📘 Lecture 1 — Introduction to Second Language Acquisition
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the field of Second Language Acquisition (SLA), defining it as a research field focused on learners and learning rather than teachers and teaching. It establishes key concepts, explores what constitutes a good theory, and examines different views on the nature of language, setting the foundation for understanding how learners internalize and use a new linguistic system.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the introduction to SLA and its fundamental questions about how learners internalize and use a second language. It then discusses key concepts, including the difference between first and second language acquisition. The need for good theories is explored, along with the types of theories—specifically property theory and transition theory—and how to evaluate them. Finally, the lecture examines different views on the nature of language, describing it as learned, systematic, a skill, for communication, rule-governed, and unique.
📝 Lecture Summary
Introduction to SLA; Key Concepts
Second language acquisition (SLA) is a research field that focuses on learners and learning rather than teachers and teaching. The field addresses fundamental questions of how learners come to internalize the linguistic system of another language and how they use that system during comprehension and speech production. The term "second language" includes languages other than the native language, languages of wider communication encountered within a local region or community, and foreign languages. Learning can either be formal, planned, and systematic or informal and unstructured.
Key Concept: The learning and acquisition of a second language occurs once first language acquisition is established. For example, a child who speaks Hindi as a first language starts learning English when they begin school. In fact, a young child can learn a second language faster than an adult can learn the same language.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding that language development is heavily determined by the nature of the environment is crucial. A stimulating environment is required to enable natural curiosity, intelligence, and creativity to develop, and to enable our biological capacities to unfold.
What Makes a Good Theory: The Need; What Makes a Good Theory: Types of Theories
In the sciences and social sciences, a theory is a more or less abstract set of claims about the significant units within a phenomenon under study. It aims at explanation as well as description. Theories are produced collaboratively and evolve through systematic enquiry, assessed through hypothesis testing and involving a reflexive process. A good theory is supposed to give clear and explicit statements about its claims and must be testable or falsifiable in some way.
Two main types of theories are discussed:
- Property Theory: Concerned with the structure of the language and how a language changes; how certain words become obsolete; how certain factors lead to the addition of new words and merge them in a language system. In property theory, the language system is important.
- Transition Theory: More concerned with the developmental processes of language education. It is interested in finding out the different stages of learning in a second language learner. It can relate to first language acquisition, telling about the different learning stages in a child's life and how that learning is different or similar to second language learning.
🔑 Definition — Property Theory: A type of theory concerned with the structure of language and how it changes over time, focusing on the language system itself. 🔑 Definition — Transition Theory: A type of theory concerned with the developmental processes and different stages of learning in a language learner.
Evaluating a Theory of SLA
Theories are also distinguished from frameworks and models. These latter constructs refer to compilations of ideas and constructs that are bigger than theories. They may subsume some theories, but their intent is less to explain and predict and are generally more descriptive in nature. They can describe what happens in some detail and in some cases make relationships between different things, but they may not be able to explain why something happens the way it does.
Views on the Nature of Language
Language is the most important phenomenon in the world, dominating every aspect of human life and serving as a yardstick to separate us from other beings. Several views on the nature of language are presented:
- Language is learnt: Learning of language is not an automatic process. It is behaviour but not of the type like walking and crawling that comes to a child in a natural way.
- Language is a system: Each language is a unique system consisting of sounds, structures, and vocabulary. A person learning a new language must learn new sounds, new structures, and new vocabulary. The sound system differs from language to language depending upon the culture.
- Language is a skill: Learning a language is a skill subject, like swimming and cycling. It cannot be learned just by studying rules; it requires rigorous practice, with a lot of repetition for major linguistic skills like listening, speaking, reading, and writing.
- Language is for communication: Language is the best means of communication and self-expression. Human beings express their ideas, thoughts, feelings, and emotions through language, connecting past, present, and future.
- Language is rule governed: Each language is governed by a particular set of rules. For example, English is an S.V.O. language, meaning in forming a sentence, we put subject, then verb, and after verb there comes object.
- Language is unique: Each language has its own style of functioning, with its own specialty in sounds, vocabulary, and structures.
