π Lecture 35 β COST OF CAPITAL
π Overview: This lecture explains how firms calculate the cost of capital β the minimum return required to compensate investors for financing projects. It covers the cost of equity, debt, and preferred stock, along with capital structure weights and the tax effect on debt costs, which are essential for making sound investment decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture defines the cost of capital and its relationship to risk, then explains how to estimate the cost of equity using the dividend growth model, including estimating growth rates. It covers the cost of debt via yield to maturity, the cost of preferred stock as a perpetuity, calculating capital structure weights using market values, and the tax effect that makes debt cheaper after taxes.
π Lecture Summary
Cost of Capital
The cost of capital is the required return on an investment β the minimum return a firm must earn to compensate investors for the capital used. For a risk-free project, the cost of capital equals the risk-free rate. For a risky project, the cost of capital is higher than the risk-free rate. The terms required return, appropriate discount rate, and cost of capital are used interchangeably. The cost of capital depends on the risk of the investment (the use of money), not the source of money. A firm's overall cost of capital reflects the required return on its assets as a whole and is a mixture of the returns needed to compensate creditors (debt) and stockholders (equity).
π‘ Why this matters: The cost of capital is the benchmark for evaluating new projects β if a project's return is below this cost, it destroys value.
Cost of Equity
The cost of equity (Rβ) is the return required by stockholders. Under the dividend growth model, assuming dividends grow at a constant rate g, the price per share (Pβ) is:
Pβ = Dβ / (Rβ β g), where Dβ = Dβ Γ (1 + g).
Rearranging gives:
π Formula: Rβ = Dβ / Pβ + g β The cost of equity equals the dividend yield plus the growth rate.
To estimate Rβ, we need Dβ (dividend just paid), Pβ (current stock price), and g (estimated growth rate).
π Example: GSS Company paid a dividend of $4 per share last year (Dβ). Stock price is $60. Dividends grow at 6% (g = 0.06).
Step 1: Dβ = $4 Γ 1.06 = $4.24
Step 2: Rβ = $4.24 / $60 + 0.06 = 0.0707 + 0.06 = 13.07%
π Definition β g (growth rate): The estimated annual growth rate of dividends, calculated from historical dividend changes or analysts' forecasts.
π Example: A company had dividends: 1999: $1.10; 2000: $1.20 (9.09% change); 2001: $1.35 (12.50%); 2002: $1.40 (3.70%); 2003: $1.55 (10.71%). Average growth rate = (9.09 + 12.50 + 3.70 + 10.71) / 4 = 9%.
Limitations of dividend growth approach:
- Only applicable to companies paying constant growth dividends.
- Estimated cost of equity is very sensitive to the estimated growth rate.
- Does not explicitly consider risk.
Cost of Debt
The cost of debt (Rα΄ ) is the return demanded by creditors on new borrowings. It can be observed from interest rates in financial markets or estimated using the firm's bond ratings. The coupon rate on outstanding debt is irrelevant because it reflects past costs, not current costs.
π Example: GenTech issued a 30-year, 7% bond 8 years ago. The bond now sells for 96% of face value ($960). Using bond valuation, the yield to maturity is approximately 7.37%, so the cost of debt (Rα΄ ) = 7.37%.
Cost of Preferred Stock
Preferred stock pays a fixed dividend every period forever, making it a perpetuity.
π Formula: Rα΄ = D / Pβ β The cost of preferred stock equals the fixed dividend divided by the current price per share.
π Example: CG Inc. has two preferred stock issues:
- Issue 1: D = $1.78, Pβ = $25.35 β Rα΄ = $1.78 / $25.35 = 7.02%
- Issue 2: D = $1.72, Pβ = $24.90 β Rα΄ = $1.72 / $24.90 = 6.91%
Cost of preferred stock is between 6.9% and 7%.
Capital Structure Weights
Capital structure weights show the proportion of financing from equity and debt.
- Market value of equity (E) = shares outstanding Γ price per share.
- Market value of debt (D) = market price per bond Γ number of bonds outstanding (summed across issues).
- For non-traded debt, estimate market value using yields on similar traded debt.
- For short-term debt, book value approximates market value.
Total market value: V = E + D
Weights: E/V (equity percentage) and D/V (debt percentage).
π Example: If equity market value = $200 million and debt market value = $50 million, V = $250 million.
E/V = $200 / $250 = 80% (equity)
D/V = $50 / $250 = 20% (debt)
The Tax Effect
Interest paid on debt is tax-deductible, while dividends are not. This makes debt cheaper because the government effectively pays part of the interest cost.
π Formula: After-tax cost of debt = Rα΄
Γ (1 β Tα΄), where Tα΄ = corporate tax rate.
π Example: A firm borrows $1 million at 9% (Rα΄ = 9%), with a tax rate of 34% (Tα΄ = 0.34).
- Total interest = $1,000,000 Γ 0.09 = $90,000
- Tax savings = $90,000 Γ 0.34 = $30,600
- After-tax interest = $90,000 β $30,600 = $59,400
- After-tax interest rate = $59,400 / $1,000,000 = 5.94%
Using the formula: 9% Γ (1 β 0.34) = 5.94%
β Key Takeaways
The cost of capital is the minimum return a firm must earn to satisfy investors and varies with investment risk. The cost of equity can be estimated using the dividend growth model (Rβ = Dβ/Pβ + g), but this method is sensitive to growth estimates and assumes constant growth. The cost of debt is the yield to maturity on current bonds, and the after-tax cost (Rα΄ Γ (1 β Tα΄)) is lower due to the tax deductibility of interest. Capital structure weights (E/V and D/V) based on market values determine the overall cost of capital. The tax effect is critical β debt financing becomes cheaper after taxes, encouraging firms to use debt.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the cost of capital for a risk-free project, and how does it differ for a risky project?
