π Lecture 29 β MAKING CAPITAL INVESTMENT DECISIONS
π Overview: This lecture introduces the process of evaluating proposed investments by focusing on relevant cash flows and discounted cash flow analysis. It covers the stand-alone principle, common pitfalls like sunk costs and opportunity costs, and demonstrates how to build pro forma financial statements to compute key capital budgeting metrics such as NPV and IRR.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture explains the concept of incremental cash flows and the stand-alone principle as the foundation for project evaluation. It then examines common mistakes in identifying relevant cash flows, including sunk costs, opportunity costs, side effects, net working capital, and financing costs. Finally, it walks through constructing pro forma financial statements and using them to calculate operating cash flow, project cash flow, NPV, IRR, payback period, and average accounting return (AAR) for a sample project.
π Lecture Summary
Project Cash Flows
To evaluate a proposed investment, we must consider the changes in the firmβs cash flows and decide whether they add value to the firm. The first step is to decide which cash flows are relevant and which are not.
Relevant Cash Flows
A relevant cash flow for a project is a change in the firmβs overall future cash flow that comes about as a direct consequence of the decision to take the investment. Since these relevant cash flows are defined in terms of changes in, or increments to, the firmβs existing cash flow, they are called the incremental cash flows associated with the project.
π Definition β Incremental Cash Flows: Any and all changes in the firmβs future cash flows that are a direct consequence of taking the project.
The Stand-Alone Principle
The stand-alone principle is the assumption that evaluation of a project may be based on the projectβs incremental cash flows. This means analyzing the project as a "minifirm" with its own future revenues and costs, its own assets, and its own cash flows.
Common Pitfalls in Identifying Incremental Cash Flows
Although it seems easy to decide whether a cash flow is incremental, there are situations where mistakes are easy to make. The key categories to watch for are:
- Sunk Costs
- Opportunity Costs
- Side Effects
- Net Working Capital
- Financing Costs
- Other Issues
Sunk Costs
A sunk cost is a cost that has already been incurred and cannot be recouped, and therefore should not be considered in an investment decision. An example is a consultantβs fee paid for evaluating the option of launching a new product. This cost is irrelevant to the future decision.
Opportunity Costs
An opportunity cost is the most valuable alternative that is given up if a particular investment is undertaken. For example, if a piece of land bought years ago could be sold at current market rates but instead is used to build a school, the opportunity cost charged to the school project should be the land's current market price, not its original purchase price.
Side Effects
A project can have side or spillover effects, both good and bad. For example, sales of a new car by a certain company might come at the expense of the sales of the company's other cars. This phenomenon is called erosion, piracy, or cannibalism. Cash flows from the new product line should be adjusted downward to reflect lost profits on other lines.
Net Working Capital
Normally, a project requires investments in net working capital (NWC) in addition to long-term assets. This includes cash in hand, inventories, and accounts receivables, as well as accounts payables; the balance being the net working capital. As the project winds down, net working capital gets freed up. Investment in NWC resembles a loan, as the firm provides NWC at the beginning and recovers it towards the end.
π Definition β Net Working Capital (NWC): Current assets minus current liabilities, representing the short-term investment required to support a project's operations.
Financing Costs
We do not include interest paid or any other financing costs like dividends or principal paid while analyzing a proposed investment. We are only interested in the cash flow generated by the assets of the project. The mixture of debt and equity a firm chooses to use in financing a project is a managerial variable and does not form part of the project evaluation process.
Other Issues
We are only concerned with measuring cash flows when they actually occur, rather than when they occur in an accounting sense. Also, we are interested in after-tax cash flows, as incremental cash flows means after-tax incremental cash flows.
Pro Forma Financial Statements
Pro forma financial statements project future yearsβ operations in a summarized format. To prepare these statements, we need estimates of quantities like unit sales, selling price per unit, variable cost per unit, and total fixed cost.
Suppose we want to prepare a set of pro forma financial statements for a project for ND Enterprises. The background information is:
- Sales of 10,000 units/year @ $5/unit.
- Variable cost/unit is $3. Fixed costs are $5,000/year. Project has no salvage value. Project life is 3 years.
- Project cost is $21,000. Depreciation is $7,000/year.
- Investment in net working capital is $10,000.
- The firmβs required return is 20%. The tax rate is 34%.
Projected Income Statements
| Amount | |
|---|---|
| Sales (10,000 units/year @ $5/unit) | $50,000 |
| Var. costs ($3/unit) | 30,000 |
| Gross Profit | $20,000 |
| Fixed costs | 5,000 |
| Depreciation | 7,000 |
| EBIT | $8,000 |
| Taxes (34%) | 2,720 |
| Net income | $5,280 |
Projected Balance Sheets
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Net Working Capital | $10,000 | $10,000 | $10,000 | $10,000 |
| Net Fixed Assets | 21,000 | 14,000 | 7,000 | 0 |
| Total | $31,000 | $24,000 | $17,000 | $10,000 |
Project Cash Flows
We know that:
Project Cash Flow = Project operating cash flow β Project change in net working capital β Project capital spending
We also know that:
Operating Cash Flow (OCF) = Earnings before interest and taxes + Depreciation β Taxes
Letβs use the information from the previous example to do a capital budgeting analysis.
Project operating cash flow (OCF):
- EBIT: $8,000
- Depreciation: +$7,000
- Taxes: -$2,720
- Operating Cash Flow: $12,280
π Formula: OCF = EBIT + Depreciation β Taxes
π Example: OCF = $8,000 + $7,000 - $2,720 = $12,280
Project Cash Flow Summary
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Operating Cash Flow | $12,280 | $12,280 | $12,280 | |
| Change in NWC | -$10,000 | $10,000 | ||
| Capital Spending | -$21,000 | |||
| Total | -$31,000 | $12,280 | $12,280 | $22,280 |
The firm must spend $21,000 up front for fixed assets and invest an additional $10,000 in net working capital. So the immediate outflow is $31,000. The recovery of $10,000 tied up in NWC in the last year will lead to a cash inflow of the same amount.
