π Lecture 1 β Introduction to Forensic Psychology (I)
π Overview: This introductory lecture establishes the foundational definition, scope, and applications of forensic psychology as a discipline bridging psychological science and the legal system. It outlines the diverse professional roles of forensic psychologists, traces the historical development of the field from the late 19th century through its recognition as an APA division in 2001, and provides practical guidance on educational pathways for specialization.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition of forensic psychology from Wrightsman and Bartel & Bartel, the breadth of its applications including child custody, competency evaluations, and victim support, the professional activities of forensic psychologists such as criminal investigation and offender treatment, the historical background from Munsterberg's 1908 work through the M'Naghten case and the establishment of the APA Forensic Psychology Division in 2001, the distinction between psychologists and psychiatrists, the current state and future growth of the field, and the clinical route to becoming a forensic psychologist.
π Lecture Summary
What is forensic psychology?
Forensic Psychology is devoted to psychological aspects of legal processes in courts. The term is also often used to refer to investigative and criminological psychology. The word βforensicβ means legal; anything that is pertinent to law comes into the area of forensic psychology. The range of application of forensic psychology is not merely limited to the criminals; it involves all matters that are relevant to our legal and civil systems like courts, police, lawyers, crime investigations, criminal behaviours, police recruitments, trainings, and adjustment.
π Definition β Forensic Psychology (Wrightsman): "Forensic Psychology is reflected by any application of psychological knowledge or methods to a task faced by the legal system"
π Definition β Forensic Psychology (Bartel & Bartel): Views forensic psychology as both: (1) The research endeavor that examines aspects of human behavior directly related to the legal process, e.g., eyewitness memory and testimony, jury decision making, or criminal behavior; and (2) The professional practice of psychology within or in consultation with a legal system that encompasses both criminal and civil law and the numerous areas where they interact.
Breadth of forensic psychology
Forensic psychology is a very new and exciting area because of the immense range of its applications. These include child custody decisions, child abuse of an emotional, physical, and sexual nature, matters of competency to stand trial, victim support responsibilities, jury selection, alleviating police burnout, competency evaluations, serving as an expert witness, advising legislators on public policy, and treatment of chronic offenders.
What do forensic psychologists do?
A forensic psychologist is more likely to be involved in: applying psychological theory to criminal investigation, understanding psychological problems associated with criminal behaviour, the treatment of criminals including piloting and implementing treatment programmes, modifying offender behaviours, responding to the changing needs of staff and prisoners, reducing stress for staff and prisoners, providing hard research evidence to support practice, undertaking statistical analysis for prisoner profiling, giving evidence in court, advising parole boards and mental health tribunals, and crime analysis.
Brief historical background
Historically, the legal system has embraced medical expertise, so legal issues relating to madness and insanity continue to be examined within a medical framework; hence the adoption of terms such as βdiseaseβ of the mind and mental βillnessβ. The field predates the Sociological jurisprudence movement of 1930-1950 and goes back at least to 1908 when Hugo Munsterberg (the founder of applied psychology) published the book On the Witness Stand. Others cite historical benchmarks in Germany with the psychiatrist Albert von Schrenck-Notzing offering testimony in court about pretrial publicity as far back as 1896. German police employed psychologists to help them in investigations as early as 1920βs.
Hugo MΓΌnsterberg, a student of Wilhelm Wundt and a professor at Harvard University, is generally credited with founding the field of forensic psychology. His landmark textbook, On the Witness Stand (1908), comprised nine chapters arguing for the involvement of psychologists in a number of aspects of the legal system.
In the United States, the first psychological experiment on the psychology of testimony was conducted by J. McKeen Cattell of Columbia University. In American criminology, one can trace the origins of a clinical or psychological criminology to the psychiatrist William Healy, who in 1909 created the Juvenile Psychopathic Institute to assist the newly created juvenile court in Illinois, and his classic work is called Pathological Lying, Accusation, and Swindling.
The history of the insanity defense goes back to England, to the case of Daniel M'Naghten in 1843, who shot and killed the secretary of the prime minister, and the M'Naghten test for insanity was used for assessment.
Development as an APA division
In 2001 the American Psychological Association (APA) approved the creation of a new division called the forensic psychology division. Nowadays, psychologists are routinely consulted by courts on various issues. Because the history of forensic psychology as a unique discipline is relatively short, it has struggled to promote a clear identity for itself and is often interpreted as the poor relation of medical and psychiatric opinion. Typically, medical professionals were invited by courts to comment on insanity. Psychologists had been asked for help but infrequently. With the passage of time, the legal system began feeling the crucial need of psychologists to assess different situations, mental states, and behaviors of criminals.
