π Lecture 8 β SLA Hypotheses
π Overview: This lecture explores Stephen Krashen's five key hypotheses about Second Language Acquisition (SLA), including the Monitor, Natural Order, Input, and Affective Filter Hypotheses. It also examines Schumann's influential Acculturation Model, which views SLA through social and psychological distance factors. Understanding these theories is crucial for grasping how learners internalize a second language and the conditions that facilitate or hinder acquisition.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Krashen's Monitor Hypothesis, Natural Order Hypothesis, Input Hypothesis (with a critique), and Affective Filter Hypothesis, followed by Schumann's Acculturation Model of SLA. It explains the function of the monitor, the predictable order of rule acquisition, the role of comprehensible input, the affective factors that block or allow input, and the social and psychological distance factors that determine acculturation and success in SLA.
π Lecture Summary
Monitor Hypothesis
According to Krashen, the learning system has only one function, i.e., as a monitor or editor. It comes into play only to "make changes in the form of our utterance." Acquisition initiates the utterances and is responsible for fluency; thus, the monitor is thought to alter the output of the acquired system. This hypothesis is criticized because the monitor doesn't operate all the time, as the pressures and demands of conversing in real time often don't allow it. Moreover, it is impossible to test the claims empirically.
π Definition β Monitor: The learned system's function that edits or corrects utterances after they have been generated by the acquired system. π‘ Why this matters: This hypothesis distinguishes between subconscious acquisition (fluency) and conscious learning (editing), but its limited operation in natural speech challenges its practical role.
Natural Order Hypothesis
This hypothesis states that we acquire the language rules in a predictable order that cannot be determined solely by formal simplicity. This hypothesis is criticized for being too strong. It ignores well-documented cases of language transfer or individual variability. It is based almost exclusively on the morpheme studies, which reflect accuracy of production rather than acquisition sequences.
π Definition β Natural Order Hypothesis: The claim that grammatical structures are acquired in a predictable, universal sequence, independent of instruction or simplicity. π‘ Why this matters: It suggests teaching should follow natural acquisition sequences, but critics argue it oversimplifies complex learner variability.
Input Hypothesis
The Input Hypothesis is linked to the above-mentioned hypotheses. It claims that we move along the developmental continuum by receiving comprehensible input. Too simple or too complex input will not be useful for acquisition. It claims that speaking is a result of acquisition and not its cause. Speech cannot be taught directly; it emerges on its own as a result of building competence via comprehensible input. Further, it says that if input is understood, the necessary grammar is automatically provided. This hypothesis is criticized for being vague and imprecise. It is impossible to verify the theory as no independently testable definitions are given. Nor does the theory specify the internal workings of the "Language Acquisition Device" where acquisition actually takes place.
π Definition β Comprehensible Input: Input that is slightly beyond the learner's current level (i+1), which is necessary for acquisition to occur. π Formula: i + 1 β The learner moves from their current level (i) to the next level (i+1) by understanding input containing structures at this next stage. π Example: A learner who knows basic present tense ("I walk") hears a sentence like "Yesterday, I walked to the store." The -ed past tense marker is just beyond their current level. If understood in context, this input triggers acquisition of the past tense rule. If the input is too simple ("I walk now") or too complex ("Having walked, I had been thinking..."), no acquisition occurs.
Affective Filter Hypothesis
Just comprehensible input is not enough; learners also need to "let that input in" as it is. The Affective Filter supposedly determines how receptive to the input a learner is going to be. This filter captures the relationship between affective variables and the acquisition process. It posits that acquirers vary with respect to the strength or level of their affective filter. Learners' attitude toward second language acquisition determines their input and affective filter. Major criticism on this hypothesis claims it to be vague and a-theoretical.
π Definition β Affective Filter: An imaginary barrier that prevents learners from fully processing comprehensible input; it is raised by negative emotions like anxiety, low motivation, or low self-confidence. π‘ Why this matters: It explains why two learners receiving the same input may have different acquisition outcomes based on their emotional states.
