๐ Lecture 05 โ Evolutionary and Genetic Basis of Behaviour
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the evolutionary and genetic foundations of behavior, tracing the development of the human brain and species from a biological perspective. It examines key evolutionary theories, taxonomic classification, and the distinctive characteristics of Homo sapiens, while also addressing the nature-nurture debate through ethological and sociobiological lenses. Understanding these concepts is critical for linking brain development to behavioral changes across species.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the brain-behavior relationships from biological systems, the theory of evolution and its developmental process, evolution of Homo sapiens, brain development and behavior changes, genetic programming of behavior, similarities and differences between species, taxonomic classification of animals, the phyletic scale, species-specific traits, and historical evolutionary theories including those of Linneas, Buffon, Lamark, Lysenko, and Darwin. It also touches on the nature-nurture debate between ethologists/sociobiologists and experimentalists.
๐ Lecture Summary
Evolutionary and genetic basis of Behavior
These lectures take students through the evolution of the brain, evolution of mammalian species, and the evolution of man, linking these to brain development. Classification on the phylogenetic scale reveals similarities across the scale. The development of the concept of evolution includes Lamarkian and Darwinian theories, concepts of natural selection, survival of the fittest, speciation, and adaptation. Gene transmission is explained through the Watson and Crick model of the double helix, detailing the components of genetic material and the process of transmission. The lecture also addresses the nature-nurture debate with ethologists and sociobiologists (based on Darwinian evolution) and experimentalists.
๐ Definition โ Phylogenetic scale: a scale ordered in terms of differential characteristics across species, showing evolutionary relationships.
Man: defined in biological terms as Homosapien
Man, biologically defined as Homosapien, is a comparatively newly evolved species with a biological presence of not more than 50,000 years. There are several distinctive characteristics of the homosapien:
a) The only animal with an upright walk and true bipedalism. This is an extremely complex development requiring changes in the pelvic bones, vertebral column, cranium placement on top of the vertebral column, and visual system. Man can cover long distances without losing stamina or strength to hunt.
b) Language as an โintegrated systemโ. It is a more learned, more refined communication system where combinations of sounds and intonations are used in a sophisticated manner. All cultures and tribes have their own language. Humans have a specialized cortical area for language.
c) Specialized hunter-gatherer roles differentiating according to biological functions for male-females. Females have greater responsibility for looking after offspring and stay with the young while males foraged.
d) Domestication of other animals' specialized abilities to benefit his survival (camels, horses, cows, dogs, chickens).
e) Highly evolved and complex societies.
f) Kills own species without biological benefit โ warfare and murder in other animals is species-specific for survival purposes only.
g) Highly evolved abstract thinking, aesthetics, tools, painting in primitive caves. However, Homo sapiens is similar to other biological species as can be seen through taxonomic classification.
๐ก Why this matters: These distinctive characteristics explain how human behavior and brain function differ from other species while still sharing fundamental biological structures and evolutionary origins.
Taxonomic Classification
All animals in the animal kingdom are categorized into this classification, which categorizes animals from general to specific. For Homo sapiens, the classification works as follows:
- Kingdom โ Animalia: most general, all animals on the face of the earth
- Phylum: Chordata (notochord, pharyngeal gill slits)
- Subphylum: Vertebrata (vertebral column)
- Class: Mammalia (vertebrates that bear their young and suckle them โ humans belong to this category)
- Order: Primate (what they forage/hunt โ flesh/vegetable eating)
- Family: Hominids (for humans)
- Genus: Homo
- Species: Sapien
๐ Definition โ Species: Basic to classifying animals, usually clear and apparent difference between species. Species don't interbreed in naturally occurring circumstances, not because they are incapable of doing so but for reasons unknown (answers lie in genetic fitness). Cross mating is not biologically beneficial as genes are not propagated further โ biologically, this is not a fit response. The case of cross breeding of Horse and ass equals mule (sterile) โ fit for human as beast of burden but not for either species as this would end the genes of both the horse, the ass, and the mule.
๐ Definition โ Species specific: Differences in appearance, shape, and form. For example, horse, donkey, and zebra come from the same family EQUUS but are different species. All three are herbivorous with similarities in behavior and appearance yet there are differences โ a horse may kick like a donkey but is more territorial.
๐ Definition โ Phyletic scale: a scale ordered in terms of differential characteristics.
๐ Example: Horse-donkey-zebra example โ Horse, donkey, and zebra all belong to the same family EQUUS, all are herbivorous with similar behaviors and appearances, yet they are different species. They do not naturally interbreed because cross-mating is not biologically beneficial. When cross-breeding does occur (horse + ass = mule), the offspring is sterile, meaning genes from both parents are not propagated further.