- Using the dividend growth model, how do you calculate the cost of equity?
- Why is the coupon rate on existing debt irrelevant when calculating the cost of debt?
- How do you calculate capital structure weights using market values?
- A firm borrows at 8% with a 30% tax rate. What is the after-tax cost of debt?
π Lecture 36 β WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL
π Overview: This lecture explains how to calculate a firmβs overall cost of capital by combining the costs of different financing sources (equity, debt, and preferred stock). Understanding WACC is essential because it serves as the required return and discount rate for evaluating new projects with similar risk to existing operations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and calculation of the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC), including its formula and components. It walks through a complete example of using WACC to evaluate a warehouse renovation project with an NPV analysis. Then, it presents a detailed case study of EMN Corporation showing how to estimate the cost of equity using the dividend growth model, compute the weighted average cost of debt from multiple bond issues, and calculate WACC using both book value and market value weights. Finally, it summarizes how to obtain costs of equity, debt, and WACC.
π Lecture Summary
WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL
To calculate the firmβs overall cost of capital, we multiply the capital structures with the associated costs and add up the pieces. The result is called the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC).
π Definition β WACC: The overall return the firm must earn on its existing assets to maintain the value of the stock; it is also the required return on any investments by the firm that have the same risks as existing operations. So for evaluating the cash flows of a proposed expansion project, this is the discount rate to be used.
π Formula: WACC = (E/V) Γ R_E + (D/V) Γ R_D Γ (1 β T_C) β The weighted sum of the cost of equity and the after-tax cost of debt.
For a firm using preferred stock, the formula expands to: WACC = (E/V) Γ R_E + (P/V) Γ R_P + (D/V) Γ R_D Γ (1 β T_C)
π Example: A company wants to renovate its warehouse distribution system. The plan will cost $50 million and is expected to save $12 million per year after taxes over the next six years. The company has a target debt-equity ratio of 1/3 (i.e., E/V = 0.75 and D/V = 0.25). The company has a cost of debt of 10% and a cost of equity of 20%. Assuming a tax rate of 34%, should the company go for the project?
Step 1: Calculate WACC WACC = (0.75 Γ 20%) + (0.25 Γ 10% Γ (1 β 0.34)) WACC = 15% + 1.65% = 16.65%
Step 2: Calculate NPV using WACC as the discount rate Since cash flows are an ordinary annuity: NPV = -$50 + [$12 Γ (1 β (1/(1 + 0.1665)^6) / 0.1665] NPV = -$50 + [$12 Γ 3.6222] NPV = -$50 + $43.47 = -$6.53 million
The negative NPV means that the financial market offers superior projects in the same risk class, so the project should be rejected.
EMN Corporation
EMN Corporation has 77.3 million shares of stock outstanding. The book value per share is $17.62, but the stock actually sells for $45.41. The total equity is about $1.36 billion on a book value basis but is closer to $3.51 billion on a market value basis.
EMN paid $1.76 per share in dividends last year and analysts estimate this dividend to grow by 7% through the next 5 years.
π Formula: The estimated cost of equity using the dividend growth model is: R_E = [D_0 Γ (1 + g) / P_0] + g R_E = [$1.76 Γ (1 + 0.07) / $45.41] + 0.07 R_E = 0.1115 or 11.15%
EMN has four long-term bond issues that account for essentially all of its long-term debt. To calculate the cost of debt, we combine these four issues by computing a weighted average.
| Coupon Rate | Maturity | Book Value (Face value in millions) | Price (% of par) | Yield to Maturity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.375% | 2007 | $496 | 102.375 | 4.857% |
| 7.25 | 2027 | 496 | 102.007 | 7.067% |
| 7.625 | 2027 | 200 | 113.045 | 6.502% |
| 7.60 | 2030 | 297 | 101.000 | 7.509% |
To calculate the weighted average cost of debt, we take the percentage of the total debt represented by each issue and multiply by the yield on the issue.
| Coupon Rate | Book Value (% of Total) | Market Value (% of Total) | Yield to Maturity | Book Values | Market Values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 6.375% | 0.33 | 0.33 | 4.857% | 1.62% | 1.60% |
| 7.25 | 0.33 | 0.33 | 7.067% | 2.35% | 2.32% |
| 7.625 | 0.13 | 0.15 | 6.502% | 0.87% | 0.95% |
| 7.60 | 0.20 | 0.19 | 7.509% | 1.50% | 1.46% |
| Total | 1.00 | 1.00 | 6.34% | 6.34% |
Whether market values or book values are used, the cost of debt remains 6.34% because market values and book values are similar, and EMN has no preferred stock.
