๐ Lecture 13 โ Perceptual Defence
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how emotional and psychological factors influence perception, examining how individuals protect themselves from threatening stimuli. It covers perceptual defense mechanisms, the theory of cognitive dissonance, the social nature of perception including stereotyping and the halo effect, and the subliminal nature of perception.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an exploration of perceptual defence, explaining how unpleasant stimuli raise recognition thresholds and cause individuals to avoid threatening information. It then delves into cognitive dissonance theory, defining the discomfort from conflicting thoughts and examining how people resolve this tension. The social nature of perception is discussed through stereotyping and the halo effect, followed by a brief section on subliminal perception and its implications.
๐ Lecture Summary
PERCEPTUAL DEFENCE
Not only do absolute thresholds vary from person to person, they also vary from time to time for a single person. The type of stimulus, the state of one's nervous system, and the costs of false "detections" all make a difference. Emotional factors are also important. Unpleasant stimuli, for example, may raise the threshold for recognition. This effect is called perceptual defense. "Dirty" words took longer to recognize when flashed on a screen than did "clean" words. Apparently it is possible to process information on more than one level and to resist information that causes anxiety, discomfort, or embarrassment.
In other words, the tendency of perceivers to protect themselves against ideas, objects, or people that are threatening to them is called perceptual defence. It is a function of selective perception which protects the individual from threatening or contradictory stimuli. "Perceptual defence occurs when a personโs value orientations act as a barrier to stimuli that are threatening." For example, an alcoholic may avoid anti-drinking and driving campaigns in fear of what could happen because they know they drink and drive sometimes. They fear what could possibly happen if they actually accepted the message.
In case of consumer, perceptual defence can cause them to avoid or misinterpret otherwise important messages. It can occur under the following conditions:
- When consumers have strong beliefs and attitudes about a brand. If the message does not conform to what they believe, they are less likely to perceive. If someone sees an ad for vegetables, they may choose to ignore it if they eat fast food every day.
- When consumers have consistent experience with a brand. Brand-loyals are less likely to switch, regardless of how much "better" another product is.
- When anxiety is produced by a stimulus. If an overweight person sees an ad for Weight Watchers or a gym, they may disregard the message because that stimuli produces fears and anxieties.
- When there is a high level of postpurchase dissonance. Consumers will search out positive information about a brand after they have purchased that brand and they will ignore the negative information.
๐ Definition โ Perceptual Defence: the tendency of perceivers to protect themselves against ideas, objects, or people that are threatening to them; a function of selective perception which protects the individual from threatening or contradictory stimuli.
๐ Example: An alcoholic may avoid anti-drinking and driving campaigns because they fear accepting the message would create discomfort about their own behavior.
Cognitive Dissonance Theory
It may be defined as the feeling of uncomfortable tension which comes from holding two conflicting thoughts in the mind at the same time.
Dissonance increases with:
- The importance of the subject to us.
- How strongly the dissonant thoughts conflict.
- Our inability to rationalize and explain away the conflict.
Dissonance is often strong when we believe something about ourselves and then do something against that belief. If I believe I am good but do something bad, then the discomfort I feel as a result is cognitive dissonance.
Cognitive dissonance is a very powerful motivator which will often lead us to change one or other of the conflicting belief or action. The discomfort often feels like a tension between the two opposing thoughts. To release the tension we can take one of three actions:
- Change our behaviour.
- Justify our behaviour by changing the conflicting cognition.
- Justify our behaviour by adding new cognitions.
Dissonance is most powerful when it is about our self-image. Feelings of foolishness, immorality and so on (including internal projections during decision-making) are dissonance in action.
If an action has been completed and cannot be undone, then the after-the-fact dissonance compels us to change our beliefs. If beliefs are moved, then the dissonance appears during decision-making, forcing us to take actions we would not have taken before.
Cognitive dissonance appears in virtually all evaluations and decisions and is the central mechanism by which we experience new differences in the world. When we see other people behave differently to our images of them, when we hold any conflicting thoughts, we experience dissonance.
Dissonance increases with the importance and impact of the decision, along with the difficulty of reversing it. Discomfort about making the wrong choice of car is bigger than when choosing a lamp.
