π Lecture 23 β Linear Programming (Continued 1)
π Overview: This lecture continues the study of linear programming by focusing on graphic specification and solution methods. It demonstrates how to solve a profit maximization problem graphically by identifying the feasible region, isoprofit lines, and the optimal corner point, and extends these concepts to cost minimization problems and special cases.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the graphic specification and solution of linear programming (LP) models, including graphing the feasible space defined by inequality constraints, graphing the objective function as isoprofit lines, and finding the optimal solution at a corner point. It then presents the algebraic solution using slack and surplus variables, followed by graphic and algebraic solutions for cost minimization problems. The lecture concludes with a discussion of special cases: multiple optimal solutions, infeasible solutions, and unbounded solutions.
π Lecture Summary
Analytic Expression
The decision problem is to maximize total profit contribution, Ο, subject to resource constraints. For our example, the objective function and constraints are expressed as:
(1) Maximize Ο = $12QX + $9QY Subject to: (2) Input A: 4QX + 2QY β€ 32 (3) Input B: 1QX + 1QY β€ 10 (4) Input C: 3QY β€ 21 Where QX β₯ 0 and QY β₯ 0.
Graphical Solution of Linear Programming Models
Graphical solution is limited to LP models containing only two decision variables (can be used with three variables only with great difficulty). Graphical methods provide visualization of how a solution for an LP problem is obtained. The steps followed are: express the objective function as an equation and constraints as inequalities; graph the inequality constraints as equations; identify the feasible solution space where all constraints are satisfied simultaneously; graph the objective function as a series of isoprofit or isocost lines; and find the optimal solution at the extreme point or corner of the feasible region that touches the highest isoprofit line (for maximization) or the lowest isocost line (for minimization).
Graphing the Feasible Space
A solution is called feasible when it satisfies all constraints. The non-negativity constraints are shown by the positive quadrant. The complete determination of the feasible region requires determining the boundaries set by the technical (functional) constraints. The inequality sign indicates the firm can use up to, but no more than, the available units of an input.
The constraint equation for input A (4QX + 2QY = 32) divides the XY plane into two half-spaces. Every point lying on the line or to the left of the line satisfies the constraint (4QX + 2QY β€ 32); every point to the right violates it. Adding constraints for inputs B (QX + QY = 10) and C (QY = 7) further limits the feasible space. Because C is used only in Y production, it does not constrain X. Together with the non-negativity requirement, these three constraints completely define the feasible space (the shaded area where all constraints are met simultaneously).
Graphing the Objective Function
The objective function (Ο = $12QX + $9QY) is graphed as a series of isoprofit curves. The slope of the objective function is determined by the coefficients of the two variables. All isoprofit curves are a series of parallel lines that take on higher values as one moves upward and to the right. The general formula for isoprofit curves, solving for QY, is: QY = Ο/b β a/b QX, where a and b are profit contributions of X and Y. The slope is βa/b. In our example, the slope is β12/9 = β4/3, or β1.33.
π Definition β Isoprofit Curve: A line representing all combinations of two products that yield the same total profit contribution. π Formula: QY = Ο/b β a/b QX β The intercept is total profit divided by profit per unit of Y; the slope is the negative ratio of the profit contributions of X and Y.
Graphic Solution of a Maximization Problem
The firm should operate on the highest isoprofit curve obtainable. Point M in Figure 3 is the optimal solution, where the firm produces 6 units of X and 4 units of Y, yielding a total profit of $108. At point M, constraints on inputs A and B are binding (fully utilized), while input C is nonbinding (slack). The optimal solution to any linear programming problem always lies at a corner point of the feasible space.
π Example: At M, equations 4QX + 2QY = 32 and QX + QY = 10 are solved simultaneously. Subtracting 2 times the second equation from the first gives 2QX = 12, so QX = 6. Substituting 6 for QX in QX + QY = 10 gives QY = 4. The total profit is 12(6) + 9(4) = $108.
Algebraic Solution of the Profit Maximization Problem
Slack variables convert β€ constraints into equalities. A slack variable represents unused resources and contributes nothing to the objective function. Zero slack implies full utilization (binding constraint); positive slack implies excess capacity. For our problem, three slack variables (SA, SB, SC) are added. The complete specification is:
Maximize Ο = $12QX + $9QY + 0SA + 0SB + 0SC Subject to: 4QX + 2QY + SA = 32; 1QX + 1QY + SB = 10; 3QY + SC = 21; all variables β₯ 0.
By substituting the values of QX and QY at each corner of the feasible region into the objective function, we can determine profit at each corner. The optimal (profit-maximizing) point is at corner M with Ο = $108.
π Definition β Corner Point Property: The optimal solution to an LP problem will always occur at a corner point of the feasible region, formed by the intersection of two constraint lines.
Graphic Solution of the Cost Minimization Problem
For a cost minimization problem, each inequality constraint is expressed as βequal to or greater than.β All points on or above the constraint line satisfy the inequality. The feasible region is the area above all constraint lines. The objective function is minimized by superimposing the lowest isocost line on the feasible region.
π Definition β Isocost Line: A line representing all combinations of two inputs that result in the same total cost.
