📘 Lecture 35 — Women’s Role in Politics of Pakistan-I
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the historical and contemporary role of women in Pakistan’s political landscape, from pre-independence activism to post-1947 legislative participation. It matters because understanding women’s political journey reveals the structural barriers they have overcome and the critical contributions they have made to shaping Pakistan’s democracy and legal framework.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five sequential topics: first, women’s political role in pre-independence India under British rule and the Pakistan Movement; second, key developments after 1947 that enabled women’s political participation; third, women’s representation in Pakistan’s legislative process from 1970 onward; fourth, the specific roles women political leaders play in advancing women’s rights; and fifth, concrete evidence of Pakistani women’s legislative success, including pro-women laws passed between 2006 and 2017.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 148: Women’s Role in Politics of Pakistan: Pre Independence
Women in the Indo-Pak subcontinent, though not in large numbers, had been participating in politics historically, with figures like Razia Sultana and the Rani of Jhansi. Under the Government of India Act 1935, six million women were enfranchised with limited franchise, and reserved seats were allocated in the Council of State and Assembly. In the 1937 elections, eight women were elected from general constituencies and 42 from reserved ones. Initially focused on educational reforms, women’s activism later became central to the freedom movement.
A major milestone occurred when Quaid-i-Azam Mohammad Ali Jinnah created the All India Muslim Women’s Sub-Committee of the Muslim League. By the mid-1940s, prominent women leaders emerged: Jahanara Shahnawaz (Lahore), Begum Salma Tassaduq Hussain, Begum Fatima (Bengal), Shaista Ikramullah (Sindh), Lady Abdullah Haroon (Sindh), and Begum Zari Sarfraz (NWFP, now KPK). Women actively organized processions and protests. In 1941, Lady Abdul Qadir, Fatima Begum, and Miss M. Qureshi founded the Muslim Girls Student Federation. Women’s committees formed in 1942 due to Jinnah’s interest, and 5,000 women participated in the 1943 All-India Muslim League session in Karachi. In the 1946 elections, Begum Salma Tassaduq Hussain and Begum Jahan Ara Shahnawaz contested. Women actively participated in the Civil Disobedience Movement of 1947, leading to independence on 14 August 1947.
🔑 Definition — Limited franchise: The right to vote granted to only a specific subset of women (based on property ownership or education), not universal suffrage.
📌 Example — 1937 elections: 8 women were elected from general constituencies, and 42 from reserved seats, under the Government of India Act 1935.
Topic 149: Women’s Role in Politics of Pakistan: After Independence
After 1947, several developments paved the way for women’s political and social activism. First, girls and women gained better access to education, including higher and professional education. Second, increasing numbers of women entered professions and public sector service. Third, women who had contributed to refugee welfare now worked for social reforms and women’s welfare.
In the first legislature, Jahanara Shahnawaz and Shaista Ikramullah were the two women representatives. The Muslim Personal Law of Shariat (1948) recognized women’s right to inherit property, and in 1951 was extended to agricultural land. In 1954, the draft Charter of Women’s Rights proposed by Jahanara Shahnawaz reserved 3% of seats for women at central and provincial levels. The 1956 Constitution accepted the principle of female suffrage for reserved seats based on territorial constituencies.
The Muslim Family Laws Ordinance (MFLO) of 1961 granted women rights regarding marriage, child custody, divorce, and registration. The 1973 Constitution strengthened protections: Article 25(1) declares all citizens equal before law; Article 25(2) prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex alone; Article 25(3) allows the State to create special laws for women and children; and Article 34 ensures full participation of women in all national spheres. The 18th Amendment devolved most social issues to provinces, increasing resources for women’s empowerment.
💡 Why this matters: These early legal victories—especially property inheritance rights and constitutional protections—established the foundational framework for all subsequent women’s rights legislation in Pakistan.
Topic 150: Women in the Legislative Process in Pakistan
The first assembly elected on adult franchise and population basis was formed after the 1970 general elections. It had 313 members (169 from East Pakistan, now Bangladesh, and 144 from West Pakistan), with 13 reserved seats for women (7 from East, 6 from West). Under the 1973 Constitution, a bicameral parliamentary system was adopted: the National Assembly initially had 200 general seats plus 10 reserved for women. In 1985, a Presidential Order (P.O. No. 14 of 1985) added 7 general seats and 10 reserved women’s seats, plus 10 for minorities, bringing the total to 237. By 2017, the Senate had 19 women (18%) and 85 men (82%) out of 104 senators. In the National Assembly (after 2013 elections), out of 342 members, 71 (21%) were women—but only 10 (4%) were elected on general seats versus 262 (96%) men. After the 2018 elections, the National Assembly had 60 women on reserved seats and 8 elected on general seats, while the Senate had 20 women out of 104.
