π Lecture 31 β Grammatical Influences on Cognition
π Overview: This lecture examines the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis by exploring how grammatical structures in different languages may influence cognitive processes. It investigates specific grammatical featuresβsubjunctive mood, object marking, substance marking, and gender systemsβand presents experimental evidence showing how language might shape thought, while also acknowledging the controversies and limitations of this hypothesis.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Bloom's controversial studies on counterfactual reasoning differences between Chinese and English speakers, the development of subjunctive abilities in foreign language learners (particularly Spanish), Carroll and Casagrande's Navaho-English comparison study on grammatical marking of form, cross-linguistic differences in grammatical marking of objects and substances between English and Japanese, grammatical gender systems in Spanish versus English, and final critical observations about the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis including its ambiguous formulations and measurement challenges.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-181: Grammatical Influences on Cognition: Studies of Subjunctive
H. Bloom (1981) conducted influential but controversial studies on differences between how Chinese and English speakers reason. He focused on counterfactual reasoning, defined as the ability to reason about an event that is contrary to fact. For example, consider a situation where several people are waiting for John; he is late, and the group consequently is late to the movies. The English language has the subjunctive mood, shown in sentence (2): "If John had come earlier, they would have arrived at the movies on time" (adapted from Bloom, 1981, p. 19). This grammatical structure enables speakers to discuss states of affairs known to be false. Lucy (1992b) noted that counterfactual reasoning is more specialized than habitual thought because it is probably more accessible to those with higher levels of education, raising questions about whether Whorfian effects can be observed when assessing more habitual forms of thought.
π Definition β Counterfactual Reasoning: The cognitive ability to reason about an event that is contrary to known facts or reality. π Formula: [If [counterfactual condition], then [imagined outcome]] β This grammatical structure allows speakers to mentally simulate alternative realities that did not occur. π Example: In the scenario where John arrived late causing the group to miss the movie start, English speakers can say "If John had come earlier, they would have arrived at the movies on time" β this subjunctive construction permits reasoning about a situation known to be false.
π‘ Why this matters: This research investigates whether the presence or absence of specific grammatical structures (like subjunctive mood) determines a speaker's ability to perform certain types of reasoning.
Topic-182: The Development of Subjunctive and Complex-Syntactic
For many foreign-language (FL) learners of Spanish, the subjunctive is one of the most unique grammatical constructs of the Spanish language. The subjunctive is not highly productive in English, so students have almost no L1 models with which to formulate hypotheses about its use in Spanish. This challenge is augmented by the subjunctive's linguistic complexities β it denotes abstract concepts (e.g., marking irrealis events and states) and has a syntactic distribution that is largely limited to subordinate clauses. The present review critically examines almost thirty years of research aimed at understanding the processes through which learners pass in the development of subjunctive abilities and the factors that interact with those processes. The author contextualizes this by analyzing important studies on subjunctive acquisition in first-language (L1) and bilingual contexts, then examines factors affecting subjunctive development in FL contexts and variables influencing the development of abilities for processing complex syntax. Finally, the chapter outlines experimental design issues that limit the generalization of conclusions from these L1, bilingual, and FL studies.
π Definition β Irrealis Events: Events or states that are not actual or real, but are hypothetical, desired, doubted, or otherwise not part of factual reality. π Definition β Subjunctive Mood: A grammatical mood used to express hypothetical, wished-for, or uncertain actions or states, typically appearing in subordinate clauses.
Topic-183: Grammatical Marking of Form
A study by Carroll and Casagrande (1958) compared Navaho and English. They observed that in Navaho, the form of the verb for handling an object varies with the form or shape of the object. The verb varies if the object is a long flexible object (such as a piece of string) versus a long rigid object (such as a stick) or a flat flexible object (such as a cloth). On the basis of this grammatical distinction, Carroll and Casagrande proposed that Navaho-speaking children would learn to discriminate the forms of objects at an earlier age than their English-speaking peers. They used an object triads test in which the child had to pick which of two objects, of three presented, went best together. For example, a child might be presented with a yellow stick and a piece of blue rope of comparable size. The child would then be shown a yellow rope and asked with which of the first two it went best, allowing researchers to determine whether children were focusing more on color or form. Carroll and Casagrande compared children who spoke Navaho with children who spoke English but came from the same reservation and lived in similar circumstances. The results seemed to support Whorf's view that grammatical distinctions in a language may influence or determine certain cognitive processes. However, observations from suburban children suggested that even if grammatical categories determine qualities of thought, they are not the only determinants β other attributes of the child's environment may serve the same function.
