π Lecture 23 β ZERO GROWTH STOCKS
π Overview: This lecture covers three main types of stock valuation models based on dividend patterns: zero growth stocks, constant growth stocks, and non-constant growth stocks. Understanding these models is essential for determining the fair value of common shares in different dividend scenarios.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers zero growth stocks valued as perpetuities, constant growth stocks using the dividend growth model, the relationship between stock price growth and dividend growth, and non-constant growth stocks where dividends change over time before settling into steady growth. It includes multiple numerical examples demonstrating each valuation approach.
π Lecture Summary
ZERO GROWTH STOCKS
A share of common stock in a company with a constant dividend is termed as zero growth type of stocks. This implies that Dβ = Dβ = Dβ = D = constant. Since the dividend is always the same, the stock can be viewed as an ordinary perpetuity with a cash flow equal to D every period.
The per share value is Pβ = D/R, where R is the required rate of return.
π Definition β Zero Growth Stock: A common stock where dividends remain constant over time, never growing.
π Formula: Pβ = D/R β The stock price equals the constant dividend divided by the required rate of return.
π Example: CVP corporation has a policy of paying a $10 per share dividend every year indefinitely. If the required rate of return is 20%, the value of a share is $10/0.20 = $50 per share.
Constant Growth Stocks
Stocks where dividends grow at a steady rate are termed as having a growth rate g. If we let Dβ be the dividend just paid, then the next dividend Dβ is Dβ = Dβ Γ (1 + g). The dividend in two periods is Dβ = Dβ Γ (1 + g) = Dβ Γ (1 + g)Β². Generalizing: Dβ = Dβ Γ (1 + g)α΅.
An asset with cash flows that grow at a constant rate forever is called a growing perpetuity. The reason for constant growth of dividend lies in the fact that companies have this aspect as an explicit goal.
As long as the growth rate g is less than the discount rate R, the present value of cash flows can be written as Pβ = Dβ(1 + g)/(R - g) = Dβ/(R - g). This is commonly known as the dividend growth model.
π Definition β Constant Growth Stock: A stock where dividends grow at a constant rate g every period.
π Formula: Pβ = Dβ/(R - g) = Dβ(1 + g)/(R - g) β The stock price equals next year's dividend divided by the difference between the required return and the growth rate.
π Example: Suppose Dβ is $2.30, R is 13% and g is 5%. The price per share is Pβ = $2.30 Γ 1.05/(0.13 - 0.05) = $2.415/0.08 = $30.19.
The price of the stock at any time t is Pβ = Dβ(1 + g)/(R - g) = Dβββ/(R - g). The dividend growth model makes the implicit assumption that the stock price will grow at the same constant rate as the dividend. Pβ = Pβ Γ (1 + g)β΄.
If the growth rate g is bigger than discount rate R, then the present value of dividends keeps getting bigger and bigger, so the stock price is infinitely large. The same is true if growth rate and discount rate are equal.
π Formula for any growing perpetuity: PV = Cβ/(R - g) = Cβ(1 + g)/(R - g)
π Example β GG Company: The next dividend is $4 per share, investors require 16% return, and dividends grow by 6% every year. The price today is Pβ = $4/(0.16 - 0.06) = $40. The dividend in 4 years is Dβ = $4 Γ 1.06Β³ = $4.764. The price in 4 years is Pβ = $4.764 Γ 1.06/(0.16 - 0.06) = $5.05/0.10 = $50.50. Verify: Pβ = $40 Γ 1.06β΄ = $50.50. π‘ Why this matters: This shows that stock price grows at the same rate as dividends in the constant growth model.
Non-Constant Growth Stocks
Consider a company currently not paying any dividends. You predict in 5 years the company will pay a dividend for the first time, say $0.50, growing at 10% per year indefinitely. The required rate is 20%.
First calculate what it will be worth once dividends are paid, then calculate the present value of that future price to get today's price. The 1st dividend will be paid in 5 years. The price in 4 years will be Pβ = Dβ /(R - g) = $0.50/(0.20 - 0.10) = $5. Current value by discounting back four years at 20%: Pβ = $5/1.20β΄ = $5/2.0736 = $2.41.
For non-constant growth with dividends in intermediate years: Consider dividend forecasts: Year 1 = $1.00, Year 2 = $2.00, Year 3 = $2.50. After year 3, dividend grows at constant 5% per year. Required return is 10%.
First compute the present value of the stock price three years down the road, then add the present value of dividends paid between now and then. The price in 3 years is Pβ = Dβ(1 + g)/(R - g) = $2.50 Γ 1.05/(0.10 - 0.05) = $52.50.
Total value: Pβ = Dβ/(1+R)ΒΉ + Dβ/(1+R)Β² + Dβ/(1+R)Β³ + Pβ/(1+R)Β³ = $1/1.10 + $2/1.10Β² + $2.50/1.10Β³ + $52.50/1.10Β³ = $0.91 + $1.65 + $1.88 + $39.44 = $43.88.
