๐ Lecture 06 โ Investigative Psychology
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces Investigative Psychology as a scientific approach to criminal investigation, contrasting it with traditional subjective profiling methods. It covers the fundamental concepts of profiling, its components, applications in counter-terrorism, and the various limitations and ethical concerns associated with profiling techniques.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture defines Investigative Psychology and its two main approaches: clinical/subjective and empirical/logical. It outlines the eight steps of criminal investigation, explains the concept of profiling with its basic components, provides historical examples like witch profiling, discusses computerized profiling (CAPPS) and hijacker profiles from the 1970s, and examines different types of profiling including geographic, racial, and criminal profiling, concluding with the limits of profiling.
๐ Lecture Summary
Investigative Psychology
Investigative Psychology is a new area of applied psychology that brings together issues in the recovery of investigative information, the drawing of inferences about that information, and the ways police decision making can be supported through scientific research. Inferences about the characteristics of the offender are made to identify him, focusing on what type of persons can commit specific types of crimes. Important behavioral features of crime are identified that may help make out and prosecute the crime successfully.
๐ Definition โ Investigative Psychology: The term given to a new area of applied Psychology that brings together issues in the recovery of investigative information, the drawing of inferences about that information, and the ways in which police decision making can be supported through various systems derived from scientific research.
๐ Example: A dead body is found with a knife in the right hand along with a suicidal note. Investigation uncovered that the murdered man was left-handed, although the knife was found in his right hand. When interviewing family, only the wife stressed that her husband was under stress and not mentally healthy, whereas other sources (friends, family members, neighbors, and written records like diaries and letters) depicted the man as quite happy and satisfied. These behavioral features led to incorporating his wife into the list of suspects.
Two Approaches to Investigation
There are two approaches to investigate a criminal case:
- Clinical / Subjective Approach
- Empirical and Logical Approach
Clinical / Subjective Approach: Traditional police profiling which grew out of the experience of police officers offering opinions and making judgments to their colleagues about the possible characteristics of unknown offenders. This approach emphasizes subjective processes such as "thinking like the criminal phenomenon".
Empirical and Logical Approach: In contrast, Investigative Psychology originates directly out of empirical research and logical illation to cover the full range of investigative activities, not only the preparation of profiles. Important behavioral features of crime are identified that may help make out and prosecute the crime successfully. The assumption processes contrast with the subjective approach; Investigative Psychology stresses that the results of scientific psychology can contribute to many aspects of civilian and criminal investigation, including the full range of crimes from robbery to terrorism, not just intense crimes of violence with an obvious psychopathic component.
Investigations are done with the help of research findings and statistical analysis. The contribution to investigations draws on the extent to which an offender displays various tested characteristics. Investigative Psychology research is determining behaviorally important and empirically supported information regarding the consistency and variability of the behavior of many different types of offenders.
Eight Steps of Criminal Investigation
A criminal investigation roughly consists of the following eight steps:
- Determine if a crime has been committed.
- Verify the jurisdictional and statutory authority before beginning a thorough and systematic inquiry.
- Discover all the facts and collect the evidence.
- Recover any stolen property, if any.
- Identify the executors or culprits.
- Locate and apprehend the culprits.
- Aid the prosecution by providing evidence of guilt admissible in court.
- Testify effectively as a witness in court.
Narrowly, Investigative Psychology is a term referring to methods of identifying key features of a crime and the likely characteristics of the perpetrator. In short, investigative psychology is profiling, and in some instances, profiling is used to summarize the psychological features of persons who may commit a crimeโin this sense, profiling is prediction. Inferences about the characteristics of the offender are made to identify him, and assumptions are made about whether there are other crimes likely to have been committed by the same person.
Profiling
Profiling is the psychological sketch of the unknown criminal and is mostly used to narrow down an investigation to those suspects who possess certain behavioral and personality features that are revealed by the way a crime was committed. The primary goal is to aid local police in limiting and rectifying their suspect list so they can direct their resources where they might do the most good. Profiling in itself does not identify a specific suspect, reveal a certain individual, or give an address or phone number. Instead, a Psychological Sketch is a general biographical description of the most likely type of unknown suspect.
๐ Definition โ Profiling: The psychological sketch of the unknown criminal, mostly used to narrow down an investigation to those suspects who possess certain behavioral and personality features revealed by the way a crime was committed.
