π Lecture 36 β Contemporary Social Theorists: George Hebert Mead (1863-1931)-III
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of George Herbert Mead's social theory, focusing on the concept of the generalized other, the dual phases of the self as βIβ and βme,β and his view of society. It concludes with the seven basic principles of Symbolic Interactionism, explaining how thought, meaning, and interaction construct human society.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the generalized other, which is the attitude of the entire community essential for a complete self, and the two phases of the self: the spontaneous and creative βIβ and the conforming βme.β It then discusses Mead's concept of society as an ongoing social process and the formation of social institutions. Finally, it outlines the seven basic principles of Symbolic Interactionism, including the capacity for thought, the role of social interaction, and how meanings and symbols shape action and society.
π Lecture Summary
Topic 146: Generalized Other
The game stage yields one of Meadβs best-known concepts, the generalized other. The generalized other is the attitude of the entire community or, in the example of the baseball game, the attitude of the entire team. The ability to take the role of the generalized other is essential to the self: βOnly in so far as he takes the attitudes of the organized social group to which he belongs toward the organized, co-operative social activity or set of such activities in which that group is engaged, does he develop a complete self.β It is also crucial that people be able to evaluate themselves from the point of view of the generalized other and not merely from the viewpoint of discrete others. Taking the role of the generalized other, rather than that of discrete others, allows for the possibility of abstract thinking and objectivity.
In other words, to have a self, one must be a member of a community and be directed by the attitudes common to the community. While play requires only pieces of selves, the game requires a coherent self. The generalized other also represents Meadβs familiar propensity to give priority to the social, because it is through the generalized other that the group influences the behavior of individuals. Mead also looks at the self from a pragmatic point of view. At the individual level, the self allows the individual to be a more efficient member of the larger society. Because of the self, people are more likely to do what is expected of them in a given situation.
π Definition β Generalized Other: The attitude of the entire community or organized social group that an individual takes on, allowing them to evaluate themselves from a group perspective rather than from the perspective of discrete others.
Phases of self: I and me As Mead puts it, βThe self is essentially a social process going on with these two distinguishable phases.β It is important to bear in mind that the βIβ and the βmeβ are processes within the larger process of the self; they are not βthings.β The βIβ is the immediate response of an individual to others. It is the incalculable, unpredictable, and creative aspect of the self. People do not know in advance what the action of the βIβ will be: βBut what that response will be he does not know and nobody else knows.β We are never totally aware of the βI,β and through it we surprise ourselves with our actions. We know the βIβ only after the act has been carried out, only in our memories. Mead lays great stress on the βIβ for four reasons: First, it is a key source of novelty in the social process. Second, it is where our most important values are located. Third, the βIβ constitutes the realization of the self and permits us to develop a βdefinite personality.β Finally, Mead sees an evolutionary process in history where people in primitive societies are dominated more by the βmeβ while in modern societies there is a greater component of the βI.β π‘ Why this matters: The βIβ gives Meadβs theoretical system dynamism and creativity, preventing actors from being totally dominated by external and internal controls.
The βIβ reacts against the βme,β which is the βorganized set of attitudes of others which one himself assumes.β In other words, the βmeβ is the adoption of the generalized other. In contrast to the βI,β people are conscious of the βmeβ; the βmeβ involves conscious responsibility. As Mead says, βThe βmeβ is a conventional, habitual individual.β Conformists are dominated by the βme,β although everyone has, and must have, a substantial βme.β It is through the βmeβ that society dominates the individual. Indeed, Mead defines social control as the dominance of the expression of the βmeβ over the expression of the βI.β In pragmatic terms, the βmeβ allows the individual to live comfortably in the social world, while the βIβ makes change in society possible.
π Definition β βIβ: The immediate, incalculable, unpredictable, and creative aspect of the self that responds to others. π Definition β βMeβ: The organized set of attitudes of others that one assumes (the adoption of the generalized other), representing the conventional, habitual, and socially controlled aspect of the self.
