๐ Lecture 39 โ GENDER, HEALTH AND VIOLENCE
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the intersection of gender with health and violence, exploring how gender bias manifests in medical research and healthcare systems. It addresses the women's health movement, men's health concerns, aging from a gendered perspective, and the complex issue of gender-based violence in its various forms, highlighting both challenges and pathways to solutions.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five major topics: the Women's Health Movement and its critique of androcentric medicine, men's voices against gender bias in health issue prioritization, the relationship between gender, health, and aging including physical and psychological changes, violence as a gender issue including domestic violence typology and prediction, and different faces of violence including physical, psychological, sexual, economic, and moral violence as categorized by Brazilian law.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic 169: The Womenโs Health Movement
The medical system has had an androcentric approach, meaning it has been centered on men and male perspectives. This bias affects women's health and well-being in significant ways. Women participants were literally absent from clinical trials related to drugs, medical technology, and health-care options on which the contemporary system is based. This is clearly biased because on one hand androcentric medicine insists that biological differences between the sexes have unavoidable health consequences, yet researches are routinely conducted using only male subjects (Lindsey, 2011).
In one federally funded study examining the effects of diet on breast cancer, only men were used as sample subjects. Men are diagnosed with breast cancer in only about one percent of all breast cancers. This sort of study can provide information about only a very small segment of population at risk. The larger group at risk remains unattended due to a gender biased approach. Another example is research on heart disease โ in one big study on heart disease, over 35,000 subjects were used to examine the effect of low doses of aspirin on heart attack risk, and all selected subjects were men. The findings could not be generalized to women because hormonal differences between women and men were not considered, even though heart disease is the leading cause of death for both men and women.
The Women's Health Movement (WHM) began in the early 1970s in the United States as part of the American feminist movement focusing on improving women's healthcare. It sprouted from sheer dissatisfaction with patriarchal dominance over women's health care and challenged androcentric practices of mainstream modern medicine. The movement states that women should be empowered to take control of their health care, should have control over medical decisions, and should actively play a part in all phases of their health.
๐ก Why this matters: The exclusion of women from medical research means treatments and medications may be less effective or even dangerous for women, as sex-based physiological differences are systematically ignored.
Topic 170: Menโs Voice against Gender Bias in Highlighting Health Issues
Just as women have complained about androcentric approaches, men have also highlighted areas where men have been neglected and women given preference. For example, girls' and young women's poor nutrition is often talked about as a matter of grave concern whereas the significance of adequate nutrition for boys and young men is rarely touched upon. Women's poor nutrition is highlighted more as a gender issue rather than an issue of limited economic resources that affects boys and girls, men and women equally.
Another area with a gender gap is awareness about early detection of breast cancer or cervical cancer in women. Campaigns run and huge amounts of money are allocated for educating women about early cancer detection. On the other hand, some cancers found in men can also be treated successfully if detected early. For example, in case of testicular cancer the survival rate is very high โ up to 99% โ if detected at a very early stage. However, one rarely comes across a campaign or health education literature where this information is given to the public and where proper self-examination for detecting a lump is taught, just like Breast Self-Examination. According to this perspective, women are perceived as more vulnerable while risks faced by men are ignored.
Topic 171: Gender, Health, and Aging
With advancement in medical science, improvements in healthcare systems, and adoption of healthy lifestyles, the number of older adults is increasing. Life expectancy has improved and many major killers like infections which used to cause early deaths are under control. Usually old age is calculated as 65 years and above. It is expected the number of people 60 years or older will rise from 900 million to two billion between 2015 and 2050 (from 12% to 22% of global population).
Aging is an inevitable part of life that takes place throughout the lifespan. The WHO's Global Strategy and Action Plan on Ageing and Health addresses 5 priority areas: 1) Commitment to Healthy Ageing, 2) Aligning health systems with the needs of older populations, 3) Developing systems for providing long-term care, 4) Creating age-friendly environments, and 5) Improving measurement, monitoring and understanding. Non communicable diseases are the most common health conditions in older adults, with major causes of death being heart disease, strokes and lung disease. Major causes of disability include sensory impairment, neck and back pain, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, depressive disorders, falls, diabetes, dementias, and osteoarthritis.
