π Lecture 9 β GENES AND EXPERIENCE
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between genes, heredity, and behavior. It covers foundational Mendelian genetics, the structure and function of DNA, and how genetic traits are transmitted, with a special focus on how genetic variability and different inheritance patterns (sex-linked, sex-influenced, and sex-limited traits) shape behavior and survival.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with Mendelian genetics and Mendel's conclusions, then moves to mutations and cell division (meiosis and mitosis). It explains the structure of DNA (Watson-Crick model) and RNA's role in heredity. The summary then covers behavioral genetics, the concepts of dominance and recessiveness, and the impact of genetic variability versus inbreeding. Finally, it details three types of sex-related inheritance: sex-linked, sex-influenced, and sex-limited traits, with examples like colorblindness, baldness, and sickle cell anemia.
π Lecture Summary
Mendelian Genetics:
The lecture begins with Mendelian Genetics, based on the work of Austrian Monk Gregor Mendel who studied sweet peas. In 1866, he concluded that heredity is transmitted by heritable units. When both parents transmit the same trait, it is expressed in the offspring; when they have different genes, a hybrid form is established. Dominant traits are expressed, while recessive traits are inherited but not expressed, appearing only when the offspring gets a recessive gene from both parents. A key conclusion was that experience cannot affect the hereditary unit (genes).
π Definition β Mutation: An inheritable change in the genetic material, not a reshuffling of old gene material. It can be a genetic mutation (change in one gene) or a chromosomal mutation (change in chromosomal combinations).
π Definition β Alleles: The two genes at one location. If the alleles are the same (from both parents), the zygote is homozygous for that gene. If they are different, the gene is heterozygous (one dominant, one recessive).
π Example: After fertilization, cells divide through mitosis, while meiosis is the cell division in parents that produces gametes.
DNA
DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid) is found only in the cell nucleus, is very stable, and self-replicates. It is composed of simple sugars (deoxyribose), phosphates, and four nucleotide bases: Adenine, Guanine, Thymine, and Cytosine. Watson and Crick described the double helix model, where two strands are wound around each other. The bases bond in permanent pairs: Adenine always bonds with Thymine (A-T) , and Guanine always bonds with Cytosine (G-C) .
π Definition β Messenger RNA (mRNA) : Carries the genetic code from the nucleus of the cell to the ribosomes in the cell soma.
π‘ Why this matters: Since DNA does not leave the nucleus, heredity is transferred via RNA. The mRNA transcribes the genetic code, while Transfer RNA (tRNA) transfers the needed amino acids to the ribosomes for protein manufacturing. The kinds of proteins made determine the organism's characteristics (e.g., male/female, human/ape, flower color).
Behaviors and Genes
Behavior genetics aims to identify the genetic basis of behavior. Dominance is the tendency for one trait to express itself, but this can be affected by factors like sex (e.g., the same gene may be dominant for males and recessive for females, as in baldness). The continuous shuffling of chromosomes during reproduction leads to genetic variation in the population, upon which natural selection can work.
π Example: Sickle cell anemia is a condition where red blood cells are shaped like a sickle. The dominant homozygous gene for this condition is fatal in infancy. However, the sickle cell trait was a beneficial selection in malaria-infested areas of Africa, ensuring greater survival. This trait became disadvantageous in colder climates like the USA, where higher oxygen levels are needed.
Genetic variability vs. In breeding
Genetic variability is important because it increases the gene pool, making a wider range of genes available. This increases the chances of transmitting healthier genes and lowers the chances of bad recessive genes expressing themselves. In contrast, inbreeding (e.g., cousin marriages) restricts the gene pool, leading to the expression of behavioral and other defects.
π‘ Why this matters: Genetic variability can (a) lead to the development of a new species through sexual recombinations and natural selection, and (b) ensure the survival of existing species when the environment changes (e.g., African slaves with sickle cell anemia who were heterozygous survived better in cold America).
1. Sex Linked traits
Sex-linked traits are traits located on a gene carried on the X chromosome (also called X-linked). The Y chromosome is small and carries very few genes. Since males have one X and one Y (XY), and females have two Xs (XX), a defective gene on the X is expressed in males because there is no counteracting gene on the Y. In females, the trait is expressed only if both X chromosomes carry it.
π Definition β Sex Linked traits: Traits that follow the distribution of the X chromosome. Examples include Hemophilia, Colorblindness, Huntingtonβs chorea, and Turnerβs syndrome (XO, one missing sex chromosome).
Key characteristics:
- The incidence is higher in males.
- It is never transmitted from male parent to male offspring.
