π Lecture 35 β Children vs. Adults in Second-Language Learning
π Overview: This lecture examines the common belief that children are better second-language learners than adults, exploring the psychological, neurological, and social factors that actually differentiate their learning processes. It argues that children and adults learn differently rather than one being inherently superior, and discusses practical implications for teaching methods based on age-related cognitive and social characteristics.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the psychological category of children vs. adults in second-language learning, including processing differences in the brain, proficiency differences, pronunciation abilities, aging and learning ability, and different learning methods. It then addresses motivation and attitude factors, followed by social category factors including language attitudes, age, and gender effects. The lecture concludes with basic psychological factors (explication, induction, memory), social situations for learning (natural, classroom, community), and the question of a critical age for syntax acquisition.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-205: Children are Better: A Common Belief Psychological Category
Speaking a second language is an important skill for all people, both young and old. It has long been believed that children are better able to learn a second language. In actuality, it is not that children learn language better than adults, but that adults and children learn language differently. By understanding these differences and making adjustments to the learning process, all people can acquire a second language, no matter their age.
Processing differences: There are distinct differences in the way an adult brain processes a foreign language when compared to the brain of a child. Dr. Paul Thompson of UCLA used MRI imaging and animation technology to view what parts of the brain adults and children use when learning a second language. Children use a part of their brain called the "deep motor area", which is responsible for processes that are not consciously thought about, like brushing your teeth or getting dressed. For children, processing a new language is second nature. Adults process language in a more active part of the brain, meaning they think more consciously about language rather than it being intuitive.
Proficiency differences: One reason it seems that children acquire a second language quicker than adults is because of the different standards of proficiency between adults and children. Children have a smaller vocabulary and it is easy to learn enough of a second language to communicate their needs. Adults have a much larger vocabulary and think and communicate in more complex ways than children. This means it takes them longer to acquire the ability to communicate effectively in a second language. Although it seems that children learn language quicker than adults, in actuality adults and adolescents have the edge.
Pronunciation: Another reason the myth persists is because of the child's ability to adapt the proper pronunciation of a language. The younger a child begins to learn a second language, the better their pronunciation. Adults have a more difficult time adapting the pronunciation of a foreign language, and so sound less competent than a child who has the ability to speak a second language with the proper accent.
Aging and learning ability: Another common misconception is that as people age, their ability to learn a new skill diminishes. In actuality, people do not lose their ability to learn as they age. The only challenges an older learner faces are the weakening of vision and hearing. The loss of hearing in particular can affect a person's ability to learn a language in the traditional classroom setting. A healthy, older adult is perfectly capable of learning a second language.
Learning methods: Because children and adults learn differently and use different parts of their brains to process language, the way they are taught should also differ. Exposing children to a second language at home as well as at school is essential. Singing songs, reading books, and repetition of foreign words are all useful tools for children. Older learners, especially those with hearing and vision difficulties, may have difficulties learning in a traditional classroom setting. Working with a group that focuses more on understanding the language rather than perfecting pronunciation, and integrates new concepts into the adults' preexisting cognitive structures, will help the older learner succeed.
Motivation: The question of motivation for learning a second language is not likely to arise in a natural type of setting such as with a young child. A 1- or 2-year-old needs no motivation to learn a second language; given language input, the young child will automatically learn β with learning even occurring in negative circumstances. An older child of 4 or 5 years, however, may need motivation since by that age the child may be aware of whether a language is positively or negatively regarded by others, or the child may prefer other activities.
Attitude: A negative attitude towards the target language or its speakers, or the other members of the class, may affect one's determination and persistence to be involved in the classroom and its activities. This same negative attitude could impair memory functioning and detract from focusing on the target language. In the same way, any of a host of personality and sociocultural variables could have deleterious effects (Brown, 1987).
Topic-206: Social Category
Three types of social structures which can affect the acquisition of second languages are: sociolinguistic setting, specific social factors, and situational factors. Sociolinguistic setting refers to the role of the second language in society. Specific social factors include age, gender, social class, and ethnic identity. Situational factors are those which vary between each social interaction.
