π Lecture 14 β Learning Strategies and Second Language Learning
π Overview: This lecture explores the application of Anderson's ACT* cognitive theory to second language learning, focusing on how learning strategies can be understood as complex cognitive skills. It examines the three stages of skill acquisitionβcognitive, associative, and autonomousβand discusses how learning strategies, classified into metacognitive, cognitive, and social/affective categories, can be taught and proceduralized to enhance language learning.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers explanations of learning offered by ACT* theory, including its three stages (cognitive, associative, autonomous) illustrated with a grammar example; a critique of Anderson's position that second language grammar is initially learned through conscious study; the classification of learning strategies into metacognitive, cognitive, and social/affective categories; the benefits of applying cognitive theory to second language acquisition; and the application of ACT* to fluency development, including Towell and Hawkins' perspective on combining Universal Grammar with information-processing models.
π Lecture Summary
Explanations of Learning Offered
Anderson's ACT* model proposes that complex cognitive skills, including language learning, develop through three distinct stages. At the cognitive stage, learners acquire declarative knowledgeβfacts and information about the skill. At the associative stage, this declarative knowledge is converted into procedural knowledge through practice and application. At the autonomous stage, the skill becomes increasingly automatic and rapid, requiring less conscious effort.
π Definition β Cognitive Stage: The initial learning phase where learners acquire factual knowledge (declarative knowledge) about a skill, such as grammar rules.
π Example: A learner at the cognitive stage learns that an -s must be added to the verb after a third person singular subject.
π Definition β Associative Stage: The phase where learners practice applying declarative knowledge, working out how to perform the skill in context, and forming associations between actions and knowledge.
π Example: At the associative stage, the learner works out how to add an -s when the context requires it, learning to associate the action with the corresponding declarative knowledge.
π Definition β Autonomous Stage: The final phase where the skill becomes automatic and rapid, and the original declarative knowledge may even be lost from conscious awareness.
π Example: At the autonomous stage, the learner's action of adding -s becomes increasingly automatic, performed without conscious thought.
π‘ Why this matters: These stages explain why language learners progress from slow, rule-based production to fluent, effortless performance.
Critique
Contemporary second language learning theorists disagree with Anderson's implied position that second language grammar is initially learned through conscious study and application of explicit rules. There is consensus that much grammar learning takes place without conscious awareness. Some information-processing theorists have responded by suggesting that the declarative knowledge component can be subdivided into conscious and unconscious parts. Others argue that information-processing models are most helpful in explaining more peripheral strands in second language learning.
Application of ACT* to Learning Strategies
O'Malley and Chamot (1990) suggest that learning strategies are procedures undertaken by learners to make their language learning as effective as possible. Learning strategies must not be confused with communication strategies; they do overlap but differ in focus. Learning strategies facilitate learning, whereas communication strategies help overcome a specific communicative problem.
π Definition β Learning Strategies: Procedures undertaken by learners to make their language learning as effective as possible. They facilitate the learning process itself.
Classification of Learning Strategies
Learning strategies can be classified into three categories:
- Metacognition strategies: These involve selective attention, planning, monitoring, and evaluation.
- Cognitive strategies: These include rehearsal, organization, inferencing, summarizing, deducing, imagery, transfer, and elaboration.
- Social or affective strategies: These involve co-operation, questioning for clarification, and self-talk.
Learning Strategies and Second Language Learning
Learning strategies are complex procedures applied to tasks; they may be represented as procedural knowledge, acquired through cognitive, associative, and autonomous stages of learning. The strategies may be conscious in early stages of learning and later be performed without the person's awareness. Thus, these have to be learned in exactly the same way as other complex cognitive skills. Before a skill is proceduralized, it will have to compete for working memory space with other aspects of the task in hand. If learning strategies are a skill, then they can be taught and get proceduralized more quickly, freeing working memory space for other aspects of learning.
π Definition β Proceduralized: The process by which declarative knowledge (knowing that) is converted into procedural knowledge (knowing how), making performance automatic and freeing up working memory.