Topic 147: Society
At the most general level, Mead uses the term society to mean the on-going social process that precedes both the mind and the self. Given its importance in shaping the mind and self, society is clearly of central importance to Mead. At another level, society represents the organized set of responses that are taken over by the individual in the form of the βme.β Thus, individuals carry society around with them, giving them the ability, through self-criticism, to control themselves. However, Mead has relatively little to say explicitly about society, in spite of its centrality in his theoretical system. His most important contributions lie in his thoughts on mind and self.
At a more specific societal level, Mead does have a number of things to say about social institutions. Mead broadly defines an institution as the βcommon response in the communityβ or βthe life habits of the community.β More specifically, he says that βthe whole community acts toward the individual under certain circumstances in an identical wayβ¦ there is an identical response on the part of the whole community under these conditions. We call that the formation of the institution.β We carry this organized set of attitudes around with us, and they serve to control our actions, largely through the βme.β Society shapes mind and self because the capacity for mind and self arises out of, and continues to be dependent on, role-taking. It is about reading the gestures of others and determining the attitudes of others. Self is understood as a process of adjustment within the framework imposed by stable relations. The key to understanding society lies in the use of language and role-taking by individuals with mind and self.
π Definition β Institution (Mead): The common response in the community or the life habits of the community, formed when the whole community acts toward an individual in an identical way under certain circumstances.
Topic 148-149: Symbolic Interactionism: Basic Principles
Some symbolic interactionists (Blumer, 1969a; Manis and Meltzer, 1978; A. Rose, 1962; Snow, 2001) have tried to enumerate the basic principles of the theory. These principles include the following:
- Human beings, unlike lower animals, are endowed with the capacity for thought.
- The capacity for thought is shaped by social interaction.
- In social interaction people learn the meanings and the symbols that allow them to exercise their distinctively human capacity for thought.
- Meanings and symbols allow people to carry on distinctively human action and interaction.
- People are able to modify or alter the meanings and symbols that they use in action and interaction on the basis of their interpretation of the situation.
- People are able to make these modifications and alterations because, in part, of their ability to interact with themselves, which allows them to examine possible courses of action, assess their relative advantages and disadvantages, and then choose one.
- The intertwined patterns of action and interaction make up groups and societies.
1. Capacity for Thought: The crucial assumption that human beings possess the ability to think differentiates symbolic interactionism from its behaviorist roots. Individuals in human society were not seen as units motivated by external or internal forces beyond their control. Rather, they were viewed as reflective or interacting units. The ability to think enables people to act reflectively rather than just behave unreflectively. The ability to think is embedded in the mind, but symbolic interactionists conceive of the mind as a continuing process, part of the larger process of stimulus and response, not as a thing or a physical structure.
2. Thinking and Interaction: The general capacity for thought must be shaped and refined in the process of social interaction. This leads the symbolic interactionist to focus on a specific form of social interactionβsocialization. To symbolic interactionists, socialization is a dynamic process that allows people to develop the ability to think in distinctively human ways. It is not simply a one-way process where the actor receives information, but a dynamic process where the actor shapes and adapts the information to his or her own needs. Interaction is the process in which the ability to think is both developed and expressed.
3. Learning Meanings and Symbols: Meaning stems not from solitary mental processes but from interaction. The central concern is how people learn meanings and symbols during interaction in general and socialization in particular. People respond to signs unthinkingly, but they respond to symbols in a thoughtful manner. Signs stand for themselves (e.g., the gestures of angry dogs). Symbols are social objects used to represent whatever people agree they shall represent. Words, physical artifacts, and physical actions (e.g., the word boat, a cross, a clenched fist) all can be symbols. Symbolic interactionists conceive of language as a vast system of symbols.
π Definition β Symbols: Social objects used to represent (or βstand in forβ) whatever people agree they shall represent. π Definition β Signs: Stimuli that stand for themselves and elicit an unthinking response.
4. Action and Interaction: Meadβs differentiation between covert and overt behavior is useful here. Covert behavior is the thinking process, involving symbols and meanings. Overt behavior is the actual behavior performed by an actor. Most human action involves both kinds. Meanings and symbols give social action (involving a single actor) and social interaction (involving two or more actors) distinctive characteristics. Social action is that in which individuals are acting with others in mind, gauging the impact of their action on others.
