π Lecture 9 β EFFECTIVE COUNSELOR
π Overview: This lecture examines the personal characteristics, beliefs, and traits that differentiate effective from ineffective counselors, building on Carl Rogers' assertion that counselor attitude matters more than technique. It explores both beneficial and harmful motives for entering the counseling profession, emotional responsiveness, sense of worth, anxieties, and sex-role identity, providing a framework for counselor self-assessment and professional development.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Combs et al. (1969) meta-analysis on effective vs. ineffective counselor traits, Meier and Davis's (2001) principles for self-assessment, beneficial and harmful counselor motives for entering the profession, emotional responsiveness including inability to repress feelings and internalizing others' feelings, counselor sense of worth and anxieties with their positive and negative consequences, and sex-role identity and expectations including androgyny and gender-based overgeneralizations.
π Lecture Summary
Example of Congruence
The lecture opens with an example demonstrating counselor congruence β the counselor's ability to be genuine and authentic by sharing a personal experience relevant to the client's struggle. The client says: "My parents do not understand me. When I want to communicate my viewpoint to them, they think I am being disrespectful. They donβt understand that disagreeing does not mean being rude." The counselor responds: "These kinds of communication gaps can sometimes exist between parents and their children. When I was a teenager I often thought that it was difficult to make my parents understand what I felt."
Meta Analysis of Combs et al. (1969)
Combs and his colleagues conducted a series of studies concluding that the personal beliefs and traits of the counselor or therapist differentiated between effective and ineffective helping. Roger maintained that the counselor's theory and methods were far less important than the client's perception of the counselor's attitude.
Effective helpers perceive others as able, rather than unable, to solve their own problems and manage their own lives. They also perceive others as dependable, friendly, worthy, able to cope, and able to be communicative and self-disclosing. In general, effective helpers maintain a positive view of human nature and approach family, friends, colleagues, and clients in a trusting, affirming way. The major technique of counseling was the "self as instrument." Effective counselors are more likely to identify with people rather than things.
Meier and Davis (2001)
Helpers who are the most effective strive to apply four principles to assess characteristics and traits that impact their own ability to assist others:
- Become aware of your personal issues
- Be open to supervision
- Avoid hiding behind the use of too many tests
- Consult when presented with an ethical dilemma
Other Personal Characteristics of an Effective Counselor
The lecture lists six key areas of personal characteristics: Motives, Emotional Responsiveness, Sense of Worth & Anxieties, Sex-Role Identity and Expectations, Values, and Cultural Bias.
Counselorβs Motives to Enter the Profession: Beneficial Motives
Humanism involves a commitment to create a better world by empowering others through fostering their personal development. Humanism allows counselors to commit themselves to the struggle to make themselves and others better people for the sake of a better world.
People Orientation draws on Holland's theory of personality types, which asserts that special heredity and experiences lead to six main personality types: realistic, investigative, artistic, social, enterprising, and conventional. The social personality type in particular is found in the helping professions, with characteristics including responsible, helpful, friendly, idealistic, feminine, insightful, and kind.
Intellectual Curiosity means effective counselors tend to enjoy the challenge of making and testing hypotheses about human behavior. They are in a constant process of revising their models of the person and of counseling practice.
Worked-through Emotional Pain means counselors who have worked through their pain and attained some distance from it may have extra sensitivity to the needs of others.
Commitment to Competence means effective counselors like to do things well and are prepared to work at it. Dimensions of competence include honestly evaluating the counseling process, staying well-studied, being prepared to work on professional issues, learning from a supervisor, and maintaining professional integrity.
Counselorβs Motives to Enter the Profession: Harmful Motives
Unresolved Emotional Pain β Counselors with unresolved emotional pain may have an underlying agenda to seek help rather than to provide it. Their attraction to nurturing others stems from their own need to be nurtured.
Do-Gooding β These counselors may wish to take charge and, by so doing, treat clients as objects and infantilize them. Do-gooders may overly concern themselves with obtaining clients' approval and appreciation for their good works.
Seeking Intimacy β Some people are attracted to counseling because it provides opportunities for psychological closeness they find difficult to obtain otherwise. This way of gaining emotional closeness was one of Carl Rogers's own motivations for becoming a counselor.
True Believerism β True-believerism implies lack of openness to conflicting evidence and to the specific needs of individual clients. Examples include true believers in the rights of minority groups, or believers in terms of theoretical positions like hard-line rational emotive behavior therapy or gestalt therapy advocates.