π Definition β Non-Constant Growth Stock: A stock where dividends grow at different rates over different time periods before eventually settling into constant growth.
β Key Takeaways
The three stock valuation models depend entirely on the dividend pattern: zero growth uses the perpetuity formula Pβ = D/R, constant growth uses the dividend growth model Pβ = Dβ/(R-g) where stock price grows at the same rate g as dividends, and non-constant growth requires discounting each dividend separately plus the terminal price. The growth rate must always be less than the required return for finite stock prices. For non-constant growth, always compute the future stock price when dividends become constant, then discount everything back to present.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for a zero growth stock and why does it work?
- Under what condition does the constant growth model give an infinite stock price?
- In the GG Company example, why is Pβ exactly equal to Pβ Γ (1+g)β΄?
- For a non-constant growth stock that pays its first dividend in 5 years, why do we compute the stock price in year 4 (not year 5)?
- In the last example with dividends of $1, $2, and $2.50, what is Dβ and how is it used?
π Lecture 24 β NON-CONSTANT GROWTH STOCKS
π Overview: This lecture examines stock valuation when growth rates are not constant, using a case study of supernormal growth. It also explores the components of required return and provides a detailed overview of common and preferred stock features, including shareholder rights, dividend policies, and the structure of stock markets.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers non-constant growth stock valuation using the CR Inc. supernormal growth case, calculation of dividends during supernormal and stable growth periods, and determination of stock price using present value of future dividends. It then explains the components of required return (dividend yield and capital gains yield) and provides a summary of stock valuation methods. Finally, it discusses common stock features including shareholder rights, cumulative vs. straight voting, proxy voting, classes of stock, dividends, and preferred stock features, along with an overview of primary and secondary stock markets.
π Lecture Summary
Non-Constant Growth Stocks
Companies may experience periods of supernormal growth where growth rates are unsustainably high for a limited time. To value such stocks, we must calculate dividends during the supernormal growth period and then find the stock price when growth stabilizes. The price at the end of the supernormal period is calculated using the constant growth model for the long-run growth rate.
CR Inc.: A Case of Supernormal Growth
- Company growing at 30% per year for 3 more years, then drops to 10% indefinitely.
- Total dividends just paid: $5 million; required return: 20%.
- Year 1 Dividend: $5.00 Γ 1.3 = $6.500 million
- Year 2 Dividend: $6.50 Γ 1.3 = $8.450 million
- Year 3 Dividend: $8.45 Γ 1.3 = $10.985 million
The price at time 3 (Pβ) is calculated using the long-run growth rate (g = 10%): Pβ = Dβ Γ (1 + g) / (R - g) Pβ = $10.985 Γ 1.10 / (0.20 β 0.10) = $120.835 million
To determine the value today (Pβ), we need the present value of all dividends plus the present value of Pβ: Pβ = Dβ/(1+R)ΒΉ + Dβ/(1+R)Β² + Dβ/(1+R)Β³ + Pβ/(1+R)Β³ Pβ = $6.50/1.10ΒΉ + $8.45/1.10Β² + $10.985/1.10Β³ + $120.835/1.10Β³ Pβ = $5.42 + $5.87 + $6.36 + $69.93 = $87.58 million
π Per share value: $87.58 million / 20 million shares = $4.38 per share
Components of Required Return
From the dividend growth model Pβ = Dβ/(R - g), rearranging to solve for R gives: R = Dβ/Pβ + g
This tells us total return (R) has two components:
- Dividend Yield (Dβ/Pβ): Expected cash dividend divided by current price, similar to current yield on a bond
- Capital Gains Yield (g): The rate at which stock price grows
π Example: Stock selling for $20/share, next dividend $1, growth rate 10%. R = $1/20 + 10% = 5% + 10% = 15% Verify: Pβ = $1 Γ 1.10 / (0.15 β 0.10) = $1.10/0.05 = $22 Stock price grew by 10% ($20 to $22); dividend yield = $1/$20 = 5%; capital gains yield = $2/$20 = 10%; total return = 15%.
π‘ Why this matters: This decomposition helps investors understand expected sources of return and compare stocks with different growth characteristics.
Summary of Stock Valuation
- General Case: Pβ = present value of all future dividends Dβ, Dβ, Dβ..., discounted at required return R
- Constant Growth: If dividend grows at steady rate g, Pβ = Dβ/(R - g) β the dividend growth model
- Zero Growth: If dividend is constant (g=0), Pβ = D/R
- Non-constant Growth: Requires calculating dividends period-by-period during supernormal growth, then using constant growth model for stable period
- Required return: R = Dβ/Pβ (dividend yield) + g (capital gains yield)
Common Stock Features
Common stocks have no special preference either in paying dividends or in bankruptcy.
Shareholder Rights: Shareholders control the organization by electing directors who hire management.