Evolution of Evolutionary theories
๐ Linneas: believed that animals were created as one act of creation, and that species were fixed and unchanging. Variation within species was possible, but each species was independent in its creation.
๐ Comte Georges Du Buffon (1707-1788): Proposed degeneration โ one species could become another. This introduced the concept of change, specifically the degeneration of monkey into man, influenced by the effect of environment, forces of migration, environmental variation, and struggle for existence. These concepts were later used by Darwin.
๐ Lamark (1744-1829): Wrote the book Philosophie zoologique presenting his views. He introduced the concept of Transmutation โ animals are in a constant state of flux, constantly being perfected, and the direction of change is towards higher forms. Lamarkian change gives a ladder of life where animals move upwards to higher forms and dead material returns to regenerate. Change, not fixity of species, was elaborated for the first time, and environmental pressures bring about small heritable changes. He also proposed the concept of use and disuse โ organs grow and shrink from use.
๐ Lysenko: Gave his theory of inheritance of acquired characteristics, proposing that if changes were made in one generation, they would be passed on to the next generation.
๐ Darwin (1809-1882): Traveled to the Galapagos Island on the HMS Beagle. His nine famous voyages over 22 years provided well-documented evidence of animal species. His meticulous observations and notes led him to see patterns in similarities and differences in appearances, behavior, and other patterns. He wrote the book "Origin of Species" based on this documentation. The conclusions drawn are:
a. There is diversity and variation in the genetic composition of a population, and this provides the rough shape that natural selection works on.
b. Organisms vary (could be due to mutations or other mechanisms of genetic variability), and this variation is then inherited.
c. Natural overproductive tendencies exist, but there is a natural tendency to maintain a constant population.
๐ Example: Darwin's Galapagos voyage โ Darwin observed finches and other species on the Galapagos Islands over 22 years. He noted variations in beak shapes and behaviors across different islands, which led him to conclude that species adapt to their environments through natural selection. Finches with beaks suited to available food sources survived and reproduced more successfully, passing those traits to subsequent generations.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are: (1) Homo sapiens is a relatively new species (less than 50,000 years old) with distinctive characteristics including bipedalism, language, complex societies, and abstract thinking, yet shares taxonomic classification with all animals; (2) Taxonomic classification moves from general (Kingdom Animalia) to specific (Species Sapien), with species defined by their inability to naturally interbreed for genetic fitness reasons; (3) Evolutionary theories evolved from Linneas's fixity of species through Buffon's degeneration and Lamark's transmutation to Darwin's theory of natural selection based on variation, inheritance, and overproductive tendencies; (4) Darwin's observations from the Galapagos Islands provided evidence that genetic variation within populations, combined with natural selection, drives evolutionary change โ not the inheritance of acquired characteristics proposed by Lysenko; (5) The nature-nurture debate involves ethologists and sociobiologists (grounded in Darwinian evolution) versus experimentalists, highlighting ongoing questions about the relative contributions of genes and environment to behavior.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven distinctive characteristics of Homo sapiens that differentiate humans from other species?
- Explain the complete taxonomic classification for humans from Kingdom to Species, including the defining features of each level.
- Why don't different species naturally interbreed, and what is the biological consequence when cross-breeding occurs (as in the horse-donkey-mule example)?
- Compare and contrast Lamark's theory of transmutation with Darwin's theory of natural selection โ what are the key differences in their explanations of evolutionary change?
- What were Darwin's three key conclusions from his Galapagos Island observations, and what evidence supported each conclusion?
๐ Lecture 6 โ Evolutionary and Genetic Basis of Behaviour
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the relationship between evolution and behavior, explaining how Darwin's theory of evolution provides a biological framework for understanding why organisms behave the way they do. It covers the mechanisms of natural selection, genetic variation, and adaptation, and traces the evolutionary journey from early mammals to Homo sapiens, highlighting how brain development and behavior changed across species.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Darwin's theory of evolution including the struggle for existence, natural selection, and descent with modification; genetic variation through mutations and gene pool combinations; evolutionary adaptations (centripetal and centrifugal) and speciation through isolation and adaptive radiation; and the evolutionary timeline from mammals to primates to hominids including Australopithecus, Pithecanthropus, Neanderthal, and Cro-Magnon.