WACC on Book Value Basis:
- Equity (book): $1.362 billion
- Debt (book): $1.489 billion
- Total value: $2.851 billion
- E/V = $1.362b/$2.851b = 0.48
- D/V = $1.489b/$2.851b = 0.52
- WACC = (0.48 Γ 11.15%) + (0.52 Γ 6.34% Γ (1 β 0.34))
- WACC = 5.352% + 2.176% = 7.53%
WACC on Market Value Basis:
- Equity (market): $3.510 billion
- Debt (market): $1.540 billion
- Total value: $5.050 billion
- E/V = $3.510b/$5.050b = 0.70
- D/V = $1.540b/$5.050b = 0.30
- WACC = (0.70 Γ 11.15%) + (0.30 Γ 6.34% Γ (1 β 0.34))
- WACC = 7.805% + 1.255% = 9.06%
Using market value weights gives 9.06% for EMNβs WACC, which is much higher than 7.53% using book values. So using book values can lead to trouble, particularly if equity book values are used. EMNβs market-to-book ratio is about 2.6, so book values significantly overstate the percentage of EMNβs financing that comes from debt.
π‘ Why this matters: Using book values instead of market values can seriously understate the true cost of capital, leading firms to accept projects that destroy shareholder value because the discount rate used is too low.
Summary of Capital Cost
- The Cost of Equity R_E: The dividend growth model gives R_E = D_1/P_0 + g, where D_1 is the expected dividend in one period, g is the dividend growth rate, and P_0 is the current stock price.
- The Cost of Debt R_D: For a firm with publicly held debt, the cost of debt can be measured as the yield to maturity on the outstanding debt. The coupon rate is irrelevant. If the firm has no publicly traded debt, the cost of debt can be measured as the yield to maturity on similarly rated bonds.
- The Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC): The firmβs WACC is the overall required return on the firm as a whole. It is the appropriate discount rate to use for cash flows similar in risk to the overall firm.
- WACC Calculation: WACC = (E/V) Γ R_E + (D/V) Γ R_D Γ (1 β T_C), where T_C is the corporate tax rate, E is the market value of the firmβs equity, D is the market value of the firmβs debt, V = E + D, E/V is the percentage of financing that is equity, and D/V is the percentage that is debt.
β Key Takeaways
The Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) is the overall return required on a firm and serves as the discount rate for evaluating projects with similar risk to existing operations. It is calculated by weighting the cost of equity and the after-tax cost of debt by their respective proportions of total financing. Market value weights should always be used instead of book value weights because book values can significantly distort the true cost of capital, especially when the market-to-book ratio is high. For the cost of equity, use the dividend growth model; for the cost of debt, use the yield to maturity on outstanding or similarly rated bonds, not the coupon rate. A project should only be accepted if its NPV computed using WACC is positive.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for WACC when a firm uses only equity and debt financing?
- Why must market value weights be used instead of book value weights when calculating WACC?
- What is the correct measure to use for the cost of debtβthe coupon rate or the yield to maturity?
- A firm has a WACC of 16.65% and evaluates a project with a negative NPV of -$6.53 million. Should the project be accepted or rejected, and why?
- How do you calculate the cost of equity using the dividend growth model?
π Lecture 37 β CAPITAL STRUCTURE
π Overview: This lecture examines how a firm's mix of debt and equity (capital structure) affects its value, cost of capital, and shareholder returns. It introduces the concept of financial leverage, shows how leverage impacts EPS and ROE, and explores the critical idea of homemade leverageβdemonstrating that investors can replicate corporate leverage on their own.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the guiding principle of capital structure decisions based on maximizing firm value and minimizing WACC, financial leverage and its impact on EPS and ROE under different economic scenarios, calculation of the break-even EBIT point, and the concept of homemade leverage showing investors can adjust leverage personally through borrowing or lending.
π Lecture Summary
CAPITAL STRUCTURE
The guiding principle in choosing the debt-equity ratio is to choose a course of action that maximizes the value of a share of stock. When it comes to capital structure decisions, this is the same thing as maximizing the value of the whole firm. The WACC tells us that the firm's overall cost of capital is the weighted average of the costs of various components of the firm's capital structure. Usually, while describing WACC, we take the capital structure of the firm as given. But what happens to the cost of capital when we vary the amount of debt financing, or debt-equity ratio? Since values and discount rates move in opposite directions, the value of the firm's cash flows (or the value of the firm) is maximized when the WACC is minimized. One capital structure is better than another if it results in a lower weighted average cost of capital. A particular debt-equity ratio represents the optimal capital structure if it results in the lowest possible WACC. This optimal capital structure is also called the firm's target capital structure.
π Definition β Optimal Capital Structure: The debt-equity ratio that results in the lowest possible WACC, thereby maximizing the value of the firm.
π‘ Why this matters: Capital structure decisions are fundamental because they directly impact the firm's cost of capital and, ultimately, its market value. Managers must find the right balance between debt and equity to minimize financing costs.
Financial Leverage
Financial leverage refers to the extent to which a firm relies on debt. The more debt financing a firm uses in capital structure, the more financial leverage it employs. Financial leverage can dramatically alter the payoffs to the shareholders in the firm, but it may not affect the overall cost of capital. While illustrating how financial leverage works, we ignore taxes here and describe the impact of leverage in terms of its effect on earnings per share (EPS) and return on equity (ROE) . For meaningful analysis, we use cash flows instead of these accounting figures, but results will be the same.