Language attitudes: Language attitudes in the learner, the peer group, the school, the neighborhood, and society at large can have an enormous effect on the second language learning process, both positive and negative.
Learner attitudes: Learners manifest different attitudes towards: 1) the target language, 2) the target language speakers, 3) the target language culture, 4) the social value of learning the L2, 5) particular use of the target language, and 6) themselves as members of their own culture. In general, positive attitudes towards the L2, its speakers, and its culture can enhance learning, while negative attitudes can impede learning. However, if learners have a strong reason for learning, negative attitude can have a positive effect. Learners may have conflicting attitudes β they might want to learn the L2 as a way of assimilating into the majority culture, but at the same time wish to keep their L1 as a means of maintaining their L1 identity.
Age: Younger speakers are subject to peer group pressure and use the nonstandard form used by their peer group; the middle-aged group is less subject to peer group pressure and is more influenced by mainstream societal values. For older people, social pressures lessen and social networks again become narrow. Generally, learners who learn an L2 after puberty are unlikely to acquire a native-speaker accent, while those who begin after 15 years are less likely to develop full grammatical ability β Chambers and Trudgill (1980).
Gender: Two apparently contradictory principles noticed by sociolinguists are: 1) In stable sociolinguistic stratification, men use a higher frequency of nonstandard forms than women. 2) In the majority of linguistic changes, women use a higher frequency of the incoming forms than men. Women may be better language learners. They are more sensitive to new linguistic forms and are more ready to incorporate them into their speech, thus they will be more likely to rid themselves of any interlanguage forms that deviate from target-language norms.
In sum, currently there are no clear-cut explanations yet as to why females outperform males in L2 learning. The reasons that females hold a more positive attitude seems to have been widely agreed. Male and female culture differences are also possible explanations. Females are more cooperative and more delicate in dealing with relationships while males emphasize maintaining their hierarchical relationship. Thus female 'culture' fits L2 learning, as it is more readily to deal with the threat to their identity posed by L2 learning. There is also some evidence suggesting that females' better listening comprehension ability puts them at an advantage in L2 learning.
Topic-207: Basic Psychological Factors Affecting Second-Language Learning
Explication: The nature of explication is the process whereby the rules and structures of a second language are explained to a learner. This explanation is given in the first language of the learner. The learner is then expected to understand, learn, and apply the rule in the second language. While parts of a second language can be learned by explication, it is impossible for it to be learned entirely by explication because not all of the rules of any one language have been discovered and written down. Even for English, the most researched of all languages, one still finds linguistic journals discussing concepts involved in such commonplace features as tense and the article.
π Definition β Explication: The process whereby the rules and structures of a second language are explained to a learner in the learner's first language.
Induction: Learning rules by self-discovery is the essence of the process of induction. The child who is exposed to second-language speech and remembers what he or she has heard will be able to analyze and discover the generalization or rule that underlies that speech. Not only must the learner devise the rule based on the speech that has been heard, but he or she must also figure out how those rules are to be applied in other cases.
π Definition β Induction: Learning rules by self-discovery, where the learner analyzes speech to discover underlying generalizations.
Memory: Vocabulary learning and rote memory is crucial to learning. It is inconceivable that a person with severe memory impairment could ever learn his or her native language, much less a second language. The learning of the simplest word requires memory. A person learning the word 'dog', for example, must retain a connection between the hearing of 'dog' and the experience of seeing, touching, or smelling a dog. Such a connection between the sound and the object is arbitrary β there is no logical relationship between the sound 'dog' and its meaning.
Topic-208: Summary of Three Important Psychological Factors Affecting Second-Language Learning
Three basic psychological categories are: Intellectual (subdivided into Inductive and Explicative), Memory, and Motor Skills. Along the left margin of the table, persons are divided into three age groups: Children under 7, Children 7 to 12, and Adults over 12.
