📘 Lecture 32 — Contemporary Social Theorists: Ralf Dahrendorf (1929-1979)-I
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces Ralf Dahrendorf's conflict theory as a direct antithesis to structural functionalism. It explores his core arguments about power as the fundamental source of social friction, the dual nature of society requiring both conflict and consensus theories, and how power distribution creates social stratification and prevents competition.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Dahrendorf's conflict theory in opposition to functionalism across three main topics: Power as the ability to carry out one's will despite resistance and how norms are established and maintained by power rather than consensus; Conflict as society's second face alongside consensus, with Dahrendorf arguing both are prerequisites for each other; and Power and Social Stratification explaining how differential authority distribution creates social hierarchy and prevents competition from groups with different power bases.
📝 Lecture Summary
Contemporary Social Theorists: Ralf Dahrendorf (1929-1979)-I
Like functionalists, conflict theorists study social structures and institutions, but their conclusions are often direct opposites of functionalist positions. To functionalists, society is static or in moving equilibrium; to Dahrendorf, every society at every point is subject to processes of change. Functionalists emphasize orderliness; conflict theorists see dissension and conflict at every point. Functionalists argue every element contributes to stability; conflict theorists see many elements contributing to disintegration and change. Functionalists see society held together informally by norms, values, and common morality; conflict theorists see order stemming from coercion by those at the top.
Topic 132: Power
Power is the ability of the actor in a social relationship to carry out his own will despite resistance — to force others. Power is the control of sanctions, which enable the powerful to give orders and obtain what they want from the powerless. People dislike submission, which is why there exists an inevitability of conflict of interests all the time in society. Power is a lasting source of friction.
🔑 Definition — Power: The ability of an actor in a social relationship to carry out his own will despite resistance, involving control of sanctions to obtain orders from the powerless.
Power and norms: Norms do not define or emerge from consensus. Norms are established and maintained by power. Norms are explained in terms of interests of the powerful, with sanctions for violations. People use the power of law for punishment, and established norms are nothing but ruling norms.
💡 Why this matters: This reverses the functionalist view that shared values create norms; Dahrendorf argues that those in power create norms to serve their interests.
Topic 133: Conflict
Dahrendorf (1959, 1968) is the major exponent of the position that society has two faces — conflict and consensus — and sociological theory should be divided into two parts: conflict theory and consensus theory. Consensus theorists should examine value integration; conflict theorists should examine conflicts of interest and the coercion that holds society together. Dahrendorf recognized that society could not exist without both conflict and consensus — they are prerequisites for each other. We cannot have conflict unless there is some prior consensus. For example, French housewives are highly unlikely to conflict with Chilean chess players because there is no contact between them, no prior integration. Conversely, conflict can lead to consensus and integration, as shown by the alliance between the United States and Japan after World War II.
Despite this interrelationship, Dahrendorf was not optimistic about developing a single sociological theory encompassing both processes: “It seems at least conceivable that unification of theory is not feasible at a point which has puzzled thinkers ever since the beginning of Western philosophy” (1959:164). Eschewing a singular theory, Dahrendorf set out to construct a conflict theory of society.
Dahrendorf began with, and was heavily influenced by, structural functionalism. He noted that to the functionalist, the social system is held together by voluntary cooperation or general consensus. However, to the conflict (or coercion) theorist, society is held together by “enforced constraint”; thus, some positions in society are delegated power and authority over others. This led to his central thesis: the differential distribution of authority “invariably becomes the determining factor of systematic social conflicts” (1959:165).
📌 Example: French housewives vs. Chilean chess players — no conflict occurs because there is no prior contact or integration between them. Conflict requires some prior relationship.
📌 Example: U.S.-Japan alliance after WWII — a conflict (war) led to eventual consensus and integration (alliance).
Conflict and change: Powerful and powerless are always in opposition to each other. Dahrendorf looks for a new balance between power and opposition. Conflict is a great creative force of human history due to its ability to bring change. His theory looks more like a coercive theory of society.