The TA Corporation currently has no debt in its capital structure. The company is considering a restructuring that would involve issuing debt and using proceeds to buy back some of the outstanding equity. The table below presents both current and proposed capital structures:
| Current | Proposed | |
|---|---|---|
| Assets | $8,000,000 | $8,000,000 |
| Debt | $0 | $4,000,000 |
| Equity | $8,000,000 | $4,000,000 |
| Debt/Equity ratio | 0 | 1 |
| Share price | $20 | $20 |
| Shares outstanding | 400,000 | 200,000 |
| Interest rate | 10% | 10% |
EPS and ROE under current capital structure:
| Recession | Expected | Expansion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| EBIT | $500,000 | $1,000,000 | $1,500,000 |
| Interest | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Net income | $500,000 | $1,000,000 | $1,500,000 |
| EPS | $1.25 | $2.50 | $3.75 |
| ROE | 6.25% | 12.5% | 18.75% |
EPS and ROE under proposed capital structure:
| Recession | Expected | Expansion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| EBIT | $500,000 | $1,000,000 | $1,500,000 |
| Interest | $400,000 | $400,000 | $400,000 |
| Net income | $100,000 | $600,000 | $1,100,000 |
| EPS | $0.50 | $3.00 | $5.50 |
| ROE | 2.5% | 15% | 27.5% |
The impact of leverage is evident when examining the restructuring effect on EPS and ROE. Particularly, the variability in both EPS and ROE is much larger under the proposed capital structure, illustrating how financial leverage acts to magnify gains and losses to shareholders.
π Example: Under the expected scenario, EPS increases from $2.50 (no debt) to $3.00 (with debt), while under the recession scenario, EPS drops from $1.25 to $0.50. This shows leverage amplifies both gains and losses.
Calculating Break-Even Point
To find the break-even EBIT where EPS is the same under both capital structures:
A. With no debt: EPS = EBIT/400,000
B. With $4,000,000 in debt at 10%: EPS = (EBIT - $400,000)/200,000
C. Solve for the break-even EBIT (EBITBE): EBITBE/400,000 = (EBITBE - $400,000)/200,000
D. With algebra: EBITBE = $800,000 And EPSBE = $2.00/share
The graph shows that when EBIT is below $800,000, the no-debt structure gives higher EPS (disadvantage to debt). When EBIT is above $800,000, the debt structure gives higher EPS (advantage to debt).
π Formula: Break-even EBIT: EBITBE/Current Shares = (EBITBE - Interest)/New Shares
π Example: The MPD Corporation currently uses no-debt financing and has decided to incorporate $1 million debt at 9%. MPD has 200,000 shares outstanding and a share price of $20. Under the old structure: EPS = EBIT/200,000. Under the new structure, interest = $1,000,000 Γ 0.09 = $90,000. The company repurchases $1,000,000/$20 = 50,000 shares, leaving 150,000 outstanding. EPS = (EBIT - $90,000)/150,000. Equating: EBIT/200,000 = (EBIT - $90,000)/150,000, giving EBIT = (4/3) Γ (EBIT - $90,000), so EBIT = $360,000 and EPS = $1.80. Management expects EPS to exceed this figure.
From the above discussion, the following conclusions can be drawn:
- The effect of financial leverage depends on the company's EBIT. When EBIT is relatively high, leverage is beneficial.
- Under the expected scenario, leverage increases returns to shareholders as measured by ROE and EPS.
- Shareholders are exposed to more risk under the proposed capital structure since EPS and ROE are much more sensitive to changes in EBIT.
- Because of the impact financial leverage has on both the expected return to stockholders and the riskiness of the stock, capital structure is an important consideration.
Homemade Leverage
The last conclusion is not necessarily correct because shareholders can adjust the amount of financial leverage by borrowing and lending on their own. The use of personal borrowing to alter the degree of financial leverage is called homemade leverage. Returning to the TA corporation, we can illustrate that it makes no difference whether or not TA uses the proposed capital structure.
Proposed Capital Structure (replicating with leverage):
| Recession | Expected | Expansion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| EPS | $0.50 | $3.00 | $5.50 |
| Earnings for 100 shares | $50.00 | $300.00 | $550.00 |
| Net cost = 100 shares at $20 = $2,000 |
Original capital structure and homemade leverage:
| Recession | Expected | Expansion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| EPS | $1.25 | $2.50 | $3.50 |
| Earnings for 200 shares | $250.00 | $500.00 | $750.00 |
| Less interest on $2,000 at 10% | $200.00 | $200.00 | $200.00 |
| Net earnings | $50.00 | $300.00 | $550.00 |
| Net cost = 200 shares at $20 β amount borrowed = $4,000 β $2,000 = $2,000 |
The proposed capital structure results in a debt-equity ratio of 1. To replicate this capital structure at the personal level, the stockholder must borrow enough to create this same debt-equity ratio of 1. Notice that the net earnings ($50, $300, $550) are identical under both approaches, and the net cost is also identical ($2,000). Therefore, an investor can achieve the same payoff by buying shares in the unlevered firm and borrowing personally.
π Definition β Homemade Leverage: The use of personal borrowing or lending to alter the degree of financial leverage an investor experiences from owning shares in a firm.
Unlevering
Under the condition that TA management adopted the proposed capital structure, suppose an investor who owned 100 shares preferred the original capital structure. To create leverage, investors borrow on their own; to unlever, investors must loan out the money. In TA, the corporation borrowed an amount equal to half its value. The investor can unlever the stock by simply loaning out the money in the same proportion. The investor sells 50 shares for $1,000 total and then loans out $1,000 at 10%.
| Recession | Expected | Expansion | |
|---|---|---|---|
| EPS (Proposed structure) | $0.50 | $3.00 | $5.50 |
| Earnings for 50 shares | $25.00 | $150.00 | $275.00 |
| Plus interest on $1,000 at 10% | $100.00 | $100.00 | $100.00 |
| Total Payoff | $125.00 | $250.00 | $375.00 |
These payoffs ($125, $250, $375) match exactly what the investor would have received by owning 100 shares in the unlevered firm ($1.25 Γ 100, $2.50 Γ 100, $3.75 Γ 100). This demonstrates that corporate leverage decisions can be undone by investors through personal lending.