Capital Budgeting Evaluation
Based on the projected cash flows, we can compute the following capital budgeting metrics:
- NPV = -$31,000 + $12,280/1.20ΒΉ + $12,280/1.20Β² + $22,280/1.20Β³ = $655
- IRR = 21%
π‘ Why this matters: A positive NPV of $655 and an IRR (21%) greater than the required return (20%) suggest the project adds value and should be undertaken.
- Payback = 2.3 years
- AAR = $5,280 / {(31,000 + 24,000 + 17,000 + 10,000) / 4} = 25.76%
π Formula: Average Accounting Return (AAR) = Average Net Income / Average Book Value of Investment
π Example: AAR = $5,280 / ($82,000 / 4) = $5,280 / $20,500 = 25.76%
The firm should invest in this project because the NPV is positive and the IRR exceeds the required return.
β Key Takeaways
The foundation of capital investment analysis is identifying incremental cash flowsβthe changes in the firm's total cash flow directly caused by the project. It's critical to avoid common errors by ignoring sunk costs and including opportunity costs (at current market value), adjusting for side effects like cannibalism, accounting for investments in net working capital (which are recovered at the end), and excluding financing costs. The stand-alone principle allows us to analyze a project as a "minifirm" using pro forma statements to calculate its operating cash flow (OCF) and total project cash flow. Finally, a project should be accepted if it has a positive NPV and an IRR greater than the required return, which signal that the project adds value to the firm.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the stand-alone principle, and why is it useful in project evaluation?
- Explain why a sunk cost is not a relevant cash flow, but an opportunity cost is relevant.
- How does the phenomenon of erosion affect the calculation of a new project's incremental cash flows?
- Why is the initial investment in net working capital treated as a cash outflow, and why is its recovery treated as an inflow?
- Based on the ND Enterprises example, calculate the project's total cash flow in year 3, explaining each component.
π Lecture 30 β Pro Forma Financial Statements
π Overview: This lecture teaches how to prepare pro forma financial statements for capital budgeting projects and use them to evaluate project cash flows and investment decisions. It covers operating cash flow calculation, the tax shield approach, net working capital adjustments, and MACRS depreciation methods.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers pro forma income statements and balance sheets for a sample project (ND Enterprises), project cash flow calculation and capital budgeting evaluation using NPV, IRR, payback, and AAR. It then explores the tax shield approach to OCF, a closer examination of net working capital effects on cash flow including accounts receivable and payable adjustments, and concludes with MACRS depreciation methods and property classes.
π Lecture Summary
Pro Forma Financial Statements
A project at ND Enterprises is analyzed with sales of 10,000 units/year at $5/unit, variable costs of $3/unit, and fixed costs of $5,000/year. The project cost is $21,000 with $7,000/year depreciation, $10,000 investment in net working capital (NWC), a required return of 20%, and a tax rate of 34%. The projected income statement shows sales of $50,000, variable costs of $30,000, gross profit of $20,000, fixed costs of $5,000, depreciation of $7,000, EBIT of $8,000, taxes of $2,720, and net income of $5,280. The projected balance sheet shows NWC constant at $10,000 each year, net fixed assets declining from $21,000 to $14,000 to $7,000 to $0 over years 0 through 3, with total assets falling from $31,000 to $10,000.
Project Cash Flows
Operating Cash Flow (OCF) is calculated starting from EBIT of $8,000, adding back depreciation of $7,000, and subtracting taxes of $2,720, giving $12,280 per year. The project requires an immediate outflow of $31,000 ($21,000 for fixed assets plus $10,000 for NWC). In year 3, the recovery of $10,000 in NWC adds to the cash flow. Total project cash flows are -$31,000 in year 0, $12,280 in years 1 and 2, and $22,280 in year 3.
π Definition β Operating Cash Flow (OCF): The cash generated from a project's normal operations, calculated as EBIT + Depreciation - Taxes.
π Formula: OCF = EBIT + Depreciation β Taxes β Measures the actual cash produced by operations after accounting for tax payments.
π Example: For ND Enterprises, EBIT = $8,000, Depreciation = $7,000, Taxes = $2,720, so OCF = $8,000 + $7,000 - $2,720 = $12,280.
Capital Budgeting Evaluation
The Net Present Value (NPV) of the project is calculated as -$31,000 + $12,280/1.20ΒΉ + $12,280/1.20Β² + $22,280/1.20Β³ = $655. The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is 21%. The Payback period is 2.3 years. The Average Accounting Return (AAR) is $5,280 divided by the average book value of assets ($31,000 + $24,000 + $17,000 + $10,000)/4 = $20,500, giving 25.76%. Since NPV is positive ($655) and IRR (21%) exceeds the required return (20%), the firm should invest in this project.
π‘ Why this matters: A positive NPV means the project adds value to the firm, while an IRR above the required return confirms the investment meets the firm's profitability threshold.
The Tax Shield Approach
The tax shield definition of OCF is: OCF = (Sales β Costs) Γ (1 β T) + Depreciation Γ T, where T is the corporate tax rate (34%). For ND Enterprises, (Sales β Costs) = $50,000 β ($30,000 + $5,000) = $15,000, so OCF = $15,000 Γ 0.66 + $7,000 Γ 0.34 = $9,900 + $2,380 = $12,280. This shows OCF has two components: the project's "would be" cash flows without depreciation ($9,900) and the depreciation tax shield ($2,380).