π‘ Why this matters: Teaching learning strategies can accelerate proceduralization, freeing cognitive resources for other aspects of language processing.
Benefits of Cognitive Theory Application to SLL
General benefits of applying cognitive theory to second language acquisition are as follows:
- Learning is an active and dynamic process in which individuals make use of a variety of information and strategic modes of processing.
- Language is a complex cognitive skill in terms of how information is stored and learned.
- Learning a language entails a stage-wise progression from initial awareness, active manipulation of information and learning processes to full automaticity in language use.
- Learning strategies parallel theoretically derived cognitive processes and have the potential to influence learning outcomes in a positive manner.
ACT* and Fluency Development in Second Language Acquisition
Towell and Hawkins reject the idea that Anderson's model can account for all aspects of second language learning. They use models of natural language processing in order to explain how grammatical knowledge transforms into fluent performance in second language. To explain why certain grammatical structures appear before others and why learners go through rigid stages in acquisition of second language, they resort to Universal Grammar approach. To understand how learners use this grammatical knowledge in increasingly efficient ways, Towell and Hawkins appeal to an information-processing account.
β Key Takeaways
The ACT* model's three stagesβcognitive, associative, and autonomousβexplain how language skills develop from conscious rule application to automatic performance. Learning strategies are complex cognitive skills that can be classified into metacognitive, cognitive, and social/affective categories, and teaching these strategies can accelerate proceduralization, freeing working memory. While ACT* provides a useful framework for understanding fluency development, theorists like Towell and Hawkins argue it cannot account for all aspects of second language acquisition, requiring integration with Universal Grammar for explaining developmental sequences. The cognitive theory approach emphasizes that language is an active, dynamic process progressing from initial awareness to full automaticity.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three stages of skill acquisition in Anderson's ACT* model, and what happens in each stage regarding the use of declarative knowledge?
- Why do contemporary SLL theorists disagree with Anderson's position that second language grammar is initially learned through conscious study of explicit rules?
- What is the difference between learning strategies and communication strategies?
- Name the three categories of learning strategies as classified by O'Malley and Chamot, and provide one example from each category.
- How do Towell and Hawkins combine Universal Grammar and information-processing accounts to explain fluency development in second language acquisition?
π Lecture 15 β Theories of Second Language Processing and Connectionism
π Overview: This lecture explores two major theoretical frameworks for understanding how second language learners process linguistic input: Processability Theory and the Perceptual Saliency approach. It also introduces Connectionism, a computational model of learning that fundamentally challenges rule-based accounts of language acquisition by proposing that learning occurs through associative pattern recognition in neural networks.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Processability Theory and its focus on the gradual acquisition of computational mechanisms for processing grammatical information, the Teachability Hypothesis derived from Processability Theory which predicts that instruction cannot skip developmental stages, the Perceptual Saliency approach and Slobin's operating principles, and finally Connectionism (parallel distributed processing) which views learning as the strengthening of connections in neural networks through repeated activation rather than the construction of abstract rules.
π Lecture Summary
Theories of Second Language Processing; Processability Theory; Teachability Hypothesis
The next two theories discussed focus on factors controlling how SL learners process linguistic input: Processability Theory and Perceptual Saliency approach.
Processability Theory, outlined by Pienemann, aims to clarify how learners acquire computational mechanisms that operate on the linguistic knowledge they construct. It claims that we need both a theory of grammar and a processing component to understand SLA. It focuses on the acquisition of the procedural skills required for processing the formal properties of second languages. Pienemann believes that language learning is the gradual acquisition of computational mechanisms. Limitations in processing skills in the early stage of learning prevent learners from attending to some aspects of SL. The processing challenge within this framework is that learners must learn to exchange grammatical information across elements of a sentence.
π Definition β Processability Theory: A theory by Pienemann stating that SLA involves the gradual acquisition of computational mechanisms needed to process grammatical information across sentence elements.