5. Making Choices: Because of the ability to handle meanings and symbols, people can make choices. They need not accept the meanings and symbols imposed on them from without. On the basis of their own interpretation of the situation, humans are capable of forming new meanings and new lines of meaning. Thus, actors have at least some autonomy and are capable of making unique and independent choices.
6. Thinking ability helps in altering the meanings: People can make modifications and alterations to meanings because of their ability to interact with themselves. This thinking ability allows them to examine possible courses of action, assess the relative advantages and disadvantages, and then choose one.
7. Groups and societies: The intertwined patterns of action and interaction make up groups and societies. Actors may not be passive elements of the group. Human society is to be seen as consisting of acting people. Actions are intertwined, leading to collective action, which may take an entirely new shape. This represents a micro-level focus of society.
β Key Takeaways
Meadβs self is a social process composed of the creative, unpredictable βIβ and the conforming, socially controlled βme.β The βIβ is the source of novelty and change, while the βmeβ represents the internalization of the communityβs attitudes, or the generalized other. Society is the ongoing social process that shapes mind and self and is carried by individuals as an organized set of attitudes. The seven principles of Symbolic Interactionism build from the capacity for thought, which is developed through social interaction where meanings and symbols are learned, allowing for thoughtful action, autonomous choice, and the formation of groups and collective action.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the generalized other and why is it essential for the development of a complete self?
- Distinguish between the βIβ and the βmeβ in Meadβs theory. Provide one key characteristic for each.
- According to Mead, what is a social institution?
- What differentiates a sign from a symbol in Symbolic Interactionism?
- List three of the seven basic principles of Symbolic Interactionism as outlined by Blumer and others.
π Lecture 37 β MUSLIM THINKERS: ABD AL-RAHMAN IBNE KHALDUN (1332-1406)-I
π Overview: This lecture introduces Ibn Khaldun, the most prominent Muslim scholar in the social sciences, and his groundbreaking work, the Muqaddimah. It explains how Ibn Khaldun moved beyond traditional philosophy of history to establish a new independent science of human society (Elm al Umran), focusing on understanding the social dynamics behind historical events rather than merely recording them.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the life and three major periods of Ibn Khaldun, his critique of traditional historiography and his development of a deeper "reflective" and "pragmatic" approach to history. It introduces his core concept of the new science of Elm al Umran (the knowledge of social life) and its essential elements: Umran, Ebar, and Asabiyya. The lecture also distinguishes the Muqaddimah (the inner meaning of history) from the Kitab al-βIbar (the surface history of dynasties).
π Lecture Summary
Topic 150: Introduction
Abd al-Rahman Ibne Khaldun (1332β1406 AD) was born in Tunis and traced his descent to a South Arabian clan from Hadhramaut, Yemen. His ancestors settled in Seville, Andalusia, and later left for North Africa after the Reconquista. He was a judge and held posts in many courts of the Maghrib (North Africa) and Andalusia.
Ibne Khaldun is best known for his Muqaddimah, a prolegomena to the scientific study of history that provides a method for studying society. In this work, he claims to have discovered a new science, referring to it as both βilm al-βumran al-bashari (the science of human social organization) and βilm al-ijtimaβ al-insani (the science of human society). The lecture notes that he is often excluded from the serious study of the history of sociology, with little attention given to non-Western precursors.
π Definition β Muqaddimah: The prolegomena or introduction to the scientific study of history, in which Ibn Khaldun established a new science of human society.
Three periods of his life:
- Professional political life serving various sultans in Tunis, Morocco, Spain, and Algeria (1352-1372).
- Seclusion in ben-salameh Burg where he worked on his Muqaddimah (1372-1376), finishing it in Tunisia in 1382.
- Period of juridical and academic work in Egypt (1376-1406).
Topic 151-152: Beyond Philosophy of History
The lecture uses Hegel's classification of three types of history to understand Ibn Khaldun's work:
- "Original history": records the deeds of a people and a time.
- "Reflective history": records past deeds but interprets them through the spirit of a later age, with four kinds (Universal, Pragmatic, Critical, and Histories of specific fields).
- "Philosophical history": interprets history as the rational development of spirit.