Schumannβs Acculturation Model of SLA
Schumannβs Acculturation Model views second language acquisition from a radically different angle and remained influential during subsequent decades. Schumann noticed that early interlanguage resembled pidgin language with characteristic features. SLA was compared to the complexification of pidgins. This process was linked to the degree of acculturation of learners. The closer they feel to the target language community, the better the learner will "acculturate" and vice versa. This model was influential in opening alternative lines of research comparing SLA with pidginization and creolization, and bringing to the fore social and psychological variables along with their roles in SLL.
According to the model, success depends on the extent to which learners adapt fully to the target language culture. Two major factors are identified in acculturation: social distance and psychological distance.
π Definition β Acculturation Model: The theory that SLA success is determined by the degree to which a learner socially and psychologically integrates with the target language community.
Social Distance factors refer to those involving the relationship between the internal characteristics of a language group and the ability for the learner to become closer (socially) to that target language group. Among these factors are the social dominance of the language group, the ability for the individual to integrate into the group, the cohesiveness and size of the group, the attitude of both the group and the individual toward each other, and the length of exposure between the two.
π Definition β Social Distance: The degree of contact and integration between the learner's group and the target language group; greater social distance hinders SLA.
Psychological Distance factors refer to the extent to which individual learners cope psychologically with learning an L2. Among these factors are anxiety, motivation, and self-confidence.
π Definition β Psychological Distance: The learner's internal emotional state that affects their ability to process the L2; greater psychological distance hinders SLA. π Example: A Spanish-speaking immigrant in the U.S. who lives in a large, cohesive Spanish-speaking neighborhood (low integration, high social distance) and feels anxious about making English mistakes (high psychological distance) will likely acculturate slowly and acquire English more slowly than an immigrant who lives in an English-speaking area, feels motivated, and is confident.
β Key Takeaways
You must remember that Krashen's hypotheses form a comprehensive but heavily criticized framework: the Monitor Hypothesis explains learning's editing role, the Natural Order Hypothesis posits a fixed acquisition sequence, the Input Hypothesis demands comprehensible input (i+1), and the Affective Filter Hypothesis explains how emotions block input. The major criticism across all is that they are vague, untestable, and lack empirical rigor. Schumann's Acculturation Model offers a social-psychological alternative, arguing that SLA success depends on reducing both social distance (integration with the target group) and psychological distance (anxiety, motivation). Finally, note that Schumann linked early interlanguage to pidginization, opening a new line of research.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to the Monitor Hypothesis, what is the sole function of the "learned system"?
- What is the main criticism of the Natural Order Hypothesis regarding its evidence base?
- Explain the concept of "comprehensible input" (i+1) and why input that is too simple or too complex is not useful.
- List three affective variables that can "raise" the Affective Filter.
- In Schumannβs Acculturation Model, name two factors each that fall under "Social Distance" and "Psychological Distance."
π Lecture 9 β Second Language and Universal Grammar
π Overview: This lecture examines the evolution of Second Language Acquisition (SLA) research in the 1980s and beyond, with a particular focus on the Universal Grammar (UG) approach developed by Noam Chomsky. It explains how UG provides both a descriptive framework for understanding what constitutes knowledge of language and a transition theory for explaining how that knowledge is acquired by second language learners.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers SLA research from the 1980s onward, including the role of internal mechanisms such as language-specific and cognitive issues, the continuing influence of the first language, and fundamental questions about language knowledge, acquisition, and use. It introduces the Universal Grammar approach as both a property theoryβcharacterizing underlying linguistic knowledgeβand a transition theoryβdescribing the process of language learning. Key aims of linguistic research are also discussed, including descriptive and explanatory adequacy.
π Lecture Summary
SLA 1980s and Beyond; SLA: The Role of Internal Mechanisms; SLA 1980s: The Role of First Language
By the mid-1980s, Second Language Learning (SLL) had matured into an autonomous field of inquiry. It encompassed substantial research programs with distinctive theoretical orientations and methodologies. New links emerged with cognitive science, neuro-psychology, and socio-cultural frameworks, greatly enriching the perception of SLA. However, the SLL research agenda continued to focus on fundamental issues carried forward from the 1970s.