Aging and Physical and Physiological Changes include: decreased efficiency of bodily organ functions, changes in physical appearance, reduced physical strength and fitness, impaired muscular coordination, sensory impairment, and chronic diseases. Psychological changes include loneliness, despair, feeling of worthlessness, empty nest syndrome, and affected memory.
Gender differences in aging: More women than men experience problems associated with aging for more years because women have higher longevity than men. Majority of adults who fall in the category of "oldest of the old" would be women. More women than men have arthritis with subsequent restricted mobility, pain, and dependence. Many women experience problems related to menopause and osteoporosis. Women are at a much higher risk of osteoporosis which causes bone fractures, potentially resulting in prolonged bed rest. The risk of Coronary Heart Disease (CHD) which used to be much less in pre-menopausal age is about the same in older men and women, though the rate of female CHD patients is still less than male patients.
Marriage and Loneliness: Because of gender differences in longevity, usually more women face loneliness in late adulthood as men die before wives. Wives are generally younger than their husbands and live in widowhood for many years. People who have had a happy marriage enjoy better health. For men, being married and having a companion may be sufficient even if the marriage had been turbulent. For women, the quality of marriage is more important โ a turbulent marriage can have serious effects on their health.
The empty nest syndrome affects older adults' lives. It does not cause stress if the husband and wife have a caring attitude towards each other. Midlife women whose children had left were more satisfied and happier than those whose children were still with them (Neugarten, 1970; Turner, 1982). Working mothers, especially full time, feel little or no stress from empty nest.
Personality: Many older women perceive themselves as more capable of solving problems, more assertive, less dependent, and more authoritative at home. Older men often perceive themselves as more nurturing, cooperative and less dominant in old age (Bengston, Reedy and Gordon, 1985). More women less than 80 years of age may feel depressed and more men may abuse alcohol (NIH Consensus Development Conference, 1991).
Financial Problems: Most retired people experience financial problems. In case of women, dependence is higher because most women in Pakistani society are house wives and must rely on husband's pension or children. For a single or widowed man, old age is tougher than for a single or widowed woman โ women being more industrious and equipped with household skills can manage life in limited resources better than men in similar circumstances.
Topic 172: Violence as a Gender Issue
Goal No.5 in Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) is Gender Equality, with nine targets. The first two are: 1) End all forms of discrimination against all women and girls everywhere, and 2) Eliminate all forms of violence against all women and girls in the public and private spheres, including trafficking and sexual and other types of exploitation. This shows global realization that violence against women is a menace that needs to be curbed. Violence can be understood as an emotionally charged act marked by aggression, involving infliction of hurt or injury to the victim.
Gender and Violence: Overall, more men have been hurt as a result of violent acts, conflicts, disputes compared to women. However, men were mostly involved in situations involving combat where violence was very likely โ this can be understood through their profession, upbringing where aggression was not discouraged. Violence is treated as an important social problem and as a gender-issue because women are subjected to violence even when they had not opted to be part of a violent situation.
Domestic Violence is the best example. Violence against women indicates suppression and exploitation of women in society. Violence is not necessarily physical โ it may be verbal, psychological, emotional, and even social. Rape is one of the most common and severe forms of violence experienced by women. Sexual harassment is another form. A common definition: "Domestic violence or partner abuse is the physical, sexual or psychological maltreatment of a spouse, a former spouse, or an intimate partner so as to gain or maintain power or control" (Papalia, Olds, and Feldman, 2001, p. 542). It is difficult to gauge exact incidence since it is quite unreported or under reported โ victims may not report due to self-consciousness, shame, embarrassment, fear of breaking relationship, or family pressure.
Domestic violence can be of two types (Johnson, 1995):
๐ Common couple violence: A conflict leads to an argument that turns into a fight involving physical violence that can be minor or major and serious. In case of serious physical violence, the likelihood of being injured is higher for women than for men.
๐ Patriarchal terrorism: Many people don't recognize this as violence. Such violence is exercised by men alone. Physical force along with other control strategies is used by men for dominating their family. This form of violence may end up in injury and even death to women and children.