Algebraic Solution of the Cost Minimization Problem
The cost minimization problem can also be solved algebraically by identifying the corners of the feasible region and comparing costs. A surplus variable is subtracted from β₯ constraints to convert them to equations. A surplus variable represents an excess above a constraint requirement level and contributes nothing to the objective function.
For the example problem: Minimize Z = $6xβ + 3xβ, subject to 2xβ + 4xβ β₯ 16 (nitrogen) and 4xβ + 3xβ β₯ 24 (phosphate), with xβ, xβ β₯ 0. Adding surplus variables: 2xβ + 4xβ - sβ = 16; 4xβ + 3xβ - sβ = 24. The corner points are A (0,8) with Z = $24, B (4.8, 1.6) with Z = $33.6, and C (8,0) with Z = $48. The optimal (cost-minimizing) solution is at point A with Z = $24.
π Definition β Surplus Variable: A variable subtracted from a βgreater than or equal toβ constraint to convert it to an equation; it represents the amount by which the optimal solution exceeds the minimum requirement.
Special Cases or Irregular Types of Linear Programming Problems
Three special types of LP problems exist: Multiple optimal solutions occur when the objective function is parallel to a constraint line (they have the same slope), causing the isoprofit or isocost line to be located along a line segment of the feasible region. An infeasible problem has no feasible region because every possible solution violates at least one constraint, typically due to conflicting constraints. An unbounded problem has an objective function that increases (maximization) or decreases (minimization) indefinitely, meaning the LP model does not have a finite solution.
π‘ Why this matters: Recognizing these special cases is critical for interpreting LP solutions correctly. A computer output might show βunboundedβ or βinfeasible,β and the manager must understand what this means for the decision model.
β Key Takeaways
For profit maximization, the optimal solution is found at the corner point of the feasible region where the highest isoprofit line touches the boundary. For cost minimization, the optimal solution is at the corner where the lowest isocost line touches the boundary. Slack variables convert ββ€β constraints into equalities and represent unused resources, while surplus variables convert ββ₯β constraints into equalities and represent excess capacity. Binding constraints have zero slack, and nonbinding constraints have positive slack. Special cases like multiple optimal solutions, infeasible solutions, and unbounded solutions can occur and must be identified for correct interpretation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five steps for solving a linear programming problem graphically?
- In the profit maximization example, why does the optimal solution occur at the intersection of constraints A and B but not C?
- What is the difference between a slack variable and a surplus variable, and when is each used?
- What does the Corner Point Property state, and why is it important for solving LP problems?
- What three special cases can occur in linear programming, and what causes each?
π Lecture 24 β Linear Programming (Continued 2)
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of duality in linear programming, where every primal problem has a corresponding dual problem. It explains shadow prices, which represent the marginal value of resources, and demonstrates how solving the dual provides insights into resource allocation and optimal decision-making for managers.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the duality concept and shadow prices, the meaning of dual and shadow prices, dual specification and solution, rules for transforming primal to obtain the dual, duality theorems including complementary slackness, advantages of the dual, solving the dual of profit maximization with algebraic and corner point methods, using the dual solution to solve the primal, and duality properties.
π Lecture Summary
DUAL IN LINEAR PROGRAMMING (LP) β DUALITY CONCEPT
Pairs of symmetrical LP problems are called the primal and the dual. Every primal has a dual and vice versa, and their solutions are related. Shadow prices represent the change to the objective function value per unit increase to a right-hand side of a constraint, assuming no other changes to input parameters. That is, Change in objective value = [Shadow price][Change in the right hand side value]. Managers are interested in knowing if it is worthwhile to increase production by purchasing additional units of raw materials or expanding production facilities.
π‘ Why this matters: Shadow prices help managers determine the true economic value of additional resources.
THE MEANING OF DUAL AND SHADOW PRICES
Every linear programming problem, called the primal problem, has a corresponding symmetrical problem called the dual problem. A profit maximization primal problem has a cost minimization dual problem, while a cost minimization primal problem has a profit maximization dual problem. The solutions of a dual problem are the shadow prices, which give the change in the value of the objective function per unit change in each constraint in the primal problem.
For example, the shadow prices in a profit maximization problem indicate how much total profits would rise per unit increase in the use of each input. Shadow prices thus provide the imputed value or marginal valuation of each input to the firm. If a particular input is not fully employed, its shadow price is zero because increasing the input would leave profits unchanged and its slack variable > 0 (unused resource in a maximization problem). A firm should increase the use of the input as long as the marginal value or shadow price of the input exceeds the cost of hiring it.
π Definition β Shadow Price: The change in the objective function value per unit increase in the right-hand side of a constraint, representing the imputed value or marginal worth of each input.
DUAL SPECIFICATION AND SOLUTION
- Dual Objective Function: Dual of profit maximization problem seeks minimum cost solution given constraints. Dual of minimum cost problem seeks highest production value given resource constraints.
- Dual Constraints: Binding constraints imply no slack. Nonbinding constraints imply slack.
- Dual Slack Variables: Binding constraints imply zero slack variable values. Nonbinding constraints imply nonzero slack variables.
