๐ Lecture 09 โ Changing Organizational Culture
๐ Overview: This lecture explores why and how organizational culture must change in response to internal and external pressures. It covers the influence of founders on culture, the impact of the external environment (specific and general), and the specific drivers of cultural change such as mergers, globalization, and virtual organizations. The lecture also provides a practical step-by-step framework for implementing cultural change while preserving the organization's core identity.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining how an organization's culture originates from its founders' vision and then examines how the external environment (both specific and general) forces cultural adaptation. It then details three major reasons for cultural change: mergers and acquisitions, rapidly changing external environments (including globalization's many effects), and the emergence of virtual organizations. Next, it identifies three specific aspects of culture that must change: organizational structure, politics, and emotions. Finally, it outlines an eight-step process for how to successfully change organizational culture while avoiding common pitfalls.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction: The Original Source of Organizational Culture
An organization's current customs, traditions, and way of doing things are largely due to what it has done before and its past successes. The original source of an organization's culture usually reflects the vision or mission of the founders. Founders are not constrained by previous customs, and the small size of most new organizations helps them instill their vision in all members. However, organizations are open systems that interact with their environment as they take in inputs and distribute outputs. The external environment refers to forces and institutions outside the organization that can potentially affect its performance.
๐ Definition โ External Environment: Forces and institutions outside the organization that potentially can affect the organization's performance.
The Two Components of the External Environment
The external environment is made up of two components: the specific environment and the general environment. The specific environment includes those constituencies that have a direct and immediate impact on managers' decisions and actions and are directly relevant to achieving the organization's goals. It includes customers, suppliers, and public pressure groups. The general environment includes broad economic, political, legal, socio-cultural, demographic, technological, and global conditions that may affect the organization. If the external environment undergoes change, it impacts the organization, and to adapt, the organization must undergo a change in its culture. Similarly, changes in the internal environment also necessitate cultural change.
๐ Definition โ Specific Environment: Constituencies that have a direct and immediate impact on managers' decisions and actions and are directly relevant to achieving organizational goals. ๐ Definition โ General Environment: Broad economic, political, legal, socio-cultural, demographic, technological, and global conditions that may affect the organization.
Why Change the Culture?
Organizational culture needs to be changed because it has a direct impact on managerial decision making. Culture constrains what managers can and cannot do. These constraints are rarely explicit, not written down, and unlikely to be spoken, but all managers quickly learn what to do and what not to do in their organizations. ๐ก Why this matters: Culture acts as an invisible rulebook that shapes every decision; changing it unlocks new possibilities for organizational adaptation and growth.
Change is specifically required for two major reasons:
1. Mergers and Acquisitions A merger is a tool used by companies to expand their operations, often aiming to increase long-term profitability. However, 50-75% of all mergers and acquisitions are found to fail at adding value. Acquisitions can occur through a hostile takeover by purchasing the majority of outstanding shares against the target board's wishes. Mergers and acquisitions affect the culture because they either completely change the norms and values of the organization or partially amend them. ๐ Definition โ Merger: A tool used by companies for expanding operations, often aiming at an increase of long-term profitability, usually occurring in a consensual setting. ๐ Definition โ Acquisition: Occurs through a hostile takeover by purchasing the majority of outstanding shares of a company in the open market against the wishes of the target's board. ๐ Key Term โ Poison Pill: A shareholder rights plan used as a form of protection against a hostile takeover.
2. Rapidly Changing External Environment The external environment is in constant change, best understood by considering globalization. Globalization refers to the greater international movement of commodities, money, information, and people, and the development of technology, organizations, legal systems, and infrastructures to allow this movement. Its effects include international cultural exchange, multiculturalism, diversity, greater travel and tourism, immigration, spread of consumer products, world-wide fads, universal values, global telecommunications infrastructure, increased global standards, corporate imperialism, cultural imperialism, and the emergence of virtual organizations.