📐 Formula: Reserved seats for women = percentage of total assembly strength allocated by law (changed from 3% in 1954 to current levels) → that’s the minimum number guaranteed for women without needing to win general elections.
Topic 151: The Role of Women Political Leaders in Tackling Women’s Rights Issues
Women parliamentarians are essential because they are closer to other women, aware of their problems, and more likely to propose women-friendly solutions. Women political leaders contribute in six ways: (1) Organizing women at the grass-root level, raising political and social consciousness; (2) Identifying needs through observation and research; (3) Identifying barriers that impede women’s empowerment; (4) Finding solutions to problems, especially in consultation with affected women; (5) Devising and implementing interventions by motivating and mobilizing women; (6) Campaigning, awareness raising, and setting up facilities.
Topic 152: Pakistani Women’s Success in Legislation
Women parliamentarians’ legislative productivity in 2018-2019 was remarkable. In the National Assembly, each male member sponsored 3 agenda items on average, while each woman sponsored 8. In the Senate, men sponsored 8 and women 7. 62% of female lawmakers contributed to discussions/debates—90% of female Senators and 46% of female MNAs. Specific contributions included: Private members’ bills (53%, or 39 out of 74); Resolutions (27%, or 27 out of 100); Calling Attention Notices (47%, or 51 out of 108); Questions (32%, or 561 out of 1772); Proposals for amendments to parliamentary rules (40%, or 4 out of 10); Motions for debate on public importance (39%, or 41 out of 104); Parliamentary interventions singly or with other women (around 30%); and partnered business with male colleagues (3%).
Key pro-women laws passed at the federal level include: Protection of Women (Criminal Laws Amendment) Act, 2006; Protection against Harassment of Women at the Workplace Act, 2010; Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2010 and subsequent amendments in 2011, 2016 (for honor killings and rape); National Commission on the Status of Women Act, 2012; Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016; Elections Act, 2017; Hindu Marriage Act, 2017; and National Commission on the Status of Children Act, 2017.
📌 Example — Women’s legislative productivity in 2018-2019: In the National Assembly, women sponsored 8 agenda items per member versus 3 for men; women authored 53% of all private members’ bills and contributed to 62% of parliamentary debates.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Women in Pakistan have a long political heritage, from pre-independence organizing under the Muslim League to becoming active legislators after 1947. The legal framework—especially the 1973 Constitution’s Articles 25, 34, and 18th Amendment—provides the basis for women’s political rights and protections. Women’s representation in parliament has increased significantly, from 3% reserved seats to over 20% in the National Assembly today, but most women still enter through reserved seats rather than general elections. Women parliamentarians have been remarkably productive, sponsoring nearly three times more agenda items than their male counterparts and authoring over half of private members’ bills. A robust set of pro-women laws has been passed between 2006 and 2017, addressing harassment, honor killings, rape, marriage, and workplace protections.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What was the significance of the All India Muslim Women’s Sub-Committee created by Jinnah?
- List four key provisions of the 1973 Constitution that protect women’s rights.
- How many women were in the National Assembly after the 2018 elections, and how many were on reserved versus general seats?
- What were the six specific ways women political leaders can contribute to women’s rights, according to the lecture?
- Name three pro-women laws passed between 2006 and 2017, and state the year each was enacted.
📘 Lecture 36 — WOMEN’S ROLE IN POLITICS OF PAKISTAN-II
📖 Overview: This lecture examines women's political participation in Pakistan, focusing on local government as a crucial but often neglected arena. It details the achievements and barriers women face in this sphere, explores societal beliefs that hinder their political roles, and outlines a path forward for more impactful involvement.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers women in local government in Pakistan, including the introduction of reserved seats under the Local Government Ordinance 2001. It details the achievements of women councilors at the local level, highlighting their role as a bridge to legislators. The lecture then systematically lists the social, cultural, economic, political, and religious barriers hindering women's political participation. It analyzes stereotypical beliefs about women's roles in politics and their consequences, before concluding with necessary steps and initiatives like the Election Commission of Pakistan's Gender Affairs Wing for a more inclusive political future.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 153: Women in Local Government in Pakistan
Women’s political participation at the local government level is often neglected, despite being a critical arena. While women parliamentarians at national/provincial levels may lack direct links to grassroots women, party workers at the local level are knowledgeable about local issues and can make excellent contributions. By being part of local government, women can effectively tackle issues affecting women and children, such as health, sanitation, clean drinking water, and education. They can provide locally acceptable solutions and demonstrate leadership, especially when facing barriers like restricted mobility or family responsibilities. A new beginning for local government came with the Local Government Ordinance, 2001, which provided 33% reserved seats for women in all three tiers: District, Tehsil, and Union Councils.