Topic 134: Power and Social Stratification
Social differentiation of positions, status rank, and order in society are due to power distribution. Norms define its working. Norms are derived and upheld by power. For functionalists, stratification is a need of society and serves a function — power helps attract the talented to occupy important positions. But Dahrendorf does not agree because the talented may not occupy important positions.
🔑 Definition — Social stratification (Dahrendorf): The differentiation of positions, status rank, and order in society due to power distribution, with norms derived and upheld by power.
Powerful prevent competition: Occupants of power positions try to legitimize and take advantage of their power position and convince everyone of its legitimacy and importance for their own indispensability. This prevents competition from groups with different potential power bases. Such social stratification can create conflict.
Coercion and integration: In a typical industrial society:
- Separation of ownership and control of business
- Managers don't own
- Owners don't manage
- Ownership and control is blurred — different from Marx
📌 Example: In modern corporations, owners (shareholders) do not manage daily operations, and managers (who run the company) do not own it — unlike Marx's model where owners directly controlled production.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Dahrendorf's conflict theory fundamentally opposes functionalism by arguing that power, not consensus, creates social order and norms. Power is the ability to impose one's will despite resistance, and it inevitably creates conflict between the powerful and powerless. Society has two faces — conflict and consensus — which are prerequisites for each other and cannot be unified into a single theory. The differential distribution of authority is the determining factor of systematic social conflicts. Unlike Marx, Dahrendorf sees ownership and control as separated in modern industrial societies, making power relations more complex than simple class struggle.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Dahrendorf, how do norms originate — from consensus or from power?
- What does Dahrendorf mean when he says society has "two faces"?
- Why can't French housewives conflict with Chilean chess players?
- How does Dahrendorf's view of social stratification differ from the functionalist view?
- How is Dahrendorf's analysis of industrial society different from Marx's analysis?
📘 Lecture 33 — Contemporary Social Theorists: Ralf Dahrendorf (1929-1979)-II
📖 Overview: This lecture examines Ralf Dahrendorf's conflict theory, focusing on how authority, inequality, and conflicting interests generate social conflict. It explores the structural and psychological prerequisites for class mobilization, the role of violence and the state in conflict, and concludes with Dahrendorf's dialectical view that conflict and consensus are complementary faces of society.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Dahrendorf's analysis of conflict determinants including authority and legitimacy, the structural and psychological requirements for class mobilization, violence and institutionalized conflict, the relationship between conflict and the state including bureaucracy, the dialectical process of conflict resolution, and finally Dahrendorf's position as a conflict functionalist who sees consensus and conflict as complementary.
📝 Lecture Summary
Conflict: Determinants
Inequalities and conflicting interests produce conflicts. Conflict will take place among groups that differ in their authority over others. Authority is power attached to a role or position.
🔑 Definition — Legitimacy: being defined and delimited by social norms backed by sanctions which are stable and recurrent patterns of authority and are institutionalized.
The conflict may be generated between those who have authority and those who don't have authority. These groups are called classes, which signifies conflict groups in organizations in which orders are given and taken. Authority is dichotomous: one may have it or may not have it. Incumbents' interests are formed accordingly. Persons/groups may have more or less authority. Conflict may come from other groupings. All classes do not engage in active conflict all the time — it needs necessary prerequisites.
The mobilization of classes: The structural requirements
Formation of active interest groups requires:
- Technically: A founder and charter/ideology.
- Politically: More liberal the state, the more likely is the mobilization for active conflict.
- Socially: Group formation is more likely if:
i. Structural requirements
- Potential group members are well concentrated geographically
- Can communicate easily — technology helps
- Stand in the same relation to authority, recruited in similar ways, with similar background (homogeneity)
- Nevertheless, sufficient degree of force can suppress the conflict
ii. The psychological requirements
- Individuals identify themselves with the interests associated with their position
- Interests are important and real to them — class interests will be more real to people who share the culture
- Should not belong to a number of associations
- Greater their personal chances of class mobility, less likely they are to identify actively with it
- Individuals may have all the psychological requirements for class mobilization, yet may not react
- This happened in preindustrial societies — it is a question of fate
The violence and conflict
Violence through various methods (weapons) is only chosen if conflict is institutionalized to keep the conflict less violent. These are the established rules of the game and procedures are laid down through discussions and no physical violence takes place.