Research: Festinger first developed this theory in the 1950s to explain how members of a cult who were persuaded by their leader, a certain Mrs Keech, that the earth was going to be destroyed on 21st December and that they alone were going to be rescued by aliens, actually increased their commitment to the cult when this did not happen. The dissonance of the thought of being so stupid was so great that instead they revised their beliefs to meet with obvious facts: that the aliens had, through their concern for the cult, saved the world instead.
In a more mundane experiment, Festinger and Carlsmith got students to lie about a boring task. Those who were paid $1 felt uncomfortable lying.
๐ Example: Smokers find all kinds of reasons to explain away their unhealthy habit. The alternative is to feel a great deal of dissonance.
๐ Definition โ Cognitive Dissonance: the feeling of uncomfortable tension which comes from holding two conflicting thoughts in the mind at the same time.
Social Nature of Perception
Social nature of perception relates to how people look at themselves and others. There are two effects that are worth mentioning while talking about social nature of perception:
1) Stereotyping
Stereotypes are generalizations, or assumptions, that people make about the characteristics of all members of a group, based on an image (often wrong) about what people in that group are like. For example, one study of stereotypes revealed that Americans are generally considered to be friendly, generous, and tolerant, but also arrogant, impatient, and domineering. Asians, on the other hand, were expected to be shrewd and alert, but reserved. Clearly, not all Americans are friendly and generous; and not all Asians are shrewd. If you assume you know what a person is like, and don't look at each person as an individual, you are likely to make errors in your estimates of a person's character.
The word stereotype was invented by Firmin Didot in the world of printing; it was originally a duplicate impression of an original typographical element, used for printing instead of the original. American journalist Walter Lippmann coined the metaphor, calling a stereotype a "picture in our heads" saying "Whether right or wrong, ...imagination is shaped by the pictures seen... Consequently, they lead to stereotypes that are hard to shake." (Public Opinion, 1922, 95-156).
In conflicts, people tend to develop overly-negative images of the other side. The opponent is expected to be aggressive, self-serving, and deceitful, for example, while people view themselves in completely positive ways. These stereotypes tend to be self-perpetuating. If one side assumes the other side is deceitful and aggressive, they will tend to respond in a similar way. The opponent will then develop a similar image of the first party, and the negative stereotypes will be confirmed. They may grow worse, as communication is shut down and escalation heightens emotions and tension.
When we consider a person good (or bad) in one category, we are likely to make a similar evaluation in other categories. It is as if we cannot easily separate categories. It may also be connected with dissonance avoidance, as making them good at one thing and bad at another would make an overall evaluation (which we do anyway) difficult.
Edward Thorndike found, in the 1920s, that when army officers were asked to rate their charges in terms of intelligence, physique, leadership and character, there was a high cross-correlation.
2) Halo effect
The halo effect refers to a cognitive bias whereby the perception of a particular trait is influenced by the perception of the former traits in a sequence of interpretations.
The halo effect is involved in Kelley's implicit personality theory, where the first traits we recognize in other people then influence the interpretation and perception of latter ones (because of our expectations). Attractive people are often judged as having a more desirable personality and more skills than someone of average appearance. Celebrities are used to endorse products that they have no expertise in evaluating.
When commanding officers were asked to rate their soldiers in an early psychology experiment conducted by Edward L. Thorndike, he found high cross-correlation between all positive and all negative traits. People seem to rarely think of each other in mixed terms; instead we seem to see them as universally roughly good or roughly bad across all categories of measurement. Solomon Asch also performed research in this area. The halo effect may be involved with the theory of cognitive dissonance. Solomon Asch has also done a study about central traits and his findings suggest that attractiveness is a central trait, so we presume all the other traits of an attractive person are just as attractive and sought after.
The halo effect is also a term used in HR recruitment. While interviewing a person, you might be influenced by one of his attributes and ignore his/her other weaknesses.
๐ Definition โ Stereotype: generalizations or assumptions that people make about the characteristics of all members of a group, based on an image (often wrong) about what people in that group are like. ๐ Definition โ Halo Effect: a cognitive bias whereby the perception of a particular trait is influenced by the perception of the former traits in a sequence of interpretations.
๐ Example (Stereotyping): Assuming all Americans are friendly and generous while all Asians are shrewd, ignoring individual differences. ๐ Example (Halo Effect): Attractive people are often judged as having a more desirable personality and more skills than someone of average appearance.