The likelihood that women would be homicide victims as a consequence of domestic violence is higher than the likelihood of men being victims (Brannon, and Feist, 2000). Men are more likely to be hurt by strangers, whereas women are more likely to be hurt by their husband. In collectivistic or group cohesive societies, the husband may be supported by other family members in exercising domestic violence.
Can we predict domestic violence? Wife beating is more common in societies where aggressive behavior is common in other situations, where women have inferior status, and where physical force is used to resolve disputes (Broude, 1994). Girls and women younger in age, belonging to lower socio-economic class, financially dependent, less educated or uneducated, and less exposed to practical life outside the household are more likely to be subjected to domestic violence. Men more likely to exercise domestic violence would be less educated/uneducated, unemployed/financially over-burdened, drug/alcohol abusers, belonging to lower socio-economic class, having experienced domestic violence in their own home, and those having no familial or social pressure against their violent behavior.
Consequences of domestic violence: Hurts physically, psychologically, and emotionally; shatters women's self-confidence, leads to low self-esteem and self-doubt; results in fear, learned helplessness, and passive acceptance of oppression.
Way forward: Education for men and women, awareness of basic human and legal rights; availability of legal aid, help lines, shelter homes, and counseling for women; family therapy; teaching civic sense and civilized conduct to children and adolescents; a proactive media.
Topic 173: Different Faces of Violence
Gender based violence is a serious issue and a matter of concern for the global community. Violence may take different forms โ from not allowing girls to receive education, not giving them enough food, to not allowing them to raise a voice in decision making, to subjecting them to physical violence and hurt.
According to UNWOMEN: 49 countries still do not have laws to protect women from domestic violence. 39 countries bar equal rights of inheritance for daughters and sons. Figures from 87 countries show that one in five women and girls under age 50 will have experienced physical and/or sexual violence by an intimate partner within the last 12 months. 15 million girls under age 18 every year are robbed of their childhood due to harmful practices such as child marriage. Compared to men, women do 2.6 times more unpaid care and domestic work.
Different countries have laws for tackling gender based violence. One good example is Brazil's Maria Da Penha law on Domestic and Family Violence which presents a comprehensive model describing the following categories of violence:
๐ Physical Violence: "any conduct that offends the integrity or the physical health of a woman" โ including beating, throwing objects, strangulating, suffocating, torture, injury using sharp objects or fire arms, or injury by burning.
๐ Psychological Violence: "any behavior that causes emotional damage and diminishes self-esteem; harms and disrupts the full development of a woman; or aims to degrade or control her actions, behaviors, beliefs, and decisions" โ including threats, restrictions on movement, persecution, humiliation, manipulation, insult, blackmailing, ridicule, insults.
๐ Sexual Violence: "when women are forced to witness, maintain or participate in unwanted sexual activity, in its different forms."
๐ Economic Violence: "any conduct that entails retention, subtraction, partial or total destruction of objects, work instruments, personal documents, property, values, and economic rights or resources, including those intended to meet the woman's needs."
๐ Moral Violence: "any conduct that constitutes calumny, defamation or libel" โ damaging a woman's reputation, spreading rumors about her, exposing her intimate life.
Way forward: Education and awareness about rights and responsibilities; self-defense training; awareness about significance of prompt reporting of incidents; identifying and helping men who experience domestic violence from women; counseling facilities.
โญ Key Takeaways
This lecture reveals that gender bias in health is bidirectionalโwomen have been excluded from clinical trials for heart disease and breast cancer research, while men's cancers like testicular cancer receive far less public awareness and campaign funding than women's cancers. Aging affects women and men differently due to women's higher longevity, leading to more years with chronic conditions like arthritis and osteoporosis, and greater likelihood of widowhood and financial dependence. Violence as a gender issue centers on the fact that women are subjected to violence in situations they did not choose (like domestic settings), while men are more often victims in combat or confrontational situations they entered voluntarily. Domestic violence can be predicted by factors including lower socioeconomic status, lack of education, financial dependence, and exposure to violence during upbringing. Gender-based violence takes five distinct formsโphysical, psychological, sexual, economic, and moralโas outlined in Brazil's comprehensive Maria Da Penha law.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What evidence does the lecture provide for androcentric bias in medical research, and why is this problematic for women's health?
