π Lecture 27 β MONOPOLY
π Overview: This lecture examines monopoly as the opposite extreme of perfect competition, where a single firm is the sole producer of a good with no close substitutes. It covers the characteristics, sources, pricing and output decisions, and social costs of monopoly, providing essential tools for understanding market power and its economic implications.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the definition and characteristics of monopoly markets, then explores four key sources of monopoly power. It details monopoly price and output decisions using the MR = MC rule, with separate analysis of short-run and long-run determination. The lecture concludes with a discussion of social costs of monopoly, including deadweight loss with a numerical example showing welfare calculations.
π Lecture Summary
CHARACTERISTICS OF MONOPOLY MARKETS
Monopoly exists when an individual producer has the ability to set market prices. Monopoly firms are price makers, not price takers. Key characteristics include a single seller, a unique product, blockaded entry and/or exit, imperfect dissemination of information, and opportunity for long-run economic profits. Classic examples include electricity utilities, gas, sanitary services, transportation and telecommunication services.
SOURCES OF MONOPOLY
Monopoly is the market organization where a single firm sells a product with no close substitutes. The monopolist represents the entire market and faces a negatively sloped demand curve. Unlike perfect competition, a monopolist can earn profits in the long run because entry is essentially blocked. There are four basic reasons for monopoly:
First, the firm may control the entire supply of raw materials required for production. Second, the firm may own a patent or copyright that prevents other firms from using a particular production process or producing the same product. For example, Xerox had a monopoly on copying machines and Polaroid on instant cameras. Patents are granted by the government β 17 years in the US and 20 years in Pakistan.
Third, economies of scale may operate over a sufficiently large range of outputs, leaving only one firm supplying the entire market. Such a firm is called a natural monopoly. Examples include public utilities (electrical, gas, water, local transportation and telecommunication companies). Having more than one firm would lead to duplication of supply lines and higher costs per unit. Fourth, a monopoly may be established by a government franchise, where the firm is the sole producer and distributor but is subjected to governmental regulation. Examples include the post office, railways, airlines, taxis, broadcasting, TV channels, and medical units.
MONOPOLY PRICE/OUTPUT DECISIONS
Under monopoly, the industry demand curve is identical to the firm demand curve. Both slope downward. The monopolist faces a downward-sloping demand curve and can set either price or quantity, but not both β given one, the other is determined along the demand curve.
MONOPOLY OUTPUT RULE
A monopoly uses the same profit-maximization rule as any other firm: produce at the output level where marginal revenue equals marginal cost (MR = MC). Because the demand (average revenue) curve is negatively sloped and declining, the marginal revenue curve must lie below it. When a monopoly equates MR and MC, it simultaneously determines the output level and market price.
π Definition β Marginal Revenue (MR): The additional revenue from selling one more unit of output.
π Formula: MR = MC β The profit-maximizing condition for a monopoly firm
MONOPOLY PRICING RULE
Given the level of output Q that maximizes profits, the monopoly price is the price on the demand curve corresponding to the Q units produced. Given a downward-sloping monopoly demand curve, price always exceeds marginal revenue under monopoly. This is because price is average revenue, and a downward-sloping demand curve requires that MR be less than AR. In competitive markets, P = MR = MC = AC in long-run equilibrium. In monopoly markets, profit-maximization requires MR = MC, but barriers to entry make above-normal profits possible, and P > AC in long-run equilibrium.
π Formula: p = p(Q) β The monopoly price is determined by the demand curve at the profit-maximizing quantity π Formula: P > MR = MC β Under monopoly, price exceeds both marginal revenue and marginal cost
SHORT-RUN PRICE AND OUTPUT DETERMINATION UNDER MONOPOLY
In Figure 1, D is the market demand curve faced by the monopolist, and MR is the corresponding marginal revenue curve. The profit-maximizing output level is Q = 500 units. At this level, AR = P = $11, AC = $8. The monopolist earns a profit of AF = $3 per unit and AFBC = $1,500 in total (shaded area in Figure 1). Since MR = MC = $6, P = AR > MR, so P > MC. As MC cuts MR from below β beyond point E, MC > MR and since P = AR > MR, P > MC.
A monopolist (like a perfect competitor) could also break even or incur losses in the short run, depending on the height of ATC at the best level of output. If ATC = P, the monopolist breaks even; if ATC > P, the monopolist incurs a loss. As in perfect competition, it pays for a monopolist to remain in business in the short run even with losses, as long as P > AVC.