๐ Lecture Summary
Evolution
As noted in the previous lesson, evolutionary concepts were already developing before Darwin. However, Darwin's unique contribution was providing a mechanism for how and why evolution occurs.
Theory of Evolution
Darwin was the first to propose the actual mechanism of evolution. The first premise is that limited resources exist, and all living organisms compete for these resources. Therefore, a struggle for existence is fundamentally a struggle for resources and survival.
Who wins this battle? The species with even the slightest advantageโfor example, the long neck of a giraffe allowing it to reach food higher in treesโhas the best chance of survival and can continue to propagate under hostile and competitive conditions. The best adapters are the best reproducers, and the best reproducers are the ones best fit for survival.
๐ก Why this matters: This principle explains why behaviors that enhance survival (like foraging, predator avoidance, and mate selection) become genetically encoded over generations.
Decent With Modification
Genetic variation within a population provides a rough template for natural selection to work upon. Variation can also occur via mutation, which is a change in chromosomal order or the genetic code. Modification of genetic variation takes place through natural selection.
What is Natural selection?
Natural selection affects all living organisms by keeping a species strong and fit for existence under its current living conditions. NATURE SELECTS! Natural selection pressures can work only in the presence of genetic variability.
Adaptations made in one generation, if beneficial, are carried to the next generationโthis is a constant process of adaptation. If species do not adapt, they do not survive. For example, dogs that do not learn to watch for cars on the road die, meaning the end of their genes. Primates developed extensions to help in survival and hunting, such as young chimpanzees using hollow sticks to collect ants, because they could not compete with stronger hunters and predators.
Genetic Variation
Genetic variation or phylogenetic inertia can be defined as basic inherited properties in which there is variation and the extent to which they can change. All organisms have combinations of characteristics; however, each has a unique combination. These combinations can change.
Changes in the genetic combination can occur through:
- a) Combinations of different gene poolsโfor example, interracial marriage or marriage of completely unrelated individuals.
- b) Mutationsโchanges in gene material through radiation, a genetic accident, or (now) genetic manipulation. These changes lead to new and unusual combinations of genes.
๐ Definition โ Genetic variation (phylogenetic inertia): Basic inherited properties that vary among individuals and can change across generations. ๐ Formula: Genetic variation = Gene pool combinations + Mutations โ New genetic combinations ๐ Example: Interracial marriage combines gene pools from different populations, creating new genetic combinations. A radiation-induced mutation could alter the DNA sequence, producing a novel trait not seen in either parent.
Survival of the fittest
Survival of the fittest refers to qualities that enable survival and further propagation in a hostile environment. This is not about being healthy or physically strong but having qualities that allow animals to propagate successfully so that offspring survive to continue contributing to the gene pool. The gene pool for the next generation is improved because weaker genes do not survive to contribute to it. The fittest genes live on, propagate, and make up successive generations.
What if a species is doing very well? This would increase the number of surviving animals, which would again lead to competition for food, and thus the struggle for existence would continue.
Evolutionary adaptation and speciation
Evolutionary adaptation and speciation are evolutionary processes or changes a species undergoes to enhance its survival.
Evolutionary adaptation There are two kinds of adaptations during evolution:
- Centripetal: The organism remains in the same state for millions of years because there are no environmental pressures to change. There is stability, and no change is beneficial for survival. The animal does not change; for example, the silverfish has remained the same for millions of years.
- Centrifugal: When there is a non-stable environment with very rapid changes taking place, rapid change in the species occurs to survive. It is during centrifugal change that mutations occur in large numbers and very rapidly because selection pressures are intense.
๐ Definition โ Centripetal adaptation: An evolutionary state where a species remains unchanged for long periods due to stable environmental conditions. ๐ Definition โ Centrifugal adaptation: Rapid evolutionary change in a species driven by intense environmental pressures and unstable conditions. ๐ Example: The silverfish (centripetal) has not changed morphologically for millions of years. In contrast, during a rapid climate shift (centrifugal), a population of birds might develop different beak shapes within a few generations to exploit new food sources.
Speciation occurs when the same species spreads to different geographical locations and evolves differently into distinct species. The same birds that go to the sea would develop qualities of sea-birds, while those that go to the hills would develop characteristics needed for survival in the hills.
Isolation Whenever a species is geographically isolated and there is no competition, they evolve into different species depending on the location (dividing territory for mutual benefit). The animals in Australia and the Galapagos Islands are good examples.