Ibn Khaldun's Muqaddimah starts with a "critical history" of Muslim histories, then does "reflective history" through systematic interpretation of facts, and finally performs "pragmatic history" by learning lessons and applying them to his own time. His vision defined history as: informing about human society, its qualities (like savagery, coexistence, solidarities), man's conquests and dominations, and what results from them (professions, subsistence, knowledges, arts).
His method distinguished right from wrong in historical information by investigating human social organization (identical with civilization), distinguishing between conditions that attach to its essence and those that are accidental. He did not merely seek to βpass throughβ history but intended to βpass beyond itβ and reveal its secrets through comprehension and analysis of the nature and causes of historical events.
The Kitab al-βIbar is Ibn Khaldun's larger empirical work on the history of the Arabs and Berbers. The Muqaddimah serves as its introduction. The surface (zahir) aspect of history is detailed in the Kitab al-βIbar, while the inner meaning (batin) of history is dealt with in the Muqaddimah. The Muqaddimah clarified the method to ascertain true events from false narratives. The Muqaddimah is the First Book of the Kitab al-βIbar, while Books Two and Three deal with the history and dynasties of various peoples. The substantive interest of both works lies in explaining the formation and decline of Maghribian and Arab states.
π Definition β Kitab al-βIbar: Ibn Khaldun's larger empirical work on the history of the Arabs and Berbers, which covers the surface phenomenon of history.
Topic 153: Elm al Umran
Instead of using Tarikh (History), Ibn Khaldun invents the new discipline of Elm al Umran, or the Knowledge of Social Life. This is an independent science with social organization as its subject matter. Its object does not belong to rhetoric (moving the mass to accept/reject an opinion) or politics (administering home/city for preserving the species). It is an entirely original science.
π Definition β Elm al Umran: The new science invented by Ibn Khaldun, meaning the Knowledge of Social Life, with human social organization as its subject matter.
The three essential elements of Elm al Umran are Umran, Ebar, and Asabiyya.
- Umran: An Arabic term with the root word umr ("life"). It means a certain interrelated set of relations which evolves and changes through time. The material necessities of life (Ma'ishat) condition its formation.
- It can be badavi (sedentary/bedouin), where people relocate persistently due to environmental limitations and subsistence requirements.
- It can be hadhary (settled), where cities are allowed by natural abundance and means for protection.
- Each formation develops objective relations, rules of social conduct, taboos, and a sense of belonging.
π Example: A group of people living in a desert with scarce resources will form a badavi (sedentary) umran, constantly moving for subsistence. This creates a strong sense of group belonging and specific rules of survival. In contrast, a community in a fertile river valley will develop a hadhary (settled) umran, building cities, establishing complex divisions of labor, and creating formal rules for urban life.
β Key Takeaways
Ibn Khaldun created a revolutionary new science, Elm al Umran, that went beyond traditional history to analyze the dynamics of human society, state formation, and decline. His key concept of Umran explains how societies evolve based on material conditions, either as mobile badavi or settled hadhary communities. His work distinguished between the surface events of history (Kitab al-βIbar) and the inner, causal analysis of social change (Muqaddimah). He is a crucial, yet often overlooked, non-Western precursor to modern sociology, having developed frameworks for analyzing social solidarity, political power, and historical cycles centuries before Western sociologists.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three periods of Ibn Khaldunβs life and their primary activities?
- According to the lecture, what is the difference between the Muqaddimah and the Kitab al-βIbar?
- How does Ibn Khaldun's approach to history go beyond Hegel's "critical history" and into what other types of history?
- What is Elm al Umran, and why did Ibn Khaldun consider it an entirely original and independent science?
- Differentiate between badavi and hadhary forms of Umran, and explain what conditions each form.