π Example: Colorblindness is transmitted from the motherβs X to sons, where it is expressed. If transmitted to daughters, it remains recessive.
2. Sex Influenced Traits
With sex influenced traits, the trait is inherited and transmitted equally by both sexes, but the sex of the individual determines dominance. A gene may be dominant in one sex and recessive in the other.
π Definition β Sex Influenced traits: Traits where sex determines dominance. Famous examples are white forelock and baldness.
Key characteristics:
- More common in men than women (unlike sex-linked traits, the fatherβs gene is transmitted equally to sons and daughters).
- The trait shows up in men when neither mother nor father shows it (double recessive).
- Shows up in all the sons of a woman who has the trait.
3. Sex Limited
Sex limited traits are expressed in one sex but not the other. These characteristics are carried by sex genes as well as other genes, but they require the right amount of hormones for expression. It is not always complete dominance; it can be incomplete.
π Definition β Sex limited traits: Traits expressed in only one sex. Examples include reproduction (only in females) and growth of hair on ears in men with age. Albinism is more common in males (95%) compared to females (5%), and alkeptonuria (black urine) also occurs more in males.
π Example: Montague (1954) reported that albinism was more common in males, indicating an incomplete sex-limited trait.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture provides the biological foundation for understanding how behavior is shaped by genetics. The most critical points are: (1) Mendel's principles of dominant and recessive traits explain basic inheritance patterns. (2) DNA's double helix structure and its base-pairing rules (A-T, G-C) are the basis for heredity, with RNA acting as the messenger. (3) Genetic variability is essential for species survival, while inbreeding increases the risk of expressing harmful recessive traits. (4) Sex-linked traits are on the X chromosome and are expressed more in males, never passing from father to son. (5) Sex-influenced and sex-limited traits demonstrate that gene expression can vary based on the sex of the organism, requiring hormones for full expression.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four nucleotide bases in DNA, and which ones bond together permanently?
- What is the difference between a homozygous and a heterozygous genotype?
- Why is sickle cell anemia a beneficial trait in some environments but harmful in others?
- Why are sex-linked traits like colorblindness more common in males than females?
- What is the key difference between a sex-linked trait and a sex-influenced trait?
π Lecture 10 β Genes and Experience
π Overview: This lecture explores the fundamental relationship between genetic inheritance and behavior, addressing how genes influence behavior indirectly through proteins and amino acids rather than directly. It introduces the discipline of behavior genetics and examines experimental methods for studying genetic contributions to behavior, including selective breeding studies in animals and the effects of inbreeding on physical and behavioral outcomes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the genetic basis of behavior, explaining that genes act on proteins/amino acids which influence structure and metabolism, and that behavior results from polygenic systems rather than single genes. It discusses experimental studies using genetic manipulation through artificial selection, including Tryon's maze-bright and maze-dull rat experiments, Cooper and Zubeck's environmental enrichment studies, Dobzhansky and Benzer's pioneering work on Drosophila, and the effects of inbreeding on physical and behavioral deficits in both animals and humans.
π Lecture Summary
Genetic Basis of behavior
Genes do not act directly on behavior; instead, they act on proteins/amino acids, which are responsible for the structure and metabolism of the organism. Behavior geneticists agree on two key points: a) environment and experience are important as they interact with genetic material, and researchers try to pinpoint how much each contributes to behavior; b) a single gene at a single location cannot lead to one behavior. Behavior is the sum total of different genes at different loci β it is not an all-or-none characteristic. It is always a combination of different genes, forming polygenic systems.
π Definition β Behavior genetics: The discipline that studies how much genes contribute to behavior, recognizing that both genetic and environmental factors interact.
Experimental Studies: Genetic Manipulation
Experimental studies manipulate genes using artificial selection and other conditions in animals reared in labs. Environmental conditions in the laboratory are held constant (temperature, day/night cycle, food, social environment). Researchers select specific traits of interest, follow them up, mate animals with those characteristics, and then follow and test progenies (offspring) for behavioral and other characteristics.
Behavioral geneticists measure and test behavior of interest in laboratory animals by taking the characteristics of interest, testing animals, and carefully examining their scores/performance. Animals scoring on both extremes β the High and Low scorers β are separated from the group. Low scorer females and low scorer males are mated, and the same procedure is carried out for high scorers. The progenies develop into two separate populations through repeated selective testing and mating. This technique has been used as early as the 1930s.