Pienemann's Processability Theory explains that SL learners follow a fairly rigid route while acquiring certain grammatical structures. It implies that structures only become 'learnable' when previous steps on this acquisitional path have been acquired. According to Pienemann, learners can only operate within their Hypothesis space, constrained by available processing resources. This led him to develop the "teachability hypothesis", which considers the pedagogical implications of the learnability or processability model. It predicts:
- Stages of acquisition cannot be skipped through formal instruction
- Instruction will be beneficial if it focuses on structures from 'the next stage'
π Definition β Teachability Hypothesis: Pienemann's hypothesis stating that instruction is only effective when it targets structures that are at the learner's next developmental stage and that stages cannot be skipped through teaching.
π‘ Why this matters: The most interesting aspect of the Teachability Hypothesis is its attempt to establish a direct, testable link between learning and teaching, with clear practical implications for curriculum design and classroom instruction.
π Example: If a learner is at Stage 2 of acquiring English negation (e.g., "no go"), instruction on Stage 4 structures (e.g., "I didn't go") would be ineffective. Only instruction on Stage 3 structures (e.g., "I don't go") would be beneficial, as that represents "the next stage."
The Perceptual Saliency approach
The Perceptual Saliency approach argues that human beings perceive and organize information in certain ways, and it is perceptual saliency of linguistic information that drives the learning process forward, rather than an innate language-specific module. We find similarity in linguistic development across children and across languages because human beings are programmed to perceive and organize information in a certain way. Slobin (1979) has devised operating principles which guide children in their processing of the linguistic strings which they encounter. These principles are based on the claim that certain linguistic forms are more 'accessible' or more 'salient' to children than others.
π Definition β Perceptual Saliency: The principle that certain linguistic forms are more noticeable and accessible to learners due to how humans naturally perceive and organize information, driving acquisition without requiring an innate language-specific module.
The operating principles are as follows:
- Pay attention to the end of words
- Linguistic elements encode relations between words
- Avoid exceptions
- Underlying semantic relations should be marked overtly and clearly
- Use of grammatical markers should make semantic sense
π Example: A child learning English will more readily acquire the plural "-s" (which appears at the end of words, following Principle 1) than the irregular plural "men" (which violates Principle 3: avoid exceptions). Similarly, the past tense "-ed" follows Principles 1 and 5 more clearly than irregular forms like "went" or "ran."
Connectionism; Connectionist Approach Difference from Other Approach
Connectionism (or parallel distributed processing) has been given new life by advances in computer technology. It likens the brain to a computer consisting of neural networks β complex clusters of links between information nodes. These links or connections become strengthened or weakened through activation or non-activation. Learning in this view occurs on the basis of associative process rather than the construction of abstract rules. It claims that learners are sensitive to regularities in the language input and extract probabilistic patterns on the basis of these regularities. Learning occurs as these patterns become strengthened or weakened through repeated activation or non-activation.
π Definition β Connectionism: A theory of language acquisition that views learning as the strengthening of connections between information nodes in neural networks through repeated activation, based on associative processes rather than the construction of abstract rules.
Connectionism strikingly differs from other approaches as it does not believe that the learning of rules underlies the construction of linguistic knowledge β rather, it happens through associative process. According to connectionists, learning is not rule-governed. Connectionism is seen as an alternative to symbolic accounts of language acquisition. It is a transition theory that explains how associative patterns emerge in learners.
π Definition β Neural networks: Complex clusters of links between information nodes in the brain where connections become strengthened or weakened through activation or non-activation.
π Example: A child learning the past tense in English does not first learn the rule "add -ed." Instead, through repeated exposure to "walk-walked," "play-played," "talk-talked," the connection between the base form and the past tense form becomes strengthened. With enough activation, the network generalizes this pattern to new verbs. However, frequently encountered irregular forms like "go-went" also have strong connections, explaining why learners sometimes produce both "goed" and "went."
