π Lecture Summary
Topic-126: Introduction to Vocabulary Teaching
Both first (L1) and second (L2) language educators agree that mastering vocabulary is essential for becoming a mature language user. While L1 and L2 vocabulary learning are not fundamentally different, they differ significantly in the rate of vocabulary growth. In L1 learning contexts, the amount of regular input is immense, allowing much vocabulary to be learnt incidentally. In contrast, L2 contexts have smaller amounts of regular input, meaning fewer vocabulary items are acquired incidentally. Therefore, it is hypothesized that teachers have the greatest influence on the quality and quantity of L2 vocabulary learnt by EFL learners (Laufer 2003). Teachers' careful planning and knowledge of vocabulary learning issues can enhance the learning process.
π‘ Why this matters: This establishes why explicit vocabulary instruction is more critical in L2 contexts than in L1 contexts.
Topic-127: Vocabulary Size and Coverage: Key Facts and Figures
According to Nation (2006), a well-educated native speaker of English knows about 20,000 word families, or around 32,000 vocabulary items (Goulden et al. 1990). This is an unrealistic goal for L2 programmes. A highly educated non-native speaker of English knows around 8000β9000 word families β less than half of a native speaker.
A more realistic way to determine vocabulary learning goals is to identify how much vocabulary is needed to perform specific activities. The relationship between lexical coverage (percentage of known words in a text) and reading comprehension is crucial.
π Definition β Lexical coverage: The percentage of known words in a text that a reader or listener understands.
Hu and Nation (2000) studied that knowledge of 98%β99% of lexical items in a written text is required to avoid comprehension problems. With 80% text coverage (one in every five words unknown), no L2 reader demonstrated satisfactory comprehension. At 90%, very few learners showed adequate comprehension. At 100%, most learners demonstrated good comprehension. Further analysis revealed that 98% text coverage (one unknown word in every 50 words) would be required for most L2 learners to achieve good comprehension.
Nation (2006) found that a vocabulary of 9000 word families would be needed to read Lady Chatterley's Lover, and 8000β9000 for similar novels and newspaper texts. For simplified texts (graded readers), only 3000 word families were needed for 98% coverage. For spoken texts, a children's movie required about 7000 word families, and unscripted spoken English required 6000β7000 word families. Thus, if 98% is the ideal coverage, 8000β9000 word families are needed for most written texts, and 6000β7000 word families for most spoken texts. Van Zeeland and Schmitt (2013) proposed that based on 95% coverage, learners would need 2000β3000 word families for adequate listening comprehension.
Topic-128: How Much Vocabulary Do EFL Learners Know?
L2 vocabulary learning progress is often slow and uneven due to factors such as insufficient input, lack of output opportunities outside the classroom, teaching methods used, and amount of time dedicated to English and vocabulary learning.
Nurweni and Read (1999) investigated 324 first-year university students in Indonesia after six years of formal English instruction. On average, learners knew 1226 English words (986 words from the General Service List and 240 words from the University Word List). Since L2 learners are thought to require 4000β5000 words to read university textbooks, these learners were not equipped with even basic vocabulary for university-level readings. The authors recommended paying more attention to high-frequency words.
Webb and Chang (2012) investigated 166 EFL learners in Taiwan over five years. Learners with less exposure to English learnt as few as 18 words in one year, while those with greater exposure learnt as many as 430 words in one year. After nine years of instruction, less than half of all learners had mastered the first 1000 word families, and only 16% had mastered the second 1000 word families. The study highlighted the need to focus on high-frequency words in the first and second 1000 word families.
Topic-129: Choosing Words to be Learned in an English Language-Learning Programme
Frequency plays a central role in language acquisition, processing, and use. Lexical frequency effects are robust in psycholinguistic research and are thought to organize the lexicon. Some words are acquired early (milk, bottle, dog), others later (internet, university, marriage), and many may never be acquired by even highly educated L1 users (dactylion, tachyphagia, yclept). Frequency should guide decisions about planning and sequencing words.
Nation (2006) found that the greatest variation in vocabulary occurs in the first 1000 word families, which cover around 80% and 83% of written and spoken texts respectively. The most frequent 1000 word families in the BNC cover over 85% of words in 88 television programmes and around 86% of words in 318 movies. This demonstrates the value of high-frequency words and makes learning the first 1000 word families of primary importance.
The second 1000 word families account for around 9% and 6% of written and spoken language respectively, while the fourth and fifth 1000 word families provide only 3% coverage of written and 2% coverage of spoken texts. Learners' primary task should be sufficient mastery of the words in the most frequent 1000 word families before moving to higher levels.