π Definition β Object Triads Test: An experimental method where participants are presented with three objects and asked to choose which two of the three go best together, revealing which perceptual features (e.g., color vs. form) participants prioritize. π Example: A child sees Object A (yellow stick), Object B (blue rope of comparable size), and Object C (yellow rope). The child must choose whether Object C goes best with Object A (same color β yellow) or Object B (same form β rope). The choice reveals whether the child prioritizes color or form in categorization.
Topic-184: Grammatical Marking of Objects and Substances
Languages differ in their grammatical distinction of objects and substances. In English, objects such as candles and chairs are referred to as count nouns. Count nouns have distinct singular and plural forms (e.g., candle, candles). Moreover, count nouns can be counted (one candle, two candles, and so on). In contrast, nouns such as air, water, and mud are referred to as mass nouns. They cannot take the plural morpheme and cannot be directly counted. We can count even mass nouns by using expressions such as two buckets of mud or three gallons of water. In contrast, in Japanese, all inanimate nouns are treated like English mass nouns (Gentner & Boroditsky, 2001). These nouns cannot take the plural morpheme and can only be counted in the indirect manner of English mass nouns. According to the Whorf hypothesis, if it is correct, children would not notice these similarities and differences (between objects and substances) before acquiring the linguistic distinction (between mass and count nouns) that draws one's attention to them. Moreover, the hypothesis would suggest that children acquiring English and Japanese would see this aspect of the world very differently.
π Definition β Count Nouns: Nouns that have distinct singular and plural forms and can be directly counted (e.g., candle/candles, one candle, two candles). π Definition β Mass Nouns: Nouns that cannot take the plural morpheme and cannot be directly counted (e.g., air, water, mud), requiring indirect expressions like two buckets of mud. π Example: An English-speaking child sees a rock (count noun) and a pile of mud (mass noun) β English grammar treats these differently. A Japanese-speaking child sees the same objects, but Japanese grammar treats both as mass nouns. The Whorf hypothesis predicts these children would perceive these objects' fundamental nature differently due to their languages' grammatical distinctions.
Topic-185: Grammatical Marking of Gender
English marks grammatical gender only in singular personal pronouns (e.g., he, she, it). In contrast, other languages have much more extensive gender systems. Spanish nouns that refer to males end in -o (as in hermano or brother, and gato or male cat) and words that refer to females end in -a (hermana, gata). In addition, many Spanish nouns are marked for gender even if there is no obvious semantic basis for it. For example, key, grapes, and table are feminine in Spanish, and plane, telephone, and bucket are masculine. The gender systems of English and Spanish are quite different, and it is natural to investigate what effect these systems might have on their learners.
π Definition β Grammatical Gender: A system of classifying nouns into gender categories (e.g., masculine, feminine, neuter) that may or may not correspond to biological sex, affecting agreement with other words in a sentence. π Example: In Spanish, la llave (key β feminine) requires feminine articles and adjectives, while el aviΓ³n (plane β masculine) requires masculine forms, even though keys and planes have no inherent biological sex.
Topic-186: Final Observations
Both Sapir and Whorf agreed that it is our culture that determines our language, which in turn determines the way that we categorize our thoughts about the world and our experiences in it. For more than fifty years, researchers have tried to design studies that will support or refute this hypothesis. Support for the strong version (linguistic determinism) has been weak because it is virtually impossible to test one's world view without using language. Support for the weaker version (linguistic relativity) has been minimal. Problems with the hypothesis begin when one tries to discern exactly what the hypothesis is stating. Penn notes that the hypothesis is stated "more and less strongly in different places in Sapir's and Whorf's writings" (1972:13). At some points, Sapir and Whorf appear to support the strong version of the hypothesis, and at others they only support the weak version. Alford (1980) also notes that neither Sapir nor Whorf actually named any of their ideas about language and cognition the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis β this name only appeared after their deaths, leading to wide interpretation of what researchers consider to be the one and only hypothesis. Another problem is that the hypothesis requires a measurement of human thought β measuring thought and one's world view is nearly impossible without the confounding influence of language, another of the variables being studied. Researchers settle for the study of behavior as a direct link to thought. If one believes the strong version of linguistic determinism, one also has to agree that thought is not possible without language β this raises questions about pre-linguistic thought of babies (how can babies acquire language without thought?) and the origin of language (language would have to be derived from a source outside the human realm because thought is impossible without language, and before language there would have been no thought).