π‘ Why this matters: Connectionism fundamentally challenges all rule-based theories (including Universal Grammar, Processability Theory, and Monitor Theory) by proposing that what looks like rule-governed behavior is actually the result of statistical pattern extraction from input. This shift has major implications for whether we should explicitly teach grammar rules or simply provide rich, patterned input.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember is that Processability Theory by Pienemann proposes a rigid developmental route for grammatical structures, leading to the Teachability Hypothesis that instruction cannot skip stages and is only effective at the next stage. The Perceptual Saliency approach by Slobin explains cross-linguistic developmental similarities through operating principles based on how humans naturally perceive and organize linguistic information, emphasizing salience over innate modules. Connectionism radically differs from all other approaches by rejecting rule-based learning entirely, proposing instead that acquisition occurs through associative processes where neural connections strengthen or weaken through repeated activation. For exams, remember the six operating principles of Slobin, the two predictions of the Teachability Hypothesis, and the core distinction that connectionism sees learning as probabilistic pattern extraction rather than rule construction. Finally, understand that connectionism is a transition theory that explains how associative patterns emerge, making it a computational alternative to symbolic accounts of language acquisition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two key predictions of Pienemann's Teachability Hypothesis, and what practical implications do they have for language instruction?
- List Slobin's five operating principles for processing linguistic strings, and explain which principle accounts for children's preference for regular grammatical markers over irregular ones.
- How does Connectionism's view of learning differ fundamentally from rule-based approaches like Processability Theory or Universal Grammar?
- According to Processability Theory, what is the main processing challenge that SL learners face, and why does this create a rigid developmental route?
- In what way does Connectionism function as a "transition theory," and what does it mean that learning in this framework is "not rule-governed"?
π Lecture 16 β Evaluation of Cognitive Approaches and Functional Perspectives
π Overview: This lecture critically evaluates cognitive approaches to second language acquisition, examining their scope, achievements, and limitations. It then introduces functional/pragmatic perspectives, which prioritize meaning-making and communicative goals as driving forces in language development. Understanding these contrasting frameworks is essential for comprehending how different theoretical lenses shape our view of the SLA process.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the evaluation of cognitive approaches to second language learning, including their scope and achievements, the cognitivists' view of language, language learning, and the language learner. It also introduces functional/pragmatic perspectives on second language learning and functional perspectives on first language development, examining how meaning-making interacts with grammatical development.
π Lecture Summary
Evaluation of Cognitive Approaches to Second Language Learning: Scope and Achievements
The scope of cognitivists' research varies widely. Some apply general models of language processing or use computers to simulate acquisition of discrete grammatical phenomena. Some cognitivists focus specifically on processing mechanisms and how they develop in SLL, believing they also need a property theory to understand the linguistic system, which will complement their transition theory. Others, adopting an emergentist or connectionist approach, see their field as the whole process of language learning and do not separate the development of processing from development of the linguistic system.
Processing theorists do not say much about language itself; they concentrate on the study of processing constraints operating in SLA. In contrast, connectionists believe that our mind is predisposed to look for associations between elements and create neural links between them. They see language as a set of probabilistic patterns that gets strengthened in the learner's brain through repeated activation. They rely on controlled laboratory research involving experiments with artificial language or small fragments of real languages. However, this controlled nature can be seen as a disadvantage.
Overall, connectionist models are often criticized for their clinical and fragmentary view of language, ignoring social and linguistic phenomena. They are unable to explain what the mental grammar of the learner consists of and what constrains learners' hypotheses about the language system. The developmental route of SLL and the acquisition of highly complex linguistic phenomena are not yet convincingly explained by these approaches.
π‘ Why this matters: The distinction between processing theories and connectionist theories represents a fundamental divide in how cognitive scientists view the relationship between language processing and linguistic knowledge.
Evaluation: Cognitivists' View of Language
Cognitivists primarily investigate the development of processing in SL learners. To do so, psychologists use laboratory techniques to measure accurately performance indicators, while linguists apply linguistic analysis techniques to study SL learners' productions or intuitions. Both methodologies have their advantages and disadvantages. The ultimate goal of any SLA model is a better understanding of the SLA process overall. This goal is much enriched by cognitive studies. These studies have also enlightened us on the processes involved in speeding up the acquisition process.