Research shows that students in various EFL contexts may not know some high-frequency words found in the first 1000 word families (Danelund 2013; Nurweni and Read 1999; Quinn 1968; Webb and Chang 2012). This suggests vocabulary learning in EFL contexts may lack important elements in course planning and delivery.
Vocabulary-Learning Programme: Key Features
Several challenges exist with L2 vocabulary learning: (1) L2 vocabulary learning rates are slow and uneven due to insufficient input; (2) the task appears daunting since an educated native speaker knows 20,000 word families while an educated L2 speaker's vocabulary is 8000β9000 words; (3) words differ in frequency and coverage value, so words must be chosen judiciously.
Nation's (2001) model incorporates the vocabulary component of a language course with these main elements:
1. Establishing Goals and Needs: While the overarching goal is to increase vocabulary size, specific goals differ. Depending on what learners already know, focus may be on high-frequency, academic, technical, or low-frequency vocabulary. Nation (2001) and Webb and Chang (2012) suggest using diagnostic testing such as the VLT (Vocabulary Levels Test) (Schmitt et al. 2001) or Productive Levels Test (Laufer and Nation 1999) to determine what learners already know.
2. Taking into Account Environmental Factors: Nation (2001) suggests establishing features of the learners (Do they share the same L1?), the teachers (Are teachers well informed?), and the situation (Do L1 and L2 share cognate vocabulary?).
3. Following Vocabulary-teaching Principles: Three core principles:
- Content and sequencing: Frequency and range of occurrence should guide what and when to learn. Students should be trained in vocabulary learning strategies (guessing from context, learning word parts, using a dictionary, using word cards).
- Format and presentation: High-frequency words should occur in the four strands: meaning-focused input (learning through listening and reading), meaning-focused output (learning through speaking and writing), language-focused learning (deliberately learning pronunciation, vocabulary, grammar, discourse), and fluency development (becoming fluent in using already known words). This principle highlights the importance of spaced, repeated exposures to target vocabulary.
- Monitoring and assessment: Regular and systematic use of tests and quizzes to measure progress and motivate learners.
4. Evaluation of the Vocabulary Component: Questions for evaluating effectiveness include: Were goals reached? Were environmental factors considered? Were learners' needs met? Did vocabulary knowledge extend beyond form and meaning? Were there sufficient opportunities to encounter target vocabulary?
Topic-130: Vocabulary Learning Activities: Learning Outside the Classroom
Researchers recommend paying more attention to vocabulary learning and focusing on high-frequency words. However, there is a limit to explicit vocabulary teaching in the classroom. Nation (2001) notes that opportunities for indirect vocabulary learning should occupy more time than direct learning activities.
Extensive Reading
Reading is central to Nation's (2001) strand of meaning-focused input. Acquiring vocabulary through reading leads to learning gains due to repeated encounters with the same word. Extensive reading offers repeated exposure to lexical items and provides opportunities to use words according to context.
Modern technology like the RANGE programme (Nation and Heatley 2002) allows teachers to choose texts according to learners' vocabulary levels. Webb and Chang (2012) argue that selecting texts for high-frequency words provides superior conditions for comprehension.
Day and Bamford (2002) proposed ten principles for extensive reading:
- The reading material is easy
- A variety of reading material on a wide range of topics must be available
- Learners choose what they want to read
- Learners read as much as possible (Nation and Wang (1999) suggest one book per week)
- The purpose of reading is usually related to pleasure and information
- Reading is its own reward
- Reading speed is usually faster rather than slower
- Reading is individual and silent
- Teachers orient and guide learners
- The teacher is a role model of a reader
Extensive reading promotes learner autonomy, can be motivating, and results in substantial vocabulary learning difficult to achieve through explicit teaching in short classroom periods.
Extensive Viewing
Researchers suggest that extensive viewing of L2 television can complement extensive reading. Television provides multimodal contextual cues (aural and visual) that make it easier for learners to work out meanings and learn new items.