Basic Components of a Profile:
- Probable AGE of suspect
- Probable SEX of suspect
- Probable RACE of suspect
- Probable RESIDENCE of suspect
- What INTELLIGENCE level the suspect is operating at
- The probable OCCUPATION of suspect
- The probable MARITAL STATUS of suspect
- The probable LIVING ARRANGEMENTS of suspect
- The PSYCHOSEXUAL MATURITY of the suspect
- The probable TYPE AND CONDITION OF VEHICLE driven by the suspect
- The suspect's probable MOTIVATING FACTORS
- The probable ARREST RECORD of the suspect
- What PROVOCATION FACTORS might drive the suspect out?
- What INTERROGATION TECHNIQUES would work best with the suspect?
๐ Example: Profile of a Witch (Kramer & Sprenger 1971)
- Elderly female beyond child bearing range
- Poor
- Lives on edge of town
- Displays knowledge of herbal medicines
- Contains the Mark of the Devil on her body
- Steals men's potency, causing impotence in the surrounding areas
Prevent Terrorism: The same psychological sketch of a criminal is made but to prevent future crime and terrorism.
Computerized Profiling
Contemporary uses of computerized profiling can be found in USA Airline Security. The airline industry used CAPPS (Computer Assisted Passenger Prescreening System), an automated system which scores each airline passenger's profile to identify drug dealers and potential terrorists or who might pose a threat to civil aviation. 10 out of the 19 hijackers in the 9/11 attack were identified via the CAPPS system (unfortunately, nothing much was done about it).
CAPPS is sensitive to the following traveling patterns:
- One-way tickets: Under the light of past terrorist activities, terrorists are more likely to buy one-way tickets.
- Pay in cash: In Pakistan, paying in cash is quite frequent, but in the US usually people pay through cards, so paying in cash can be considered a reason of black money.
- Travel alone: Terrorists usually do not travel with the family.
- Persistent patterns: A very important factor is the persistent patterns of traveling; a suspected person always buys one-way tickets, always pays in cash, and travels alone.
Is It Successful? CAPPS did flag two of the four hijackers of flight AA 77 as suspicious when they checked in at Dulles Airport on September 11, 2001. Their bags were searched but they were not given a personal search.
The Problem of False Positives: Many times passengers face the problem of false positive; in simple terms, a false positive normally means that a test claims something to be positive when that is not the case. For example, a CAPPS identifying a person as a terrorist when they actually are not.
๐ Definition โ False Positive: A test claims something to be positive when that is not the case; e.g., CAPPS identifying a person as terrorist when they are not.
The September 9/11 incident of terrorism changed the way psychologists view terrorism. After the incident, it was realized that only a traveling profile is not enough, and for further data, psychologists were asked for deeper profiling. Cameras were fixed to record the behavior of people at airports, and a deeper profile came forward to avoid the chances of errors:
- Dressing pattern and clothes
- Nationality
- Travel history
- Behavior at airport
- Books purchased at airport
- Cultural and social background
The Hijacking Epidemic
From 1968 to 1978, a much heightened crime was plane hijacking in the US. There was a hijacking epidemic and hundreds of local flights were hijacked and diverted to Cuba:
- In 1968, 36 hijackings, 20 of which were US planes diverted to Cuba
- In 1969, 71 hijackings, 58 diverted to Cuba
- In 1970, 69 hijackings
The Profile in the 1970s: Psychologists prepared profiles of hijackers and identified that they were:
- Unsuccessful Members of Society
- Socially Inadequate
- Unsteady Occupational Patterns
- Occupational Problems
- Lacking in Resourcefulness
- Feelings of Helplessness & Hopelessness
- Suicidal
- Unconscious desire to gain control over the world
But this profiling is no longer valid at international levels. Nowadays, terrorists do not fit the earlier profiling and no terrorist has a typical profileโthey are socially adequate, have girlfriends, are happily married with children, and have stable businesses or jobs.
Criminal Profiling
Another form of profiling relevant to police work is criminal profiling, like who is the offender? Or what place or person can be the next target of a criminal act.
๐ Definition โ Criminal Profiling: A form of profiling relevant to police work that seeks to identify who the offender is and/or what place or person can be the next target of a criminal act.
Geographic Profiling
Geographic profiling is an investigative aid that predicts the offender's most likely location (i.e., home, work, social venues, and travel routes).
