๐ Lecture 12 โ COUNSELING SKILLS
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the critical role of counselor nonverbal communication in building the therapeutic relationship. It identifies common nonverbal pitfalls that can damage rapport, examines sensitive topics like touching and space, and introduces key concepts for effective nonverbal communication such as congruence, sensitivity, and synchrony.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins with a detailed examination of counselor nonverbal communication and numerous nonverbal pitfalls, including excessive closeness, distancing behaviors, and eye contact issues. It then addresses the problematic topic of touching clients, followed by skill development activities for self-observation. The lecture further covers the use of space, timing, and concludes with concepts that facilitate good nonverbal communication: congruence, sensitivity, synchrony, mirroring, and staying on topic.
๐ Lecture Summary
COUNSELORโS NONVERBAL COMMUNICATION
Counselors express nonverbal information through eye contact and body movements. Clients often make assumptions about a therapistโs kinesics (body language) based on their own personal experiences, rather than attempting to understand the counselor's unique expression. The counselor's nonverbal communication is strongly related to building the therapeutic relationship.
Nonverbal Pitfalls of the Counselor
Numerous nonverbal behaviors by the counselor can negatively impact the client and the therapeutic relationship.
- Excessive physical closeness at outset of treatment: The client may feel crowded or overwhelmed, or misunderstand the behavior as seductiveness by the counselor.
- Excessive physical distance at outset of treatment: The client may feel rejected or not accepted, perceiving the counselor as arrogant or standoffish.
- Distancing body movements or facial expression: This includes a bored look, yawning, lack of consistent eye contact, crossed arms or legs, or moving the chair away. The client may feel judged, rejected, misunderstood, or perceive the clinician as judgmental or emotionally absent.
- Absent/inconsistent eye contact: The client may feel ignored, not cared for, not attended to, or perceive the clinician as shy, insecure, or distracted.
- Excessive eye contact: The client may feel under scrutiny, uncomfortable, intruded upon, or perceive the counselor as intrusive.
- Creating barriers out of objects (e.g., desk): If the desk between counselor and client is too big, the client may feel rejected, unimportant, or perceive the clinician as aloof.
- Incongruent facial expressions or gestures: This can cause the client confusion, feeling misunderstood, placated, or lied to, and may lead to perceiving the clinician as inconsistent.
- Distracting mannerisms (e.g., twirling hair, playing with an earring, scratching): The client may feel perceived as boring or uninteresting, not attended to, or perceive the clinician as anxious or inattentive.
- Excessively loud voice or rapid speech: The client may feel bossed around, overwhelmed, or perceive the clinician as angry or hostile.
- Excessively low voice or slowed rate of speech: The client may feel insecure about the value of treatment or perceive the clinician as unsure of self.
- Impatient rate of speech, poor timing (e.g., interrupting client): The client may feel perceived as incompetent or unimportant, not feel heard, or perceive the clinician as incompetent or unempathic.
A Touchy SubjectโTouching
Touching a client is very problematic in today's society. Knowing how to touch appropriately is a major concern for counselors. Touch is a powerful way to communicate caring and empathy, but it can also be easily misunderstood, misconstrued, and damaging to the counseling relationship. Touch closes all distance between two individuals. The best rule of thumb for beginning clinicians is to refrain from the impulse to touch, especially early on. If the clinician does not want to refrain, the next-best solution is to ask the client if touch is acceptable. If a client indicates any hint of reticence, the clinician would violate the clientโs personal boundaries through touch.
Skill Development Activity 1
For the next week, listen carefully to the conversation styles of others. Attempt to identify their listening pitfalls and note the consequences. The point is to gain awareness of how pitfalls manifest, starting with others before identifying them in your own listening.
Skill Development Activity 2
Begin to observe yourself in conversations with other people. Evaluate honestly how you listen and pay attention to whether you have any listening pitfalls that get in the way of open and attentive hearing. As you identify your primary pitfalls, make action plans about how to eliminate them.
Use of Space
The two most important aspects of space utilization are distance and position. Observing how clients use personal and environmental space is a useful way to understand them better. Distance refers to the amount of personal space a client appears to require. Some clients need more distance, while others prefer minimum distance. Counselors need to be aware of and accommodate the clientโs space needs as much as possible. Difficulty can arise if the personal space needs of the client and clinician conflict significantly.
Gender and Cultural Differences
Although cultural differences exist that may make the need for personal space somewhat predictable, it is generally best to observe the personal-space needs of each client individually and then attempt to honor and respect those needs. Gender differences may also be observed.