Given the monopoly firm's total revenue and total cost functions: TR = 50Q β 0.00025QΒ² TC = 361,250 + 5Q + 0.0002QΒ²
Finding marginal revenue and marginal cost: MR = 50 β 0.0005Q MC = 5 + 0.0004Q
Setting MR = MC: 50 β 0.0005Q = 5 + 0.0004Q Q = 50,000 units
At Q = 50,000: P = $37.50, AC = $22.23
π Formula: Ο = (P β AC) Γ Q π Example: Ο = ($37.50 - $22.23) Γ 50,000 = $15.27 Γ 50,000 = $763,750 maximum economic profit
LONG-RUN PRICE AND OUTPUT DETERMINATION UNDER MONOPOLY
In the long run, all inputs and costs are variable, and the monopolist can construct the optimal scale of plant to produce the best level of output. The best level of output is given at the point where P = LMC, and the optimum scale of plant is the one with the SATC curve tangent to the LAC curve at the best level of output. Unlike perfect competition, entry is blocked under monopoly, so the monopolist can earn economic profits in the long run. Because of blocked entry, the monopolist is also not likely to produce at the lowest point on its LAC curve.
Figure 2 shows that the best level of output for the monopolist in the long run is 700 units (point E', where MR = LMC). At Q = 700, P = $9 (point A' on the D curve). The monopolist builds the optimum scale of plant given by the SATC curve tangent to the LAC curve at Q = 700 (point F'). Operating at Q = 700, the monopolist has SATC = LAC = $5 (point F'). The monopolist earns a long-run profit of A'F' = $4 per unit and A'F'B'C' = $2,800 in total (compared to $1,500 in the short run). Because entry is blocked, the monopolist continues to earn these profits as long as demand and cost conditions remain unchanged.
π‘ Why this matters: Unlike competitive firms that earn zero economic profit in the long run, monopolists can sustain above-normal profits indefinitely due to barriers to entry.
SOCIAL COSTS OF MONOPOLY
Monopolies have an incentive to underproduce and earn economic profits. Underproduction occurs when a monopoly curtails output to a level where the value of resources employed (measured by marginal cost) is less than the social benefit (measured by the price customers are willing to pay). Under monopoly, marginal cost is less than price at the profit-maximizing output level. While economic profits provide incentives and help allocate resources, it is difficult to justify above-normal profits resulting from market power rather than exceptional performance.
DEADWEIGHT LOSS FROM MONOPOLY
Monopoly markets create a loss in social welfare due to the decline in mutually beneficial trade activity. There is also a wealth transfer problem β consumer surplus is transferred to producer surplus, as shown in Figure 3.
π Definition β Deadweight Loss: The net loss in total surplus (consumer plus producer surplus) that results from monopoly pricing and output decisions, representing inefficiency in the market.
Given demand and supply functions: Qβ = -40 + 4p β p = 10 + 0.25Qβ Qα΄° = 170 - 2p β p = 85 β 0.5Qα΄°
Competitive Market Solution: Supply = Demand: -40 + 4p = 170 - 2p β 6p = 210 β p = $35/month 10 + 0.25Q = 85 β 0.5Q β 0.75Q = 75 β Q = 100 million customers
Monopoly Solution: MR = MC: 85 β Q = 10 + 0.25Q β 1.25Q = 75 β Q = 60 million At Q = 60: P = 85 β 0.5(60) = $55/month
π Deadweight Loss Calculation: Consumer Deadweight Loss (Area ABD) = Β½[(100 β 60) Γ (55 β 35)] = $400 million per month Producer Deadweight Loss (Area BCD) = Β½[(100 β 60) Γ (25 β 35)] = $200 million per month Total Deadweight Loss = $600 million per month Transfer to Producer Surplus (Rectangle) = 60 Γ (55 β 35) = $1,200 million per month
β Key Takeaways
The most critical lesson from this lecture is that monopolists maximize profits by producing where MR = MC, which results in a lower quantity and higher price than under perfect competition β creating deadweight loss and transferring consumer surplus to producer surplus. Unlike competitive firms, monopolies can sustain long-run economic profits due to barriers to entry, and they typically do not produce at the minimum point on their LAC curve. The four sources of monopoly β resource control, patents/copyrights, natural monopoly, and government franchise β explain how monopoly power arises in different contexts. Students must master the numerical calculations of optimal output, price, profit, and deadweight loss using the MR = MC framework with given TR and TC functions. Finally, remember that under monopoly, P > MR = MC, which is the fundamental distinction from perfect competition where P = MR = MC.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four basic sources of monopoly power, and how does each prevent entry by other firms?