๐ Definition โ Geographic Profiling: An investigative aid that predicts the offender's most likely location, including home, work, social venues, and travel routes.
Racial Profiling
Racial profiling is police-initiated action that relies on race, ethnicity, or national origin rather than the behavior of an individual or information that leads the police to a particular criminal. It is the inclusion of race as a primary determinant in the characterization of a person considered likely to commit a particular type of crime.
"Driving While Black" is a parody of the real crime "driving while intoxicated"; it refers to the idea that a driver can be pulled over by a police officer simply because he or she is black and then questioned or searched and charged with a niggling or perhaps non-existent offense. This concept stems from a long history of racism in the United States and other countries and is generally a reference to racial profiling as employed by many police forces.
๐ Definition โ Racial Profiling: Police-initiated action that relies on race, ethnicity, or national origin rather than behavior or information that leads police to a particular criminal; the inclusion of race as a primary determinant in characterizing a person considered likely to commit a particular crime.
Limits of Profiling
There are several limits of profiling. Profiling requires lots of training and experience, yet many experts state that profiling cannot be taught or learned as it is an art. With all sophistications, a profiler can only give an ambiguous sketch and cannot tell about anything certainly; it can hardly ever directly point to an individual. Even the most sophisticated profiling can only yield some judgment of probabilities. Old profiles have failed because of ever-changing types and styles of terrorists and terrorism acts. It tends to eliminate a large number of people from investigation, and innocent people are suspectedโthis could be problematic as sometimes profiles misguide (e.g., according to profile, suspect is 20 years old Black, while crime was committed by a 40-year-old White).
Two major limits are:
- Individual differences
- Unpredictability (Will be discussed in detail in the next lecture)
โญ Key Takeaways
Investigative Psychology differs fundamentally from clinical/subjective profiling by relying on empirical research and statistical analysis rather than intuition. Profiling provides a general psychological sketch to narrow suspect lists but cannot directly identify specific individuals. Computerized profiling systems like CAPPS, while useful, suffer from false positives and require deeper behavioral analysis beyond simple travel patterns. Historical profiles (like 1970s hijackers) become obsolete as terrorist demographics and behaviors change significantly. The major limitations of profiling include individual differences in criminal behavior and inherent unpredictability, along with ethical concerns such as racial profiling (e.g., "Driving While Black").
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main approaches to criminal investigation discussed in this lecture, and how do they differ?
- List the 14 basic components that make up a typical psychological profile of a suspect.
- What is CAPPS, what traveling patterns does it screen for, and what is the "false positive" problem associated with it?
- How did the profile of hijackers from the 1970s differ from modern terrorists?
- Define racial profiling and provide one example of how it manifests in policing.
๐ Lecture 7 โ Media Hype vs. Reality
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the practical realities of investigative psychology, contrasting media portrayals with actual forensic practice. It covers the typology of crime scenes (organized, disorganized, mixed), the phenomena of trophy taking and staging, the method of psychological autopsy, and the inherent limitations of profiling and psychological autopsy due to individual differences and the unpredictability of human behavior.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by debunking media myths about forensic psychology, then defines and characterizes organized, disorganized, and mixed crime scenes. It discusses trophy taking and staging as offender behaviors, followed by an in-depth explanation of psychological autopsy, including its methods and the types of deaths. The lecture concludes by outlining the procedure for equivocal death analysis and critically examining the limitations of both profiling and psychological autopsy, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach.
๐ Lecture Summary
Media Hype vs. Reality
Media portrayals of forensic psychologists, as seen in films like "Silence of the Lambs," are not accurate depictions. Forensic psychologists cannot become psychically linked with killers. In reality, there are more misses than hits, and the success rate is not higher than chance. Forensic psychology is a scientific discipline with limitations, and career opportunities, though increasing, are limited.
Crime Scene Typology
Crime scenes can be divided into three categories: organized, disorganized, and mixed.
1. Organized Crime Scenes An organized crime scene shows planning, forethought, and an exertion to avoid detection. The offender knows what he is doing and takes steps to avoid leaving evidence. The victim is selected, not random. Characteristics include a planned offense, transported and hidden body, controlled conversation, demands a submissive victim, missing weapon or evidence, victim is a targeted stranger, personalizes the victim, crime scene reflects control, restraints used, and aggressive acts done before death.