Subliminal Nature of Perception
Anytime information is processed below the normal limen (threshold or limit) for awareness, it is subliminal. Subliminal perception was demonstrated by an experiment in which people saw a series of shapes flashed on a screen for 1/1000 second each. Later, they were allowed to see these shapes and other "new" shapes for as long as they wanted. At that time, they rated how much they liked each shape. Even though they could not tell "old" shapes from "new," they gave "old" shapes higher ratings (Kunst-Wilson & Zajonc, 1980). It seems that the "old" shapes had become familiar and thus more "likable," but at a level below normal awareness.
To summarize, there is evidence that subliminal perception occurs. However, well-controlled experiments have shown that subliminal stimuli are basically weak stimuli. Advertisers are better off using the loudest, clearest, more attention-demanding stimuli available โ as most do.
๐ Definition โ Subliminal Perception: when information is processed below the normal limen (threshold or limit) for awareness.
โญ Key Takeaways
Perceptual defence is a critical concept showing how individuals block out threatening information to protect themselves, often influencing consumer behavior when messages conflict with beliefs or cause anxiety. Cognitive dissonance theory explains the powerful discomfort from holding conflicting thoughts, driving people to change behaviors, justify actions, or add new cognitions to reduce tension. Stereotypes are oversimplified generalizations that can create self-perpetuating negative cycles in conflicts, while the halo effect demonstrates how a single positive trait can bias perceptions across all categories. Subliminal perception occurs below awareness but is generally weak, making it less effective for advertising than direct, attention-grabbing stimuli. Understanding these perceptual biases is essential for recognizing how emotions, social influences, and unconscious processes shape our interpretation of the world.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is perceptual defence and what four conditions can cause it to occur in consumers?
- Name the three ways people can resolve cognitive dissonance according to the theory.
- How did Festinger's research on a cult demonstrate cognitive dissonance in action?
- What is the difference between stereotyping and the halo effect?
- What did the Kunst-Wilson & Zajonc (1980) experiment reveal about subliminal perception?
๐ Lecture 14 โ Attribution
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how people explain the causes of behaviorโboth their own and others'. It introduces attribution theory, the distinction between dispositional and situational attributions, the concept of locus of control, and common attributional errors like the fundamental attribution error and self-serving bias. Understanding these concepts is critical for managing perceptions and motivations in organizational settings.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the human tendency to attribute causes to events, the distinction between dispositional (internal) and situational (external) attribution, the concept of locus of control and its characteristics, the three factors (consensus, consistency, distinctiveness) influencing attributions, and two major attributional errors: fundamental attribution error and self-serving bias.
๐ Lecture Summary
Attribution
It is one of the basic human instincts to try to explain things around us to ourselves and other people, attributing cause to events. This gives us a greater sense of control. Attributions are judgments about what caused a personโs behaviorโeither characteristics of the person (internal) or of the situation (external). When another person has erred, we often use internal attribution, saying it is due to internal personality factors. When we have erred, we will more likely use external attribution, attributing causes to situational factors rather than blaming ourselvesโand vice versa: we attribute our successes internally and the successes of our rivals to external luck.
When a football team wins, supporters say โwe won.โ But when the team loses, supporters say โthey lost.โ Attributions are significantly driven by emotional and motivational drives. Self-serving attributions involve blaming other people and avoiding personal recrimination. We also tend to blame victims for their fate as we seek to distance ourselves from thoughts of suffering the same plight. We tend to ascribe less variability to other people than ourselves, seeing ourselves as more multifaceted and less predictable than others. In practice, there is often a two-step process: starting with an automatic internal attribution, followed by a slower consideration of whether an external attribution is more appropriate. If we are hurried or distracted, we may not get to this second step, making internal attribution more likely.
Dispositional and Situational Attribution
Behavior is considered to be determined by either internal or external factors, determining dispositional or situational attribution.
๐ Definition โ Dispositional attribution: Where "cause" is attributed to internal/personality factors. Inside factors fall inside your own control. You can choose to behave in a particular way or not, so your behavior is not influenced by forces outside your control. Therefore, you feel responsible. A typical example is your own intelligence. In other words, dispositional attribution is the explanation of individual behavior as a result caused by innate characteristics residing within the individual, as opposed to outside influences from the environment or culture.