Adaptive radiation is an adaptive process where the same species develops different characteristics. In Australia, marsupials radiated into different species such as the tasmanian cat, koala (trees), duckbill (water), and kangaroo (land), spreading and foraging across grass, tree, water, hill, and land.
๐ Definition โ Adaptive radiation: The process by which a single ancestral species diversifies into multiple species adapted to different ecological niches. ๐ Example: Marsupials in Australia evolved from a common ancestor into koalas (arboreal), kangaroos (terrestrial), and duckbilled platypuses (aquatic), each adapted to a different habitat.
Evolution: Mammalian, Primate To Homosapien
The first major phase in evolution is speculated to be when fish moved onto land, evolving into amphibians and then dinosaurs. Dinosaurs ruled the earth in various forms; they were huge physically but had very small brains. At about the end of the reptilian era, a very small mammalian species evolved:
- a) It had a fur coating for thermoregulation.
- b) Had strong olfaction (the brain grew, possibly due to olfaction).
- c) Better hearing (had to compete with large animals, so they foraged in the dark)โbones in the jaws moved to the side to form ear bones.
- d) Vision gradually highly evolved for higher primates.
Mammalian evolution began with the monotremata, which were egg-layers like reptiles but were fur-bearing and nursed their young. This led to attachmentโa benefit for survival because young could learn to survive from the mother. The young stayed with the mother until they were out of the vulnerable stage.
Advantages: Instead of having 10 eggs with none surviving (open to predators), species have one offspring (a major investment that develops slowly and lives to propagate). POPULATION GROWTH IS SLOW BUT STEADY.
This also brought about a change in the maternal role. The young suckles and stays with the mother. The purposes of this development are:
- a) Nurturance is provided directly so that there is fitness.
- b) Learning directly from an adult: the young learns to run when the mother does, to eat what she does.
- c) Protection from bigger and more dangerous animals by the adult (maternal aggression is well documented).
Thus, early development became an important period where attachment and bonding began. This is a sensitive period where the young is tied to the mother through pheromonal signals. The highest form of attachment bonding with mother developed in primates.
๐ก Why this matters: The evolution of mammalian parentingโnursing, attachment, and maternal protectionโprovides the biological foundation for the complex social behaviors and emotional bonds observed in humans today.
Human Evolution
-
Hominids evolved into at least 7 different species. Their names specify the location where their remains were discovered:
- Australopithecus (about 2-3 million years ago, brain size 500 cc)
- Java (Indonesia)
- Peking (China)
- Olduvai man (in the Olduvai Gorge in Africa)
- Pithecanthropus
- Homo Erectus (brain size about 900 cc)
- Neanderthal (brain size 1400 cc, Germany)
- Cro-Magnon
-
Pithecanthropus: The earliest man-ape who was cave-living and used stone tools. There is evidence in the caves of the use of fire (therefore, fire had been discovered). There is also evidence of cannibalism, with a special favorite appearing to be brains (cracked craniums are evidence for such activity). There appears to have been families and some social groups.
-
Neanderthal: Remains found in the Neander Valley in Germany. Evidence indicates the Neanderthal was present around 100,000 to 50,000 years ago. In appearance, they were small and heavy-set, brutal-looking, with a slightly larger brain size but a very efficient brain compared to earlier species. This was the beginning of a man shaped like an ape. There is evidence of increased tool use with specialized tools for cutting, piercing, and shaping. This ape-man migrated by traveling across, as indicated by remains spread over Europe, Africa, and the Near East.
๐ Definition โ Hominids: The biological family of primates that includes humans and their fossil ancestors. ๐ Example: Brain size evolution in hominidsโAustralopithecus (500 cc) โ Homo Erectus (900 cc) โ Neanderthal (1400 cc)โshows a clear trend of increasing cognitive capacity over millions of years.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) Darwin's theory of evolution explains behavior through natural selection, where organisms with traits that enhance survival and reproduction pass those traits to future generations; (2) genetic variation from mutations and gene pool mixing provides the raw material for natural selection to act upon; (3) adaptations can be centripetal (stability, no change) or centrifugal (rapid change under intense environmental pressure); (4) speciation and adaptive radiation occur when populations become isolated and evolve different traits suited to their environments; and (5) mammalian evolution introduced fur, enhanced senses, and maternal care/nursing, which created attachment and bondingโculminating in primates and the progressively larger-brained hominids (Australopithecus, Pithecanthropus, Neanderthal, and Cro-Magnon).
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between centripetal and centrifugal adaptation, and what triggers each?