- What health issue do men's advocates highlight as receiving less attention compared to women's breast cancer campaigns, despite having a 99% survival rate with early detection?
- Why do more women than men experience the negative effects of aging for longer periods, and what specific health conditions are more common in older women?
- What are the two types of domestic violence identified by Johnson (1995), and how do they differ in terms of perpetrators and outcomes?
- According to the Maria Da Penha law in Brazil, what are the five categories of gender-based violence, and what does each category include?
๐ Lecture 40 โ GENDER AND EDUCATION-I
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the critical relationship between gender and education, emphasizing education as a fundamental human right with profound implications for women's empowerment and societal development. It examines global educational disparities, the impact of educational deprivation on women, and the international framework of Sustainable Development Goal 4 aimed at ensuring inclusive and equitable quality education for all by 2030.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four main topics: the definition and importance of gender and education, including personal and social consequences of educational deprivation and barriers to women's education; the Sustainable Development Goals (specifically Goal 4) and their targets for educational equality; the origin and historical development of education from informal to formal systems; and the three forms of educationโformal, informal, and non-formalโand their relationship to gender.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic 174: Gender and Education
Education is described as the "door to awareness" that gives knowledge and brings the person in contact with the world. It is a basic right of all children, male and female, and is the first step towards enlightenment and empowerment. The lecture emphasizes that today's educated children will be tomorrow's educated parents, and an educated mother educates the whole family. Depriving children of education blocks their path to progress, prosperity, empowerment, and a better life. Many children globally either lack access to education or the resources required for it, while many others are not allowed to be educated. The impact of denying education is even more serious and long-term for girls because they will be mothers tomorrow, and educated mothers are better aware of disease prevention, proper nutrition, medical consultation, child development, and healthy lifestyles.
Many women in underdeveloped countries are deprived of this right. According to an earlier study, of the 875 million illiterate adults worldwide, two-thirds are females. Girls constituted the majority of the 121 million children not in school. In 2002, 24 million girls in Sub-Saharan Africa were not going to school, with Sub-Saharan Africa, South Asia, East Asia, and the Pacific being the regions where 83% of all out-of-school girls belonged (Verma, 2006).
Personal and Social Consequences of Educational Deprivation The doorways to social and economic empowerment are blocked. Most uneducated women are less likely to be aware of and adopt healthy practices, which negatively affects their own and their children's health. In contrast, educated women adopt disease prevention strategies and are more aware of precautions against reproductive and childbirth complications. Uneducated women are less aware of their legal rights and have little knowledge of how to protect themselves against abuse and violence. They are also economically dependent on males, and there is a negative effect on their self-confidence and self-concept.
Barriers to Women's Education
- Cultural Practices
- Early Marriages
- Early motherhood
- Poor, no, or inaccessible educational facilities
- Disinterest of the ruling circles
๐ Definition โ Educational Deprivation: The state of being denied access to education, which blocks social and economic empowerment, negatively impacts health awareness, legal knowledge, economic independence, and self-confidence. ๐ Example: In Sub-Saharan Africa in 2002, 24 million girls were out of school, with 83% of all out-of-school girls globally concentrated in Sub-Saharan Africa, South Asia, East Asia, and the Pacific.
Topic 175: Education, and Equality: the SDGs
Goal No. 4 in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) is to "ensure inclusive and equitable quality education and promote lifelong learning opportunities for all." This demonstrates that education is a matter of global concern. The goal has seven associated targets indicating how this global goal is to be attained by 2030. All nations have been working on this goal, and some considerable progress has been made. In 2016, around 750 million adults, of whom two-thirds were women, remained illiterate. Half of the illiterate population lives in South Asia, and one-fourth live in sub-Saharan Africa. In 2017, 262 million children and youth aged 6 to 17 were still out of school. More than 50% of children and adolescents were not meeting minimum proficiency standards in reading and mathematics. The learning environment, capacities of teachers, and quality of education need improvement. Learning outcomes for the full life cycle, particularly for women, girls, and marginalized people in vulnerable settings, need to be improved (Source: Report of the Secretary-General, Special edition: progress towards the Sustainable Development Goals).