Cumulative Voting: Permits minority participation. Total votes = number of shares Γ number of directors to be elected. Votes can be distributed however the shareholder wishes.
- A formula: [1/(N+1)% of stocks + 1] shares guarantees a seat, where N = number of directors to be elected.
- π Example: Sami (20 shares) and Junaid (80 shares) electing 4 directors. Sami casts 20Γ4=80 votes for himself; Junaid casts 80Γ4=320 votes but cannot give all 4 candidates more than 80 votes each. Sami is guaranteed a seat.
Straight Voting: Directors elected one at a time. Majority shareholder (50%+1 shares) wins all seats β "all or nothing."
Staggering: Only a fraction of directors are up for election at one time. Makes it harder for minority to elect a director under cumulative voting and makes takeover attempts less likely.
Proxy Voting: A proxy is a grant of authority to someone else to vote the shareholder's shares. Management seeks proxies; dissatisfied shareholders may start a proxy fight to replace management.
Classes of Stocks: Some firms have multiple classes with unequal voting rights, primarily to raise equity while maintaining control.
Other Rights: Right to share proportionately in dividends; right to share in assets after liquidation; right to vote on major matters (e.g., mergers); preemptive right β right to share proportionately in any new stock sold before it's offered to the public.
Dividends: Return on capital paid to shareholders at the discretion of the board of directors.
- Not a liability unless declared
- Not a business expense (not tax deductible)
- Dividends received by individuals are ordinary income (fully taxable); corporations can exclude a percentage of dividends received from other corporations
Preferred Stock Features
Preferred stock has dividend priority over common stock, normally with fixed dividend rate, sometimes without voting rights. Preference means preferred shareholders must receive dividends before common shareholders.
Stated Value: Preferred shares have stated liquidating value; dividends are described in dollars per share.
Accumulation of Dividends: Most preferred dividends are cumulative β if not paid in a year, they are carried forward as arrearage. Unpaid preferred dividends are not debts; directors can defer indefinitely, but common stockholders must also forego dividends.
Is Preferred Stock Debt? Preferred shareholders receive stated dividends and stated value; hold credit ratings like bonds; sometimes convertible into common stock and callable.
The Stock Market
- Primary Market: Where new securities are originally sold to investors (companies raise money)
- Secondary Market: Where previously issued securities are traded among investors
Dealer: Buys and sells securities from maintained inventory. Bid price = price dealer pays; ask price = price dealer sells; difference = spread.
Broker: Arranges transactions among investors without buying/selling for own account; facilitates trades.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) For non-constant growth stocks, you must calculate dividends during the supernormal period, find the terminal price using the constant growth model, then discount everything back to present value; (2) Required return R = Dividend Yield (Dβ/Pβ) + Capital Gains Yield (g), where g is both the dividend growth rate and the stock price appreciation rate; (3) Cumulative voting protects minority shareholders, with [1/(N+1)% + 1 share] guaranteeing a board seat, while straight voting allows majority control; (4) Preferred stock has dividend priority over common stock, accumulated dividends may be carried forward as arrearage, and payment is at the board's discretion; (5) The primary market involves new securities issuance to raise capital, while the secondary market involves trading existing securities between investors through dealers (who maintain inventory) or brokers (who match buyers and sellers).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- In the CR Inc. example, what is the terminal stock price (Pβ) and how is it calculated using the long-run growth rate?
- What are the two components of required return R according to the dividend growth model, and what does each represent?
- Under cumulative voting, what percentage of shares plus one share guarantees a board seat when N directors are to be elected?
- What is the difference between cumulative voting and straight voting in terms of minority shareholder representation?
- What distinguishes a dealer from a broker in the stock market, and what are the bid price, ask price, and spread?
π Lecture 25 β Preferred Stock Features
π Overview: This lecture introduces the features of preferred stock, including dividend priority, cumulative dividends, and the distinction between debt and equity. It then explains the structure of stock markets (primary vs. secondary) and the roles of dealers and brokers. Finally, it introduces capital budgeting and the concept of Net Present Value (NPV) for evaluating investment decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers preferred stock features like stated value and cumulative dividends, and debates whether preferred stock is debt or equity. It then distinguishes between primary and secondary stock markets, defining dealers and brokers. The main topic shifts to capital budgeting, focusing on estimating Net Present Value (NPV) and its rule for accepting or rejecting projects.
π Lecture Summary
Preferred Stock Features
Preferred stock has dividend priority over common stock, normally with a fixed dividend rate, sometimes without voting rights. "Preference" means preferred shareholders must receive a dividend before common shareholders are entitled to anything. Preferred shares have a stated liquidating value, and the cash dividend is described in dollars per share. A preferred dividend is not like bond interest; directors may decide not to pay it irrespective of net income. Dividends on preferred stock may be cumulative or non-cumulative; most are cumulative. If preferred stocks are cumulative and not paid in a particular year, they are carried forward as an arrearage. Unpaid preferred dividends are not debts of the firm. Directors can defer the preferred dividend indefinitely, but common stockholders must also forego dividends. Sometimes delayed payments are compensated by voting rights.