Tryon (1934) Experiment
Tryon carried out an experiment at the University of Berkeley where he bred maze bright rats (who did extremely well on maze tests) and maze dull rats (who made many errors in mazes) for 21 generations. By the 8th generation, he found no overlap in the two populations. To rule out the possibility that results were due to rearing (bright mothers rearing bright offspring), he designed an experimental cross fostering design in which maze bright offspring were reared by maze dull parents; they still made significantly fewer errors. Similarly, using the same procedure, dull rats were reared by bright rats. Since then, many behaviors such as open field activity, alcohol and morphine preference have been identified using such designs.
π‘ Why this matters: Behavior is complex with multiple variables. There is not just one single gene for maze running β there are many cues involved. Further, Searle (1949) reported that when comparing the two groups across 30 different tests, maze bright rats were superior in performance and less emotional. Therefore, the better learner may learn because of greater emotional stability, not because they are more intelligent!
π Example: Tryon's cross fostering experiment β Maze bright offspring reared by maze dull parents still made significantly fewer errors than maze dull offspring, demonstrating that genetic factors, not just maternal rearing, contributed to maze learning ability.
Environment Effects: Cooper and Zubeck (1958)
Cooper and Zubeck raised maze bright/dull rats in three different environments: a) impoverished environment (cage made from wire netting with groups living together), b) stimulating and enriched housing with wire netting, group housing, plus toys and ramps for animals to play with. Their findings showed that maze dull rats perform similarly to maze bright rats if reared in a stimulating environment.
Further, Bennett, Diamond, Krech and Rozenweig (1964) found that rats in richer environments have thicker cortices, meaning their brain development is affected by early stimulation.
π Example: Maze dull rats in enriched environments performed as well as maze bright rats, demonstrating that environmental enrichment can compensate for genetic disadvantages in maze learning.
Dobzhansky and Benzer's Work on Drosophila
The foremost names in genetics and behavior are Theodosius Dobzhansky and Seymour Benzer. Their pioneering work on Drosophila (fruitfly) involved taking a genetically heterogeneous population and, through selective breeding, creating new breeds to show that behavior is genetically linked. Much work was needed to identify which behaviors were linked to which genes and located on which chromosome. Constant selection had to be maintained, or the genetic pool could break down, genes could reassort, and the effort could be wasted (the behavior under observation could get lost). A simple careless mistake of a stray fly entering the experimental breeding cage could ruin the results.
In Dobzhansky and Benzer's experiments, gene material was changed through radiation and bioengineering manipulations. They developed mutants including:
- Sluggish (slow movers)
- Hyperkinetic (very fast movers who died soon because they consumed more oxygen and had faster body metabolism)
- Non-climbers (those who could not climb against gravity)
- Easily shocked (goes into seizure)
- Negatively phototactic (those who move away from light source β normal flies move towards light)
Studies on Dogs and Mice
John Paul Scott at his laboratory in Bar Harbor, Maine, identified dogs for characteristics. The beagle breed (Snoopy dog of the cartoons) became the model for hyperactivity.
Mouse strains were identified and bred for different characteristics: aggressive behaviors, alcoholics vs. nonalcoholic, hoarders vs. non-hoarders, emotionality (defecate in a novel situation), and waltzing mice (inner ear defect). All of this is a consequence of inbreeding.
Inbreeding
Inbreeding is simply defined as repeatedly using the same gene pool, which leads to expression of recessive genes that may carry both behavioral and physical defects.
π Definition β Inbreeding: Repeated use of the same gene pool, leading to expression of recessive genes that may carry both behavioral and physical defects.
π Example: Theisen (1972) reported that death rate in children below 10 years of age is 24 per 1000 in normal population. In interrelated marriages (cousin marriages), it rises to 81 per 1000. In closer marriages, the rate rises even more. Other serious effects include: physically less capable, weaker, and age when they walked and talked was much later than normals (showing developmental lags). Other deficits reported include lower intelligence scores, with lower verbal scores, and language scores even lower than normals.
π‘ Why this matters: It is well documented that if the gene pool is reduced, more recessive disorders show up. Larger gene pools lead to healthier and longer-surviving offspring that can compete in a wide range of environments.
β Key Takeaways
Behavior is not determined by single genes but by polygenic systems where multiple genes at different loci combine to produce complex behaviors. The interaction between genes and environment is critical β as demonstrated by Cooper and Zubeck's finding that maze dull rats raised in enriched environments perform as well as maze bright rats, and Bennett et al.'s discovery that environmental enrichment produces thicker cortices. Experimental genetic manipulation through selective breeding (Tryon, 1934) and radiation/bioengineering (Dobzhansky and Benzer) has demonstrated clear genetic links to behaviors including maze learning, activity levels, phototaxis, and emotionality. Cross fostering designs rule out environmental rearing effects, confirming genetic contributions. Inbreeding consistently produces recessive genetic defects leading to higher mortality, developmental delays, and lower cognitive abilities, while larger gene pools promote healthier offspring.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why can a single gene at a single location not produce a specific behavior, and what term describes the system of multiple genes contributing to behavior?