- Why does a monopolist's marginal revenue curve lie below its demand curve, and how does this affect the relationship between price and marginal cost at the profit-maximizing output?
- Using the example from the lecture, calculate the profit-maximizing output given TR = 50Q β 0.00025QΒ² and TC = 361,250 + 5Q + 0.0002QΒ², and verify that profit equals $763,750.
- In the long-run monopoly analysis (Figure 2), why does the monopolist produce 700 units rather than expand output to the lowest point on the LAC curve?
- Calculate the total deadweight loss from monopoly using the numerical example where competitive equilibrium is Q=100, P=$35 and monopoly equilibrium is Q=60, P=$55 with MC curve p=10+0.25Q.
π Lecture 28 β MONOPOLY / MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
π Overview: This lecture explores the social costs and benefits of monopoly power, particularly through the lens of patents and natural monopolies. It then transitions to monopolistic competition, a market structure blending elements of both monopoly and perfect competition, covering its characteristics, price/output decisions, and long-run equilibrium outcomes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing the social cost of monopoly through patents, examining how patent exclusivity creates monopoly pricing and welfare loss, followed by the social benefits of monopoly including economies of scale and the natural monopoly dilemma. It then defines monopolistic competition, lists its key characteristics, and explains product differentiation and its relationship to demand elasticity. The lecture details short-run monopoly equilibrium and long-run equilibrium outcomes (high-price/low-output and low-price/high-output), providing numerical examples for each scenario.
π Lecture Summary
SOCIAL COST OF MONOPOLY
One major source of monopoly is the ownership of a patent or copyright that precludes other firms from using a particular production process or producing the same product. Intellectual Property (IP) is critical for a competitive economy in the context of ongoing globalization, as sustainable economic growth now depends largely on a hi-tech R&D base and efficient knowledge input. The new concept of an IP based nation is gaining ground because intellectual property enables technology creation and technology transfer. A patent for an invention is a grant of exclusive rights to make, use, and sell the invention for a limited period of 20 years, excluding others from making, using, or selling the invention.
In competitive markets, price and quantity that balance supply and demand also maximize total social welfare, measured by consumersβ surplus and producersβ surplus. For example, in drug markets, when a patent gives a firm a monopoly, the firm charges the monopoly price (point T in Figure 1), which is well above the marginal cost of making the drug. When the patent expires (point N), new firms enter, making the market more competitive, and the price falls from the monopoly price to marginal cost.
π‘ Why this matters: Patents provide temporary monopoly power that creates higher prices and reduced output compared to competitive markets, but they also incentivize innovation by allowing firms to recoup R&D investments.
SOCIAL BENEFITS OF MONOPOLY
In a natural monopoly, the LRAC (Long-Run Average Cost) declines continuously, meaning one firm is most efficient. Some real-world monopolies are government-created or government-maintained. This creates a dilemma of natural monopoly: monopoly has the potential for efficiency, but unregulated monopoly can lead to economic profits and underproduction.
Natural monopoly presents a dilemma: on one hand, economic efficiency could be enhanced by restricting the number of producers to a single firm. On the other hand, monopolies have an incentive to underproduce and generate unwarranted economic profits. A very large scale of operation is often required to produce most products efficiently, and this is possible only when a few firms operate. For example, economies of scale operate over such a large range of outputs that steel, aluminum, automobiles, mainframe computers, aircraft, and many other products can be produced efficiently only by very large firms. Figure 2 shows that without regulation, natural monopolies would charge quite high prices (Pβ) and produce too little output (OQ).
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION
Monopolistic competition is a market structure that lies between the extremes of monopoly and perfect competition. It is the partly competitive, partly monopolistic market structure faced by firms in the clothing, food, hotel, retailing, and consumer products industries. Given the lack of perfect substitutes, monopolistically competitive firms have some discretion in setting pricesβthey are not price takers. However, given fierce competition from imitators offering close but not identical substitutes, such firms enjoy only a normal rate of return on investment in long-run equilibrium.
Monopolistic competition is similar to perfect competition in that there is a large number of sellers. The major difference is that consumers perceive important differences among the products offered by monopolistically competitive firms, whereas the output of perfectly competitive firms is homogeneous. This gives monopolistically competitive firms at least some discretion in setting prices.