๐ Definition โ Situational attribution: Where "cause" is attributed to external/social factors. Outside factors fall outside your control. You perceive you have no choice, so your behavior is influenced, limited, or completely determined by influences outside your control. Therefore, you feel not responsible. A generic example is weather.
Internal or external attribution is also made with respect to other peopleโis another person personally responsible for a certain event, or is it caused by something beyond their control? We make this sort of attribution when deciding whether to blame a friend for failing to pay back a loan. If we blame it on her personal qualities, the attribution is internal. If we blame it on a problem she is having, the attribution is external.
๐ก Why this matters: The distinction between dispositional and situational attribution is the foundation for understanding how we assign responsibility, blame, and credit in organizational and social life.
Locus of Control
A major concept in the study of attribution theory is locus of control: whether one interprets events as being caused by one's own behavior or by outside circumstances.
๐ Definition โ Locus of Control: The tendency to place the primary responsibility for oneโs success or failure either within oneself (internally) or on outside forces (externally).
A person with an internal locus of control ("internal") will believe her performance on a work project is governed by her ability or how hard she works. An external locus of control ("external") will attribute success or failure by concluding the project was easy or hard, the boss was helpful or unhelpful, or some other rationale. In general, an internal locus of control is associated with optimism and physical health. People with an internal locus tend to be more successful at delaying gratification.
Internal locus people believe they control their own fate:
- Easier to motivate
- Better to handle complex info and problem solving
- More achievement orientated
- More independent
- More difficult to lead
External locus people believe they are pawns; luck and chance determine outcomes:
- Hard to motivate
- Blame others for poor performance
- Conform easier
- Easier to lead
๐ Three factors influencing internal vs. external attributions:
- Consensus: Whether other people exhibit similar behavior; whether people tend to respond to similar situations in the same way. High consensus โ external attribution.
- Consistency: Whether the behavior occurs repeatedly; whether the person has a history of behaving the same way. High consistency โ internal attribution.
- Distinctiveness: Whether the behavior occurs in other, similar situations; whether the behavior is unusual for that person. High distinctiveness โ external attribution.
๐ก Why this matters: Locus of control and these three factors help explain why different people make different causal attributions for the same event, which has major implications for motivation, leadership, and conflict resolution in organizations.
Attributional Errors
Fundamental Attribution Error
In attribution theory, the fundamental attribution error (also known as correspondence bias or overattribution effect) is the tendency for people to over-emphasize dispositional, or personality-based, explanations for behaviors observed in others while under-emphasizing situational explanations. When trying to understand social settings, we tend to view behavior as a particularly significant factor and explain it in terms of internal disposition (personality traits, abilities, motives, etc.) as opposed to external situational factors.
This error occurs due to our focus on the person more than their situation, about which we may know very little. Western culture exacerbates this error by emphasizing individual freedom and autonomy, socializing people to prefer dispositional factors to situational ones.
When we are playing the role of observer (looking at others), we make this fundamental attribution error. When we are thinking about ourselves, we tend to make situational attributions.
๐ Definition โ Fundamental Attribution Error: The tendency to underestimate the influence of external factors on anotherโs behavior and to overestimate the influence of internal factors. It occurs when situational factors are ignored in judging others.
๐ Example: A manager sees an employee arrive late for a meeting and immediately assumes the employee is lazy or irresponsible (internal attribution), ignoring the possibility that the employee's car broke down or there was a family emergency (situational factors).
Self-Serving Bias
Self-serving bias is the tendency to overestimate the contribution of internal factors to oneโs successes and the contribution of external factors to oneโs failures. In other words, it is the tendency to present oneself favorably. A self-serving bias occurs when people are more likely to claim responsibility for successes than failures. It may also manifest as a tendency to evaluate ambiguous information in a way beneficial to one's interests.
๐ Definition โ Self-Serving Bias: The tendency to take credit for successes (internal attribution) and blame failures on external factors (external attribution).