🔑 Definition — Local Government Ordinance, 2001: A Pakistani law that introduced a new local government system, notably reserving 33% of seats for women across all three tiers (District, Tehsil, Union Council).
📐 Formula: None.
📌 Example: The 2001 Local Government Ordinance reserved 33% of seats in District, Tehsil, and Union Councils for women, enabling them to address local issues like health and sanitation.
Topic 154: Achievements of Women in Local Government in Pakistan
Women’s representation in local government has been on a very large scale compared to national/provincial levels, especially after the 33% quota. For example, more than 36,000 directly elected women Union Councilors were inducted in the 2001-2002 elections and 24,000 in the 2005 elections. Women serve in all three tiers alongside their male counterparts. The benefits of this system include acting as seed beds for future political leaders, providing opportunities for middle and lower-middle-class women and less educated women to become leaders. Many housewives and political novices became Councilors. These councilors serve as a bridge between MNAs/MPAs and the local community, bringing grassroots issues to legislators, making it easier to address women's issues.
🔑 Definition — Trickle-down effect: In this context, the concept that women's emancipation and participation at the national/provincial level will create a positive impact and encourage participation at the local level.
📐 Formula: None.
📌 Example: Over 36,000 women were elected as Union Councilors in 2001-2002 as a direct result of the 33% reserved seat quota in the Local Government Ordinance, 2001.
Topic 155: Barriers to Women’s Political Participation
Women's political participation faces numerous social, cultural, economic, political, and religious barriers that hinder their empowerment. These barriers affect women as voters, political workers, and leaders. Key barriers include: the patriarchal mindset questioning female leadership; stereotypical beliefs about women's capability; political party dynamics where women find it hard to reach higher levels; party preferences based on gender rather than capability; women's inexperience and hurdles to gain experience; young age, limited education, or low socioeconomic status; dual responsibilities; a non-supportive attitude from family and community; hesitation as voters due to community pressure and inaccessible polling stations; and issues of physical mobility.
🔑 Definition — Patriarchal mindset: A social system where men hold primary power, leading to beliefs that women cannot or should not be leaders.
📐 Formula: None.
📌 Example: A woman may face a barrier as a political worker when a political party assigns her tasks based on her gender rather than her individual capability, preventing her from reaching higher levels.
Topic 156: Beliefs about Women’s Role in Politics
Stereotypical beliefs held by society and women themselves become hurdles in women's political empowerment. The belief that "women's place is at home" leads to girls lacking skills for the outside world. The belief that "women cannot be leaders" means their socialization focuses on household skills, not public dealing. The belief that "women cannot manage large-scale political activity" results in them being given only small team leader roles. The belief that "women lack emotional stability" leads to men being preferred for decision-making positions. The belief that "women can be easily intimidated by opponents" prevents them from being given assignments to show their ability. Furthermore, women's own beliefs about self are a barrier due to socialization that makes them feel dependent and avoid challenges. However, these beliefs are changing as many women have become excellent role models, encouraging more women to participate in decision-making.
🔑 Definition — Stereotypical beliefs: Oversimplified and fixed ideas about a particular group (here, women) that are not necessarily accurate and can limit their opportunities.
📐 Formula: None.
📌 Example: The belief that "women cannot be leaders" leads to a consequence where girls are socialized to be good at household skills rather than interpersonal communication, thus hindering their path to political leadership.
Topic 157: Women and Politics; Way Forward
To make women's political participation stronger and more effective, several steps are needed. These include compulsory education for girls, empowerment-oriented education, legal rights awareness, and a political party commitment to increased women's participation. Involving civil society organizations for mobilizing women at the grassroots level and abiding by global commitments on women's rights are also crucial. The Election Commission of Pakistan has set up the Gender Affairs Wing to work on improved participation. This wing has established a system for gathering information on women's votes and formed the Gender and Disability Electoral Working Group (GDEWG) to mainstream women and other marginalized groups into the political process.
💡 Why this matters: This topic outlines concrete, actionable steps and existing institutional mechanisms (like the Gender Affairs Wing) that are actively working to dismantle the barriers and beliefs discussed earlier, providing a positive path forward for women's political empowerment in Pakistan.
🔑 Definition — Gender Affairs Wing: A wing of the Election Commission of Pakistan established to improve women's participation in the electoral and political process.
📐 Formula: None.
📌 Example: The Election Commission of Pakistan's Gender Affairs Wing created the Gender and Disability Electoral Working Group (GDEWG) to mainstream women and other marginalized groups into the political process.