- What was Tryon's cross fostering experiment, and what did it demonstrate about genetic versus environmental contributions to maze learning?
- How did Cooper and Zubeck's (1958) environmental enrichment study challenge the interpretation that maze bright and maze dull rats differ purely in intelligence?
- What behavioral mutants did Dobzhansky and Benzer create in Drosophila through radiation and bioengineering manipulations?
- According to Theisen (1972), what specific deficits occur in children from interrelated marriages compared to the normal population?
π Lecture 11 β Genes and Experience
π Overview: This lecture explores the biological basis of behavior through the lens of genetics, examining how genes influence behavior and how genetic abnormalities can lead to behavioral defects. It covers Mendelian genetics, the Watson-Crick model, behavioral genetics, and the effects of inbreeding versus hybrid vigor, while detailing specific genetic disorders and chromosomal abnormalities that affect human behavior and development.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the biological systems and genetic basis of behavior, including Mendelian genetics, the Watson-Crick model of DNA, the discipline of behavior genetics, inbreeding studies and their consequences, hybrid vigor, behavioral defects due to single gene defects (PKU, Tay-Sach's disease, Huntington's chorea, Alzheimer's), chromosomal abnormalities (Downs syndrome, Klienfelters syndrome, Turner's syndrome, XYY syndrome, Lesch-Nyhan syndrome), twin study methodologies (monozygotic vs dizygotic), adoption studies, and the genetic basis of schizophrenia with supporting twin and foster child research.
π Lecture Summary
Objective: To understand the Brain behavior relationships from the perspectives of biological systems
This lecture introduces students to biological systems, their genetic basis, and similarities with other animals. It covers Mendelian Genetics, the genetic programming of behavior, the Watson-Crick Model of DNA, similarities and differences between species including humans, and how much genes contribute to behavior through the discipline of Behavior Genetics.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the genetic basis of behavior helps distinguish between inherited and environmental influences on human development and psychopathology.
Inbreeding
Adams and Neal (1967) studied children of very close genetic relationships (incestuous). Among 18 such cases, 5 died, 2 were mentally retarded, and only 7 out of 18 were normal physically and otherwise. In the control group, only 1 case had problems, with 17 out of 18 normal. Restricting the gene pool leads to serious aftereffects.
Sociobiology of incest: Barash (1977) states that "close breeding reduces the fitness of the participants because of the reduced viability of the offspring produced. Incest taboo has genetic predispositions." Natural selection pressures work on gene pools; if gene pools are reduced, fewer genes are available and bad genes show up.
Hybrid vigor: When two different gene pools are mated, their offspring is stronger with greater chances of survival in animals (horses, dogs, cows), birds, vegetables, flowers, or people of Asia.
Behavioural Defects Due To Genes
The following behaviours and genes have shown to be linked to behavioral defects.
Deficiencies Due To Single Gene Defects
In some cases, a defect in one gene at one locus affects total behavior. Several specific disorders are discussed.
Phenylketonuria (PKU): This is characterized by mental retardation and queer smelling urine, identified as the presence of phenyl pyruvic acid in urine. This is an amino acid disorder. Asbjorn Folling (1934), an Austrian dentist, first noticed it in two of his children with symptoms of vomiting, irritability, seizures, and hyperactivity. This is due to inheritance of a double recessive gene for this disorder as parents are homozygous. This disorder completely upsets the biochemical pathway, creating toxins that damage the brain irreversibly. There is irreversible brain damage due to buildup of phenylpyruvic acid and byproducts (toxin). Hospital checks immediately after birth are needed; if results are positive, babies are placed on a controlled diet to reduce damage. Timing of treatment is important, especially when the brain is developing rapidly. Diamond and colleagues (1997) showed that early control reduces but does not completely eliminate cognitive deficits similar to prefrontal damage.
π Definition β Phenylketonuria (PKU): A genetic disorder caused by a double recessive gene involving an amino acid metabolism defect leading to buildup of phenylpyruvic acid, causing irreversible brain damage and mental retardation.
π Formula: Controlled diet after birth β Reduced (but not eliminated) cognitive deficits
π Example: Folling (1934) identified PKU in two children with vomiting, irritability, seizures, and hyperactivity. Immediate hospital screening after birth allows for dietary intervention to minimize brain damage during rapid brain development.