Evaluation: Cognitivists' View of Language Learning
Connectionists are primarily concerned with the individual; they do not see the learner as a social being. They are interested in the mind as a processor of information rather than in the specificity of the linguistic information it contains. The link they build up with neurology and neurobiology is also important.
The advantages of these models over traditional symbolic models are: a. They are neurally inspired. b. They incorporate distributed representation and control of information. c. They are data-driven with prototypical representations. d. They show graceful degradation as do humans with language disorders. e. They are models of learning and acquisition rather than static description.
Cognitivists' View of the Language Learner
This section is integrated within the preceding evaluation, describing the learner as an information processor rather than a social being. Connectionists focus on the individual mind and its neural associations, with the learner's brain strengthening probabilistic patterns through repeated activation.
Functional/Pragmatic Perspectives on Second Language Learning
Researchers who adopt this approach are centrally concerned with the ways in which SL learners set about making meaning and achieving their personal communicative goals. They emphasize the importance of learners' speech acts and how they exploit immediate social, physical, and discourse context to make meaning. They argue that the meaning-making efforts are a driving force in ongoing second language development that interacts with the development of formal grammatical systems.
Functional Perspectives on First Language Development
Functionalism in linguistics is the explication and explanation of grammatical structure in which semantic and pragmatic constructs are integral. This perspective emphasizes that grammatical forms are shaped by their communicative functions, and that understanding how learners make meaning is essential for explaining language development.
β Key Takeaways
The cognitive approaches to SLA are divided between processing theorists, who focus on processing constraints, and connectionists, who see language as probabilistic neural patterns strengthened through repeated activation. While connectionist models are neurally inspired and show graceful degradation like human language disorders, they are criticized for ignoring social and linguistic phenomena and for failing to explain complex linguistic acquisition. In contrast, functional/pragmatic perspectives view meaning-making and achieving communicative goals as the driving force in language development, arguing that grammatical systems develop interactively with these communicative efforts. Students must remember that functionalism explains grammatical structure through semantic and pragmatic constructs, making it fundamentally different from cognitive approaches that prioritize information processing over social communication.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the main difference between processing theorists and connectionists in their approach to SLA?
- What are the five advantages of connectionist models over traditional symbolic models?
- Why are connectionist models criticized for their view of language learning?
- What is the central concern of researchers adopting functional/pragmatic perspectives on second language learning?
- According to functionalism, how are semantic and pragmatic constructs related to grammatical structure?
π Lecture 17 β Cognitive, Textual, Social Orientations and Functionalism
π Overview: This lecture explores three key functionalist orientations in second language acquisition: cognitive, textual, and social. It examines how functionalism views language development as driven by communicative needs and evaluates the scope, achievements, and limitations of this tradition in understanding inter-language development.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers cognitive orientation exemplified by Slobin's "basic child grammar" and agent-object encoding; textual orientation focusing on discourse organization and cohesion; social orientation examining the relationship between language development and social context; multifunctional orientation integrating all three perspectives; evaluation of functionalism's scope and achievements in SLA; and functionalism's contribution to understanding the nature of inter-language communication.
π Lecture Summary
Cognitive, Textual, Social Orientations and Functionalism
The functional approaches in SLA pay attention respectively to the relations between grammatical development and prototype events, between grammar, pragmatics and text organization, and between grammar and the social world. The functional tradition is well established in SLA theory, claiming that language development is driven by pragmatic communicative needs and that the formal resources of language are elaborated to express more complex patterns of meaning. Functionalist research typically takes the form of naturalistic case studies, mostly of adults in early stages of SLA, offering rich accounts of both rate and route of naturalistic SLA.
These studies vary in their scope of enquiries. Some adopted a "patch approach," studying evolution of forms or development of SL within "time" or "space" domain. Others proposed an SL "basic variety" that represents a proto-grammar stage that all learners should pass through.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding functionalist orientations helps explain how learners communicate meaning before mastering formal grammar.