π Formula: OCF = (Sales β Costs) Γ (1 β T) + Depreciation Γ T β Separates operating cash flow into after-tax operating income plus the tax savings from depreciation.
π Example: With Sales=$50,000, Costs=$35,000, T=34%, Depreciation=$7,000, OCF = $15,000Γ0.66 + $7,000Γ0.34 = $9,900 + $2,380 = $12,280.
A Closer Look on NWC
When sales include credit and costs include unpaid amounts, cash flow adjusts via changes in NWC. For a sample year with sales $500, costs $310, and net income $190, if accounts receivable rise by $30 (to $910 from $880) and accounts payable rise by $55 (to $605 from $550), NWC decreases by $25 (from $330 to $305). Cash revenues are sales minus the increase in receivables = $500 β $30 = $470. Cash costs are costs minus the increase in payables = $310 β $55 = $255. Net cash flow is $470 β $255 = $215, matching the formula Total Cash Flow = OCF β Change in NWC β Capital Spending = $190 β (-$25) β $0 = $215.
π Definition β Change in NWC: The difference in net working capital (current assets minus current liabilities) between two periods, used to adjust operating cash flow for credit sales and unpaid costs.
π Example: With sales $500, costs $310, ΞAR = +$30, ΞAP = +$55, ΞNWC = -$25, cash flow = $190 β (-$25) β 0 = $215.
The Pencil Company Example
For a year with sales of $998 and costs of $734, accounts receivable rose from $100 to $110 (+$10), inventory fell from $100 to $80 (-$20), and accounts payable fell from $100 to $70 (-$30). NWC changed from $100 to $120 (+$20). Cash revenues = $998 β $10 = $988. Cash costs = $734 β $20 + $30 = $744. Net cash flow = $988 β $744 = $244.
Depreciation
Accounting depreciation is a non-cash deduction that affects cash flow only through its influence on the tax bill. The Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS) assigns each asset to a property class (3-year, 5-year, 7-year) with fixed depreciation percentages. For example, a $12,000 automobile in the 5-year class has depreciation of 20% ($2,400) in year 1, 32% ($3,840) in year 2, 19.2% ($2,304) in year 3, 11.52% ($1,382.40) in years 4 and 5, and 5.76% ($691.20) in year 6. The ending book value after year 6 is $0.
π Definition β MACRS: A depreciation method that assigns assets to property classes with fixed annual percentages, ignoring salvage value and actual economic life for tax purposes.
π Formula: Depreciation = Cost of Asset Γ MACRS Percentage for that year β Calculates annual depreciation deduction for tax purposes.
π Example: For a $12,000 automobile, year 1 depreciation = $12,000 Γ 20% = $2,400; year 2 = $12,000 Γ 32% = $3,840; total over 6 years = $12,000.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that OCF can be calculated both directly (EBIT + Depreciation β Taxes) and via the tax shield approach (OCF = (Sales β Costs)(1 β T) + Depreciation Γ T), both yielding the same result. Changes in NWC crucially adjust cash flow for credit sales and unpaid costs, with cash revenues = sales β increase in receivables and cash costs = costs β increase in payables + increase in inventory. MACRS depreciation uses fixed percentages based on property class (3, 5, or 7 years) and ignores salvage value, with the depreciation tax shield (Depreciation Γ T) being the key cash flow benefit. A positive NPV and IRR greater than the required return indicate the project should be accepted.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- For ND Enterprises, what is the operating cash flow (OCF) for each year using the direct method?
- How do you calculate the tax shield component of OCF, and what is its value in the ND Enterprises example?
- If accounts receivable increase by $30 and accounts payable increase by $55, how do you compute cash revenues and cash costs from sales of $500 and costs of $310?
- For a 5-year MACRS property costing $12,000, what is the depreciation in year 3?
- What does a positive NPV of $655 and IRR of 21% (above 20%) tell you about the ND Enterprises project?
π Lecture 31 β DEPRECIATION
π Overview: This lecture explains the Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS) for depreciation and its impact on tax calculations and project cash flows. It demonstrates how depreciation affects taxable income, asset sale tax consequences, and net present value analysis through detailed examples, including a comprehensive capital budgeting project for The M Inc.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers MACRS depreciation tables and calculations, book value versus market value concepts, tax implications of asset sales including depreciation recapture and capital gains, and a complete project cash flow analysis for The M Inc. including revenue projections, operating cash flows, net working capital changes, capital spending, and project evaluation using NPV, IRR, and payback period.
π Lecture Summary
DEPRECIATION
The lecture begins with a MACRS (Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System) depreciation example for an automobile costing $12,000, classified as 5-year property. The depreciation percentages are: Year 1: 20.00% ($2,400), Year 2: 32.00% ($3,840), Year 3: 19.20% ($2,304), Year 4: 11.52% ($1,382.40), Year 5: 11.52% ($1,382.40), and Year 6: 5.76% ($691.20), totaling 100% depreciation.
The book value declines each year as depreciation is subtracted. For Year 1, beginning book value is $12,000, depreciation is $2,400, ending book value is $9,600. By Year 6, ending book value reaches $0.
π Definition β Book Value: The original cost of an asset minus accumulated depreciation.
π Formula: Ending Book Value = Beginning Book Value β Depreciation
Book Value versus Market Value
If the car is sold after 5 years for an estimated market value of 25% of purchase price ($3,000), there is a difference between market price ($3,000) and book value ($691.20) of $2,308.80. This difference is subject to taxes at 34%: 0.34 Γ $2,308.80 = $784.99.
The reason for tax payment is that the difference between market and book value represents excess depreciation that must be recaptured when the asset is sold. This is not a tax on capital gain, which occurs only if the market price exceeds the original cost. If book value exceeds market value, the difference is treated as a loss for tax purposes.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the tax treatment of asset sales is crucial for calculating accurate after-tax cash flows in capital budgeting.