๐ Definition โ Globalization: The greater international movement of commodities, money, information, and people; and the development of technology, organizations, legal systems, and infrastructures to allow this movement. ๐ Definition โ Virtual Organization: An organization existing as a corporate, educational, or otherwise productive entity that does not have a central geographical location and exists solely through telecommunication tools. It comprises a set of (legally) independent organizations that share resources and skills to achieve its mission/goal.
Organizational Culture Must Change In Terms Of:
- Change in organizational structure: Organizational structure is the arrangement of various jobs and levels of management. It may be flat (fewer layers) or vertical (many layers). To change culture, the structure needs revision. For example, organizations are moving from centralized to decentralized decision making, requiring fewer managerial layers.
- Change in organizational politics: Politics is the art of gaining and sharing power. To change culture, the politics of the organization need to be reviewed and adjusted to the new culture.
- Change in organizational emotions: The emotions of the organization refer to the feelings possessed by employees. They need to be manipulated according to the requirements of the changing culture.
๐ Definition โ Organizational Structure: The arrangement of various jobs and levels of management within the organization. ๐ Definition โ Organizational Politics: The art of gaining and sharing power within an organization. ๐ Definition โ Organizational Emotions: The feelings which are possessed within the organization by the employees.
How to Change Organizational Culture
Following are the eight steps in changing organizational culture:
- Assess current culture: The first step is to assess the current culture and the requirements โ why and what needs to be changed.
- Set change goals, bottom line: The second step is to set goals and targets โ to define the ultimate motive behind the cultural change effort.
- Recruit experienced people: The third step is to involve experienced people from within and outside the organization to carry out the change process.
- Make changes and include employees in changes: Once changes are made, employees need to be made a part of the change since they will be the first to get affected.
- Expect problems, be ready to tackle: Problems may arise in terms of non-compliance from employees. These should be expected, and plans should be in place to help sort them out.
- Move decisively, defuse resistance: The cultural change should be enforced with rigor, and resistance shall be countered with tactful measures.
- Persist, get feedback: The change should not be rolled back since it was meticulously designed. Feedback may be taken from employees to ensure the change causes the desired results.
- Do not abandon roots: An important consideration is not to abandon the cultural roots of the organization. The change should be congruent with the mission statement and the original culture of the organization.
โญ Key Takeaways
- Organizational culture originates from founders' vision but must evolve in response to both internal changes and external environmental pressures (specific and general).
- The primary drivers for cultural change include mergers and acquisitions (which often fail 50-75% of the time), globalization, and the rise of virtual organizations that require new norms for trust, communication, and negotiation.
- Cultural change must address three key organizational dimensions simultaneously: structure (moving toward decentralization), politics (redistributing power), and emotions (managing employee feelings).
- The eight-step change process emphasizes assessment first, involving experienced people and employees, expecting and managing resistance, and critically โ never abandoning the organization's original cultural roots.
- Culture acts as an invisible constraint on managerial decision-making; changing it is essential for organizational adaptation and survival in a dynamic environment.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two components of the external environment, and how does each affect organizational culture?
- Why do 50-75% of mergers and acquisitions fail to add value, and how do these events impact organizational culture?
- What is a virtual organization, and why does its emergence require changes in organizational culture?
- List the three aspects of organizational culture that must change (structure, politics, emotions) and explain why each is important.
- What is the final step in the eight-step process for changing organizational culture, and why is it critical?
๐ Lecture 10 โ Reward Systems: Pay
๐ Overview: This lecture examines pay as the primary reward system available to managers and organizations. It explores how compensation systems can be designed to attract, retain, and motivate competent employees while supporting organizational objectives. The lecture covers different pay methods, incentive plans, and new pay techniques, emphasizing the strategic importance of aligning pay policies with firm characteristics and environment.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by establishing the importance of pay as a reward system and its economic, sociological, and psychological impacts on employees. It then distinguishes between managers and owners in terms of pay philosophies before examining research findings on pay as a reward. The lecture covers three main methods of pay: base pay, merit pay, and pay for performance. Within pay for performance, it details individual incentive plans and team-based incentive plans, including gain sharing and profit sharing. Finally, it introduces new pay techniques such as commissions beyond sales, rewarding leadership roles, pay for knowledge, skill pay, competency pay, and broad-banding.