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture emphasizes that local government, with its 33% reserved quota for women since 2001, is a vital entry point for women's political participation, allowing millions of women to serve as councilors and address local issues. However, women's political empowerment is significantly hindered by deep-seated social, cultural, political, and religious barriers, including patriarchal mindsets, stereotypical beliefs about women's capabilities, and internalized beliefs of inferiority. The lecture highlights that these barriers are reinforced by socialization, which prepares women for domestic roles rather than public leadership. A clear path forward exists through compulsory education, legal awareness, and institutional commitment, including the proactive role of the Election Commission of Pakistan's Gender Affairs Wing. The ultimate takeaway is that while women's political participation is growing, sustained effort across societal, educational, and political fronts is essential for overcoming persistent barriers.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What was the key provision of the Local Government Ordinance 2001 for women's political participation, and how many women Union Councilors were elected in the 2001-2002 elections?
- List four specific benefits of women's participation in local government as mentioned in the lecture.
- Identify and explain three distinct types of barriers to women's political participation (e.g., social, cultural, economic, etc.) mentioned in the lecture.
- Describe the "belief about self" that becomes a hurdle for women in politics and explain its consequence.
- What is the Gender Affairs Wing, and what is one of its key initiatives to improve women's political participation?
📘 Lecture 37 — Gender and Health-I (Topics 158-162)
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the critical relationship between gender and health, demonstrating how biological, behavioral, and social factors create different health outcomes for men and women. It covers gendered mortality and morbidity patterns, the special significance of women's health promotion, and global and Pakistan-specific health statistics, making it essential for understanding health disparities as a gender justice issue.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture opens with the WHO definition of health and outlines seven ways health becomes a gender issue, including differential life expectancy, disease incidence, risk factors, and healthcare access. It then covers WHO's top ten facts on women's health, the significance of health promotion for women (focusing on reproductive responsibility, disease risk, domestic duties, stereotypical beliefs, and empowerment), gender differences in mortality and life expectancy (with biological and behavioral explanations), leading causes of death globally and by sex, and morbidity patterns including NCDs and Pakistan-specific data on maternal mortality and infant survival.
📝 Lecture Summary
Gender and Health
Health is defined as "a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity" (WHO, 1946). A healthy person enjoys well-being in a holistic sense—physically, psychologically, and socially. Health is one of the basic human rights; all humans have a right to good health and healthcare, including prevention measures.
Health becomes a gender issue in multiple ways: life expectancy differs between men and women; incidence of different diseases varies by sex; men and women face different risk factors; they engage in different kinds of risky behaviors; families may value healthcare for male and female members differently; and the uptake of medical facilities differs. According to World Health Statistics Overview 2019, gender-related factors result in differential outcomes—for example, girls' increased risk of adverse health outcomes from early pregnancy following child marriage. Men and women experience different risks of work-related injuries due to gender-based division of labor. Women may adopt health-compromising behaviors like depriving themselves of essential nutrients for weight loss, while men indulge more in smoking, alcohol use, and risky driving.
💡 Why this matters: The seven ways health is gendered show that health disparities are not just biological but are shaped by social norms, economic resources, and discriminatory practices.
WHO's top ten facts on women's health include:
- Tobacco use rising rapidly in younger women in developing countries
- HIV in sub-Saharan Africa increasingly affects females
- Serious health consequences of violence against women (widespread globally)
- Decline in early marriage but still very high rates
- Majority of adolescent mothers live in developing countries
- Around 99% of maternal and 90% of neonatal mortalities occur in developing countries
- Women earning income are more likely than men to buy insecticide-treated nets
- Risk of COPD (Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease) is 50% higher in women due to indoor cooking smoke from traditional stoves
- Risk of visual impairment is higher in women
- Life expectancy is higher for women than men; boys at birth are expected to live fewer years than girls
Significance of Health Promotion and Disease Prevention for Women
Women's health calls for special attention and needs to be protected and enhanced for several reasons:
The Responsibility of Reproduction: A healthy mother gives birth to a healthy baby. Women's health must be protected for problem-free pregnancy and healthy babies. Women also experience many reproductive health issues that men do not.
Risk of Disease: Women are at high risk of certain preventable diseases (e.g., HIV) and treatable conditions (e.g., breast cancer) if diagnosed early. Appropriate diagnostic measures and treatment facilities are essential.
Women's Domestic Responsibilities: Women care for households, young children, and elderly relatives. If working outside the home, their responsibility doubles. They need to be healthy to meet all demands.