π Definition β Depreciation Recapture: The gain from selling a depreciated asset that is taxed as ordinary income up to the amount of depreciation taken.
The SS Company
The SS Company purchased an IT system for $160,000 (5-year MACRS property). Yearly depreciation allowances are: Year 1: 20.00% ($32,000, ending book value $128,000), Year 2: 32.00% ($51,200, $76,800), Year 3: 19.20% ($30,720, $46,080), Year 4: 11.52% ($18,432, $27,648), Year 5: 11.52% ($18,432, $9,216), Year 6: 5.76% ($9,216, $0).
If sold after 4 years for $10,000, the book value is $27,648, creating a tax loss of $17,648. The company receives $10,000 from the buyer and saves 0.34 Γ $17,648 = $6,000 in taxes. The total after-tax cash flow from the sale is $10,000 + $6,000 = $16,000 cash inflow.
π Example: For SS Company, selling a system with book value $27,648 for $10,000 creates a $17,648 tax loss, resulting in tax savings of $6,000 and total after-tax proceeds of $16,000.
The M Inc.
The M Inc. is evaluating a new product line with projected unit sales over 8 years: 3,000, 5,000, 6,000, 6,500, 6,000, 5,000, 4,000, and 3,000 units. The product sells for $120 per unit for the first three years, dropping to $110 thereafter due to competition. Net working capital requires $20,000 initially, then 15% of sales each year. Variable costs are $60 per unit, fixed costs are $25,000 per year. Equipment costs $800,000 (7-year MACRS property) and will be worth 20% of cost ($160,000) in 8 years. Tax rate is 34%, required return is 15%.
Revenue projections for Year 1: $120 Γ 3,000 = $360,000; Year 2: $120 Γ 5,000 = $600,000; Year 3: $120 Γ 6,000 = $720,000; Year 4: $110 Γ 6,500 = $715,000; Year 5: $110 Γ 6,000 = $660,000; Year 6: $110 Γ 5,000 = $550,000; Year 7: $110 Γ 4,000 = $440,000; Year 8: $110 Γ 3,000 = $330,000.
π Definition β Net Working Capital (NWC): Current assets minus current liabilities; changes in NWC represent cash flows related to operating liquidity needs.
Operating Cash Flow Calculations (Years 1-4)
For Year 1: Revenues $360,000 β Variable Costs ($60 Γ 3,000 = $180,000) β Fixed Costs $25,000 β Depreciation $114,320 = EBIT $40,680. Taxes (34%): $13,831. Net Income: $26,849.
For Year 2: Revenues $600,000 β VC $300,000 β FC $25,000 β Depreciation $195,920 = EBIT $79,080. Taxes: $26,887. Net Income: $52,193.
For Year 3: Revenues $720,000 β VC $360,000 β FC $25,000 β Depreciation $139,920 = EBIT $195,080. Taxes: $66,327. Net Income: $128,753.
For Year 4: Revenues $715,000 β VC $390,000 β FC $25,000 β Depreciation $99,920 = EBIT $200,080. Taxes: $68,027. Net Income: $132,053.
Operating Cash Flow Calculations (Years 5-8)
For Year 5: Revenues $660,000 β VC $360,000 β FC $25,000 β Depreciation $71,440 = EBIT $203,560. Taxes: $69,210. Net Income: $134,350.
For Year 6: Revenues $550,000 β VC $300,000 β FC $25,000 β Depreciation $71,440 = EBIT $153,560. Taxes: $52,210. Net Income: $101,350.
For Year 7: Revenues $440,000 β VC $240,000 β FC $25,000 β Depreciation $71,440 = EBIT $103,560. Taxes: $35,210. Net Income: $68,350.
For Year 8: Revenues $330,000 β VC $180,000 β FC $25,000 β Depreciation $35,600 = EBIT $89,400. Taxes: $30,396. Net Income: $59,004.
Changes in Net Working Capital
NWC starts at $20,000 (Year 0 cash outflow). For Year 1, NWC becomes 15% Γ $360,000 = $54,000, requiring an additional investment of $54,000 β $20,000 = $34,000 (cash outflow).
Year 2: NWC = 15% Γ $600,000 = $90,000, increase = $90,000 β $54,000 = $36,000 outflow. Year 3: NWC = 15% Γ $720,000 = $108,000, increase = $18,000 outflow. Year 4: NWC = 15% Γ $715,000 = $107,250, decrease = $107,250 β $108,000 = -$750 (cash inflow of $750). Year 5: NWC = 15% Γ $660,000 = $99,000, decrease = $99,000 β $107,250 = -$8,250 inflow. Year 6: NWC = 15% Γ $550,000 = $82,500, decrease = $82,500 β $99,000 = -$16,500 inflow. Year 7: NWC = 15% Γ $440,000 = $66,000, decrease = $66,000 β $82,500 = -$16,500 inflow. Year 8: NWC = 15% Γ $330,000 = $49,500, decrease = $49,500 β $66,000 = -$16,500 inflow (total NWC recovered).
Capital Spending
The initial equipment investment is $800,000 at Year 0 (outflow). At the end of the project (Year 8), the equipment has a market value of $160,000 but a book value of $0. This $160,000 excess is taxable at 34%, so after-tax proceeds = $160,000 Γ (1 β 0.34) = $105,600 (cash inflow in Year 8).
π Example: For the equipment, market value $160,000 minus book value $0 = $160,000 gain, taxed at 34% = $54,400 tax, leaving $105,600 after-tax proceeds.