β Key Takeaways
The optimal capital structure minimizes WACC and maximizes firm value. Financial leverage magnifies both gains and losses for shareholders, making EPS and ROE more sensitive to changes in EBIT. The break-even EBIT is the point where EPS is identical under different capital structures, and leverage is beneficial only when actual EBIT exceeds this break-even point. Most importantly, through homemade leverage and unlevering, investors can replicate or reverse corporate leverage decisions on their own, suggesting that in a world without taxes and bankruptcy costs, capital structure may not affect firm valueβa foundation of the Modigliani-Miller proposition.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the relationship between WACC and firm value, and why does the optimal capital structure minimize WACC?
- How does financial leverage affect EPS and ROE under different economic scenarios (recession, expected, expansion)?
- Calculate the break-even EBIT for a firm with 300,000 shares outstanding (no debt) considering adding $2,000,000 debt at 8% interest, with a share price of $25.
- Explain how an investor can use homemade leverage to replicate the returns of a levered firm by borrowing personally.
- What is unlevering, and how can an investor undo the effects of corporate leverage through personal lending?
π Lecture 38 β M&M Propositions
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Modigliani and Miller (M&M) propositions on capital structure, first in a world without taxes and then with corporate taxes. It explains why capital structure matters (or doesn't) for firm value and cost of capital.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers M&M Proposition 1 and 2 without taxes, showing how cost of equity changes with leverage while WACC remains constant. It then introduces business risk versus financial risk, followed by the impact of corporate taxes on capital structure, introducing the interest tax shield and M&M Proposition 1 with taxes.
π Lecture Summary
M&M PROPOSITIONS
Corporate borrowing is relatively less significant for corporate structure because investors can borrow or lend on their own. The stock price remains almost the same whichever capital structure a company chooses, based on the argument by Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller (commonly known as M&M).
The 1st proposition states that it is completely irrelevant how a firm chooses to arrange its finances. The size of the pie (firm's total value) does not depend on how it is sliced. Although changing the capital structure may not change the firm's total value, it does cause important changes in the firm's debt and equity.
We know that WACC = (E/V) x RE + (D/V) x RD where V = E + D. WACC can be interpreted as the required return on the firm's overall assets (RA). Thus RA = (E/V) x RE + (D/V) x RD. Rearranging: RE = RA + (RA β RD) x (D/E). This 2nd proposition tells us that the cost of equity depends on three things: the required return on firm's assets RA, the firm's cost of debt RD, and the firm's debt-equity ratio D/E.
As the firm raises its debt-equity ratio, the increase in leverage raises the risk of the equity and therefore the required return or cost of equity (RE). WACC remains the same, supporting M&M proposition 1.
π Formula: RE = RA + (RA β RD) x (D/E) β The cost of equity equals the return on assets plus a premium that increases with the debt-equity ratio.
π Example: RCD corporation has a WACC of 12% (ignoring taxes). It can borrow at 8%. With a target capital structure of 80% equity and 20% debt, D/E = 0.2/0.8 = 0.25, so RE = 12% + (12% - 8%) x 0.25 = 13%. With 50% equity, D/E = 1.0, so RE = 12% + (12% - 8%) x 1.0 = 16%. WACC in first case = 0.80 x 13% + 0.20 x 8% = 12%. In second case = 0.50 x 16% + 0.50 x 8% = 12%. So WACC is 12% in both cases.
Business and Financial Risk
M&M proposition 2 shows that the firm's cost of equity can be broken into two components. The required return on firm's assets, RA, depends on the nature of the firm's operating activities. The risk inherent in the firm's operations is called the business risk, which depends on the systematic risk of the firm's assets.
The component (RA β RD) x (D/E) is determined by the firm's financial structure. For an all-equity firm, this component is zero. The increase in debt financing raises the required return on equity because the risk born by the investors increases. This extra risk is called financial risk.
π Definition β Business Risk: The risk inherent in the firm's operations, dependent on the systematic risk of the firm's assets. π Definition β Financial Risk: The extra risk borne by equity holders that results from debt financing.
Corporate Taxes & Capital Structure
Debt features two key aspects: interest paid on debt is tax deductible (a benefit for the firm), and failure to meet debt financing may lead to bankruptcy (a cost of debt financing).
Consider Firm U (unlevered) and Firm L (levered), identical on the left side of the balance sheet. EBIT is $1,000 every year for both firms. Firm L has issued $1,000 worth of perpetual bonds at 8% interest every year.
| Firm U | Firm L | |
|---|---|---|
| EBIT | $1,000 | $1,000 |
| Interest | 0 | 80 |
| Taxable Income | $1,000 | $920 |
| Taxes (30%) | 300 | 276 |
| Net Income | $700 | $644 |
Cash flow from assets = EBIT β Taxes. Firm U = $700, Firm L = $724. Total cash flow to Firm L is $24 more, as its tax bill is $24 less. Interest being tax deductible has generated a tax saving equal to interest payment multiplied by tax rate, i.e. $80 x 0.30 = $24. This tax saving is called the Interest Tax Shield.