π Definition β Cumulative Preferred Stock: A type of preferred stock where unpaid dividends accumulate and must be paid before any dividends can be paid to common stockholders.
Is Preferred Stock Debt or Equity?
Preferred shareholders are only entitled to receive a stated dividend and the stated value of their shares. Preferred stocks hold credit ratings much like bonds. They are sometimes convertible into common stock and are often callable.
The Stock Market
Shares of stock are bought and sold at stock exchanges. The stock market consists of the primary market (where new securities are originally sold to investors; companies sell securities to raise money) and the secondary market (where previously issued securities are traded among investors).
π Definition β Dealer: An agent who buys and sells securities from a maintained inventory, standing ready to buy from investors wishing to sell and sell to investors wishing to buy. The price the dealer wishes to pay is the bid price; the price they sell for is the ask price. The difference is the spread.
π Definition β Broker: An agent who arranges security transactions among investors, matching buyers with sellers, without buying or selling for their own accounts.
Capital Budgeting
Capital budgeting asks: "What long-term investment should the firm take on?" An investment is worth undertaking if it creates value, characterized by its worth in the marketplace being more than its cost. For example, buying a run-down house for $25,000, spending $25,000 on repairs (total $50,000), and then finding it is worth $60,000. The market value ($60,000) exceeds the cost ($50,000) by $10,000, creating $10,000 in value. A manager must identify the feasibility of investing $50,000 ahead of time β determining whether a proposed project will be worth more than it costs. The difference between an investment's market value and its cost is called the Net Present Value (NPV) . NPV measures how much value is created or added today by undertaking an investment. Capital budgeting is a search for investments with positive NPVs. Investment decisions are simplified when a market exists for similar assets; otherwise, we must estimate value using indirect market information.
π‘ Why this matters: NPV is the core tool for determining if a project increases shareholder value.
Estimating Net Present Value
To estimate the value of a new business (e.g., fertilizer), we:
- Estimate future cash flows.
- Apply discounted cash flow (DCF) to estimate the present value of cash flows.
- Estimate the difference between the present value of future cash flows and the cost of investment.
Example:
- Cash revenues: $20,000 per year
- Cash costs (including taxes): $14,000 per year
- Business life: 8 years
- Salvage value in 8 years: $2,000
- Project cost to launch: $30,000
- Discount rate: 15%
- Shares outstanding: 1,000
π Formula: Present Value (PV) = PV of annuity + PV of lump sum PV = $6,000 x (1 β 1/1.15βΈ) / 0.15 + $2,000 / 1.15βΈ PV = $6,000 x 4.4873 + $2,000 / 3.0590 PV = $26,924 + $654 = $27,578
π Formula: Net Present Value (NPV) = Present Value of future cash flows β Initial Cost NPV = -$30,000 + $27,578 = -$2,422
π Example: Since NPV is negative (-$2,422), this is not a good investment. It would decrease the total value of stock by $2,422. With 1,000 shares outstanding, the impact is a loss of $2,422 / 1,000 = -$2.422 per share. If NPV were positive, the effect would be favorable.
This leads to the Net Present Value Rule: βAn investment should be accepted if the net present value is positive and rejected if it is negative.β If NPV is zero, we are indifferent. The task of coming up with cash flows and the discount rate is more important than the discounting process itself.
β Key Takeaways
Preferred stock has dividend priority over common stock, often with a cumulative feature where unpaid dividends accumulate as arrearage. The stock market consists of primary and secondary markets, with dealers buying/selling from inventory (earning the bid-ask spread) and brokers matching buyers and sellers. Capital budgeting uses NPV analysis: a project is accepted if its present value of future cash flows exceeds its initial cost (positive NPV), increasing shareholder value. The discounted cash flow (DCF) method is used to estimate the present value of future cash flows, and the NPV rule is the fundamental decision criterion for investments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does "cumulative" mean when referring to preferred stock dividends?
- What is the difference between a dealer and a broker in the stock market?
- A project costs $100,000 and is expected to generate a present value of future cash flows of $95,000. Should the project be accepted according to the NPV rule?
- In the NPV calculation example, why was the investment considered "not good"?
- What is the primary goal for a firm when using Net Present Value in capital budgeting?
π Lecture 26 β Using NPV
π Overview: This lecture explores the Net Present Value (NPV) rule for investment decisions and introduces the Payback Period as an alternative capital budgeting method. It demonstrates how NPV guides value-maximizing choices while critically examining the payback rule's strengths and weaknesses.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the NPV rule and a practical example of launching a new product with projected cash flows over five years. It then introduces the Payback Period rule, showing how to calculate it using various examples, including a project with multiple payback periods. Finally, it compares the two methods, highlighting the payback rule's shortcomings like ignoring time value of money and its advantages like simplicity and liquidity focus.