Project Total Cash Flows
Year 0: Operating CF $0 β NWC $20,000 β Capital Spending $800,000 = -$820,000 Year 1: OCF $141,169 β NWC $34,000 = $107,169 Year 2: OCF $248,113 β NWC $36,000 = $212,113 Year 3: OCF $268,113 β NWC $18,000 = $250,673 Year 4: OCF $231,973 β NWC -$750 = $232,723 Year 5: OCF $205,790 β NWC -$8,250 = $214,040 Year 6: OCF $172,790 β NWC -$16,500 = $189,290 Year 7: OCF $139,790 β NWC -$16,500 = $156,290 Year 8: OCF $94,064 β NWC -$66,000 + Capital Spending $105,600 = $266,204
Project Evaluation
The Net Present Value (NPV) at 15% is calculated as $65,488, indicating the project is acceptable. The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is 17.24%, also above the required return of 15%. The Payback Period is 4.08 years.
π Definition β Net Present Value (NPV): The sum of present values of all project cash flows discounted at the required rate of return; a positive NPV indicates value creation.
π Formula: NPV = Ξ£ (CFβ / (1 + r)α΅) β Initial Investment β Measures whether a project adds value above the required return.
π Example: For The M Inc., discounted cash flows at 15%: Yr 0: -$820,000; Yr 1: $93,190; Yr 2: $160,388; Yr 3: $164,821; Yr 4: $133,060; Yr 5: $106,416; Yr 6: $81,835; Yr 7: $58,755; Yr 8: $87,023. Sum = $65,488 positive NPV.
β Key Takeaways
The key concepts from this lecture are that MACRS depreciation provides accelerated depreciation schedules for different asset classes, and the tax treatment of asset sales depends on the difference between market value and book value (depreciation recapture if market > book, tax loss if book > market). For capital budgeting, total project cash flows combine operating cash flows, net working capital changes, and capital spending (including after-tax proceeds from asset sales). The M Inc. case demonstrates that a project with positive NPV ($65,488) and IRR (17.24%) exceeding the required return (15%) should be accepted, with a payback period of 4.08 years.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between depreciation recapture and a capital gain when selling an asset?
- How do you calculate the after-tax cash flow from selling an asset when market value exceeds book value?
- In the M Inc. project, why does net working capital become a cash inflow in later years?
- What is the formula for operating cash flow (OCF) and how is it calculated from net income and depreciation?
- Why is the total after-tax proceeds from selling the equipment in Year 8 ($105,600) less than its market value ($160,000)?
π Lecture 32 β RETURNS
π Overview: This lecture examines how financial managers assess investment returns by understanding both dollar and percentage returns from market history. It introduces the critical concepts of return variability, variance, and standard deviation as measures of investment risk, establishing the fundamental relationship between risk and reward.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the components of dollar returns including income and capital gains, calculation of percentage returns through dividend yield and capital gains yield, the variability of returns across different asset classes, and the statistical measurement of risk using variance and standard deviation with practical examples.
π Lecture Summary
RETURNS
One of the financial manager's key responsibilities is to assess the value of proposed investments. The minimum return required from a non-financial investment must be at least as large as what can be obtained from buying financial assets of similar risk. Lessons from market history teach us that there is a reward for bearing risk, and the greater the potential reward, the greater the risk.
Any gain or loss from an investment is called the return on investment, typically expressed as dollar returns with two components:
- Income earned (Dividends)
- Capital gain (change in asset value)
Dollar returns equal the sum of cash received plus the change in dollar value of the asset.
π Definition β Return on Investment: The gain or loss from an investment, consisting of income earned plus capital gains.
π Formula: Dollar Return = Cash Received + (Ending Value β Beginning Value)
π Example: You bought 100 shares one year ago at $25 each ($2,500 total investment). Over the year, you received $20 in dividends ($0.20/share Γ 100 shares). At year-end, stock sells for $30/share ($3,000 total). Dollar gain = $20 + ($3,000 β $2,500) = $520. If you sell, total cash inflow = $2,500 + $520 = $3,020. If you hold, the capital gain is still part of your return.
Percentage Returns
Percentage returns are more convenient because they do not depend on how much you actually invest.
π Definition β Dividend Yield: Dividend divided by beginning price.
π Definition β Capital Gains Yield: (Ending price β Beginning price) divided by beginning price.
π Formula: Total Percentage Return = Dividend Yield + Capital Gains Yield
π Formula: Percentage Return = Dollar Return Γ· Beginning Market Value
π Example: From the previous example: Dividend Yield = $20/$2,500 = 0.8%. Capital Gains Yield = ($3,000 β $2,500)/$2,500 = 20%. Total Percentage Return = 0.8% + 20% = 20.8%.
π Example: You buy stock at $25/share. Year-end price is $35/share. You receive $2 dividend per share. Dividend Yield = $2/$25 = 8%. Capital Gains Yield = ($35 β $25)/$25 = 40%. Total Percentage Return = 8% + 40% = 48%. If you invested $1,000, you would have $1,480 at year-end.
Variability of Returns
Year-to-year returns on common stocks tend to be more volatile than returns on long-term bonds. Measuring this variability is key to examining risk.
A frequency distribution of common stock returns over 72 years shows returns ranging from -55% to +55%, with the highest frequency (16 years) in the 10-20% range.
To measure the spread in returns, we need to know how far actual returns deviate from the average return. The most commonly used measures are variance and its square root, the standard deviation.
π Definition β Variance: Measures the average squared differences between actual returns and the average return. The larger the number, the more actual returns tend to differ from the average.
π Definition β Standard Deviation: The square root of variance, measuring the spread of returns. The larger the standard deviation, the more spread out the returns.