These fundamental issues include:
- The role of internal mechanisms (like language-specific issues and cognitive issues)
- The role of the first language
- The role of psychological variables affecting learning (motivation, personality, language aptitude)
- The role of social and environmental factors
- The role of input
Linguistics and Language Learning: Universal Grammar Approach
The Universal Grammar (UG) approach was developed by Noam Chomsky. It posits that language is a result of the interplay of two factors: the initial state (the "language acquisition device") and the course of experience (input). The aim of UG is twofold: descriptive adequacy and explanatory adequacy.
UG is a property theory that attempts to characterize the underlying linguistic knowledge in second language learners' minds. The main goals of SLA are to answer three basic questions about human language:
- What constitutes knowledge of language?
- How is knowledge of language acquired?
- How is knowledge of language put to use?
Aims of Linguistic Research
Linguistic theory aims to:
- Describe the mental representations of language that are stored in the human mind.
- Define what all languages have in common as well as their distinctive characteristics.
The UG approach in SLL provides a detailed descriptive framework that enables the formulation of well-defined hypotheses about the task facing the learner. It also allows researchers to analyze the learners' language in a more focused manner.
Universal Grammar: Knowledge of Language and Universal Grammar as a 'Transition Theory'
A transition theory describes the process of language learning. UG is also a transition theory because it is interested in describing the language transition process or learning process that occurs during the learning of the second language.
In that sense, UG answers the two main questions that Chomsky said learners must know or that language theory must answer:
- It describes the knowledge of the language (as a property theory).
- It moves on to explain how that knowledge is acquired by the learners (as a transition theory).
π Definition β Universal Grammar (UG): A linguistic theory developed by Noam Chomsky that posits humans are born with an innate set of grammatical principles common to all languages. It attempts to characterize the underlying linguistic knowledge in learners' minds. π Definition β Property Theory: A theory that characterizes or describes the nature of linguistic knowledge or competence in the mind of the learner. π Definition β Transition Theory: A theory that describes the process by which language knowledge is acquired or learned over time. π Formula: Language = Initial State (innate language acquisition device) + Course of Experience (input) β This means language ability results from the interaction between our biological language faculty and the language we are exposed to. π‘ Why this matters: Understanding UG helps explain why second language learners make specific types of errors and why some aspects of language are easier or harder to learn than others.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that SLA research in the 1980s moved beyond earlier questions to integrate internal mechanisms, cognitive science, and socio-cultural frameworks while keeping core issues like first language role and input. The Universal Grammar approach is fundamentally concerned with two types of adequacy: descriptive (what we know) and explanatory (how we know it). UG functions as both a property theory that characterizes the mental representation of language and a transition theory that explains the learning process. The three essential questions UG seeks to answer for SLA are: what constitutes knowledge of language, how it is acquired, and how it is put to use. Finally, linguistic research aims to discover what all languages share in common and what makes each language unique.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three basic questions about human language that SLA research aims to answer according to the UG approach?
- What is the difference between a property theory and a transition theory in the context of Universal Grammar?
- Name the two factors that, according to Chomsky, interact to produce language.
- What are the two main aims of linguistic research as described in this lecture?
- What were the five fundamental issues carried forward from the 1970s that remained central to the SLA research agenda in the 1980s?
π Lecture 10 β Universal Grammar and First Language Acquisition
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between Universal Grammar (UG) and first language acquisition, examining how children acquire language despite limited input. It considers theoretical scenarios for second language acquisition, arguments from first language development supporting UG, and evidence opposing the universal grammar approach. The lecture emphasizes that language acquisition is rule-governed, systematic, and appears largely separate from general cognition.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers how children create mental representations of language beyond the input they receive, theoretical scenarios for whether second language grammars are constrained by UG or not, how language knowledge (competence) is accessed and used, arguments from first language acquisition including developmental stages and rule-governed behavior, and opposing evidence such as cognitive deficits with normal language development and specific language impairment.