Lin and Chanturia (2014) outlined principles for internet television:
- Learners receive extensive exposure to English
- Learners observe authentic, everyday English (important for formulaic language)
- Internet television facilitates contextual vocabulary acquisition
Since television emphasizes authentic input (which may not be "easy"), it may only be suitable for more advanced EFL learners. Strategies for effective use include:
- Repeated viewing: Leads to repeated encounters with vocabulary items
- Training on contextual vocabulary learning skills: Helps learners acquire vocabulary implicitly
- Programme selection: Programmes in factual, drama, and comedy categories were more representative of everyday English
- Narrow viewing: Viewing programmes on the same or similar theme provides multiple repetitions
- Subtitles: Intralingual subtitles (same language) or interlingual subtitles (L1) can aid learning, though native-language subtitles may create lexical interference
Benefit from reading-while-listening activities
Research shows that reading with listening leads to greater vocabulary learning than reading alone. The Compleat Lexical Tutor (available at http://www.lextutor.ca/) offers electronic versions of graded readers with recordings, as well as word lists, concordancers, vocabulary profilers, and vocabulary tests.
Overall, researchers agree that watching television and internet television can be a useful EFL activity promoting learner autonomy and enhancing vocabulary learning.
π‘ Why this matters: These out-of-class activities provide the repeated exposure and contextual learning that is often missing in limited classroom time.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that L2 vocabulary learning is significantly slower than L1 learning due to limited input, and research shows that 98% lexical coverage is needed for adequate comprehension, which requires approximately 8000β9000 word families for written texts and 6000β7000 for spoken texts. High-frequency words, particularly the first 1000 word families covering about 80% of texts, should be prioritized, and diagnostic testing like the VLT should be used to determine learners' current knowledge. Nation's model provides a comprehensive framework with four strands (meaning-focused input, meaning-focused output, language-focused learning, and fluency development) and emphasizes spaced repeated exposures. Finally, out-of-class activities like extensive reading and extensive viewing are essential for supplementing limited classroom instruction and promoting vocabulary growth.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What percentage of lexical coverage did Hu and Nation (2000) determine is required for most L2 learners to achieve good comprehension of a text?
- According to Webb and Chang (2012), how many words did learners with less exposure to English learn in one year, and what does this suggest about the relationship between input and vocabulary growth?
- What are the four strands of Nation's (2001) vocabulary-teaching principles, and what does each strand focus on?
- What is the difference between extensive reading and extensive viewing, and what additional benefit does television provide through multimodal cues?
- What is the purpose of using the Vocabulary Levels Test (VLT) and Productive Levels Test in a vocabulary-learning programme?
π Lecture 27 β Teaching Pronunciation in a Language Classroom
π Overview: This lecture explores the paradigm shift in teaching pronunciation within the context of English as a Lingua Franca (ELF). It emphasizes the need to move beyond native-speaker models and focuses on intelligibility, awareness-raising, and self-monitoring as core goals. The lecture also provides practical guidance on incorporating phonetics, phonology, and internet-based resources into pronunciation instruction.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing the changing landscape of English, moving from ESL/EFL to ELF/EIL, and contextualizing this for Pakistan. It then details new approaches emphasizing intelligibility, awareness-raising, and self-monitoring. The lecture provides a foundation in phonetics and phonology for teachers and concludes with a comprehensive overview of the role of the internet, including speech analysis software, video conferencing, and accent archives, in teaching and learning pronunciation.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-131: Introduction: Pronunciation and the Changing Landscape of English
The need for English as a lingua franca is increasing. The distinction between ESL and EFL is being replaced by EIL (English as an International Language) and ELF (English as a Lingua Franca). This shift is not just terminological but indicates a major change in mindset for ELT. ELF is defined as βa means of communication between people who come from different first language backgroundsβ (Jenkins 2012, p. 486). This includes all users of English, native and non-native. With this definition, the goals of teaching pronunciation have become manifold, moving beyond the traditional aim of acquiring a single 'standard' pronunciation. Learners must now understand pronunciation features across different varieties, from dialectal variations to learner errors.
π Definition β ELF (English as a Lingua Franca): A means of communication between people who come from different first language backgrounds. π‘ Why this matters: This redefines the goal of pronunciation teaching from achieving a native-like accent to achieving mutual intelligibility in diverse global interactions.
Topic-132: Teaching Pronunciation and the Case of Pakistan
The lecture prompts consideration of the following factors in the Pakistani context:
- Education system of Pakistan
- L2 and ELT in Pakistan
- Examination system in Pakistan
- Language skills and Classroom practices
Topic-133: New Approaches and Goals in Teaching Pronunciation
Intelligibility in an ELF Context The core idea is that teaching should be based on the ability to communicate with native and non-native speakers alike. Instead of adhering to a standard norm like Received Pronunciation (RP) or General American (GA), the focus is on acknowledging variability in language use. Both Jenkins (2000) and Wells (2005) emphasize the importance of pronunciation features that impede intelligibility, as wrong pronunciation is often the cause of communication breakdown. Wells (2005) suggests focusing on areas that impede communication without undermining learner confidence. He appeals to contrastive analysis (CA) as a useful initial step to identify potential areas of unintelligibility by comparing L1 and English.