Induction: Insofar as Induction is concerned, this ability remains at a relatively high level with age, except with certain individuals in old age. Such ability allows us to make new discoveries.
π‘ Why this matters: This table shows that inductive ability β the capacity to discover rules from exposure β does not decline significantly with age, supporting the claim that adults can learn second languages effectively.
Topic-209: Social Situations Affecting Second-Language Learning
There are many social situations in which a second language is learned, which can be covered according to three categories: the natural, the classroom, and community context. The natural situation is similar to that in which the first language is learned and can involve social situations such as family, play, or the workplace. The classroom situation involves the social situation of the school classroom. The community context allows students to have access to a natural situation outside of the class and thereby supplement their classroom learning. Each of these types of social situations has its own advantages and disadvantages.
Topic-210: Classroom Situations: Is There A Critical Age for Second-Language Learning?
Adults can learn a second language, so it is reasonable to ask about a critical age for second-language acquisition. As far as adult second-language learning is concerned, a very great number of adults do, in fact, learn the syntax of other languages perfectly. There are those who speak second languages so well that, on the basis of the grammar alone (not the pronunciation), they would be judged native speakers. There is no demonstrated critical age for learning syntax. However, there are studies which demonstrate a differential effect for the age at which acquisition of syntax began. Patkowski (1980) had native speakers of English rate the syntax of transcripts of spontaneous speech from immigrants to the USA who had entered before or after the age of 15. Transcripts were used to remove any possible influence of accent on the raters.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical finding from this lecture is that children and adults learn second languages differently rather than one being inherently superior β children use the "deep motor area" for intuitive processing while adults use more conscious brain regions. Adults and adolescents actually have the edge in proficiency development due to their larger vocabularies and complex thinking, though children excel in pronunciation. There is no critical age for learning syntax, as adults can achieve native-like grammatical competence. Social factors including attitudes, age, gender, and motivation significantly affect learning outcomes, with females potentially outperforming males due to more positive attitudes and better listening comprehension. Finally, language learning requires the interplay of three psychological factors β induction (which remains strong with age), explication (which is limited because not all rules are known), and memory (which is crucial for vocabulary acquisition).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
According to Dr. Paul Thompson's MRI research, which part of the brain do children use when processing a second language, and how does this differ from adult brain processing?
-
What is the difference between explication and induction as methods of second-language learning, and why can a language not be learned entirely by explication?
-
According to Chambers and Trudgill (1980), what is the relationship between age of acquisition and the likelihood of achieving native-like grammatical ability and accent?
-
What two contradictory principles regarding gender did sociolinguists observe in language use, and how do these relate to women's performance in L2 learning?
-
What did Patkowski's (1980) study find regarding the age at which syntax acquisition began, and why did the researchers use transcripts instead of audio recordings?
π Lecture 36 β LANGUAGE, LEARNING, AND TEACHING
π Overview: This lecture explores the complex process of second language acquisition (SLA), focusing on learner characteristics, the role of age, and various learning strategies. It then traces the historical evolution of language teaching methods across nineteen centuries and the twentieth century, linking them to major schools of thought in linguistics and psychology.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers three key learner characteristics (motivation, anxiety, beliefs), the critical period hypothesis and age-related factors in SLA, four major learning strategies (memory, cognitive, comprehension, metacognitive), the definition of language teaching, and three main schools of thought (structural/behavioral, generative/cognitive, constructivist). It concludes with a historical survey of language teaching methods from the Classical/Grammar Translation Method to Communicative Language Teaching.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-211: Second Language Acquisition: Learner Characteristics, Linguistic Factors, Learning Processes
Three learner characteristics have consistently been found to be consequential for language learning: motivation, anxiety, and beliefs about language learning. These internal factors significantly influence a learner's success in acquiring a second language.