🔑 Definition — Nature of Language: The fundamental characteristics of language, including that it is learned, systematic, a skill, for communication, rule-governed, and unique.
⭐ Key Takeaways
SLA is a research field centered on how learners internalize and use a second language, requiring a stimulating environment for development. A good theory in SLA must be testable, falsifiable, and provide clear explanations, with two key types being property theory (focusing on language structure) and transition theory (focusing on developmental stages). Language is a complex phenomenon that is learned, systematic, a skill, rule-governed, for communication, and unique to each culture. Theories must be distinguished from frameworks and models, which are more descriptive and less explanatory. Understanding the nature of language is fundamental to studying how second languages are acquired and taught.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary focus of Second Language Acquisition (SLA) as a research field?
- What are the two main types of theories discussed in this lecture, and what does each type focus on?
- What are the essential characteristics a good theory must possess according to the lecture?
- List at least four different views on the nature of language presented in this lecture.
- Why is a stimulating environment considered important for language development?
📘 Lecture 02 — Nature of Language, Modularity and Language Variability
📖 Overview: This lecture explores foundational debates in second language acquisition, including the distinction between competence and performance, the nature vs. nurture controversy, and modularity of mind. It introduces key concepts like Universal Grammar and interlanguage variability, which are essential for understanding how learners build their language systems.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers views on the nature of language including competence and performance, the language learning process through the nature vs. nurture debate, modularity in language learning and its application to SLA, and the concepts of system and variability in learner interlanguage. Key figures discussed include Chomsky, Skinner, and Piaget.
📝 Lecture Summary
Views on the Nature of Language: Competence and Performance
Linguists disagree over their main focus of study. Noam Chomsky prefers competence over performance. By competence, he refers to the abstract and hidden representation of language knowledge held inside minds with its potential to create and understand original utterances in a given language. However, there are difficulties in studying competence as language performance data are believed to be imperfect reflections of competence. The competence can only be assessed indirectly, under controlled conditions, through wide-ranging tests.
🔑 Definition — Competence: The abstract, hidden representation of language knowledge held inside the mind, with the potential to create and understand original utterances in a given language. 🔑 Definition — Performance: The observable use of language in real situations, which is considered an imperfect reflection of underlying competence. 💡 Why this matters: This distinction is crucial because researchers must design careful tests to infer what learners actually know (competence) from what they produce (performance).
The Language Learning Process: Nature vs. Nurture
The best-known controversy involves B. F. Skinner and Noam Chomsky. Skinner advocates behaviorist mechanisms; whereas, Chomsky emphasized the role of innate dispositions that expect natural languages to be organized in particular ways and support the role of Universal Grammar (UG).
🔑 Definition — Behaviorism (Skinner): The view that language is learned through environmental exposure, imitation, reinforcement, and habit formation. 🔑 Definition — Universal Grammar (UG) (Chomsky): The theory that humans are born with an innate, specialized biological capacity for language that constrains how languages are organized.
When we talk about errors in second language utterances, Behaviorists view errors as a result of "bad habits" which can be controlled through rote learning and pattern drilling using target language models. Recent studies contradict this view by claiming that errors and mistakes are patterned, although some of them are caused by first language influence, yet this is not true for all of them.
The Language Learning Process: Modularity
There are different views on seeing the mind as modular or unitary. In Piaget's view, language is simply one manifestation of the general skill of symbolic representation, and first language acquisition does not require any special mechanism. In contrast, Chomsky considers language as too complex to be learnt from environmental exposure and too distinctive in its structure to be learnable by general cognitive means. Universal Grammar is thus endowed with its own distinctive mechanism for learning.
🔑 Definition — Modularity of Mind: The view that the mind consists of specialized, independent modules or components, each dedicated to specific functions (e.g., language). 🔑 Definition — Unitary View of Mind (Piaget): The perspective that language is not a separate faculty but emerges from general cognitive abilities like symbolic thinking. 💡 Why this matters: Whether language has its own dedicated module or emerges from general cognition affects how SLA researchers explain why second language learning differs from first language learning.