Tay-Sach's disease: This is infantile and juvenile cerebral lipdosis or amauratic idiocy. It is a defect in lipid metabolism due to a double recessive gene at a single locus, meaning both parents are carriers. This is found mainly in Eastern European Ashkenazi Jewish families. Individuals homozygous for this gene do not survive.
The infantile form is found mainly at a few months of age (during the 1st year); symptoms include motor weakness, blindness (cherry red spot in the retina), and mental deterioration. Death occurs in 1-3 years. The juvenile form is found at around 2-10 years of age with similar symptoms: optic atrophy, blindness, paralysis, mental deterioration, eventually death.
π Definition β Tay-Sach's disease: A genetic lipid metabolism defect caused by a double recessive gene, primarily found in Ashkenazi Jewish families, leading to blindness, motor weakness, mental deterioration, and death.
π Example: Infantile form presents at a few months with cherry red spot in the retina and mental deterioration, with death within 1-3 years.
Huntington's chorea: This is characterized by progressive degeneration both physical and mental. This is due to a dominant gene transmitted to males only. The cortex and Basal ganglia are affected. Damage to the cortex results in dementia (forgetting), and damage to the Basal ganglia leads to involuntary jerky movements. Drugs are given to control movements. The onset of symptoms is between 30-50 years, with death occurring between 5-20 years with rapid progression of deterioration.
π Definition β Huntington's chorea: A progressive degenerative disorder caused by a dominant gene affecting the cortex and basal ganglia, leading to dementia and involuntary jerky movements, with onset between 30-50 years.
π Example: A male inherits the dominant gene; symptoms begin in their 30s-40s with dementia (cortex damage) and jerky movements (basal ganglia damage), progressing to death within 5-20 years.
Alzheimer's disease: Genetic transmission is shown to occur especially in cases where it shows up in young individuals. Chances increase if a close relative has it. The case of Hannah's heirs: a Jewish mother from Russia had it, and 5 out of 8 children developed Alzheimer's during their late 40s.
Chromosomal Abnormalities
The abnormalities which occur due to defects in the chromosome and follow the transmission of the chromosome are several.
Downs Syndrome (mongolism): In a normal human there are 23 pairs of chromosomes (23 from mother and 23 from father), totaling 46 chromosomes. However, in some cases there is an additional chromosome adding up to 47 chromosomes. There is a trisomy (instead of two, there are three chromosomes) at pair number 21. This can sometimes occur at pair number 15 (pair number 21 intermingled with #15 during sex cell formation, and #15 carries an extra #21). The older the age of the mother, the more chances of Downs syndrome in the child. Therefore, amniocentesis is routinely required to test for this to prepare parents and advise them.
π Definition β Downs Syndrome: A chromosomal abnormality involving trisomy at chromosome pair 21 (47 total chromosomes), causing developmental delays, with increased risk associated with older maternal age.
Klienfelters Syndrome (XXY): This is a genetic anomaly related to the sex chromosome. One extra X is transmitted to an otherwise normal male pattern β a male with female characteristics or a masculinized female. There is atrophy of reproductive ducts, sometimes mental retardation and some personality problems (not in all cases).
π Definition β Klienfelters Syndrome: A sex chromosome anomaly (XXY) where an extra X chromosome is present in males, causing female characteristics, reproductive duct atrophy, and sometimes mental retardation.
Turner's syndrome: This involves a missing sex chromosome. There is only one X chromosome. These are females with short stature and undeveloped ovaries. They have normal intelligence but are deficient in spatial discrimination (spatial discrimination β space-form blindness β cannot copy figures right). Hypothesis: this trait may be sex-linked.
π Definition β Turner's syndrome: A chromosomal anomaly with a missing sex chromosome (XO), resulting in short stature, undeveloped ovaries, and spatial discrimination deficits.
XYY Syndrome: This is also a chromosomal anomaly where an additional Y chromosome is attached to the normal male pair. These males are taller, muscular, and sturdy, slightly retarded. The extra Y increases maleness and aggression. Research on jail inmates with aggressive, brutal crimes (Jarvick, 1973) found incidence of 2-13% in jail population compared to about 1% in normal population.
π Definition β XYY Syndrome: A chromosomal anomaly with an extra Y chromosome, associated with tall stature, muscular build, slight retardation, and increased aggression.
π Example: Jarvick (1973) found 2-13% incidence of XYY in jail populations (aggressive criminals) versus 1% in the general population.