Emotional Responsiveness
You bring to counseling your capacity to experience your feelings. It is important for counselors to be responsive to their flow of feeling for reasons including being genuine, spontaneous, and able to resonate and appropriately respond to clients' feelings. Your feelings are a good guide to issues in your relationships with clients.
Inability and Repressing Feelings β As you grew up, you learned that it is unsafe to acknowledge, experience, and express all feelings. For example, if in adolescence someone is told that it is a sin to think about the opposite sex, the person as an adult may feel anxious when having intimacy with their spouse. Consequently, some people find it difficult to express any feelings β they are emotionally flat and lifeless. Different families may inhibit or dilute the experiencing of specific emotions like sensuality, anger, sadness, or death anxiety. Differences also exist across cultural, gender, and social class groups. For example, the 'strong, silent' type is a male stereotype; because of this gender stereotype, men often find it difficult to be empathic and emotionally responsive compared to women.
Internalize others' feeling as if your own β The main thrust of Rogers's person-centered therapy is to assist clients to experience their own inner valuing process rather than to deny and distort their feelings. Counselors learn to internalize the feelings of significant others in their past as if they were their own.
Transferring unfinished business β Both counselors and clients can distort their perceptions and feelings towards one another by transferring perceptions from past relationships. Transferred feelings can be either positive or negative.
Counselorβs Sense of worth & Anxieties
Sense of worth β Insecurities and fears, if not confronted and managed, can be the breeding ground for distorted communication. This is determined by one's relationships with parents. Members of facilitative families help each other become mentally healthy, while parents of retarding families feel insecure and transmit their insecurity to their children. The counselor's resulting lack of sense of worth as a consequence of their own insecurities can hinder the counseling relationship.
Meaninglessness and Alienation β Rollo May talked about the modern individual's isolation from the environment. Carl Jung and Victor Frankl maintained that a sense of meaning keeps us alive. Sullivan maintained that 90% of human communication is specially designed not to communicate. There is a close connection between the counselor's sense of worth and feelings of anxiety:
- Insecurity manifests and engenders anxiety. People who feel worthwhile are relatively free from debilitating anxieties.
- Counselor anxiety may be facilitating, debilitating, or both. For example, a little anxiety will increase the counselor's sensitivity to feel the client's problems. However, it may also make the counselor more anxious or defensive. For example, the rule 'I must always have my clients' approval' leads to over-sensitivity to cues of rejection.
Fears and Anxieties β Positive Consequences:
- Sensitivity to clients' anxieties
- Necessary to tone counselors up
Negative Consequences:
- May cease to listen accurately
- May perceive and relate to clients in terms of their own needs
- Assuming too much responsibility
Results of excessive anxiety β Specific behaviors that may result from excessive counselor anxiety include:
- Asking too many questions
- Offering superficial reassurance and being too directive in telling clients how to behave
Sex-Role Identity and Expectations
Certain psychological characteristics have been traditionally viewed as either 'feminine' or 'masculine.' Feminine characteristics have included being affectionate, gentle, sensitive to the needs of others, tender, and warm. Masculine characteristics have included being aggressive, ambitious, assertive, analytical, and dominant.
Sex-role identity develops due to the socialization process. The books we read show boys and girls in different roles, as do films and television programs. Both male and female children are exposed to different treatments in schools, including the subjects they were encouraged to study and the occupations thought appropriate for them.
The androgynous male or female 'is flexible masculine or feminine as circumstances warrant' (Bem, 1981, p.362). Our current sex-role identity is the internalized sum of individual differences, personal situational factors, and cultural, social, and environmental influences. The traditional feminine sex role has created problems for many women in areas such as expressing anger, being autonomous, and obtaining power and status. The traditional masculine role has created problems for many men through excessive concern with success, power, and competition, being emotionally inexpressive, and restricting affectionate behavior between men.
Counselors may assess clients differently according to whether or not they fit into traditional sex roles. Females and males can be brought up with the capacity to express a range of characteristics independently of whether they have traditionally been viewed as 'masculine' or 'feminine' β for instance, men can be tender and women assertive. As long as males and females adopt the strengths rather than the deficits of the other sex's gender characteristics, androgyny is helpful for enriching people's lives. The counselor may engage in simplistic over-generalizations about the characteristics of males and females and insufficiently acknowledge within-group differences.