2. Disorganized Crime Scenes A disorganized crime scene shows no planning or premeditation. The motive is impulse, rage, or an intense emotional state, resulting in a chaotic scene. The victim is selected at random and is often at the wrong place at the wrong time. The offender uses materials at hand for a hurried, blitz-style attack. Characteristics include the body left at the death scene, spontaneous offense, evidence or weapon present, victim or location known, body left in view, depersonalizes the victim, minimal conversation, a sloppy crime scene, and sudden violence.
3. Mixed Crime Scene A mixed crime scene shows characteristics from both organized and disorganized scenes. This can indicate two offenders, or that the offender planned the crime but was interrupted during the act, causing it to deteriorate into a disorganized state. For example, during a planned robbery, an unplanned murder of a resistant victim occurs.
๐ก Why this matters: According to Kocsis, Cooksey & Irwin (2002), the organized-disorganized typology has limited usefulness. In reality, crime scenes exist along a continuum, from perfectly organized to absolutely chaotic, making distinction difficult.
Trophy Taking
The violent, repetitive offender often exhibits trophy taking, a criminal conduct that goes beyond the actions needed to commit the crime. A crime scene trophy is a meaningful souvenir taken to remember the incident, psychologically control the victim, or both. This can include pieces of clothing, photographs, jewelry, or even a body part, serving as a signature and a challenge to authorities.
๐ Definition โ Trophy Taking: Taking a meaningful souvenir from a crime scene that goes beyond the actions needed to commit the crime, used to remember the incident and control the victim.
Staging
Staging is the purposeful alteration of a crime and crime scene by the offender to mislead authorities and redirect the investigation. It is a conscious criminal action to ruin an investigation. The person who stages a scene almost always had a relationship with the victim. Motives can include insurance fraud (making a suicide look like a murder) or protecting a family member's reputation (making a murder look like a suicide).
๐ Definition โ Staging: The purposeful alteration of the crime and crime scene by the offender to mislead authorities and redirect the investigation.
Red Flags
Offenders who stage crime scenes often make mistakes because they arrange the scene based on what they believe it should look like. Under stress and time pressure, they create inconsistencies and clues in forensic findings. These inconsistencies serve as red flags of staging, preventing investigations from becoming misguided.
Psychological Autopsy
Psychological Autopsy is the psychological reconstruction of a person's life, specifically a dead person. It is also called a psychiatric autopsy, retrospective death assessment, reconstructive evaluation, or equivocal death analysis. It is different from profiling because the profile is of a dead person and the identity is known. The term was first coined in 1977 by the Los Angeles Medical Examiner's Office to investigate suicide cases (Shneidman, 1977).
๐ Definition โ Psychological Autopsy: A specific method for examining the life of a dead person to determine the manner and circumstances of their death.
Elements involved in a psychological autopsy:
- History: Alcohol/drug history, stress history, medical/family medical history, recent stressors, military, employment, educational, sexual, and dietary history.
- Interpersonal relationships: Writings, books/music, websites visited, phone calls, conversations, interests/hobbies, and old/current enemies.
- Reactions by parties to the victim's death: Degree of lethality, early warning signs, and who may have intended harm.
- Assessment of intention about the decedent's role in their own demise: Including sub-intentional, covert, or unconscious roles.
- Socio-emotional state of the victim: Fantasies, dreams, thoughts, premonitions, fears, phobias, mood swings, mental status, concentration, judgment, and IQ.
Types of Deaths The five generally accepted manners of death are: Natural, Accident, Suicide, Homicide, and Undetermined.
Clarification of Equivocal Death Analysis
Equivocal death investigations are inquiries open to two or more interpretations. The facts may be purposely vague or misleading, as in a staged crime scene. The manner of death is open to question, resembling murder, suicide, accident, or natural causes. The forensic psychologist's role is difficult and important.
๐ Definition โ Equivocal Death Analysis: The investigation of deaths that are open to two or more interpretations, where the facts may be vague or misleading.
Purpose of Equivocal Death Analysis To uncover the reality behind vague and undetermined facts. In the US, insurance companies hire detectives and forensic psychologists to find the real reason for deaths. Forensic psychologists make reconstructions of the person to uncover the truth.
Reconstruction Involves the use of the scientific method, logical reasoning, sources of information, experience, or skill to interpret events surrounding a crime. Bevel & Gardner (2001) define it as "determining the most probable sequence of events." It begins with a walk-through of the crime scene, imitating possible events to prove or disprove any sequence.