π Lecture Summary
UG: Acquisition of Language
Children create mental representation of language based on messy input that goes beyond the input they are exposed to. This mental representation is very similar to that of other native speakers of the same language variety. Language is described as the most abstract piece of knowledge. Second language learners, by contrast, are cognitively mature and presumably much more resourceful in problem solving and dealing with abstract concepts.
UG: Acquisition of Language: Theoretical Scenarios
From a theoretical point of view, different possible scenarios are open to consideration. Two main possibilities exist: either second language grammars are constrained by universal grammar (UG) or UG does not constrain second language grammar (UG is impaired).
How is Language Put to Use?
The UG approach is concerned with knowledge of language called "competence." It is not about performance β how language is used in real life. A complete theory of language must also define how we access our knowledge base and how it relates to sociolinguistic and psychological variables. Chomsky acknowledges this and has been concerned almost exclusively with addressing the first two issues.
Arguments from First Language Acquisition
The notion of an innate language faculty in children argues that children go through developmental stages which are very similar across children of a given language, though progress rate varies. These stages are similar across languages. Child language is said to be rule-governed and systematic; children are resistant to correction and have limited processing capacity.
π Definition β Developmental stages: predictable, sequential phases all children pass through during language acquisition, with similar patterns across languages and children, though individual rates vary.
UG and First Language Acquisition
Universalists do not conclude that there must be a specific language module in the brain. Language does not seem to be linked in any clear way to intelligence. Children vary in the age at which they go through these developmental steps and in how fast they go through each stage. Many children with cognitive deficit develop language normally. There are numerous examples of people with cognitive disabilities or difficulties who performed well in language(s).
π‘ Why this matters: This separation between language and general cognition is a foundational argument for Universal Grammar β if language were simply part of general intelligence, cognitive deficits would always impair language, but this is not observed.
Opposing Evidence
Evidence of the opposite is also found. There are many cognitively "normal" children with impaired language condition known as "specific language impairment." A study suggests that some aspects of language at least might be genetically controlled. Damage to the left hemisphere of the brain also results in language deficit. Language and cognition seem to be largely separate but they do interact.
π Definition β Specific language impairment (SLI): a language disorder in children who have normal cognitive abilities and no other developmental disabilities, suggesting language can be selectively impaired.
π Example: Children with cognitive disabilities or difficulties who performed well in language(s) provide evidence for the separateness of language and cognition. Conversely, cognitively "normal" children with specific language impairment provide opposing evidence, showing that language ability can be impaired even when general intelligence is intact.
β Key Takeaways
The critical points from this lecture are: First, children create mental representations of language that go beyond the messy input they receive, supporting the idea of an innate language faculty. Second, theoretical scenarios for second language acquisition include both UG-constrained and UG-unconstrained possibilities. Third, UG is concerned with competence (knowledge of language) not performance (real-life use). Fourth, language acquisition is rule-governed and systematic across children and languages, though rate varies individually. Finally, language and cognition appear largely separate but interact, as evidenced by both cognitively impaired individuals with normal language and cognitively normal individuals with specific language impairment.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does the UG approach focus on β competence or performance?
- What are the two theoretical scenarios for whether UG constrains second language grammar?
- What evidence suggests that language and cognition are largely separate?
- What is "specific language impairment" and why is it considered opposing evidence to universal grammar claims?
- Why do universalists argue that children must have an innate language faculty despite limited and messy input?
π Lecture 11 β Universal Grammar and Second Language Learning
π Overview: This lecture explores the role of Universal Grammar (UG) in second language learning, building on the concept of an innate language faculty. It examines the arguments for UG, its principles, cross-linguistic variation, and several hypotheses about whether second language learners have access to UG. The lecture also evaluates the scope and achievements of UG theory in the context of SLA.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers arguments for Universal Grammar based on Lenneberg's biologically triggered behaviors, the principles of UG including structure-dependency and functional categories, sources of cross-linguistic variation in UG, the relationship between UG and second language learning, different hypotheses regarding access to UG in SLA, and an evaluation of UG's scope and achievements.