π Definition β Contrastive Analysis (CA): A method of identifying potential areas of difficulty in language learning by systematically comparing and contrasting the learner's first language (L1) and the target language. π‘ Why this matters: CA helps teachers and learners predict which specific pronunciation features will be challenging, allowing for targeted instruction.
Raising Awareness in Pronunciation Teaching Two crucial factors are awareness raising and self-monitoring. This relates to Schmidt's (1990, 2001) 'noticing hypothesis' , which states that learners must notice a feature to learn it. For example, a learner must first notice the distinction between /iΛ/ and /Ιͺ/ in beach and bitch to produce them correctly. Phonemic awarenessβthe awareness of discreet sound units that contribute to differences in meaning (e.g., /p/ in pin vs. /f/ in fin)βfacilitates learning. This awareness can be taught by examining articulatory details (e.g., how the two TH sounds /ΞΈ/ and /Γ°/ are produced) and by comparing and contrasting L1 and English sounds. In an ELF context, this also means being sensitive to differences among regional varieties (e.g., RP /ΙΛ/ vs. GA /Γ¦/ in dance).
π Definition β Noticing Hypothesis: The theory that learners must consciously notice a linguistic feature in the input for it to become intake and be acquired. π Definition β Phonemic Awareness: The ability to recognize and manipulate the individual sounds (phonemes) in spoken words.
Self-Monitoring in Pronunciation Learning Awareness alone does not guarantee production. Speech production is automatic (Levelt, 1989). In L2 learning, initial effort requires conscious control using declarative knowledge (e.g., rules about tongue placement) which must be practiced to become 'automatic'. This is reflected in the discrepancy between a student who succeeds in minimal pair drills (controlled processing) but fails in natural speech (automatic processing). The crucial intermediate stage is 'self-monitoring' , where learners turn declarative knowledge into 'controlled processing' and then into 'automatic processing'. Learners must constantly monitor their own speech to identify and modify features that impede communication.
π Definition β Minimal Pair Drills: A teaching technique where students practice distinguishing and producing pairs of words that differ by only one sound (e.g., ship /ΚΙͺp/ vs. sheep /ΚiΛp/).
Topic-134: The Basis for Pronunciation: Phonetics and Phonology
It is not recommended to turn pronunciation teaching into the teaching of phonetics and phonology jargon. However, understanding the knowledge and research in these fields can facilitate teaching. For example, the phonetic knowledge that the voicing distinction between /s/ and /z/ is caused by the vibration of the vocal cords is very useful for learners whose L1 does not have this contrast.
Topic-135: Role of the Internet in Teaching and Learning Pronunciation
The internet has revolutionized language learning, moving from CALL (Computer-Assisted Language Learning) to WELL (Web-Enhanced Language Learning) and mobile learning. Key internet resources for pronunciation include:
- Authentic English speech (e.g., BBC, CNN, movies)
- Online dictionaries with audio (e.g., Cambridge, Merriam-Webster)
- Web-based pronunciation exercises
- Downloadable speech analysis programmes (e.g., PRAAT, SFS/WASP)
- Online video communication facilities (e.g., Skype)
Speech analysis programmes like PRAAT allow learners to see visual displays of their speech (e.g., pitch patterns), which is useful for awareness raising and self-monitoring. Video conferencing tools like Skype provide face-to-face communication with speakers from different backgrounds, helping learners reflect on intelligibility. Other valuable resources include 'The Speech Accent Archive' , IDEA (International Dialects of English Archive) , and "Accents of English from Around the World" (University of Edinburgh), which provide speech samples from hundreds of language backgrounds, making learners aware of different varieties of English.
π Definition β CALL (Computer-Assisted Language Learning): The use of computer technology to aid in the teaching and learning of a language. π Definition β WELL (Web-Enhanced Language Learning): The use of internet and web-based technologies to support language learning.
β Key Takeaways
The primary goal of pronunciation teaching has shifted from achieving a native-like accent to ensuring intelligibility in a global ELF context. Teachers must focus on raising learners' phonemic awareness and promoting self-monitoring to help them identify and correct errors that cause communication breakdown. A practical understanding of phonetics and phonology is a useful tool for teachers, but not an end goal for learners. Finally, modern resources like the internet, speech analysis software, and accent archives are invaluable for creating authentic, awareness-raising, and interactive pronunciation learning experiences.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between the traditional goal of teaching pronunciation and the new goal in an ELF context?