Lesch-Nyhan syndrome: This is due to a recessive gene carried on the X chromosome, found only in males. Symptoms include Cerebral palsy, involuntary movements of the limbs, hands, feet, and facial muscles, and self-mutilation of lips, mouth, and fingers. This is due to an enzyme deficiency with extreme overproduction of uric acid. Self-mutilation is due to increased Dopamine B-hydroxylase in plasma.
π Definition β Lesch-Nyhan syndrome: An X-linked recessive genetic disorder found only in males, characterized by cerebral palsy, involuntary movements, self-mutilation, and overproduction of uric acid.
Behavioural Characteristics
Studies have used monozygotic (MZ) twins (same egg, same sperm, same time fertilization) and dizygotic (DZ) twins (different eggs, different sperms, same time of fertilization) to identify behavioral defects due to gene defects. Genetic influences on human behavior utilize twin studies paradigm: MZ twins have 100% genes common, and DZ twins are like other siblings with 50% genes in common.
Monozygotic and dizygotic twin studies follow many different methodologies, from comparing those reared together in the same environment to those reared apart in different environments (adoption/foster parents).
In adoption studies, if behavior is similar to that of the biological parents, then behavior is due to genes; however, if behavior was similar to adopted parents, then behavior can be attributed to the effects of environment. Comparisons of performances of related and unrelated individuals are made on a wide range of tests. The behavior geneticist estimates how much is due to gene (genetic variation) and environment (environmental variation).
In studying genetic basis of behavior (especially complex behaviors), it must be remembered that: a) more than one characteristic makes up a trait, and b) these traits are continuous (in gradations of more/less) such as I.Q., schizophrenia, alcoholism. Therefore, the task of the behavioral geneticist is not easy. However, studies have identified genetically transmitted mental illness and other disorders.
Schizophrenia
Twin Studies: Schizophrenia is a genetically inherited disorder as evidenced by multiple research studies. The incidence of schizophrenia in the general population is 1%. This rises if there is a close relative with schizophrenia: with siblings and dizygotic twins this rises to 10-15%, and the expectancy of schizophrenia if one parent has it is about the same (10-15%). However, if both parents have it, the expectancy rises to 40-65%. Schizophrenia is due to chemical, neural, and biological imbalances created by genetic codes. These imbalances could be due to inheritance of a) a recessive gene from both parents, or b) a dominant gene from one parent who has this disorder. A review of 17 studies from 1928 to 1972 from all over the world showed that the highest incidence is among MZ twins and lower among DZ twins.
π Definition β Schizophrenia: A genetically inherited mental disorder involving chemical, neural, and biological imbalances, with incidence rising from 1% in general population to 40-65% when both parents have the disorder.
π Example: Rosenthal's (1959) study on MZ twins with schizophrenia reported 60% presence in concordant twins; males had later age of onset and more favorable outcome. Inouye (1961) studied 3 groups of MZ twins in Japan: chronic schizophrenia 17/23 (74% concordant), mild transient 9/23 (39% concordant).
Foster child studies: The classic study by Heston (1966) followed 50 children born to schizophrenic mothers and separated within a few days after birth. For controls, he took 50 children born to normal mothers. There was a higher incidence of schizophrenia/personality disorder and other abnormalities in 47 out of 50 children of schizophrenic mothers. There were 5 schizophrenics, 4 mentally retarded, 9 antisocial, and 13 with neurotic personalities. In controls, there were only 2 with personality disorders and 7 with neurotic personalities.
Thus, there is strong evidence to link schizophrenia with genes transmitted to offspring. Research in more recent years has also shown the same (see Pinel page 463-464).
π Example: Heston (1966) found 5 schizophrenics, 4 mentally retarded, 9 antisocial, and 13 neurotic among 50 children of schizophrenic mothers raised apart, compared to only 2 personality disorders and 7 neurotic in controls born to normal mothers.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture include the distinction between single gene defects (PKU, Tay-Sach's, Huntington's) and chromosomal abnormalities (Downs, Turner's, Klienfelters, XYY), with specific mechanisms and inheritance patterns for each. Students must understand the twin study paradigm β that MZ twins share 100% genes while DZ twins share 50% β and how adoption studies separate genetic from environmental influences. The relationship between inbreeding (increased recessive disorders) and hybrid vigor (stronger offspring from diverse gene pools) is essential. For schizophrenia, the data showing 1% general population incidence rising to 10-15% with one affected parent and 40-65% with two affected parents provides critical evidence for genetic transmission. Finally, the importance of timing in treatment (as with PKU's controlled diet during rapid brain development) demonstrates the interaction between genetic predispositions and environmental interventions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the key differences between monozygotic and dizygotic twins in terms of genetic similarity, and how are they used to study genetic influences on behavior?