π Lecture Summary
USING NPV
Given that the goal of financial management is to increase share value, the net present value rule states: "An investment should be accepted if the net present value is positive and rejected if it is negative." In the unlikely event that NPV is zero, we would be indifferent between taking and not taking the investment. Two important comments are made: first, the task of coming up with cash flows and the discount rate is much more important than the process of discounting itself. Second, the process of discounting cash flows only gives an estimated figure of NPV; the true NPV can be found by putting the investment for sale and seeing what we got for it.
π‘ Why this matters: The NPV rule directly links investment decisions to the goal of maximizing shareholder wealth.
Suppose we are asked to decide whether or not to launch a new product. Based on projected costs and sales, we expect cash flows over a 5-year life to be $2,000 in the first two years, $4,000 in the next two, and $5,000 in the last year. It would cost about $10,000 to begin production. Given a 10% discount rate, we calculate the total value of the product by discounting its cash flow to present: PV = $2,000/1.1 + 2,000/1.1Β² + 4,000/1.1Β³ + 4,000/1.1β΄ + 5,000/1.1β΅ = $1,818 + 1,653 + 3,005 + 2,732 + 3,105 = $12,313 The present value of expected cash flows is $12,313, but the cost is $10,000, so the NPV is $12,313 β 10,000 = $2,313. Based on the NPV rule, we should take on the project.
π Definition β Net Present Value (NPV) Rule: An investment should be accepted if the net present value is positive and rejected if it is negative.
The Payback Rule
The payback period is the amount of time required for an investment to generate cash flows sufficient to recover its initial cost. The rule is: "An investment is acceptable if its calculated payback period is less than some specified number of years."
π Definition β Payback Period: The amount of time required for an investment to generate cash flows sufficient to recover its initial cost.
Suppose the initial investment is $60,000, and the cash flows are $20,000 in the first year and $90,000 in the second. The cash flows over the first two years are $110,000, so the project pays back sometime in the second year. After the first year, the project has paid back $20,000, leaving $40,000 to be recovered. This $40,000 is $40,000/90,000 = 4/9 of the second year's cash flows. Spreading this ratio over 365 days: 4/9 x 365 β 162 days, meaning the payback period is just over 1 year and 5 months.
π Example: The projected cash flows from a proposed investment are: Year 1: $100, Year 2: $200, Year 3: $500. The project costs $500. After the first 2 years, cash flows total $300. After the 3rd year, the total cash flow is $800, so the project pays back between the end of year 2 and end of year 3. Out of $500 cash flows for the 3rd year, we need to cover $200, so we wait $200/500 = 0.40 years. The payback period is 2.4 years or about two years and five months.
Considering Projects A through E:
- Project A: Payback period is 2.6 years
- Project B: Never pays back
- Project C: Payback period is 4 years
- Project D: Has two payback periods (2 and 4 years, both correct)
- Project E: Unrealistic but pays back in 6 months, illustrating that a rapid payback does not guarantee a good investment
Compared to NPV, the payback period rule has several shortcomings: time value of money is ignored, it fails to consider risk differences, and it doesn't provide an objective basis for a particular cutoff period. The primary shortcomings are: by ignoring time value, we may be led to take investments worth less than they cost; by ignoring cash flows beyond cutoff, we may reject profitable long-term investments. Generally, it tends to bias us towards shorter-term investments.
However, the qualities of the payback period rule include: simple and easy to calculate, useful for large numbers of small investment decisions by corporations; its bias towards short-term projects emphasizes liquidity, i.e., quickly freeing up cash for other uses; and it adjusts for more uncertain cash flows expected later in a project's life (though by ignoring them altogether).
π Example: Consider Long-term vs. Short-term investments:
- Short: Year 0: -$250, Year 1: $100, Year 2: $200 (payback = 1 + $150/200 = 1.75 years)
- Long: Year 0: -$250, Year 1: $100, Year 2: $100, Year 3: $100, Year 4: $100 (payback = 2 + $50/100 = 2.5 years) With a cutoff of two years, Short is accepted and Long is not. However, requiring a 15% return: NPV (Short) = -$250 + 100/1.15 + 200/1.15Β² = -$11.81 NPV (Long) = -$250 + 100 x (1 β 1/1.15β΄)/.15 = $35.5 The NPV of the shorter-term investment is negative, diminishing shareholder equity, while the longer-term investment increases share value.
Summary
The payback period is a break-even measure in an accounting sense but not in an economic sense. It does not focus on the right issue of the impact of an investment on the value of stock. Its simplicity is helpful for decisions on minor investments.
Advantages: Easy to understand, adjusts for uncertainty of later cash flows, biased towards liquidity. Disadvantages: Ignores the time value of money, requires an arbitrary cutoff point, ignores cash flows beyond the cutoff date, biased against long-term projects such as research and development and new projects.