Modularity and SLA
The modularity debate extends into SLA research. If language is modular and governed by Universal Grammar, then second language learners may still access this innate faculty, at least partially. If language is not modular, then SLA relies on the same general learning mechanisms used for any complex skill.
System and Variability in SLA
The learner's language system is unstable and characterized by a high degree of variability, which is a central feature of learner interlanguage. Recent studies claim that errors and mistakes are patterned, although some of them are caused by first language influence, yet this is not true for all of them.
🔑 Definition — Interlanguage: The systematic but evolving linguistic system that a second language learner constructs at any given point in their learning journey. 🔑 Definition — Variability: The characteristic of interlanguage where a learner's use of language features is inconsistent and changes over time or across different contexts.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember the fundamental distinction between competence (abstract knowledge) and performance (actual use), and the major debate between nature (Chomsky's Universal Grammar) and nurture (Skinner's behaviorism). The modularity debate contrasts Chomsky's view of language as a specialized mental module with Piaget's view of language as part of general cognition. Crucially, learner language is not random error but a systematic, though variable, interlanguage system where patterns emerge even in errors. Understanding this variability is essential for analyzing and interpreting second language learner data.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between competence and performance in Chomsky's view?
- How do behaviorists explain errors in second language utterances, and how does the lecture critique this view?
- What is the core disagreement between Piaget and Chomsky regarding the nature of language learning?
- Define Universal Grammar and explain its role in Chomsky's theory of language acquisition.
- Why is variability considered a central feature of learner interlanguage?
📘 Lecture 3 — Creativity And Second Language Learning
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the interplay between creativity and routine in second language acquisition, examining how learners use both novel constructions and prefabricated chunks. It addresses the phenomenon of fossilization, where learning appears to freeze at a deviant stage, and investigates cross-linguistic influences like language transfer. The lecture also contrasts behaviorist and contemporary theoretical views on the role of language use and performance in developing second language competence.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining creativity in cognitive terms and its relation to language learning processes. It then examines the roles of formulas and routines in both first and second language use. A major focus is on limited learning and fossilization, including psycholinguistic and sociolinguistic interpretations. Cross-linguistic influences such as language transfer are discussed, followed by an analysis of second language use and performance from behaviorist and information-processing perspectives. The lecture concludes with references to other theorists.
📝 Lecture Summary
Creativity And Routines In SLA
Creativity is a complex notion, especially in cognitive terms. For language learning, creativity is not about the product but about the process of learning—understanding how the target language works through creative thinking. Learners’ surface utterances can be linked to an underlying rule system, even if these appear primitive and deviant compared to the target language system. Formulas and routines play an important part in everyday language use by native speakers. First-language utterances are a complex mix of creativity and prefabrication. A frequent use of unanalyzed chunks is also evident in young children’s first language as well as in the early stages of second language acquisition.
💡 Why this matters: This shows that even "incorrect" learner language follows systematic rules, and that routine expressions are a normal part of language development, not a failure to be creative.
Limited Learning: Fossilization
Second Language (SL) learners mostly remain noticeably different from native speakers in their pronunciation, and many continue to make grammar mistakes even when well-motivated or after years of study. This is typified by incomplete success. Fossilization refers to the situation when a learner’s SL system seems to “freeze” or become stuck at some more or less deviant stage. These two phenomena are significant facts about the SLL process.
🔑 Definition — Fossilization: A phenomenon in second language acquisition where a learner's interlanguage ceases to develop, remaining permanently at a stage that deviates from the target language norms.
Psycholinguistic and Sociolinguistic views interpret these phenomena differently. The former claims that language-specific learning mechanisms simply cease to work for older learners, and no amount of study can recreate them. The latter group argues that older SL learners do not have the social opportunities or motivation to identify with the native community; they may instead value their distinctive identity as learners or as members of an identifiable minority group.
Cross-Linguistic Influences
Learners’ performance in SL is influenced by the language or languages they already know. This is obvious in their accent as well as in certain characteristic mistakes. This phenomenon is called language transfer. Behaviorists view it as an important source of error and interference in SLL. However, recent theorists hold widely differing views on the extent and nature of these influences.