π Lecture 38 β Muslim Thinkers: Abd Al-Rahman Ibne Khaldun (1332-1406)-II
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of Ibn Khaldun's sociological contributions, focusing on his foundational concept of elm al umran (the science of social life) and the theory of social change. It explains how Ibn Khaldun's notions of asabiyya (solidarity) and the cyclical rise and fall of dynasties provide a systematic framework for understanding the transformation of human societies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Elm al Umran is presented as a new science of sociology that studies human association and social organization through the concepts of ebar (understanding) and asabiyya (solidarity). The lecture then examines Ibn Khaldun's theory of social change, comparing nomadic and sedentary societies and explaining the role of asabiyya in the formation and decline of states. Finally, it delves into the social philosophy of solidarity, defining asabiyya as a complex sociological reality rooted in blood relations and group cohesion.
π Lecture Summary
Topic 154: New Science: Elm al Umran Sociology
Umran is a complex notion that covers everything from geographical and demographic concepts of the settled world to sociability. It also refers to "political authority and dynasties," "savagery and sociability," and different "ways of making a living." Human beings must dwell together in cities and hamlets for companionship and to satisfy needs, driven by their natural disposition toward cooperation. Umran may be found in outlying regions or as sedantry in cities, villages, and towns that serve protection and fortification purposes.
According to Ibn Khaldun, umran is determined by the material conditions of its formation. Differences in nations' customs and ways of living result from differences in their economic life. With this conception, Ibn Khaldun proposes elm al umran (the science of social life) as a theory of social formations and political change. Its subject matter is human life in association with others and subjection to the rules and necessities of social life within space and time. Sociality is inevitable and necessary for mankind, otherwise man's being and God's will would not actualize.
Elm al umran is formulated upon the methodological notion of ebar (understanding) and the theoretical concept of asabiyya (solidarity). Instead of using khabar (which pertained to geographical facts or miraculous events), Ibn Khaldun begins his historical analysis with ebar. For him, it was important not to give reports about past generations but to understand events. Such understanding is attainable only if one applies suitable methods for historical knowledge. Criticizing analogical reasoning in historical investigation, Ibn Khaldun identifies this approach, along with forgetfulness and negligence, as factors that may sway a man from his purpose. To apply knowledge of the present to historical information is a great error β one ought to be aware of the changes that conditions have undergone.
π Definition β Umran: A complex sociological notion covering everything from geographical and demographic concepts of the settled world to sociability, political authority, and different ways of making a living. π Formula: Elm al Umran = ebar (understanding) + asabiyya (solidarity) β theory of social formations and political change π Example: Ibn Khaldun uses ebar instead of khabar for historical analysis β rather than simply reporting past events, he seeks to understand them by being aware of changes in conditions over time.
Topic 155-156: Social Change
Ibn Khaldun theorizes differences in social organization between nomadic (Al-umran al-Badawi) and sedentary societies (Al-Umran Alhadari). Fundamental to his theory is the concept of Asabiyyah, or group feeling. Only a society with a strong Asabiyyah could establish domination over one with a weak Asabiyyah.
Asabiyyah and power: Asabiyyah refers to the feeling of solidarity among members of a group based on sharing common descent. It makes a group a power group. According to Ibn Khaldun, Bedouin have superior Asabiyyah, which is why they defeated sedentary people in urban areas and established their own dynasties or Aldawlah.
Change in society β Formation and decline of states: Bedouin get set in urban ways of life and experience a great decline in their Asabiyyah, followed by a decline in military strength, making them vulnerable to attack and conquest by tribal groups from the outside. This is the cycle of rise and decline of states. Ibn Khaldun estimated this cycle to take approximately four generations.
Ibn Khaldun was captivated by the rapid phenomena of change in the 14th century Maghreb (North Africa). The Berbers, the original population, were replaced by an influx of Arabs beginning in the 11th century. The Arabs outnumbered and overpowered the Berbers, stripping them of most of their lands.
Theory of change: In the Muqaddima, Ibn Khaldun discussed questions such as: How have dynasties risen and fallen? What were the roles of al-asabiyya and religion in social change? Why do the vanquished always tend to imitate their conquerors? How did the Arab State systematically follow short-lived cycle patterns of growth and development?
Typology of society: The Bedouin & Sedentary distinction discussed by Ibn Khaldun is similar to Western sociologists' typologies of: traditional & modern, rural & urban, folk & urban, pre-industrial & industrial, Gemeinschaft & Gesellschaft, and mechanical & organic solidarity.