Targets for Goal 4
- 4.1: By 2030, ensure all girls and boys complete free, equitable, and quality primary and secondary education leading to relevant and effective learning outcomes
- 4.2: By 2030, ensure all girls and boys have access to quality early childhood development, care, and pre-primary education
- 4.3: By 2030, ensure equal access for all women and men to affordable and quality technical, vocational, and tertiary education, including university
- 4.4: By 2030, substantially increase the number of youth and adults with relevant skills for employment, decent jobs, and entrepreneurship
- 4.5: By 2030, eliminate gender disparities in education and ensure equal access to all levels of education for the vulnerable
- 4.6: By 2030, ensure all youth and a substantial proportion of adults achieve literacy and numeracy
- 4.7: By 2030, ensure all learners acquire knowledge and skills to promote sustainable development, human rights, gender equality, and a culture of peace
- 4.a: Build and upgrade education facilities that are child, disability, and gender sensitive
- 4.b: Expand scholarships available to developing countries for higher education enrolment
- 4.c: Substantially increase the supply of qualified teachers in developing countries
๐ก Why this matters: Goal 4 is directly associated with Goal 5 (Gender Equality), as attaining the goal of education for all is a critical part of achieving gender equality.
๐ Definition โ Sustainable Development Goal 4: A global goal to ensure inclusive and equitable quality education and promote lifelong learning opportunities for all by 2030, with specific targets addressing gender disparities, literacy, and educational access for vulnerable populations. ๐ Formula: SDG 4 + SDG 5 โ Gender Equality through Education for All
Topic 176: Origin and Development of Education
Education refers to a process of delivering and receiving knowledge involving learning that takes place in a formal setup, like a school. This learning involves transmission of knowledge in various disciplines as well as cultural norms, values, and practices. Education can be formal, informal, or non-formal. The standards, methods, and contents of education may vary from culture to culture, though certain levels of achievement and expectations from students are quite similar. The nature, content, methods, and techniques of imparting education have evolved over many centuries.
Initially, education was informal. Teachers or mentors would teach their students or followers in informal setups. Teaching didn't necessarily take place at one fixed place, according to a fixed format and timing, or in only one focused area. A single teacher could educate people in a variety of areas. As the number of learners increased and more areas of specialized knowledge emerged, education became more formalโwith specific content, place, plan, and specific persons.
The Late 18th and early 19th century saw major developments in education. A significant development was the introduction of a compulsory education system in Germany (then Prussia). Another milestone was Industrialization, which created a greater need for a specialized and educated workforce. The two World Wars also led countries to require knowledgeable and educated persons for rapid progress and development. Formal education was required at all levels. With the advent of new technologies, machinery, and new needs, there was a need for persons with specialized knowledge and skill. The importance of research and innovation was realized, leading to a need for doctors, engineers, scientists, pharmacists, and all sorts of professionals. Subsequently, there was more investment in education at all levels.
๐ Definition โ Education (historical context): A process of delivering and receiving knowledge that evolved from informal mentoring to formal, compulsory, institutionalized systems driven by industrialization, wars, and the need for specialized professionals.
Topic 177: Gender and Forms of Education
Education is defined as a process of teaching and learningโdelivering and receiving knowledge, including transmission of knowledge in various disciplines as well as cultural norms, values, and practices. 'Education' generally refers to learning that takes place in a formal setup, like a school, college, or university. However, education can be of other types: formal, informal, and non-formal education.
Formal education: Takes place at a specific place, specific time, with a specified program. A set curriculum is followed, teachers must be trained, specified textbooks are used, and students receive some document/degree/certificate upon completion. There must be a hierarchical structure.
Informal education: Takes place in a flexible setting, not designed according to any pre-fixed plan or to meet the aims of a set curriculum. Time and place are not fixed. Examples include teaching children basic counting, nursery rhymes, or alphabets at home by mothers, siblings, and grandparents. Girls learn household skills informally from family members, while some others learn the same skills in formal settings as well.
Non-formal education: Meant for special target groups and designed for the needs of people in that group, e.g., adult literacy programs. Non-formal education is, in some ways, similar to formal educationโplanned and organized to meet the needs of the persons to be educated.