Stereotypical Beliefs about Women's Health: In patriarchal societies, women's health receives less attention than men's. This is evident in dietary habits and poor nutrition provided to the girl child. Women often postpone consulting a doctor, leading to delayed diagnosis of serious problems.
Gender, Health, and Women Empowerment: With more women entering the active workforce, health and fitness are more important than when women were homebound. Life is more competitive and stressful; strong minds and bodies are required to combat pressures from home and work.
Gender and Mortality
Mortality refers to death, usually discussed in terms of mortality rate.
🔑 Definition — Mortality Rate: "A percentage of the total number of deaths over the population size (X 1000) in a given time period, usually a year" (Lindsey, 2011).
There are gender differences in mortality rates, leading causes of death, and expected life span. Life expectancy of women is generally higher than men. At a global scale, boys at birth are expected to live 69.8 years whereas girls' expectancy is 74.2 years. At age 60, life expectancy is higher for women (21.9 years) than men (19 years). HALE (years lived in full health) is also higher for women (64.8) than men (62).
Biological and behavioral reasons: Women seem to have natural protection against heart disease until menopause; after menopause, risk is similar for men and women. The top leading cause for both sexes is Ischemic Heart Disease followed by Strokes. Behaviorally, men indulge in more health-compromising and risky behaviors—more smoking, alcohol use, and in higher quantities—leading to cancers, cardiovascular disease, respiratory problems, and liver cirrhosis. Deaths by road injury are higher in men; adolescents and young adults engage in one-wheeling, jumping from high places, street fights, and drowning. However, women face serious health conditions too; rates of acute illnesses (respiratory, digestive) and nonfatal chronic problems (anemia, headache, arthritis, varicose veins) are higher in women in developed countries.
Gender differences in healthcare uptake: Men generally postpone seeking medical consultation, possibly due to stereotypical masculinity where being "ill" means being "weak" and not "masculine." When hospitalized, men stay longer for chronic and life-threatening conditions. Women on the other hand report illness more often than men, seek treatment for minor illnesses, report more un-explained symptoms, and visit doctors regularly for routine gynecological tests and pregnancy-related consultations.
Gender and Mortality in the World
The leading causes of death globally for both sexes (WHO) are:
- Ischemic heart disease
- Stroke
- Chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder
- Lower respiratory infections
- Alzheimer's disease and other dementias
- Trachea, bronchus, and lung cancers
- Diabetes mellitus
- Road injury
- Diarrheal disease
- Tuberculosis
Leading causes for females:
- Ischemic heart disease, Stroke, Lower respiratory infections, Chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder, Alzheimer's disease and other dementias, Diabetes mellitus, Diarrheal disease, Breast cancer, Kidney diseases
Leading causes for males:
- Ischemic heart disease, Stroke, Chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder, Lower respiratory infections, Trachea, bronchus, and lung cancers, Road injury, Cirrhosis of the liver, Tuberculosis, Diabetes mellitus
Gender and Morbidity; Men, Women, and Girls
Morbidity refers to suffering from a health condition or being diseased. It also refers to having a disease/symptom, or the amount of disease within a population, including medical problems caused by treatment.
🔑 Definition — Morbidity: The condition of being diseased or the incidence of disease in a population; also refers to medical problems caused by a treatment.
Decades ago, infectious or communicable diseases were major killers; today non-communicable diseases (NCDs) are the primary health threats. According to WHO, 40.5 million (71%) deaths in 2016 were due to NCDs out of 56.9 million global deaths. Major NCDs include cardiovascular diseases, cancers, and chronic lung diseases. Cardiovascular diseases caused 44% of all NCD deaths, cancers caused 22%, diabetes around 4%, and chronic lung diseases 9%. The proportion was higher for lower-income countries—31.5 million deaths (over 75%) from NCDs occurred in low and middle-income countries. 46% of deaths happened before age 70.
Pakistan-specific health statistics:
- Life expectancy at birth m/f (2016): 66/67 years
- Probability of dying under five (per 1000 live births, 2017): 75
- Probability of dying between 15 and 60 years m/f (per 1000 population, 2016): 178/139
- Average life expectancy in Pakistan: 66.6 years (68.2 for females, 65.8 for males) vs. global average 71.5 years
- Maternal mortality rate (MMR) in Pakistan: decreased from 431/100,000 live births (1990) to 178/100,000 live births (2015)
Top ten leading causes of death in Pakistan (2012):
- Ischemic Heart Disease
- Lower Respiratory Infections
- Stroke
- Preterm Birth Complications
- Diarrheal Diseases
- Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
- Tuberculosis
- Birth Asphyxia & Trauma
- Neonatal Sepsis & Infections
- Diabetes Mellitus
Communicable diseases (tuberculosis, diarrheal diseases, lower respiratory infections) accounted for 17.8% of all deaths. NCDs (heart disease, COPD, diabetes) caused 22.3%. A significant 12.8% of all deaths were caused by complications in women's reproductive health (neonatal sepsis, birth asphyxia, preterm birth complications). The survival rate of female babies is higher than male babies, but female infants may not receive the same care. There is a significant number of female fetus abortion in many countries, particularly India and China. Girl children need provision of adequate healthcare and nutrition.