π‘ Why this matters: For instance, a criminal is presented in court and the defense lawyer states that the criminal is mentally retarded. A judge is not capable of understanding the real nature of mental retardation. Although the judge has the authority to make the decision, only a trained psychologist can verdict whether the criminal is mentally retarded or not.
π Definition β Psychiatrist: A medical doctor who specializes in the diagnosis and treatment of mental disorders. Beyond any doubt, only well-trained psychologists are authorized to make judgments and operate in the field of forensic psychology; even psychiatrists do not meet the requirements of this area.
In Pakistan, development of forensic psychology has a long route to exceed and many hurdles to overcome, because the field is very new even in the USA and many other European countries.
Future of Forensic Psychology
Forensic psychology has experienced steady growth in the past two decades. It is predicted that research work, consultation, and clinical practice in psychology and the law will continue to grow over the next ten years. The highest demand is predicted to be working with the courts, attorneys, and lawmakers. Jobs will also continue to grow in colleges and universities where most of the research is conducted. Laws are constantly changing, which can be good news for a forensic psychologist. Exploring different ways of dealing with juvenile offenders is also becoming a popular subject; decisions related to dealing with these offenders often require the expert advice of a forensic psychologist. Those who hold doctorate degrees will have many more career opportunities than those with only a master's degree. It is almost impossible to specialize in this field with only a bachelorβs degree.
How to become a Forensic Psychologist
The preferred route to become a forensic psychologist is through the clinical route; meaning become a clinical psychologist first and then specialize in forensic psychology. Individuals interested in pursuing a forensic psychology career should take psychology and criminal justice courses at the core of their academic studies. There are very limited numbers of academic institutions that specifically offer a forensic psychology degree. Two institutes in Pakistan are offering diplomas in forensic psychology. Clinical, social, cognitive, criminal investigative, and developmental psychology also help to prepare one for this specialty.
A forensic psychologist may choose to solely focus his/her career on research, ranging anywhere from examination of eyewitness testimony to learning how to improve interrogation methods. Another form of forensic psychology work is public policy, in which researchers can help in the design of correctional facilities and prisons. More generally, forensic psychology covers territory between the traditional options of criminal justice (i.e., academic training, law enforcement, and corrections).
β Key Takeaways
Forensic psychology is defined as any application of psychological knowledge or methods to tasks faced by the legal system, encompassing both research and professional practice across criminal and civil law. The field was founded by Hugo Munsterberg in 1908 with his book On the Witness Stand, and key historical milestones include von Schrenck-Notzing's 1896 testimony, Cattell's experiments on testimony, Healy's Juvenile Psychopathic Institute in 1909, and the 1843 M'Naghten case establishing the insanity defense. The APA recognized forensic psychology as an official division in 2001, yet the field continues to struggle for clear identity against medical/psychiatric dominance in legal contexts. The preferred educational pathway is the clinical route, requiring a doctorate degree, with growing demand predicted in court consultation, research, and juvenile justice. A critical distinction is that only trained psychologists (not psychiatrists) are qualified to make judgments in forensic psychology.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two components of Bartel & Bartel's definition of forensic psychology?
- Name the founding figure of forensic psychology and his landmark 1908 publication.
- What was the significance of the 1843 Daniel M'Naghten case for forensic psychology?
- Why is a judge unable to independently determine whether a criminal is mentally retarded in court?
- What is the preferred educational route to become a forensic psychologist, and why is a bachelor's degree insufficient?
π Lecture 2 β INTRODUCTION TO FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY
π Overview: This lecture explores the practical realities of a career in forensic psychology, weighing its rewarding aspects against its significant challenges. It then demonstrates the unique role forensic psychologists play in complex legal scenarios, including murder investigations, child custody disputes, and false confessions, while also outlining their responsibilities in police work and the court system.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by listing the pros and cons of a career in forensic psychology, covering both the rewarding and frustrating aspects of the field. It then uses a murder case example to show how a forensic psychologist can assist in investigations, contrasting this with traditional police methods. The lecture continues by examining the psychologist's role in child custody cases and the assessment of multiple parties. It explores the issue of hidden confessions and the unique pressures of working with police. Finally, it discusses the professional responsibilities of a forensic psychologist in assisting the court.
π Lecture Summary
Pros and Cons of a Career in Forensic Psychology
This section introduces the dual nature of forensic psychology as a demanding but fulfilling profession. It warns that "weak-hearted" or very sensitive people should avoid this field because they will encounter blood, murders, dead bodies, miseries, and violence. The lecture presents a table listing rewarding aspects like helping others, diverse opportunities, a changing environment, recognition as an expert witness, and personal fulfillment from beneficial research. Conversely, it highlights frustrating aspects such as demands for continuing education, a high risk of injury from violent individuals, necessary teamwork with various professionals, inadequate pay, and a high burnout risk from trying to change unchangeable situations.