Activity 1: My Sex-Role Identity and Expectations asks the counselor to reflect on whether they received different toys or clothes on account of their sex, what roles their mother and father played in caring for them, and who performed domestic tasks in their family.
Activity 2: Learning Psychological Characteristics asks the counselor to consider which psychological characteristics each parent encouraged or discouraged them to show, including gentleness, ambitiousness, feeling of vulnerability, sensitivity, competitiveness, career orientation, dominance, concern with clothes, being nurturing, and home orientation.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical things a student MUST remember from this lecture are: (1) Effective counselors perceive others as able, dependable, friendly, and worthy, and the "self as instrument" is the major technique of counseling β personal beliefs and traits matter more than methods. (2) Beneficial motives for entering the profession include humanism, people orientation, intellectual curiosity, worked-through emotional pain, and commitment to competence, while harmful motives include unresolved emotional pain, do-gooding, seeking intimacy, and true believerism. (3) Emotional responsiveness is essential; counselors must be aware of their own repressed feelings, the tendency to internalize others' feelings, and the risk of transferring unfinished business from past relationships. (4) Counselor sense of worth is closely tied to anxiety β a little anxiety can be facilitating, but excessive anxiety leads to asking too many questions, superficial reassurance, and being overly directive. (5) Androgyny β flexibility in masculine or feminine characteristics as circumstances warrant β is helpful for counselors, while rigid sex-role expectations and overgeneralizations about males and females can impair judgment and the therapeutic relationship.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to Combs et al. (1969), what are the key personal beliefs and traits that differentiate effective from ineffective counselors?
- What are the four principles Meier and Davis (2001) recommend for counselors to assess their own characteristics and traits?
- What is the difference between "worked-through emotional pain" and "unresolved emotional pain" as counselor motives, and how does each affect the helping relationship?
- How can counselor anxiety be both facilitating and debilitating β give one example of each from the lecture.
- What is androgyny according to Bem (1981), and why is it considered helpful for counselors?
π Lecture 10 β EFFECTIVE COUNSELOR
π Overview: This lecture examines the essential personal characteristics required of effective counselors, including how their values and cultural biases impact therapeutic work. It explores the daily stresses practitioners face, the path to burnout, and presents comprehensive models of psychological health and wellness that apply to both counselors and their clients.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the personal characteristics model focusing on counselors' values and their influence on clients, cultural biases inherent in Western counseling theories and practice, the daily world of the practitioner including common stressors and organizational demands, the stress-burnout continuum with warning signs, and two comprehensive psychological health models: Kinnier's criteria and the multidimensional Wheel of Wellness. It also includes self-reflection activities for personal and professional development.
π Lecture Summary
Personal Characteristics Model
Influence of Counselor's Values on Client's Values
Values are principles that guide our life. Counselors' values influence how they work with clients and can bring value conflicts into the counseling relationship. Counselors must understand their own values and the values of others, recognizing that no one set of values is superior to others. Every person has a set of beliefs that determines their decisions, their ability to appreciate things around them, their consciences, and their perceptions of others. Values serve as reference points for individuals, providing a basis for determining which course of action to take, e.g., respecting elders. A counselor's conflict with certain values can also cause relationship difficulties with clients. For religious counselors, issues of contraception, abortion, divorce, and intentional single parenting create value conflicts.
Using the Schwartz Universal Values Questionnaire (Schwartz, 1992), Kelly (1995) surveyed a national sample of nearly 500 American counselors. The prevalence of values as reported by the counselors were: benevolence, 5.27; self-direction, 5.08; universalism, 4.89; achievement, 4.63; hedonism, 4.14; security, 4.07; stimulation, 3.59; tradition, 3.17; power, 2.09.
π Definition β Value Neutrality: The position that counselors should remain neutral while counseling and communicate no value orientation to the client, allowing the client to move from an external to an internal locus of control.
Williamson (1958) called for an abandonment of the neutral position, suggesting that this could easily lead the client to believe that the counselor can accept unlawful behavior. Some maintain that the counselor should remain neutral and appear nonmoralizing, ethically neutral, and focused on the client's values. If topics such as pro-choice versus pro-life, religion, euthanasia, or gay, lesbian, and bisexual orientation arise, the counselor would not take a position. However, such a situation could lead to the client feeling that the counselor supported behavior unacceptable by social, moral, or legal standards.