π Lecture Summary
Arguments of (Universal Grammar) UG
The evidence indicates that there must be an innate language faculty that is biologically triggered. Lenneberg (1967) outlined characteristics typical of biologically triggered behaviors and argued that language conforms to these criteria. Aitchison presents Lenneberg's criteria as six features:
- The behaviour emerges before it is necessary β children start talking before they need it for survival.
- Its appearance is not a result of a conscious decision.
- Its emergence is not triggered by external events.
- Direct teaching and intensive practice have relatively little effect.
- There is a regular sequence of 'milestones' as the behaviour develops, correlated with age and other aspects of development.
- There may be a 'critical period' for acquisition β humans must be exposed to language before puberty for language to develop.
Principles of UG
The first language learner's initial state is supposed to consist of a set of principles; languages vary only in limited ways, meaning language learning is highly constrained in advance. UG includes the principle of structure-dependency, which states that language critically depends on the structural relationship between elements in a sentence. All languages consist of sentences containing at least a Noun-Phrase and a Verb-Phrase.
π Definition β Structure-dependency: A principle of UG stating that language operations depend on the structural relationships between elements in a sentence, not on linear order.
UG: Cross-linguistic Variation
UG includes a universal inventory of categories that the child selects from based on input. According to White, there are three potential sources of cross-linguistic variation relating to functional categories:
- Languages can differ in which functional categories are realized in the grammar (e.g., Japanese lacks the category Determiner).
- The features of a particular functional category can vary from language to language (e.g., French has a gender feature while English does not).
- Features vary in strength: a feature can be strong in one language and weak in another, with syntactic consequences (e.g., Inflection features are strong in French and weak in English, resulting in word-order alterations).
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding cross-linguistic variation helps explain why second language learners from different L1 backgrounds face different challenges when learning the same L2.
UG and Second Language Learning
Universal Grammar is a theory of natural languages that includes second language as well. First and second language learning are similar in many ways. In L1 acquisition, the explanation that generated most enthusiasm was about a kind of language blueprint in the brain. Second language learners go through fairly rigid stages which are unlike both their L1 and the L2 they are exposed to. The situation is complicated by several factors:
- SL learners are cognitively mature.
- They already know at least one other language.
- They have different motivations for learning a second language.
These points have important implications for the role of UG in SLL.
UG and SLL β Different Hypothesis
Even if the UG hypothesis is correct for first language learning, there are logical possibilities concerning its role in SLL:
- Second languages are not constrained by UG principles and parameters and do not behave like natural languages.
- They are UG constrained. There are different hypotheses about whether the SL learner has full access or partial access to UG.
Learners might not be able to reset parameters; therefore, they operate with first language settings for some parts of the new language.
π Definition β Parameter resetting: The process by which a learner adjusts the settings of UG parameters from their L1 value to the L2 value.
Evaluation of UG: Scope
Scope and Achievements of Universal Grammar (UG):
- UG theory aims to describe and explain human language.
- It is nonetheless directly relevant to the study of SL.
- It is a linguistic theory, not a learning theory.
- It has been hugely influential in drawing up sophisticated hypotheses regarding SLA.
- It helps explore the interplay between first and second language learners and facilitates understanding of the linguistic knowledge learners bring to SLA.
- It is primarily concerned with the description and explanation of the formal system underlying language.
- Its scope does not include a theory of processing or learning.
- UG is more of a property theory and not a transition theory β it must be evaluated as such.
π Definition β Property theory: A theory that describes and explains the nature of linguistic knowledge (what is known).
Transition theory: A theory that explains how learners acquire that knowledge over time (how learning happens).
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that UG is a theory of innate, biologically triggered language faculty supported by Lenneberg's six criteria for biologically based behaviors. The principle of structure-dependency and the existence of functional categories are central to UG, and cross-linguistic variation arises from differences in which categories are realized, their features, and feature strength. For SLA, the key debate involves whether second language learners have full, partial, or no access to UG, particularly regarding parameter resetting from L1 to L2 settings. Finally, UG is a property theory (describing linguistic knowledge) not a transition theory (explaining learning processes), which limits but does not diminish its scope and influence in SLA research.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six features Lenneberg identified for biologically triggered behaviors, and how do they apply to language acquisition?