Timing
Timing refers to all time parameters of the session, such as starting and ending on time, as well as the use of time within sessions. It is an important nonverbal means of regulation, helping client and clinician negotiate who speaks when. For example, a clientโs important self-disclosure a few minutes before the end of a session may communicate ambivalence about whether to discuss the topic or may be an attempt to extend the therapy hour. If the counselor extends the session, the nonverbal communication is that the client can manipulate the clinician. If the clinician holds fast to the therapeutic hour, a clear communication is made that the counselor has good personal boundaries.
Concepts facilitating Good Nonverbal Communication
Three important concepts facilitate good nonverbal communication and thus therapeutic rapport: congruence, sensitivity, and synchrony.
Congruence
Congruence refers to the clinician's efforts to keep personal verbal and nonverbal expressions in line with each other. Achieving congruence between what a counselor says and does is critical to good therapeutic rapport.
- Example 1 (Conveyance of comfort): Calm, soothing voice; relaxed posture; open facial expression; saying "Please make yourself comfortable."
- Example 2 (Expression of empathy): Nodding; smiling; inviting gestures; open body posture; verbal expression: "What a frightening experience."
- Example 3 (Matched kinesics and paralinguistics): Congruence in all aspects of expression; appropriate accenting: the counselor may say "Yes, I do understand."
๐ Definition โ Congruence: The clinician's efforts to keep personal verbal and nonverbal expressions in line with each other.
Sensitivity (understanding the client's nonverbal communications)
Sensitivity refers to a mental-health-care provider's ability to receive and understand the client's nonverbal communications. Learning how to interpret the kinesics and paralinguistics (vocal cues like tone, pitch, and rate) of each individual client is a critical component of sensitivity.
๐ Definition โ Sensitivity: The mental-health-care provider's ability to receive and understand the client's nonverbal communications.
Synchrony (matching a clientโs lowered voice and lowered rate of speech)
Synchrony refers to the clinicianโs ability to match or oppose the client's nonverbal expressions as therapeutically indicated. For example, matching a client's lowered voice and slowed rate of speech when the client talks about a sad event will help the client feel heard and understood.
๐ Definition โ Synchrony: The clinicianโs ability to match or oppose the client's nonverbal expressions as therapeutically indicated.
Mirroring Nonverbal Behavior
In a successful, smoothly flowing interview, movement symmetry often occurs between counselor and client. When a client pauses, the counselor nods, and the client then finishes the sentence. This is represented by a โpassingโ of movement back and forth between client and counselor, where both unconsciously assume the same physical posture. Dissynchronous movement can indicate that the interview is on the wrong track. This tool should not be used manipulatively but to increase awareness and insight.
Staying on the Topic
To attend, you must also โlisten.โ For example, if a client states they got anxious while shopping, an attending counselor would focus on that experience (e.g., "You say you wanted to run when you saw your friend. Can you describe the situation in more detail?"), while a nonattending counselor would ignore it (e.g., "Did you get admission in bachelors this year?").
Helpful Behaviors: Nonverbal
Helpful nonverbal behaviors include: tone of voice similar to the helpee, maintaining good eye contact, occasional head nodding, facial animation, occasional smiling, occasional hand gesturing, close physical proximity to the helpee, and a moderate rate of speech.
โญ Key Takeaways
A counselor's nonverbal communication is as important as their verbal responses and directly shapes the therapeutic relationship. Common pitfalls like excessive distance, absent eye contact, or distracting mannerisms can cause clients to feel rejected, judged, or unimportant, while incongruence between words and body language creates confusion and distrust. Key concepts like congruence (matching verbal and nonverbal messages), sensitivity (understanding client cues), and synchrony (matching expressions) are essential for building rapport. Touch is a high-risk intervention that should be avoided early in therapy unless the client explicitly consents. Finally, observing a client's use of space, timing of disclosures, and mirroring behaviors provides valuable insight into their comfort and readiness to engage.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are three potential client reactions to a counselor who maintains excessive physical distance at the start of treatment?
- Explain the difference between sensitivity and synchrony in the context of counselor nonverbal communication.
- Why is touching a client considered a "touchy subject," and what is the recommended alternative to acting on the impulse to touch?
- What might a client's important self-disclosure made just a few minutes before the end of a session communicate nonverbally?
- How can a counselor demonstrate they are "staying on the topic" with their nonverbal and verbal responses?