💡 Why this matters: Dahrendorf argues that institutionalizing conflict (creating formal rules and procedures) actually reduces violence, contrary to the assumption that formalizing conflict escalates it.
Conflict and the state
The state is the most powerful association. The ruling class (elite group) holds the positions on top of state hierarchy. There exist critical lines of conflict between those who give orders and those who receive it. Additionally, bureaucracy also has a chain of command that becomes part of ruling class that acts as buffer against any threat.
State and bureaucracy
State and bureaucracy serve together as a separate institution where authority and power are separated to have control on other groupings, so that others are likely to oppose and restrict its control over them. The conflict between government and business/industry, other groupings/unions spearheads the conflict and restricts the state's control, and ultimately conflict gets resolved in certain new arrangements of power and authority.
The state and conflict
Some government projects have consequences for range and intensity of political conflict. For example, the "Orange Train" project in Lahore, Pakistan was opposed by many groups and courts intervened and tried to resolve after listening to both parties.
Concluding remarks
Dahrendorf discussed a close relationship between power and conflict and presented a theory of conflict group formation where group formations reflect potential confrontations. He claims that the conflict may lead to violence and the conflict and violence gets resolved only through a continuous dialectical process.
Dialectics of conflict
According to Dahrendorf, groups have different powers although not typical of the type Marx talked about like "haves" and "have nots." Conflict can be between the state and the rich business groups. Polarization between those with and without authority is an important source of conflict. No conflict according to him is of permanent nature and it can be resolved. Some government projects have consequences for range and intensity of political conflict. Movements can be part of conflict groups — for example, feminism vs. adult franchise, government vs. business groups, bureaucracy vs. public.
Conflict functionalist
Consensus and conflict are the two faces of society. Dahrendorf did not reject the consensus approach by the functionalists. Neither approach should plead exclusive validity. They may be complimentary — separate only for the sake of analysis. Consensus has seeds of conflict. The resolution of conflict results in consensus. That is change.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical points for examination are: first, authority is dichotomous and generates conflicting interests between those who give orders and those who receive them, forming the basis of class conflict. Second, Dahrendorf identifies specific structural prerequisites (geographic concentration, communication, homogeneity) and psychological prerequisites (identification with interests, low mobility chances) for class mobilization. Third, institutionalizing conflict through established rules and procedures actually reduces violence rather than escalating it. Fourth, the state and bureaucracy function together as a powerful institution, but other groupings (business, unions) can oppose and restrict state control, leading to new power arrangements. Fifth, Dahrendorf rejects the exclusive validity of either conflict or consensus approaches, arguing they are complementary — consensus contains seeds of conflict, and conflict resolution produces new consensus.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What does Dahrendorf mean by saying authority is "dichotomous," and how does this relate to class formation?
- List three structural requirements and two psychological requirements for the formation of active interest groups according to Dahrendorf.
- How does institutionalization of conflict affect the level of violence in conflict situations?
- According to Dahrendorf, what role does bureaucracy play in relation to the ruling class and the state?
- Why does Dahrendorf call himself a "conflict functionalist," and how does he reconcile conflict and consensus?
📘 Lecture 34 — CONTEMPORARY SOCIAL THEORISTS: GEORGE HEBERT MEAD (1863-1931)-I
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces George Herbert Mead, a foundational figure in symbolic interactionism who developed an evolutionary theory connecting body, mind, self, and society. It explains why Mead prioritizes society over the individual in understanding social experience and examines the social act as the primary unit of analysis.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Mead's introduction as a social psychologist and his connection to symbolic interactionism, the role of symbols in human interaction, the priority of the social over the individual mind, the conception of society as a process of role-taking, and the four stages of the social act—impulse, perception, manipulation, and consummation—as an organic, dialectical whole.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 139: Introduction
George Herbert Mead is a prominent American philosopher, social scientist, and social psychologist famous for developing an evolutionary theory connecting body, mind, self, and society. As a social psychologist, he was interested in the social development of individuals by examining how individuals develop socially as a result of participating in group life.