๐ Lecture Summary
PAY
Pay is the first reward system available to managers or owners. The pay system is one of the most important mechanisms that firms and managers can use to attract, retain, and motivate competent employees to perform in ways that support organizational objectives. It also has a direct bearing on the extent to which labor costs detract from or contribute to business objective and profitability.
The HR department plays an important role in designing administrative rules and procedures to ensure fair allocation of pay, control labor costs, and maintain parity with competitorโs pay levels for similar jobs. However, organizations face many choices in terms of which pay policies and practices to use. The challenges for top managers, in consultation with the HR personnel, are to pick those that are most appropriate to the firm. Most managers of all levels of the organization enjoy some discretion in making pay decisions for subordinates. Such decisions should be equitable and relate to criteria such as unique skills, performance level, and the flexibility to perform multiple tasks.
An employeeโs pay cheque is certainly important for its purchasing power. In most societies, however, a personโs earnings also serve as an indicator of power and prestige and are tied to feelings of self-worth. In other words, compensation affects a person economically, sociologically, and psychologically. For this reason, mishandling compensation issues is likely to have a strong negative impact on employees and, ultimately, on the firmโs procedure.
The wide variety of pay policies and procedures presents managers with a two-pronged challenge: to design a compensation system that:
- enables the firm to achieve its strategic objectives and
- is molded to the firmโs unique characteristics and environment.
Usually managers and owners are different in terms of:
- Using pay as an incentive: Managers tend to pay more since they are more interested in the well-being of the company in the long run. Owners are interested more in short-run profits, in general.
- Risk taking: Managers tend to take greater risk while owners have a long term perspective and take fewer risks. They are concerned about losing their investment.
- Time horizons: As mentioned earlier, managers have a short term perspective and owners have a long term perspective.
Research shows a number of things that are related to pay as reward:
- Pay increases motivation
- The more money given, the more employees want. This means that as the employees get more money as reward for performance, they tend to be focused more on money only rather than on the job.
- Reduction in pay will lead to lowering of morale
- Money means different things to different employees depending on age, gender, status, family, etc.
- If the gap (spread) in pay is more in a team of workers, performance of team is low
- Rewarding team rather than person is more motivating
Methods of Pay
1. Base Pay It is the first and the largest element of total compensation. It comprises fixed pay an employee receives on a regular basis, either in the form of a salary or as an hourly wage. It is determined by market conditions.
2. Merit Pay It is paid according to predetermined criteria, e.g. cost of living.
3. Pay for Performance Simply put, pay-for-performance is that more the work done, the more the pay; bonus or stock options. Pay for performance systems, also called incentive systems, reward employee performance on the basis of three assumptions: a) Individual employees and work teams differ in how much they contribute to the firmโnot only in what they do but also in how well they do it. b) The firmโs overall performance depends to a large degree on the performance of individuals and groups within the firm. c) To attract, retain, and motivate high performers and to be fair to all employees, a company needs to reward employees on the basis of their relative performance.
๐ Definition โ Pay for performance (incentive systems): Reward systems that compensate employee performance based on the assumptions that individuals and teams differ in contribution, that firm performance depends on individual/group performance, and that companies need to reward relative performance to attract, retain, and motivate high performers.
Individual incentive plan At the most micro level, firms attempt to identify and reward the contributions of individual employees. Individual-based pay plans are the most widely used pay-for-performance plans in industry. Individual bonus programs are given on a one-time basis and do not raise the employeeโs base pay permanently. Bonuses tend to be larger than merit pay increases because they involve lower risk to the employer. Bonuses can also be given outside the annual review cycle when employees achieve certain milestones or offer a valuable cost-saving suggestion.