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION CHARACTERISTICS
- Many buyers and sellers
- Product heterogeneity
- Free entry and exit
- Perfect information
- Opportunity for normal profits in long-run equilibrium
Monopolistic competition is defined as the form of market organization in which there are many sellers of a differentiated product, and entry into and exit from the industry are rather easy in the long run. Differentiated products are those that are similar but not identical and satisfy the same basic need. Examples include numerous brands of breakfast cereals, toothpaste, cigarettes, detergents, cold medicines, and cosmetics. The differentiation may be real (e.g., different nutritional content) or imaginary (e.g., all aspirin brands contain the same basic ingredients).
As the name implies, monopolistic competition is a blend of competition and monopoly. The competitive element results from the fact that there are many sellers of the differentiated product, each too small to affect others. The monopoly element arises from product differentiationβthe product sold by each seller is somewhat different from any other seller's product. The resulting monopoly power is severely limited by the availability of many close substitutes.
Monopolistic competition is most common in the retail and service sectors. National-level examples include clothing, cotton textiles, bakers, and food processing. Local-level examples include fast-food outlets, shoe stores, gasoline stations, beauty salons, drugstores, video rental stores, and pizza parlors.
Since each firm sells a somewhat different product, we cannot derive a market demand curve and market supply curve as under perfect competition. Instead of a single equilibrium price, there is a cluster of prices. The analysis is restricted to the "typical" firm, assuming that all firms selling similar products face identical demand and cost curves.
π Definition β Product Differentiation: The process of distinguishing a product from competitors' offerings, creating imperfect substitutes and giving the firm some control over price. π‘ Why this matters: Product differentiation is the key feature that distinguishes monopolistic competition from perfect competition and gives firms pricing power.
RELATION BETWEEN PRODUCT DIFFERENTIATION AND ELASTICITY OF DEMAND
The effect of product differentiation is to create downward-sloping firm demand curves in monopolistically competitive markets. Unlike a price taker facing a perfectly horizontal demand curve, the firm can independently determine an optimal price/output combination. The degree of price flexibility depends on the strength of product differentiation. The more differentiated a firm's product, the lower the substitutability of other products for it. Strong differentiation results in greater consumer loyalty and greater control over price.
Figure 3 illustrates this with demand curves of firms A and B. Firm A's product is only slightly differentiated, making it close to being a price taker. Firm B has successfully differentiated its product, so consumers are less willing to accept substitutes, making firm B's demand relatively less sensitive to price changes. Weaker product differentiation implies high sensitivity to price changes.
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION PRICE/OUTPUT DECISIONS
Monopolistic competition combines elements of both monopoly and perfect competition. The monopoly aspect is most forcefully observed in the short run. With demand curve D1 and its related marginal revenue curve MR1, the optimum output Q1 is found where MR1 = MC. Short-run monopoly profits equal to the area P1LMAC1 are earned. Such profits can arise from new product introductions, product and process improvements, creative packaging and marketing, or an unexpected rise in demand.
Over time, short-run monopoly profits attract competition, and other firms enter the industry. This competitive aspect of monopolistic competition is seen most forcefully in the long run. As competitors emerge, the market share and profits of the initial innovating firm diminish. Firm demand and marginal revenue curves shift to the left (from D1 to D2 and MR1 to MR2 in Figure 4). Optimal long-run output occurs at Q2 where MR2 = MC. Because optimal price P2 equals ATC2, where cost includes a normal profit, economic profits are zero.
The price/output combination (P2Q2) describes a monopolistically competitive market equilibrium with high product differentiation. If new entrants offered perfect substitutes, each firm's long-run demand curve would become nearly horizontal, approaching perfectly competitive equilibrium (D3 with P3 and Q3). In most instances, competitor entry reduces but does not eliminate product differentiation, and an intermediate price/output solution is often achieved.
A firm will never operate at the minimum point on its average cost curve in monopolistically competitive equilibrium. Each firm's demand curve is downward sloping and tangent to the ATC curve at some point above minimum ATC. However, this does not mean a monopolistically competitive industry is inefficient. The downward-sloping demand curve implies consumers value an individual firm's products more highly than products of other producers. The higher prices and costs reflect the economic cost of product variety.