Symbolic interactionism is a term coined by Herbert Blumer that represents a wide range of ideas of various thinkers including George Herbert Mead, Charles H. Cooley, Erving Goffman, W. I. Thomas, and Herbert Blumer. Mead gained popularity as a symbolic interactionist because of his belief that humans have the capacity to create and use symbols in order to represent to one another objects, ideas, feelings, and virtually anything they experience in life.
Key elements of environment: Symbols — One creates one's image through various interactions. People interact using symbols with agreed meanings attached to them. Symbols are either written or verbal, and society teaches us these symbols. Symbols denote objects, signs, gestures, letters, words, numbers, and figures that stand for realities in social and physical environments. The social environment includes a common set of symbols and their understanding by people in a group.
💡 Why this matters: Symbols are the foundation of all human interaction and social reality according to Mead.
Actions not predetermined — Every member of society needs language for interaction. Actions of society members are not predetermined by nature; rather, they are learned. Because actions are learned, the newborn infant is unorganized and dependent on adults for direction and survival. Nature determines a child's ability, whereas subsequent development depends on interaction with other individuals who are part of the social environment. In other words, nature is important but not deterministic of future development.
Mind, Self and Society — Mead's famous book Mind, Self and Society was published retrospectively by his students based on their notes from his courses, moving his ideas from oral to written tradition. This volume is of utmost importance for symbolic interactionism because it serves as an intellectual pillar. According to Mead, mind, self, and society are connected through interaction, and symbols related to the environment are necessary for interaction.
🔑 Definition — Symbolic interactionism: A theoretical approach representing ideas that humans have the capacity to create and use symbols to represent objects, ideas, feelings, and experiences, with the use of these symbols becoming the basis of interaction.
Topic 140: The Priority of the Social
In his review of Mind, Self and Society, Ellsworth Faris argued that "not mind and then society; but society first and then minds arising within that society" would have been Mead's preference. Faris's inversion of the book's title reflects that society, or more broadly the social, is accorded priority in Mead's analysis.
In Mead's view, traditional social psychology began with the psychology of the individual to explain social experience. In contrast, Mead always gives priority to the social world in understanding social experience. Mead explains: "We are not, in social psychology, building up the behavior of the social group in terms of the behavior of separate individuals composing it; rather, we are starting out with a given social whole of complex group activity, into which we analyze (as elements) the behavior of each of the separate individuals composing it."
To Mead, the social whole precedes the individual mind both logically and temporally. A thinking, self-conscious individual is logically impossible without a prior social group. The social group comes first, and it leads to the development of self-conscious mental states.
The conception of society — For Mead, society is the term for the processes of role-taking with varieties of specific and generalized others and the consequent coordination of action. Diverse individuals come into contact, role-take, and adjust their responses. A community of attitudes is created that regulates the actions of individuals. Society is composed of a plurality of actors who: play different roles, share a common set of significant symbols, perceive themselves as a distinguishable entity, share a community of attitudes, and constitute a geopolitical entity.
🔑 Definition — Priority of the social: The principle that society comes first both logically and temporally, and the individual mind develops within and from the social group.
Topic 141: The Social Act
Mead considered the act to be the most "primary unit" in his theory. In analyzing the act, Mead focused on stimulus and response. However, stimulus does not elicit an automatic, unthinking response from the human actor. The stimulus serves as an occasion or opportunity for the act, not as a compulsion or a mandate.
Four stages of social act — Mead identified four basic and interrelated stages in the act that represent an organic whole (they are dialectically interrelated). Both lower animals and humans act, and Mead is interested in the similarities and especially the differences between the two.