๐ Lecture 13 โ COUNSELING SKILLS
๐ Overview: This lecture focuses on the critical skill of maintaining congruence between a counselorโs verbal and nonverbal communication. It provides detailed examples of how to align words, tone, and body language to convey specific messages like empathy, warmth, and understanding. Additionally, it introduces the foundational concept of active listening, distinguishing it from mere hearing, and explains its importance and core techniques in the therapeutic relationship.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture first provides practical "hints" for maintaining congruence, offering tables that pair intended communications (e.g., conveying comfort, patience, empathy) with corresponding nonverbal expressions and sample verbalizations. It then transitions to a comprehensive discussion on listening and understanding skills, defining active listening, contrasting it with hearing, and outlining its importance for establishing rapport, trust, and client disclosure. Finally, it lists the key skills for effective listening, including paraphrasing, reflection of feeling, and summarization.
๐ Lecture Summary
HINTS TO MAINTAIN CONGRUENCE
This section concentrates on maintaining congruence between a counselorโs verbal and nonverbal communication. This consistency can be maintained by communicating verbal and nonverbal messages consistently. Several examples are provided to show how to align a counselor's intended communication with their nonverbal expressions and verbalizations.
Intended Communication: Conveyance of Comfort
- Nonverbal Expression: Calm, soothing voice; relaxed posture; open facial expression
- Sample Verbalizations: โThis is a safe place"; "Please make yourself comfortable"
Intended Communication: Conveyance of Patience
- Nonverbal Expression: Slow rate of speech; patient gestures; focused attention
- Sample Verbalizations: โTake your timeโ; โWe have plenty of timeโ
Intended Communication: Welcoming the Client
- Nonverbal Expression: Nodding; smiling; inviting gestures; open body posture
- Sample Verbalizations: โWelcome; please have a seatโ; โIt's nice to see you againโ
Intended Communication: Expression of Empathy
- Nonverbal Expression: Leaning forward; sensitive eye contact; matching nonverbal; sensitive timing; appropriate accenting; facing client
- Sample Verbalizations: โWhat a frightening experienceโ; โIt must have been very difficult time for youโ
Intended Communication: Expression of Understanding
- Nonverbal Expression: Matched paralinguistic and kinesics; appropriate rate of speech; gentle voice; nodding
- Sample Verbalizations: โYes, I do understand.โ
Intended Communication: Expression of Caring
- Nonverbal Expression: Warm, soft voice; connected body posture (open seating and leaning forward); open and relaxed facial expressions
- Sample Verbalizations: โI am so sorry to hear that your mother diedโ; โI truly care about what happened to you.โ
Intended Communication: Expression of Warmth
- Nonverbal Expression: Warm, soft voice; gentle rate of speech; connected body posture; soft facial expressions
- Sample Verbalizations: โYou really deserved this.โ; โYou really need support and guidance from him right now.โ
Intended Communication: Expression of Confusion
- Nonverbal Expression: Open body posture; accenting hand gestures; complementing facial expression (e.g., wrinkled forehead, questioning eyes)
- Sample Verbalizations: โHelp me understand this better...โ ; โNo, I'm not quite clear on that yet.โ
- ๐ Example: The client says that he was not interested in some job, and then says he applied for it. The counselor in such a situation can ask for clarity.
Skill Development Activity 1
- Practice focused attention on people by practicing with friends and family.
- Apply all the skills mentioned before to your day-to-day conversations with people you know well.
- Reflect on: How did you feel in these conversations? Do you notice any changes in responses? Are people aware of what you are doing? How do they feel about it? How do you feel in these conversations? Are you learning more about these people than you used to?
Listening and Understanding Skills
This section defines active listening and distinguishes it from simple hearing.
๐ Definition โ Active Listening: It entails showing understanding by tuning into and reflecting with your verbal, voice and body messages the crux of the meaning contained in the verbal, voice and body messages of clients. This term was popularized by Thomas Gordon in his 1970 book Parent Effectiveness Training. It entails not only understanding a speakerโs communication but also showing that you have understood.
-
A key distinction is made between hearing and listening:
- Hearing involves the capacity to be aware of and to receive sound.
- Listening not only involves receiving sounds, but also, as much as possible, accurately understanding their meaning.
-
Listening in a therapeutic manner means taking in the client's whole story. The first prerequisite to such complete and active listening is the ability to allow a client to speak uninterruptedly, even if the client takes breaks or pauses between words, sentences, or thoughts. Learning not to speak prematurely, in essence interrupting the client's stream of thought, is one of the most important listening skills.
Importance of Active Listening
Active listening is crucial for several reasons:
- Establishing rapport: You are more likely to develop rapport with clients if they feel understood by you.
- Establishing trust: In the face of clients' inevitable mistrust, counselors need to establish their credentials of honesty, integrity and reliability.
- Bridging differences: By showing your understanding you build bridges not walls.