- Define the 'noticing hypothesis' and give one example of how it applies to pronunciation teaching.
- What is the difference between a learner's performance in a minimal pair drill and their performance in natural spontaneous speech, according to the lecture?
- Name two specific internet-based resources (websites or software) mentioned that can help learners develop awareness of different English accents.
- Why is understanding phonetic knowledge (e.g., voicing) considered useful for a teacher, even though teaching phonetic jargon is not recommended?
π Lecture 28 β Teaching Speaking in a Language Classroom
π Overview: This lecture examines the pedagogical landscape for teaching speaking in second language (L2) classrooms, exploring both direct/controlled and indirect/transfer approaches. It provides a comprehensive framework for understanding speaking competence, speech production processes, and practical classroom tasks, culminating in an integrated, holistic approach that combines direct instruction, indirect practice, and metacognitive support.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an introduction to the two main approaches to teaching speaking: direct/controlled (focus on form) and indirect/transfer (focus on fluency through peer practice). It then examines the construct of speaking competence, breaking it down into enabling skills (pronunciation, speech function, interaction management, discourse organization, and communication strategies) and language/discourse knowledge. The cognitive processes of speech production (conceptualization, formulation, articulation, and metacognition) are explored, along with factors affecting L2 speaking performance. Finally, the lecture details three types of classroom speaking tasks (communication-gap, discussion, and monologic tasks) and presents three key pedagogical strategies for enhancing performance: pre-task planning, task repetition, and metacognition enhancement, culminating in the Teaching Speaking Cycle (TSC).
π Lecture Summary
Topic-136: Introduction: Teaching Speaking in a Language Classroom
Language learners often work in pairs or groups to build confidence and fluency in speech, based on the assumption that frequent practice transfers skills from the classroom to real life. This is called the indirect/transfer approach (Burns, 1998). The alternative is the direct/controlled approach, where learners focus on getting language forms right through drills and grammar instruction, which was common before Communicative Language Teaching (CLT).
π‘ Why this matters: While there have been no major paradigm shifts, new understandings from discourse analysis, genre theory, and corpus research (like the CANCODE spoken corpus) have expanded the direct approach by introducing learners to a variety of spoken texts and their discourse structures. The lecture proposes a comprehensive, holistic approach that integrates the strengths of both direct and indirect instruction with metacognition.
Topic-137: Second Language: Speaking Activities
A good L2 speaker is confident, fluent, and grammatically correct. The construct of speaking involves dynamic interactions of mental, articulatory, and social processes. Speakers must decide what to say, use linguistic knowledge to construct utterances, encode messages in sounds, and consider the context of interaction.
Speaking Competence β Johnson (1981) describes it as producing utterances that are simultaneously "right" on several levels: grammatical, appropriate to the speaker's aim, the relationship, the setting, the topic, and the linguistic context. All this must be done quickly in a conversation.
Enabling Skills β Goh and Burns (2012) group speaking skills into four clusters:
Pronunciation Skills β These are articulatory and phonological skills at two levels:
- Segmental level: Producing discrete sounds (vowels, consonants, diphthongs)
- Suprasegmental level: Overall sound patterns realized through prominence (stress on selected syllables) and tones (pitch movements). These have important communicative value in discourse, not just emotional expression.
π Example:
A: Where's my bag? B: //UNder the TA ble// A: (Looking at the top of table) Where? B: //NOT ON the table// UN der it//
In Bβs first reply, βtableβ gets the stress. In the second, the stress shifts to βonβ and βunderβ to show contrast, because βtableβ is now shared information.
Speech Function Skills β We use speech to perform speech acts (to get things done). Learners need to use appropriate language, vocabulary, and grammar to convey functions like inform, accept, decline, request, explain, and describe. Advanced learners need more complex functions like negotiate, advise, and argue.
Interaction Management Skills β These are skills to manage an interaction, including initiating, taking turns, giving turns, asking for clarification, changing topics, and closing an interaction. Formulaic expressions are important for these functions, and learners must also recognize and produce moves in socioculturally appropriate ways.
Discourse Organization Skills β For longer turns (e.g., presentations), learners need skills to construct spoken texts according to sociocultural conventions. They need to know discourse routines (stages and moves) and use discourse markers to signpost transitions.