- Explain how the concept of "survival of the fittest" relates to the gene pool of the next generation.
- Describe three key mammalian adaptations that improved survival compared to reptiles.
- What is adaptive radiation, and use marsupials in Australia as an example to explain it.
- List the major hominid species in order of increasing brain size, and state the approximate brain volume for Australopithecus, Homo Erectus, and Neanderthal.
๐ Lecture 7 โ Evolutionary and Genetic Basis of Behaviour
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how evolution has shaped human behavior and brain development, tracing key adaptations from early hominids to modern Homo sapiens. It also examines the genetic basis of behavior and the nature-nurture debate, explaining how innate programming interacts with environmental experience.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers evolutionary developments of Homo sapiens including stereoscopic vision, bipedalism, skull/brain size increase, cortical specialization, thumb opposition, language evolution, teeth/jaw changes, family and social group evolution, reduced body fat, and improved vision. It then discusses human brain evolution focusing on cerebral cortex growth and encephalization, followed by the relevance of evolution to psychology, the innate vs. learned behavior continuum, how genes program behavior through protein templates, and how internal and external cues trigger behaviors.
๐ Lecture Summary
Objective
The objectives of this lecture are to understand the concepts of evolution and its developmental process, and to trace the evolution of Homo sapiens to understand brain development and behavior changes as they evolved.
Important developments of Homosapien development
Stereoscopic vision evolved as a specialized form of vision for seeing depth. This reduced dependence on smell, which had been a strong evolutionary adaptation in early mammals to compete with dinosaurs. In evolved primates, visionโnot olfactionโbecame the primary sense, with depth perception and distance vision (aided by upright posture) working very well for hunting and locating prey across longer distances.
Bipedalism involved a change in the pelvic bones of early ape-men. The human pelvis is shorter in length and wider to support upright posture and balance, whereas the ape pelvis is longer and thinner to support a bent posture. Bipedal running emerged earlier in man-apes (and higher primates) before walking. Walking is an efficient method of covering long distances without exhaustion; apes can outrun humans in short distances, but humans win over longer distances, making them more efficient hunters.
๐ Definition โ Bipedalism: Walking on two legs, a key evolutionary adaptation enabling upright posture.
Why bipedalism is important:
- a) Walking and maintaining stamina over long distances enabled man-apes to cover more hunting grounds.
- b) Hunting became more efficient as walking left the walker's hands free for tools! Tool use and bipedalism emerged around the same time. Darwin considered this the most important developmentโtool use as both cause and effect of bipedal locomotion.
Other major developments relevant to brain and behavior:
- Skull and brain size: Increase in brain size, indicating developments in specialized functions as well as growth in the size of the brain, neurons, and cells.
- Increased cortex: In lower animals, the cerebral cortex primarily has sensory-motor functions, whereas in humans, cortex functions have become more specialized. Sensory-motor functions are reduced, and higher-order functions such as association have evolved. The cortex has taken over as the master control in humans.
- Thumb: The separation of the thumb from fingers is a major development. It is larger and more separated in humans, making the hand more efficient and useful for grasping and efficient tool useโthese are prehensile hands.
- Language evolved in humans as a strong means of social and other communication; visual cues no longer remain as important. Language can be easily learned by infants by being with the caretaker (usually mother). Language also sharpened the capabilities of Homo sapiens for planning, foresight, language, art, and culture.
- Teeth and jaw (and forehead) development: In baboons and other apes, male canines are much larger as they are the fighters, used to threaten, attack, hold, shake, and pierce enemies. Females have smaller canines. Reduced canine size accompanied the development of differentiated female roles. Jaws moved so that the jaw bone's position relative to the vertebral column shifted for balance and support of bipedalism. The forehead slope was also reduced, making facial appearance less brutish.
- Family evolved: Since females carry young in utero for gestation, the female role/investment and involvement is greater with the infant. Females must remain with the infant and cannot move around freely while carrying the youngโboth can be endangered. Therefore, the male role as hunter evolved. Sexual dimorphism evolved to keep the family together and for protection of the offspring.
- Social groups: Since male hunting alone would be vulnerable to predators, hunting in groups evolved while females nursing stayed behind. Males hunting together could also hunt large animals, so food would last longer. Thus, social living evolved first in caves, with food sharing and increased social contact leading to increased use of language and signals.
- Reduced fat deposits on body occurred because there was less need to store food, and discovery of fire and fur coverings reduced the need for fat to keep the body ready for times of starvation and cold. Body hair was also reduced, perhaps because it created an impediment in running, and specialized sweat glands for rapid diffusion of heat evolved.