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION PROCESS
Short-run Monopoly Equilibrium:
- Monopolistically competitive firms take full advantage of short-run monopoly
- In short run: MR = MC, P > AC, and Ο > 0
Long-run High-price/Low-output Equilibrium:
- With differentiated products: MR = MC and P = AR = AC at a point above minimum LRAC
- No excess profits exist, so Ο = 0
Long-run Low-price/High-output Equilibrium:
- With homogenous products: MR = MC and P = AC at minimum LRAC
- No excess profits exist, so Ο = 0 (competitive market equilibrium)
SHORT-RUN MONOPOLY EQUILIBRIUM (EXAMPLE)
Given:
- TR = 20,000Q β 15.6QΒ²
- TC = 400,000 + 4,640Q + 10QΒ²
- MR = 20,000 β 31.2Q
- MC = 4,640 + 20Q
- P = AR = 20,000 β 15.6Q
π Formula β Profit Maximization Condition: MR = MC
π Formula: 20,000 β 31.2Q = 4,640 + 20Q β 51.2Q = 15,360 β Q = 300 units
π Example: P = 20,000 β 15.6(300) = $15,320 Ο = TR β TC = [20,000(300) β 15.6(300)Β²] β [400,000 + 4,640(300) + 10(300)Β²] = 6,000,000 β 1,404,000 β 400,000 β 1,392,000 β 900,000 = $1,904,000 (or $1.9 million)
Therefore, the financial planning committee should recommend a $15,320 price and 300-unit output level to maximize short-run profits.
LONG-RUN HIGH-PRICE/LOW-OUTPUT EQUILIBRIUM
AC = TC/Q = 400,000/Q + 4,640 + 10Q = 400,000Qβ»ΒΉ + 4,640 + 10Q Slope of AC curve: d(AC)/dQ = -400,000Qβ»Β² + 10 Slope of demand curve: -15.6 (same as original)
At tangency point: Slope of AC = Slope of Demand -400,000Qβ»Β² + 10 = -15.6 QΒ² = 400,000/25.6 Q = 125 units
P = AC = 400,000/125 + 4,640 + 10(125) = 3,200 + 4,640 + 1,250 = $9,090
Ο = P Γ Q β TC = 9,090(125) β 400,000 β 4,640(125) β 10(125)Β² = 1,136,250 β 400,000 β 580,000 β 156,250 = $0
π Key Insight: At long-run high-price equilibrium, price equals average cost, and economic profit is zero.
LONG-RUN LOW-PRICE/HIGH-OUTPUT EQUILIBRIUM
The low-price/high-output (perfectly competitive) equilibrium occurs where P = MR = MC = AC. This reflects a perfectly horizontal demand curve with minimized average costs.
π Formula β Minimum Average Cost Condition: MC = AC
π Formula: 4,640 + 20Q = 400,000Qβ»ΒΉ + 4,640 + 10Q 20Q β 10Q = 400,000Qβ»ΒΉ 10Q = 400,000/Q QΒ² = 40,000 Q = 200 units
P = AC = 400,000/200 + 4,640 + 10(200) = 2,000 + 4,640 + 2,000 = $8,640
Ο = P Γ Q β TC = 8,640(200) β 400,000 β 4,640(200) β 10(200)Β² = 1,728,000 β 400,000 β 928,000 β 400,000 = $0
π Example: Under this low-price equilibrium scenario, the ABC monopoly price falls from the original $15,320 to $8,640, and output changes from the monopoly level of 300 units to the competitive equilibrium level of 200 units per month. The company earns only a risk-adjusted normal rate of return.
Following the onset of competition, the firm XYZ will reduce its output from 300 units/month to a level between Q = 125 and Q = 200 units/month. The short-run profit-maximizing price of $15,320 will fall to a level between $9,090 (high-price/low-output equilibrium) and $8,640 (low-price/high-output equilibrium).
β Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that monopoly power, whether from patents or natural monopoly, creates a trade-off between higher prices/lower output and the incentive for innovation or efficiency from economies of scale. Monopolistic competition is characterized by many sellers with differentiated products, allowing short-run monopoly profits that erode to zero economic profit in the long run through free entry. The key distinction between the two long-run equilibria is product differentiation: high differentiation leads to higher prices and lower output (P=$9,090, Q=125) compared to the competitive low-differentiation equilibrium (P=$8,640, Q=200). A monopolistically competitive firm never operates at minimum average cost, and the higher costs reflect consumer willingness to pay for product variety. The short-run profit maximization rule (MR=MC) applies, with the numerical example showing that setting price at $15,320 and output at 300 units yields $1.9 million in short-run profits.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the social costs and benefits of monopoly, particularly regarding patents and natural monopolies?