Since debt is perpetual, the same $24 shield will be generated every year forever. Since Firm L's cash flow is always $24 greater, its worth is more than Firm U by the value of this $24 perpetuity. Because the tax shield is generated by paying interest, it has the same risk as the debt, and 8% is therefore the appropriate discount rate.
PV = $24 / 0.08 = $300, which equals 0.30 x $1,000 = $300.
π Formula: PV of interest tax shield = (TC x D x RD) / RD = TC x D
The value of Firm L, VL, exceeds the value of Firm U, VU, by the present value of the interest tax shield, TC x D.
π Definition β Interest Tax Shield: The tax saving generated by the tax deductibility of interest payments, equal to interest payment multiplied by the tax rate.
M&M Proposition 1 With Taxes
M&M Proposition 1 with taxes states that: VL = VU + TC x D
π Definition β M&M Proposition 1 (with taxes): The value of the levered firm equals the value of the unlevered firm plus the present value of the interest tax shield.
π‘ Why this matters: This proposition suggests that debt financing is highly advantageous and in the extreme, a firm's optimal capital structure is 100% debt. A firm's WACC decreases as the firm relies more heavily on debt financing.
M&M Summary
The No-Tax Case
- Proposition 1: The value of the firm levered (VL) is equal to the firm unlevered (VU): VL = VU. Implications: A firm's capital structure is irrelevant. A firm's WACC is the same no matter what mixture of debt and equity is used.
- Proposition 2: The cost of equity, RE is: RE = RA + (RA β RD) x D/E. Implications: Cost of equity rises as the firm increases its use of debt financing. The risk of the equity depends on business risk (which determines RA) and financial leverage (determined by D/E).
The Tax Case
- Proposition 1 with taxes: The value of the firm levered (VL) is equal to the value of the firm unlevered (VU) plus the present value of the interest tax shield: VL = VU + TC x D. Implications: Debt financing is highly advantageous and in the extreme a firm's optimal capital structure is 100% debt. A firm's WACC decreases as the firm relies more heavily on debt financing.
β Key Takeaways
Without taxes, M&M propositions show that capital structure is irrelevantβfirm value and WACC remain unchanged regardless of debt-equity mix. The cost of equity increases with leverage (RE = RA + (RA β RD) x D/E) to exactly offset the benefit of cheaper debt, keeping WACC constant. Business risk comes from operations, while financial risk is the additional risk borne by equity holders from debt financing. With corporate taxes, debt becomes advantageous because interest payments create a tax shield valued at TC x D, increasing firm value and reducing WACC. This leads to the extreme implication that optimal capital structure would be 100% debt under the tax-only view.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does M&M Proposition 1 (no taxes) state about the relationship between firm value and capital structure?
- Using M&M Proposition 2 (no taxes), if a firm has RA = 15%, RD = 10%, and a debt-equity ratio of 0.5, what is its cost of equity?
- What is the difference between business risk and financial risk according to M&M?
- How is the interest tax shield calculated, and why does it increase firm value?
- According to M&M Proposition 1 with taxes, what is the optimal capital structure for a firm?
π Lecture 39 β Bankruptcy Costs
π Overview: This lecture examines the static theory of capital structure, which balances the tax benefits of debt against the costs of financial distress. It explains how firms determine their optimal capital structure and introduces the fundamental concepts of net working capital management, including how to identify sources and uses of cash.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers bankruptcy costs (direct and indirect), financial distress costs, the static theory of capital structure, and the concept of optimal capital structure. It then illustrates these concepts through three comparative cases (M&M with no taxes, M&M with taxes, and static theory), followed by managerial recommendations regarding leverage. The lecture concludes with an introduction to net working capital, current assets and liabilities, and the sources and uses of cash.
π Lecture Summary
Bankruptcy Costs
Direct Bankruptcy Costs are the costs directly associated with the bankruptcy process, such as legal and administrative expenses. Indirect Bankruptcy Costs are the costs of avoiding a bankruptcy filing, which are incurred by a firm that is already in financial distress.
π Definition β Financial Distress Costs: The total of both the direct and indirect costs associated with going bankrupt or experiencing financial distress.
Static Theory of Capital Structure
The Static Theory of Capital Structure states that a firm borrows up to the point where the tax benefit from an extra dollar of debt is exactly equal to the cost that comes from the increased probability of financial distress. This theory leads to the concept of an Optimal Capital Structure, which is the debt level (D*) that maximizes the firm's value (V_L*). The difference between the firm's value under the static theory and the M&M value with taxes is the loss in value from the possibility of financial distress. The difference between the static theory value and the M&M value with no taxes is the net gain from leverage.
π Formula: Optimal Capital Structure: The firm's value is maximized at V_L* when debt equals D*. The capital structure is composed of D*/ V_L* in debt and (1 - D*/ V_L*) in equity. The capital structure that maximizes firm value also minimizes the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC).
Case 1, 2, and 3
Case 1 (M&M with no taxes, no bankruptcy costs): The value of the firm (V_L) and its WACC are not affected by capital structure. The firm's value remains constant at V_U regardless of debt, and WACC remains constant regardless of the debt-equity ratio.
Case 2 (M&M with corporate taxes, no bankruptcy costs): The value of the firm increases and the WACC decreases as the amount of debt goes up. This is due to the PV of the tax shield on debt (T_C x D). The firm value line slopes upward.