- Improved power of stereoscopic vision and other functions: Since longer distances could be seen while standing, there was development of perception and memory, which became important for remembering food sources, water holes, and predators to watch out for.
Evolution of the human brain
There was rapid growth in both brain size and intellectual functioning, but growth in intellectual capacity was more important. Elephants (8000cc) and whales (5000cc) have bigger/heavier brains than humans (1300cc). Genius brains are not different from common men. Total brain size may not be the critical issue. It is the growth of the cerebral cortexโits size has grown enormously, and it has taken over functions from lower (and earlier evolved) areas. The cerebral cortex has grown so much that it must be folded to fit into the cranium. Thus, convulations (folds) and deep grooves are formed to fit more cortex into a small cranial case. The cerebral cortex has taken over association functions, not only sensory or motor functions. The higher the animal on the evolutionary scale, the greater the control of the cerebral cortex. Homo sapiens, being the highest evolved primate, therefore has the highest degree of encephalization.
What has evolution to do with psychology?
Evolutionary psychology studies the evolvement of a wide range of human and other behaviors such as monogamy, polyandry, and gender roles. These studies provide insights into the most complex social and other human behaviors, which have resulted from adaptations over millions of years.
- Behaviours of all animal kingdoms evolved and are similar.
- Evolution influences genesโgenes programmed for neural development need interaction from the environment/experience. The brain continuously interacts with the environment; whatever is successful is passed on to the next generation.
๐ก Why this matters: While humans' rate of biological evolution may have slowed, social/cultural evolution is increasingly complex and fast. This raises important questions about where we are heading.
The Nature vs. Nurture Debate
The nature or nurture debate keeps recurring in research and discussions among scientists working in behavioural neurosciences. To answer this, we must remember: a) behaviour occurs in relation to some eventโit must interact with the environment, affecting it and being affected by it; b) the organism comes already equipped to face the world in a particular mannerโit is a "genetically determined animal possessing biological structures and capabilities and limits."
Thus, behavior is genetically determined as well as exploited when an appropriate environment is provided. Some behaviour is completely determined, others are somewhat determined, while some are not at all controlled by genes. The range of behaviours extends from completely innate to completely learnt. In lower animals such as fruitflies, behaviour is carried out as per genetic programming in response to environmental cues. In humans, the language apparatus is biologically developed, but languages are learnt (which language is taught depends on the environment). Similarly, culture and traditions are not biologically determined.
The continuum shows that in lower animals and simpler organisms, behavior is innately determined, whereas in humans, some behaviors are completely learnt:
Innate (completely determined) ------------------------------------ Only learned
Fruitflies Human languages
Do Genes Produce Innate Behaviour?
Noโgenes only provide templates for the synthesis of appropriate proteins, protein chains, and timing of release. There is programming of genetic proteins and chains which determine the brain program and developments that can flourish in a certain environment. The triggering cues for genetically programmed behaviors come from the environment.
- External cues come from the outside environment. Example: a lion hunting for food; a deer sees the lion and runs to save itself.
- Internal cues come from within the organism's systemsโthe hormones, the needs, and the signals from these lead the organism to action. Example: signals for food/nutrition cause animals to feel hungry and seek food. If there is a rise in prostaglandins levels, birds start nest building.
- Combination of both external and internal cues: You see food or smell food and immediately feel like eating.
Can Experience Affect Innate Behaviour?
Yes, in some cases it can. Mothering behaviour is due to hormonal changes after birth. However, we cannot induce mothering with drugs only, unless this has been experienced earlier (naturally). This experiment was carried out with ring doves.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that evolution shaped key human developments including bipedalism (freeing hands for tools), increased cerebral cortex size and specialization (especially association areas), language evolution, and social group livingโall of which transformed brain and behavior. Brain size alone is not the key factor; rather, it is the growth and folding of the cerebral cortex and the degree of encephalization that differentiate humans. Behavior exists on a continuum from completely innate to completely learned, with lower animals more genetically programmed and humans having more environmentally influenced behaviors. Genes do not directly produce behavior; they provide protein templates, and the triggering cues (internal and external) come from the environment. Experience can modify even innate behaviors, as demonstrated by the ring dove mothering experiment.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What were the key evolutionary developments in Homo sapiens that impacted brain and behavior, and how did bipedalism specifically enable tool use?