The lecture concludes this section by emphasizing that while the money may not compensate for the hard work, the true personal payment comes from making a difference in society. It notes that the burnout rate is high and testifying in court is stressful, so extensive education is required to get ahead.
How can a forensic psychologist help in investigation of murder?
This section uses an example of a man found dead with a bullet wound to demonstrate the unique contributions of a forensic psychologist. Using this scenario, the lecture explains that a forensic psychologist is often more appropriate than police alone to deal with the situation, as they can assess multiple dimensions of a case.
π Definition β Forensic Psychologist: An appropriate person to deal with a murder investigation by assessing multiple dimensions and aspects of the case, often working like a detective.
The lecture contrasts the way of police investigation with the way of psychologist investigation. It states that people often feel reluctance to tell the truth to police due to traditional investigation methods that may include them as suspects. In contrast, psychologists can gather information through the application of psychological knowledge, interviewing the family and third parties like friends and neighbors.
π‘ Why this matters: Unlike clinical psychology where the examinee is assumed truthful, in forensic psychology there is an obvious motivation to present a distorted picture for a secondary gain. This requires special skills and strategies.
The specific assessment procedures a forensic psychologist uses include:
- Assess the personality type from collected information
- Analyze medical records for presence/absence of mental illness
- Create a profile
- Perform a psychological autopsy
How a forensic psychologist help in child custody cases
This section addresses the complex legal issue of child custody, noting that assessment is one of the most complex, challenging, and professionally risky areas of forensic evaluation. It explains that divorce rates are 50% in the US and one out of every three in the UK. Using an example of a couple with a 10-year-old daughter where the father alleges the mother is unfit due to mental illness and the mother claims the father is abusive, the lecture shows how a psychologist can help.
The psychologist applies several techniques to find the truth:
- Interview the child, both parents, and other people in the family (grandparents, servants)
- Assess the child using projective techniques
- Assess both parents and other family members
The lecture warns that parents may fake being good when given straightforward questions. To deal with this, projective techniques are essential, and the psychologist must be well-trained, experienced, and skillful to administer them and make recommendations to the court.
How forensic psychologists help in exploring the hidden nature of confessions?
This section explains that forensic psychologists help identify the real nature and motive of false confessions. It notes that suggestible but innocent suspects might give false confessions because of police behavior and many other factors. The lecture describes a scenario where a person confesses to murder and the court asks the psychologist to decide if the confession is genuine.
The section highlights that police may create different sorts of hampers to inhibit the psychologist's work, such as standing in front of the suspect and giving meaningful looks. Despite these hurdles, a skillful psychologist can still understand the situation and make recommendations to court, making it difficult for police to torture the suspect further.
Police psychologists
This section outlines the three main areas where forensic psychologists help police work effectively:
-
Recruitment: Psychologists help select persons who suitably fit the dynamic nature of police work by using different personality, aptitude, and ability tests to assess the right person for the job.
-
Training: Psychologists help design training programs to develop empathy and customer service attitude in the police force.
-
Adjustment to stressful job: The stressful nature of police work leads to problems like Post Shooting Stress Disorder, Depression, and other mental and adjustment problems. Police psychologists help cope with these situations.
The lecture notes these three aspects will be discussed in detail in forthcoming lessons.
Professional responsibilities
This section explains that forensic psychologists serve multiple clients in the judicial system, including the retaining attorney, the judge and jury, and society as a whole. The lecture contrasts this with clinical psychology, where the client is readily identifiable as the person receiving services.
π Definition β Clinical Psychology: A field where the person to whom professional services are offered is the client, the one owed the legal duty and privilege.
In contrast, forensic psychologists serve multiple clients and take an oath to tell the whole truth. Their ultimate goal should only and only be to assist the court and find out the truth.
β Key Takeaways
Forensic psychology is a rewarding but demanding field that involves dealing with violence, blood, and death, with high burnout risk and inadequate pay. The true payment comes from making a difference in people's lives and society. Unlike clinical psychology where individuals are assumed truthful, in forensic psychology there is motivation to distort information, requiring special skills like using projective techniques and interviewing third parties. A forensic psychologist's ultimate professional responsibility is to assist the court and find the truth, serving multiple clients including the attorney, judge, jury, and society. Key areas of work include murder investigations, child custody assessments, false confessions analysis, and police recruitment and training.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- List four potentially rewarding aspects and four frustrating aspects of a career in forensic psychology mentioned in the lecture.