RULES OF TRANSFORMING PRIMAL TO OBTAIN THE DUAL
- The direction of optimization is reversed.
- The inequality sign of the constraints are reversed, but the non-negativity restraint on decision variables is always maintained.
- The rows of the coefficient matrix of the constraints in the primal are transposed into columns for the coefficient matrix of constraints in the dual.
- The row vector of coefficients in the objective function in the primal is transposed into a column vector of constants in the dual. This means the number of choice variables in a Primal = the number of constraints in the Dual.
- The column vector of constants from the primal constraints is transposed into a row vector of coefficients for the objective function in the dual.
- Primal decision variables (xj) are replaced by dual decision variables (yi).
Primal β Dual Transformation:
| Primal | Dual |
|---|---|
| Maximize: Ο = cβxβ + cβxβ + cβxβ | Minimize: C = rβyβ + rβyβ |
| Subject to: | Subject to: |
| aββxβ + aββxβ + aββxβ β€ rβ | aββyβ + aββyβ β₯ cβ |
| aββxβ + aββxβ + aββxβ β€ rβ | aββyβ + aββyβ β₯ cβ |
| aββyβ + aββyβ β₯ cβ | |
| xβ β₯ 0, xβ β₯ 0, xβ β₯ 0 | yβ β₯ 0, yβ β₯ 0 |
DUALITY THEOREMS
DUALITY THEOREM I a) The optimal values of the primal and the dual objective functions are always identical, provided that optimal feasible solutions do exist. b) The maximum value of the primal (profit max problem) equals the minimum value of the dual (cost minimization) problem.
DUALITY THEOREM II (COMPLEMENTARY SLACKNESS) a) If a certain choice variable in a LP is optimally nonzero, then the corresponding dummy variable in the counterpart program must be optimally zero. Yi > 0 β Si = 0 and Xj > 0 β tj = 0 b) If a certain dummy variable in a LP is optimally nonzero, then the corresponding choice variable in the counterpart program must be optimally zero. Si > 0 β Yi = 0 and tj > 0 β Xj = 0
ADVANTAGES OF THE DUAL
From the Duality theorems, the solution of one program provides full solution to the other. This is beneficial because:
- It enables us to solve Minimization problems in terms of Maximization, which is frequently easier to solve.
- For a primal with 3 decision variables, the dual reduces the program to 2 decision variables, which can be solved graphically.
THE DUAL OF PROFIT MAXIMIZATION
We formulate and solve the dual problem for the constrained profit maximization problem. In the dual problem we seek to minimize the imputed values, or shadow prices, of inputs A, B, and C. Defining VA, VB, and VC as the shadow prices of inputs A, B, and C, respectively, and C as the total imputed value, the dual objective function is:
Minimize C = 32VA + 10VB + 21VC
Where the coefficients 32, 10, and 21 represent the fixed quantities of inputs A, B, and C available. The constraints assume that the sum of the shadow price of each input times the amount used to produce 1 unit of a product must be equal to or larger than the profit contribution of a unit of that product.
Primal: Maximize: Ο = 12X + 9Y Subject to: A: 4X + 2Y β€ 32 B: X + Y β€ 10 C: 3Y β€ 21 X β₯ 0, Y β₯ 0
Dual: Minimize C = 32VA + 10VB + 21VC Subject to: A: 4VA + VB β₯ 12 B: 2VA + VB + 3VC β₯ 9 VA β₯ 0, VB β₯ 0, VC β₯ 0
Since we have three decision variables requiring a three-dimensional figure, we solve algebraically. From the primal solution, input C is a slack variable so VC = 0. Setting VC = 0 and subtracting constraints:
4VA + VB = 12 Minus 2VA + VB = 9
So: 2VA = 3 or VA = $1.5, VB = $6 and VC = $0
C = 32(1.5) + 10(6) + 21(0) = $108
This minimum cost equals the maximum profit from the primal ($108), as required by Duality Theorem I. Substituting VA = 1.5, VB = 6, VC = 0: 4(1.5) + 6 + SA = 12 β SA = 0 2(1.5) + 6 + 3(0) + SB = 9 β SB = 0
Both constraints are binding and fully utilized.
π Formula β Duality Theorem I: Max Ο (Primal) = Min C (Dual)
π Example:
- Primal: Maximize Ο = 12X + 9Y subject to constraints
- Dual: Minimize C = 32VA + 10VB + 21VC
- Solution: VA = $1.5, VB = $6, VC = $0
- C = 32(1.5) + 10(6) + 21(0) = $108 = Maximum profit from primal
CORNER POINT SOLUTION OF THE DUAL PROBLEM
Table 1 β Corner Point Solutions
| Point | VA | VB | VC | tβ | tβ | Imputed Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | -12 | -9 | --- |
| 2 | 0 | 12 | 0 | 0 | 3 | $120 |
| 3 | 4.5 | 0 | 0 | 6 | 0 | $144 |
| 4 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | $117 |
| 5 | 1.5 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 0 | $108 |
USING THE DUAL SOLUTION TO SOLVE THE PRIMAL
Maximize: Ο = 12X + 9Y + 0SA + 0SB + 0SC Subject to: Input A: 4X + 2Y + SA = 32 Input B: X + Y + SB = 10 Input C: 3Y + SC = 21 Where X, Y, SA, SB, SA β₯ 0
4X + 2Y = 32 Minus 2(X + Y = 10) So: 2X = 12, X = 6 and Y = 4
Ο = 12(6) + 9(4) = $108 3(4) + SC = 21 SC = 21 - 12 = 9
The same optimal values for decision variables, slack variables and objective function are obtained.