๐ Definition โ Reconstruction: Determining the most probable sequence of events surrounding the commission of a crime.
Procedure of Equivocal Death Analysis Psychologists garner information through:
- Conducting interviews with family members and people who knew the deceased.
- Examination of personal documents (suicide notes, diaries, letters).
- Post-mortem reports.
- Medical reports.
- Police reports.
US Military and Equivocal Death Analysis Any death on military property or of military personnel undergoes an equivocal death analysis. This is done not for insurance but to ensure no foul play occurred and to improve conditions.
Limits of Profiling and Psychological Autopsy
There are two distinct limitations of profiling and psychological autopsies: individual differences and unpredictability of human behavior.
1. Individual Differences No two human beings are alike, and knowledge about human nature is very limited. Life is not simple, even in death. Despite new technologies, awareness remains limited.
2. Unpredictability of Human Behavior Human behavior is undeterminable and unpredictable. For example, a lifelong criminal may suddenly seek forgiveness and become spiritual, while a pious man may commit a crime like child molestation. Statistical and scientific approaches can mislead in such cases. The caution is to "never leave the element of unpredictability." Also, social class distinctions can lead to biased suspicion (e.g., assuming a servant stole).
A Major Limitation of the Clinical/Subjective Approach: The court does not believe in psychological proofs or intuitions and demands physical, strong clues. For forensic psychology to work effectively, a balance of the statistical and clinical approaches is needed. Instincts can lead to evidence, so intuition must be integrated with statistical probabilities. The better idea is to start with science and then make it artistic.
โญ Key Takeaways
For your exam, you must remember the three crime scene typologies and their key characteristics, especially the contrast between organized (planned, controlled) and disorganized (impulsive, chaotic). Understand the concepts of trophy taking and staging, including the red flags that reveal staging. Be able to define psychological autopsy and describe its five procedural elements and the five types of death. The most critical, higher-order takeaway is the two major limitations of profiling and psychological autopsyโindividual differences and unpredictabilityโand why a balanced approach (science first, then art) is necessary.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of crime scenes, and what is the key difference between an organized and a disorganized crime scene?
- How is "trophy taking" different from "staging"?
- What is the "red flag" of a staged crime scene?
- What is the primary purpose and procedure of a psychological autopsy in an equivocal death analysis?
- What are the two main limitations of profiling and psychological autopsy, and why is a combined clinical-statistical approach recommended?
๐ Lecture 8 โ PSYCHOLOGY OF VIOLENCE
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces psychological models of violence, beginning with the psychoanalytical model developed by Sigmund Freud. It explores the structure of personality (Id, Ego, Superego), the role of unconscious motivation, life and death instincts, and the psychosexual stages of development. Understanding these foundational concepts is critical for analyzing aggressive and violent behavior from a psychoanalytic perspective.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers an overview of six psychological models of violence (psychoanalytical, behavioral, humanistic, social cognitive, attachment theory, and psychobiological), then focuses exclusively on the psychoanalytical model. Key topics include Freudโs discovery of the unconscious mind, the law of conservation of energy applied to behavior, the structural model of personality (Id, Ego, Superego), the instincts of Eros and Thanatos, and the five psychosexual stages of development from oral through genital stages, including the Oedipus and Electra complexes.
๐ Lecture Summary
Psychological models of violence
Various theories explain why humans do things, why they fail to do what they should, and why they do what they should not. These theories examine how people learn, feel, think, and react differently to different situations. Six important models are listed: Psychoanalytical model, Behavioral Model, Humanistic Model, Social cognitive model, Attachment theory model, and Psychobiological model.
Psychoanalytical Model
Sigmund Freud grounded this perspective in the 1890s by writing about the unconscious; he was the first to discover the unconscious mind. According to Freud, the unconscious is the area of the psyche where unknown wishes and needs are kept that play a significant role in our conscious behavior. Freud believed that the majority of what we experienceโunderlying emotions, beliefs, feelings, and impulsesโare not available to us at a conscious level. Most of what drives us is buried in our unconscious.
Unconscious motivation plays a prominent role in Freud's theories. According to Freud, most human behavior is the result of desires, impulses, and memories that have been repressed into an unconscious state, yet still influence actions. Freud believed the human mind consists of a tiny conscious part available for direct observation and a much larger subconscious portion that plays an even more important role in determining behaviorโpeople often do not know why they show any behavior.