π Example: In a presentation, use simple markers like 'Next' or complex ones like 'We have just examined X, letβs now consider Y.' For a narrative, learners need the structure: orientation-problem-resolution-coda.
Communication Strategies β These are special techniques for oral communication, serving a social function (enhancing interaction) or a psycholinguistic function (compensating for inadequate vocabulary).
- Interactional strategies: Asking for clarification, repetition, comprehension checks.
- Hesitation devices: Using formulaic expressions like 'Well' or 'Yes, thatβs a good point' to gain thinking time.
- Approximation: Using generic terms like 'thing' for precise terms not known.
- Cognitive strategies: Paraphrasing, circumlocution, word coinage, borrowing from L1.
- Metacognitive strategies: Planning, self-monitoring, and evaluating.
Language and Discourse Knowledge β Grammar knowledge has expanded to include spoken grammar and the structuring of different genres (conversations, lectures, interviews). For example, oral narratives use past tense forms, while giving instructions uses imperative verb forms.
Topic-138: Processes in Speech Production and Designing Activities
Leveltβs (1989) framework describes three main processes:
- Conceptualization: A speakerβs mental planning to determine what to say (selecting information and activating speech act intentions).
- Formulation: Accessing and retrieving vocabulary (words, phrases, chunks) and applying grammar knowledge to express meaning clearly.
- Articulation: The physical process of saying words aloud through phonological encoding at segmental and suprasegmental levels.
Directions of Speech Processing β These processes often occur interactively (especially in spontaneous speech) but can also occur linearly (one process completes before the next starts). L2 speakers often struggle with interactive processing and use communication strategies.
Metacognitive Processes β These operate beyond direct language manipulation:
- Monitoring: Checking accuracy and appropriateness during speech.
- Evaluation: Reviewing what was said after speaking to assess effectiveness.
- Planning: Overlapping with conceptualization when speakers have time to think.
L2 Speaking Performance β Segalowitz (2010) explains that L2 fluency is affected by many demands: limited cognitive processing capacity, inadequate cultural knowledge, and time pressures. Learners often focus on meaning over accuracy, use self-repairs, and employ communication strategies to maintain interaction.
Topic-139: Classroom Speaking Tasks
There are three broad types of speaking tasks:
Communication-gap tasks: Learners interact with a partner to convey missing information, describing, narrating, or explaining.
Discussion tasks: Learners share personal views, often on open or controversial topics. They can draw on background knowledge and beliefs. If a consensus is needed, they negotiate. Simulations are discussion tasks where learners take on roles (e.g., doctor, MP) in a scenario.
Monologic tasks: Learners present ideas individually to a listener or group (e.g., giving a talk, telling a story, presenting a report). These can be spontaneous or planned. Doing them in small groups reduces anxiety and enables peer feedback.
Topic-140: Enhancing Second Language Speaking Performance and LTM
Three key strategies can enhance L2 speaking performance:
Pre-task Planning β Giving learners time to plan before a speaking task can have positive effects on fluency, accuracy, and language complexity, though effects on accuracy are inconclusive. Strategy training at the pre-task stage helps learners apply strategies during speaking. However, individual differences (like self-monitoring ability) can confound effects.
Task Repetition β The repeated use of the same or similar task (Bygate, 2001). Research shows it leads to more accurate and natural speech, better narrative framing, wider lexical range, and improved grammar and pronunciation. It frees up cognitive space, allowing learners to attend to form in the repeat performance.
Metacognition Enhancement β Metacognition (Flavell, 1976) is the ability to think about oneβs own thinking and learning. It includes:
- Person knowledge: Knowledge of oneβs own learning
- Task knowledge: Nature and demands of tasks
- Strategy knowledge: How to approach tasks
π Definition β Metacognition: an individualβs ability to consider about his/her own thinking and learning, encompassing knowledge of self, tasks, and strategies, and the use of strategies for problem-solving, monitoring, and regulating thinking.
In L2 speaking, metacognition is applied through awareness-raising and strategy-instruction activities. Studies show that using CEFR level descriptors for self-evaluation and engaging in metacognitive reflections (planning, monitoring, evaluating) improve speaking performance.
A Comprehensive and Holistic Approach for Teaching Speaking β This approach combines the strengths of direct/controlled and indirect/transfer ways of teaching, integrated with supportive metacognitive processes. Key principles include:
- Using technology (e.g., smart phone recordings) to give permanence to transient spoken language for noticing and analysis.
- Using video recordings of expert speakers as models.
- Incorporating pre-task planning and task repetition as regular procedures.