Topic-212: Age and Acquisition Instructional Variables
The age of second language (L2) acquisition is a factor that has raised a lot of interest and controversy. This phenomenon is called the βcritical periodβ or βtime sensitive.β According to Lenneberg, the critical period for language acquisition begins around the age of two. Research published prior to the mid-1990s claimed that people learning a second language after puberty still retain a foreign accent, while those who acquired it before puberty did not. Scovel suggests that if second language learning begins after the age of 12 years, learners can never βpass themselves off as native speakers phonologically.β
In early childhood, becoming bilingual is often an unconscious event, as natural as learning to walk or ride a bicycle. According to scientific surveys, language aspects such as pronunciation and intonation can be acquired easier during childhood, due to neuromuscular mechanisms which are only active until to the age of 12. Long agrees, but goes further by conditioning the acquisition of a native competence in morphology and syntax to exposure to the second before the age of 15. These assertions are contradicted by empirical studies on older beginners who have reached very high levels of second language competence.
Other factors to consider are childrenβs flexibility, spontaneity, and tolerance to new experiences. Kids are more willing to communicate with people than adults, they are curious and they are not afraid of making mistakes. They handle difficulties (such as missing vocabulary) very easily by using creative methods to communicate, such as non-verbal means of communication and use of onomatopoetic words. Also the idea of a foreign civilization is not formed in their minds yet. Only at the age of 8 does it become clear to them that there are ethnic and cultural differences. Last but not least, aspects such as time, greater learning and memory capacity are advantages in early language learning. On the other hand there are surveys which point out the risk of semi-legalism and advise parents to organize language planning carefully.
Topic-213: Rejoicing in Our Defeats: Language Learning and Teaching
Second language learning is a conscious process where the learning of another language other than the First language (L1) takes place. Often confused with bilingualism and multilingualism, the process has to take place after the first language(s) has already been acquired. People who adopt the memory strategy depend on their memorizing ability. They find ways to remember better to aid in entering information into long-term memory, by creating a word-meaning map in their brain (mental linkages), and then being able to retrieve that information. Adopting this strategy will allow the learning and retrieval via sounds (e.g., rhyming), images (e.g., a mental picture of the word itself or the meaning of the word), a combination of sounds and images (e.g., the keyword method), body movement (e.g., total physical response), mechanical means (e.g., flashcards), or location (e.g., on a page or blackboard). Things they do: do a lot of exercises on English grammar, create a word bank, and memorize meanings.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding different learning strategies helps teachers tailor instruction to individual student needs and helps learners become more effective and autonomous.
Cognitive strategy: People who adopt the cognitive strategy tend to analyze and reason. They form internal mental codes and revise them to receive and produce the message in the target language. Adopting this strategy will enable you to internalize the language in direct ways such as through reasoning, analysis, note-taking, summarizing, synthesizing, outlining, and practicing in naturalistic settings, and practicing structures and sounds formally.
Comprehension strategy: People who adopt the comprehension strategy find themselves guessing unknown words when listening and reading. They also try to replace words they do not know with longer phrases or other words that they know when speaking and writing to overcome gaps in knowledge.
Metacognitive strategy: People who adopt the metacognitive strategy plan, arrange, focus, and evaluate on their own learning process. They identify and monitor their own learning style preferences and needs, such as gathering and organizing L2 materials, arranging a study space and a schedule for L2 revision and learning, monitoring mistakes made in L2, evaluating task success, and evaluating the success of any type of learning strategy.
Language teaching cannot be defined apart from learning. Teaching is guiding and facilitating learning, enabling the learner to learn, setting the conditions for learning. Your understanding of how the learner learns will determine your philosophy of education, your teaching style, your approach, methods, and classroom techniques. If, like B. F. Skinner, you look at learning as a process of operant conditioning through a carefully paced program of reinforcement, you will teach accordingly. If you view second language learning as a deductive rather than an inductive process, you will probably choose to present copious rules and paradigms to your students. An extended definitionβor theoryβof teaching will spell out governing principles for choosing certain methods and techniques. In other words, your theory of teaching is your theory of learning "stood on its head."