DUALITY PROPERTIES
Some relationships between the primal and dual problems:
- If one problem has feasible solutions and a bounded objective function (and so has an optimal solution), then so does the other problem, so both the weak and the strong duality properties are applicable.
- If the optimal value of the primal is unbounded, then the dual is infeasible.
- If the optimal value of the dual is unbounded, then the primal is infeasible.
β Key Takeaways
The dual problem transforms a maximization primal into a minimization dual, with shadow prices representing the marginal value of each resource. The key duality theorem states that the optimal objective function values of the primal and dual are always equal. Complementary slackness links binding constraints and nonzero decision variables across problems. Solving the dual is advantageous because it may simplify computation (e.g., reducing 3 variables to 2) and because it provides shadow prices that guide managerial decisions on resource acquisition (increase use when shadow price exceeds hiring cost). Slack resources always have zero shadow prices.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is a shadow price and how is it interpreted in a profit maximization problem?
- State Duality Theorem I β what relationship does it establish between primal and dual optimal values?
- According to the rules of transformation, what happens to the direction of optimization and inequality signs when converting a primal to a dual?
- If a slack variable is nonzero in the primal, what does this imply about the corresponding shadow price in the dual?
- In the dual profit minimization example, why was VC set to zero, and what did this imply about input C in the primal?
π Lecture 25 β COMPETITIVE MARKETS
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of market structure and its impact on firm behavior and pricing decisions. It examines four primary market structuresβperfect competition, monopoly, monopolistic competition, and oligopolyβwith a detailed focus on the characteristics and profit-maximizing behavior of firms in perfectly competitive markets.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and components of market structure, including the role of potential entrants and factors shaping the competitive environment such as product characteristics, entry/exit conditions, and product differentiation. It then describes the four main market structures and provides an in-depth analysis of perfect competition, including price determination, profit maximization, and short-run analysis using marginal revenue-marginal cost approaches.
π Lecture Summary
A MARKET
A market consists of all firms and individuals willing and able to buy or sell a particular product.
MARKET STRUCTURE
Market structure describes the competitive environment in the market for any good or service. Market structure refers to the competitive environment in which the buyers and sellers of the product operate. Market structure is typically characterized on the basis of four important industry characteristics:
- The number and size distribution of active buyers and sellers and potential entrants
- The degree of product differentiation
- The amount and cost of information about product price and quality
- Conditions of entry and exit
Effects of market structure are measured in terms of the prices paid by consumers, availability and quality of output. In general, the greater the number of market participants, the more vigorous is price and product quality competition. The more even the balance of power between sellers and buyers, the more likely it is that the competitive process will yield maximum benefits.
POTENTIAL ENTRANT
A potential entrant is an individual or firm posing a sufficiently credible threat of market entry to affect the price/output decisions of incumbent firms. Potential entrants play extremely important roles in many industries. Some industries with only a few active participants might at first appear to hold the potential for substantial economic profits. However, a number of potential entrants can have a substantial effect on the price/output decisions of incumbent firms. For example, Dell, Gateway, Hewlett-Packard, IBM, and other leading computer manufacturers are viable potential entrants into the computer component manufacturing industry. These companies use their threat of potential entry to obtain favorable prices from suppliers of microprocessors, monitors, and peripheral equipment.
FACTORS THAT SHAPE THE COMPETITIVE ENVIRONMENT
Effect of Product Characteristics on Market Structure: Transportation service is available from several sources; railroads compete with bus lines, truck companies, airlines, and private autos. The substitutability of these other modes of transportation for rail service increases the degree of competition in the transportation service market. Good substitutes always increase competition.
EFFECT OF ENTRY AND EXIT CONDITIONS ON COMPETITION
In order to maintain above-normal profits over the long run requires barriers to entry, mobility, or exit. A barrier to entry is any factor that creates an advantage for existing firms over new arrivals. Legal rights such as patents and provincial or federal licenses can present substantial barriers to entry in beverages, pharmaceuticals, cable television, television and radio broadcasting, and other industries.
A barrier to mobility is any factor that creates an advantage for large leading firms over smaller non-leading rivals. Factors that sometimes create barriers to entry and/or mobility include substantial economies of scale, scope economies, large capital or skilled-labor requirements, and ties of customer loyalty.
A barrier to exit is any restriction on the ability of incumbents to redeploy assets from one industry or line of business to another. Competitive forces can also be diminished through barriers to exit just as barriers to entry could.
EFFECT OF PRODUCT DIFFERENTIATION ON COMPETITION
Product differentiation includes any real or perceived differences in the quality of goods and services offered to consumers. Sources of product differentiation include all of the various forms of advertising promotion, plus new products and processes made possible by effective programs of research and developmentβthat is, innovation.