Case 3 (Static theory with corporate taxes and bankruptcy costs): The value of the firm (V_L) reaches a maximum at D*, the optimal amount of borrowing. At the same time, the WACC is minimized at the debt-equity ratio D*/E* (WACC*). The firm value increases initially due to the tax shield, but then decreases due to the PV of bankruptcy costs. The net gain from leverage is the difference between the firm's value under static theory and its value with no debt (V_U).
π Example: In Case 3, the value of the firm is initially V_U (value with no debt). As debt is added, the value rises due to the tax shield. However, as debt increases further, the probability and cost of financial distress rise, subtracting value from the firm. The firm reaches its maximum value at a specific debt level (D*), which is lower than the value predicted by M&M with taxes.
Some Managerial Recommendations
- Tax Benefits: Tax benefits from leveraging are only important to firms that are in a tax-paying position. Firms with substantial losses or tax shields from other sources (like depreciation) will get less benefit from leverage.
- Risk of Distress: Firms with a greater risk of experiencing financial distress will borrow less than firms with a lower risk.
- Assets: The cost of financial distress depends on the firm's assets and how easily their ownership can be transferred. Tangible assets are easier to transfer than intangible assets, making distress less costly for firms with tangible assets.
Net Working Capital
Net working capital (NWC) is the difference between current assets and current liabilities. Often, short-term financing is called net working capital management. Current assets are cash and other assets expected to convert to cash within one year (e.g., cash, marketable securities, accounts receivable, inventories). Current liabilities are obligations requiring cash payment within one year (e.g., accounts payable, expenses payable, notes payable).
π Formula: Balance Sheet Identity: NWC + Fixed assets = Long-term debt + Equity π Formula: Cash Identity: Cash = Long-term debt + Equity + Current liabilities - Current assets (other than cash) - Fixed assets
Sources and Uses of Cash
- Activities that Increase Cash (Sources): Increasing long-term debt, equity, or current liabilities; decreasing current assets (other than cash) or fixed assets.
- Activities that Decrease Cash (Uses): Decreasing long-term debt, equity, or current liabilities; increasing current assets (other than cash) or fixed assets.
- Sources of cash always involve increasing a liability (or equity) account or decreasing an asset account.
- Uses of cash involve decreasing a liability (or equity) or increasing an asset account.
π Example: If accounts payable go up by $100, it is a source of cash (the firm borrowed $100 from its suppliers). If accounts receivable go up by $100, it is a use of cash (the firm has not yet collected $100 from its customers).
β Key Takeaways
The static theory of capital structure is the central concept, which balances the tax shield benefit of debt against the increasing costs of financial distress. This trade-off creates a unique optimal capital structure (D*) that maximizes firm value and minimizes WACC, contrasting with M&M's earlier models where value either stays constant or increases indefinitely with debt. Managers must consider their firm's tax position, risk profile, and asset tangibility when making leverage decisions. Finally, understanding the difference between sources and uses of cash is fundamental to managing net working capital.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Define direct and indirect bankruptcy costs.
- What is the fundamental trade-off in the static theory of capital structure?
- In the static theory model, what happens to the firm's value and its WACC at the optimal capital structure (D*)?
- Name two factors that reduce the benefit of leverage for a firm.
- If a company increases its inventory, is this a source or a use of cash?
π Lecture 40 β OPERATING CYCLE AND CASH CYCLE
π Overview: This lecture explains the short-term financial activities of a manufacturing firm, focusing on the timing of cash flows. It defines and calculates the operating cycle and cash cycle, showing how long it takes a firm to convert inventory into cash and how to manage the gap between cash outflows and inflows.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the sequence of events and decisions in short-run activities, introduces the concepts of operating cycle (inventory period + accounts receivable period) and cash cycle (operating cycle minus accounts payable period), explains how to calculate these cycles using financial ratios, and discusses the interpretation and management of the cash cycle for profitability.
π Lecture Summary
Short-Run Activities and Cash Flow Timing
For a typical manufacturing firm, short-run activities consist of a sequence of events (buying raw materials, paying cash, manufacturing, selling, collecting cash) and corresponding decisions (how much inventory to order, whether to borrow, production technology, credit extension, and collection methods). These activities are unsynchronized because payment for purchases may not happen at the same time as receipts from sales, and they are uncertain because future sales and costs cannot be precisely predicted.
Consider the following chronological events:
- Day 0: Acquire inventory on credit (no cash effect)
- Day 30: Pay for inventory (-$1,000)
- Day 60: Sell inventory on credit (no cash effect)
- Day 105: Collect on sale (+$1,400)
Operating Cycle
The operating cycle is the time period between the acquisition of inventory and the collection of cash from receivables. In the example, it is 105 days.
The inventory period is the time it takes to acquire and sell inventory (60 days in the example). The accounts receivable period is the time between the sale of inventory and collection of the receivable (45 days in the example).
π Definition β Operating Cycle: The sum of the inventory period and the accounts receivable period. It describes how a product moves through current asset accounts: it begins as inventory, is converted to a receivable when sold, and is converted to cash when collected.
π Formula: Operating cycle = Inventory period + Accounts receivable period β This tells the total time from purchasing inventory to receiving cash from its sale.
π Example: 105 days = 60 days + 45 days
Cash Cycle
The accounts payable period is the time between receipt of inventory and payment for it. In the example, payment is made after 30 days.
The cash cycle is the time between cash disbursement and cash collection. Since cash is spent on day 30 but not collected until day 105, the firm must finance $1,000 for 75 days.