Patterson (1958) points out that the counselor's values definitely influence those of the client, affect the ethics of the counseling relationship, the goals of counseling, and the methods employed. Patterson cites evidence that no matter how passive and valueless the counselor appears, the client's value system is influenced and gradually becomes more similar to the counselor's. However, Patterson suggests counselors are not justified in consciously and directly imposing their values on their clients.
π Example β Value Similarity and Counseling Outcome (Cook, 1966): In an experiment using the Study of Values test, Cook found that in 3 value-similarity groups, the medium similarity group improved more than those in either high similarity or low similarity groups. Differences in the counselors' and clients' value systems affected counseling outcome. When clients grouped by how similar their values were to the counselor's, clients in the medium similarity group improved more, suggesting that when the counselor or client perceives the world as too similar to or too different from the other's, it has an adverse effect on their interactions.
Belkin (1984) suggests that the primary value to which counselors must commit themselves is freedom. Freedom is an ideal that propels the individual to certain types of actions. Freedom allows the individual to determine what direction to move in, to be creative, to make choices and be responsible for them. Freedom also commits the client to assuming responsibility for their actions and consequences.
Research indicates that social class bias influenced psychiatric residents' diagnosis of patients (Lee, 1968; Fitzgibbons & Shearn, 1972). The professional background of the therapist had an important influence on whether the therapist judged a patient schizophrenic or not (Fitzgibbons & Shearn, 1972).
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the inevitable influence of your own values on clients is crucial β you cannot be truly neutral, but you must avoid imposing your values while being aware of how value similarity or difference affects therapeutic outcomes.
Cultural Bias in Theory and Practice
It is widely acknowledged that current theories are derivatives of Western culture and are not universally applicable to cross-cultural counseling situations (Corey, 2001; Schmidt, 2002). Examples of cultural differences are abundant (Argyle, 1985). This is manifested in different behaviors, for example, calling others by first name, direct or indirect gaze, etc. Christopher (1996) addresses diversity issues through the concept of moral visions.
π Example β Cultural Differences in Social Behavior (Argyle, 1985): Argyle studied 22 social relationships in 4 cultures: Britain, Italy, Hong Kong, and Japan. Addressing the other person by first name was highly endorsed in only three Japanese relationships, a much lower figure than in the other three cultures. Looking the other person in the eye during conversation was highly endorsed in virtually all British and Italian relationships, but in under half of Japanese and Hong Kong relationships.
Christopher points out that different cultures provide different moral visions. The ideal person in traditional Confucian China was first and foremost characterized by absolute loyalty and being a dutiful son or daughter. In contrast, in American culture, attributes such as authenticity and autonomy are reinforced. Most Western counseling or psychotherapy theories are moral visions that presuppose the importance of individualism. For example, behaviorist, cognitive-behavioral, and reality theories emphasize utilitarian individualism β rationality, control over emotions, enhanced human liberty, the importance of achieving self-defined goals, and opposition to irrational authority. Humanistic theories like person-centered and Gestalt theories promote the importance of turning inward, making contact with inner experiencing, and identifying and expressing feelings. Such emphases may not be congruent with the moral visions of clients from other cultures.
Western values include emphasis on youth, assertiveness, independence, and competition, whereas the corresponding Eastern values emphasize maturity, compliance, interdependence, and cooperation. Awareness of cultural differences and the ability to build bridges across them are important counseling skills. Income, educational attainment, and occupational status are currently three of the main measures of social class; you bring your skills at understanding people from different social classes and of forming counseling relationships with them.
Usher (1989) provided guidelines for assessing cultural bias inherent in theories of counseling and psychotherapy:
-
Assumptions about Normal Behavior: Pedersen (1987) argued that "what is considered normal behavior will change according to the situation, the cultural background of a person or persons being judged, and the time during which a behavior is being displayed or observed." Person-centered and REBT emphasize the welfare and centrality of the individual and deemphasize obligation and duty to family, organizations, and society.
-
Dependence on Abstract Words: Would all clients understand concepts like self-actualization or fictional finalism? Many clients are not receptive to abstractions or conceptualizations.
-
Neglect of Client Support Systems: In some cultures, talking with family members or friends may be more acceptable than talking with a trainee professional who is usually a total stranger.
-
Focus on Changing the Individual: Linear thinking emphasizes cause-and-effect relationships, whereas the nonlinear or circular thinking characteristic of some cultures does not separate cause and effect. Counselors who use Western theory as the sole basis for practice assume their role is to make the client more congruent with the system, which is problematic when Western culture-bound paradigms like the DSM are used to assess culturally different clients.