Education for all is one of the Sustainable Development Goals to be achieved by 2030, reflecting global concern that not everyone receives formal education. Although all children suffer, more girls than boys are affected. One major reason is cultural practices that lead parents to prefer daughters stay home and learn household chores. Early marriages and early motherhood are other major hurdles. Educational facilities are not accessible in many cases. However, in urban areas of developed and developing countries, the number of boys and girls going to school has been improving. In higher education, girls are making significant achievementsโthe number of girls in higher educational institutions and young women entering professional educational institutions is increasing. In non-formal education, mostly NGOs take up the responsibility of adult literacy, helping women who couldn't be educated due to family pressure or early marriage.
๐ Definition โ Formal Education: A planned, structured educational system with a specific place, time, curriculum, trained teachers, hierarchical structure, and certification (degree/diploma). ๐ Definition โ Informal Education: Flexible, unplanned learning that occurs in everyday settings (e.g., home) without a fixed curriculum, time, or place, such as learning household skills from family. ๐ Definition โ Non-formal Education: Organized educational activities designed for specific target groups (e.g., adult literacy programs) that are planned to meet their needs but may not follow a standard curriculum or lead to formal certification.
โญ Key Takeaways
Education is a fundamental human right with particular importance for girls because educated mothers educate their families and improve health outcomes, yet two-thirds of the world's illiterate adults are women and more girls than boys remain out of school due to barriers including cultural practices, early marriage, and inaccessible facilities. The Sustainable Development Goal 4 provides a comprehensive global framework with specific targets for achieving inclusive, equitable quality education by 2030, directly linked to gender equality (SDG 5). Historically, education evolved from informal mentoring to formal compulsory systems driven by industrialization and the need for specialized professionals. The three forms of educationโformal, informal, and non-formalโserve different purposes, with non-formal education playing a crucial role in adult literacy for women who missed formal schooling.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five main barriers to women's education identified in the lecture?
- What was the global number of illiterate adults in 2016, and what proportion were women?
- List four specific targets under SDG Goal 4 that directly address gender disparities in education.
- What historical developments contributed to the shift from informal to formal education systems?
- How does non-formal education differ from formal and informal education, and what role do NGOs play in providing it for women?
๐ Lecture 41 โ GENDER AND EDUCATION-II
๐ Overview: This lecture examines how gender intersects with education through multiple societal forcesโreligion, politics, economy, and social mobility. It argues that while education is a fundamental right and pathway to development, gendered barriers and stereotypes often limit women's access to meaningful, goal-directed education. Understanding these dynamics is critical for achieving equitable educational outcomes and national progress.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture explores the relationship between gender education and religion, showing that while no religion discourages knowledge, some interpretations restrict girls' schooling. It then examines how politics and polity shape educational systems, policies, and resource allocation. The economic dimension is analyzed through education's role in development and Sustainable Development Goal #4. Finally, it covers social mobility through education and the gendered dynamics at different educational levels, including single-sex versus mixed-gender schooling.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic 178: Gender Education and Religion
Education and religion are closely associated. Religion itself teaches and educates people. No religion discourages attainment of knowledge; Islam in fact encourages learning and acquiring knowledge. However, some people view religion and contemporary formal education as opposite to each other. Because of this approach, restrictions may be imposed on children's, especially girls', education. Looking around the world, many countries strictly practice religion yet educate women at all levels. Education and knowledge are to be used for the service of humanity, which our religion teaches.
In Pakistan, Islamic Studies is taught at all levels of education. Young men and women acquire religious knowledge alongside scientific knowledge. It nurtures ethics.
Topic 179: Gender Education and Polity
Politics and polity are related.
๐ Definition โ Polity: "an organized society, such as a nation, city, or church, together with its government and administration"
๐ Definition โ Politics: the methods, techniques, and activities for running the government and the political system
Education and the educational system are affected by politics. This includes the system of education, the content of education, the emphasis of education, the focus of education, and the beneficiaries of education. Education is the most important and major force behind social change. Social change includes change in gender related beliefs, social attitudes in general, and political practices, affiliations, and ideologies.