- What are the five key characteristics of monopolistic competition, and how does product differentiation affect demand elasticity?
- In the short-run monopoly equilibrium example, what price and output level maximize profits, and what is the resulting profit amount?
- What are the two long-run equilibrium outcomes in monopolistic competition, and how do their price and output levels differ?
- Why does a monopolistically competitive firm never operate at the minimum point of its average cost curve, and what does this imply about efficiency?
π Lecture 29 β Oligopoly
π Overview: This lecture introduces oligopoly, a market structure characterized by few sellers and strategic interdependence among firms. It covers the basic features and sources of oligopoly, the role of strategic interdependence, and four key models of oligopoly behavior: Cournot, Bertrand, Stackelberg, and Sweezy (Kinked-Demand). Understanding oligopoly is crucial because managerial decision-making here is far more complex than in other market structures.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the basic characteristics and sources of oligopoly, including economies of scale, capital requirements, patents, brand loyalty, raw material control, and government franchises. It explains the role of strategic interdependence, where each firm's actions affect rivals' profits. It then details four profit-maximization models: Cournot (output-setting), Bertrand (price-setting), Stackelberg (leader-follower), and Sweezy (kinked-demand). The lecture also introduces the contestable market model.
π Lecture Summary
Oligopoly: Basic Characteristics and Sources
Oligopoly is a market structure with few sellers (usually less than 10) of a homogeneous or differentiated product. If there are only two sellers, it is a duopoly; if three, a triopoly. A pure oligopoly sells a homogeneous product, while a differentiated oligopoly sells a differentiated product.
Basic features include: few sellers, homogeneous or unique products, blockaded entry and exit, imperfect information dissemination, and opportunity for above-normal profits in the long run. Sources of oligopoly are similar to monopoly: economies of scale, huge capital investments, patents, brand loyalty, control of raw materials, and government franchises. A further barrier is limit pricing, where existing firms charge a low price to discourage entry, sacrificing short-run profits for long-run profits.
π‘ Why this matters: These barriers reinforce the "fewness" of firms, preventing the market from becoming more competitive in the long run.
Role of Strategic Interdependence
The distinguishing characteristic of oligopoly is interdependence or rivalry among firms. Each firm must consider the expected reaction of other firms when making decisions about pricing, product differentiation, advertising, and service. Because competitors can react in many ways, there is no single general model of oligopoly behavior; each model is based on a particular behavioral response.
Strategic interdependence means that rival firms are not in complete control of their own destiny.
Profit Maximization in Four Oligopoly Settings
The lecture introduces four oligopoly settings: 1. Cournot Model, 2. Bertrand Model, 3. Stackelberg Model, and 4. Sweezy (Kinked-Demand) Model.
Cournot Oligopoly Model: Oligopoly Output-Setting Models
Developed by Augustin Cournot in 1838, the Cournot model assumes firms produce homogeneous or imperfect substitutes, set output (not price), believe rivals will hold output constant, and face barriers to entry. Firms make simultaneous and independent output decisions.
An output-reaction curve shows the relationship between a firm's profit-maximizing output and its competitor's output. A firm's reaction function shows how its optimal output varies with each possible action by its rival.
Cournot equilibrium (also Nash Equilibrium) is where the two reaction curves intersect. Cournot equilibrium output exceeds monopoly output but is less than competitive output.
π Formula: Firm A's Reaction Curve: ( Q_A = 750 - 0.5Q_B )
π Example: Two-firm duopoly with demand ( P = 1600 - Q ), where ( Q = Q_A + Q_B ), and ( MC_A = MC_B = $100 ).
- Firm A's ( MR_A = 1600 - 2Q_A - Q_B ). Setting ( MR_A = MC ) gives ( Q_A = 750 - 0.5Q_B ) (Reaction Curve for A).
- Firm B's Reaction Curve: ( Q_B = 750 - 0.5Q_A ).
- Solving simultaneously: ( Q_A = Q_B = 500 ) units.
- Cournot equilibrium output: ( Q = 1000 ) units.
- Cournot equilibrium price: ( P = 1600 - 1000 = $600 ).
- Profit for each firm: ( \pi = ($600 \times 500) - ($100 \times 500) = $250,000 ).