Impulse — The first stage involves an "immediate sensuous stimulation" and the actor's reaction to that stimulation—the need to do something about it. Hunger is a good example of an impulse. The actor (both nonhuman and human) may respond immediately and unthinkingly to the impulse, but more likely the human actor will think about the appropriate response (for example, eat now or later). In thinking about a response, the person considers not only the immediate situation but also past experiences and anticipated future results of the act. Hunger may come from an inner state, be elicited by the presence of food in the environment, or arise from some combination. The impulse involves both the actor and the environment.
Perception — The second stage involves the actor searching for and reacting to stimuli that relate to the impulse and the various means available to satisfy it. People have the capacity to sense or perceive stimuli through hearing, smell, taste, and so on. Perception involves incoming stimuli as well as the mental images they create. People do not simply respond immediately to external stimuli but rather think about and assess them through mental imagery. People are not simply subject to external stimulation; they also actively select characteristics of a stimulus and choose among sets of stimuli. A stimulus may have several dimensions, and the actor selects among them. Mead refuses to separate people from the objects they perceive; perception and object cannot be separated from one another.
Manipulation — The third stage involves manipulating the object or taking action with regard to it. People have hands (with opposable thumbs) that allow them to manipulate objects far more subtly than lower animals. The manipulation phase constitutes an important temporary pause in the process so that a response is not manifested immediately. For example, a hungry human being sees a mushroom but picks it up first, examines it, and perhaps checks whether it is edible before eating. The pause afforded by handling the object allows humans to contemplate various responses, involving both the past and the future. The manipulation of the mushroom becomes a kind of experimental method in which the actor mentally tries out various hypotheses.
Consummation — The last phase of the act involves taking action that satisfies the original impulse. Both humans and lower animals may consume the mushroom, but humans are less likely to eat a bad mushroom because of their ability to manipulate and think about the implications. Lower animals must rely on a trial-and-error method, which is less efficient and more dangerous.
The social act: one organic process — Although the four stages are separated in sequential order for discussion, Mead sees a dialectical relationship among them. The four parts interpenetrate to form one organic process. Facets of each part are present at all times from the beginning to the end of the act, such that each part affects the other. For example, manipulating food may lead the individual to the impulse of hunger and the perception that one is hungry and food is available.
Act: Total process — The act is a covert mental process that occurs between the stimulus and the response. Mead recognized the importance of observable behavior (empiricism) but also the covert aspects of behavior (philosophy). The act comprises both overt and covert aspects of human action. The act involves only one person, whereas the social act involves two or more persons.
🔑 Definition — Act: The most primary unit in Mead's theory, a covert mental process that occurs between stimulus and response, comprising both overt and covert aspects of human action.
📐 Concept: The four stages of the act (Impulse → Perception → Manipulation → Consummation) form an organic whole with dialectical interrelationships.
📌 Example (Impulse Hunger): An individual feels hunger (impulse), searches for and identifies food (perception), picks up and examines the food before eating (manipulation), and finally eats to satisfy hunger (consummation).
⭐ Key Takeaways
Mead's symbolic interactionism prioritizes society over the individual, meaning the social group must exist first for minds and selves to develop. Symbols are the foundation of human interaction, allowing individuals to communicate and coordinate through shared meanings. The act is Mead's fundamental unit of analysis, with four dialectically related stages—impulse, perception, manipulation, and consummation—that distinguish human action from animal behavior through the capacity for mental deliberation. Humans have unique advantages over lower animals, including the ability to use symbols, pause for manipulation before responding, and think through future consequences. The social act involving two or more persons extends individual action into social coordination through role-taking and shared symbols.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What does Ellsworth Faris mean by "not mind and then society; but society first and then minds arising within that society"?
- What are the four stages of the act according to Mead, and how do they form an organic whole?
- How does Mead distinguish human action from lower animal action in the manipulation stage?
- Why does Mead consider society to be a process of role-taking rather than a fixed structure?