- How does the way of psychologist investigation differ from the way of police investigation in a murder case?
- What specific assessment procedures does a forensic psychologist use when investigating a murder case?
- Why are projective techniques essential when assessing parents in child custody cases?
- What are the three main areas where police psychologists help police work effectively?
π Lecture 03 β FORENSIC PSYCHOLOGY AND POLICE
π Overview: This lecture explores the critical relationship between forensic psychology and police work. It examines the stressful nature of policing, the historical controversy and research regarding police intelligence quotients (IQ), and the evolution of psychological screening methods used to select suitable police personnel. Understanding this relationship is fundamental because police are the primary law enforcement arm of the justice system, and psychological principles are essential for improving their performance, selection, and well-being.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the relationship between police and forensic psychology, highlighting the stressful nature of police work. It then delves into the historical debate about police IQ, examining early studies by Terman and Thurstone that suggested low intelligence, along with contradictory findings and the role of education. Finally, it details the evolution of police screening in the US, focusing on the rationale of "screening in" versus "screening out" and the use of specific personality inventories like the MMPI and IPI.
π Lecture Summary
Relationship of police and Forensic Psychology
The relationship between police and forensic psychology is foundational. The term police psychology was popularized by pioneers like Dr. Martin Reiser, who became America's first full-time police psychologist hired by the LAPD in 1968. Policing is central to forensic psychology because it is the law enforcement department where psychological principles are directly applied. The bond between the two fields is particularly strong due to the stressful nature of police work, which is one of the top-rated professions for job stress, alongside air traffic controllers and dentists.
π Definition β Police Psychology: A specialized field of forensic psychology focused on applying psychological principles to law enforcement, including assisting with stress management, optimal shift schedules, pre-employment screening tests, developing profiles of serial offenders, training officers to deal with the mentally ill, and providing counseling services.
π‘ Why this matters: Forensic psychologists are essential to help police departments function effectively by addressing the human factors that impact performance and decision-making.
Police and Intelligence Quotients
This section examines the historical and controversial link between policing and intelligence. Researchers began testing police IQ in the early 20th century. In 1917, Louis Terman administered IQ tests to police applicants and found that only three out of a large number scored over 100 (the average IQ). He concluded that policing attracted people with low IQ. In 1922, Louis Thurstone administered the Army Intelligence Test (Alpha) to 358 police officers in Detroit and confirmed these findings, reporting an average score of 71.44 for patrol officers, with sergeants and lieutenants scoring even lower, falling into the "borderline" or "extremely low" categories.
Descriptive Classifications of Intelligence Quotients:
- 130+: Very superior
- 120-129: Superior
- 110-119: High average
- 90-109: Average
- 80-89: Low average
- 70-79: Borderline
- Below 70: Extremely low
This led to the question: What causes low IQ in police? Thurstone concluded that intelligent people avoided the police department because they were not valued, and those who joined would eventually leave for professions where intelligence was more appreciated. Other contributing factors included early socialization into the police culture, home situations, and socio-economic status.
An exception to these findings came in 1927 when Maude Merrill tested the Palo Alto Police in California and found an average IQ score of 104, with officers having over two years of experience averaging an IQ of 143 (very superior/genius range). Poland (1978) later reviewed the literature and concluded that education is the key to success, suggesting that recruiting people with higher education leads to more intelligent policing.
US recommendations
In response to the research, a US committee gave several recommendations for improving police departments. These included using tests of mental ability for recruitment, conducting oral psychiatric interviews, physical exams, and in-depth background investigations. A psychological exam was recommended to include:
- Evaluation of intellectual capacity
- Evaluation of emotional stability
- Assessment of personality characteristics
π Example β Change in US Police Departments Over Time:
- 1960s: Narrol & Levitt found that police were being tested for "street smarts" (aptitude), but the recommendations for emotional stability and personality assessment were not being followed.
- 1970s: Many large US police departments began using standardized personality inventories. Over 48% were using the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI).
- 2003: Cochrane, Tett & VandeCreek surveyed 155 municipal police departments and found a total transformation:
- 91% were using personality measures.
- 71.6% were using MMPI.
- 24.5% were using CPI.
- 18.7% were using 16 PF.
- 11.6% were using IPI.
Rationale of using personality inventories
The basic reason for using personality inventories is to find the person who is fit for the police job and to assess if those on duty are still fit for duty. The major aspects of personality assessment are screening in and screening out.
π‘ Why this matters: These two concepts represent the core strategic goals of psychological testing in policing.