Role of religion: Both Bedouin society and the new Muslim society had a strong sense of solidarity. Al-asabiyya was the social bond for Bedouin society, while Muslim brotherhood was the binding factor of the new multi-ethnic society.
Ibn Khaldun intermingles his notion of asabiyya with the religious notion of "good," presenting an alternative practical answer to persisting problems. For him, religion is a revolutionary and normative force in history resting upon its relationship with asabiyya. Ibn Khaldun considers religion as a self-conscious asabiyya. In religiosity, an individual will is mediated into collective will β not due to objective conditions of life but by a moral choice "with God's mediation." He establishes a mutual relationship between religion and asabiyya: both are in need of each other while reinforcing each other simultaneously. No religion could have succeeded in history without asabiyya as its social ground. Although social deterioration is an inevitable historical necessity, it can be sustained when asabiyya is reinforced by religion.
π‘ Why this matters: This framework explains how good life can be achieved when a community already has asabiyya and religion comes to its help β offering a practical solution to social decline.
Act β Total process: For Ibn Khaldun, a sedentary, over-materialistic environment corrupts human nature and undermines the basis of Islamic values, resulting in the decline of Islamic civilization. This is his theory of change describing the transformation of society from a simple state to a more complex one.
π Definition β Asabiyyah: Group feeling or solidarity based on sharing common descent, which makes a group a power group and enables it to establish domination. π Formula: Strong Asabiyyah β Domination β Establishment of dynasty β Urbanization β Decline of Asabiyyah β Vulnerability β Conquest by outside groups π Example: In 14th century Maghreb, Arabs (with strong asabiyyah) outnumbered and overpowered the Berbers, stripped them of their lands, and established dominance β following the cycle of rise and decline over approximately four generations.
Topic 157: The Social Philosophy of Solidarity: Al-asabiyya
Another central notion in elm al umran is asabiyya (solidarity). Applying his critical method of ebar to observable data of political strife and social instability, Ibn Khaldun reaches the theoretical construct of asabiyya. According to Ibn Khaldun, asabiyya comes from blood relationship "or something corresponding to it." Blood ties (elteham) are natural among men and lead to affection for one's relations and blood relatives. If the direct relationship between persons who help each other is very close, leading to close contact and unity, the ties are obvious and clearly require the existence of a feeling of solidarity without any outside prodding.
Asabiyya is rooted in s-b, which denotes binding, and derived from the verb asaba, meaning "he twisted." Asabiyya then means "men twisted together" by some form of proximity. As filliative solidarity, it is very much related to the natural environment and simplistic life system of family and tribal bond.
For Ibn Khaldun, asabiyya is a two-edged historical phenomenon. It is a simple life system of mutual belonging and egalitarian relationships. However, it is not a psychological term β it pertains to a "complex sociological reality" with significant psychological implications. As such, asabiyya "produces the ability to defend oneself, to offer opposition, to protect oneself, and to press claims. Whoever loses it is too weak to do any of these."
π Definition β Asabiyya (solidarity): A complex sociological phenomenon rooted in blood relations or corresponding ties, meaning "men twisted together" by proximity β producing the ability to defend, oppose, protect, and press claims. π Example: A tribal group with strong asabiyya can defend itself and claim territory, while a group that loses asabiyya becomes too weak to offer any opposition or protection.
β Key Takeaways
Ibn Khaldun's elm al umran is a foundational theory of social formations and political change that uses ebar (understanding) and asabiyya (solidarity) as its core methodological and theoretical concepts. The cycle of rise and decline of states β estimated at four generations β is driven by asabiyya: strong group feeling allows domination, but urbanization and material comfort erode it, making societies vulnerable to conquest. Religion and asabiyya have a mutual relationship where religion reinforces asabiyya, potentially sustaining a society against inevitable deterioration. The distinction between Bedouin (nomadic) and sedentary societies parallels later Western sociological typologies like Gemeinschaft/Gesellschaft and mechanical/organic solidarity. Asabiyya is not merely psychological but a complex sociological reality rooted in blood ties, producing the capacity for collective defense and political action.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the subject matter of elm al umran according to Ibn Khaldun?