- Helping clients to disclose: Good listening helps clients to feel accepted, safe and understood, which in turn helps them choose to tell stories and share their inner world with you.
- Helping clients to experience feelings: Rewarding listening can help clients to acknowledge their inner flow of emotions.
- Gathering information: Effective listening allows the counselor to collect crucial data from the client.
- Helping clients to assume responsibility: Clients who are listened to sharply are more likely to assume responsibility for working on their problems.
๐ก Why this matters: Active listening is not passive; it is a deliberate, skill-based technique that is foundational for building a therapeutic alliance and facilitating client change.
What are Listening & Understanding Skills?
Following is the list of important Listening and understanding skills:
- Possess an Attitude of Respect & Acceptance
- Tune into the Client's Internal Viewpoint
- Opening remarks
- Open questions
- Paraphrasing
- Reflection of feeling
- Summarization
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical elements from this lecture for exam preparation are understanding how to maintain congruence between verbal and nonverbal messages for specific therapeutic intentions like empathy, warmth, and understanding. You must be able to define active listening and clearly distinguish it from the physical act of hearing. The importance of active listening is paramount; it is the bedrock for establishing rapport, trust, and client disclosure. Finally, you should be able to list and briefly describe the core skills involved in active listening and understanding, such as paraphrasing, reflection of feeling, and summarization.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the central purpose of the "hints" provided at the beginning of the lecture regarding counselor communication?
- Name three specific nonverbal behaviors a counselor should use to convey empathy to a client.
- How does the lecture define "active listening," and which author is credited with popularizing the term?
- What is the key difference between "hearing" and "listening" as described in the lecture?
- List at least four reasons why active listening is considered important in the counseling process.
๐ Lecture 14 โ Listening & Understanding Skills
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental listening and understanding skills essential for effective counseling. It emphasizes the importance of an accepting attitude, empathy, and specific verbal techniques like paraphrasing and reflection to build rapport and understand the client's internal world. Mastering these skills is crucial for creating a safe therapeutic environment and accurately perceiving client concerns.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers an attitude of respect and acceptance, including barriers to this attitude such as anxiety-evoking feelings/clients and trigger words. It details empathy as tuning into the client's internal viewpoint, differentiating between primary and advanced empathy and various levels of empathic response. Finally, it discusses the use of opening remarks and small rewards to encourage client communication.
๐ Lecture Summary
What are Listening & Understanding Skills?
The core skills for active listening and understanding in counseling include possessing an attitude of respect & acceptance, tuning into the client's internal viewpoint, and using verbal techniques. These techniques are opening remarks, open questions, paraphrasing, reflection of feeling, and summarization.
1. Possess an Attitude of Respect & Acceptance
This involves suspending judgment and accepting clients as fallible human beings with rights to their own thoughts and feelings. It does not mean agreeing with everything a client says, but respecting their version of reality. Fromm (1956) notes the word respect comes from the Latin respicere, meaning "to look at," highlighting the ability to prize an individual's unique individuality and allow them to grow on their own terms. Counselors must avoid internal and external barriers like filtering and body cues that tell clients to edit themselves.
๐ Definition โ Respect: The ability to look at others as they are and to prize their unique individuality, allowing them to grow and develop on their own terms without exploitation and control.
Barriers to an Accepting Attitude
- Anxiety-evoking feelings: Clients expressing feelings (e.g., apathy, hostility, grief) that the counselor finds hard to handle.
- Anxiety-evoking clients: Certain categories of clients (e.g., opposite sex, seriously disturbed, very intelligent) that feel threatening to the counselor.
- Current unfinished business: Personal issues (e.g., a recent argument) that interfere with being open to a client.
๐ Example: Counselor Sadaf has intrusive thoughts about her own marital problems, which distracts her from her sessions.
- Trigger words, phrases and attitudes: Emotionally charged words (e.g., sexist or racist comments) that raise a "red flag" for a counselor.
๐ Example: Counselor Imran struggles to control his anger when a client uses the derogatory term "Paki" and voices racist opinions.
- Prejudices: Counselors may have biases related to age, sex, culture, race, social class, or other differences, causing them to "tune out" certain clients.
๐ก Why this matters: These barriers prevent the counselor from being fully present and accepting, which is the foundation of a therapeutic relationship.
2. Empathy: Tuning into the Client's Internal Viewpoint
Responding from the client's internal viewpoint shows an accurate understanding of their perspective, as if you are inside their world. Responding from an external viewpoint comes from the counselor's own perspective or where they think the client should be.