- Explain the principle of structure-dependency and why it is considered a universal property of language.
- According to White, what are the three potential sources of cross-linguistic variation relating to functional categories? Provide an example for each.
- What are the two main logical possibilities regarding whether UG constrains second language learning, and what does "parameter resetting" mean in this context?
- Why is UG described as a "property theory" rather than a "transition theory," and what are the implications of this distinction for SLA research?
π Lecture 12 β Evaluations of Universal Grammar and Cognitive Approaches
π Overview: This lecture critically evaluates the Universal Grammar (UG) approach to second language acquisition, examining its view of language, language acquisition, and the language learner. It then introduces Cognitive Approaches to SLL, contrasting them with UG and outlining two main sub-approaches: Processing Theorists and Emergentist/Constructionist perspectives.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by evaluating the Universal Grammar (UG) approach across three dimensions: its view of language, its view of language acquisition, and its view of the language learner. It then introduces Cognitive Approaches to second language learning, explaining their focus on learning processes and the learner as an individual. Finally, the lecture distinguishes between two main cognitive approaches: Processing Theorists, who develop transition theories, and Emergentist/Constructionist approaches, which reject the separation of property and transition theories and explain language through general cognition principles.
π Lecture Summary
Evaluation of Universal Grammar (UG): View of Language
The UG view of language has been very influential since the 1950s but remains controversial. UG approaches language as a mental framework underlying all human languages, focusing on the sentence and its internal structure rather than larger units of language. It studies languages clinically and βin a vacuumβ as a mental object, not a social or psychological one. UG rigidly separates language knowledge from language use. Its methodologies are criticized for not representing reality, as it is preoccupied with modeling linguistic competence and not concerned with naturalistic performance.
π Definition β Universal Grammar (UG): A mental framework underlying all human languages, studied as a mental object separate from social or psychological contexts. π Formula: UG = mental framework β clinical study of sentence structure β focus on competence, not performance π Example: UG theorists study the internal structure of sentences (e.g., syntactic rules) but ignore how learners use language in real-world conversation; they rely on native speaker judgments, which have been criticized for lack of reliability.
π‘ Why this matters: UGβs narrow focus on competence allows for well-defined hypotheses but ignores social and psychological variables central to understanding SLA.
Evaluation of UG: View of Language Acquisition
UG theorists are exclusively concerned with documenting and explaining the nature of the second language (SL) linguistic system. They ignore social and psychological variables in acquisition. Recent UG work has addressed criticisms of unreliability in SL judgments by using a range of elicitation techniques. However, UG has left many central areas of SLA untouched. Despite these limitations, UG has been very useful for linguistic analysis, facilitating well-defined and focused hypotheses that help establish and explain facts about SLA.
π Definition β Elicitation techniques: Methods used to collect language data from learners, addressing earlier criticisms of unreliable native speaker judgments. π Formula: UG research = focus on linguistic system + elicitation techniques β well-defined hypotheses about SLA facts π Example: To study how learners acquire English question formation, a UG researcher might ask learners to judge grammaticality of sentences, rather than observing natural conversation.
Evaluation of UG: View of Language Learner
The UG approach views the learner solely as a processor of a mind that contains language. Variations among individuals are of little concern. The primary emphasis is on language as the object of study and on what is universal within the mind. UG makes clear and explicit statements about the ground it aims to cover and the claims it makes. It has systematic procedures for theory evaluation and both explains and describes at least some language phenomena. UG increasingly engages with other theories in the field.
π Definition β Theory evaluation: Systematic procedures used by UG researchers to test and refine their claims about universal linguistic properties. π Formula: UG view of learner = mind containing language β focus on universals β systematic theory evaluation π Example: A UG researcher studying Japanese learners of English would focus on universal syntactic constraints (e.g., subjacency) rather than individual differences in motivation or learning style.
Cognitive Approaches to SLL: Introduction
Cognitive Approaches to second language learning place more emphasis on the learning component of SLL and focus on transition theoriesβhow learners move from one stage of knowledge to another. The focus is on the learner as an individual. Cognitive theorists are interested in how the human brain processes and learns new information. While UG theorists were interested primarily in competence and not in how learners access linguistic knowledge in real time, these are central issues for cognitive theorists (i.e., what strategies are employed when an incomplete linguistic system lets the learner down?).