- What role do symbols play in Mead's theory of social interaction and social development?
📘 Lecture 35 — CONTEMPORARY SOCIAL THEORISTS: GEORGE HEBERT MEAD (1863-1931)-I
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational concepts of George Herbert Mead’s social behaviorism, focusing on how human society and individual consciousness emerge from social interaction. Mead explains the mechanisms of gestures, significant symbols, mind, and self as processes that develop within and through social experience, not as innate mental properties. Understanding these concepts is crucial for grasping the symbolic interactionist tradition in sociology.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four main topics: Gestures as the basic mechanism of social acts and the distinction between nonsignificant and significant gestures, with emphasis on the vocal gesture; Significant Symbols as gestures that arouse the same response in both speaker and listener, making language and true communication possible; Mind defined as an internalized conversation with oneself that is social and functional, oriented toward problem-solving; and Self as the ability to take oneself as an object, which develops through social experience and reflexivity.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 142: Gestures
The gesture is defined by Mead as the basic mechanism in the social act and the social process. Gestures are “movements of the first organism which act as specific stimuli calling forth the (socially) appropriate responses of the second organism” (Mead, 1934/1962:14). Both lower animals and humans are capable of gestures in the sense that the action of one individual mindlessly and automatically elicits a reaction by another individual.
Mead’s famous example of a dog fight illustrates this: “The act of each dog becomes the stimulus to the other dog for his response… The very fact that the dog is ready to attack another becomes a stimulus to the other dog to change his own position or his own attitude. He has no sooner done this than the change of attitude in the second dog in turn causes the first dog to change his attitude.” Mead labels this a “conversation of gestures.” One dog’s gesture automatically elicits a gesture from the second; there are no thought processes taking place on the part of the dogs.
Humans sometimes engage in mindless conversations of gestures, such as actions in boxing and fencing matches when one combatant adjusts “instinctively” to the actions of the second. Mead labels such unconscious actions “nonsignificant” gestures. What distinguishes humans is their ability to employ “significant” gestures, or those that require thought on the part of the actor before a reaction.
The vocal gesture is particularly important in the development of significant gestures. Not all vocal gestures are significant (e.g., a mindless grunt). However, the development of vocal gestures, especially in the form of language, is the most important factor in making possible the distinctive development of human life: “The specialization of the human animal within this field of the gesture has been responsible, ultimately, for the origin and growth of present human society and knowledge.”
A distinctive characteristic of the vocal gesture is that when we utter a vocal gesture, we hear ourselves just as others do. One result is that the vocal gesture can affect the speaker in much the same way that it affects the listeners. Another is that we are far better able to stop ourselves in vocal gestures than we are able to stop ourselves in physical gestures. This ability to control oneself and one’s reactions is critical to other distinctive capabilities of humans.
🔑 Definition — Gesture: Movements of the first organism which act as specific stimuli calling forth the socially appropriate responses of the second organism.
🔑 Definition — Conversation of Gestures: A situation where one individual’s gesture automatically elicits a gesture from another, without thought processes taking place.
🔑 Definition — Nonsignificant Gesture: Unconscious actions that do not require thought on the part of the actor before a reaction.
🔑 Definition — Significant Gesture: Gestures that require thought on the part of the actor before a reaction.
📌 Example — Dog Fight: One dog’s readiness to attack becomes a stimulus for the other dog to change position; this change in attitude causes the first dog to change his attitude in turn. This is a conversation of gestures with no thought involved.
💡 Why this matters: The vocal gesture’s unique property of being heard by the speaker as others hear it enables self-control and is the foundation for all higher mental processes in Mead’s theory.
Topic 143: Significant Symbols
A significant symbol is a kind of gesture which only humans can make. Gestures become significant symbols when they arouse in the individual who is making them the same kind of response they are supposed to elicit from those to whom the gestures are addressed. Only when we have significant symbols can we truly have communication; communication in the full sense is not possible among ants, bees, and so on.