β Key Takeaways
The NPV rule is the theoretically correct method for investment decisions because it directly measures the increase in shareholder value, accepting projects only when NPV is positive. The payback period, while simple and useful for emphasizing liquidity, has serious flaws: it ignores the time value of money, requires an arbitrary cutoff, and disregards cash flows after the payback point, potentially leading to value-destroying decisions by favoring short-term projects over profitable long-term ones.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to the NPV rule, when should an investment be accepted?
- What is the payback period for a project costing $500 with cash flows of $100 in year 1, $200 in year 2, and $500 in year 3?
- Why might the payback rule lead to a decision that reduces shareholder value?
- What are the two primary shortcomings of the payback period rule?
- Give one advantage and one disadvantage of using the payback period rule.
π Lecture 27 β Average Accounting Return
π Overview: This lecture introduces two capital budgeting techniques: Average Accounting Return (AAR) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR). It explains how AAR uses accounting profits rather than cash flows, while IRR focuses on the discount rate that makes NPV zero, and highlights the strengths and weaknesses of both methods.
ποΈ Topics Covered
First, Average Accounting Return is defined and illustrated through a store investment example with a 5-year life, showing how average net income and average book value are calculated. Then, Internal Rate of Return is introduced as the discount rate that makes NPV zero, with trial-and-error calculation methods. Finally, Problems with IRR are examined, including non-conventional cash flows causing multiple rates of return and issues with mutually exclusive investments where NPV should be used instead of IRR for ranking decisions.
π Lecture Summary
Average Accounting Return
It is defined as some measure of average accounting profit divided by some measure of average accounting value. Specifically, it uses average net income and average book value.
A store investment example is provided:
- Required investment in improvements: $500,000
- Store has a 5-year life; investment is 100% depreciated over 5 years: $500,000 / 5 = $100,000 per year
- Tax rate is 25%
The projected financials are:
| Year | Revenue | Expenses | Earnings before depreciation | Depreciation | Earnings before taxes | Taxes (25%) | Net income |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $433,333 | $200,000 | $233,333 | $100,000 | $133,333 | $33,333 | $100,000 |
| 2 | $450,000 | $150,000 | $300,000 | $100,000 | $200,000 | $50,000 | $150,000 |
| 3 | $266,667 | $100,000 | $166,667 | $100,000 | $66,667 | $16,667 | $50,000 |
| 4 | $200,000 | $100,000 | $100,000 | $100,000 | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| 5 | $133,333 | $100,000 | $33,333 | $100,000 | -$66,667 | -$16,667 | -$50,000 |
- Average net income is: [$100,000 + 150,000 + 50,000 + 0 + (-50,000)] / 5 = $50,000
- Average book value = ($500,000 + 0) / 2 = $250,000
π Formula: AAR = Average net income / Average book value = $50,000 / $250,000 = 0.20 or 20%
The AAR rule states: βA project is acceptable if its average accounting return exceeds a target average accounting return.β
Drawbacks of AAR:
- It is not a rate of return in any meaningful economic sense, as it ignores the time value of money.
- It lacks an objective or target AAR to be compared with.
- It focuses on net income and book value rather than cash flow and market value.
Advantages:
- Easy to calculate.
- Needed information will usually be available.
Internal Rate of Return
With IRR, we try to find a single rate of return that summarizes the merits of a project. This rate is an βinternalβ rate because it only depends on the cash flows of a particular investment, not on rates offered elsewhere.
Consider a project that costs $100 today and pays $110 in one year. It pays a return of 10%, which is the internal rate of return.
The IRR Rule states: βBased on IRR rule an investment is acceptable if the IRR exceeds the required return. It should be rejected otherwise.β
For this example, the NPV at discount rate R is: NPV = -$100 + 110/(1 + R). To find the break-even discount rate, we set NPV equal to zero and solve for R:
- NPV = 0 = -$100 + 110/(1 + R)
- $100 = $110/(1 + R)
- 1 + R = $110/100 = 1.10
- R = 10%
Thus, βthe IRR on an investment is the required return that results in a zero NPV when it is used as the discount rate.β
For a more complicated investment with cash flows of $60 per year for two years and a cost of $100, we find IRR by equating NPV to zero: NPV = 0 = -$100 + 60/(1 + IRR) + 60/(1 + IRR)Β²
The IRR is found by trial and error:
- At 0%: NPV = $20.00
- At 10%: NPV = $4.13
- At 15%: NPV = -$2.46
The IRR is about 13.1%. If the required return is less than 13.1%, we would take this investment; otherwise, reject it.
Another example: A project costs $435.44 with cash flows of $100 in year 1, $200 in year 2, and $300 in year 3.
- At 0%: NPV = $164.56
- At 10%: NPV = $46.15
- At 15%: NPV = $0.00
- At 20%: NPV = -$39.61
The IRR is 15%. At 18% required return, we should not take this investment because the IRR (15%) is less than the required return (18%).
IRR and NPV rules always lead to identical decisions as long as:
- Projectβs cash flows are conventional (first cash flow is negative and rest are positive).