π Formula: Variance = Sum of Squared Deviations Γ· (n β 1)
π Formula: Standard Deviation = βVariance
π Example: Investment returns: 10%, 12%, 3%, and -9% over four years.
| Year | Actual Return | Average Return | Deviation from Mean | Squared Deviation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 0.10 | 0.04 | 0.06 | 0.0036 |
| 2 | 0.12 | 0.04 | 0.08 | 0.0064 |
| 3 | 0.03 | 0.04 | -0.01 | 0.0001 |
| 4 | -0.09 | 0.04 | -0.13 | 0.0169 |
| Total | 0.16 | 0.00 | 0.0270 |
Average Return = (0.10 + 0.12 + 0.03 β 0.09)/4 = 0.04 = 4%
Variance = 0.0270/(4 β 1) = 0.009
Standard Deviation = β0.009 = 0.09487 = 9.487%
π‘ Why this matters: Standard deviation quantifies investment risk. A higher standard deviation means greater return volatility, directly relating to the risk-reward tradeoff in financial decision making.
β Key Takeaways
Dollar returns consist of income (dividends) plus capital gains, while percentage returns standardize this as dividend yield plus capital gains yield. Market history confirms a positive relationship between risk and reward, with common stocks showing greater volatility than bonds. Variance and standard deviation measure this volatility by quantifying how actual returns deviate from the average return. The calculation uses squared deviations divided by (n-1) to account for sample bias. Understanding these measures is essential for evaluating any investment opportunity.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two components of dollar returns on an investment?
- How do you calculate total percentage return from dividend yield and capital gains yield?
- If a stock has returns of 15%, -5%, 8%, and 2% over four years, what is the average return?
- Why do we divide by (n-1) instead of n when calculating variance from sample data?
- What does a larger standard deviation indicate about an investment's returns?
π Lecture 33 β Variability of Returns
π Overview: This lecture examines how to measure and interpret the variability (risk) of investment returns using variance and standard deviation. It introduces the concepts of expected returns, risk premiums, and portfolio diversification, showing how combining assets can fundamentally alter an investor's risk profile.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers calculating variance and standard deviation for historical returns, computing expected returns under different probability scenarios, determining risk premiums, calculating variance for expected returns, and building portfolios with multiple assets to manage risk through diversification.
π Lecture Summary
Variability of Returns
In general, the variance for T historical returns is calculated as: Var(R) = [(Rβ - RΜ)Β² + ... + (Rβ - RΜ)Β²] / (T - 1). The standard deviation is always the square root of the variance and provides a measure of return volatility in the same units as the original returns.
For Company X and Company Y with four years of returns:
- Company X average return: RΜβ = (-.20 + .50 + .30 + .10)/4 = .175 (17.5%)
- Company Y average return: RΜα΅§ = (.05 + .09 - .12 + .20)/4 = .055 (5.5%)
π Definition β Variance: The average squared deviation of returns from their mean, measuring the dispersion of returns. π Formula: Var(R) = Ξ£(Rβ - RΜ)Β² / (T-1) β Calculates the average squared difference between each return and the mean return.
For Company X, deviations are: -.375, .325, .125, -.075 with squared deviations of .140625, .105625, .015625, .005625, summing to .267500. Variance = .2675/3 = .0892, Standard Deviation = β.0892 = .2987 (29.87%).
| Company X | Company Y | |
|---|---|---|
| Variance (ΟΒ²) | .2675/3 = .0892 | .0529/3 = .0176 |
| Standard Deviation (Ο) | β.0892 = .2987 | β.0176 = .1327 |
Standard deviation for Company X (29.87%) is more than twice Company Y's (13.27%), indicating Company X is the more volatile investment.
π Example: Company X had returns of -20%, 50%, 30%, and 10% over four years. The average return is 17.5%. The variance calculation shows the extreme deviations (-37.5% and +32.5%) produce large squared terms, resulting in a high standard deviation of 29.87%, confirming high volatility.
Expected Return
Given a single period, Stock L has an expected return of 25% and Stock U has 20%. Stock L may go up to 70% in an economic boom or slide to -20% in a recession, while Stock U may earn 30% in a recession and 10% during a boom.
π Definition β Expected Return: The weighted average of possible returns, where the weights are the probabilities of each state occurring.
With equal probabilities (0.5 each for recession and boom):
- E(Rβ) = (0.5 Γ -0.20) + (0.5 Γ 0.70) = 0.25 (25%)
- E(Rα΅€) = (0.5 Γ 0.30) + (0.5 Γ 0.10) = 0.20 (20%)
π Example: For Stock L, with a 50% chance of a recession (return -20%) and 50% chance of a boom (return 70%), the expected return is 25%. For Stock U, with the same probabilities, returns of 30% and 10% produce an expected return of 20%.
Risk Premium
The risk premium is the difference between the return on a risky investment and that on a risk-free investment (RΖ). If risk-free investments offer 8%:
- Risk Premium (U) = E(Rα΅€) - RΖ = 20% - 8% = 12%
- Risk Premium (L) = 25% - 8% = 17%
π Definition β Risk Premium: The excess return an investor expects to receive for bearing the risk of an investment over a risk-free alternative.
Unequal Probabilities Case: With an 80% chance of recession and 20% chance of boom:
- E(Rβ) = (0.8 Γ -0.20) + (0.2 Γ 0.70) = -0.02 (-2%)
- E(Rα΅€) = (0.8 Γ 0.30) + (0.2 Γ 0.10) = 0.26 (26%)
If risk-free rate is 10%:
- Risk Premium (U) = 26% - 10% = 16%
- Risk Premium (L) = -2% - 10% = -12% (negative risk premium)
π Example: When recession probability rises to 80%, Stock L's expected return becomes negative (-2%), producing a negative risk premium of -12% when the risk-free rate is 10%. This means investors would expect to lose money relative to the risk-free alternative.
Calculating the Variance
To calculate variance of expected returns: (1) Determine squared deviations from the expected return, (2) Multiply each squared deviation by its probability, (3) Sum all the products.