🔑 Definition — Language Transfer: The influence of a learner's first language (or any previously learned language) on the acquisition and use of a second language, affecting pronunciation, grammar, and vocabulary.
Second Language Use and SLL
Performing in a language involves speaking, making sense of data we hear, interpreting, and processing incoming language data. Language input is essential for normal language learning. The behaviorist theory saw regular (oral) practice as helpful in forming correct language “habits.” In contrast, contemporary theorists put emphasis on the “practice” function. For instance, information-processing theorists argued that language competence consists of both a knowledge component and a skill component. They see a vital role of SL use or SL performance in developing the skill component.
📌 Example: A learner may know (knowledge component) the grammar rule for the past tense (-ed) but still need extensive practice in speaking and listening (skill component) to produce it accurately and fluently in real-time conversation.
Second Language Use and SLL: Other Theorists
The lecture notes that the topic of SL use and its role in learning is further explored by other theorists beyond those already mentioned, though specific names and details are not provided in this lecture text. The implication is that the debate between the role of input, practice, and innate mechanisms continues across different schools of thought.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that second language learning involves a dynamic mix of creative rule-formation and the use of memorized routines or chunks. Fossilization is a key concept representing the permanent cessation of learning before reaching native-like proficiency, with both psychological and social explanations. The learner's first language inevitably influences SL acquisition through language transfer, which can be a source of both errors and facilitation. Finally, linguistic competence involves both knowledge (knowing the rules) and skill (using them fluently), with active language use being essential for developing the skill component according to information-processing theories.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- In the context of SLA, what is the distinction between "creativity" as a learning process and the use of "unanalyzed chunks"?
- According to the psycholinguistic view, what causes fossilization in older second language learners?
- How does a sociolinguistic perspective differ from a psycholinguistic one in explaining the incomplete success of SL learners?
- What is the behavioral view of language transfer, and what term do they use for its negative effects?
- According to information-processing theorists, what are the two main components of language competence, and how does SL use contribute to each?
📘 Lecture 4 — Second Language Use and Performance Perspective
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how second language learners use and perform in the target language, exploring key theories like Krashen’s Comprehensible Input Hypothesis and the role of interaction. It distinguishes between psycholinguistic and sociolinguistic perspectives on performance and concludes with different views of the learner as a language processor. Understanding these perspectives is crucial for grasping how input, interaction, and learner identity shape SLA.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the Comprehensible Input Hypothesis and its contrast with Swain’s Comprehensible Output Hypothesis, then moves to the performance perspective from psycholinguistics, including the role of negative evidence. It then discusses the sociolinguistic view of interaction as a social process, and finally covers three main views of the learner: linguistic, social psychological, and socio-cultural perspectives.
📝 Lecture Summary
Second Language Use and SLL: Comprehensible Input Hypothesis
Language acquisition requires meaningful interactions in the target language, where speakers focus on conveying messages rather than grammatical forms. Error correction and explicit rule teaching are not considered relevant to acquisition. However, caretakers and native speakers modify their speech to help acquirers understand, and these modifications are thought to assist the acquisition process.
🔑 Definition — Comprehensible Input Hypothesis: Language acquisition occurs when learners understand input that contains language just beyond their current competence, achieved through meaningful interaction and natural communication.
📌 Example: A native speaker uses simpler vocabulary and slower speech when addressing a learner, ensuring the message is understood without focusing on grammar.
Second Language Use and SLL: Performance Perspective and Psycholinguistics
This perspective views interaction as integral and mutually influential between speaking and listening. From a psycholinguistic view, interaction offers opportunities for learners to fine-tune the language input they receive, ensuring it is well adapted to their internal needs.
🔑 Definition — Performance Perspective: A theoretical viewpoint that examines SLA by focusing on how learners actually use language in real-time, especially during interaction.
Performance Perspective and Psycholinguistics: Negative Evidence
Interaction is interesting to linguistic theorists because of controversies over the usefulness of negative evidence for second language development. This term refers to any input that informs the learner about unacceptable forms in the target language. It includes formal correction by a teacher and informal paraphrasing by a native-speaking conversational partner. However, corrections often seem ineffective; therefore, recent theorists put more emphasis on the provision of positive evidence.