- Projects are independent (decision to accept or reject one project does not affect others).
π‘ Why this matters: The NPV profile graph shows that when NPV > 0, the discount rate is less than the IRR, and when NPV < 0, the discount rate is greater than the IRR, confirming that IRR is the break-even point.
Problems with IRR
Problems with IRR arise when cash flows are non-conventional or when comparing two or more investments.
Non-conventional Cash Flows: A mining project requires a $60 investment. Cash flows in year 1 are $155, but in year 2, $100 must be spent to restore the terrain, making both year 0 and year 2 negative.
- At 0%: NPV = -$5.00
- At 10%: NPV = -$1.74
- At 20%: NPV = -$0.28
- At 30%: NPV = $0.06
- At 40%: NPV = -$0.31
This creates a multiple rates of return problem, with IRRs of 25% and 33β %. The NPV is positive only if the required return is between 25% and 33β %. The IRR rule breaks down completely here, while NPV works just fine.
π‘ Moral of the Story: When cash flows are not conventional, the obvious question βWhat is the rate of return?β may not be answered, although NPV works just fine.
Mutually Exclusive Investments: If two investments are mutually exclusive, taking one means you cannot take the other. The question is: βwhich investment is best?β The answer is the one with the largest NPV.
Example of mutually exclusive investments:
| Year | Investment A | Investment B |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | -$100 | -$100 |
| 1 | $50 | $20 |
| 2 | $40 | $40 |
| 3 | $40 | $50 |
| 4 | $30 | $60 |
- IRR for A is 24%
- IRR for B is 21%
NPV at different discount rates:
| Discount rate | NPV (A) | NPV (B) |
|---|---|---|
| 0% | $60.00 | $70.00 |
| 5% | $43.13 | $47.88 |
| 10% | $29.06 | $29.79 |
| 15% | $17.18 | $14.82 |
| 20% | $7.06 | $2.31 |
| 25% | -$1.63 | -$8.22 |
The crossover point is at approximately 11.1%.
- At discount rates less than 11.1%, NPV for B is higher, so B is better even though A has a higher IRR.
- At discount rates greater than 11.1%, NPV for A is higher, so A is better.
Moral of the Story: Whenever we have mutually exclusive investments, we should not rank them based on their returns. IRR can be misleading in determining the best investment. Instead, we should look at their relative NPVs to avoid the possibility of choosing incorrectly.
Qualities of IRR:
- Most widely used capital budgeting method.
- Easily communicated and understood.
- We can estimate IRR even if we donβt know the discount rate.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture contrasts AAR and IRR as capital budgeting tools. AAR is simple but flawed because it uses accounting profits and ignores the time value of money. IRR is more widely used as it focuses on cash flows and the discount rate that makes NPV zero; however, IRR can be misleading with non-conventional cash flows (causing multiple rates of return) and when comparing mutually exclusive investments where NPV should be the deciding factor. The fundamental takeaway is that for mutually exclusive projects, always use NPV for ranking decisions, not IRR.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for Average Accounting Return (AAR), and what are its main drawbacks?
- How is the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) defined in relation to Net Present Value (NPV)?
- Under what conditions do the IRR and NPV rules always lead to identical decisions?
- What problem arises when calculating IRR for a project with non-conventional cash flows?
- When comparing two mutually exclusive investments, why might the one with a lower IRR be the better choice?
π Lecture 28 β PROFITABILITY INDEX
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Profitability Index (PI) as a capital budgeting tool that measures value created per dollar invested. It also discusses why firms use multiple evaluation criteria in practice and provides a historical comparison of capital budgeting techniques used by CFOs.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and calculation of Profitability Index, its advantages and disadvantages, ranking problems with mutually exclusive investments, capital budgeting practice under uncertainty, historical trends in usage of various capital budgeting techniques (Payback, AAR, IRR, NPV), and a summary of all investment criteria including discounted cash flow methods and accounting criteria.
π Lecture Summary
PROFITABILITY INDEX
The Profitability Index (PI), also called the benefit-cost ratio, is defined as the present value of the future cash flows divided by the initial investment. If a project costs $200 and the present value of its future cash flows is $220, then PI = $220 / 200 = 1.10. The NPV for this investment is $20, making it desirable. For a positive NPV investment, PI will be greater than 1.00, and less than 1.00 for a negative NPV investment.
The PI of 1.10 tells us that per dollar invested, $1.10 in value or $0.10 in NPV results. Thus, PI measures value created per dollar invested. It is often proposed as a measure of performance for government or other non-profit investments. When capital is scarce, it is a sensible approach to allocate it to those projects with the highest PI.
π Definition β Profitability Index (PI): The present value of future cash flows divided by the initial investment. π Formula: PI = PV of Future Cash Flows / Initial Investment β measures value created per dollar invested. π Example: An investment costs $5 and has a $10 PV (NPV = $5, PI = 2). Another investment costs $100 and has a $150 PV (NPV = $50, PI = 1.50). If these are mutually exclusive, the second is preferred despite a lower PI, because it creates more total value.