Screening in means searching for the person who is fit for the job by looking for a "police personality"βthe specific traits, habits, reactions, and attitudes of an ideal officer. The goal is to identify desired traits and then employ tests to find matching personalities. However, this approach was judged a "lost cause" due to individual differences. Two very different personalities could both be excellent officers, while two identical personalities might perform totally differently. Consequently, screening in is not a pursuable goal.
Screening out is a more reasonable objective. It is the use of psychological tests to identify pathological personalities or people unsuitable for policing. The goal is to identify and exclude those who should not join the department. The MMPI is a key tool for this purpose.
Frequently used personality inventories
The two most frequently used personality inventories in police screening are the MMPI and the IPI.
π Definition β MMPI (Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory): A standardized questionnaire developed at the University of Minnesota in 1940. It is one of the most popular clinical psychology personality inventories, with almost 70% of police psychologists administering it. The test has 567 items that generate 6 validity scales and 10 basic clinical/personality scales: Hypochondriasis, Depression, Hysteria, Psychopathic Deviate, Masculinity-Femininity, Paranoia, Psychasthenia, Schizophrenia, Hypomania, and Social Introversion.
Limitations of MMPI: While useful for screening out people with pathology, the MMPI is not necessarily a good predictor of actual police performance.
π Definition β IPI (Inwald Personality Inventory) : A 310-question "true-false" inventory specifically designed for the selection of law enforcement personnel. It was developed in response to the specific requirements of the public safety selection process and has 26 scales. It has better face validity (it appears to be a reasonable and well-designed way to measure what it is supposed to measure).
π‘ Why this matters: The shift from using the general MMPI to also using specialized tools like the IPI shows the increasing sophistication of forensic psychology in creating tests tailored to the specific demands of police work.
β Key Takeaways
Police psychology is a vital subfield of forensic psychology because the stressful and demanding nature of police work requires psychological support and expertise. While early research suggested police had low IQs, later studies showed that education is the critical factor for intelligent policing, leading to formal recommendations for psychological screening. The primary goal of personality testing in police selection has shifted from attempting to "screen in" an ideal personality type (a failed goal due to individual differences) to "screening out" individuals with pathologies. Two key tests used for this purpose are the MMPI, a general clinical inventory, and the IPI, a test developed specifically for law enforcement selection. The evolution of US police departments over the 20th century shows a clear trend towards widespread adoption of these psychological principles.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Who is considered America's first full-time police psychologist, and when was he hired by the LAPD?
- What was the main conclusion drawn by Louis Terman and Louis Thurstone from their early IQ testing of police officers, and what contradictory finding did Maude Merrill later report?
- According to Poland (1978), what is the "key to success" for improving police intelligence and performance?
- Distinguish between the goals of "screening in" and "screening out" in police personality assessment. Which goal is considered more reasonable and why?
- Name the two most frequently used personality inventories in police screening and state one key difference between them (e.g., their origin, number of items, or specific purpose).
π Lecture 4 β Police Psychology
π Overview: This lecture examines two critical issues in policingβexcessive use of force and corruptionβand explores how forensic psychology can help address them. It covers personality profiles linked to misconduct, strategies for combating corruption through personnel selection and training, and the vital role of police counseling and stress management in maintaining officer wellbeing and integrity.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining and analyzing the issue of excessive use of force in policing, including the two personality types (Antisocial and Ineffectual) associated with such behavior, as identified by Bartol (1982). It then discusses police corruption, noting its global prevalence and the role of forensic psychology in addressing it through personnel selection, training, and police counseling/on-duty stress management. The personnel selection section details a PERSEREC study correlating personality traits from instruments like MMPI-2 and 16-PF with corrupt behavior. The training section focuses on developing empathy and a customer service attitude. Finally, the lecture defines stress, outlines its sources (organizational, external, task-related, personal), and highlights its impact on officers and their families.
π Lecture Summary
Issues of police
The lecture identifies two major police issues: use of excessive force and corruption.
Use of excessive force
Use of excessive force is described as an unacceptable behavior. π Definition β Excessive force: "When the level of force exceeds the level considered justifiable under the circumstances, it is called excessive force." π Example: In a park, a woman called the police because young boys refused to stop playing cricket. When one boy resisted, policemen caught and beat him badly, ultimately beating him to death. This was excessive force because a warning or simple arrest would have been sufficient. A psychologist can help determine if force was excessive and recommend a remedy.