In short, market structure is broadly determined by entry and exit conditions. Low regulatory barriers, modest capital requirements, and nominal standards for skilled labor and other inputs all increase the likelihood that competition will be vigorous. Because all of these elements of market structure have important consequences for the price/output decisions made by firms, the study of market structure is an important ingredient of managerial economics.
MARKET STRUCTURE AND DEGREE OF COMPETITION
Market structure refers to the competitive environment in which the buyers and sellers of the product operate. Four types of market structure are usually identified. These are perfect competition at one extreme, pure monopoly at the opposite extreme, and monopolistic competition and oligopoly in between.
PERFECT COMPETITION (NO MARKET POWER):
- Many buyers and sellers
- Buyers and sellers are price takers
- Product is homogeneous
- Very easy market entry and exit
- Non-price competition not possible
- Perfect mobility of resources
- Economic agents have perfect knowledge
Examples: Stock Market, agricultural products, financial instruments, precious metals, petroleum products, prominent markets for intermediate goods and services (e.g., discount retailing, unskilled labor market)
MONOPOLY (ABSOLUTE MARKET POWER SUBJECT TO GOVERNMENT REGULATION):
- One firm, firm is the industry
- No close substitutes for product
- Significant barriers to resource mobility
- Market entry and exit difficult or legally impossible
- Non-price competition not necessary
Examples: pharmaceuticals, Microsoft, Government franchise (Post Office, Water Supply, Energy, National Airlines)
MONOPOLISTIC COMPETITION (MARKET POWER BASED ON DIFFERENTIATED PRODUCTS):
- Many sellers and buyers (large number of relatively small firms acting independently)
- Differentiated product
- Market entry and exit relatively easy
- Non-price competition is very important
- Perfect mobility of resources
Examples: Fast-food outlets, boutiques, restaurants
OLIGOPOLY (MARKET POWER BASED ON PRODUCT DIFFERENTIATION AND/OR THE FIRM'S DOMINANCE IN THE MARKET):
- Few sellers and many buyers (small number of relatively large firms)
- Product may be homogeneous or differentiated
- Market entry and exit difficult
- Non-price competition is very important among firms selling differentiated products
- Barriers to resource mobility
Examples: Automobile manufacturers, oil refining, processed foods, airlines
π Definition β Perfect Competition: A market structure where individual producers have no influence on market prices; they are price takers as opposed to price makers. π‘ Why this matters: Perfect competition serves as the benchmark model for analyzing market efficiency and firm behavior.
CHARACTERISTICS OF PERFECTLY COMPETITIVE MARKETS
Perfect competition exists when individual producers have no influence on market prices; they are price takers as opposed to price makers. This lack of influence on price typically requires:
- Large numbers of buyers and sellers: Each firm produces a small portion of industry output, and each customer buys only a small part of the total.
- Product homogeneity: The output of each firm is essentially the same as the output of any other firm in the industry.
- Free entry and exit: Firms are not restricted from entering or leaving the industry.
- Perfect dissemination of information: Cost, price, and product quality information is known by all buyers and all sellers.
- Opportunity for normal profit in long-run equilibrium: Fierce price competition keeps P = MC and P = AR = AC.
- Non-price competition not possible.
There is a great number of buyers and sellers of the product, and each seller and buyer is too small in relation to the market to be able to affect the price of the product. This means that a change in the output of a single firm will not affect the market price of the product. Similarly, each buyer of the product is too small to be able to extract from the seller such things as quantity discounts and special credit terms.
The product of each competitive firm is homogeneous, identical, or perfectly standardized. An example of this might be grading of wheat and cotton crops. As a result, buyers cannot distinguish between the output of one firm and the output of another, so they are indifferent from which firm they buy the product.
Under perfect competition, there is perfect mobility of resources. That is, workers and other inputs can easily move geographically from one job to another and can respond quickly to monetary incentives. There are no patents or copyrights, "vast amounts" of capital are not necessary to enter the market, and already established firms do not have any lasting cost advantage over new entrants because of experience or size.
Finally, under perfect competition, consumers, resource owners, and firms in the market have perfect knowledge as to present and future prices, costs, and economic opportunities in general. Thus, consumers will not pay a higher price than necessary for the product. Price differences are quickly eliminated, and a single price will prevail throughout the market for the product.
Perfect competition, as defined above, has never really existed. Perhaps the closest we might come today to a perfectly competitive market is the stock market. Another example is the market for such agricultural commodities as wheat, cotton, and corn. The natural gas industry and the trucking industries also approach perfect competition. In the milk market, each dairy farmer produces milk that is essentially identical to that offered by other dairy farmers. Similarly, each milk buyer purchases a small portion of aggregate production, so that he does not receive a cut-rate or volume discount. Because both buyers and sellers can trade as much milk as they want at the going price, both are price-takers and the milk market is said to be perfectly competitive.
The fact that perfect competition in its pure form has never really existed in the real world does not reduce the usefulness of the perfectly competitive model. A theory must be accepted or rejected on the basis of its ability to explain and to predict correctly and not on the realism of its assumptions. The perfectly competitive model does give us some useful explanations and predictions of many real-world economic phenomena when the assumptions of the perfectly competitive model are only approximately satisfied.