Physical gestures can be significant symbols, but they are not ideally suited because people cannot easily see or hear their own physical gestures. Vocal utterances are most likely to become significant symbols, although not all vocalizations are such symbols. The set of vocal gestures most likely to become significant symbols is language: “a symbol which answers to a meaning in that experience of the first individual and which also calls out the meaning in the second individual … It is now a significant symbol and it signifies a certain meaning” (Mead, 1934/1962:46).
In a conversation of gestures, only the gestures themselves are communicated. However, with language, the gestures and their meanings are communicated.
One of the things that language does is call out the same response in the individual who is speaking that it does in others. The word dog or cat elicits the same mental image in the person uttering the word that it does in those to whom it is addressed. Another effect is that language stimulates the person speaking as it does others. The person yelling “fire” in a crowded theater is at least as motivated to leave as are those to whom the shout is addressed. Thus, significant symbols allow people to be the stimulators of their own actions.
Adopting his pragmatist orientation, Mead looks at the “functions” of gestures and significant symbols. The function of the gesture “is to make adjustment possible among the individuals implicated in any given social act.” The “significant symbol affords far greater facilities for such adjustment and readjustment than does the nonsignificant gesture, because it calls out in the individual making it the same attitude toward it … and enables him to adjust his subsequent behavior to theirs in the light of that attitude” (Mead, 1934/1962:46).
From a pragmatic point of view, a significant symbol works better in the social world than does a nonsignificant gesture. In communicating displeasure to others, an angry verbal rebuke works far better than contorted body language. A speaker is conscious of uttering an angry rebuke and reacts to it in much the same way as the person to whom it is aimed reacts. Thus, the speaker can think about how the other person might react and can prepare his or her reaction to that reaction.
Of crucial importance is another function of significant symbols — they make the mind, mental processes, and so on, possible. It is only through significant symbols, especially language, that human thinking is possible (lower animals cannot think, in Mead’s terms).
🔑 Definition — Thinking: “Simply an internalized or implicit conversation of the individual with himself by means of such gestures” (Mead, 1934/1962:47). Mead argues: “Thinking is the same as talking to other people” (1982:155). Thinking involves talking to oneself.
This is a behavioristic definition of thinking, not a mentalistic one. Significant symbols also make possible symbolic interaction — people can interact with one another not just through gestures but also through significant symbols, making possible much more complex interaction patterns and forms of social organization.
🔑 Definition — Significant Symbol: A gesture that arouses in the individual who is making it the same kind of response it is supposed to elicit from those to whom the gestures are addressed.
📌 Example — “Fire!” in a theater: The person yelling “fire” is at least as motivated to leave the theater as are those to whom the shout is addressed, demonstrating that language stimulates the speaker as it does others.
💡 Why this matters: Significant symbols, especially language, are the foundation for thinking, mind, and all higher human mental processes. They enable the complex social organization that distinguishes human society.
Topic 144: Mind
The mind is defined by Mead as a process and not a thing, as an inner conversation with one’s self. It is not found within the individual; it is not intracranial but is a social phenomenon (Franks, 2007). The mind arises and develops within the social process and is an integral part of that process. The social process precedes the mind; it is not, as many believe, a product of the mind. The mind, like other concepts, is defined functionally rather than substantively.
A distinctive characteristic of the mind is the ability of the individual “to call out in himself not simply a single response of the other but the response, so to speak, of the community as a whole. That is what gives to an individual what we term ‘mind.’ To do anything now means a certain organized response; and if one has in himself that response, he has what we term ‘mind’” (Mead, 1934/1962:267).
Thus, the mind can be distinguished from other like-sounding concepts in Mead’s work by its ability to respond to the overall community and put forth an organized response.
Mead also looks at the mind in a pragmatic way. The mind involves thought processes oriented toward problem solving. The real world is rife with problems, and it is the function of the mind to try to solve those problems and permit people to operate more effectively in the world.
🔑 Definition — Mind: A process and not a thing; an inner conversation with one’s self that is a social phenomenon arising within the social process.