Research by Bartol (1982) found that police applicants who score low on personality tests and later become involved in excessive force, misconduct, accidents, or deadly force tend to fall into two groups:
- Antisocial Personality β characterized by narcissism, suspiciousness, cynicism, tough-mindedness, insensitivity, defensiveness, rigidity, irritability, resentfulness, sensation seeking, and hyperactivity.
- Ineffectual Personality β characterized by indecisiveness, introversion, dependency, cautiousness, oversensitivity, and tended to be quiet individuals who went through the motions and failed to make a difference on the street.
Corruption
The lecture emphasizes that police are not the only corrupt department, nor are Pakistani police uniquely corrupt; no single country in the world is without corruption. Police are often perceived as more corrupt because of their frequent interaction with society. The application of psychology to law enforcement and public safety is a rapidly growing area, though the field suffers from an identity complex.
π Forensic psychology can help combat police corruption at three levels:
- Personnel Selection
- Training Level
- Police Counseling and On duty Stress Management
Strategies to combat with the corruption of police
Personnel Selection
Personnel selection involves using personality test results to help selection boards with "screening-in" or "screening-out" candidates. However, many personality tests are not good predictors of honesty or corrupt behavior.
The PERSEREC Study examined correlations between personality traits (measured by the MMPI-2, IPI, 16-PF, and CPI) and employees who were forced to resign, fired, disciplined, or prosecuted. Personality traits with high correlation to police corruption included:
MMPI-2:
- Lying: .32
- Hypochondriasis: .31
- Paranoia: .34
- Problematic Anger: .39
- Imperturbability: .41
16-PF:
- Tough Poise: .23
- Overly Shrewd: .22
- Overenthusiastic: .28
- Bold: .28
- Adjustment Problems: .20
IPI:
- Trouble with the Law: .29
- Antisocial Attitudes: .24
- Family Conflicts: .32
CPI:
- Capacity for Status: .20
- Good Impression: .28
- Independence: .22
An American agency found that immaturity, unreliability, and irresponsibility at a young age were the best predictors of corrupt behavior. However, identification of these traits does not guarantee honest behavior, as many officers with these traits did not become corrupt, and some without them did.
Training level
Once desired traits are identified, they can be improved at the training level through:
- Designing training programs by applying psychological principles: Psychologists understand teaching and learning principles and can help design effective programs.
- Basic things to develop during training: a. Empathy: π Definition β Empathy refers to the "appreciation of another's problems and feelings without experiencing the same emotional reaction. To be distinguished from sympathy that is usually nonobjective and non-critical." A policeman must learn to be empathetic: "Seek first to understand, and then to be understood." Training in empathy helps understand community problems, maintain a good police image, and handle corrupt behavior. b. Customer service attitude: π Definition β Customer service attitude is a positive attitude toward the customer that is evident through both verbal and nonverbal communication. π Positive attitude can be defined as a helpful state of mind or feeling regarding a situation or fact. Skilled professionals require utmost skill, tact, diplomacy, and a positive attitude. A positive attitude is deeply rooted in character, but encouraged character aspects can be learned through practice and willingness to change. Training for customer service attitude can help improve police behavior.
π‘ Why this matters: Developing empathy and customer service skills directly reduces community conflict and can help prevent both excessive force incidents and corruption by building trust and positive officer-community relationships.
Police Counseling and on duty Stress Management
Police counseling is a common function for the police psychologist. Officers often receive free, in-house counseling due to the stressful nature of their job. Confidentiality can be an issue, so external counseling sources are sometimes used.
Stress management
Police stress is perhaps the most common problem a police psychologist deals with. Other problems include compassion fatigue, marital problems, alcoholism, and suicide. PTSD (Post-Shooting Traumatic Response) or burnout are common, as is "burst stress" β where there is no steady stressor; officers go from periods of complete calm to high activity in sudden bursts (like a military "hurry up and wait" drill).
The families of police officers also suffer vicarious occupational stress β from unpredictability, shift work, fear (of death, injury, kidnapping), isolation, and low pay. Children of officers are held to higher community standards, and spouses struggle with communication. Relationships in police families are often distant (NIJ, 1991).
π Definition β Stress: "Stress is mental or physical tension that results from physical, emotional, or chemical causes. It is emotionally disruptive or upsetting condition occurring in response to adverse external stimuli and is capable of affecting physical and mental health which can be characterized by increased heart rate, a rise in blood pressure, muscular tension, irritability and depression."
Police work requires incredible restraint ("BUT YOU CAN'T"), and demands for greater control have increased stress effects. Police suicide has received recent media attention, leading to reviews on the topic.