Cognitive Orientation
Cognitive orientation can be exemplified by the work of Slobin (1985) that proposed the existence of 'basic child grammar' in which children construct their own form-function relationship to reflect a child's-eye view of the world. He suggested that one of the opening wedges for grammar is the linguistic encoding of a scene in which an agent brings about change of state in an object.
π Definition β Basic Child Grammar: A concept proposed by Slobin where children construct their own form-function relationships that reflect a child's perspective of the world. π Formula: Agent acts on object β change of state β linguistic encoding (Example: "boy breaks window" where "boy" is agent, "breaks" is action, "window" is object undergoing change)
Textual Orientation
In textual orientation, the central issue is to investigate the extent to which particular linguistic devices are employed to organize stretches of discourse intra-sententially as well as across broader stretches of text. At discourse level, functional linguists are interested in how both vocabulary and grammar are deployed to create textual cohesion across sequences of clauses and sentences.
π Definition β Textual Cohesion: The way vocabulary and grammar are deployed to create connections across sequences of clauses and sentences in discourse.
Social Orientation
Functionalist research with social orientation is interested in the relationship between the development of a child's formal language system and aspects of their social world. Some of this work examines children's speech acts and their relationship with lexical or grammatical choices. Other work looks more broadly at the social context in which children interact and the types of speech events they are engaged in, seeking to link these influences to linguistic development.
π Definition β Speech Acts: Utterances that perform an action (e.g., requesting, promising, commanding) and their relationship to lexical or grammatical choices.
Multifunctional Orientation
Multifunctional orientation integrates all three perspectives β cognitive, textual, and social β recognizing that language development simultaneously involves prototype events, text organization, pragmatic functions, and social context.
Evaluation: Scope and Achievements
The functionalist tradition has contributed to our understanding of inter-language communication and made interesting suggestions about interactions between formal and functional development. Functionalists have demonstrated various devices which inter-language users deploy to convey meaning. They have drawn attention to textual and discourse organization issues, and offered considerable evidence that early learners rely heavily on parataxis rather than on syntax.
π Definition β Parataxis: The arrangement of clauses or phrases one after another without coordinating or subordinating conjunctions (e.g., "I came. I saw. I conquered." instead of "I came, I saw, and I conquered.")
Functionalism and the Nature of Inter-Language
A continuing limitation of the functionalist approach is that most attention is given to earliest stages of development. The range of target languages investigated is also not very wide. This means that while functionalism has provided rich insights into early SLA, its applicability to later stages and diverse languages remains limited.
β Key Takeaways
Functionalism views language development as driven by communicative needs, with formal grammar emerging from pragmatic functions. The three orientations β cognitive (exemplified by Slobin's basic child grammar), textual (focusing on discourse cohesion), and social (examining speech acts and social context) β offer complementary perspectives on how learners construct inter-language systems. Functionalist research has demonstrated that early learners rely heavily on parataxis rather than syntax, and has provided rich case study evidence of both rate and route of naturalistic SLA. However, a major limitation is the narrow focus on earliest developmental stages and limited range of target languages investigated. The patch approach studying evolution of forms within time or space domains contrasts with the basic variety concept of a universal proto-grammar stage.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is Slobin's "basic child grammar" and what does it propose about children's language development?
- How do textual orientation and social orientation differ in their focus within functionalist research?
- What does "parataxis" mean, and why is it significant for understanding early inter-language development?
- What are two main limitations of the functionalist approach to SLA according to this lecture?
- What is the difference between the "patch approach" and the "basic variety" approach in functionalist research?
π Lecture 18 β FUNCTIONALISM AND INTERACTION IN SECOND LANGUAGE LEARNING
π Overview: This lecture examines functionalist perspectives on second language acquisition, focusing on the gradual nature of interlanguage development and the role of communicative need. It then shifts to the interactionist approach, exploring how input, interaction, and output β particularly through negotiation of meaning and the Output Hypothesis β contribute to second language learning, with relevant comparisons to first language acquisition.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers functionalism on language learning and development, the functionalist view of the language learner, input and interaction in second language learning, the significance of interaction in SLL, input and interaction in first language acquisition, and findings from CDS (child-directed speech) research relevant to SLL. It discusses the Input Hypothesis, Interaction Hypothesis, Output Hypothesis, and cross-cultural variation in caregiver speech.