PRICE DETERMINATION UNDER PERFECT COMPETITION
In Figure 1, the total cost and total revenue curves of a perfectly competitive firm are shown. The TR curve is a straight line through the origin showing that price is constant at all levels of output. The firm is a price taker and can sell any amount of output at the given market price, with its TR increasing proportionately with its sales. The slope of the TR curve is the MR. It is constant and equal to the prevailing market price, since all units are sold at the same price. Thus P = MR = AR. The shape of the TC curve reflects the U shape of the AC and MC curves. The firm maximizes its profit at Q = 50,000 units, where the distance between the TR and TC is the greatest.
[Figure 1 not reproduced here - shows TR and TC curves with profit maximization at Q=50,000]
The TR-TC approach is awkward to use when firms are combined together in the study of the industry. The alternative approach based on marginal cost-marginal revenue uses price as an explicit variable and shows clearly that the behavioral rule leads to profit maximization. Under perfect competition, the price of a product is determined at the intersection of the market demand curve and the market supply curve of the product.
Given that the market price of a product is determined at the intersection of the market demand and supply curves, the perfectly competitive firm is a price taker. The perfectly competitive firm takes the price of the product as given and has no perceptible effect on that price by varying its own level of output and sales. Since the products of all firms are homogeneous, a firm cannot sell at a price higher than the market price; otherwise, the firm would lose all its customers. On the other hand, there is no reason for the firm to sell at a price below the market price, since it can sell any quantity at the given market price. As a result, the firm faces a horizontal or infinitely elastic demand curve for the product at the market price determined at the intersection of the market demand and supply curves. For example, a small wheat farmer can sell any amount of wheat at the given market price of wheat.
[Figure 2 not reproduced here - shows market equilibrium and the firm's horizontal demand curve]
Role of Marginal Analysis:
- Set MΟ = MR β MC = 0 to maximize profits
- MR = MC when profits are maximized
Normal Profit Equilibrium:
- There are no economic profits in competitive equilibrium; firms earn a normal rate of return
- With a horizontal market demand curve, MR = P, so P = MR = MC = ATC
Given the equilibrium price of P = $45, a perfectly competitive firm faces the horizontal or infinitely elastic demand curve shown by d at P = $45. The perfectly competitive firm only determines what quantity of the product to produce at P = $45 in order to maximize its total profits. When the product price is constant, the change in the total revenue per unit change in output or marginal revenue (MR) is also constant and is equal to the product price. That is, for a perfectly competitive firm, P = MR.
The equilibrium price and quantity can be determined algebraically by setting the market demand and supply functions equal to each other and solving for the equilibrium price. Substituting the equilibrium price into the demand or supply functions and solving for Q, we get the equilibrium quantity.
π Formula β Market Equilibrium: QD = QS
π Example: For the product in Figure 2: QD = 625 β 5P QS = 175 + 5P
Setting QD = QS: 625 β 5P = 175 + 5P 450 = 10P P = $45
Substituting P = $45 into the demand function: QD = 625 β 5(45) = 625 β 225 = 400 units
PROFIT MAXIMIZATION WITH CALCULUS
Ο = TR β TC dΟ/dQ = dTR/dQ - dTC/dQ = 0 so that dTR/dQ = dTC/dQ
Since dTR/dQ = MR and dTC/dQ = MC, the above condition becomes MR = MC. But under perfect competition, the price is given to the firm and is constant.
Therefore: dTR/dQ = d(PQ)/dQ = P = MR
π Formula β First-Order Condition (FOC) for Profit Maximization under Perfect Competition: P = MR = MC
(The Product Rule of differentiation will not apply as under perfect competition, P (price) is constant, so d(PQ)/dQ = P)
The second-order condition (SOC) for profit maximization requires that the second derivative of Ο with respect to Q be negative:
dΒ²Ο/dQΒ² = dΒ²TR/dQΒ² - dΒ²TC/dQΒ² < 0 dΒ²TR/dQΒ² < dΒ²TC/dQΒ²
So verbally: Slope of MR curve < Slope of MC curve, thus MC must have a steeper slope than the MR curve, or the MC curve must cut the MR curve from below.
Under perfect competition, the slope of MR curve is zero, hence the SOC is simplified as follows: 0 < dΒ²TC/dQΒ² MC must have a positive slope, or the MC must be rising.
SHORT-RUN ANALYSIS OF A PERFECTLY COMPETITIVE FIRM
In the short run, some inputs are fixed, and these give rise to fixed costs, which go on whether the firm produces or not. Thus, it pays for the firm to stay in business in the short run even if it incurs losses, as long as these losses are smaller than its fixed costs. The best level of output of the firm in the short run is the one at which the firm maximizes profits or minimizes losses.