Awards, like bonuses, are one-time rewards but are given in the form of a tangible prize, such as a paid vacation or a television set etc.
The advantages of individual-based pay-for-performance plans are:
- Performance that is rewarded is likely to be repeated
- Individuals are goal oriented and financial incentives can shape an individualโs goals over time.
- Assessing the performance of each employee individually helps the firm achieve individual equity.
The disadvantages of individual-based pay-for-performance plans are:
- Create competition and destroy cooperation among peers
- Sour working relationships between subordinates and supervisors.
Team-based incentive plan In an attempt to increase the flexibility of their workforces, a growing number of firms are redesigning work to allow employees with unique skills and backgrounds to tackle projects or problems together. For instance, at Compaq Computer Corp., as many as 25 percent of the companyโs 16,000 employees are on teams that develop new products and bring them to market. Employees in this new system are expected to cross job boundaries within their team and to contribute in areas in which they have not previously worked.
Team-based pay plans normally reward all team members equally based on group outcomes. These outcomes may be measured objectively or subjectively whether the criteria for defining a desirable outcome are broad or narrow. As in individual-based programs, payments to team members may be made in the form of a cash bonus or in the form of non-cash awards such as trips, time off, or luxury items.
Team-based pay plans may include: Gain sharing plan: where team/group performance is rewarded as a whole when the organization gains as a result of the contribution of the group. Profit sharing: where profit is shared by employees in an organization. Whatever the profit of the organization is, the employees get a certain percentage in it.
Advantages of team-based-pay-for-performance plans:
- They foster group cohesiveness.
- They aid performance measurement.
Disadvantages of team-based-pay-for-performance plans:
- Possible lack of fit with individualistic cultural values
- The free-riding effect
- Difficulties in identifying meaningful groups
- Inter-group competition leading to a decline in overall performance
New Pay Techniques
Commissions beyond sales to customers It is an incentive plan in which employees are given commission on factors other than sales to customers. These factors may include customer satisfaction etc.
Rewarding leadership roles This incentive plan is linked with the leadership ability of the managers. It is based on employee satisfaction and the ability of the manager to produce the desired results for the organization.
Rewarding new goals As indicated by the name, this plan is linked with the employeeโs ability to achieve other goals than the core goals of profits and sales. These goals may include improved productivity or customer satisfaction etc.
Pay for knowledge This plan is based on the knowledge of the workers in the organization. For example in a team, some of the employees may be more knowledgeable than the others, therefore, they are paid more.
Skill pay Under this plan, employees are paid on the basis of their skills rather than the job they perform.
Competency pay This plan tends to reward the competencies of the employees which are not visible but are useful for the organization. For example an employee may know more than one language.
Broad-banding This refers to setting a range of pay within which certain employees may exist. For example, the pay range for middle level managers may be 10,000 to 50,000. The top management may increase pay within these limits and does not need any pay grading system.
๐ Definition โ Broad-banding: A pay technique that sets a range of pay within which certain employees may exist, allowing top management to increase pay within these limits without needing a formal pay grading system.
โญ Key Takeaways
Pay is a critical reward system serving economic, sociological, and psychological functions, and it must be strategically designed to achieve organizational objectives while fitting the firm's unique characteristics. Managers and owners differ in their approach to pay: managers tend to have longer time horizons and pay more as incentives, while owners focus on short-run profits and take fewer risks. Three main pay methods exist: base pay (fixed salary or hourly wage), merit pay (based on predetermined criteria like cost of living), and pay for performance (incentive systems). Pay for performance can be individual-based (bonuses, awards) or team-based (gain sharing, profit sharing), each with distinct advantages and disadvantagesโindividual plans risk creating competition and destroying cooperation, while team plans may suffer from free-riding and inter-group competition. New pay techniques include commissions beyond sales, rewarding leadership roles, rewarding new goals, pay for knowledge, skill pay, competency pay, and broad-banding, all designed to align compensation with specific organizational needs.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three ways in which compensation affects a person according to the lecture?