๐ Definition โ Empathy (Rogers, 1961): The ability to enter the clientโs phenomenological world, to experience it as if it were your own without ever losing the โas ifโ quality. It involves perception/understanding and the ability to communicate that understanding.
๐ Definition โ Empathy (Martin, 1983): Communicated understanding of the other personโs intended emotional message. The client must feel that they are understood.
Two Forms of Empathy
- Primary Empathy: Responding to show you have understood the clientโs major themes.
- Advanced Empathy: Exploring themes, issues, and emotions that are below the surface.
Levels of Empathy
- The counselor's responses detract from or do not attend to the client.
- The counselor responds to expressed feelings but subtracts noticeable affect.
- The counselor's response is essentially interchangeable with the client's expression.
- The counselor's response adds noticeably, expressing feelings a level deeper than the client was able to express.
๐ Example: Client: 'I've got this big test coming up and I don't seem to be able to concentrate. I'm worried sick.'
- External Viewpoint: โThis is a case of test anxiety.โ / โYou will be all right on the day.โ
- Internal Viewpoint: โYou're scared because your lack of concentration prevents you from revising.โ
3. Use Opening Remarks & Small Rewards
Counselors use opening remarks to build rapport and encourage clients to share. These can be general invitations or in response to the client's body language. Small rewards are verbal and non-verbal cues (e.g., "Uh-hmm," "I see," "Please continue") that encourage the client to keep talking. These are not evaluative but show the counselor is listening.
๐ Definition โ Small Rewards: Minimal verbal and non-verbal prompts used by a counselor to encourage a client to continue speaking, without making a value judgment on the content.
โญ Key Takeaways
- An accepting, non-judgmental attitude is the bedrock of effective listening. Counselors must actively manage their own barriers like anxiety, trigger words, and unfinished business to remain present.
- Empathy is not just understanding the client; it is the communicated understanding of their internal emotional world, which must be perceived by the client.
- Differentiating between external and internal viewpoints is critical; effective responses reflect the client's reality, not the counselor's opinions or assumptions.
- Use opening remarks and small rewards to build rapport and facilitate client disclosure without leading or evaluating.
- Empathic responses exist on a continuum from simple (primary) to deep (advanced), and the counselor must use the appropriate level for the stage of counseling.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six specific listening and understanding skills listed at the beginning of the lecture?
- List the five specific barriers to an accepting attitude that a counselor must be aware of.
- According to Rogers, what is the crucial "as if" quality that distinguishes empathy from being the client?
- What is the difference between primary empathy and advanced empathy?
- Provide an example of a counselor responding to a client's statement from an external viewpoint, and then rewrite it as an internal viewpoint response.
๐ Lecture 15 โ Listening & Understanding Skills
๐ Overview: This lecture completes the discussion of listening and understanding skills essential for effective counseling. It focuses on the proper use of open questions while identifying problematic question types that counselors must avoid. Understanding these distinctions is critical for building therapeutic rapport and facilitating client self-disclosure.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the remaining listening and understanding skills from the previous session, beginning with a detailed examination of questioning techniques. It distinguishes between problematic question types (suggestive, assumptive, judgmental, attacking, controlling, and closed questions) and their pitfalls, then presents open-ended questions as the preferred approach. The lecture concludes with guidance on purposeful questioning and the transition from closed to open-ended questions.
๐ Lecture Summary
Asking Questions: Open Questions
Questions serve multiple purposes in counseling: to initiate interviews, facilitate communication, motivate self-disclosure, elaborate on topics, shift topics, enhance client awareness, aid diagnosis, and guide the client. However, counselors must distinguish between helpful and harmful question types before mastering open questions.
๐ก Why this matters: The wrong type of question can damage the therapeutic relationship, while well-phrased open questions empower clients to explore their experiences.
Suggestive Questions
๐ Definition โ Suggestive Questions: Questions that give hidden advice disguised as a question, often beginning with stems like "Don't you think...?" "Could you...?" or "Have you ever (considered)...?"
These questions put answers into clients' mouths, even when the counselor is unaware they are giving advice. Counselors must listen with a "third ear" to detect whether their questions are actually suggestions.
๐ Example:
- Counselor: "Have you ever tried talking to your father about your husband's behavior?"
- Client: "No I haven't. Should I?"
Assumptive Questions
๐ Definition โ Assumptive Questions: Questions that give the client the impression the counselor expects a particular answer; statements disguised as questions.
They start with stems like "But you have (haven't)...?" "Do you really...?" "Isn't it?" or "Do (don't) you...?" The client must decide whether to comply with the assumption or contradict the counselor.
๐ Example:
- Counselor: "But you aren't taking drugs yourself?"