- Why is total brain size not the critical factor for intellectual capacity, and what is the significance of cerebral cortex folding (convulations)?
- Explain the continuum from innate to learned behavior and provide examples from fruitflies and human language.
- Do genes produce innate behavior directly? What do genes actually provide and what triggers genetically programmed behaviors?
- Can experience affect innate behavior? Provide an example from the ring dove experiment.
๐ Lecture 08 โ GENES AND EXPERIENCE
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the nature-nurture debate in behavioral neuroscience, examining how genetic programming and environmental experience interact to shape behavior. It introduces ethology, fixed action patterns, and the genetic basis of behavior, providing a continuum from completely innate to completely learned behaviors across species.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the nature-nurture interaction continuum from innate to learned behavior, the role of internal and external cues in triggering genetically programmed behaviors, the concept of encephalization and its relation to environmental influence, ethology and fixed action patterns with sign stimuli and releasers, evidence for fixed action patterns in humans, genetic basis of behavior through chromosomal composition examples, and fundamental genetic concepts including chromosomes, genes, proteins, genotype, and phenotype.
๐ Lecture Summary
Objective: Genes and Experience
Behavior occurs in relation to some event and involves interaction with the environment. The organism comes equipped with genetically determined biological structures, capabilities, and limits. Thus, behavior is both genetically determined and exploited when an appropriate environment is provided. Some behaviors are completely determined, others somewhat determined, and some not at all controlled by genes. The range extends from completely innate to completely learned. In lower animals like fruitflies, behavior follows genetic programming in response to environmental cues. In humans, the language apparatus is biologically developed, but languages are learned depending on the environment. Culture and traditions are not biologically determined.
The continuum shows: Innate (completely determined) โ Fruitflies โ Only learned โ Human languages.
Do Genes Produce Innate Behavior?
No; genes only provide templates for synthesis of appropriate proteins, protein chains, and timing of release. Programming of genetic proteins and chains determines brain programs and developments that can flourish in a certain environment. Triggering cues for genetically programmed behaviors come from the environment:
- External cues: e.g., lion hunting for food; deer sees lion and runs to save itself.
- Internal cues: from within the organism's systems โ hormones, needs, and signals lead to action. e.g., signals for food/nutrition; animals feel hungry and seek food. Rise in prostaglandins levels triggers nest building in birds.
- Combination: seeing or smelling food immediately triggers feeling like eating.
๐ก Why this matters: Experience can affect innate behavior. For example, mothering behavior is due to hormonal changes after birth, but cannot be induced with drugs alone unless previously experienced naturally (as shown in ring dove experiments).
Nature-Nurture: Interaction
The interaction has limits. Rats can learn food-related tasks (press lever for food) as this exists in their natural survival repertoire, but they will not groom face for food as this is not part of their innate feeding program.
Greater influence of environment occurs with higher order animals or animals with larger brain sizes. This means greater adaptability in animals on the higher evolutionary scale, with very few typical behavior patterns. Thus: the higher the animal on evolutionary scale, the greater the encephalization (larger cerebral cortices and control), and the more they are affected by environment.
Ethology
Ethology is a branch of life sciences that studies behavior in its natural environment. The underpinning theoretical view is Darwinian evolution: behavior is predetermined and preprogrammed, set in motion by a cue, and carried through in a fixed action pattern. These processes are determined through natural selection (only adaptive behaviors are maintained).
๐ก Why this matters: Fixed Action Pattern โ once a behavior is initiated, it will go through the whole innate process to completion. Characteristics: a) stereotypic: same behavior pattern repeated again and again (e.g., peacock dance) b) innate: different behaviors for young vs. old, male vs. female c) repetitive: same form repeated every time stimuli presented d) completed once initiated: cannot be stopped; animal stops when behavior ends e) cannot be modified through learning.
Sign Stimuli and Releasers
Ethologists found that signs (stimuli) which act as releasers are important for Fixed Action Patterns. Characteristics:
- A specific sign stimulus affects one species only
- Can affect only males/females or both in different ways
- Sign stimuli can be: visual (sight of another), acoustic (sound of call), olfactory/chemical (smell/odor), or behavioral (wolf snarls to display canines)
Sign stimuli lead to fixed action patterns in one animal, which then leads to response of further sign stimuli. This exchange of signals can lead to full range of behaviors. Example: distress signal of mother hen for chicks when she sees an eagle; chicks respond with distress calls and run to hide under her feathers.