Topic-214: Schools of Thought in Second Language Acquisition
Structural Linguistics and Behavioral Psychology: In the 1940s and 1950s, the structural, or descriptive, school of linguistics, with its advocatesβLeonard Bloomfield, Edward Sapir, Charles Hockett, Charles Fries, and othersβprided itself in a rigorous application of scientific observations of human languages. Only "publicly observable responses" could be subject to investigation. An important axiom of structural linguistics was that languages can differ from each other without limit, and that no preconceptions could apply across languages. Freeman Twaddeli stated that the scientist proceeds as though there were no such things as mind, spirit, or soul. Such attitudes prevailed in B. F. Skinner's thought particularly in Verbal Behavior (1957), in which he said that any notion of "idea" or "meaning" is explanatory fiction, and that the speaker is merely the locus of verbal behavior, not the cause. Charles Osgood reinstated meaning in verbal behavior, explaining it as a "representational mediation process" but still did not depart from a generally nonmentalistic view of language. Language could be dismantled into small pieces or units and these units could be described scientifically, contrasted, and added up again to form the whole.
Generative linguistics and cognitive psychology: In the decade of the 1960s, generative-transformational linguistics emerged through the influence of Noam Chomsky. The generative linguist was interested not only in describing language (achieving the level of descriptive adequacy) but also in arriving at an explanatory level of adequacy, that is, a "principled basis, independent of any particular language, for the selection of the descriptively adequate grammar of each language" (Chomsky, 1964). Early seeds were planted by Ferdinand de Saussure (1916) who claimed a difference between parole (what Skinner "observes," and what Chomsky called performance) and langue (akin to competence, or our underlying and unobservable language ability). Cognitive psychologists asserted that meaning, understanding, and knowing were significant data for psychological study. They freed themselves from the strictly empirical study typical of behaviorists and employed the tools of logic, reason, extrapolation, and inference in order to derive explanations for human behavior. The generative linguist and cognitive psychologist were far more interested in the why question: what underlying factorsβinnate, psychological, social, or environmental circumstancesβcaused a particular behavior?
Constructivism - a multidisciplinary approach: Constructivism emerged as a prevailing paradigm in the last part of the twentieth century. A refreshing characteristic of constructivism is its integration of linguistic, psychological, and sociological paradigms. It has two branches: cognitive and social. In the cognitive version, emphasis is placed on the importance of learners constructing their own representation of reality. These claims are rooted in Jean Piaget's seminal work; for Piaget, "learning is a developmental process that involves change, self-generation, and construction, each building on prior learning experiences." Social constructivism emphasizes the importance of social interaction and cooperative learning in constructing both cognitive and emotional images of reality. The champion of social constructivism is Lev Vygotsky (1978), who advocated the view that "children's thinking and meaning-making is socially constructed and emerges out of their social interactions with their environment."
π Definition β Descriptive Adequacy: The level of analysis where a grammar successfully describes the linguistic data of a particular language. π Formula: Descriptive Adequacy (what) β Explanatory Adequacy (why) π Example: A structural linguist asks what someone did (e.g., threw a chair), while a generative linguist asks why they did it (e.g., their psychological state). The first is rigorous but limited; the second is richer but riskier.
π Definition β Competence vs. Performance: Competence (langue) is the underlying, unobservable knowledge of a language system; Performance (parole) is the overt, observable manifestation of language use.
π Definition β Constructivism: A multidisciplinary approach integrating linguistic, psychological, and sociological paradigms, emphasizing that learners actively construct their own understanding and knowledge of the world through experience and social interaction.
Topic-215: Nineteen Centuries of Language Teaching
Kelly's (1969) survey of language teaching over "twenty-five centuries" revealed anecdotal accounts but few research-based methods. In the Western world, "foreign" language learning was synonymous with learning Latin or Greek. Latin was taught by means of the Classical Method: focus on grammatical rules, memorization of vocabulary and of various declensions and conjugations, translation of texts, doing written exercises. As other languages began to be taught in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, the Classical Method was adopted as the chief means for teaching foreign languages. Late in the nineteenth century, the Classical Method came to be known as the Grammar Translation Method. Prator and Ceice-Murcia listed the major characteristics of Grammar Translation:
- Classes taught in the mother tongue; little use of the L2.