π Definition β Cash Cycle: The difference between the operating cycle and the accounts payable period. It represents the gap between short-term cash outflows and inflows that must be financed, either by borrowing or by holding a liquidity reserve.
π Formula: Cash cycle = Operating cycle β Accounts payable period β This tells how many days the firm needs to arrange financing for its operations.
π Example: 75 days = 105 days β 30 days
The gap can be filled either by borrowing or by holding a liquidity reserve in the form of cash or marketable securities. Alternatively, the gap can be shortened by changing the inventory, receivable, and payable periods.
Roles in Managing Operating Cycle
Various managers influence the short-term financial management of assets and liabilities:
- Cash Manager: Handles collection, concentration, disbursement, short-term investment, short-term borrowing, and bank relations (affects cash, marketable securities, short-term loans)
- Credit Manager: Monitors and controls accounts receivable and makes credit policy decisions (affects accounts receivable)
- Marketing Manager: Makes credit policy decisions (affects accounts receivable)
- Purchase Manager: Decides on purchases, supplies, and may negotiate payment terms (affects inventory, accounts payable)
- Production Manager: Sets production schedules and materials requirements (affects inventory, accounts payable)
- Payables Manager: Decides on payment policies and whether to take discounts (affects accounts payable)
- Controller: Provides accounting information on cash flows, reconciles accounts receivable, and applies payments (affects accounts receivable, accounts payable)
Calculating Operating and Cash Cycle
Using balance sheet information (in thousands) and an income statement with Net Sales of $11,500 and Cost of Goods Sold of $8,200:
Average Inventory = $2,500, Average Accounts Receivable = $1,800, Average Accounts Payable = $875
π Formula β Inventory Turnover: Cost of goods sold / Average Inventory β Tells how many times inventory is sold and replaced during the year.
π Example: Inventory turnover = $8.2 million / $2.5 million = 3.28 times
π Formula β Inventory Period: 365 days / Inventory Turnover β Tells the average number of days inventory sits before being sold.
π Example: Inventory period = 365 / 3.28 = 111.3 days
Assuming all sales were credit sales:
π Formula β Receivables Turnover: Credit Sales / Average Accounts Receivable β Tells how many times receivables are collected during the year.
π Example: Receivables turnover = $11.5 million / $1.8 million = 6.4 times
π Formula β Receivables Period: 365 days / Receivable Turnover β Tells the average number of days customers take to pay.
π Example: Receivables period = 365 / 6.4 = 57 days (also called days' sales in receivables or average collection period)
π Example: Operating cycle = 111 days + 57 days = 168 days
π Formula β Payables Turnover: Cost of goods sold / Average Payables β Tells how many times payables are paid off during the year.
π Example: Payables turnover = $8.2 million / $0.875 million = 9.4 times
π Formula β Payables Period: 365 days / Payables Turnover β Tells the average number of days the firm takes to pay its suppliers.
π Example: Payables period = 365 / 9.4 = 39 days
π Example: Cash cycle = 168 days β 39 days = 129 days
Example: SP Company
SP Company has the following figures: Inventory (beginning $5,000, ending $7,000), Accounts Receivable (beginning $2,700, ending $2,400), Accounts Payable (beginning $750, ending $4,800), Credit Sales = $50,000, Cost of Goods Sold = $30,000.
π Calculations:
- Average Inventory = ($5,000 + $7,000)/2 = $6,000
- Average Receivables = ($2,700 + $2,400)/2 = $2,000
- Average Payables = ($750 + $4,800)/2 = $3,750
- Inventory turnover = $30,000/$6,000 = 5 times
- Receivable turnover = $50,000/$2,000 = 25 times
- Payable turnover = $30,000/$3,750 = 8 times
- Inventory period = 365/5 = 73 days
- Receivable period = 365/25 = 14.6 days
- Payable period = 365/8 = 45.6 days
- Operating cycle = 73 + 14.6 = 87.6 days
- Cash cycle = 87.6 β 45.6 = 42 days
Interpreting Cash Cycle
These calculations reveal that the cash cycle depends on inventory, receivable, and payable turnovers. It increases if inventory and receivables periods get longer, and decreases if the payable period is lengthened.
Most firms have a positive cash cycle and require more financing for inventories and receivables for longer cash cycles. The link between the firm's cash cycle and its profitability is provided by Total Assets Turnover (Sales/Total Assets). The higher this ratio, the greater the firm's accounting Return on Assets (ROA) and Return on Equity (ROE). Therefore, the shorter the cash cycle, the lower the firm's investment in inventories and receivables, the lower total assets, and the higher total asset turnover.
π‘ Why this matters: A shorter cash cycle means the firm needs less external financing, has lower asset investments, and achieves higher profitability through better asset utilization.
β Key Takeaways
The operating cycle (inventory period + receivables period) measures the total time from inventory acquisition to cash collection, while the cash cycle (operating cycle minus payables period) measures the net financing gap. A shorter cash cycle reduces the need for external financing and improves profitability by increasing total asset turnover, return on assets, and return on equity. The cash cycle can be managed by adjusting inventory, receivable, and payable periods through coordinated actions of cash, credit, marketing, purchase, production, and payables managers.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the operating cycle, and how is it calculated?
- What is the cash cycle, and how is it different from the operating cycle?
- How does a longer inventory period affect the cash cycle?
- Using the formula, calculate the cash cycle if a firm has an inventory period of 73 days, a receivable period of 14.6 days, and a payable period of 45.6 days.
- Why does a shorter cash cycle improve a firm's profitability?