π Definition β Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis: The theory that language determines or influences thought and perception, with a strong version (linguistic determinism β language determines thought) and a weak version (linguistic relativity β language influences thought).
π‘ Why this matters: These final observations highlight fundamental methodological and philosophical problems with testing the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, including circularity issues and the challenge of measuring thought independently of language.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis remains controversial because the strong version (linguistic determinism) is nearly impossible to test without the confounding influence of language, and the hypothesis itself was never formally named by Sapir or Whorf, leading to multiple interpretations. Studies like Bloom's work on counterfactual reasoning and Carroll and Casagrande's Navaho-English comparison provide some support for linguistic influences on cognition, but alternative explanationsβsuch as environmental factors (as seen with suburban children in the form-discrimination study)βcomplicate the findings. Cross-linguistic differences in grammatical features (subjunctive mood, count/mass noun distinctions, object-form verbs, and gender systems) present natural laboratories for testing Whorfian effects, but results are often mixed. The hypothesis faces fundamental philosophical challenges regarding pre-linguistic thought in infants and the origin of language itself, making the weaker version (linguistic relativity) more widely accepted than the strong version (linguistic determinism).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What did Bloom's (1981) study find about counterfactual reasoning differences between Chinese and English speakers, and what grammatical structure was central to this investigation?
- How did Carroll and Casagrande (1958) use the object triads test to determine whether Navaho-speaking children focused more on color or form compared to English-speaking children?
- What is the key difference between how English and Japanese grammatically treat inanimate nouns, and what prediction does the Whorf hypothesis make about children acquiring these two languages?
- What are the two versions of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis, and why is the strong version particularly difficult to test empirically?
- What philosophical problems arise if one accepts the strong version of linguistic determinism, particularly regarding babies and the origin of language?
π Lecture 32 β Neurolinguistics and Disorders
π Overview: This lecture explores language disorders from a neurolinguistic perspective, focusing on syntactic deficits in aphasia, particularly Broca's aphasia. It examines the classification and causes of aphasia, reading and writing disorders including various types of dyslexia, and explains how brain damage affects language processing abilities.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with syntactic disorders in language impairment, specifically agrammatic Broca's aphasia and its connection to Chomsky's generative theory. It then covers aphasia as an acquired language disorder, its causes and diagnosis including primary progressive aphasia. Reading and writing disorders are examined, followed by detailed explanations of phonological and surface dyslexia. The lecture concludes with discussions of dyslexia as a learning disability and deep dyslexia as an acquired reading disorder with distinctive semantic errors.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-187: Neurolinguistics and Disorders: Disorder of Syntax
Syntactic deficits are common in language disorders and have been a primary focus of research since the field's beginnings. Interest first focused on Broca's aphasia, an acquired language disorder caused by strokes affecting left frontal brain regions. The core symptom is agrammatic spontaneous speech, characterized by omissions of free functional elements and severe reduction in utterance length and syntactic complexity. This results in very short utterances consisting of simple, linearly organized strings of open-class words. Agrammatic Broca's aphasia has been considered ideal for investigating syntactic deficits, particularly within Chomsky's generative approach, which posits that the human language faculty is due to a specialized, domain-specific language organ in the brain that is part of our biological endowment and genetically specified. According to this theory, brain lesions affecting this language organ should impair the language faculty, and agrammatic Broca's aphasia seemed to exemplify this predicted case.
π Definition β Agrammatic spontaneous speech: Speech characterized by omissions of free functional elements and a severe reduction of the length and syntactic complexity of utterances, giving the impression of lacking syntactic structure.
π‘ Why this matters: The study of syntactic deficits in Broca's aphasia provides crucial evidence for understanding whether language is supported by specialized brain tissue, as proposed by generative linguistic theory.
Topic-188: Aphasia to Neurolinguistics
Aphasia is an acquired language disorder subsequent to brain damage in the left hemisphere. It is characterized by diminished abilities to produce and understand both spoken and written language compared with the speaker's presumed ability pre-cerebral damage. The type and severity depend on the location and extent of cerebral damage and the effect on connecting brain areas. Diagnosis is made in comparison with assumed normal adult language, and language changes associated with normal aging are not classed as aphasia.