- Much vocabulary taught in the form of lists of isolated words.
- Elaborate explanations of the intricacies of grammar.
- Reading of difficult classical texts begun early.
- Texts treated as exercises in grammatical analysis.
- Occasional drills and exercises in translating sentences from L1 to L2.
- Little or no attention to pronunciation.
It does virtually nothing to enhance a student's communicative ability in the language.
Topic-216: Language Teaching in the Twentieth Century
Against the backdrop of the previous 19 centuries, a glance through the past century of language teaching gives us a picture of varied interpretations of the "best" way to teach a foreign language. Albert Marckwardt saw these as a cyclical pattern in which a new paradigm of teaching methodology emerged about every quarter of a century. Mitchell and Vidal described the last century metaphorically as a pendulum swinging between opposing options: focus on accuracy vs. focus on fluency, separation of skills vs. integration of skills, and teacher-centered vs. learner-centered approaches. They suggested a new metaphor: "that of a major river, constantly flowing, fed by many sources of water."
One of the best examples is the revolutionary Audiolingual Method (ALM) of the late 1940s and 1950s. The ALM with its overemphasis on oral production drills borrowed tenets from its predecessor, the Direct Method, but had essentially sprung from behavioral theories of learning of the time. The same era has seen linguists searching for answers to the nature of communication and communicative competence. Many of the pedagogical innovations of the last few decades are captured in the term Communicative Language Teaching (CLT), now a catch phrase for language teachers. CLT is an eclectic blend of the contributions of previous methods into the best of what a teacher can provide in authentic uses of the second language in the classroom. The single greatest challenge in the profession is to move beyond teaching rules and patterns to teaching students to communicate genuinely, spontaneously, and meaningfully.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that second language acquisition is influenced by a complex interplay of learner characteristics (motivation, anxiety, beliefs), age (with a critical period for native-like pronunciation ending around puberty), and learning strategies (memory, cognitive, comprehension, and metacognitive). Historically, the field has moved from the structural/behaviorist school, which focused on observable stimuli and responses, to the generative/cognitive school, which prioritized underlying competence, and finally to constructivism, which emphasizes the learner's active role in building meaning through social interaction. This theoretical evolution is mirrored in language teaching, which has progressed from the Grammar Translation Method (focused on rules and translation) through the Audiolingual Method (focused on drills) to the modern Communicative Language Teaching (CLT), which prioritizes authentic, meaningful communication. A key takeaway is that a teacher's theory of teaching is directly derived from their theory of learning.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- List the three learner characteristics that have been found to be consequential for second language acquisition.
- What is the critical period hypothesis, and what specific language aspect is most affected by an age of acquisition after 12?
- Name and briefly describe the four learning strategies for second language learning outlined in Topic-213.
- What is the main difference between the structural/behaviorist and generative/cognitive schools of thought in terms of the questions they ask about language?
- List two major characteristics of the Grammar Translation Method and explain the central goal of the Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) approach.
π Lecture 37 β LEARNING STYLE
π Overview: This lecture explores various learning styles that mediate between emotion and cognition in language acquisition. It covers field independence/dependence, multiple classroom learning styles (auditory, visual, verbal, kinesthetic, social), ambiguity tolerance, reflectivity/impulsivity, and the practical role of these styles in teaching and learning English as a second language.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with learning styles as mediators between emotion and cognition, focusing on field independence as the ability to perceive relevant items within distracting fields. It then examines learning styles in the classroom including auditory, visual, verbal, kinesthetic, and social learners. The discussion continues with ambiguity tolerance and the reflectivity/impulsivity dimension, followed by the role of learning styles in teaching/learning processes. The lecture concludes with visual, auditory, and kinesthetic styles, and students' diverse learning styles in ESL contexts.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-217: Learning Style: Field Independence
Learning styles mediate between emotion and cognition. A reflective style grows out of a reflective personality or mood, while an impulsive style arises from an impulsive emotional state. People's styles are determined by how they internalize their total environment, where physical, affective, and cognitive domains merge. Styles may be stable traits in adults, but DΓΆrnyei and Skehan (2003) note that while predispositions may be deep-seated, flexibility and adaptation to particular circumstances are possible. Individuals show general tendencies toward one style, but differing contexts evoke differing styles. A "bicognitive" person can manipulate both ends of a style continuum.