-
Describe the genetic mechanism, symptoms, and treatment window for Phenylketonuria (PKU).
-
What are the five chromosomal abnormalities discussed in this lecture, and what is the specific chromosomal defect for each?
-
According to twin and foster child studies, what is the evidence for genetic transmission of schizophrenia, and what are the specific incidence rates?
-
Explain the concept of hybrid vigor and why inbreeding leads to increased behavioral and physical defects, citing the Adams and Neal (1967) study.
π Lecture 12 β Genes and Experience
π Overview: This lecture explores the genetic basis of higher-order behaviors, focusing on intelligence and alcoholism as case studies. It examines the complex interplay between genetic inheritance and environmental influences, highlighting how both factors contribute to behavioral outcomes. The lecture critically evaluates research methods in behavior genetics and raises important questions about how we define and measure inherited traits.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a discussion of behavioral characteristics, specifically intelligence, tracing the historical views from Galton and Darwin through the eugenics movement. It then examines environmental influences on intelligence, presenting evidence from twin studies and cross-cultural research. The lecture concludes with an analysis of alcoholism as a genetically-linked trait, supported by longitudinal and adoption studies, while acknowledging the ongoing challenge of separating genetic from environmental effects.
π Lecture Summary
Behavioral Characteristics
This section continues the discussion on the genetic basis of higher-order behaviors, building on the previous lecture's analysis of schizophrenia as a disorder with strong genetic underpinnings. The lecture then turns to intelligence, noting that Sir Francis Galton and Charles Darwin were first cousins who both pioneered new ways of thinkingβGalton laid the foundation of statistics while Darwin developed evolutionary theory.
Galton's study of "famous English men" found that genius appears hereditary, but environmental influences cannot be ruled out. Upper-class families and royalty provided "better breeding grounds" for training children to take on important assignments, similar to training a crown prince. The lecture cites the Huxley family as an example: Sir Julian Huxley (biologist) and Aldous Huxley (writer) were both grandsons of Thomas Henry Huxley and great-grandsons of Leonard Huxley, suggesting genius "runs in the family."
The lecture introduces John Noyes, who started a movement called Eugenics, which propagated that scientific breeding can produce brilliant offspring leading to perfectionism. Noyes initiated a complex system of community living with highly educated, well-to-do professionals. Of the 57 children born in this community, only 6 of 58 died (including one mother), compared to a mortality rate of 45 in the general population. The surviving children later started corporations and hospitals that became the basis of present-day entrepreneurship and business in the US.
The view that intelligence is inherited remains controversial due to several issues: how is intelligence defined? How is it measured? Intelligence is a "sum total of many abilities." While these may be inherited, evidence shows that environmental stimulation makes a difference, particularly early stimulation. It is well documented that Black children who performed poorly on IQ tests, when coached on test-taking skills, showed score improvements of as much as 20 points. This coaching is more effective when children are younger.
π Definition β Eugenics: A movement promoting scientific breeding to produce brilliant offspring, leading to human perfectionism.
π‘ Why this matters: The eugenics movement represents a historically significant but ethically problematic attempt to apply genetic principles to human behavior, raising profound questions about the relationship between genetics, environment, and social policy.
π Example β Huxley Family: Sir Julian Huxley (biologist) and Aldous Huxley (writer), both grandsons of Thomas Henry Huxley and great-grandsons of Leonard Huxley, demonstrating apparent heritability of intellectual achievement across generations.
Environmental Influences
Environmental influences can significantly affect intelligence. If the same individual is tested again after several years, it is possible to gain about 20 points on IQ tests. This raises the question: does this mean IQ actually increased, or was the initial test inaccurate?
In Israel, children living in the Kibbutz (separate from their parents) showed interesting patterns. Children of European descent had IQ scores above 100 points, whereas children of Oriental/African descent scored 80-90 points. However, after 4-5 years in the Kibbutz environment, their scores became similar, demonstrating the powerful effect of shared environment.
Twin studies provide compelling evidence for genetic influences on intelligence. Monozygotic (MZ) twins reared together showed a correlation of r = .92 on IQ scores, which is the same correlation found for height, weight, and school achievement. When MZ twins are reared separately, the correlation drops to r = .88 for IQ, and school achievement correlation falls to r = .66. For dizygotic (DZ) twins and siblings, correlations are lower, and for unrelated individuals, the correlation of IQ falls to r = .25.