π Definition β Transition theories: Theories concerned with how learners progress from one stage of linguistic knowledge to another over time. π Formula: Cognitive approach = focus on learning component + transition theories β how brain processes new information in real time π Example: A cognitive researcher might study how a beginner Spanish learner uses memory strategies to recall vocabulary during a conversation, rather than just analyzing the structure of their sentences.
Cognitive Approaches: Variations
There are two main approaches within Cognitive theories of SLA:
-
Processing Theorists: These researchers believe language knowledge might be βspecialβ in some way, but they focus on developing transition or processing theories to complement property theories (which describe the nature of knowledge). Processing approaches investigate how the second language learner processes linguistic information and how this ability develops over time.
-
Emergentist/Constructionist: These theorists do not consider the separation between property and transition theories as legitimate. They believe that both the nature of knowledge and how it is processed can be explained through general cognition principles. Constructivists believe that the complexity of language emerges from associative learning processes when exposed to a complex environment. Many claim that language develops as learners move from learning exemplars (memorized chunks) to making more abstract generalizations as their database of related utterances grows.
π Definition β Processing Theorists: Cognitive researchers who develop theories about how learners process linguistic information in real time, complementing property theories. π Definition β Emergentist/Constructionist: Theorists who reject the distinction between property and transition theories, arguing that both emerge from general cognition through associative learning.
π Formula:
Processing Theorists = special language knowledge + transition theories β real-time processing
Emergentists = no separation between property/transition + general cognition β learning via exemplars β abstraction
π Example: A Processing Theorist might study how a learner processes English past tense β-edβ rules during speech. An Emergentist would argue that the learner first memorizes many past tense forms (e.g., βwalked,β βplayedβ) and only later induces the β-edβ rule from these exemplars.
β Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must remember that the UG approach views language as a mental framework focused on competence at the sentence level, separating knowledge from use, and ignoring social/psychological variablesβthough it is valuable for generating well-defined hypotheses. Cognitive approaches shift focus to the learner as an individual and to transition theories about how the brain processes new information. Within cognitive approaches, Processing Theorists maintain a distinction between property and transition theories, while Emergentists reject this separation, arguing language emerges from associative learning of exemplars. You should be able to state the criticisms of UG (clinical study, lack of reliability in judgments, ignoring performance) and its strengths (systematic theory evaluation, clear claims). Finally, know the key difference: UG studies what is universal in the mind, while cognitive approaches study how individual learners process and learn language.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main criticisms of the Universal Grammar approachβs view of language?
- How do Processing Theorists differ from Emergentist/Constructionist theorists in their view of the relationship between property and transition theories?
- According to the lecture, what is the primary focus of the UG approach: language competence or language performance?
- What does the Emergentist/Constructionist approach mean when it says language βemerges from associative learning processesβ?
- Why has UG been described as βvery useful for linguistic analysisβ despite its limitations in explaining SLA?
π Lecture 13 β Models of Second Language Learning
π Overview: This lecture explores processing approaches to second language acquisition, focusing on how the brain's cognitive mechanisms handle second language information. It examines two major information processing modelsβMcLaughlin's model and Anderson's ACT* modelβwhich explain how learners move from controlled to automatic processing through practice and restructuring. Understanding these models is crucial for comprehending why some aspects of language become fossilized and how skill acquisition progresses.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers processing approaches in second language learning, including information processing approach and processability theory. It then delves into two specific information processing models: McLaughlin's Information Processing Model (1987, 1990) and Anderson's Active Control of Thought (ACT*) Model (1983, 1985). Key concepts discussed include automatization, controlled versus automatic processing, restructuring, fossilization, declarative and procedural knowledge, and the three stages of skill acquisition in Anderson's model.