π‘ Why this matters: As a counselor, you must recognize that your theoretical orientation carries cultural assumptions about individualism, normality, and change that may not fit clients from non-Western backgrounds, requiring you to adapt your approach.
The Daily World of the Practitioner
A complex relationship exists between elements of the therapeutic process and the demands experienced by the counselor on a daily basis (Moursund & Kenny, 2002). The demands inherent in any work environment are tremendous. Concerns about having enough clients, students, supervisees, research funds, publications, involvements in professional and community organizations, collected fees, malpractice, and liability insurance are just a few examples of demands that converge on counselors (e.g., in school, college, university, mental health center, hospital, private practice, rehabilitation clinic).
Freudenberger (1983) notes that the very nature of the therapeutic personality often makes it difficult to say no, and many people in counseling find themselves overextended, tired, and overly involved with work.
Common Individual Stressors include: striving for perfection, excessive need for approval, self-doubt, physical and emotional exhaustion, assuming too much responsibility for clients, and ruminating about cases.
Stresses associated with working in organizations include: excessive demands of agencies, constant paperwork, and dehumanization and erosion of ideals.
Stress and Burnout
How stress paves the way to burnout: Stress at work tends to impact your personal life. Working intensely with people opens you up to your own wounds β it reactivates earlier conflicts and pain. Constant stress that is not managed results in physical and psychological exhaustion.
Burnout: There are internal and external causes of burnout. Chronic burnout can lead to becoming impaired. You are challenged with recognizing signs of burnout before you become an impaired practitioner.
Warning Signs for Burnout (Kaslow, 1986): When two or more of these indicators appear periodically with gradually increasing frequency, intensity, and duration, a counselor has entered a warning zone and should seek personal counseling, take a vacation, cut back on obligations until they re-experience perspective and balance:
- Not wanting to go to work
- Constantly complaining about disliking one's practice or feeling overwhelmed
- Viewing life as dull, heavy, and tedious
- Experiencing increasing number of negative counter-transference reactions to patients or students
- Being extremely irritable, withdrawn, depressed, or intolerant at home
- Suffering frequent illnesses of inexplicable origin
- Wanting to run away from it all or having periodic suicidal ideation
Psychological Health Model
The capacity to give and receive love as a criterion for psychological health has been endorsed by many theorists including Adler (1978), Allport (1961), Erikson (1968), Freud (1930), Fromm (1955), Maslow (1970), and Sullivan (1953).
Jahoda (1958) proposed 6 criteria for mental health: a positive attitude toward self, continual movement toward self-actualization, purpose in life, ability to function independently, an accurate perception of reality, and mastery of the environment. Basic self-esteem has been viewed as essential by Allport, Erikson, Jung, Maslow, Rogers, and Sullivan. Personal autonomy and competence are emphasized by Fromm, Horney, Maslow, and Rogers.
Kinnier's Criteria for Psychological Health
Following a survey of psychological literature, Kinnier (1997) proposed 9 criteria for psychological health that apply to counselors and therapists as well as their clients:
-
Self-acceptance: Self-esteem seems to be a prerequisite for developing other important components of psychological health. Psychologically healthy individuals experience strong feelings of self-acceptance and self-love. Individuals who love and respect themselves have the capacity to love and respect others and possess the foundation for becoming self-actualized.
-
Self-knowledge (introspective): Psychologically healthy individuals know themselves well and stay aware of their feelings, motivations, and needs. They are introspective and committed to understanding themselves.
-
Self-confidence and self-control: They have appropriate skills for assertive behavior but do not unnecessarily impose their views on others. Such individuals have an internal locus of control, believe they can exert reasonable control over their lives, and feel capable of achieving their goals.
-
A clear perception of reality (enough societal consensus): Perceptions are always subjective, but there are usually enough societal consensuses about the nature of reality to provide beneficial comparisons. Psychologically healthy individuals have a clear perception of reality and an optimistic view of life.
-
Courage and Resilience: Danger and risk surround daily lives and decision-making; therefore, failures, crises, and setbacks are inevitable. Psychologically healthy individuals are aware of this reality, adapt well to challenges and changed circumstances, and can bounce back from disappointments.
-
Balance and moderation: Psychologically healthy individuals work and play, laugh and cry, enjoy planned and spontaneous time with family and friends, and are not afraid to be both illogical and intuitive. They are rarely extremists or fanatics and usually do not do anything in excess.