- Client: "Not really..... (looks away)"
๐ Comparison:
- Leading question: "She's a great person, isn't she?"
- Open-ended question: "What do you think about her?"
Judgmental Questions
๐ Definition โ Judgmental Questions: Questions that put the client on the defensive or create discomfort.
The prime example is the still-often-used "why did you do that?" which is better phrased as "How did you decide what to do at that point?" While a generalization has occurred that all "why" questions are judgmental, occasional well-planned "why" questions can be appropriate. However, it is best to eliminate them from a counselor's vocabulary as most clients react defensively.
Attacking Questions
๐ Definition โ Attacking Questions: Questions that serve to shame the client or demonstrate the counselor's power over the client; more obvious than judgmental questions.
These questions are perceived by the client as demeaning or embarrassing. Regardless of the counselor's intention, attacking questions must be eradicated from the counselor's repertoire.
๐ Examples:
- "Why are you telling me that?"
- "What is the point of this story?"
- "Aren't you listening to me?"
- "Is that supposed to make sense?"
- "Can't you understand this simple idea?"
Controlling or Intrusive Questions
๐ Definition โ Controlling or Intrusive Questions: Questions that ignore the client's agenda and needs, focusing instead on the desires and wishes of the counselor.
These questions arise from two reasons:
- The counselor is uncomfortable with the conversation topic (e.g., authority figures, divorce, sex)
- The counselor seeks specific details and the focus shifts to a counselor preoccupation (e.g., asking too many intrusive questions about the client's sex life)
Pitfalls of Such Questions:
- The counselor may be perceived as controlling the conversation
- The counselor may block clients from getting in touch with and listening to themselves
- The counselor may set the stage for an interrogation
Closed Questions
๐ Definition โ Closed Questions: Questions that curtail the speaker's options, allowing the client to answer with a simple phrase or yes-no answer.
๐ Comparison:
- Closed-ended question: "Is your relationship good or bad?"
- Open-ended question: "How do you feel about your relationship?"
Pitfalls of Closed Questions:
- The resulting interaction may not be very rich
- Counselors end up doing all the therapeutic work
- Not conducive to collaborative communication
However, closed questions can be useful for collecting information, but counselors should show restraint if they wish to help others share their worlds.
Purposeful Use of Closed Questions:
- During a crisis situation
- When a client is self-disclosing too much too quickly
- When a client is excessively anxious
- When a client's thoughts are racing or overly talkative
Shotgunning
๐ Definition โ Shotgunning: Overly relying on closed questions; a series of closed questions that cover nothing in depth and much in breadth.
The target client is likely to feel bombarded. This kind of interview can go on for hours unless the client gets fed up and leaves.
Open-Ended Questions
๐ Definition โ Open-Ended Questions: Questions that allow clients to share their internal viewpoints without curtailing their options.
Key Principles:
- Questions need to be intentional and purposeful
- Appropriate timing is critical
- Questions shall be perceived as supportive and therapeutic, not judgmental or presumptuous
- The client should not be interrupted, but waiting too long may cause the client to move to another topic
Function: Open-ended questions bring out major data and facilitate conversation. They are especially useful in initial sessions to assist clients in telling why they have come.
Description of Question Words:
- What โ facts
- How โ process or feelings
- Why โ reasons
Change from Closed- to Open-Ended Questions
๐ Examples of transitions:
| Closed Questions | Open-Ended Questions |
|---|---|
| Do you like your mother? | How do you feel about your mother? |
| Do you have a best friend? | What can you tell me about your best friend? |
| Is your apartment new? | Tell me about the place where you live. |
| Were you hospitalized after the accident? | How bad were your injuries? |
โญ Key Takeaways
Counselors must eliminate suggestive, assumptive, judgmental, attacking, and controlling questions from their repertoire as these damage the therapeutic relationship and block client self-disclosure. Closed questions have limited but legitimate uses (crisis, excessive anxiety, overly talkative clients) but should be used sparingly as they make counselors do all the therapeutic work. Open-ended questions using "what" (facts), "how" (process/feelings), and occasionally "why" (reasons) are the most effective for facilitating client self-disclosure and exploring the client's internal viewpoint. The timing and phrasing of questions must be intentional and purposeful, not stemming from counselor discomfort or a need to fill silence. Shotgunningโasking rapid series of closed questionsโmust be avoided as it leaves clients feeling bombarded.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four problematic question types that counselors must avoid, and what is the primary harm caused by each?
- Under what specific circumstances might a counselor appropriately use closed questions?
- What is "shotgunning" and why is it harmful to the counseling process?