Ranking Problem: The Profitability Index can lead to incorrect decisions when comparing mutually exclusive investments, similar to the ranking problem with IRR. While PI shows value per dollar, a lower PI project may create more total NPV.
Advantages of PI:
- Closely related to NPV, generally leading to identical decisions
- Easy to understand and communicate
- May be useful when available investment funds are limited
Disadvantages of PI:
- May lead to incorrect decisions in comparisons of mutually exclusive investments
Capital Budgeting Practice
Firms use alternative procedures even though NPV seems to tell us directly what we want to know because we operate under considerable uncertainty. We can only estimate the NPV, and the true NPV might be quite different. Since the true NPV is unknown, the financial manager seeks clues to assess the reliability of the estimated NPV. For this purpose, firms often use multiple criteria for evaluating a proposal.
If an investment has a positive NPV, a short payback, and a very high AAR, all indicators give a green signal β payback and AAR are consistent with the conclusion that NPV is positive. If there is a positive estimated NPV, a long payback, and a low AAR, this could be a good investment, but we should be much more careful since we are getting conflicting signals. If the estimated NPV is based on projections in which we have little confidence, then further analysis is probably in order.
π‘ Why this matters: Multiple criteria help managers assess the reliability of NPV estimates and avoid making decisions based on unreliable projections.
A Historical Comparison of Primary Use of Various Capital Budgeting Techniques (1959-1981):
- Payback period declined from 34% (1959) to 5.0% (1981)
- Average Accounting Return declined from 34% (1959) to 10.7% (1981)
- Internal Rate of Return increased from 19% (1959) to 65.3% (1981)
- NPV started from 0% (1959) and grew to 16.5% (1981)
- IRR or NPV combined grew from 19% (1959) to 81.8% (1981)
Percentage of CFOs Who Always Use a Given Technique in 2000:
| Technique | Percentage Always/Almost Always | Overall Score | Large Firms | Small Firms |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| IRR | 76% | 3.09 | 3.41 | 2.87 |
| NPV | 75% | 3.08 | 3.42 | 2.83 |
| Payback Period | 57% | 2.53 | 2.55 | 2.72 |
| Discounted Payback | 29% | 1.56 | 1.55 | 1.58 |
| AAR | 20% | 1.34 | 1.25 | 1.41 |
| Profitability Index | 12% | 0.83 | 0.75 | 0.88 |
Summary of Investment Criteria
1. Discounted Cash Flow Criteria: Net Present Value (NPV)
- The NPV of an investment is the difference between its market value and its cost.
- The NPV rule is to take a project if its NPV is positive.
- It is estimated by calculating the present value of the future cash flows and then subtracting the cost.
2. Discounted Cash Flow Criteria: Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
- IRR is the discount rate that makes the estimated NPV of an investment equal to zero.
- IRR rule is to take a project when its IRR exceeds the required return.
- It leads to the same decision as NPV for conventional, independent projects.
- For mutually exclusive and non-conventional projects, IRR may be misleading.
3. Discounted Cash Flow Criteria: Profitability Index (PI)
- PI is the ratio of present value to cost. It measures the present value of an investment per dollar invested.
- PI rule is to take an investment if the index exceeds 1.
- It is sometimes used to rank projects when a firm has more positive NPV investments than it can currently finance.
4. Accounting Criteria: Average Accounting Return (AAR)
- AAR is a measure of accounting profit relative to book value.
- AAR rule is to take an investment if its AAR exceeds a benchmark AAR.
5. Payback Criteria: Payback Period
- It is the length of time until the sum of an investment's cash flows equals its costs.
- Payback period rule is to take a project if its payback is less than some cutoff.
- It ignores risk, time value of money, and cash flows beyond the cutoff point.
β Key Takeaways
The Profitability Index measures value created per dollar invested and is useful when capital is scarce, but it may lead to incorrect decisions for mutually exclusive investments, similar to the IRR ranking problem. Firms use multiple capital budgeting criteria simultaneously because NPV estimates are uncertain, and conflicting signals from different methods indicate the need for further analysis. Historical data shows a clear shift away from Payback and AAR toward discounted cash flow methods (IRR and NPV), with IRR and NPV being used by over 75% of CFOs by 2000, while PI remains the least used technique at only 12%.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- If a project costs $500 and the present value of its future cash flows is $600, what is its Profitability Index and what does it tell us?
- Why might a project with a lower PI be preferred over a project with a higher PI when they are mutually exclusive?
- What does it mean when a positive NPV project has a long payback period and a low AAR, and what should the financial manager do?
- Which capital budgeting technique had the highest percentage of "always use" by CFOs in 2000, and what was that percentage for large firms?
- List two advantages and one disadvantage of using the Profitability Index for capital budgeting decisions.