- How does Ibn Khaldun distinguish between ebar (understanding) and khabar (report) in historical analysis?
- Explain the cycle of rise and decline of states β how long does Ibn Khaldun estimate this cycle to take?
- What is the relationship between religion and asabiyya in Ibn Khaldun's theoretical scheme?
- Why does Ibn Khaldun consider asabiyya a "two-edged historical phenomenon" rather than merely a psychological term?
π Lecture 39 β Muslim Thinkers: Abd Al-Rahman Ibne Khaldun (1332-1406)-III (Topic 158-161)
π Overview: This lecture delves deeper into Ibn Khaldunβs core concept of Asabiyya, explaining its origins and dual role in both the rise and the eventual fall of political orders. It outlines the organic stages of political change, from initial group solidarity to despotic rule and decline, and concludes by examining the dialectical dynamics between settled (hadhari) centers and resistant (badavi) peripheries.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining Asabiyya, tracing its roots to familial bonds, mutual help, and friendship, and comparing it to concepts like Durkheimβs ame collective and Weberβs genossenheit. It then analyses the rise and fall of political orders through four distinct stages, explaining how a ruler transitions from shared glory to personal despotism, leading to a decline in Asabiyya and political degeneration. Finally, it explores the dynamics of political change, presenting a dialectic where the Asabiyya of the dominated badavi periphery resists the oppressive hadhari center, leading to the emergence of a new political authority.
π Lecture Summary
Topic 158: Asabiyya comes through Elteham (filial bound), and Sale rahem (family bound) which is the arabic word for a natural emotion of attachment between family members.
Asabiyya arises from Elteham (filial bond) and Sale rahem (family bond), which is the Arabic word for a natural emotion of attachment between family members. It also results from Vala' (mutual help) and Halef (the bond of friendship). As such, Asabiyya has been translated variously as 'the vitality of the state', 'public spirit', 'esprit de corps', 'social solidarity', and 'common will'. It resembles Durkheim's ame collective and the Weberian notion of genossenheit, where a social and human bond is the forming thread of a life form. Gemeinshaft and filiation are thus two terms that can define the notion of Asabiyya.
The peculiarity of Asabiyya is its explaining the sense of "belonging" which denotes being subject to the "laws and conditions" of the group. Asabiyya is therefore more than anything else, a form of βintersubjectivityβ which carries social life through time and space. It can be conceived of as an intersubjective-inner sense of belonging which plays an objective role in social life by mediating between individual and group life. Asabiyya signifies social and intersubjective cohesion.
Topic 159-160: The Rise and Fall of Political Orders
For Ibn Khaldun, the destiny of political entities is that of many intertwined and dialectical contradictions. In any social formation, there is a dialectical relationship between Asabiyya on the one hand, and the rise and fall of political power on the other: The goal to which Asabiyya leads is political authority. This is because Asabiyya gives protection and makes possible mutual defense, pressing claims, and every other kind of social activity. Political authority results from superiority, and superiority results from Asabiyya.
Ibn Khaldun explains that political authority goes through several stages of change organically.
-
First Stage: The ruler successfully overthrows all opposition, appropriates authority from the preceding dynasty, and claims "all glory for itself". Glory was the common property of the group, and all members made an identical effort to gain the upper hand and defend their possessions.
-
Second Stage: The ruler gains complete control over the people and claims all authority for himself, "excluding and preventing others from trying to have a share in it". Ibn Khaldun calls this al enferade bel majd, which Max Weber later called sultanism. According to Weber, sultanism arises whenever traditional authority develops an administration and military forces that are purely personal instruments of the master. The group members are then treated as subjects, and the master's authority turns into his personal right. Ibn Khaldun explains this change from riasa (rulership) to al enferade bel majd (despotism).
-
Third Stage: Leisure and tranquillity are enjoyed as the fruits of authority. A new economic and political situation dominates the umran (civilization), and new interrelationships between the new authority and its original Asabiyya take shape. These interrelationships have dialectical characteristics and tend towards entropy (a decline into disorder).