The most common cause is a cerebral vascular accident (CVA) or stroke, but brain damage from traumatic head injury can also cause aphasia. Aphasia following trauma is non-progressive, unlike that arising from brain tumors, infections, or progressive conditions like Alzheimer's disease. The diagnosis of primary progressive aphasia is based on inclusion criteria (difficulty with language interfering with daily living, aphasia as most prominent symptom) and exclusion criteria (non-degenerative disease, psychiatric diagnosis, episodic/visual memory impairment, initial behavioral disturbance).
π Definition β Aphasia: An acquired language disorder subsequent to brain damage in the left hemisphere, characterized by diminished abilities to produce and understand spoken and written language.
π Primary Progressive Aphasia Inclusion Criteria: Difficulty with language that interferes with activities of daily living AND aphasia is the most prominent symptom.
Topic-189: Reading and Writing Disorders
Reading disorders occur when a person has trouble with any part of the reading process. Reading and language-based learning disabilities are commonly called dyslexia. These disorders are present from a young age and usually result from specific differences in the way the brain processes language. Symptoms vary and may include problems recognizing already known words, poor spelling, trouble with handwriting, difficulty reading quickly, problems reading with correct expression, and problems understanding the written word. Reading disorders are not a type of intellectual and development disorder, nor a sign of lower intelligence or unwillingness to learn. People with reading disorders may also have other learning disabilities involving writing or numbers.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding that reading disorders are brain-based processing differences rather than intelligence deficits is crucial for appropriate diagnosis and intervention.
Topic-190: Phonological and Surface Dyslexia
Surface dyslexia is a reading disorder where patients cannot recognize a word as a whole due to damage of the left parietal or temporal lobe. Individuals rely on pronunciation rules rather than whole-word recognition. They read non-words fluently (like "yatchet") but struggle with exception words that defy pronunciation rules. For example, they correctly read "mint" but err on "pint." Semantic knowledge is often preserved.
Phonological dyslexia involves difficulty sounding out unfamiliar words and poor performance on non-word reading tests. Students cannot break down individual sounds of language (phonemic awareness) and match them with written symbols, making it difficult to decode words. Most kids with reading issues have some degree of phonological dyslexia, also referred to as dysphonetic dyslexia.
π Definition β Surface dyslexia: A reading disorder where individuals cannot recognize words as wholes and rely on pronunciation rules, struggling with exception words but reading non-words fluently.
π Definition β Phonological dyslexia: A reading disorder characterized by difficulty sounding out unfamiliar words and poor phonemic awareness, making word decoding difficult.
π Example β Surface dyslexia: Patient correctly reads regular word "mint" but incorrectly reads exception word "pint" (pronouncing it to rhyme with "mint").
Topic-191: Dyslexia
Dyslexia is a brain-based type of learning disability that specifically impairs a person's ability to read. Individuals typically read at levels significantly lower than expected despite having normal intelligence. Common characteristics include difficulty with phonological processing (the manipulation of sounds), spelling, and/or rapid visual-verbal responding. Dyslexia can be inherited, and recent studies have identified genes that may predispose individuals to developing it. Specific types include: word decoding difficulty (matching letters to sounds), lack of fluency (difficulty reading quickly, accurately, and with proper expression), and poor reading comprehension (trouble understanding what is read).
π Definition β Dyslexia: A brain-based learning disability that impairs a person's ability to read, typically despite normal intelligence.
Topic-192: Deep Dyslexia
Deep dyslexia is usually classified as an acquired reading disorder in previously literate adults following brain injury, though developmental deep dyslexia has been reported in children with Williams's syndrome. It is considered central dyslexia as opposed to peripheral dyslexia. Peripheral dyslexics have difficulty matching visual characteristics of letters to stored word memories, while central dyslexics cannot properly match the visual word to the word's meaning. Deep dyslexia differs from other central dyslexias (phonological and surface dyslexia) in having more symptoms that are generally more severe. According to the "continuum" hypothesis, deep dyslexia is a more severe form of phonological dyslexia.
The main characteristic is the occurrence of semantic reading errors or semantic paralexias (transposition of letters or words) when reading aloud. For example, the written word "view" is read as "scene," or "bird" is read as "canary." These semantic errors distinguish deep dyslexia from other central dyslexias. Other symptoms include visual errors (e.g., "thing" read as "think"), derivational errors (e.g., "alcohol" read as "alcoholic"), poor reading of function words, more difficulty with abstract than concrete words, more difficulty with adjectives/adverbs/verbs than nouns, complete inability to read non-words, and often impairments in verbal working memory.