π Lecture Summary
Processing Approaches; Information Processing Models of Second Language Learning
Processing approaches examine how the brain's processing mechanism deals with second language learning. These include: 1) the information processing approach, which investigates how different memory stores (short-term memory, long-term memory) handle second language information and how this information becomes automatized and restructured; and 2) processability theory, which looks more specifically at processing demands made by various formal aspects of second language, and implications for learnability and teachability of second language structure. Two information processing models are discussed in this lecture: McLaughlin's model and Anderson's ACT* model.
π‘ Why this matters: These models provide a cognitive framework for understanding why language learning requires practice and why some errors persist despite extensive exposure.
McLaughlinβs Model
In McLaughlin's model, humans are viewed as autonomous and active. The mind is a general-purpose, symbol processing system. Complex behaviour is composed of simpler modular processes; processes take time so predictions about reaction time can be made. The mind is viewed as a limited-capacity processor.
Within this framework, second language learning is viewed as acquisition of a complex cognitive skill. To learn a second language is to learn a skill because various aspects of the task must be practiced and integrated into fluent performance. This requires automatization of component sub-skills. Automatization means that learning involves a shift from controlled toward automatic processing via practice. It results in constant restructuring of the linguistic system of the second language learner. When a second language learner seems unable to get rid of non-native-like structure despite abundant linguistic input over many years, it is called fossilization. In this model, fossilization would arise as a result of a controlled process becoming automatic prematurely.
π Definition β Automatization: Learning involves a shift from controlled toward automatic processing via practice, resulting in constant restructuring of the linguistic system. π Definition β Fossilization: When a second language learner seems unable to get rid of non-native-like structure despite abundant linguistic input over many years; arises when a controlled process becomes automatic prematurely.
Processing Approaches: Andersonβs Model
Anderson's Active Control of Thought (ACT) model* is more wide-ranging, and the terminology is different but practice leading to automatization also plays a central role. It enables declarative knowledge. Anderson posits three kinds of memory: a working memory, a declarative long-term memory, and a procedural long-term memory. This model has been criticized for insisting that all knowledge starts out in declarative form, which is clearly problematic in the case of first language learners, as Anderson has accepted in answering to the criticism. Anderson's model is a general cognitive model of skill acquisition. It can be applied to those aspects of second language learning that require proceduralization and automatization.
π Definition β Declarative knowledge: Knowledge that starts out in declarative form; knowledge about facts and things. π Definition β Proceduralization: The process of converting declarative knowledge into procedural knowledge, enabling skilled performance.
Andersonβs Model: Three Stages
According to Anderson, the move from declarative to procedural knowledge takes place in three stages:
- The cognitive stage: a description of the procedure is learnt.
- The associative stage: a method for performing the skill is worked out.
- The autonomous stage: the skill becomes more and more rapid and automatic.
π Example of the Three Stages in Language Learning: In the cognitive stage, a learner learns the grammatical rule for forming past tense verbs (e.g., "add -ed to the base form"). In the associative stage, the learner practices applying this rule, working out methods to remember exceptions (e.g., "go" becomes "went," not "goed"). In the autonomous stage, the learner can fluently and automatically use past tense forms without consciously thinking about the rule.
π‘ Why this matters: These three stages explain why language learning initially requires conscious effort and attention, but eventually becomes automatic and effortless with sufficient practice.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture presents two major cognitive models explaining how second language learning occurs through processing mechanisms. McLaughlin's model emphasizes the shift from controlled to automatic processing through practice, where fossilization occurs when controlled processes become automatic prematurely. Anderson's ACT* model describes the progression from declarative to procedural knowledge through three stages: cognitive, associative, and autonomous. Both models highlight the central role of practice and automatization in skill acquisition. The key distinction is that Anderson insists all knowledge starts in declarative form, a claim criticized for first language acquisition. Understanding these models helps explain why language learning requires time, practice, and why some errors persist despite extensive exposure.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between controlled processing and automatic processing in McLaughlin's model?
- How does fossilization occur according to McLaughlin's information processing model?
- What are the three kinds of memory posited in Anderson's ACT* model?
- Name and briefly describe the three stages of skill acquisition in Anderson's model.
- What criticism has been leveled against Anderson's ACT* model regarding the nature of knowledge?