Field independence (FI) refers to the ability to perceive a particular, relevant item or factor in a "field" of distracting items. This field may be perceptual or abstract, involving thoughts, ideas, or feelings from which one must perceive specific subsets. Field dependence (or field sensitivity) is the tendency to be dependent on the total field, making embedded parts difficult to perceive while the whole is perceived more clearly as a unified whole.
π Definition β Field Independence (FI): The ability to distinguish parts from a whole, concentrate on something (like reading in a noisy train station), or analyze separate variables without contamination from neighboring variables. π Definition β Field Dependence: The tendency to be dependent on the total field so that embedded parts are not easily perceived, though the total field is perceived more clearly as a unified whole. π Example: In a coloring book with a forest scene and hidden monkeys, the ability to spot the camouflaged monkeys depends on field independent style. A dozen monkeys were hidden among leaves and trees, some upside-down, some sideways.
Topic-218: Learning Styles in the Classroom
Auditory and musical learners like to hear solutions and examples explained. They may gravitate toward music subjects and group learning. They often possess a "good ear" for music and tones, may be distractible, and like to talk to themselves or others, hum, or sing. They might say words out loud or hum tones to better learn them.
Visual and spatial learners like diagrams, drawing out concepts, charts, and processes. They learn by looking at visual concepts, creating them, and watching others create them. Qualities include habitual doodling/drawing, being observant, not easily distracted, enjoying planning, and preferring visual instructions.
Verbal learners prefer both writing and speaking. They might favor reading, writing, word games, and poems. They know the meanings of a broad category of words, use them effectively, and actively seek new words. Qualities include being intellectual, bookworms, and good storytellers. They often seek careers in journalism, writing, administration, law, and politics.
Physical or kinesthetic learners (about 5% of the population) prefer to physically engage with materials. Qualities include preference to "get their hands dirty," being energetic (may drum fingers or shake legs), action-oriented and outgoing, and may deprioritize reading and writing. They gravitate toward careers like emergency services, physical education, and sports.
Social and interpersonal learners show preference toward groups and collaboration. Some gravitate toward leadership. Qualities include being extraverted, good communicators, sensitive, and empathetic. Not all social learners are extraverted; they can also be visual, auditory, verbal, logical, or physical learners. The interpersonal aspect describes settings where they are most comfortable. Social doesn't strictly mean verbalβsome social learners prefer to listen in a group setting.
Topic-219: Ambiguity Tolerance
Ambiguity tolerance concerns the degree to which one is cognitively willing to tolerate ideas and propositions that run counter to one's own belief system or structure of knowledge. Ambiguity tolerant individuals are relatively open-minded in accepting ideologies, events, and facts that contradict their views. They are more content to entertain and even internalize contradictory propositions. Ambiguity intolerant individuals are more closed-minded and dogmatic, tending to reject items that are contradictory or slightly incongruent with their existing system.
Reflectivity and impulsivity relate to tendencies toward quick or gambling guesses (impulsive) versus slower, more calculated decisions (reflective). David Ewing (1977) referred to systematic and intuitive styles. An intuitive style involves making several different gambles based on "hunches" before a solution is achieved. Systematic thinkers weigh all considerations, work out loopholes, and after extensive reflection, venture a solution.
π Example: Kagan (1965) found that conceptually reflective children tend to make fewer errors in reading than impulsive children. However, impulsive persons are usually faster readers and eventually master the "psycholinguistic guessing game" (Goodman, 1970) of reading without necessarily deterring comprehension.