- What are the three key differences between managers and owners in terms of pay philosophy?
- What are the three assumptions underlying pay-for-performance (incentive) systems?
- List two advantages and two disadvantages of individual-based pay-for-performance plans.
- What is the difference between gain sharing and profit sharing as team-based incentive plans?
๐ Lecture 11 โ Reward Systems: Recognition and Benefits
๐ Overview: This lecture examines how organizations use recognition and benefits as reward systems to motivate employees and maintain competitiveness. It covers the components of effective employee recognition programs, introduces Efficiency Wage Theory, and explores both traditional and newer types of employee benefits that serve as indirect compensation.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with employee recognition programs, including their components of fairness and visibility, practical recognition strategies, and rewards. It then introduces Efficiency Wage Theory, explaining how above-market wages can attract top talent while discussing potential drawbacks like increased unemployment and inflation. Finally, it covers employee benefits comprehensively, distinguishing between traditional benefits (health insurance, pensions, vacation time) and newer type benefits (wellness programs, life cycle benefits, Employee Assistance Programs, and flexible benefits).
๐ Lecture Summary
RECOGNITION
Organizational and social recognition is used by managers as rewards. Companies operating in global markets need employees who continuously improve how they do their jobs to keep the company competitive. Employees are more likely to share their ideas for work improvements when managers give them credit for their contributions. Employee recognition programs can enhance employee relations by communicating that the organization cares about its employees' ideas and is willing to reward them for their efforts. The HR department helps by developing and maintaining formal employee recognition programs such as suggestion systems and recognition awards.
A recognition program does not have to be expensive. An effective program has two components: fairness and high visibility and consistency.
To be fair, a program must not favor one employee over another merely because of position or relationship with a supervisor. There must be an effective means of identifying employees who should be recognized. In many programs, there is an easy means by which employees can nominate others for recognition. Supervisors can also keep lists of notable employee achievements.
Making a program highly visible helps ensure consistent implementation. If a recognition program becomes viewed as management's "program of the month," nominations will drop and those nominated may be perceived as management's "favorites." Small but meaningful achievements may be ignored unless there is a plan to actively solicit nominees.
๐ก Why this matters: The structure of recognition programs is limited only by imagination. One approach is to have small rewards initially, making each recipient eligible for a larger reward at year-end.
The reward itself should be just part of the process. Recognition can be achieved by giving the reward at a gathering of employees and recognizing the award in corporate communications like newsletters or Intranet sites. Suggested awards include: calling deserving employees into your office for focused recognition; buying a trophy for the most deserving employee; sending faxes, emails, or voice mails saying "thank you"; attaching recognition notes to paychecks; taking support staff to lunch; photographing employees being congratulated by managers; having senior managers attend team meetings for recognition; inviting work teams to your house; assigning recognized employees as mentors; repeating positive remarks to employees; staying alert to preferred types of praise; and catching people doing things right.
Efficiency Wage Theory
Efficiency Wage Theory states that organizations can save money by offering higher pays/benefits because they can hire the best talent. The idea is to pay way above average wages to attract the best employees. These bright workers will be very productive, more than most employees, because you'll have a group of the best and brightest working together. Those workers, because of their high wage and fear of losing it, won't slack off and there will be less risk of them leaving. In developing countries, employees may earn enough from increased wages to buy food and medicineโhealthier employees can be more productive!
Why doesn't everyone pay Efficiency wages? The reason is cost. You pay above market wages to attract the best, and if enough other firms start doing the same, that new higher wage becomes the new market wage, requiring you to raise prices again to attract superstar employees.