๐ Example: A reasonable man went to meet a lady. At the conscious level, the man totally does not admit or realize that he has romantic feelings about that lady. But at the end of the meeting, when he was on his way back home, he remembered that he left his keys at the girl's home and went back to pick them up. Freud would explain this as a trick and planning of his unconscious to make him go back to the lady's house again.
Law of Conservation of Energy
In physics, the law of conservation of energy states that energy cannot be remade, created, or destroyed (made to disappear to nowhere) and that energy can be changed from one form to another (e.g., illuminating a bulb using energy from falling water). This idea inspired Freud, and he applied the same concept to human behavior. When applied to the unconscious mind, we become aware that our unconscious wishes are not destroyed but transformed. We suppress a drive, and it will appear in some other way.
๐ก Why this matters: This explains why suppressed urges do not simply vanishโthey resurface in disguised forms, such as dreams, slips of the tongue, or even violent acts.
Structural Model
According to Freud, our personality consists of three parts: Id, Ego, and Superego.
Id: Id is a Greek word. According to Freud, we are born with the Id, an important part of our personality because as newborns, it allows us to get our basic needs met. Freud believed the id is based on our pleasure principle. The id wants whatever feels good at the time, with no consideration for the reality of the situation. When a child is hungry, the id wants food, so the child cries. When the child needs to be changed, is uncomfortable, in pain, too hot, too cold, or just wants attention, the id speaks up until needs are met. The id doesn't care about reality or the needs of anyone elseโonly its own satisfaction. Babies are not considerate of their parents' wishes. When the id wants something, nothing else is important. In immature people, the Id is dominant.
Superego: As a person grows, parents and society start to control them. The concept of right and wrong is taughtโthis is called the emergence of the superego. The superego is the moral part of us and develops due to the moral and ethical restraints placed on us by parents or caregivers. Many equate the superego with the conscience, as it dictates our belief of right and wrong. The child internalizes the parents and makes them part of the self.
๐ Example: Parents were leaving for work and forbade their children to take candies from the cupboard. When parents left, the three-year-old brother tried to open the cupboard door to take candies, but the elder brother warned him, "Do not eat candies, this is wrong." In this instance, the elder brother has internalized his parents, and his superego is playing the role of his parents.
Ego: The Id always leaves you in trouble and least bothers about consequences (like jumping on beds or eating ice cream with a sore throat). The basic aim of the Id is to seek pleasure, but on the contrary, the superego is against pleasure and serves as a constant watchman. Since survival is difficult with this constant conflict, the conflict gives birth to another part Freud called the Ego. It creates balance between Id and Superego, starts from childhood, emerges as a mediator, and comes from survival instincts.
The ego is based on the reality principle and works at the conscious level. It tries to balance the Id's and Superego's demands through logical and rational thinking. The ego understands that other people have needs and desires and that being impulsive or selfish can hurt us in the long run. The ego's job is to meet the needs of the Id while taking into consideration the reality of the situation. In a healthy person, according to Freud, the ego is the strongest so it can satisfy the needs of the Id, not upset the Superego, and still take into consideration the reality of every situation. If the Id gets too strong, impulses and self-gratification take over a person's life. If the Superego becomes too strong, the person would be driven by rigid morals, judgmental and unbending in interactions with the world.
Instincts
Freud believed humans were driven by two conflicting central desires: Eros and Thanatos.
๐ Definition โ Eros: Eros is a Greek word meaning god of love and sexual desire. Eros is the pleasure and life instinct. Freud's description included all creative, life-producing drives.
๐ Definition โ Thanatos: Thanatos is the death drive or death instinct, representing an urge inherent in all living things to return to a state of calm, or ultimately of non-existence. It represents the quest for pleasure balanced with the destructive urge.
Freud took the idea of three aspects of personality from Hinduism's concept of trinity: Brahma (creator), Vishnu (maintainer), and Shiva (destroyer). Destruction is equally important as old things are replaced by new things.