π Lecture Summary
Functionalism on Language Learning and Development
Functionalist researchers insist on the gradual nature of Inter Language (IL) development and syntacticization, but with possible reorganizational consequences. Most functionalists have adopted a 'patch' approach β working on overall utterance structure when studying the basic variety or exploring development within semantic and formal sub-systems. They argue for a multi-level approach to analysis. While their contribution at the descriptive level has been very strong and varied, their contribution to explaining IL development is limited. It clearly shows how effective a basic variety can be in meeting immediate communication needs, but it is less clearly established that communicative need is the primary driver for syntacticization and development beyond the basic variety.
π Definition β Inter Language (IL): the intermediate, evolving linguistic system that a second language learner constructs as they progress toward the target language. π Definition β Basic variety: the early, simplified stage of interlanguage that is efficient for immediate communication but lacks complex syntax and morphology. π Example: A functionalist study might show a learner saying "Me go store yesterday" β functionally effective for communication, but lacking target-like syntax (auxiliary, past tense marking). Over time, the learner's IL syntacticizes to "I went to the store yesterday."
Functionalist View of the Language Learner
Functionalist research largely concentrates on analyzing learners' inter-language output and pays relatively less attention to input and even interaction. It has mostly concerned itself with naturalistic adult learners acquiring a socially dominant target language (TL) in the workplace and other non-domestic settings. It has conducted extensive comparative cross-language studies but has been mainly interested in discovering universal rather than language-specific characteristics of the learning process. Functionalist research on the emergence of SL has also concerned itself with instructed learners β these learners are seen as more successful in acquiring morphology. Though functionalists agree that instruction works by increasing acquisition rate and pushing along the acquisitional route, it does not explicitly explain the reason.
π Definition β Naturalistic adult learners: adults who acquire the target language primarily through exposure and use in social/work environments, without formal instruction. π Example: A functionalist might compare a Turkish immigrant learning German naturally at work versus an instructed learner in a classroom, finding the instructed learner acquires German case morphology faster, but both follow a similar developmental sequence.
Input and Interaction in Second Language Acquisition
The main focus here is directly on the role of environmental language use in promoting SLL in the form of input received by the SL learner, SL output produced by the learner, and SL interaction between learner and some other conversation partner. The 'interactionist' perspective mostly does not challenge the concepts of autonomous language module or cognitive mechanisms at work within the individual learner. The Input Hypothesis claims that comprehensive input is the only necessary condition for language learning to take place, provided that the learner pays attention to it. This is further directed toward the Interaction Hypothesis and Output Hypothesis. Interactions are not a simple one-directional source of target language input feeding into the learner's presumed internal acquisition device. Instead, when learners engage with their interlocutor in negotiations around meaning, input's nature might be qualitatively changed. The more input is queried, recycled, and paraphrased, the greater its potential usefulness as input becomes because it should become increasingly well-targeted to particular developmental needs.
π Definition β Input Hypothesis: the claim that comprehensible input (language just beyond the learner's current level) is necessary and sufficient for language acquisition. π Definition β Interaction Hypothesis: the claim that interaction, especially negotiation of meaning, modifies input in ways that facilitate acquisition. π Example: A learner says "I go store." The interlocutor asks, "You went to the store? When did you go?" This negotiation recycles and paraphrases the input, making it more comprehensible and highlighting the past tense form "went."
The Output Hypothesis
Merrill Swain's (1985, 1995) study with immersion students led her to question the claim that comprehensible SL input was sufficient to ensure inter-language development. So she advanced her claims called the 'Output Hypothesis.' Swain argued that students often succeed in comprehending second language (SL) text while only partly processing them. SL production (output) really forces learners to undertake complete grammatical processing. Thus, it drives forward most effectively the development of SL syntax and morphology.