- Comparison: Under perfect competition, ( P = MC = $100 ), so ( Q = 1500 ) units. Under monopoly, ( MR = 1600 - 2Q ), setting ( MR = MC ) gives ( Q = 750 ) units, ( P = $850 ), and ( \pi = $562,500 ).
π‘ Why this matters: The Cournot outcome lies between the competitive and monopoly outcomes, showing that oligopoly firms have some market power but not as much as a monopolist.
Bertrand Model: Oligopoly Price-Setting Models
Presented by Joseph Bertrand in 1883, the Bertrand model focuses on price reactions. For identical products, Bertrand predicts a competitive market price/output solution (price = marginal cost). For differentiated products, it shows how price-setting oligopolies can profit.
Basic features: few firms selling to many consumers, identical products at constant marginal cost, each firm independently sets price, barriers to entry, consumers have perfect information and zero transaction costs.
Bertrand equilibrium occurs when firms set ( P_1 = P_2 = MC ). If one firm sets a price above MC, the other has an incentive to slightly undercut, capturing the entire market. This undercutting continues until both charge MC. The relationship between profit-maximizing price and competitor price is called the oligopoly price-reaction curve.
From the manager's viewpoint, the Bertrand model is undesirable (zero economic profit). From the consumer's viewpoint, it is desirable (competitive outcome).
π Formula: Firm A's Price-Reaction Curve: ( P_A = 15 - 0.25P_B )
π Example: Two-firm duopoly with differentiated products. Firm A demand: ( Q_A = 60 - 2P_A + P_B ). Firm B demand: ( Q_B = 60 - 2P_B + P_A ). ( MC_A = MC_B = 0 ).
- Firm A's profit: ( \pi_A = 60P_A - 2P_A^2 + P_A P_B ). Setting ( \partial \pi_A / \partial P_A = 0 ) gives ( P_A = 15 - 0.25P_B ) (Price-Reaction Curve for A).
- Firm B's Price-Reaction Curve: ( P_B = 15 - 0.25P_A ).
- Solving simultaneously: ( P_A = P_B = $20 ).
- Each firm's output: ( Q_A = 60 - 2(20) + 20 = 40 ) units. Revenue (and profit) for each: ( $20 \times 40 = $800,000 ).
- Comparison: Under monopoly, ( P = $30 ), ( Q = 30,000 ) units, and profit = ( $900,000 ).
π‘ Why this matters: The Bertrand model shows that price competition is "tougher" than quantity competition, leading to lower profits than in the Cournot model.
The Contestable Market Model
According to the contestable market model, barriers to entry and exit determine a firm's price and output decisions. Even if an industry has only one firm, it could be competitive if entry is open. The stronger the ability to collude and prevent entry, the closer it is to monopoly; the weaker the ability, the more competitive it is.
A market is contestable if entry is "absolutely free" (new firms face same costs) and exit is "entirely costless" (no sunk costs). An example is an airline starting a new route and leaving without capital loss. In a contestable market, firms operate as if perfectly competitive, selling at a price covering average costs and earning zero economic profit.
Key assumptions: producers have same technology, consumers respond quickly, existing firms cannot quickly lower price, and no sunk costs. Key implication: the threat of entry disciplines incumbent firms, giving them no market power.
β Key Takeaways
The key feature of oligopoly is strategic interdependence: each firm's decisions significantly impact its rivals, requiring firms to anticipate reactions. There is no single model of oligopoly; instead, different models (Cournot, Bertrand, etc.) are based on different assumptions about firm behavior (output vs. price competition). In the Cournot (output-setting) model, equilibrium lies between competitive and monopoly outcomes, while in the Bertrand (price-setting) model with identical products, the outcome is perfectly competitive (price = MC). The contestable market model emphasizes that even a monopolist can behave competitively if entry and exit are free, highlighting the power of potential competition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the distinguishing characteristic of oligopoly that makes decision-making more complex than in other market structures?
- What are the key differences between the Cournot and Bertrand models in terms of the decision variable (price vs. output) and the resulting equilibrium price?
- In a Cournot duopoly with demand ( P = 1600 - Q ) and ( MC = $100 ), what is the Cournot equilibrium price and output?
- In the Bertrand model with identical products, why do firms end up charging a price equal to marginal cost?
- According to the contestable market model, what two conditions are necessary for a market to be contestable, and what is the key implication for incumbent firms?