-
Love of others: Capacity to give and receive love (Adler, 1978; Fromm, 1955): Many theoretical orientations believe the ability to give and receive love, the desire to develop close ties, and the need to belong are fundamental to mental health.
-
Love of life: People who are active, curious, spontaneous, venturesome, and relaxed have traits that promote their capacity to partake of and enjoy life.
-
Purpose in life: Individuals vary in their choice of the most meaningful aspects of life. Work, love, family, intellectual or physical accomplishment, or spirituality may become the primary focus.
The Multidimensional Health and Wellness Model
Systemic models of wellness suggest that all identified dimensions of wellness interact and must all be evaluated (Skovholt, 2001) as components of a lifelong paradigm to promote health and wellness. Health has been defined as the absence of illness; wellness goes far beyond the absence of illness and incorporates a zest and enthusiasm for life that results when the dimensions of wellness have been addressed, developed, and integrated. A person can be "well" even when undergoing treatment for physical illness because the physical dimension is just one dimension of the wellness model.
In 1984, Hettler proposed six dimensions of wellness: intellectual, emotional, physical, social, occupational, and spiritual. A later revision (Myers et al., 2000) indicated the following Wheel of Wellness as a basis for working holistically with clients: Spirituality, Self-direction, Work and leisure, Friendship, and Love.
Activity 1: Assessing Your Personal Characteristics β Use this list as a catalyst for honest self-reflection: Sensitivity, Personal presence, Compassion & empathy, Flexibility & willingness to receive feedback, Integrity, Modeling, Insight. Reflect on how well you know yourself and assess your current level of interpersonal functioning.
Activity 2: Conduct an interview with a mental health professional. Before the interview, develop a list of questions that you are interested in exploring. Write up the salient points and conclusions of your interview in your Counseling Journal.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical understanding from this lecture is that counselors' values inevitably influence clients, but research shows medium value similarity produces the best outcomes, not total similarity or dissimilarity. You must be aware that Western counseling theories carry cultural biases emphasizing individualism, autonomy, and abstract concepts that may not fit clients from collectivist cultures. The daily demands of practice create significant stress that can lead to burnout, with specific warning signs including not wanting to go to work, irritability, and counter-transference reactions. Psychological health for both counselor and client involves multiple dimensions according to Kinnier's nine criteria, including self-acceptance, resilience, balance, and purpose in life. Finally, wellness is a multidimensional, holistic concept going beyond the absence of illness, encompassing spiritual, intellectual, emotional, physical, social, and occupational dimensions that must all be addressed.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to Cook's (1966) research on value similarity, which group of clients showed the most improvement β high similarity, medium similarity, or low similarity with their counselor?
- What are the four guidelines proposed by Usher (1989) for assessing cultural bias in counseling theories?
- List at least five of the seven warning signs of burnout identified by Kaslow (1986) that indicate a counselor has entered a "warning zone."
- What are the nine criteria for psychological health proposed by Kinnier (1997)?
- According to the multidimensional wellness model, what are the five components of the Wheel of Wellness as revised by Myers et al. (2000)?
π Lecture 11 β Counseling Skills
π Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational microskills that form the building blocks of all counseling and therapy approaches. It emphasizes that the counseling relationship depends on the counselor's ability to attend to and understand clients through both verbal and nonverbal communication. Mastering these observable skills enables counselors to build therapeutic rapport and effect positive change across theoretical orientations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture defines the counseling relationship and introduces microskills as observable actions that effect positive change. It covers attending skills as complex proficiencies in verbal and nonverbal domains, then provides detailed analysis of nonverbal communication including body language and movement (kinesics) across all body parts, paralinguistics including voice volume, articulation, pitch, emphasis, and rate (VAPER), and the use of pauses and silence. The lecture includes multiple tables showing possible interpretations of common kinesic expressions for eyes, mouth, facial expressions, shoulders and arms, legs and feet, and body movement.
π Lecture Summary
The Counseling Relationship and Microskills
The counseling relationship is defined as the quality and strength of the human connection that counselors and clients share. Listening and showing understanding skills are central to building quality relationships with clients. All counseling relationships consist of two relationships: the counselor's relationship with the client and the client's relationship with the counselor.