🔑 Definition — Negative Evidence: Any type of input that provides information about what is grammatically unacceptable in the target language, such as formal corrections or conversational repairs.
🔑 Definition — Positive Evidence: Input that provides examples of what is grammatically acceptable in the target language, without explicit correction.
💡 Why this matters: The debate over negative versus positive evidence is central to understanding how learners actually notice and internalize grammatical rules.
Performance Perspective: Sociolinguistics
In the sociolinguistic view, interaction is seen as essentially social. The identity of the learner and their language knowledge are collaboratively constructed and reconstructed in the course of interaction. The details of these functions vary from apprenticeship to scaffolding, where more knowledgeable speakers support the learner's development.
🔑 Definition — Apprenticeship: A social learning arrangement where a novice learns from a more expert member of the community through guided participation.
🔑 Definition — Scaffolding: A temporary supportive structure provided by an expert to help a learner perform a task they cannot do independently, which is gradually removed as competence increases.
Views of the Learner
Second language learners can be children or adults learning the language formally (in school or college) or informally (through social interaction). They may learn a localized language to become an insider in a local speech community or a language of wider communication for economic development. There are three main views among SLL researchers:
Linguistic perspective is concerned with modeling language structures and processes within the mind. Social psychological perspective is concerned with modeling individual differences among learners and their implications for eventual learning success. Socio-cultural perspective views the learner as social beings and members of social groups and networks. The first two focus on inner mental mechanisms and aim to document developmental routes, but are less concerned with speed or rate of development and minimize social and contextual differences.
🔑 Definition — Learner as a Language Processor: A view that the learner is an active cognitive system that processes input, pays attention to form, and builds a mental grammar of the target language.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are the distinction between the Comprehensible Input Hypothesis (Krashen) and the role of output (Swain), and the difference between psycholinguistic and sociolinguistic perspectives on interaction. Negative evidence (corrections, paraphrasing) is often ineffective, so positive evidence is prioritized. Learners are viewed from three perspectives: linguistic (inner mental mechanisms), social psychological (individual differences), and socio-cultural (social identity and collaborative construction). The learner's identity and language knowledge are collaboratively constructed in interaction from a sociolinguistic view.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to the Comprehensible Input Hypothesis, what is the primary requirement for language acquisition?
- What is the key difference between psycholinguistic and sociolinguistic views of interaction in SLA?
- Define negative evidence and give one example of how it might be provided to a learner.
- Why do recent theorists emphasize positive evidence over negative evidence?
- Name the three perspectives on the learner discussed in this lecture, and briefly state what each one focuses on.
📘 Lecture 5 — Difference Between Individual Learners
📖 Overview: This lecture examines why second language learners achieve different levels of success despite following similar developmental routes. It explores cognitive and affective factors that differentiate learners, the learner as a social being, and provides an overview of second language research history from the 1950s–1960s.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers differences between individual learners including cognitive differences (intelligence, language aptitude, language learning strategies) and affective differences (language attitudes, motivation, language anxiety, willingness). It then discusses the learner as a social being, considering social context, identity, and socially constructed elements. The lecture concludes with the history of second language research, focusing on the 1950s–1960s, including structuralism and behaviourism.
📝 Lecture Summary
Differences Between Individual Learners; Cognitive Differences; Affective Differences
Second language learners generally differ greatly in the degree of success they achieve, even when following a common developmental route. Social psychologists attribute this to individual differences among learners. Gardner and Macintyre divide learner traits into two groups: cognitive and affective (emotional). The cognitive factors include intelligence, language aptitude, and language learning strategies. The affective factors include language attitudes, motivation, language anxiety, and willingness.