- Using the Teaching Speaking Cycle (TSC) by Goh and Burns (2012), which has seven stages:
- Focusing learnersβ attention on speaking
- Providing input and/or guide planning
- Conducting speaking tasks
- Focusing on language/discourse/skills/strategies
- Repeating speaking tasks
- Directing learnersβ reflection on learning
- Facilitating feedback on learning
β Key Takeaways
The most critical understanding from this lecture is that effective speaking instruction requires a holistic approach that integrates direct instruction of language forms and discourse knowledge with indirect practice for fluency, all supported by metacognitive processes. The construct of speaking competence is multi-faceted, encompassing pronunciation skills (both segmental and suprasegmental), speech function skills, interaction management skills, discourse organization skills, and communication strategies. Speech production involves the cognitive processes of conceptualization, formulation, and articulation, operating interactively under time constraints, and is regulated by metacognitive processes of monitoring, evaluation, and planning. For the exam, remember the three types of classroom speaking tasks (communication-gap, discussion, monologic) and the three key enhancement strategies (pre-task planning, task repetition, metacognition enhancement), and be able to explain how the Teaching Speaking Cycle operationalizes the comprehensive approach.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main approaches to teaching speaking, and how do they differ in their focus?
- List and briefly describe the four clusters of speaking skills identified by Goh and Burns (2012).
- Explain the three processes in Leveltβs (1989) framework of speech production and how they can operate interactively versus linearly.
- What are the three broad types of speaking tasks, and what is a key advantage of each?
- Describe two of the three strategies for enhancing L2 speaking performance (pre-task planning, task repetition, metacognition enhancement) and provide an example of how each could be implemented in a classroom.
π Lecture 29 β TEACHING LISTENING IN A LANGUAGE CLASSROOM
π Overview: This lecture examines the critical shift in understanding listening from a passive skill to an active facilitator of L2 acquisition. It explores the unique features of spoken language, the complex factors affecting L2 listening comprehension, and provides a practical framework for designing effective listening lessons, including pre-, while-, and post-listening phases. Finally, it recommends self-study approaches like narrow listening, repeated listening, and simultaneous reading and listening to develop listening competence outside the classroom.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing the new, active role of listening in L2 development and the challenges learners face due to its fleeting nature. It then details the unique features of spoken language that distinguish it from written text. A significant portion is dedicated to analyzing the external, medium, and internal factors that affect L2 listening comprehension, drawing on empirical research. The lecture culminates in a structured, three-phase model for a well-designed listening lesson and concludes with practical, evidence-based approaches for independent listening practice.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-141: The Importance of Developing L2 Listening Skills
The role of listening in L2 programs has changed substantially. Once considered a passive skill for extracting meaning, listening is now seen as a skill that supports the growth of other language knowledge, like speaking and reading. π‘ Why this matters: Acquiring a language efficiently requires learning both written and spoken forms, as they are equally important input channels that work complementarily. Students also spend more time listening than on reading, speaking, or writing. For L2 learners, listening is often more challenging than reading because readers can control variables like pace and dictionary use, whereas real-world listening offers no such pause or rewind functions.
Topic-142: The Features of Spoken Language and classroom activities
Understanding spoken language features is crucial for teaching. Key features include:
- Sound is fleeting and transitory.
- Speech varies by person in accent, intonation, pitch, stress, volume, and pace.
- Not all written sounds are heard (e.g., silent /h/ in hour).
- Words run together due to phonological change (e.g., first of all becomes firsdavall).
- Spoken language is syntactically simpler than written language, using shorter idea units and coordinators (and, but, so).
- It contains disfluencies (fillers, hesitations, false starts) which, if identified, give listeners more processing time.
- It includes more colloquial expressions, slang, and nonstandard grammar. These features, while generalized, pose significant challenges for L2 listeners and must be considered when designing classroom activities.
Topic-143: Factors Affecting L2 Comprehension
Comprehension occurs when listeners infer meaning using linguistic and contextual knowledge. Samuels (1984) classified difficulties into external, medium, and internal factors.
External Factors: The Opportunities of Input and Speaker Factors
- Opportunities of Input: In a foreign language setting, exposure is often limited to the classroom, making L2 listening harder than L1 listening. Significant development requires hundreds of hours of listening per year.
- Speaker Factors: Two main complaints are speech rates and accent. Normal speech is 150-180 wpm. Fast speech often reduces comprehension, though this effect can depend on learner proficiency. Familiarity with a speaker's accent is the most important factor for comprehension. Accent can be a "temporary" variable; exposure to varied accents through technology can help.