π Definition β Deep dyslexia: An acquired reading disorder characterized by semantic reading errors (semantic paralexias), visual errors, derivational errors, and poor reading of function words, considered a more severe form of phonological dyslexia.
π Definition β Central dyslexia: Inability to properly match the visual word to the word's meaning, as opposed to peripheral dyslexia which involves difficulty matching visual characteristics of letters to stored memories.
π Example β Semantic paralexias in deep dyslexia: Written word "view" is read aloud as "scene"; written word "bird" is read as "canary."
π Example β Visual errors in deep dyslexia: Written word "thing" is read as "think"; written word "skate" is read as "scale."
β Key Takeaways
Syntactic deficits, particularly agrammatism in Broca's aphasia, have been central to neurolinguistic research and support Chomsky's theory of a specialized language organ in the brain. Aphasia is an acquired language disorder from left hemisphere damage, with type and severity depending on lesion location and extent, and primary progressive aphasia has specific diagnostic criteria. Reading disorders, collectively called dyslexia, are brain-based processing differences rather than intelligence deficits, with surface dyslexia involving whole-word recognition failure and phonological dyslexia involving sound-symbol decoding difficulties. Deep dyslexia is distinguished from other dyslexias by semantic paralexias (reading errors where words are replaced by semantically related words) and is considered a more severe form of phonological dyslexia. The classification of reading disorders into peripheral versus central dyslexias helps localize the specific cognitive processing failures underlying different reading impairments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the core symptom of Broca's aphasia, and how does it relate to Chomsky's generative theory of language?
- What are the inclusion and exclusion criteria for diagnosing primary progressive aphasia?
- How does surface dyslexia differ from phonological dyslexia in terms of reading abilities and underlying deficits?
- What distinguishes deep dyslexia from other central dyslexias, and what types of reading errors characterize it?
- What is the difference between peripheral dyslexia and central dyslexia in terms of the cognitive processes affected?
π Lecture 33 β First Language Acquisition
π Overview: This lecture examines major theories of first language acquisition, from ancient experiments to modern linguistic perspectives. It explores the nature-nurture debate, distinctions between competence and performance, and how insights from first language research can inform language teaching. Understanding these foundational theories is crucial for grasping how humans acquire their native language.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five main topics: Theories of First Language Acquisition analyzing historical and modern theoretical frameworks; Challenges of Approaches to First Language Acquisition examining criticisms and modifications to behaviorist views; Issues in First Language Acquisition exploring competence vs. performance and comprehension vs. production distinctions; Nature or Nurture Universal debating innate versus environmental factors; Language and Thought examining the relationship between cognition and language; and First Language Acquisition Insights Applied to Language Teaching considering implications for pedagogy.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-193: Theories of First Language Acquisition
Historical experiments have investigated whether language is innate or acquired. Psammeticus, a 7th century BC Egyptian pharaoh, believed language was inborn and that isolated children would develop their innate language. King James V of Scotland (15th century) performed a similar experiment, with children reportedly speaking Hebrew. Akbar, a 16th century Mogul emperor, hypothesized that language is learned through exposure to speech. He placed two infants with a mute nurse; the children did not acquire speech, supporting Akbar's view that language is acquired through exposure. Modern linguists have developed several major theories: Jean Piaget's Cognitive Theory (1929), Skinner's Behaviorist Theory (1957), Chomsky's Innateness Hypothesis, Lambert's Critical Period Hypothesis (1967) for first language acquisition, and Krashen's 5 hypotheses for second language learning.
π Definition β Behaviorist Theory: The theory that language is acquired through conditioning, imitation, and reinforcement, as proposed by B.F. Skinner. π Definition β Innateness Hypothesis: The theory proposed by Chomsky that humans are born with an innate capacity for language acquisition. π Definition β Cognitive Theory: Piaget's theory that language development is dependent upon and springs from cognitive development.
Topic-194: Challenges of Approaches to First Language Acquisition
Skinner's behaviorist theories faced significant criticism, particularly from Noam Chomsky (1959) who wrote a critical review of Verbal Behavior. Kemieu MacCorquodale (1970) defended Skinner's views in response. Some psychologists proposed mediation theory as a modified position, where meaning was accounted for by claiming that a linguistic stimulus elicits a "mediating" response that is self-stimulating. Charles Osgood (1953, 1957) called this a "representational mediation process" - a covert, invisible process within the learner. Mediation theory attempted to account for abstraction through a notion of "mentalism", which was controversial for behaviorists. However, mediation theories left many questions unresolved, particularly about the abstract nature of language and the relationship between meaning and utterance. Sentences have deep structures (underlying meaning) manifested by surface structures, which mediation theory could not adequately explain.