Politics is about power. It is about WHO will get WHAT, HOW MUCH, HOW, and WHEN? This applies to the resources allocated to education in a country. Different regimes believing in different ideologies have different educational policies.
Pakistan has undergone the same scenario. Some governments allocated more money for uplifting educational system and standards. However, there was always a need to include education as one of the top priority areas. This trend is associated with government policies about gender and/or women. Whether children's education is important or not, whether girls' and women's education is valuable or not, is affected by the ideology and policies of the rulers.
The modern world, the post industrialist world, requires that more and more people with specialized knowledge come forward and contribute to progress and development. There is also the need that women should become productive members of the active workforce. There is need to invest more on educational reforms. Political circles should include education as one of their top priorities. Girls' and women's education needs greater attention since they need to attain goal directed, market oriented education to become productive members of the society.
๐ก Why this matters: Political ideologies directly determine whether girls and women receive education that leads to economic participation or remain educationally marginalized.
Topic 180: Gender Education and Economy
Education is the pathway to economy and development. Education opens new avenues to progress. Education is a basic human right and is an essential ingredient of progress. Education makes good human beings, responsible citizens, workers, professionals, and politicians. The literacy rate in developed nations is very high while other nations are also trying to improve their literacy rate. Education is important for economic development, and goal directed education is even more important.
The education of girls and women requires special attention. Females constitute around half of our population. Any country striving for development requires that all of its citizens contribute actively to national development. The country cannot achieve optimum development and progress if half of its adult population, women, is not contributing to national economy.
Women may not be contributing because of two major reasons: a) Because they are not educated or b) They have not attained such education that leads to a profession or occupation
Hence, this is the significance of education and meaningful education.
Goal#4 in the Sustainable Development Goals pertains to education: Ensure inclusive and equitable quality education and promote lifelong learning opportunities for all.
Goal#4 has seven associated targets:
๐ Target 4.3: By 2030, ensure equal access for all women and men to affordable and quality technical, vocational, and tertiary education, including university
๐ Target 4.4: By 2030, substantially increase the number of youth and adults who have relevant skills, including technical and vocational skills, for employment, decent jobs and entrepreneurship
๐ Target 4.5: By 2030, eliminate gender disparities in education and ensure equal access to all levels of education and vocational training for the vulnerable, including persons with disabilities, indigenous peoples and children in vulnerable situations
These targets involve quality technical, vocational and tertiary education, technical and vocational skills, for employment, decent jobs and entrepreneurship for everyone including persons with special needs. It is therefore essential to make possible accessible education, good quality education, and occupation/profession related education.
Topic 181: Gender Education and Social Mobility
Education is positively correlated with social mobility.
๐ Definition โ Social mobility: the movement of individuals, families, or households from one social category, status, or class to another social category, status, or class
Social mobility can be vertical or horizontal. A person may move from one social position to a higher position attaining upward mobility (downward mobility may also happen). In horizontal mobility the person may remain in the same social class but moves to a better position.
One major factor that plays a very important role in social mobility is the person's education, qualification, or skill. Education, and job oriented education, of boys and young men is emphasized. On the contrary, the purposefulness of female's education is often neglected.
For a male, education with an occupation is considered to be the goal whereas for females, simply being 'educated' is considered enough. This attitude is based upon the stereotypical belief that only men are the heads of family and the bread winners. Today many women head their families and are the bread earners. Also, many women support their husbands and other male members of family in running the household.
Changing gender roles require that women should be provided education that gives knowledge as well as skill. If both men and women are educated then social mobility will be easier for the family. If all members of the family are educated and earning then vertical social mobility within the same generation will be possible. On the other hand if only one or two males are educated and earning, then perhaps only horizontal social mobility would be possible. For upward mobility the family might have to wait for another generation to attain a better social status. It is therefore imperative that all citizens have access to meaningful education. Women's education needs even more attention.
๐ก Why this matters: When women lack purposeful education, entire families are locked into slower social mobility, often requiring multiple generations to achieve upward movement.