Types of police stressors
Stressors Internal to the Police Organization:
- Poor supervision (too lenient/too tough)
- Insufficient training
- Absence of upward mobility
- Absence of an extrinsic reward system
- Offensive (annoying & silly) policies and procedures
- Excessive paperwork
- Bad equipment
- Poor salary
- Shift work (night duties)
Stressors external to the police organization:
- Absence of career development & lateral entry
- Ineffective criminal justice system
- Biased press and media influence
- Derogatory remarks of laymen
- Political interference
Stressors task-related to police work:
- Role conflict and strain
- Rotating shift work
- Fear and danger involved in job
- Giving up cases to the detective division
- Victim pain & anguish
- Employee review boards
Stressors Associated with Personal Problems:
- Marital and family relationships (like divorce, and/or other familial problems)
- Health problems
- Addictions
- Peer group pressure
- Depression
- Harassment
- Lack of accomplishment
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that excessive use of force is defined by the level exceeding what is justifiable, and Bartol (1982) identified two personality profiles β Antisocial and Ineffectual β associated with such misconduct. For combating corruption, the PERSEREC study correlated specific traits (e.g., paranoia, problematic anger, antisocial attitudes) from tests like MMPI-2 and 16-PF with corrupt behavior, though no test guarantees prediction. Training in empathy and customer service attitude can improve police behavior and reduce corruption. Finally, police experience multiple types of stress β organizational, external, task-related, and personal β affecting both officers and their families, making stress management and police counseling essential functions of forensic psychology in law enforcement.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of excessive force as taught in this lecture?
- What are the two personality types identified by Bartol (1982) that are associated with excessive use of force?
- Name the four personality test instruments used in the PERSEREC Study to predict corruption tendencies.
- List three personality traits from the MMPI-2 that showed high correlation with police corruption.
- What are the three levels at which forensic psychology can help combat police corruption?
π Lecture 05 β Police Psychology
π Overview: This lecture explores the psychological aspects of police work, focusing on the trauma officers experience after shooting incidents, the procedures for evaluating an officer's fitness for duty, and the phenomenon of false confessions. Understanding these topics is crucial for forensic psychologists who support law enforcement and the justice system.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three main areas: Post Shooting Traumatic Response (PSTR), including its symptoms and psychological support; Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation (FFDE), detailing its procedure and criteria set by the IACP; and False Confessions, explaining their types (voluntary, coerced-compliant, coerced-internalized) and the reasons behind them.
π Lecture Summary
PSTR (Post Shooting Traumatic Response)
This section introduces Post Shooting Traumatic Response (PSTR) , which is a collection of emotions and psychological response patterns that may occur after a police officer shoots a person in the line of duty. It is similar to Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) , an anxiety disorder triggered by memories of a traumatic event. PSTR is more likely if the victim dies, but not everyone involved in a shooting experiences it. The psychologist's role is important for long-term, continuously-monitored support. Officers may be furious at the person they shot, their department, colleagues, or society. Psychologists may recommend a leave of absence or administrative duties, and they help determine when an officer is ready to resume normal duties. Many departments are experimenting with peer group counseling for such incidents.
π Definition β Post Shooting Traumatic Response (PSTR) : A collection of emotions and psychological response patterns that may occur after a police officer shoots a person in the line of duty. π Example: A police officer who shoots a bank robber who was about to shoot an innocent victim may experience PSTR.
Symptoms of Post Shooting Traumatic Response (PSTR) β According to Bartol & Bartol (2004), symptoms may include:
- Perceptual distortions of time, sight and sound
- Enhanced Sense of danger
- Anger
- Sleep difficulties
- Isolation/ withdrawal
- Flashbacks
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these symptoms helps psychologists identify and support officers who may be struggling after a traumatic shooting event.
Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation (FFDE)
This section discusses Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation (FFDE) , a psychological assessment done as standard procedure for officers in high-stress positions like SWAT (Special Weapons and Tactics) teams, undercover, narcotics, vice, or internal affairs. These assessments are typically done on a yearly basis to ensure officers are "fit" to continue working. An FFDE can be ordered by any upper-rank employee on a lower-rank employee when the lower-rank employee engages in "suspicious" behavior that raises serious questions about their fitness for public safety work. The role of the psychologist is critical and difficult because they must assess co-workers and report if someone is unfit.
π Definition β Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation (FFDE) : A psychological assessment to determine if an employee is fit to carry out public safety work.