All systems of counseling and therapy employ various patterns of skills, known as microskills. Microskills are observable actions of counselors and therapists that appear to effect positive change in the session, in which active listening involves both receiver and sender. Complex interaction is broken down into manageable and learnable dimensions. Once you learn these skills, they can be fitted into a wide variety of theoretical orientations. When you learn new methods of therapy, you can build them on these skills and frame them into a variety of techniques.
Different microskills described include attending skills, listening skills (the "basic listening sequence"), focus and selective attention, influencing skills, and confrontation and challenging.
π Definition β Microskills: Observable actions of counselors and therapists that appear to effect positive change in the session, where active listening involves both receiver and sender.
Attending Skills
Attending skills is a simple phrase for a complex collection of behaviors and abilities. Attending skills are comprised of a series of complex proficiencies that cut across the verbal and nonverbal domains of communication. It is rare that people receive the full attention of their communication partner(s). When it does happen, they are keenly aware and appreciative of this fact. It is rare that people place full attention on themselves; hence, it is not surprising that most clients, and perhaps too many clinicians, are unaware of, or inattentive to, their own meta-communications (communications that go beyond the verbal). Clients are frequently unaware of communications that go beyond the verbal, and clinicians may forget to attend to these nonverbals. Attending refers to the focused attention that is placed on the other person in an interchange between two or more people. Without attending skills, the establishment of therapeutic rapport is most likely difficult, if not impossible.
π Definition β Attending skills: A series of complex proficiencies that cut across verbal and nonverbal domains of communication, referring to the focused attention placed on the other person in an interchange.
π‘ Why this matters: Without attending skills, therapeutic rapport cannot be established β this is the foundational skill from which all other counseling interventions grow.
Attending Skills: Nonverbal Communication
Nonverbal communication is important from two perspectives: nonverbal communication expressed by the client and picked up by the clinician, and nonverbal communication used by the clinician for therapeutic goals. Attending nonverbal communication is an excellent means of gaining a clearer understanding of clients. It opens up a major area of meta-communication, including body language and movement, paralinguistics, physical space, and timing.
Body Language and Movement
Kinesics can emerge from any body part. Some of the most important body features observed involve head, face, eyes, mouth, shoulders, arms, hands, legs, feet, and torso. Motor movement observations about all body parts are important as they can provide a great deal of information. Motor movement overall is often further defined as agitated, fidgety, unusual, normal, or as including tics, tremors, or motor abnormalities. Autonomic responses are also often included, drawing attention to physiological reactions such as rate of breathing, blushing versus paling, or pupil dilation. All motor and facial expressions can be assessed in terms of their congruence with verbal content of conversation as well as the level of activity or agitation they may suggest.
Kinesics derives additional importance from the reality that they are commonly used as substitutes to verbal communication β frequently clients use their body to respond to a clinician's question.
π Definition β Kinesics: Nonverbal communication that emerges from any body part, including motor movements and autonomic responses that can be assessed for congruence with verbal content.
Table 1: Sample of Possible Interpretations of Common Kinesics: Eyes
| Nonverbal Expression | Possible Meaning |
|---|---|
| Direct eye contact | Attentiveness |
| Lack of contact | Withdrawal |
| Looking down/away | Avoidance, preoccupation |
| Fixed staring | Uptightness, psychosis |
| Eye blinking | Anxiety, excitement |
| Squinting or wrinkled brow | Annoyance, concern, thoughtfulness |
| Dilated pupils | Alarm, interest |
Table 2: Sample of Possible Interpretations of Common Kinesics: Mouth
| Nonverbal Expression | Possible Meaning |
|---|---|
| Smiling | Greeting, positive mood, denial |
| Tight lips | Stress, anger/hostility, concentration |
| Quivering lips | Sadness, anger, anxiety |
| Biting/chewing of lips | Anxiety, bad habit |
| Open mouth | Surprise, boredom/fatigue/yawning |
Table 3: Sample of Possible Interpretations of Common Kinesics: Facial Expressions
| Nonverbal Expression | Possible Meaning |
|---|---|
| Flushed face | Embarrassment, anxiety |
| Eyes open wide & mouth opening | Surprise, sudden insight |
| Furrowed brow with tight mouth | Deep thought/concentration, irritation/annoyance, rejection of a therapist response |
Table 4: Sample of Possible Interpretations of Common Kinesics: Shoulders and Arms
| Nonverbal Expression | Possible Meaning |
|---|---|
| Shrugging shoulders | Uncertainty or ambivalence, indifference |
| Slouched shoulders | Sadness, withdrawal/shyness |