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that health is not merely the absence of disease but holistic well-being, and is fundamentally gendered across all dimensions—from life expectancy and disease incidence to risk behaviors, healthcare access, and societal valuation. Women live longer but suffer more morbidity from acute and chronic conditions, while men die earlier due to more risky behaviors and reluctance to seek medical help due to masculine stereotypes. The global burden of NCDs now exceeds communicable diseases, with cardiovascular disease as the top killer for both sexes, but specific diseases like breast cancer for women and liver cirrhosis for men show gendered patterns. In Pakistan, life expectancy is below global average, maternal mortality has declined but remains high, and a significant proportion of deaths stem from reproductive health complications, demanding urgent attention to women's healthcare and nutrition.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to WHO, what are the three dimensions of health beyond merely "absence of disease"?
- List at least four of the seven ways health becomes a gender issue as outlined in the lecture.
- Why is the risk of COPD 50% higher in women than in men, and what is the primary cause?
- Explain the gender differences in healthcare uptake: why do men postpone seeking medical help while women report illness more often?
- What are the top three leading causes of death globally for both males and females, and what percentage of global deaths in 2016 were due to non-communicable diseases?
📘 Lecture 38 — GENDER AND HEALTH-II
📖 Overview: This lecture explores critical gender dimensions in health, focusing on women's health challenges, nutrition, eating disorders, HIV/AIDS, and drug use. It emphasizes how gender norms, cultural practices, and media influence health outcomes differently for men and women, making health a gendered issue requiring targeted interventions.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the significance of improving women's health due to multiple responsibilities and stressors, women's nutritional challenges including traditional biases and weight concerns, eating disorders (anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa) as gendered issues influenced by media portrayals, HIV/AIDS transmission patterns showing gender disparities, and gender differences in drug use and abuse patterns.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 163: Significance of Improving Women’s Health
Women face unique health challenges due to changing lifestyles, dual and multiple responsibilities, and involvement in a highly competitive world. Women’s responsibilities at home have increased after they started working outside home, requiring them to manage jobs, household, child care, children’s education, and looking after older adults — resulting in high stress levels. Because of pressing demands, women tend to neglect their own health.
Because of stereotypical perceptions of beauty, women are generally weight conscious. Many young women deprive themselves of essential nutrients needed for a healthy body, especially when becoming a mother. Over-concern about weight and appearance damages self-concept and may lead to eating disorders. Workplace stressors including harassment pose psychological and physical threats. Domestic violence is another health threat. Poor sanitation and hygiene negatively affect girls and women, and there is a lack of facilities for physical fitness activities. The health issues faced by aging women need special attention. There must be imperative to devise ways for improving women's health through health promotion and disease prevention, addressing both physical and psychological health.
Topic 164: Women’s Health and Nutrition
Good nutrition is essential for good health. Balanced diet and adequate nutrients maintain health. Nutrition is particularly important for growing bodies. Young girls need to consume food with good nutritional value because they will carry the responsibility of reproduction and household in future. A healthy mother is more likely to give birth to a healthy baby. Poor nutrition is correlated with many health conditions including problems of hair, skin, nails, bones, vision, aches, pains, anemia, and stress tolerance.
Traditionally, in many cultures, girls are not allowed to eat certain food items (eggs, meat, dates, high-calorie diets) which presumably may lead to early puberty. If the family has limited financial resources, male members get better food because men are believed to be bread winners. Women by choice do not eat required amounts of nutritious food, preferring only food that does not lead to weight gain rather than maintaining weight through physical activity. There is a need to raise awareness about nutrition and physical fitness through media campaigns, school curricula, and psychological counseling.
🔑 Definition — Anemia: a condition characterized by insufficient healthy red blood cells or hemoglobin to carry adequate oxygen to body tissues.
💡 Why this matters: Traditional food taboos and gender-biased food distribution create long-term health consequences for women, affecting not only their own health but also the health of future generations.
Topic 165: Eating Disorders as a Gender Issue
Eating disorders are often associated with females but affect people of all ages, genders, socioeconomic groups, and cultural backgrounds. Growing awareness that major killers are non-communicable diseases (lifestyle-related) has increased concern about obesity and weight control. Being overweight is a major risk factor in many serious health conditions.