Procedure of fitness for duty evaluation β The full ramp up required by an FFDE involves:
- Psychological screening report
- Personality tests, cognitive and ability tests
- Performance evaluations
- Use of excessive force incidents
- Formal complaints
- Shootings
- Medical records
- Frequent mental status exams
- An intensive background investigation
- The collection of testimonials by fellow officers
- Follow-up on citizen complaints
- Examination of medical records
- Internal affairs investigation
- Investigation of brain injuries
IACP (International Association of Chiefs of Police) criteria for FFDE β The IACP sets the following criteria for when an FFDE is needed:
- One or more citizen complaints regarding excessive force, inappropriate verbal conduct, or inability to exercise self control and self discipline.
- Abrupt and negative change in customary behavior.
- Irrational verbal conduct or behaviors, including delusions and hallucinations.
- Suicidal statements or behaviors, or personal expressions of mental instability.
- Unexplained and excessive tiredness or hyperactivity.
- Dramatic change in eating patterns, sudden weight loss or gain, diagnosis of life threatening disorder.
- Change in attention to personal hygiene and health.
- Inappropriate use of alcohol, medications or other drugs, including symptoms of illegal drug use.
- Memory losses
- Impatience or impulsiveness, especially with loss of temper.
- Inability to defuse tense situations, or tendency to escalate situations and create confrontations.
- Unexplained and inappropriate excessive lateness or absenteeism.
- Any other factor or combinations of factors that causes a supervisor to reasonably suspect that a fitness for duty evaluation may be necessary.
π‘ Why this matters: FFDEs protect both the public and the officer by ensuring that only psychologically fit individuals continue in high-stress law enforcement roles.
False Confessions
This section defines a false confession as occurring when a suspect in a crime admits guilt even though they are not responsible for the crime. False confessions occur regularly in law systems, prompting the establishment of "confession rules" to detect and reject them. The phenomenon occurs with sensational crimes (e.g., hundreds confessed to the Lindbergh baby kidnapping in 1932 and the Black Dahlia murder in 1947) and unsolved crimes. Some people confess to crimes they couldn't have committed, including those not even born at the time.
π Definition β False Confession: A suspect in a crime admits guilt to the crime, even though he or she is not responsible for the crime.
Types of false confessions β Kassin's (1997) typology lists three types:
- Voluntary
- Coerced (which includes two subtypes: coerced-compliant and coerced-internalized)
1. Voluntary confessions β These occur without police pressure, often for attention seeking and publicity. Few people falsely confess just to seek fame or recognition or impress others, usually coming forward in celebrity cases. Another reason is protection of others β people falsely confess to protect their valuable dear ones, e.g., a younger brother falsely confesses to save his elder brother who was the sole earner for the family.
2. Coerced false confessions β These result from compelling a person to involuntarily behave in a certain way through threats, intimidation, or some other form of pressure or force. Coercion may involve actual infliction of physical or psychological harm. Coerced confessions are initiated by police because of pressure from higher authorities to solve the case or to show success for promotions.
Coerced-compliant false confessions β People confess to just get the police interrogation over with or to avoid being prosecuted for a crime elsewhere with stiffer penalties.
Coerced-internalized false confessions β People come forward and really believe they did the crime because of guilt out of interrogation or persuasion. Innocent, tired, and confused people are highly psychologically vulnerable to these types of confessions. If two persons are equally exposed to same type of coercion, one can internalize false confession because of these factors.
Techniques used for police interrogation β Police of various countries use different typical techniques for interrogations like: β’ Use of excessive force β’ Threats β’ Sleep deprivation β’ Physical and psychological torture
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding false confessions helps forensic psychologists identify vulnerable individuals and assist the legal system in preventing wrongful convictions.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture covers three critical areas for forensic psychologists working with police. First, Post Shooting Traumatic Response (PSTR) is a trauma reaction similar to PTSD that officers may experience after shooting someone in the line of duty, with symptoms including perceptual distortions, anger, sleep difficulties, and flashbacks. Second, Fitness-for-Duty Evaluations (FFDE) are periodic psychological assessments for officers in high-stress positions, with specific IACP criteria that must trigger an evaluation, such as excessive force complaints, suicidal statements, or abrupt behavioral changes. Third, false confessions occur regularly and come in three types: voluntary (for attention or to protect others), coerced-compliant (to end interrogation), and coerced-internalized (where the person actually believes they committed the crime due to psychological vulnerability). The psychologist plays a crucial role in assessing officers after shootings, determining fitness for duty, and understanding why innocent people confess.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six symptoms of Post Shooting Traumatic Response (PSTR) according to Bartol & Bartol?
- What is the difference between a voluntary false confession and a coerced false confession?
- List five of the IACP criteria that would trigger a Fitness-for-Duty Evaluation (FFDE).
- What is the difference between a coerced-compliant false confession and a coerced-internalized false confession?
- Why do some people voluntarily confess to crimes they did not commit?