| Folded arms | Bad posture, self-protection, closed to contact, emotional distance |
| Open gesturing | Openness to disclosure |
| Stiff and/or unmoving | Anger, anxiety |
Table 5: Sample of Possible Interpretations of Common Kinesics: Legs and Feet
| Nonverbal Expression | Possible Meaning |
|---|---|
| Crossing and uncrossing | Anxiety/nervousness, depression, self-protection |
| Foot tapping | Anxiety, impatience |
| Stiff and/or controlled movements | Closed to contact, repressed attitude, sore muscles |
Table 6: Sample of Possible Interpretations of Common Kinesics: Body Movement
| Nonverbal Expression | Possible Meaning |
|---|---|
| Leaning forward | Attentiveness, interest |
| Leaning away or back | Withdrawal, rejection |
| Turned to the side | Relaxation or comfort |
| Rocking or repetitive motion | Avoidance, fear of rejection |
| Habitual movement (e.g., tapping, hair twirling) | Anxiety, nervousness, bad habit, developmental disorder |
| Fidgeting | Focused attention, impatience, bad habit |
Paralinguistics
The therapist attends to how high or low the client's volume is when speaking of various contents, and whether volume or inflection changes depending on topic. Very high volume may relate to anger, whereas very low volume may indicate sadness. Nonverbal or metacommunication aspects related to voice and speech have great communication value. A high-pitched voice may suggest anxiety; changes in inflection may direct attention to particularly emotional topics.
Counselors direct their attention to several aspects of speech, including voice volume, articulation, pitch, emphasis, and rate (VAPER). Speech fluency is explored with regard to the intrusion of stuttering or similar speech errors, as well as jerky speech that changes in clarity and fluency across topics. For example, sudden hesitations in speech may indicate anxiety about a topic or second thoughts about self-disclosure. Speech errors, such as wrong word choice or inability to think of the right word, may suggest anxiety or resistance.
Rate of speech refers to the speed with which the client communicates. It could theoretically be evaluated by looking at the number of words spoken per minute. Most concretely, rate ranges from slow to fast. Slower speech rate helps you appear less nervous, and also provides more time to think of what to say.
π Definition β VAPER: Acronym for Voice volume, Articulation, Pitch, Emphasis, and Rate β the key aspects of speech that counselors attend to in paralinguistic analysis.
Effect of Gender and Culture
Rate of speech varies greatly across cultural groups.
Use of Pauses and Silence
Use of pauses and silence enhances your capacity to be a rewarding listener. The counselor can pause each time they stop speaking before responding to see if the client wishes to continue. Good use of silence also gives clients more psychological space to think things through before speaking. Some counselors and clients find silence threatening; they have to work on tendencies to interrupt too soon.
Skill Development Activities
Skill Development Activity 1: In conversations with others, begin to focus on their nonverbal expressions of emotions. Note facial features, body posture, gestures, and other bodily cues about the person you are interacting with. Do not allow the verbal content to get in the way of your nonverbal listening. Pay careful attention to body language, even if it appears inconsistent with what is being said. Begin to notice if different people have different ways of expressing the same message.
Skill Development Activity 2: When in a public place with extra time, become a people watcher. Without hearing their conversations, pay attention to how people express themselves. Try to guess what emotions they are expressing by how they hold their bodies, faces, hands, and so forth.
β Key Takeaways
Microskills are the foundational observable actions that all counselors must master, and they can be applied across any theoretical orientation. Attending skills β the focused attention placed on another person β are essential for establishing therapeutic rapport and involve both verbal and nonverbal domains of communication. Nonverbal communication, particularly kinesics (body language and movement) and paralinguistics (voice volume, articulation, pitch, emphasis, and rate), provides crucial information about client emotional states, often serving as substitutes for verbal communication. All nonverbal expressions must be assessed for congruence with verbal content, and their meanings vary across cultural groups. The use of pauses and silence enhances listening capacity, giving clients psychological space to think, though both counselors and clients may find silence threatening.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are microskills and why are they considered foundational across all theoretical orientations in counseling?
- Why is it important to assess the congruence between a client's nonverbal expressions and their verbal content?
- What does the acronym VAPER stand for and how does each component help in understanding a client's emotional state?
- How can the use of pauses and silence benefit the counseling relationship, and why might some counselors and clients find silence threatening?
- According to the lecture, what is the relationship between attending skills and the establishment of therapeutic rapport?