[Figure 3 not reproduced here - shows two panels: top panel with profit at P=$45, bottom panel with loss at P=$25]
The best level of output of the firm in the short run is the one at which the marginal revenue (MR) of the firm equals its short-run marginal cost (MC). As long as MR exceeds MC, it pays for the firm to expand output because by doing so the firm would add more to its total revenue than to its total costs (so that its total profits increase or its total losses decrease). On the other hand, as long as MC exceeds MR, it pays for the firm to reduce output because by doing so the firm will reduce its total costs more than its total revenue (so that, once again, its total profits increase or its total losses decrease). Thus, the best level of output of any firm (not just a perfectly competitive firm) is the one at which MR = MC. Since a perfectly competitive firm faces a horizontal or infinitely elastic demand curve, P = MR, so that the condition for the best level of output can be restated as the one at which P = MR = MC.
In the top panel of Figure 3, d is the demand curve for the output of the perfectly competitive firm, and the marginal and average total cost (MC and ATC) curves are also drawn. The best level of output of the firm is given at point E, where the MC curve intersects the firm's d or MR curve. At point E, the firm produces 4 units of output at P = MR = MC = $45. Since at point E, P = $45 and ATC = $35, the firm earns a profit of EA = $10 per unit and EABC = $40 in total (the shaded area). This is the largest total profit that the firm can earn. Thus, the best level of output for the firm is QX = 4, at which MR = P = MC and the total profits of the firm are maximized.
The bottom panel of Figure 3 shows that if the market price of the product is $25 instead of $45, so that the demand curve faced by the perfectly competitive firm is d', the best level of output of the firm is 3 units, as indicated by point E', where P' = MR' = MC. At QX = 3, P = $25 and ATC = $35, so that the firm incurs a loss of FE' = $10 per unit and FE'C'B = $30 in total. If the firm stopped producing and left the market, however, it would incur the greater loss of FA' = $20 per unit and FA'B'B = $60 (its total fixed costs). Another way of looking at this is to say that at the best level of output of Q = 3, the excess of P = $25 over the firm's average variable cost (AVC) of $15 can be applied to cover part of the firm's fixed costs (FA' per unit and FA'B'B in total). Thus, the firm minimizes its losses by continuing to produce its best level of output.
If the market price declined to slightly below $15, so that the demand curve facing the firm crossed the MC curve at point H (see the bottom panel of Figure 3), the firm would be indifferent whether to produce or not. The reason is that at point H, P = AVC and the total losses of the firm would be equal to its total fixed costs whether it produces or not. Thus, point H is the shutdown point of the firm. Below point H, the firm would not even cover its variable costs, and so by going out of business, the firm would limit its losses to be equal to its total fixed costs.
π Definition β Shutdown Point: The point where P = AVC; below this price, the firm minimizes losses by ceasing production entirely, limiting losses to total fixed costs.
β Key Takeaways
You must remember that perfect competition is characterized by many small firms as price takers facing homogeneous products with free entry/exit and perfect information. The profit-maximizing condition for any firm is MR = MC, which under perfect competition simplifies to P = MR = MC since price is constant. In short-run analysis, a firm should continue production as long as price covers average variable costs (P > AVC), and the shutdown point occurs where P = AVC, below which losses exceed total fixed costs. Market equilibrium price is determined by the intersection of market demand and supply curves, and the firm's demand curve is perfectly elastic (horizontal) at this price. Finally, remember the algebraic method for solving equilibrium: set QD = QS and solve for P, then substitute back to find Q.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four characteristics used to describe market structure, and what are the four main types of market structure?
- For a perfectly competitive firm, explain why the demand curve is horizontal (perfectly elastic) and why P = MR = AR holds.
- Using calculus, derive the first-order condition and second-order condition for profit maximization under perfect competition.
- A perfectly competitive firm faces market demand QD = 1000 - 20P and market supply QS = 200 + 30P. Calculate the equilibrium price and quantity. If the firm's ATC at the profit-maximizing output is $12, will the firm earn profits or losses?
- Explain the shutdown point and the decision rule for a perfectly competitive firm in the short run when price falls below average variable cost.
π Lecture 26 β COMPETITIVE MARKETS (CONTINUED)
π Overview: This lecture continues the analysis of perfectly competitive markets, focusing on how firms determine supply in the short run and long run. It explains the critical role of marginal cost curves as supply curves and examines how competitive markets achieve both allocative and productive efficiency, while also introducing the concept of deadweight loss from market imperfections.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the short-run supply curve of the competitive firm derived from the marginal cost curve above average variable cost, illustrated with a numerical example. It then examines long-run equilibrium where firms produce at the lowest point on their long-run average cost curve and break even. The discussion concludes with an analysis of perfect competition and efficiency, including consumer and producer surplus, and a detailed illustration of deadweight loss from deviations from competitive equilibrium.
π Lecture Summary
SHORT-RUN SUPPLY CURVE OF THE COMPETITIVE FIRM
The rising portion of the firm's marginal cost (MC) curve above the average variable cost (AVC) curve (or shut-down point) represents the short-run supply curve of the perfectly competitive firm. This is because the perfectly competitive firm always produces where P = MR = MC, as long as P > AVC. For example, at P = $55, the firm produces 4.5 units; at P = $45, Q = 4; at P = $25, Q = 3; and at P = $15, Q = 2.5. Given price, the output supplied is determined by the point where P = MC, establishing a unique relationship between price and quantity that defines the supply curve.