π Definition β Mediation Theory: A modified behaviorist position proposing that linguistic stimuli elicit internal mediating responses that account for meaning and abstraction. π Definition β Deep Structure: The underlying level of meaning in a sentence that is manifested through surface structures.
Topic-195: Issues in First Language Acquisition
Competence and Performance: Competence refers to one's underlying knowledge of a system, event, or fact - the non-observable ability to do something. Performance is the overtly observable manifestation or realization of competence. In language, competence is one's underlying knowledge of a language's system (grammar rules, vocabulary), while performance is actual production (speaking, writing) or comprehension (listening, reading). Chomsky (1965) likened competence to an "idealized" speaker-hearer who does not display performance variables like memory limitations, distractions, shifts of attention, errors, and hesitation phenomena (repeats, false starts, pauses, omissions, additions).
Comprehension and Production: These are distinct from competence-performance. Research shows children generally demonstrate superiority of comprehension over production - they understand "more" than they produce. For example, a child may understand a sentence with an embedded relative clause but cannot produce one. W.R. Miller (1963) provided a phonological example where a three-year-old said her name was "Litha," could hear the contrast between /s/ and /ΞΈ/ but could not produce it. This "lag" between comprehension and production requires distinguishing between production competence and comprehension competence - linguistic competence has multiple modes (speaking, listening, reading, writing).
π Definition β Competence: One's underlying knowledge of a system, event, or fact; the non-observable ability to perform something. π Definition β Performance: The overtly observable and concrete manifestation or realization of competence. π Example: A child understanding "The ball that's in the sandbox is red" (comprehension) but being unable to produce such a sentence (production lag).
Topic-196: Nature or Nurture Universal
Nativists contend that children are born with an innate knowledge of or predisposition toward language (the LAD or UG), universal in all humans. The innateness hypothesis resolved the contradiction between behaviorist conditioning and the complexity of language acquisition. However, it presented problems: the LAD proposition postpones facing the central issue of human capacity for language acquisition, and we cannot yet scientifically explain the genetic transmission of linguistic ability. Emergentist scholars challenge the notion that what is innate is grammatical or linguistic. Derek Bickerton (1981) found evidence of common patterns across languages and proposed that humans are "bio-programmed" to proceed from stage to stage - like flowering plants, people are innately programmed to "release" certain properties of language at specific developmental ages.
π‘ Why this matters: The nature-nurture debate remains central to understanding language acquisition. Environmental factors cannot be ignored, as connectionists and emergentists have shown, but genetic evidence for language abilities continues to mount.
π Definition β Nativist: The position that a child is born with innate knowledge of or predisposition toward language. π Definition β Bio-Programming: Bickerton's proposal that human beings are innately programmed to proceed through predetermined linguistic developmental stages.
Topic-197: Language and Thought Imitation, Practice and Frequency, Input, Discourse
Researchers have probed the relationship between language and cognition. The behavioral view that cognition is too mentalistic to study scientifically opposes Piaget (1972) who claimed cognitive development is central and language depends upon it. Jerome Bruner (Bruner, Olver, & Greenfield, 1966) emphasized language's influence on cognitive development, citing words shaping concepts and parent-child dialogues orienting and educating. Vygotsky (1962, 1978) differed from Piaget, claiming that social interaction through language is a prerequisite to cognitive development. Thought and language were seen as two distinct cognitive operations that grow together (Schinke-Llano, 1993).
π Definition β Social Interaction Theory (Vygotsky): The theory that social interaction through language is a prerequisite to cognitive development.
Topic-198: First Language Acquisition Insights Applied to Language Teaching
There is strong evidence for an innate linguistic capacity assisting acquisition of linguistic structures. However, by broadening language to include semantics and pragmatics, the child's environmental and social interactions become increasingly important. The capacity to learn language is multifarious - due to an inextricable combination of biological and environmental factors. These insights raise questions about whether similar language learning capacities exist in second language learners, though difficulties arise in making cross-learner comparisons.