-
Fourth Stage: The ruler is content with what his predecessors have built and wastes on pleasure and amusements. The ruler seeks to destroy the great clients of his people and followers of his predecessors. He ruins the foundations his ancestors had laid. In this stage, the dynasty is seized by senility and the chronic disease from which it is destroyed.
Decline in Asabiyya and political degeneration: This process finally ends in total political degeneration, where no concrete relationship exists between the social basis of power (Asabiyya) and the power structure. These new political orientations result in the breakup of Asabiyya and the breakdown of the existing system. If the ruler continues to keep a forceful grip on his subjects, Asabiyya (group feeling) will be destroyed. Subjects become fearful and seek to protect themselves through lies and deceit. The feeling of the people becomes diseased, and the great danger reverts upon the dynasty, from which it cannot recover.
π Definition β Al enferade bel majd: (Ibn Khaldun's term for the monopolization of glory) The stage where the ruler claims all authority for himself, excluding others. Weber later called this sultanism. π‘ Why this matters: This shows Ibn Khaldun's theory of political decay is cyclical and driven by the internal logic of power, not just by external forces.
Topic 161: The Dynamics of Political Change
This moment involves a structural process of change in the relationship between the newly formed hadhari (settled/urban) system and other already existing badavi (nomadic/rustic) collectivities. This is the moment of resistance by the dominated badavi-periphery against the hadhari-center. In Ibn Khaldun's theoretical scheme, the dialectic of domination and revolt is another dimension to the dynamics of Asabiyya. The hadhari "center", as a power bastion, exercises domination over the βperipheryβ badavin; the city has a king to whom the badavin have to submit. The chief obliges the badavin to submit to him, by will or by force.
However, the submission of the badavin is not a trouble-free situation for the hadhari-center. Due to their own Asabiyya, the dominated badavin resist the hadhari domination and do not submit easily. It is easy to establish a dynasty in lands free from group feelings (Asabiyya), where seditions and rebellions are few.
At this point, the Asabiyya of the dominated badavi-periphery appears as resistance against the hadhari-center. This is the moment of the second dialectic: the Dialectics of Domination and Revolution. In a condition of political domination, Asabiyya plays a role essentially different from its original role as the genesis of political power. This is a rebellious role which undermines the established power. In other words, Asabiyya is simultaneously a will to power and a will to resist. This rebellious undertaking happens when a "rebel revolts, or, by inviting people around himself, gathers power". As a result of the dual process of the entropic degeneration of Asabiyya inside the βcityβ and the resisting force of badavi Asabiyya, the grip of city domination over the badavi periphery is weakened and challenged. A new force of Asabiyya is formed in the periphery that challenges the faltering power of the center, and as a result, a new political authority takes shape.
π Definition β Hadhari: Settled, urban civilization associated with the center of power and luxury. π Definition β Badavi: Nomadic, rustic life associated with the periphery, strong Asabiyya, and simplicity. π‘ Why this matters: This explains Ibn Khaldun's theory of dynastic cycles, where fresh conquerors from the periphery with strong group solidarity (Asabiyya) overthrow a decaying urban center.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept is Asabiyya, defined not just as group solidarity but as an intersubjective sense of belonging that is both the foundation and the destroyer of political power. Ibn Khaldun presents a cyclical theory of history where a dynastyβs life follows a predictable organic pattern of ascent, consolidation, luxury, and decline. Political degeneration occurs when the ruler centralizes power to the point of destroying the original Asabiyya that brought him to power. History is driven by a dialectic between the decadent hadhari center and the vigorous badavi periphery, whose strong Asabiyya acts as a revolutionary force. For the exam, remember the four stages of a dynasty's lifecycle and that Asabiyya is both a "will to power" and a "will to resist."
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four original sources of Asabiyya according to Ibn Khaldun?
- What are the four stages a political authority goes through in its lifecycle, according to Ibn Khaldun?
- What term did Ibn Khaldun use for the stage when a ruler monopolizes all glory? What equivalent term did Max Weber coin?
- Explain how the role of Asabiyya changes between the rise and the fall of a dynasty.
- What is the "Dialectics of Domination and Revolution," and how does it lead to the foundation of a new political order in Ibn Khaldun's model?