SHORT-RUN FIRM SUPPLY CURVE
π Definition β Short-run supply curve: The rising portion of the competitive firm's marginal cost curve above the average variable cost curve, showing the unique relationship between price and quantity supplied.
π Formula: P = MR = MC (as long as P > AVC)
π Example: A competitive firm has TC = 361,250 + 5Q + 0.0002QΒ² and TR = 25Q. Setting MR = MC: 25 = 5 + 0.0004Q, so Q = 50,000. Since the firm is a price taker, P = MR = $25. Profit (Ο) = TR β TC = 25(50,000) β 361,250 β 5(50,000) β 0.0002(50,000)Β² = $138,750. The minimum AVC occurs at Q = 15,811 with AVC = $11.32, found by setting MC = AVC: 5 + 0.0004Q = (50,000 + 5Q + 0.0002QΒ²)/Q, solving for Q = 15,811. Since P = $25 > AVC = $11.32, the firm continues production.
LONG-RUN ANALYSIS OF A PERFECTLY COMPETITIVE FIRM
In the long run, all inputs and costs are variable, and the firm can construct the optimum scale of plant. The best level of output is where price equals long-run marginal cost (LMC). The optimum scale of plant has the short-run average total cost (SATC) curve tangent to the long-run average cost (LAC) curve at the best output level.
If existing firms earn profits, new firms enter, increasing market supply and lowering price until profits are eliminated. If firms incur losses, some exit, reducing supply until remaining firms break even. In long-run equilibrium, all firms produce at the lowest point on their LAC curve and break even, shown at point E* in Figure 2 where P = $25, Q = 4 units, and P = LMC = lowest LAC. All firms operate where P = MR = LMC = lowest LAC, and the scale of plant represented by SATC operates at its lowest point so that short-run marginal cost (SMC) equals LMC.
π‘ Why this matters: Long-run equilibrium in perfect competition ensures that firms produce at the most efficient scale and earn only a normal profit, maximizing societal welfare.
MARGINAL COST AND FIRM SUPPLY
Short-run Firm Supply: The competitive market price (P) is a horizontal line because P = MR. The marginal cost schedule is the short-run supply curve so long as P > AVC.
Long-run Firm Supply: Profit is maximized where P = MR = MC. The marginal cost curve is the long-run supply curve so long as P > ATC.
Perfect Competition and Efficiency
The model of perfect competition achieves efficiency in two ways:
- Allocative efficiency: Price = MC, maximizing consumer and producer surpluses
- Productive efficiency: In long-run equilibrium, output is produced at the lowest point on average cost curves
Welfare economics studies how allocation of economic resources affects material well-being. Competitive markets balance supply and demand and maximize total social welfare. Consumer surplus is the amount consumers are willing to pay minus what they actually pay. Producer surplus is the net benefit producers receive from production (shown in Figure 3). In the long run, firms must cover all necessary costs and earn a normal profit.
DEADWEIGHT LOSS PROBLEM
A deadweight loss is any loss suffered by consumers or producers that is not transferred but simply lost due to market imperfections or government policies. When linear demand and supply curves are used, deadweight losses appear as triangles, often called welfare loss triangles. Deadweight losses occur when market imperfections reduce transaction volume.
π Example: Given supply Q = -8000 + 8P (or P = 1000 + 0.125Q) and demand Q = 7000 β 2P (or P = 3500 β 0.5Q):
Setting supply = demand: -8000 + 8P = 7000 β 2P β 10P = 15000 β P = $1,500 per ton
Setting supply price = demand price: 1000 + 0.125Q = 3500 β 0.5Q β 0.625Q = 2500 β Q = 4,000 (000) tons
Consumer Deadweight Loss = Β½ [(4000 β 3000) Γ (2000 β 1500)] = $250,000 (000)
Producer Deadweight Loss = Β½ [(4000 β 3000) Γ (1500 β 1375)] = $62,500 (000)
Total Deadweight Loss = $250,000 + $62,500 = $312,500 (000)
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that the competitive firm's short-run supply curve is the rising portion of its MC curve above AVC, because the firm always produces where P = MR = MC as long as price exceeds average variable cost. In long-run equilibrium, all firms in perfect competition produce where P = MR = LMC = lowest LAC, earning only normal profits with no economic profits or losses. Perfect competition achieves allocative efficiency (P = MC) and productive efficiency (lowest average cost), maximizing consumer and producer surplus. Any deviation from competitive equilibrium creates deadweight loss, which is a net loss to society measured as welfare loss triangles. The numerical example of deadweight loss calculation demonstrates how to compute consumer and producer losses when market imperfections reduce transaction volume from the competitive equilibrium level.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why is the rising portion of the marginal cost curve above average variable cost considered the firm's short-run supply curve in perfect competition?
- What are the conditions for long-run equilibrium in a perfectly competitive market, and why do all firms break even?
- How do you calculate profit for a competitive firm given total cost and total revenue functions?
- What is the difference between allocative efficiency and productive efficiency in perfect competition?
- How is deadweight loss calculated when quantity is restricted below the competitive equilibrium?