For Stock L with equal probabilities: ΟΒ²β = 0.5(-.20 - .25)Β² + 0.5(.70 - .25)Β² = 0.5(0.2025) + 0.5(0.2025) = 0.2025, Οβ = β0.2025 = 45% For Stock U: ΟΒ²α΅€ = 0.5(.30 - .20)Β² + 0.5(.10 - .20)Β² = 0.5(0.01) + 0.5(0.01) = 0.0100, Οα΅€ = β0.0100 = 10%
π Formula: ΟΒ² = Ξ£[P(state) Γ (Return - E(R))Β²] β The probability-weighted average of squared deviations from the expected return.
| Stock L | Stock U | |
|---|---|---|
| Expected Return | 25% | 20% |
| Variance (ΟΒ²) | 0.2025 | 0.0100 |
| Standard Deviation | 45% | 10% |
| Coefficient of Variation (CV) | 0.5 | 0.5 |
π‘ Why this matters: Stock L has higher expected return (25%) but also higher risk (45% standard deviation). Stock U has lower expected return (20%) but much lower risk (10% standard deviation). The choice depends on the investor's risk tolerance.
For unequal probabilities (80% recession, 20% boom):
- Stock L: ΟΒ²β = 0.8(-.20 + .02)Β² + 0.2(.70 - .02)Β² = 0.8(0.0324) + 0.2(0.5184) = 0.12960, Οβ = β0.1296 = 36%
- Stock U: ΟΒ²α΅€ = 0.8(.30 - .26)Β² + 0.2(.10 - .26)Β² = 0.8(0.0016) + 0.2(0.0256) = 0.00640, Οα΅€ = β0.0064 = 8%
π Example: With unequal probabilities, Stock L's variance is 0.1296 (standard deviation 36%) while Stock U's variance is only 0.0064 (standard deviation 8%). Stock U's expected return (26%) is now higher than Stock L's (-2%), making U clearly superior on both return and risk.
Portfolios
A portfolio is a group of assets such as stocks and bonds held by an investor. Portfolio weights are the percentages of the total portfolio's value invested in each portfolio asset. If you have $50 in one asset and $150 in another (total $200), weights are 0.25 and 0.75.
π Definition β Portfolio Expected Return: The weighted average of the expected returns of the individual assets: E(Rβ) = xβ Γ E(Rβ) + xβ Γ E(Rβ) + ... + xβ Γ E(Rβ)
With equal weights (0.50 each) in Stocks L and U:
- Returns if recession occurs: 0.5 Γ (-20%) + 0.5 Γ 30% = 5%
- Returns if boom occurs: 0.5 Γ 70% + 0.5 Γ 10% = 40%
- E(Rβ) = 0.50 Γ 25% + 0.50 Γ 20% = 22.5%
Portfolio variance: ΟΒ²β = 0.5(0.05 - 0.225)Β² + 0.5(0.40 - 0.225)Β² = 0.5(0.030625) + 0.5(0.030625) = 0.030625, Οβ = β0.030625 = 17.5%
With different weights (2/11 in Stock L, 9/11 in Stock U):
- Returns if recession: 2/11 Γ (-20%) + 9/11 Γ 30% = 20.91%
- Returns if boom: 2/11 Γ 70% + 9/11 Γ 10% = 20.91%
- The returns are identical, showing zero variance
π Example: By allocating 2/11 of the portfolio to Stock L and 9/11 to Stock U, the portfolio returns become identical (20.91%) regardless of economic conditions. This demonstrates that combining assets can eliminate risk entirely through proper diversification.
π‘ Why this matters: Combining assets into portfolios can substantially alter the risks faced by the investor. Portfolio variance is NOT a simple combination of asset variancesβdiversification can reduce or even eliminate risk.
β Key Takeaways
Variance and standard deviation are the fundamental measures of return variability, with higher values indicating greater risk. Expected returns are probability-weighted averages, and risk premiums quantify the compensation investors require for bearing risk above risk-free investments. The most critical insight is that portfolio risk is not simply the average of individual asset risksβthrough proper diversification (choosing appropriate portfolio weights), investors can substantially reduce or even eliminate risk while maintaining returns. The portfolio with 2/11 in Stock L and 9/11 in Stock U perfectly illustrates how diversification can produce identical returns across all states (20.91%), achieving zero variance.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Using the formula Var(R) = Ξ£(Rβ - RΜ)Β² / (T-1), calculate the variance for a stock with returns of 10%, -5%, and 15% over three years (average return = 6.67%).
- If Stock A has expected return of 12% with 70% probability of boom (return 20%) and 30% probability of recession, what must be the recession return to achieve this expected return?
- With a risk-free rate of 5%, what is the risk premium for a stock with expected return of 14%?
- A portfolio has $200 in Asset X (expected return 8%) and $300 in Asset Y (expected return 15%). What is the portfolio expected return?
- If two stocks have perfectly offsetting returns (one rises when the other falls), what portfolio weights would achieve zero variance?
π Lecture 34 β Portfolio
π Overview: This lecture introduces portfolio expected return and variance calculations for different weighting schemes. It then explains the crucial distinction between systematic and unsystematic risk, demonstrating how diversification can eliminate the latter but not the former, establishing the concept of nondiversifiable risk.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the calculation of portfolio expected returns under two different weighting schemes (equal and unequal weights), including the computation of portfolio variance and standard deviation for a specific weighting example. It then defines systematic and unsystematic risk, breaking down the actual return into its expected and surprise components. The lecture concludes by exploring diversification and portfolio risk through empirical data, the principle of diversification, and the summary of total risk into its two main components.