Efficiency wages can also increase unemployment. If a manager hires a group of superstar employees who are much more productive, instead of hiring ten mediocre workers, only five top performers are neededโleaving the other five unemployed. If these higher wages become the regular market wage demanded by that industry, and something similar happens throughout the workforce, higher wages can cause inflation (people having more money, spending more, driving up prices).
๐ Definition โ Efficiency Wage Theory: Organizations can save money by offering higher pays/benefits because they can hire the best talent, who will be more productive and less likely to leave.
BENEFITS
Employee benefits are group membership rewards that provide security for employees and their family members. They are sometimes called indirect compensation because they are given in the form of a plan (such as health insurance) rather than cash. A benefits package complements the base-compensation and pay-incentives components of total compensation. Employee benefits protect employees from risks that could jeopardize their health and financial security, providing coverage for sickness, injury, unemployment, old age, and death. They may also provide services or facilities like child-care services or exercise centers.
Benefits issues are important to employees. Managers must help employees understand and make the best use of their benefits. For instance, if an employee's child needs urgent medical attention, managers should explain the company's medical benefits to ensure all available coverage is obtained.
Benefits are a powerful recruiting tool. Firms offering enticing benefits can use this advantage to recruit high-quality applicants. Benefits also help retain talented employees by reducing turnover. Certain benefits such as vacations, family and medical leave, and sick days give employees scheduling flexibilityโmanagers need to be aware of these to effectively manage work schedules. Managers also need to be aware of their own benefits options, particularly retirement plans, which have long-term consequences affecting quality of life during and after a career.
Types of Benefits
There are two types of benefits: Traditional and Newer Type.
Traditional Benefits:
- Health insurance: Covers hospital costs, physician charges, and other medical services; usually considered separately from other insurance due to its importance.
- Life insurance: Protects employees or dependents from financial difficulties arising from disability or death.
- Education for children
- Pension plans after retirement
- Vacation time: Employees are sent on paid vacations by the company.
- Medical facilities for self and family
- Eid holiday: An example of benefit.
- Disability compensations: Provided for disability of employees.
- Old age benefit plans: Provide certain income to retired employees.
- Free travel facilities: Often provided as part of benefits package.
Newer Type Benefits:
- Wellness programs: Designed to keep employees healthy, including provision of gyms, vacations, exercise facilities, weight control measures, etc.
- Life cycle benefits: Given at different stages of life cyclesโfor marriage, childbirth, children's education, etc.
- Employee Assistance Programs (E.A.P.): Company-sponsored programs that help employees cope with personal problems interfering with job performance. For example, programs for solving alcohol problems.
- Flexible benefits: Concern the degree of freedom employees have to tailor the benefits package to their personal needs. Some organizations have standardized packages with few optionsโthis makes sense for homogeneous workforces where a package can be designed for a "typical" employee. In organizations without a "typical" employee profile, a decentralized benefits package emphasizing choice is more effective.
- Others: Benefits that cannot be categorized above, including services such as helping employees get education or trainingโa common practice these days.
๐ Definition โ Employee Assistance Programs (E.A.P.): Company-sponsored programs that help employees cope with personal problems that are interfering with their job performance.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: effective recognition programs require fairness and high visibility, not expensive rewardsโsmall, consistent acknowledgments like thank-you notes or public praise can be highly motivating. Efficiency Wage Theory explains that paying above-market wages attracts top talent and increases productivity, but carries risks of unemployment and inflation when widely adopted. Employee benefits are powerful indirect compensation tools that serve both as recruiting advantages and retention mechanisms, protecting employees' health and financial security. Managers must distinguish between traditional benefits (insurance, pensions, vacation time) and newer benefits (wellness programs, EAPs, flexible benefits), understanding how to help employees maximize their benefits packages. Finally, flexibility in benefits design is crucialโstandardized packages work for homogeneous workforces, while heterogeneous workforces require choice-driven, decentralized benefits systems.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two essential components of an effective employee recognition program, and why is each important?