Obesity becomes a greater issue for girls and women because of stereotypical perceptions of an ideal weight. Society has different attractiveness standards for men and women. Excess weight of a man may be ignored but not of a woman. Increased concern to the extent of obsession may lead to serious psychological problems. People obsessed with losing weight are primarily females. Some may adopt practical ways (diet and exercise plans), while others develop eating disorders.
🔑 Definition — Anorexia Nervosa: an eating disorder involving drastically curtailed food intake with intention to lose weight, where the person tries to maintain body weight 15% below what should be their normal weight.
Anorexia Nervosa involves drastically curtailed food intake. The anorexic person tries to maintain body weight 15% below what should be their weight. They tend to have a BMI of 17.5. The person is not happy at or above normal weight for their height and age, has fear of gaining weight, and does not perceive their body realistically. A female may actually be underweight but feels need to lose more weight. Consumption of food is minimal with long periods of starvation. Anorexia is found significantly more in females than males.
📐 Formula: BMI (Body Mass Index) = weight (kg) / height (m²) → Anorexia threshold: BMI ≤ 17.5
📌 Example: An anorexic person weighing 45 kg with height 1.6 m would have BMI = 45 / (1.6)² = 45 / 2.56 = 17.6, which is close to the anorexic threshold of 17.5, despite being significantly underweight.
🔑 Definition — Bulimia Nervosa: an eating disorder marked by binge eating followed by purging to prevent weight gain.
Bulimia Nervosa differs from Anorexia Nervosa in eating pattern. As opposed to starvation in anorexia, bulimia is marked by binge eating and purging. The person binge eats large amounts of food within short time intervals, feeling unable to stop or control eating. Afterwards there is desire to purge through self-induced vomiting, laxatives, diuretics, enemas, or other medications. Fasting or excessive exercise may also be used. Eating disorders may be accompanied by anxiety, depression, sleep disturbance, low self-esteem, poor self-concept, irritability, disturbed interpersonal relationships. These disorders are more prevalent in societies where physical beauty is valued more than any other characteristic.
💡 Why this matters: Eating disorders are gendered because societal beauty standards place disproportionate pressure on women, making them more vulnerable to these life-threatening conditions.
Topic 166: Eating Disorders and the Role of Media
Cultural factors play an important role in development of eating disorders. Stereotypical perceptions of attractiveness and societal norms set difficult standards for young people, leading to psychological problems including eating disorders for young girls.
Media, especially electronic media, plays a significant role in establishment and promotion of societal norms and attitudes. Media is today's most influential agent of socialization and agent of social change. Observational learning takes place through media exposure. Media presents ideals, role models, and standards for young minds. Girls want to become like models and celebrities shown on screen. Heroes and heroines have all ideal attributes including a slim and trim figure. The lead role has to be slim and fair skinned. Eating disorders are more common in societies where physical beauty is the most important characteristic of a woman.
TV, cinema, fashion magazines, and internet play important roles in development of people's self-concept. Portrayal of women in media and identification with portrayed characters may lead to body dissatisfaction. This dissatisfaction and inability to understand the situation rationally may end up in disordered eating behavior. In the recent past, extremely thin models have been presented. People have raised voice against this trend, and now average/normal weight models are also being employed. Exposure to media affects young men too, with growing concern over physical fitness and pressure for developing muscular bodies, though the impact is not as big as for females.
Topic 167: HIV/AIDS as a Gender Issue
HIV/AIDS remain one of the world's most significant public health challenges, especially in low- and middle-income countries. Advances in access to antiretroviral therapy (ART) have made it possible for HIV positive persons to live longer and enjoy healthier life, and onward transmission is also prevented. In mid-2017, 20.9 million people were receiving HIV treatment.
HIV (Human Immunodeficiency Virus) is the viral agent, a retrovirus. AIDS (Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome) is the disease caused by HIV. Not every HIV positive (HIV+) person will develop AIDS. It may take an HIV+ person some years to turn into a PWA (Person with AIDS). AIDS is a syndrome (collection of symptoms) with no single symptom characterizing it. HIV damages and destroys cells responsible for the body's immune system.
🔑 Definition — Retrovirus: a virus that replicates by injecting itself into host cells, taking over the genetic workings of these cells to produce virus particles that infect new cells.
"Retroviruses replicate by injecting themselves into host cells and literally taking over the genetic workings of these cells. They can then produce virus particles that infect new cells. After HIV enters the bloodstream it invades the T cells, incorporates its genetic material into the cells, and then starts destroying cells' ability to function" (Sanderson, 2004, P; 408). T cells recognize harmful substances and attack such cells. HIV may stay latent and dormant for quite some time, but gradually begins to replicate, leading to destruction of T cells.