Psychosexual Development
Sigmund Freud's theory on psychosexual development set the groundwork for how personalities develop. He believed different driving forces develop during these stages, playing an important role in how we interact with the world. The stages are:
- Oral Stage (0-2 years)
- Anal Stage (2-5 years)
- Phallic Stage (5-7 years) โ Oedipus/Electra Complex
- Latency Period (7 years to Puberty)
- Genital Period (Puberty onward)
Oral Stage: The oral stage begins at birth when the oral cavity is the primary focus of pleasure. The child tests things by putting them into the mouth and preoccupies himself with nursing and the pleasure of sucking. The oral character who is frustrated at this stage (whose mother refused to nurse on demand or reduced nursing sessions early) is characterized by pessimism, envy, suspicion, and sarcasm. The overindulged oral character (whose nursing urges were always and excessively satisfied) is optimistic, gullible, and full of admiration for others. The stage culminates in the primary conflict of weaning, which deprives the child of both the sensory pleasures of nursing and the psychological pleasure of being cared for, mothered, and held. This stage lasts approximately one and one-half years.
Anal Stage: At one and one-half years, the child enters the anal stage. With toilet training comes the child's obsession with the anus and with the retention or expulsion of feces. This represents a classic conflict between the Id (deriving pleasure from expulsion) and the ego and superego (representing practical and societal pressures to control bodily functions).
The child meets the conflict between parental demands and their own desires in one of two ways:
- The child who fights takes pleasure in excreting maliciouslyโperhaps just before or after being placed on the toilet. If parents are too lenient and the child derives pleasure and success from expulsion, this character is generally messy, disorganized, reckless, careless, and defiant.
- Conversely, the character who encountered excessive parental strictness and is overindulged will develop into an anal retentive character. This character is neat, precise, orderly, careful, stingy, withholding, obstinate, meticulous, and passive-aggressive.
The resolution of the anal stage (proper toilet training) permanently affects the individual's propensities to possession and attitudes towards authority. This stage lasts from one and one-half to two years. Fixation at this stage is said to result in orderliness, meanness, stubbornness, and compulsiveness.
Phallic Stage: The phallic stage is the setting for the greatest, most crucial sexual conflict in Freud's model. The conflict, labeled the Oedipus complex (the Electra complex in women), involves the child's unconscious desire to possess the opposite-sexed parent and to eliminate/kill the same-sexed one.
๐ Definition โ Oedipus complex: Freud got the idea from a Greek tragedy about Oedipus Rex, son of King Laius of Thebes and Queen Jocasta. As a baby, Oedipus was sent to be killed because a fortune teller predicted he would kill his father and marry his mother. Instead, the baby was raised in the court of a King. While hunting, Oedipus unknowingly killed his real father. Later, he saved Thebes from a monster and married the queenโhis motherโfathering a girl. When he discovered the truth, he blinded himself with his mother's brooches. Freud concluded that the play's fame reflects a real dilemma.
Since the mother is the very first love of every child, when the boy becomes aware that his rival is his own father (who is loving and caring), he wants to kill him. This strange idea is pushed into the unconscious. Revulsion for the father and guilty feelings for this hatred are also pushed into the unconscious. When unconscious desires come to the conscious level, they transform into the totally opposite behavior of identifying with the father so the child can gain the appreciation and attention of the mother.
๐ Definition โ Electra complex: The Electra complex is the girl's unconscious desire to possess the father and kill the mother. A girl tries to identify with the mother to impress the father.
โญ Key Takeaways
The psychoanalytical model emphasizes that unconscious motivation drives much of human behavior, including violence. Freud's structural model divides personality into three parts: Id (pleasure principle, impulsive), Superego (moral conscience), and Ego (reality principle, mediator)โa healthy personality requires a strong Ego to balance the other two. The instinctual drives of Eros (life/pleasure) and Thanatos (death/destruction) create an inherent conflict that can manifest as aggression or violence when the death instinct is turned outward. The psychosexual stages (oral, anal, phallic, latency, genital) describe how fixation at any stage due to frustration or overindulgence can shape lifelong personality traits and conflict patterns. The Oedipus and Electra complexes during the phallic stage involve unconscious desires for the opposite-sex parent and rivalry with the same-sex parent, resolved through identification.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to Freud, what is the difference between the pleasure principle (Id) and the reality principle (Ego)?
- Explain how the law of conservation of energy applies to unconscious wishes in Freudian theory.
- What personality characteristics would you expect in an adult fixated at the anal stage due to excessive strictness during toilet training?
- Describe the Oedipus complex and explain how it is resolved through identification with the same-sex parent.
- How do the life instinct (Eros) and death instinct (Thanatos) contribute to understanding violent behavior from a psychoanalytic perspective?