- What do "what," "how," and "why" questions each elicit in open-ended questioning?
- How would you rephrase "Do you like your mother?" as an open-ended question, and why is the new phrasing more effective?
๐ Lecture 16 โ Paraphrasing
๐ Overview: This lecture focuses on three core active listening and understanding skills essential for counseling: paraphrasing, reflecting feelings, and summarizing. It explains the techniques, purposes, and nuances of each skill, emphasizing how counselors can accurately understand and respond to both the verbal and emotional content of client messages. Mastery of these skills is fundamental for building therapeutic rapport and facilitating client exploration.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers paraphrasing as a skill for mirroring client verbal content, including examples and tips for effective use. It then delves into reflecting feelings, distinguishing it from paraphrasing and explaining receiver and sender skills, picking up feeling words, handling mixed feelings, and assisting clients in labeling emotions, with categories of feelings for anger, fear, happiness, and sadness. Finally, it introduces summarizing skills, covering basic reflection summaries, and summaries at the end of a session, several sessions, and before termination.
๐ Lecture Summary
Paraphrasing
Paraphrasing is a competent skill for showing understanding in active listening. It involves repeating back the essence of a clientโs words and thoughts using the clientโs main words. The purpose is to check on the clarity of the counselorโs understanding. Paraphrasing must be decided upon some goals (reinforce, clarify, highlight, double-check, etc.). Its function is that it acts as a promoter for discussion. Focusing only on the verbal content of clientโs messages is the first step in learning to respond to their voice, body, and verbal messages, but it excludes understanding of their voices and body messages. Paraphrasing means rewording (not the same words) the speaker's verbal utterances. It is important to paraphrase because you drive people crazy if you parrot them; however, occasionally the same words can be used.
๐ Definition โ Paraphrasing: The skill of repeating back the essence of a client's words and thoughts using the client's main words to check the clarity of the counselor's understanding.
๐ Technique: Reword the clientโs verbal utterances rather than repeating them exactly (parroting). Use the personal pronoun 'you' to indicate reflection of the client's internal viewpoint. Slow down your speech rate to give more time to think.
๐ Example 1 (Using same words):
- Client: I feel terrible.
- Counselor: You feel terrible.
- Client: I heard a noise.
- Counselor: A noise?
๐ Example 2 (Staying close to the language):
- Client: I'm finding swallowing difficult.
- Speech therapist: You're having trouble swallowing.
๐ก Why this matters: A good paraphrase provides mirror reflections that are clearer and more to the point than original statements, helping clients feel understood and leading to appreciative comments like "That's right".
Reflect Feelings
Reflecting feelings is both similar to yet different from paraphrasing. Both are concerned with the meaning of the words. However, paraphrasing is simple mirroring, whereas reflecting feelings is concerned with feelings and emotions. Skilled counselors are very sharp at picking up clients' feelings. Active listening entails showing understanding by tuning into the clientโs viewpoint and reflecting, with your body and voice messages, the feelings of the client.
Clients may send voice and body messages that qualify or negate verbal messages. Reflecting feelings usually involves paraphrasing. However, the language of feelings is not words; feelings are bodily sensations which may then have word labels attached to them. Consequently, paraphrasing alone has distinct limitations. A good reflection of feelings picks up these other messages (voice and body) as well, meaning it entails responding to clients' music and not just their words. To do this, counselor responses incorporate appropriate voice and body messages.
๐ Distinction between Thoughts & Feelings:
- Thought: 'I feel that equality between the sexes is essential,' describes a thought.
- Feeling: 'I feel angry when I see sex discrimination,' labels a feeling.
- Note: "I feel like going home" is not an emotion.
Receiver & Sender Skills in Reflection:
- Receiver skills:
- Understanding clients' verbal and nonverbal messages.
- Taking into account the context of clients' messages.
- Sensing the surface and underlying meanings of clients' messages.
- Sender skills:
- Responding in ways that pick up clients' feeling words and phrases.
- Rewording feelings appropriately, using expressive rather than wooden language.
- Using voice and body messages that significantly neither add to nor subtract from the emotions conveyed.
- Checking the accuracy of your understanding.
Picking up Feeling Words and Phrases: Carkhuff (1980) recommends using your own experiences to identify feelings and emotions. One should get a general impression of what the client is expressing, then use their own experiences to understand the clientโs feelings. The counselor needs to know different feelings associated with one condition (e.g., if a client feels lonely, ask yourself how you feel when lonely โ sad, dejected, perhaps even scared).