Topic-220: The Role of Learning Styles in the Teaching/Learning Process
An individual's learning style is "the way he or she concentrates on, processes, internalizes, and remembers new and difficult academic information or skills." A person's approach to learning is a relatively stable indicator of how they perceive, interact with, and respond to the learning environment.
Understanding learning styles is a key component in effective teaching. According to Sarasin, "teaching cannot be successful without knowledge of learning styles and a commitment to matching them with teaching styles and strategies." Utilizing learning style theory in the classroom is beneficial at all educational levels. Research has found relationships between occupational preferences and learning style type. Students' learning styles are affected by educational experiences, particularly at the postsecondary level.
π Example: Individuals pursuing careers in information technology (IT) typically encounter professional work environments that exploit extensive problem-solving, drawing upon abilities with a kinesthetic learning style. Knowledge of learning styles helps design classroom activities supporting this style's development.
Topic-221: Visual, Auditory, and Kinesthetic Styles
Visual learners prefer reading and studying charts, drawings, and other graphic information. Auditory learners prefer listening to lectures and audiotapes. Kinesthetic learners show preference for demonstrations and physical activity involving bodily movement. Most successful learners utilize both visual and auditory input, but slight preferences distinguish one learner from another.
Joy Reid (1987) studied adult ESL learners and found significant cross-cultural differences. Using a self-reporting questionnaire, students rated statements on a five-point scale from "strongly agree" to "strongly disagree."
π Example: Korean students were significantly more visually oriented than native English-speaking Americans. Japanese students were the least auditory students, significantly less auditory inclined than Chinese and Arabic students. Preferences were also a factor of gender, length of time in the United States, academic field of study, and level of education. π‘ Why this matters: Measurement of style preferences (usually by self-check questionnaires) is problematic (Ehrman & Leaver, 2003), so teachers must take a cautious approach despite research confirming the importance of recognizing learners' varying preferences.
Topic-222: Students' Diverse Learning Styles in Learning English as A Second Language
Language learning success is associated with age, gender, motivation, intelligence, anxiety level, learning strategies, and language learning styles (Sharp, 2004). In a class with various learning styles, teachers must identify, respect, and work with the diversity of learners' differences.
Students may have different motivation levels, attitudes about teaching and learning, and responses to classroom environments and instructional practices. This aligns with Spolsky's general model of second language learning (1989).
Perceptual learning style involves learning through the five senses:
- Auditory learners: learn more through hearing
- Visual learners: learn more through seeing
- Tactile learners: discover things through sense of touch
- Kinesthetic learners: enjoy learning through movement and body experience
- Haptic learners: combination of tactile and kinesthetic, learning through sense of touch and body involvement
Environmental learning style comprises:
- Physical dimension: variables such as temperature, sound, light, food, time, and classroom management
- Sociological dimension: variables such as group, individual, pair and team work, and level of teacher authorityβimportant for encouraging students' motivation to learn
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are that learning styles mediate between emotion and cognition, with field independence enabling learners to distinguish relevant items from distracting fields while field dependence focuses on the whole. Classroom learning styles include auditory, visual, verbal, kinesthetic, and social types, each with distinct preferences and qualities. Ambiguity tolerance reflects openness to contradictory ideas, while reflectivity/impulsivity describes decision-making speed in problem-solving. Understanding learning styles is essential for effective teaching, as teachers must match styles with strategies, though measurement through self-report questionnaires remains problematic. Finally, perceptual and environmental learning styles play crucial roles in second language acquisition, requiring teachers to recognize and accommodate diverse learner differences.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between field independence and field dependence in learning styles, and how does this relate to the "hidden monkeys" example?
- List and briefly describe the five types of classroom learning styles discussed in Topic-218.
- How does ambiguity tolerance differ from ambiguity intolerance, and what implications does this have for language learning?
- According to Joy Reid's (1987) study, what were the cross-cultural differences found between Korean, Japanese, Chinese, and Arabic students in terms of visual and auditory preferences?
- What are the two dimensions of environmental learning style, and what variables does each dimension include?