Learner as a Social Being
The two perspectives highlighted so far have concentrated (a) on universal characteristics and (b) on individual characteristics. It is also necessary to view the SL learner as essentially a social being and consider the social context in which learning takes place, as well as the learning opportunities it makes available. Interest in 'learner as a social being' also leads to concern with a range of socially constructed elements in learners' identities and their relationship with learning. Therefore social class, power, ethnicity and gender are significant in SLL research. The relationship between the individual learner and the social context is viewed as dynamic, reflexive, and constantly changing. The 'individual differences' tradition saw that relationship as being governed by traits (aptitude, anxiety, etc.) which are relatively fixed and slow to change, while socially oriented researchers viewed motivation, anxiety etc. as being constantly reconstructed.
Summary of Key Points
This section reinforces that individual learner differences in second language acquisition are categorized into cognitive factors (intelligence, aptitude, strategies) and affective factors (attitudes, motivation, anxiety, willingness). Additionally, the learner cannot be separated from their social context, as identity, social class, power, ethnicity, and gender dynamically interact with the learning process.
History of Second Language Research; The 1950s – 1960s
This chapter explores theoretical foundations of today's thinking, focusing on the post-war period. The period since the 1950s can be divided into three main phases: 1950s–1960s, 1970s, and 1980s onwards. In the 1950s and early 1960s, SLL theorizing was much adjunct to the practical business of language teaching. Language teaching methods at that time had to be justifiable in terms of an underlying theory. 'Progressive' language pedagogy (1950s) drew on a version of structuralism developed by British linguist Palmer. This approach is summed up as follows:
- The conviction about a finite set of 'patterns' or 'structures' in language systems
- The belief that reception and practice result in accuracy and fluency in foreign language habits
- Methodology to teach 'the basic' first before encouraging learners to communicate their own thoughts and ideas
The dominant learning theory in mainstream psychology in this era was Behaviourism.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that individual differences among second language learners are divided into cognitive factors (intelligence, language aptitude, language learning strategies) and affective factors (language attitudes, motivation, language anxiety, willingness). Learners must also be understood as social beings, where social context, identity, social class, power, ethnicity, and gender dynamically influence language acquisition. The history of SLL research in the 1950s–1960s was dominated by structuralism (Palmer) and behaviourism, where language teaching focused on patterns and habit formation through practice.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Gardner and Macintyre, what are the two main groups of learner traits?
- Name the three cognitive factors and four affective factors discussed in this lecture.
- Why is it important to view the SL learner as a social being?
- What are the four socially constructed elements significant in SLL research?
- What was the dominant learning theory in mainstream psychology during the 1950s–1960s?
📘 Lecture 06 — Behaviourism and First Language Acquisition
📖 Overview: This lecture examines Behaviourism as an early theory of language acquisition, its subsequent criticism by Noam Chomsky, and the paradigm shift that occurred in the 1970s. It highlights how first language acquisition research revealed universal stages, consistent ordering, and rule-governed behavior in child language, challenging Behaviourist assumptions about imitation and habit formation.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Behaviourism and its view of language learning as habit formation through stimulus-response and reinforcement; the critique of Behaviourism led by Chomsky; the 1970s research into first language acquisition showing universal stages, similar order of acquisition, acquisition of negatives, and evidence that child language is rule-governed rather than merely imitative.
📝 Lecture Summary
Behaviourism
Behaviourism views language learning as a formation of habits, creating stimulus–response pairing that becomes stronger with reinforcement. In first language (L1) acquisition, learning a new set of habits is relatively simple. In second language (SL) learning, however, one must replace old habits with new ones, which is complicated. If SL structures are similar to the learner’s first language, learning will be easy; if they are different, learning will be difficult. From a teacher’s perspective, this had two implications: (1) learning takes place by imitating and repeating (practice makes perfect), and (2) teachers needed to focus on structures believed to be difficult—specifically, areas of difference between languages. Therefore, researchers began comparing pairs of languages in what is called contrastive analyses.
🔑 Definition — Behaviourism: A theory that views all learning, including language, as the formation of habits through stimulus–response associations strengthened by reinforcement.
🔑 Definition — Stimulus–response pairing: The association between a trigger (stimulus) and an action (response) that, when reinforced, becomes a habit.
🔑 Definition — Contrastive analyses: The systematic comparison of two languages to identify differences, which were believed to be the source of learning difficulty.