π Definition β Multifarious Capacity: The view that language learning capacity results from a complex combination of biological and environmental factors.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that first language acquisition is neither purely innate nor purely environmental but results from an intricate interaction of biological, cognitive, and social factors. Students must understand the critical distinctions between competence (underlying knowledge) and performance (observable production), as well as comprehension and production, noting that comprehension typically precedes production in development. The historical experiments and modern theories (behaviorist, nativist, cognitive, and social interactionist) each contribute valuable perspectives, but no single theory fully explains language acquisition. The nature-nurture debate continues with evidence supporting both innate linguistic capacity (bioprogramming) and environmental influences (social interaction). Finally, insights from first language acquisition - particularly the importance of social interaction and the interplay of biological and environmental factors - have direct applications to second language teaching.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What were the findings of Akbar's experiment with isolated infants, and what did they suggest about language acquisition?
- What is mediation theory, and how did it attempt to modify behaviorist explanations of language acquisition?
- How does Chomsky distinguish between competence and performance, and what performance variables does he exclude from idealized competence?
- What evidence supports the claim that comprehension precedes production in child language development?
- How do Piaget, Bruner, and Vygotsky differ in their views on the relationship between language and thought?
π Lecture 34 β Age and Acquisition
π Overview: This lecture explores the complex relationship between age and second language acquisition, comparing children and adults as language learners. It examines neurobiological, anthropological, and cognitive factors that influence acquisition, including hemispheric lateralization, critical period hypotheses, and the role of first language interference. Understanding these factors is crucial for developing effective language teaching methods across different age groups.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by comparing children and adults in second-language learning, then examines neurobiological considerations through hemispheric lateralization. It presents anthropological evidence from non-Western societies, discusses cognitive considerations including Piaget's stages, explores interference between first and second languages, revisits key issues in first language acquisition including Chomsky's innateness position and Piaget's logical thinking, and concludes with the concept of order of acquisition in language learning.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-199: Children Vs. Adults in Second-Language Learning
Comparing first and second language acquisition is not straightforward. It is illogical to directly compare a child's first language acquisition with an adult's second language acquisition because this confuses two different learning situations and two different age groups. A more logical approach is to compare first and second language learning within the same age group (children) or compare second language learning in children and adults. Nevertheless, child first language acquisition and adult second language acquisition are important comparative categories. An adult is typically defined as someone who has reached the age of puberty. Few instances of adults acquiring a first language exist, such as the case of Genie (Curtiss, 1977), a 13-year-old girl discovered after years of social isolation and abuse who had to acquire a first language. Accounts of "wolf children" and severe disability cases also fall into this category.
Topic-200: Neurobiological Considerations Hemispheric Lateralization
Hemispheric lateralization refers to the process where certain functions are assigned to either the left or right hemisphere of the brain as it matures. Intellectual, logical, and analytic functions are largely located in the left hemisphere, while emotional and social functions are controlled by the right hemisphere. Language functions appear to be controlled mainly in the left hemisphere, though evidence is conflicting. Patients with left hemispherectomies can still comprehend and produce language, while stroke victims with left hemisphere lesions often show language impairment, which is less common with right hemisphere lesions. Millar and Whitaker (1983) cautioned against the simple view that the left hemisphere is solely the "language hemisphere". A crucial question for second language researchers is when lateralization occurs. Eric Lenneberg (1967) proposed that lateralization is a slow process beginning around age 2 and completing around puberty, during which the child's brain gradually assigns functions including language to one hemisphere.
π Definition β Hemispheric lateralization: The process by which specific cognitive and linguistic functions become specialized to either the left or right hemisphere of the brain as it matures.
Topic-201: Anthropological Evidence
Some adults do acquire a native-like accent in a second language after puberty, but such cases are rare. Anthropologist Jane Hill (1970) cited research on non-Western societies where adults can acquire second languages perfectly. A unique case was reported by Sorenson (1967) studying the Tukano culture of South America, where at least two dozen languages were spoken among exogamous communities (people must marry outside their language group). Sorenson reported that during adolescence, individuals actively and almost suddenly began speaking two or three other languages to which they had been exposed. Moyer (2004) emphasized that multiple cognitive, social, psychological, and strategic variables affect ultimate proficiency in a second language.
Cognitive considerations: Human cognition develops rapidly through the first 16 years of life. Jean Piaget outlined intellectual development through stages: Sensorimotor (birth to 2), Preoperational (2 to 7), Concrete operational (7 to 11), and Formal operational (11 to 16). A critical stage for age effects on second language acquisition occurs at puberty (age 11), when a person becomes capable of abstraction and formal thinking that transcends concrete experience. Cognitively, an argument can be made for a critical period by connecting language acquisition to the concrete/formal stage transition. However, Singleton and Ryan objected to connecting Piagetian stages with critical period arguments, noting the "vagueness" and lack of empirical data in Piaget's theory. Ausubel (1964) noted that adults learning a second language could benefit from grammatical explanations and deductive thinking that would be pointless for a child.