📌 Example — Community Response: The ability to call out in oneself not just a single response of another person but the organized response of the community as a whole gives an individual what Mead terms “mind.”
💡 Why this matters: Mead’s concept of mind is radically social — it is not an individual possession but arises from and operates within social processes. This distinguishes his approach from mentalistic or individualistic theories.
Topic 145: Self
Much of Mead’s thinking involves the critically important concept of the self (Schwalbe, 2005), basically the ability to take oneself as an object. The self is the peculiar ability to be both subject and object. As with all Mead’s major concepts, the self presupposes a social process: communication among humans.
Lower animals do not have selves, nor do human infants at birth. The self arises with development and through social activity and social relationships. To Mead, it is impossible to imagine a self-arising in the absence of social experiences. However, once a self has developed, it is possible for it to continue to exist without social contact.
The self is dialectically related to the mind. On the one hand, Mead argues that the body is not a self and becomes a self only when a mind has developed. On the other hand, the self, along with its reflexiveness, is essential to the development of the mind. The self is a mental process but also a social process.
Mead resists lodging the self in consciousness and instead embeds it in social experience and social processes: “But it is where one does respond to that which he addresses to another and where that response of his own becomes a part of his conduct, where he not only hears himself but responds to himself, talks and replies to himself as truly as the other person replies to him, that we have behavior in which the individuals become objects to themselves” (1934/1962:139).
The general mechanism for the development of the self is reflexivity, or the ability to put ourselves unconsciously into others’ places and to act as they act. As a result, people are able to examine themselves as others would examine them.
The self also allows people to take part in their conversations with others. One is aware of what one is saying and as a result is able to monitor what is being said and to determine what is going to be said next.
In order to have selves, individuals must be able to get “outside themselves” so that they can evaluate themselves, so that they can become objects to themselves. People cannot experience themselves directly. They can do so only indirectly by putting themselves in the position of others and viewing themselves from that standpoint. The standpoint can be that of a particular individual or that of the social group as a whole. As Mead puts it: “It is only by taking the roles of others that we have been able to come back to ourselves” (1959:184-185).
🔑 Definition — Self: The ability to take oneself as an object; the peculiar ability to be both subject and object. It arises through social activity and social relationships.
🔑 Definition — Reflexivity: The ability to put ourselves unconsciously into others’ places and to act as they act, enabling people to examine themselves as others would examine them.
📌 Example — Robinson Crusoe: Crusoe developed a self while he was in civilization, and he continued to have it when he was living alone on a deserted island. He continued to have the ability to take himself as an object, even without direct social contact, because the self was already formed.
💡 Why this matters: The self is not innate but socially constructed. Mead’s insight that we can only see ourselves through the eyes of others is foundational to symbolic interactionism and understanding human identity formation.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember from this lecture is that Mead offers a thoroughly social behaviorist account of human consciousness: gestures are the basic mechanism of social acts, with nonsignificant gestures being automatic and significant gestures requiring thought. Significant symbols, especially language, enable true communication by arousing the same response in the speaker as in the listener, making them the foundation for mind (defined as internalized conversation with oneself oriented toward problem-solving) and self (the ability to take oneself as an object). Crucially, all these phenomena — gestures, significant symbols, mind, and self — are social processes that arise from and within social interaction, not innate properties of the individual. The vocal gesture is particularly important because the speaker hears themselves as others do, enabling self-control and self-awareness.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- According to Mead, what is the difference between a “conversation of gestures” and communication through significant symbols? Use the dog fight example to explain.
- What is a “significant symbol,” and why does Mead consider language the most important form of significant symbol?
- How does Mead define “thinking,” and why is his definition considered behavioristic rather than mentalistic?
- Explain the relationship between “mind” and “self” in Mead’s theory. How are they dialectically related?
- What is “reflexivity,” and why is it the general mechanism for the development of the self? How does the example of Robinson Crusoe illustrate that the self requires social experience to develop but not necessarily to continue?