Behaviourism under Attack
In the late 1950s, linguistics shifted from structural linguistics to generative linguistics, initiated by Noam Chomsky. In psychology, the pre-eminent role of the environment lost ground in favor of developmentalist views such as Piaget’s cognitive development theory. Chomsky strongly criticized Skinner’s Behaviourist views on several issues and rejected the idea that one can compare the behaviour of rats in a laboratory, learning simple tasks, to the behaviour of children learning language without direct teaching. Chomsky claimed that children have an innate faculty that guides them in learning language.
🔑 Definition — Generative linguistics: A linguistic approach, pioneered by Chomsky, that focuses on the innate, rule-governed nature of language rather than surface-level habits.
The 1970s: First Language Acquisition: Same Stages
In the 1970s, researchers including Klima and Bellugi (1966), Slobin (1970), and Brown (1973) found striking similarities in the language learning behaviour of young children, regardless of the language being learned. They showed that children all over the world go through similar stages, use similar constructions, and make similar kinds of errors.
💡 Why this matters: These findings directly contradicted Behaviourism, which predicted that language acquisition would vary greatly depending on the environmental input and reinforcement patterns.
First Language Acquisition: Similar Order
A consistent order of acquisition was found while studying English language structures. Children all over the world acquire negative forms around the same age and mark negation in similar ways across all languages.
📐 Finding: Children universally acquire certain grammatical structures in a fixed order, with negatives emerging at approximately the same age across languages.
📌 Example: A child learning English and a child learning Japanese both begin to produce negative expressions at roughly the same developmental stage, suggesting a universal, innate timetable rather than habit formation.
First Language Acquisition: Negatives
The acquisition of negatives was a key area of study. Children mark negation in similar ways across all languages and acquire negative structures in a predictable sequence.
📌 Example: In early negation, children might say "no want" or "no go" before they learn the adult forms "I don't want" or "I didn't go." This pattern appears across different languages and cannot be explained by simple imitation of adult speech.
First Language Acquisition: Rule Governed
Another important finding was that child language is rule-governed even if, initially, the rules children create do not correspond to adult rules. Children express relationships between elements in a sentence in a consistent way. When producing adult-like forms, they are not merely imitating and repeating; instead, they extract rules from the language they hear and apply them to their own production. It happens much later when they will be able to take on broad exceptions to those rules.
🔑 Definition — Rule-governed language: The principle that children systematically apply internalized grammatical rules to their speech, even if those rules differ from adult grammar, showing creativity rather than rote imitation.
📌 Example: A child who says "I runned" instead of "I ran" is applying the regular past tense rule (-ed) to an irregular verb. This overgeneralization shows the child has extracted a rule, not simply imitated what they heard, because adults rarely say "runned."
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture contrasts Behaviourism, which viewed language as habit formation through imitation and reinforcement, with the Chomskyan critique that children possess an innate language faculty. Research in the 1970s—by Klima, Bellugi, Slobin, and Brown—demonstrated that children across languages progress through universal stages, acquire structures like negatives in a similar order and at similar ages, and that child language is rule-governed rather than merely imitative. These findings fundamentally challenged Behaviourism by showing that children actively extract and apply rules to their speech, including overgeneralizations like "runned," which cannot be explained by imitation alone.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Behaviourism, what is the process of second language learning, and why is it considered more difficult than first language acquisition?
- What two main criticisms did Chomsky level against Skinner's Behaviourist view of language learning?
- What did Klima, Bellugi, Slobin, and Brown discover about children's language acquisition in the 1970s that contradicted Behaviourism?
- Why does a child saying "I runned" (instead of "I ran") provide evidence that language is rule-governed rather than purely imitative?
- What is "contrastive analysis" and how did it stem from Behaviourist assumptions about language teaching?