๐ Example: A student who gets a good grade on an exam says, "I got an A because I am intelligent and I studied hard!" while a student who does poorly says, "The teacher gave me an F because he does not like me!" When someone seeks out external causes for poor performance, it may be labeled self-handicapping.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are: (1) Attribution is the judgment we make about the causes of behaviorโeither internal (dispositional) or external (situational). (2) Locus of control distinguishes whether people believe they control their own fate (internal) or are controlled by external forces (external), affecting motivation, independence, and leadership. (3) Three factorsโconsensus, consistency, and distinctivenessโdetermine whether we make internal or external attributions about others' behavior. (4) The fundamental attribution error leads us to overestimate internal causes for others' failures while ignoring situational factors. (5) Self-serving bias leads us to take credit for successes and blame failures on external circumstances, which can distort performance evaluations and interpersonal relationships in organizations.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between dispositional and situational attribution?
- What are the characteristics of a person with an internal locus of control versus an external locus of control?
- What three factors influence whether we attribute someone's behavior to internal or external causes?
- What is the fundamental attribution error, and why does it occur?
- How does self-serving bias distort people's explanations of their own successes and failures?
๐ Lecture 15 โ Impression Management
๐ Overview: This lecture explores Impression Management (IM) theory, which explains how individuals and organizations deliberately shape the perceptions others hold of them. It covers the core techniques, strategies, and types of IM, emphasizing its role in social and organizational contexts, particularly during interviews and career management. Understanding IM is crucial for navigating professional interactions ethically and effectively.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining Impression Management (IM) as a goal-directed process of controlling perceptions, rooted in Goffmanโs dramaturgical perspective. It then details two main techniques: Impression Motivation (managing a bossโs view) and Impression Construction (managing a general public view). Key strategies are categorized as Demotion/prevention (correcting negative images through accounts, apologies, disassociation) and Promotion enhancement (building positive images via entitlements, enhancements, obstacle disclosure, association). Finally, three specific types of IM are examined: Self-focused, Manager-focused, and Job-focused IM, along with their implications, particularly for gender dynamics in the workplace.
๐ Lecture Summary
Impression management (IM)
Impression management (IM) theory states that any individual or organization must establish and maintain impressions that are congruent with the perceptions they want to convey to their publics (Goffman, 1959). The goal is for one to present themselves the way in which they would like to be thought of by the individual or group they are interacting with. This form of management generally applies to the first impression.
When we are under scrutiny, we will try to deliberately manage the impressions that others form of us. We will use self-enhancement to make us seem good, for example through smart dress, careful language, etc. The alternative is other-enhancement to make the other person feel good, such as with flattery. For example, watch people being interviewed on TV. Notice how a good interviewer uses other-enhancement to relax them. Spot how people use self-enhancement to look good.
To some extent, we are constantly managing impressions of others in most social circumstances and of course we want to look good in interviews. However there are two question that may be asked: the extent to which it is ethical and acceptable, both socially and for the interviewers, and the extent to which it is effective. More impression management does not necessarily mean a better impression is gained.
Impression management not only happens, it is expected to happen. This can cause a dilemma where the interviewer either marks you down for not managing impression sufficiently (for example not being smart enough or not being assertive enough) or managing it too much (low-cut dresses, boasting, exaggeration). A particular dilemma is where the interviewer expects a certain degree of exaggeration or fabrication and downgrades what everyone says. If you are truthful and everyone else exaggerates, then you can lose out.
Do manage the impression you make, but do not over-do it (and do not under-do it either). Practical tips include: dress tidily (e.g., suit and tie) but not over-doing it (e.g., bow tie, frock coat); show respect, but show neither aggression nor timidity; do not offer any outright lies; notice your body language, but do not over-control it; show your experiences in a positive light, but do not over-exaggerate.
In sociology and social psychology, impression management is the process through which people try to control the impressions other people form of them. It is a goal-directed conscious or unconscious attempt to influence the perceptions of other people about a person, object or event by regulating and controlling information in social interaction. It is usually synonymous with self-presentation, if a person tries to influence the perception of his image.
From both a communications and public relations viewpoint, the theory of impression management encompasses the vital ways in which one establishes and communicates this congruence between personal or organizational goals and their intended actions which create public perception. The idea that perception is reality is the basis for this sociological and social psychology theory, which is framed around the presumption that the otherโs perceptions of you or your organization become the reality from which they form ideas and the basis for intended behaviors.