π Lecture Summary
PORTFOLIO
We have projections on three stocks (A, B, C) across two economic states (Boom and Bust) with given probabilities. The expected returns for each stock are calculated as: E(RA) = 8.8%, E(RB) = 8.4%, E(RC) = 8.0%. For a portfolio with equal investment in each asset (weights of 1/3 each), the portfolio expected return is 8.4%. For a portfolio where Stock A has half the investment (1/2 weight) and the remainder is divided equally between B and C (1/4 each), the portfolio expected return is 8.5%.
For the unequal weighting case (A = 50%, B = 25%, C = 25%), the portfolio returns in each state are calculated: 13.75% during Boom (0.50 x 10% + 0.25 x 15% + 0.25 x 20%) and 5.00% during Bust (0.50 x 8% + 0.25 x 4% + 0.25 x 0%). The variance is calculated as ΟΒ² = 0.40 x (0.1375 - 0.085)Β² + 0.60 x (0.05 - 0.085)Β² = 0.0018375. The Standard Deviation is calculated to be 4.3%, while for the equally weighted portfolio, the standard deviation is about 5.4%.
π Definition β Portfolio Expected Return [E(RP)]: The weighted average of the expected returns of the individual assets in the portfolio, where the weights are the proportions of the total investment allocated to each asset. π Formula: E(RP) = Ξ£ (wi x E(Ri)) for all i assets β The expected return of the portfolio is the sum of each asset's weight multiplied by its expected return. π Example: For a portfolio with equal weights (1/3 each) in stocks with E(RA)=8.8%, E(RB)=8.4%, E(RC)=8.0%, the calculation is E(RP) = (1/3 x 8.8%) + (1/3 x 8.4%) + (1/3 x 8.0%) = 8.4%.
Risk
The true risk of an investment is the unanticipated or surprising part of the return. If we always receive exactly what we expect, then the investment will be risk-free. Systematic Risk (also called market risk) is a risk that influences a large number of assets, such as Gross Domestic Product (GDP), interest rates, and inflation, which affect wages, costs of supplies, asset values, and selling prices. Unsystematic Risk (also called unique or asset-specific risks) is a risk that affects a single or at most a small number of assets.
The actual return (R) of an asset can be broken down into its expected and surprise components: R = E(R) + U, where U is the surprise component. The surprise component has a systematic portion (m) and an unsystematic portion (Ξ΅), so: R = E(R) + m + Ξ΅.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the difference between systematic and unsystematic risk is fundamental because diversification can only eliminate one type (unsystematic), not the other. This distinction is the foundation of modern portfolio theory and asset pricing models.
π Definition β Systematic Risk: A risk that influences a large number of assets, also called market risk, which is nondiversifiable. π Definition β Unsystematic Risk: A risk that affects a single or at most a small number of assets, also called unique or asset-specific risk, which can be eliminated through diversification. π Formula: R = E(R) + m + Ξ΅ β The actual return equals the expected return plus the systematic surprise component plus the unsystematic surprise component.
Diversification and Portfolio Risk
If the standard deviation of annual return on a portfolio of 500 large common stocks is 20%, that does NOT mean the standard deviation of annual returns of a single stock in that portfolio is 20%. Empirical data from "How Many Stocks Make a Diversified Portfolio?" shows that the standard deviation of annual returns for a single stock is 49.24% (ratio 1.00). As the number of stocks increases, the portfolio standard deviation declines β to 23.93% with 10 stocks, 19.69% with 100 stocks, and 19.21% with 1,000 stocks. The ratio to a single stock falls to 0.49 with 10 stocks and 0.39 with 100 or more stocks.
Principle of Diversification: The benefit in terms of risk reduction from adding securities drops off as we add more securities. With 10 securities, most of the effect is already utilized, and with 30, there is very little remaining benefit. Two key points are: (1) some of the riskiness associated with individual assets can be eliminated by forming portfolios (the process called diversification), and (2) there is a minimum level of risk that cannot be eliminated simply by diversifying, called nondiversifiable risk.
If we hold a single stock, the value of our investment fluctuates because of company-specific events. If we hold a large portfolio, some stocks go up and others may go down due to company-specific events, so the net effect on the overall portfolio value is relatively small. Unsystematic risk is essentially eliminated by diversification, while systematic risk cannot be eliminated because it affects almost all assets to some degree. The size or type of portfolio has little effect on systematic risk, making it nondiversifiable risk.
Summarizing: Total risk = Systematic risk + Unsystematic risk. Systematic risk is also called nondiversifiable risk or market risk.
π‘ Why this matters: The table showing standard deviation for portfolios of different sizes provides the empirical evidence for why holding a diversified portfolio (around 30-100 stocks) is the most efficient way to reduce risk without sacrificing expected return.
β Key Takeaways
You must understand that portfolio expected return is simply a weighted average of individual asset returns and can be calculated for any set of weights. The critical distinction for risk is that systematic risk (market risk) affects many assets and cannot be eliminated by diversification, while unsystematic risk (unique risk) is specific to individual assets and can be essentially eliminated by holding a diversified portfolio. The data shows that by holding 100 randomly chosen stocks, the portfolio's standard deviation declines by about 60% from 49% to 20%, but after 30 stocks, the benefit from additional diversification is very small, revealing an irreducible level of nondiversifiable risk.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- In the lecture's example, what is the portfolio expected return for equal investment in all three stocks with E(RA)=8.8%, E(RB)=8.4%, and E(RC)=8.0%?
- What are the two types of risk that constitute the "surprise component" (U) in the formula R = E(R) + U?
- According to the empirical data, approximately how much does the portfolio standard deviation decline (in percentage terms) when moving from 1 stock to 100 stocks?
- What is the principle of diversification, and what is the name for the minimum level of risk that cannot be eliminated?
- Why can a large portfolio eliminate unsystematic risk but not systematic risk?