Lehrman developed the goose-hawk model: the same wood board cut looks like a goose from one end and a hawk from another. Goslings (baby geese) freeze with fear if the model is flown in one direction (hawk) but not the other. Experiments showed that Herring Gull leaves its egg to sit on larger one.
Fixed Action Patterns in Humans
Yes, infants turn away from noxious stimuli, smile at pleasant looks or smiles. When an unpleasant threatening face is made, the baby cries. There are innate fixed emotional expressions. Studies photographing faces with expressions across primitive and advanced worlds (New Guinea and US) were rated by judges: anger, surprise, sadness, and happiness came across the same regardless of culture.
The baby stops crying when held close because the baby responds to mother's smells/odor โ signals from pheromones that communicate her presence and closeness.
However, not everything ethologists claim is exactly as stated. Humans learn from experience to suppress anger, to smile when angry. Humans are generalized animals whereas other animals are specialized (cheetah runs faster, snake smells better), but humans can change their environment to suit needs.
Genetic Basis of Behaviour
Chromosomal composition influences behavioral characteristics:
- XY: normal males
- XYY (additional Y chromosome): evidence of aggressiveness in males shown in studies of inmates; large percentage of inmates who had committed physically aggressive and brutal crimes (Scottish jails study)
- XX: normal females
- XXY: female with male characteristics
- Trisomy (three chromosomes) XXO, XYO: lead to Downs syndrome (abnormalities)
Thus, genes determine female/male sex and the expression of characteristics of being male/female. Genes have an important role in development of physical and other characteristics.
Genetic Basis: Fundamental Concepts
Chromosomes
Chromosomes are strands of chemical proteins found in the nucleus of all cells of the organism. They are composed of a large number of genes (basic unit of heredity) located throughout on the threads of chromosomes. Chromosomes occur in matched pairs โ one from mother, one from father at fertilization. Chromosomes are specific for each species: humans have 23 chromosomes (one pair for sex, 22 for other traits); Drosophila (fruitfly) has 8. Chromosomes are composed of double strands of DNA molecules.
๐ Definition โ Chromosomes: Strands of chemical proteins in the nucleus of all cells, composed of genes, occurring in matched pairs, specific for each species.
Genes and Proteins
Genes are located on chromosomes and determine the combinations of chains of proteins involved in growth, development, and maintenance of organism's systems.
Two kinds of proteins:
- Structural proteins: determine structure of the organism (bones, teeth, hair, organs)
- Enzymes: modulate metabolism of the organism and other physico-chemical events
๐ Definition โ Genes: The basic unit of heredity located on chromosomes that determine combinations of protein chains.
๐ Definition โ Proteins: Structural proteins build organism structure; enzymes modulate metabolism.
Genotype and Phenotype
Genes express themselves in two ways:
- Genotype: set of genes which form the underlying genetic makeup of the individual (e.g., hair genes could be for straight or curly, brown or black hair)
- Phenotype: observable or measurable traits which form the outward expression of genetic basis after interaction with the environment. Behavior in all higher animals is more phenotypical compared to lower animals.
๐ Definition โ Genotype: The underlying genetic makeup of an individual. ๐ Definition โ Phenotype: Observable or measurable traits formed by interaction of genotype with environment.
๐ Example: Drosophila would develop wings at a particular temperature; flowers would bloom with the right weather conditions. Children who have undergone severe starvation during early childhood (such as in Ethiopia or Somalia) would not be able to regenerate brain or other growth cycles.
โญ Key Takeaways
The nature-nurture continuum shows that lower animals exhibit more innate behavior while higher animals show greater environmental influence due to encephalization. Fixed action patterns are stereotypic, innate, repetitive behaviors initiated by sign stimuli and carried to completion, evident in both animals and humans (such as emotional expressions and infant responses). Genes do not directly produce behavior but provide protein templates that interact with environmental cues. The genotype-phenotype distinction is critical: behavior in higher animals is more phenotypical, meaning it results from gene-environment interaction. Chromosomal abnormalities (like XYY linked to aggression) demonstrate genetic influence on behavior, but environment always plays a modulating role.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the continuum of behavior from innate to learned, and where do fruitflies and human language fit on this continuum?
- What are the four characteristics of a fixed action pattern, and what is the role of sign stimuli?
- How does the goose-hawk model by Lehrman demonstrate the effect of sign stimuli on behavior?
- What is the difference between genotype and phenotype, and why is animal behavior considered more phenotypical in higher animals?
- What chromosomal abnormality is associated with increased aggressiveness in males, and what was the evidence from Scottish jail studies?