method of the 1950s and 60s. Proponents believed language was primarily aural-oral, emphasizing formal grammatical usage over functional communicative use. They recommended a strict sequencing of skills: listening, speaking, reading, and writing, reasoning that a learner should not speak before listening or write before reading, a suggestion partly based on how children learn their first language, which ignores the differences for adult second language learners. Audio-lingualists also divided skills into two categories: active (speaking and writing) and passive (reading and listening). This was later replaced by productive (speaking and writing) and receptive (listening and reading), though both sets of terms are inadequate because effective listening and reading require as much mental activity as speaking and writing. The collaborative nature of meaning-making is lost in such encode/decode representations.
Scholars like Selinker and Tomlin (1986) call the separation of skills a โpedagogical artifactโ (p. 230), finding no substantial supportive evidence. Other studies found it inadequate for developing integrated functional skills because language skills are essentially interrelated and mutually reinforcing. Fragmenting them runs counter to language's interactive nature. Therefore, teaching skills in isolation is done more for logistical reasons (administrative convenience, time, resources) than for logical or theoretical ones. Textbook writers often continue to write separate books while acknowledging the importance of integration, showing a clear tension between what is right and what is done.
๐ Definition โ Pedagogical Artifact: A term used by Selinker and Tomlin (1986) to describe the separation of language skills in teaching, arguing it is an artificial construct with no empirical support for its pedagogical decisions.
Topic-158: The Need for Integration: Why?
Theoretical and experiential knowledge points to the importance of integrating language skills, as the learning and use of one skill can trigger cognitive and communicative associations with others. Krashen (1989, p. 90) argues that reading may be the primary means of developing reading comprehension, writing style, and more sophisticated vocabulary and grammar. Listening activities help learners make broader connections between sociolinguistic form and function and psycholinguistic interpretation and expression (Rost, 1990). Bygate (1998, p. 34) found that real-time processing in listening, exposure to language through reading, and attention to form-meaning relations in all skills can help the development of speaking. Rivers (1981, pp. 296โ7) observed that the most effective writing practice has a close connection with what is being practiced in relation to other skills.
Integration also caters to different learning styles and strategies in a classroom, offering opportunities for extroverts, introverts, and analytically/visually oriented learners equally. Several types of classroom activities stress interactive language use that requires a synthesis of skills, including interactive scenarios, problem-solving tasks, content-based activities, project-based activities, whole-language activities, and experiential activities. All are relevant for different proficiency levels. When performing a well-planned integrated activity, learners might use microstrategies like listening to directions then writing notes, brainstorming in groups, using library resources to collect information, and presenting findings to the class.
๐ Example โ Integrated Activity Microstrategies: In one activity, learners may:
- Try to understand teacher's directions and take notes (listening, speaking, and writing).
- Brainstorm in groups and decide to use the library or internet to collect information (listening, speaking, reading, and writing).
- Engage in decision-making about how to use the collected information and proceed (listening, speaking, and reading).
Topic-159: Microstrategies for Integrating Language Skills
This topic provides two detailed microstrategies showing how communication channels can be used for integrating language skills.
Microstrategy: A Matter of Money and Motherhood This strategy uses an advice column from a newspaper. The teacher selects a column that builds interest and lends itself to different interpretations. The sample text is a letter to "Miss Manners" from a daughter who feels her mother took financial advantage of her while staying to help after a birth. The microstrategy proceeds as follows:
- Listening: Read the text aloud, pausing at crucial places for students to guess what happens next.
- Reading: Distribute copies for careful reading, encouraging clarification.
- Speaking: Form small groups to discuss the mother's action and the daughter's reaction, preparing a consensus report on what they would have done.
- Speaking/Writing: Have a representative present the group's report. Ask students to role-play a mother-daughter encounter. Then, have them write an individual response to the writer.
- Extension: Encourage learners to read advice columns in local newspapers and bring interesting stories to class.
Microstrategy: A Matter of Reality and Falsehood This strategy uses reality TV shows like Survivor or Loft Story. The teacher sets the stage by asking about "Reality TV."
- Listening/Viewing: Play a videotaped episode, pausing to predict next actions. If a video is unavailable, give a short lecture or use internet printouts.
- Reading: If using printouts, have students read and discuss in small groups.
- Speaking: Groups report back, followed by question and answer.
- Writing: Ask students to collect more information from the library or internet and write a brief reflective essay on what they think of the show.
- Critical Discussion (Speaking/Listening): Lead a discussion on criticisms of reality TV (e.g., "trash television" from French critics) and the perspective of a Kenyan villager, Mohammed Leeresh, who is bemused by people being paid to "survive" conditions that are his everyday reality.
Topic-160: Exploratory Projects for Skill Integration
This topic provides general plans for designing microstrategies to integrate language skills, focusing on comic situations (sitcoms) and radio days (radio broadcasts).
Project: Comic Situations Sitcoms (situation comedies) are loaded with cultural beliefs and can be a rich resource. The teacher should:
- Select and videotape an episode, then watch it closely to jot down questions.
- Divide the episode into segments and prepare listening comprehension questions.
- Focus on conversational features (turn-taking, openings), non-lexical features (stress, intonation, rhythm, body language), and characterization to identify mannerisms or behavior patterns.
- Address jokes needed for assistance and cultural prior knowledge required.
- Think of a class project like making a transcript of the episode or rewriting the script from a different cultural point of view and enacting it.
Project: Radio Days Radio broadcasts offer resources like songs, news, interviews, and sports commentaries.
- Select and audiotape a news broadcast, listening for segments for classroom use.
- Focus on headlines, asking how to help students anticipate details by just listening to them.
- Ask listening comprehension questions and identify difficult lexical and grammatical structures.
- Relate listening/speaking to reading/writing by asking learners to bring a copy of the day's newspaper for more in-depth coverage.
- Think of a writing assignment that connects the radio broadcast, the newspaper story, and the class discussion.
- For a diverse class, make use of varying political and cultural background knowledge.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is that separating language skills is an outdated, artificial pedagogical artifact with no empirical support, whereas integrating them reflects the natural, collaborative nature of real-world communication. You must understand that skills like reading, listening, speaking, and writing are mutually reinforcingโlearning one triggers cognitive connections with others. The lecture provides concrete microstrategies for integration, such as using a newspaper advice column or a reality TV clip, which you should be able to replicate or adapt for the exam. Finally, remember that various classroom activity types (problem-solving, content-based, whole-language) all share the goal of synthesizing skills, and the key is to exploit resources like newspapers, radio, TV, and the internet beyond the limitations of traditional textbooks.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is a "pedagogical artifact" in the context of language teaching, and who described skill separation as such?
- According to the lecture, what were the two main reasons (one theoretical, one practical/logistical) that led to the historical separation of language skills?
- Name three types of classroom activities (e.g., problem-solving tasks) that naturally lead to the integration of language skills.
- Describe the step-by-step process of using an "advice column" (the "Matter of Money and Motherhood" microstrategy) to integrate all four language skills.
- Why did the Kenyan villager Mohammed Leeresh feel bemused and puzzled by the concept of the reality TV show "Survivor: Africa"?