π‘ Why this matters: The cognitive differences between children and adults suggest that teaching methods should be tailored to the learner's developmental stage, with adults potentially benefiting from explicit grammar instruction while children may learn more implicitly.
π Definition β Formal operational stage: Piaget's stage beginning at age 11 where individuals become capable of abstract thinking and formal logical reasoning beyond concrete experience.
Topic-202: Interference Between First and Second Languages
When learners begin to communicate in a second language, they often assume word-for-word translation equivalence, thinking every L1 word has one translation in L2 (Blum-Kulka & Levenston). When writing or speaking in the target language, learners tend to rely on their first language structures. When L1 and L2 structures differ, many errors occur, indicating interference of the first language on the second language.
π Definition β Interference: Errors in second language use that can be traced back to the learner's first language structures.
Topic-203: Issues in First Language Acquisition Revisited
Issue one: Position meeting the criteria for a scientific theory: Chomsky's innateness position meets convincing criteria for a scientific theory. It covers aspects of other theories, possesses properties of a scientific theory, and has claims for content. Chomsky believes both body and mind exist, and theory-making requires body, behavior, and mind. His position shares aspects from other positions, such as epiphenomenalism, which views mind as a side effect of action.
Issue two: Child's logical thinking: Piaget supports the child's logical thinking attributable to the third stage of development called the "concerned operational period" (roughly ages 7 to 11 years), which Piaget labels as "preparation for an achievement of concrete operations."
Issue three: The origins of language: Chomsky's nativist position argues that the ability to acquire language is innate and children are programmed to learn language. This pre-programming explains the speed with which children learn the complex skill of using language and the similarity of language acquisition across cultures.
π Definition β Innateness position (Chomsky): The theory that humans are biologically pre-programmed with a universal grammar that enables language acquisition, explaining the speed and universality of first language learning across cultures.
Topic-204: Order of Acquisition
Order of acquisition describes the specific, fixed, universal order in which all language learners acquire the grammatical features of their first language, regardless of the specific grammatical structure of the language they learn. This phenomenon is confirmed for first-language learners, but for second-language learners the order is much less consistent. This variability may stem from first-language interference or general cognitive interference from nonlinguistic mental faculties.
Research suggests most SLA learners begin with a silent period, processing pieces of language they hear. This is considered a period of "language shock" where learners ignore incomprehensible input. However, many "silent learners" engage in private speech or "self-talk," rehearsing important survival phrases (lexical chunks). These memorized phrases are soon used in various situations. Fewer learners have no silent period and pass directly into patterned speech used for basic communication, often showing few departures from detached words strung together, leading to more fluid phrases over time. Grammar is simplified, and learners construct an understanding of the second language, often attempting "sentences" that mix words or phrases from both their first and second languages.
π Definition β Order of acquisition: The fixed, universal sequence in which all children acquire grammatical features of their first language, which differs in consistency for second-language learners.
π Definition β Silent period: An initial phase in second language acquisition where learners process language input without producing output, often engaging in private speech and rehearsing lexical chunks.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are that comparing child first language acquisition with adult second language acquisition is complex due to fundamental differences in cognitive development, neurological lateralization, and learning contexts. Hemispheric lateralization, proposed by Lenneberg to complete around puberty, may explain critical period effects, though anthropological evidence like the Tukano culture shows adults can achieve native-like proficiency under specific social conditions. Piaget's cognitive stages suggest adults benefit more from explicit grammar instruction while children learn implicitly, and first language interference significantly shapes second language errors. The order of acquisition is universal for first language but variable for second language, and many learners begin with a silent period involving private speech and memorized lexical chunks before moving to patterned and then more fluid speech.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is it considered "illogical" to directly compare child first language acquisition with adult second language acquisition?
- What did Lenneberg propose about the timing of hemispheric lateralization, and how might this relate to a critical period for language acquisition?
- What did Sorenson's study of the Tukano culture in South America reveal about adult second language acquisition?
- According to Piaget, at what stage do individuals become capable of abstraction and formal thinking, and how does Ausubel suggest this affects adult second language learning?
- What is the "silent period" in second language acquisition, and what cognitive activities may learners be engaged in during this time?