- How does Efficiency Wage Theory explain the relationship between higher wages and organizational productivity, and what are its potential negative consequences?
- What distinguishes traditional benefits from newer type benefits, and provide two examples of each?
- Why are employee benefits considered "indirect compensation," and how do they serve as both recruiting and retention tools?
- Under what circumstances would a standardized benefits package be more effective than a flexible benefits package, and when would the opposite be true?
๐ Lecture 12 โ Perception
๐ Overview: This lecture explores perception as a complex cognitive process through which individuals acquire, interpret, select, and organize sensory information to create their unique picture of the world. Understanding perception is critical in organizational psychology because different employees may perceive the same situations very differently, leading to varied reactions and behaviors that must be managed effectively.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the distinction between sensations and perceptions, how they work together through psychophysics and thresholds, perceptual organization including Gestalt laws of grouping (proximity, similarity, continuity of direction, closure, and simplicity/pragnanze), figure-ground relationships, and perceptual selection which is influenced by both objective factors (intensity, size, contrast, repetition, motion vs. stationary, novelty/familiarity) and subjective factors (motivation and habits).
๐ Lecture Summary
Perception
Perception may be defined as the process of acquiring, interpreting, selecting, and organizing sensory information. The word perception comes from the Latin capere, meaning "to take," the prefix per meaning "completely." Methods of studying perception range from essentially biological or physiological approaches, through psychological approaches through the philosophy of mind.
In short, perception is a very complex cognitive process that yields a unique picture of the world, a picture that may be quite different from reality. In terms of organizational psychology, perception plays the role of creating a picture for the employee based on his or her own thinking. Therefore, the same situations/stimuli may produce very different reactions and behaviours from different employees. Understanding the difference between this perceived image and the real image is imperative to understand behaviour of employees. The perceptual image of the manager may be quite different from the perceptual image of the employee, and both may be very different from reality.
๐ก Why this matters: In organizational settings, managers must recognize that their own perceptions and those of their employees may not match reality, which can affect communication, motivation, and conflict resolution.
Sensations and Perceptions
Sensations can be defined as the passive process of bringing information from the outside world into the body and to the brain. The process is passive in the sense that we do not have to be consciously engaging in a "sensing" process.
Perception can be defined as the active process of selecting, organizing, and interpreting the information brought to the brain by the senses.
๐ Definition โ Sensation: The passive process of bringing information from the outside world into the body and to the brain without conscious engagement.
๐ Definition โ Perception: The active process of selecting, organizing, and interpreting the information brought to the brain by the senses.
How They Work Together
Sensation occurs when: a) Sensory organs absorb energy from a physical stimulus in the environment. b) Sensory receptors convert this energy into neural impulses and send them to the brain.
Perception follows: a) The brain organizes the information and translates it into something meaningful.
You may look at a painting and not really understand the message the artist is trying to convey. But, if someone tells you about it, you might begin to see things in the painting that you were unable to see before.
Psychophysics
Psychophysics can be defined as the study of how physical stimuli are translated into psychological experience. In order to measure these events, psychologists use Thresholds. Threshold is a dividing line between what has detectable energy and what does not. For example - many classrooms have automatic light sensors. When people have not been in a room for a while, the lights go out. However, once someone walks into the room, the lights go back on. For this to happen, the sensor has a threshold for motion that must be crossed before it turns the lights back on. So, dust floating in the room should not make the lights go on, but a person walking in should.
๐ Definition โ Psychophysics: The study of how physical stimuli are translated into psychological experience.
๐ Definition โ Threshold: A dividing line between what has detectable energy and what does not.
Perceptual Organization
Organizing raw sensory stimuli into meaningful experiences involves cognition, a set of mental activities that includes thinking, knowing, and remembering. Knowledge and experience are extremely important to perception, because they help us make sense of the input to our sensory systems.