π Definition β Accent: The way a speaker pronounces words, often tied to a specific region or group, which can act as a "temporary" barrier to comprehension that fades with exposure.
Medium Factors: Text, Task, and Context
- Text Type: Texts with only necessary info, fewer individuals/objects, and a chronological order are easier. Results on whether monologues or dialogues are easier are contradictory.
- Task Type: Tasks requiring an immediate response (e.g., matching pictures) are easier than delayed recall (e.g., summarization). Multiple-choice (MC) tasks are generally easier than questions requiring constructed answers, but can be difficult for less advanced readers.
- Listening Context: This involves minimizing the information processing load through pre-listening activities, using visual support (pictures or videos), and encouraging group work to enhance comprehension.
Internal Factors: Language Proficiency and Background Knowledge These are variables relevant to the listeners themselves. Topic familiarity has a significant positive effect on listening comprehension. Strategy use, such as applying metacognitive strategies to become a self-regulated listener, is also critical.
Topic-144: Format of a Well-Designed Listening Lesson
A theory-based lesson involves three stages: pre-listening, while-listening, and post-listening.
The Pre-listening Phase This phase is crucial, especially for beginners. Activities include:
- Establish purposes for the listening activity to enable selective listening.
- Activate background knowledge via class discussion, pre-reading a short text, presenting pictures, or previewing task questions.
- Provide linguistic support: Pre-teach key words, their spoken forms, pronunciation of proper nouns, phrases with non-transparent meaning (e.g., apple of my eye), and confusing grammatical structures.
- Set a listening goal: Tell students how many times they will listen (e.g., first for gist, second for detail, third for difficulties).
The While-listening Phase
- Students should do simple tasks requiring little writing or reading (e.g., sequencing pictures, filling out a form) to reduce working memory load.
- Use graded tasks for repeated listening:
- 1st listening: Listen for gist, tone, place, or speaker relationship.
- 2nd listening: Listen for details and complete the task.
- 3rd listening: Focus on unclear areas.
The Post-listening Phase This phase confirms comprehension and clarifies uncertain points. Activities include:
- Reviewing the transcript by reading while listening or reading alone.
- Evaluating the listening process: Students reflect on whether their difficulties came from personal, external, or medium factors and discuss solutions. A word of caution: do not spend too much time on any single phase, especially the pre-listening stage, at the expense of actual listening practice.
Topic-145: Suggested Approaches to Listening Practice
Classroom instruction alone is insufficient. Three approaches are suggested for outside-class practice:
Narrow Listening Learners focus on one topic or one author and do a great deal of listening in that area. This approach, derived from narrow reading, is suitable for all levels and is highly motivating as learners choose topics of interest.
Repeated Listening Derived from repeated reading, the goal is to make word recognition more efficient, freeing up attention for comprehension. A shorter text is best, and the speech rate can be gradually increased (e.g., from 100 to 110 to 120 wpm) using software like Audacity. It should be used cautiously as it can be boring.
Simultaneous Reading and Listening Also called reading while listening, this helps beginner learners develop awareness of form-meaning relationships and word recognition. It is different from the post-listening phase review, as here it is for enjoyment. Modern graded readers and online materials (e.g., BBC Learning English, TED talks) support this. Caution: learners may over-rely on print and ignore the audio. The best cycle for improving listening is to end with listening only.
β Key Takeaways
Listening is now understood as an active skill crucial for L2 acquisition, one that is often more challenging than reading due to the fleeting and variable nature of spoken language. Comprehension is affected by a complex interplay of external (e.g., input opportunities, speech rate, accent), medium (e.g., text and task type, visual support), and internal (e.g., language proficiency, background knowledge) factors. An effective listening lesson should be structured around three clear phases: pre-listening (to prepare and activate knowledge), while-listening (with simple, graded tasks), and post-listening (for confirmation and reflection). Finally, learners must supplement classroom instruction with independent practice using methods like narrow listening, repeated listening, and reading while listening to build fluency.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to the lecture, why is listening now considered an "active" skill rather than a passive one in L2 acquisition?
- List three specific features of spoken language that make it more difficult to process than written language.
- Explain the difference between an "external factor" and an "internal factor" affecting L2 listening comprehension, giving one example of each.
- What are the three main phases of a well-designed listening lesson, and what is the primary goal of the pre-listening phase?
- What is "narrow listening," and how does it differ in purpose from "repeated listening"?