Major modes of Transmission:
- Homosexual or Heterosexual contact
- Blood transfusion
- IV (intravenous) drug use with infected syringes
- From HIV+ mother to baby during birth process
Gender and HIV/AIDS Risk: There are gender differences in likelihood of HIV infection. Data from CDC (2003) shows:
- Modes of Transmission for men (%): Homosexual Contact (57.3), Injecting drug use (21.2), Homosexual Contact & Injecting drug use (7.6), Heterosexual contact (4.3), Transfusion (0.8), Undetermined (8.0)
- Modes of Transmission for Women (%): Injecting drug use (41.5), Heterosexual contact (39.4), Transfusion (3.0), Undetermined (15.9)
Only 4.3% of men contract HIV/AIDS from women, whereas 39.4% women get infected by men. Male to female transmission is 8 times more likely than female to male transmission (Padian, Shiboski, Glass, & Vittinghoff, 1997). The proportion of women living with HIV is 51% of the global total — around 17.4 million women. In sub-Saharan Africa in 2014, women constituted 59% of adults living with HIV.
Considering lifestyles, men are at higher risk than women due to indulgence in risky behaviors. However, high percentage of women falls victim. There is need for health education and awareness campaigns regarding nature of disease, modes of transmission, and prevention. People need to learn that unsafe, risky, and harmful behaviors must be avoided. Infected women need to learn about avoiding and/or planning pregnancy after medical advice. Easily accessible screening facilities need to be established.
📌 Example: A woman whose husband engages in unprotected extramarital heterosexual contact has an 8 times higher chance of getting infected from him than he would from her, highlighting women's biological and social vulnerability.
Topic 168: Drug Use
Gender differences are found in drug use and abuse. Even when use of certain substances (alcohol, caffeine, nicotine) is culturally acceptable for both genders, usage pattern is gender different. Gender difference in morbidity rates relative to usage is also evident.
Alcoholism is significantly higher among men. More men use alcohol throughout their lives compared to women. However, women suffer more from acute and chronic effects because they metabolize alcohol differently. Their driving gets impaired quicker. They face alcohol-induced liver disease and brain damage over shorter period of time after consumption (National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, 2008). Fetal alcohol syndrome is connected with infants having low birth weight, congenital heart defects, and mental retardation.
Men are more likely to turn to alcohol while coping with stress, whereas women are more likely to turn to prescribed drugs. Use of over-the-counter and prescribed drugs is double for women. Compared to men, women are twice as likely to take a narcotic or anti-anxiety drug for a psychological problem, and twice as likely to abuse or become addicted to them (National Institute on Drug Abuse, 2008). Alcohol use may lead to aggression, violent behavior, and has connection with criminal offenses such as rape, homicide, and spouse abuse.
Gender gap in morbidity due to drug use may decrease if women also adopted risky health-endangering behaviors. Although men of all ages smoke and consume alcohol at significantly higher rates, gender differences have started to quickly decrease amongst adolescents (National Center for Health Statistics, 2009). More female adolescents are indulging in health-compromising behaviors. Consequently, mortality rates due to liver cirrhosis, lung cancer, and heart disease (which have been lower for females) may increase.
Generally more males consume harmful substances because male adolescents spend more time outside home and are likely to meet people involved in provision of drugs. However, girls/women may also become addicts.
Way forward:
- Education, especially health education
- Active role of media in health campaigns
- Laws for prohibition of harmful substances
⭐ Key Takeaways
Women face unique health risks from multiple responsibilities, nutritional deprivation, and gender-biased beauty standards that can lead to eating disorders like anorexia nervosa (BMI ≤ 17.5, starvation) and bulimia nervosa (binge-purge cycle). Media powerfully reinforces thin ideals, especially for women, making eating disorders a gendered issue. HIV/AIDS transmission shows stark gender disparities — male-to-female transmission is 8 times more likely, and women now constitute 51% of global HIV cases. Drug use patterns differ by gender: men use alcohol more but women suffer worse effects and are twice as likely to abuse prescription drugs. Health education, media responsibility, and policy interventions are essential to address these gendered health challenges.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key factors that make improving women's health particularly important in the modern context?
- Describe the differences between Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa in terms of eating patterns and health consequences.
- Why is male-to-female HIV transmission 8 times more likely than female-to-male transmission, and what percentage of women contract HIV through heterosexual contact?
- How does media contribute to the development of eating disorders, and what changes have been observed in media representation recently?
- What are the gender differences in drug use patterns, specifically regarding alcohol versus prescription drugs, and how are these patterns changing among adolescents?