π Definition β Monozygotic (MZ) twins: Identical twins sharing 100% of their genetic material.
π Definition β Dizygotic (DZ) twins: Fraternal twins sharing approximately 50% of their genetic material, similar to regular siblings.
π Formula β IQ Correlation Pattern: MZ together (r = .92) > MZ apart (r = .88) > DZ/siblings > unrelated (r = .25), showing both genetic and environmental contributions to intelligence.
π Example β Kibbutz Study: European-descent children initially scored >100 IQ points, African/Oriental-descent children scored 80-90 points; after 4-5 years in the same environment, scores equalized, demonstrating environmental influence on intelligence.
Critical thinking about intelligence testing
The lecture poses two critical questions about intelligence testing:
- Is intelligence influenced by culture?
- Do intelligence tests measure innate intellectual capacities or cultural learning?
These questions highlight the fundamental challenge in separating genetic from environmental contributions to intelligence, as test performance inevitably reflects both inherited abilities and culturally acquired knowledge.
π‘ Why this matters: These questions challenge the validity of IQ tests as pure measures of innate intelligence, suggesting that cultural bias in testing may confound attempts to study genetic influences on intelligence.
Alcoholism
Alcoholism is another trait shown to be genetically linked, particularly transmitted from father to sons. Longitudinal studies in Scandinavian countries by Goodwin and colleagues (1979) followed children in foster homes through records. The research reported that predisposition to alcoholism is 4 times higher in males.
Research by Schukit, Goodman, and Winokur (1972) examined alcoholism in half-sisters or half-brothers with an alcoholic parent. When subjects lived with their alcoholic biological parent, the rate of alcoholism was 46%. Interestingly, even when they did not live with alcoholic biological parents, the rate remained the same at 46%. However, if foster parents were alcoholic (but not biological parents), the frequency was much lower, about 15%.
Animal studies also support genetic influences. In one study, rats showed a genetic predisposition to opiate addiction. Rats were found to be "fond of morphine" and preferred it over water after tasting it for the first time, suggesting a biological vulnerability to addiction.
π Definition β Alcoholism: A behavioral disorder characterized by compulsive alcohol consumption, shown to have genetic links particularly transmitted from father to sons.
π Definition β Longitudinal study: A research method that follows the same individuals over an extended period of time to observe developmental changes and outcomes.
π Example β Goodwin et al. (1979): Scandinavian longitudinal study following children in foster homes; found predisposition to alcoholism is 4 times higher in males with alcoholic biological fathers.
π Example β Schukit, Goodman & Winokur (1972): Half-siblings with an alcoholic biological parent showed 46% alcoholism rate whether or not they lived with that parent; with alcoholic foster parents (no biological link), rate was only 15%.
π Example β Rat opiate study: Rats showed genetic predisposition to morphine preference, preferring it over water after first taste, suggesting biological vulnerability to addiction.
The lecture concludes that "we still have a lot of research to do before we can separate clearly the effects of environment or environment [and genetics]," and this research is ongoing given the large number of variables involved.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that both intelligence and alcoholism have significant genetic components, but environmental factors play crucial and often underestimated roles. Twin studies reveal that identical twins show higher IQ correlations than fraternal twins or unrelated individuals, though the correlation decreases when twins are reared apart, highlighting environmental influences. The dramatic improvement in IQ scores following coaching and the equalization of scores among children from different cultural backgrounds in the Kibbutz show that environmental stimulation can substantially modify intellectual outcomes. For alcoholism, adoption studies reveal that having an alcoholic biological parent increases risk to 46% regardless of whether the child lives with that parent, while having only alcoholic foster parents yields only 15% risk, demonstrating strong genetic predisposition. The lecture critically questions whether intelligence tests measure innate capacity or cultural learning, emphasizing that behavior genetic research remains complex and ongoing due to the numerous interacting variables involved.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What was the IQ correlation for monozygotic twins reared together versus reared apart, and what does this difference tell us about genetic versus environmental influences on intelligence?
-
In the Kibbutz study, what were the initial IQ differences between children of European versus Oriental/African descent, and what happened after 4-5 years in the same environment?
-
According to Schukit, Goodman, and Winokur's (1972) study, what was the rate of alcoholism in half-siblings with an alcoholic biological parent (regardless of living arrangement) compared to those with alcoholic foster parents only?
-
What two critical questions does the lecture raise about intelligence testing, and why are these questions important for understanding genetic influences on behavior?
-
What was John Noyes' eugenics experiment, what were its outcomes, and what historical significance does it have for the study of genes and behavior?