π Definition β Output Hypothesis: the claim that producing language (not just comprehending it) pushes learners to process grammar fully, promoting interlanguage development. π‘ Why this matters: This hypothesis challenges the sufficiency of the Input Hypothesis, arguing that comprehension can occur with partial processing, but production demands full syntactic and morphological processing.
Input and Interaction in First Language Acquisition
When we examine the role of input and interaction in first language acquisition, adults commonly use 'special' speech styles when talking with young children. This is called 'baby talk' or child-directed speech (CDS), which might be helpful to language acquisition. But such CDS has undergone criticism from UG theorists. For instance, Noam Chomsky described the notion that aspects of first language acquisition could be related to the input as 'absurd.' In turn, some child language specialists criticized parameter-setting models of acquisition as overly deterministic and ignoring substantial evidence of probabilistic learning from 'noisy' input. Interactionists such as Gallaway and Richard (1994) have pointed out the ways in which CDS might facilitate language acquisition. These include: managing attention, promoting positive affect, facilitating segmentation, feedback, correction models, reducing processing load, encouraging conversational participation, and explicit teaching of social routines. However, interactionists are cautious about any possible contribution of CDS to language acquisition.
π Definition β Child-directed speech (CDS): the simplified, exaggerated speech style adults use when talking to young children. π Definition β Negative evidence: information that a learner's utterance is grammatically incorrect, often provided through recasts (repetitions with correction). π Example: A child says, "I goed to the park." The parent responds, "Oh, you went to the park?" β This recast provides negative evidence without explicit correction.
Findings Relevant for SLL
Some clear findings from CDS research which are also relevant to SLL are:
- Mostly CDS studies were carried out in English-speaking, middle-class family contexts in developed countries. In such contexts, CDS is typically semantically contingent (responsive to the child's meaning/focus). Also, explicit formal corrections of a child's production are unusual, but recasts are common, which offer useful negative evidence.
- There is evidence for some specific claims about the relationship between particular formal characteristics of CDS and children's developing control of particular constructions. However, such relationships are complex and dependent on the precise developmental stage reached by the individual child.
- Caretakers are neither motivated by any prime language-teaching goal nor is their speech adapted to model target grammar. Instead, it is derived from the communicative goal of engaging in conversation with a less competent partner, and sustaining and directing their attention.
- Cross-cultural studies of interaction revealed that styles of CDS in middle-class Anglophone societies are far from universal. In some cultures, infants are not seen as conversational partners. These findings strongly challenge environmentalist explanations of language learning that finely tuned CDS is actually necessary.
π Example: In a Western middle-class home, a mother might say, "Look, a doggie! Can you say doggie?" β This is semantically contingent and uses recasts. In some non-Western cultures, adults may rarely speak directly to infants, yet children still acquire language, showing that finely tuned CDS is not universally necessary.
β Key Takeaways
Functionalists emphasize the gradual, multi-level development of interlanguage, showing that the basic variety is effective for communication but syntacticization driven by communicative need is not fully explained. The Input Hypothesis claims comprehensible input is necessary and sufficient, but Swain's Output Hypothesis counters that production forces complete grammatical processing, driving SL syntax and morphology development. Interaction alters input through negotiation of meaning, making it more targeted to learner needs. CDS in L1 acquisition provides useful parallels β recasts offer negative evidence, but cross-cultural studies show finely tuned CDS is not universally necessary, challenging environmentalist claims. The key distinction is that input alone may support comprehension, but output and interaction are crucial for full syntactic development.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the functionalist view of interlanguage development, and why is the concept of "syntacticization" important?
- According to the Input Hypothesis, what is the only necessary condition for language learning to take place?
- How does the Output Hypothesis challenge the Input Hypothesis, and what evidence from immersion students supports it?
- What are four ways in which child-directed speech (CDS) might facilitate first language acquisition, according to Gallaway and Richard (1994)?
- What does cross-cultural research reveal about the universality of finely tuned CDS, and why does this challenge environmentalist explanations?