Goffman presented Impression management dramaturgically, explaining the motivations behind complex human performances within a social setting based on a play metaphor (Dillard et al., 2000). Goffmanโs work is written from a symbolic interactionist perspective, emphasizing a qualitative analysis of the interactive nature of the communication process (Barnhart, 1994).
๐ Definition โ Impression Management (IM): The goal-directed conscious or unconscious attempt to influence the perceptions of other people about a person, object or event by regulating and controlling information in social interaction. ๐ Example: An interviewee wearing a smart suit and using careful language to appear competent is using self-enhancement to manage the interviewerโs impression.
๐ก Why this matters: IM is a constant, expected part of social interaction, especially in high-stakes settings like job interviews. The core challenge is to manage impressions effectively without over-doing it (which can seem dishonest or arrogant) or under-doing it (which can signal disinterest or lack of competence).
Two Techniques of Impression Management
Impression Motivation It may simply be defined as how a boss is made to see an employee. A subordinated would try to present a picture of himself to the boss, which suits just the needs of the organization and what is expected of him. For example, when an employee has to meet his boss, he might pay special attention to his dress and take some time to do his hair. Therefore, he makes a deliberate effort to appear good in front of the boss. This technique is known as impression management.
Impression Construction It may be defined as how others are made to see one. In other words, it relates to specific type of impression that people want to make. For example, someone might want to appear competitive; he or she may show interest in a competitive sport.
๐ Definition โ Impression Motivation: The technique of managing how a specific influential person (like a boss) perceives you, often through deliberate effort to meet their expectations. ๐ Definition โ Impression Construction: The technique of managing the general impression you project to others, often focusing on a specific trait (e.g., being competitive). ๐ Example: An employee spending extra time on their hair before a meeting with the boss is an example of Impression Motivation. A person joining a competitive sports league to appear ambitious is an example of Impression Construction.
STRATEGIES OF IMPRESSION MANAGEMENT
Demotion/prevention strategy This strategy is related to correcting a negative image, when something goes wrong. It is more like minimizing the responsibility for something which has gone wrong. The demotion-preventative strategy is characterized by the following:
- Accounts: Employees attempt to excuse themselves. They try to give reasons for something going wrong; in other words, attributing the wrong to something which was deemed much important to be done, hence causing the wrong to occur.
- Apologies: It may be considered as the last resort, i.e. when employees find no other way out, they may apologise to the boss creating an impression that they take the blame and responsibility and ensure that it shall not happen again.
- Disassociation: It occurs when employees tend to detach themselves from the wrong. They often tend to exonerate themselves on the account that they had warned about the possible mishap.
Promotion enhancement It is related to creating a positive or a good image which enhances them. Employees often tend to present themselves as better than what they actually are.
- Entitlements: Under this approach, employees who feel that due credit have not been given to them for their achievements tend to elude do the key officials about it.
- Enhancements: This approach is to increase oneโs share of praise. As employees feel that the credit or praise they have received for something is not enough, they try to point out the fact to the concerned people.
- Obstacle Disclosure: This strategy involves illuminating the barriers or obstacles that were faced in achieving the goals.
- Association: This strategy involves, being seen with the right people at the right time. Therefore, a perception may be created that the employee is connected with the successful projects.
๐ Definition โ Demotion/prevention strategy: A set of techniques (accounts, apologies, disassociation) used to correct a negative image or minimize responsibility for a failure. ๐ Definition โ Promotion enhancement strategy: A set of techniques (entitlements, enhancements, obstacle disclosure, association) used to create a positive image or enhance oneโs reputation. ๐ Example โ Demotion: An employee who missed a deadline might use an account by saying the project was delayed because they were prioritizing a more urgent task. If that fails, they might use an apology. ๐ Example โ Promotion: An employee who successfully completed a project might use obstacle disclosure by telling their manager about the unexpected challenges they overcame. They might also use association by ensuring they are seen at meetings with the projectโs high-profile stakeholders.
Three Types of Impression Management
Self-focused IM Self-promotion is the packaging of oneโs strengths, especially useful where the individual is not well known to those who control resources such as promotion. However, self-promotion of successes is seen as risky, because it can be interpreted as bragging, which may result in a negative reaction by the target. Self-promotion of ambition is essential for career management, so that managers are aware of this need โ they may be too busy to read your mind. But self-promotion is a Catch 22 for ambitious women โ they are damned if they do it and damned if they donโt.