📘 Lecture 7 — Second Language Learning And Krashen’s Monitor Model
📖 Overview: This lecture begins by reviewing general principles of first language acquisition and then transitions into second language learning (SLL) theories. It critiques Contrastive Analysis and introduces Error Analysis as a more effective approach. The core of the lecture presents Krashen’s influential Monitor Model, focusing on its five hypotheses, beginning with the Acquisition-Learning Hypothesis.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture outlines First Language Acquisition General Principles, then moves to Second Language Learning (SLL) focusing on Contrastive Analysis and its shortcomings. It then introduces Error Analysis as a better method for understanding errors, asking where errors come from and linking them to learner-internal systems like Selinker's Inter-language. Finally, it introduces Krashen’s Monitor Model, detailing the first of its five hypotheses: the Acquisition-Learning Hypothesis.
📝 Lecture Summary
First Language Acquisition: General Principles; SLL: Contrastive Analysis; SLL: Error Analysis; SLL: Where do Errors Come from? Krashen’s Monitor Model; Acquisition Learning Hypothesis
The lecture begins by establishing key principles from 1970s first language acquisition research. Children progress through stages that are remarkably similar across children and languages, though individual rates vary. Child language is rule-governed and systematic, but their rules often differ from adult rules, and they are resistant to correction. Their processing capacity limits the number of rules they can apply at any one time.
These findings attracted SLA researchers because the predictions of Contrastive Analysis were not working in practice. The idea that differences between languages are always difficult and similarities are always easy was proven false. Difficulty sometimes occurs in only one direction. The task of comparing languages to design teaching programs was seen as disproportionately huge relative to its predictive power. This disillusionment led to Error Analysis, the systematic investigation of SL learners' errors. Studies showed that most errors do not originate from the first language; they appear to be learner-internal in origin. In 1972, Selinker coined the term Inter-language, referring to the language produced by learners as a system, moving beyond just errors to focus on the learner's entire language system.
🔑 Definition — Contrastive Analysis: A method of comparing two languages (L1 and L2) to predict learning difficulties based on their differences. 🔑 Definition — Error Analysis: The systematic investigation and classification of second language learners' errors to understand the learning process. 🔑 Definition — Inter-language: The separate linguistic system that a learner constructs at a given stage of second language development, which is independent from both L1 and L2.
The Acquisition-Learning Hypothesis
This is the first and foundational hypothesis of Krashen’s Monitor Model. It distinguishes between two independent processes for developing ability in a second language: acquisition and learning.
- Acquisition is a subconscious process. It is similar to how children acquire their first language. The user is usually not consciously aware of the rules being learned. The focus is on meaning, not form. The result is acquired competence, which is intuitive and allows for fluent communication.
- Learning is a conscious process. It involves formal instruction and the explicit understanding of grammatical rules. The learner knows the rules and can talk about them. The result is learned competence, which acts as a monitor or editor.
According to Krashen, acquisition is the more important process because it is what enables natural, fluent communication. Learning only serves to monitor or edit the output from the acquired system.
🔑 Definition — Acquisition: A subconscious process of developing linguistic competence, similar to first language acquisition, where the focus is on meaning. 🔑 Definition — Learning: A conscious process of gaining explicit knowledge about the rules of a language through formal study. 💡 Why this matters: This hypothesis fundamentally changes how we view language teaching. It suggests that for true fluency, classrooms should prioritize activities that promote subconscious acquisition through meaningful communication, rather than just explicit grammar drills.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that first language acquisition is stage-based, rule-governed, and resistant to correction. The failure of Contrastive Analysis led to Error Analysis, which revealed that most errors are learner-internal, not just from L1 interference, leading to Selinker’s concept of Inter-language. The central piece of this lecture is Krashen’s Acquisition-Learning Hypothesis, which makes a crucial distinction between subconscious acquisition (the basis for fluency) and conscious learning (a monitor for editing). The key takeaway is that for effective second language development, acquisition is the primary and more important process, while learning plays a secondary, editing role.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five general principles of first language acquisition outlined at the start of the lecture?
- Why did researchers become disillusioned with the Contrastive Analysis hypothesis?
- What is the main difference between Error Analysis and the study of Inter-language?
- According to Krashen’s Monitor Model, what is the difference between 'acquisition' and 'learning'?
- According to this model, which of the two processes (acquisition or learning) is more important for developing fluent communication, and why?