Topic 182: Gender and Different Levels of Education; Single or Mixed Gender
Gender differences and similarities can be observed at all levels in educational institutions. All children, when they join school, like to be in a secure environment because they have come out of a very protective atmosphere of their home. With time they make friends, become confident, and take part in games and activities. In single sex schools all friends are the same sex friends. Even in mixed sex or co-educational schools, children prefer to be in the company of same sex friends. Gender differences may be observed in their activities. Even very young children indulge into gender segregation; teachers are generally permissive about it and in fact many encourage this practice (Thorne, 1993). Most junior school teachers are females, who may not be good role models for growing boys. In junior school, male teachers too may not be the right role models for children. Girls usually get better role models in school.
Educational institutions, especially schools, are very influential agents of socialization. Students learn about gender roles, stereotypes, and preferences from their institutions. Educational institutions have their own ideologies just like parents of students. The students learn a number of attitudes, beliefs, and practices from their institutions. At times they learn new beliefs, but the ideologies acquired from parents are also strengthened further by school, teachers, and class mates. The schools may promote and strengthen gender stereotypes. This can be observed in unisex as well as co-educational institutions.
In 'girls only' schools the female stereotypes may be strengthened. Traditional female roles and values are taught and encouraged. Girls passing out from such schools may face some difficulties or psychological problems on entering coeducational institutions for higher education because they were not used to mixing up with men.
Research findings indicate that teachers treat male and female children differently. They promote stereotypical gender roles (Garrahy, 2001). The teachers in elementary school, male and female, encourage compliance and reward children who are compliant (Cohen, 1992).
When male teachers are teaching, there is less gender stereotyping. When students taught by male teachers are compared with those taught by female teachers, it is seen that the former make significantly less stereotypical explanations of the behaviors of men and women (Mancus, 1992).
In the initial years at school, not many gender differences are found in achievement of children, in terms of girls' edge (Bae, Choy, Geddes, Sable, and Snyder, 2008). Girls' grades are better and their scores may be higher than boys in reading and writing. In case of referral for special education services, it is more likely that boys will receive such referrals. Some research suggests this may be a consequence of gender bias (Wehmeyer, 2001). Some differences appear in middle school in terms of children's attitudes and interests.
Girls usually do not opt for physical sciences whereas boys are more interested in taking part in science-related tasks and activities and are more likely to use scientific equipment. Girls also may show interest in these activities, but are less likely to actually do so. This can explain why girls have little interest and lower achievement in physical science (Lee and Burkam, 1996). Although girls still get comparable or better grades than boys in mathematics, they are less interested in Math; considering their field of study, girls find math to be less interesting (Davis-Kean, Eccles, and Linver, 2002). Stereotypically Math is perceived as a male domain, and that can be one explanation of why girls start losing interest in math. Boys, girls, parents, and teachers all hold to this belief about math (Nosek, Benaji, and Greenwald, 2002; Tiedenann, 2000). It has been observed that girl's interests in science and Math may be lower, but not their grades. In higher educational institutions, the gender gap is shrinking because young women are entering into all professional fields of study.
๐ก Why this matters: Stereotypical beliefs about math and science being "male domains" actively discourage girls from pursuing these fields, even when their grades are equal to or better than boys'.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that education is profoundly shaped by religion, politics, economy, and social mobilityโall of which interact with gender to create unequal outcomes. Key points: (1) While no religion opposes education, cultural interpretations often restrict girls' schooling; (2) Political ideologies determine educational policy and resource allocation, directly affecting women's education; (3) Goal-directed, market-oriented education for women is essential for economic development, as emphasized by SDG Goal #4 targets; (4) Education enables social mobility, but women's education is often treated as purposeless compared to men's, slowing family progress; (5) Schools reinforce gender stereotypes through teacher behavior, single-sex schooling practices, and subject choicesโparticularly the perception of math as a male domainโthough the gender gap shrinks at higher education levels.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to the lecture, what are the two main reasons women may not contribute to the national economy?
- What are the seven associated targets of Sustainable Development Goal #4, and which three are specifically mentioned in this lecture?
- How does the lecture distinguish between vertical and horizontal social mobility, and what role does women's education play in each?
- What do research findings (Lee and Burkam, 1996; Davis-Kean et al., 2002) reveal about girls' interest versus achievement in math and physical sciences?
- What does Thorne's (1993) research indicate about gender segregation in elementary school classrooms, and how do teachers typically respond?