Manager-Focused IM Networking upwards and outwards, and building a good relationship with your manager are assertive tactics to gain approval of senior managers controlling significant rewards. Early use of IM by subordinates in a supervisory relationship, especially where they are of the same gender as the supervisor is likely to result in enhanced performance ratings, which is of significance for females managed by males, putting them at a disadvantage. Cranfieldโs research shows that women tend to be less instrumental than their male peers in initiation and maintenance of such relationships.
Job-Focused IM Many choose to impress through delivery of extra high performance and high commitment, but these have to be visible to achieve the rewards.
Impression management signals ambition and drive which when coupled with professionalism and commitment could be a key organisational resource. It is a tool which can benefit the individual, their team, their manager and the organisation, through highly professional and committed performance, good organisational citizenship and goal delivery, relationship-building and political/cultural awareness. However, males seem more willing than females to use upward influence IM as part of their career management. If women are not noticed, then they may not extend their potential to the full advantage of their employer or themselves. There is a growing business case for organisations to develop their resource pool of women, as some investors start to move their funds into companies with visible senior female representation. Women directors bring new ideas and different perspectives to corporate decision-making on previously all-male boards, as well as act as role models for those below, enhancing the recruitment and retention of talented women.
However, both males and females need to be noticed in order for organisations to invest in development for more senior levels. Managers should not assume that females who do not push themselves forward are not as ambitious or able as their male peers. Some men and women trust the formal HRM systems to provide career opportunities, underestimating the importance of informal networks for information about senior posts. Some individuals with potential do not always realise the importance of โbrandingโ their values and core strengths to their senior managers. Managers could help their junior staff by clarifying the kind of performance and commitment which get rewarded, so that they can make better-informed choices. Perhaps individuals do not want to use IM, but they should know the unwritten penalties for not delivering and being seen to deliver what the organisation wants and needs.
๐ Definition โ Self-focused IM: A type of impression management centered on packaging and promoting oneโs own strengths, successes, and ambition. ๐ Definition โ Manager-focused IM: A type of impression management that involves networking upwards and building a strategic relationship with oneโs manager to gain approval. ๐ Definition โ Job-focused IM: A type of impression management where individuals impress through visible, high-performance and high-commitment delivery. ๐ Example โ Self-focused: An employee at a new company might actively talk about their previous successful projects to their boss (self-promotion). ๐ Example โ Manager-focused: An employee might frequently seek their managerโs advice and volunteer for projects the manager is leading to build a stronger relationship. ๐ Example โ Job-focused: An employee consistently working late and delivering projects ahead of schedule, while also ensuring their manager is aware of these efforts.
๐ก Why this matters: The lecture highlights a critical gender dynamic in IM. While self-promotion is seen as essential for career management, it can be a โCatch 22โ for women, who may be judged negatively for behaviors that are rewarded in men. This underscores the need for organizational awareness and fairer systems for recognition and advancement.
โญ Key Takeaways
Impression Management is the deliberate, goal-directed process of controlling how others perceive you, and it is an expected part of professional life. The key challenge is balancing self-enhancement (making yourself look good) and other-enhancement (making others feel good) without over-doing either. Two primary techniques are Impression Motivation (managing a specific person like a boss) and Impression Construction (managing your general public image). Strategies for managing impressions fall into two categories: Demotion/prevention (correcting negative images through accounts, apologies, or disassociation) and Promotion enhancement (building positive images through entitlements, enhancements, obstacle disclosure, and association). Finally, there are three types of IMโSelf-focused, Manager-focused, and Job-focusedโeach with specific risks and rewards, particularly highlighting how gender can affect the effectiveness and social acceptability of these tactics.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the central idea behind Goffmanโs โdramaturgicalโ approach to Impression Management?
- What is the difference between Impression Motivation and Impression Construction?
- If an employee misses a deadline and tells their boss, โI warned you this timeline was too tight,โ which IM strategy are they using?
- Why is Self-promotion described as a โCatch 22โ for ambitious women?
- Name all three types of Impression Management and give a brief example of each.