- Mirror the intensity of clientโs feelings: Mirror the intensity of clients' feeling words in reflections. For example, a client who had a negative experience might feel 'devastated' (strong intensity), 'upset' (moderate intensity), or 'slightly upset' (weak intensity). You may err on the side of either adding or subtracting intensity.
- Mixed feelings: Sometimes clients may have varying degrees of mixed feelings, ranging from simple opposites (happy/sad) to complex combinations (hurt/angry). Good reflections pick up all key elements of feelings messages.
๐ Example (Mixed feelings):
-
Client: I'm sorry, but relieved not to have got the promotion.
-
Counselor: You're upset, but feel a weight off your shoulders at not being promoted.
-
Client: I both like being with her, yet also like being on my own.
-
Counselor: You appreciate her companionship, but enjoy your own personal space too.
-
Assist labeling of feelings: Sometimes counselors assist clients in finding the right feeling words, going beyond reflecting to helping choose words that resonate for them.
๐ Example (Assisting labeling):
- Client: I don't quite know how to express my reaction to losing my job... possibly angry... upset, that's not quite it... bewildered.
- Counselor: Hurt, anxious, confused, devastated... are any of those words appropriate?
- Client: Devastated, that's what I really feel.
Categories of Feelings: Anger: A range of options regarding the use of appropriate words should be available to counselors. Words can be changed in intensity with the context.
- Mild Feeling: Annoyed, bothered, irritated.
- Moderate Feeling: Disgusted, Harassed, Mad, Provoked, Put upon, resentful, spiteful.
- Intense Feeling: Angry, boiled, burned, contempt, enraged, fuming, furious, hot, infuriated, smoldering, steamed.
Categories of Feelings: Fear:
- Mild Feeling: Apprehensive, concerned, tense, tight, uneasy.
- Moderate Feeling: Afraid, alarmed, anxious, fearful, frightened, shock, threatened, worried.
- Intense Feeling: Desperate, overwhelmed, panicky, petrified, scared, terrified, tortured.
Categories of Feelings: Happiness:
- Mild Feeling: Amused, comfortable, glad, pleased, relieved.
- Moderate Feeling: Delighted, eager, happy, joyful, up.
- Intense Feeling: Bursting, ecstatic, elated, enthralled, excited, terrific, thrilled.
Categories of Feelings: Sadness:
- Mild Feeling: Apathetic, bored, confused, disappointed, discontented, mixed up, resigned, unsure, low.
- Moderate Feeling: Abandoned, discouraged, distressed, down, drained, empty, hurt, lonely, lost, sad, unhappy, weighted.
- Intense Feeling: Anguished, crushed, deadened, depressed, despairing, helpless, humiliated, hopeless, miserable, overwhelmed, smothered, tortured.
Summarizing Skills
Summaries are brief statements of longer excerpts from counseling sessions. They fulfill the following purpose:
- Used to pull together material in a counseling session over a period of time.
- The counselor generally summarizes selected key concepts.
- Summaries are helpful to keep a client moving, to add more data to what has already been given, and to provide structure to a casual random conversation.
Types of summaries:
- Basic reflection summary: These can take place at any stage of counseling. They are short summaries that counselors make after clients have spoken for more than a few sentences. They pull together the main feelings.
๐ Example (Basic reflection summary):
-
Counselor: You feel very unhappy with your boss. You think he does not appreciate you and manipulates people all the time to get his way. Your relationship has got to the point where you speak to each other only when absolutely necessary.
-
Summarizing at the end of a session
-
Summarizing at the end of several sessions
-
Summarizing at the end of counseling process before termination
โญ Key Takeaways
Paraphrasing involves rewording the client's verbal content to check understanding, using the client's key words, and should not be parroting. Reflecting feelings goes beyond paraphrasing to capture the client's emotional state, including nonverbal cues like voice and body messages, and requires the counselor to use both receiver and sender skills to pick up feeling words, mirror intensity, address mixed feelings, and assist in labeling emotions. Counselors must have a broad vocabulary of feeling words categorized by intensity (mild, moderate, intense) for emotions like anger, fear, happiness, and sadness. Summarizing skills, including basic reflection summaries and end-of-session or end-of-process summaries, are used to pull together key concepts from longer client disclosures and provide structure to the session. Mastery of these active listening skills is critical for demonstrating empathy, building rapport, and effectively guiding the counseling process.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the main difference between paraphrasing and reflecting feelings?
- List the four types of summarizing skills mentioned in the lecture.
- According to Carkhuff (1980), what technique can a counselor use to help identify a clientโs feelings?
- Provide an example of a moderate intensity feeling word for the emotion of sadness.
- Why is it important for a counselor to mirror the intensity of a clientโs feeling words in their reflection?