Gestalt Laws of Grouping
How people perceive a well-organized pattern or whole, instead of many separate parts, is a topic of interest in Gestalt psychology. According to Gestalt psychologists, the whole is different than the sum of its parts. Gestalt is a German word meaning configuration or pattern.
A major goal of Gestalt theory in the 20th century was to specify the brain processes that might account for the organization of perception. Gestalt theorists, chief among them the German-U.S. psychologist and philosopher, the founder of Gestalt theory, Max Wertheimer and the German-U.S. psychologists Kurt Koffka and Wolfgang Kรถhler, rejected the earlier assumption that perceptual organization was the product of learned relationships (associations), the constituent elements of which were called simple sensations. Although Gestaltists agreed that simple sensations logically could be understood to comprise organized percepts, they argued that percepts themselves were basic to experience. One does not perceive so many discrete dots (as simple sensations), for example; the percept is that of a dotted line.
Without denying that learning can play some role in perception, many theorists took the position that perceptual organization reflects innate properties of the brain itself. Indeed, perception and brain functions were held by Gestaltists to be formally identical (or isomorphic), so much so that to study perception is to study the brain.
Many investigators relied heavily on introspective reports, treating them as though they were objective descriptions of public events. Serious doubts were raised in the 1920s about this use of introspection by the U.S. psychologist John B. Watson and others, who argued that it yielded only subjective accounts and that percepts are inevitably private experiences. In response, there arose an approach known as behaviorism that restricts its data to objective descriptions or measurements of the overt behavior of organisms other than the experimenter himself.
Wertheimer (1923) studied some factors which influence grouping in images, the so called Gestalt Principles of Perceptual Organization. He identified the following grouping factors:
Figure and Background
Not only does perception involve organization and grouping, it also involves distinguishing an object from its surroundings. Once you perceive an object, the area around that object becomes the background. Gestalt psychologists have devised ambiguous figure-ground relationships - drawings in which the figure and ground can be reversed - to illustrate their point that the whole is different from the sum of its parts. The "figure and ground" illusion is commonly experienced when one gazes at the illustration of a black vase the outline of which is created by two white profiles. At any moment one will be able to see either the black vase (in the centre area) as "figure" or the white profiles on each side (in which case the black is seen as "ground"). Seeing one aspect apparently excludes seeing the other.
Although such illustrations may fool our visual systems, people are rarely confused about what they see. In the real world, vases do not change into faces as we look at them. Instead, our perceptions are remarkably stable. The Gestaltist's concept of "figure-ground segregation" is not only referring to foreground-background, but also covers situations, e.g., in which you look through a window outside at a tree. The frame of the window is then the ground the tree the "figure", although it is behind the "ground."
๐ Definition โ Ambiguous figure-ground relationships: Drawings in which the figure and ground can be reversed to illustrate that the whole is different from the sum of its parts.
๐ Definition โ Figure-ground segregation: The Gestalt concept of distinguishing an object (figure) from its surroundings (ground), applicable beyond simple foreground-background relationships.
Proximity
Objects that are close to each other in physical space are often perceived as belonging together. This is the law of proximity or closeness. In the figure below, proximity results in a grouping containing pairs of dots.
Similarity
This law states that objects that are similar are perceived as going together. For example, if I ask you to group the following objects: (* * # * # # #) into groups, you would probably place the asterisks and the pound signs into distinct groups.
Continuity of Direction
There is a tendency in our perception to follow a direction, to connect the elements in a way that makes them seem contiguous or flowing in a particular direction. We follow whatever direction we are led. Dots in a smooth curve appear to go together more than jagged angles. This principle really gets at just how lazy humans are when it comes to perception.
Closure
There is a tendency in our perception to complete incomplete figures, to fill in gaps. Units forming a closed figure tend to be perceived together. We actually tend to complete a form when it has gaps.
Simplicity/Pragnanze
We group elements that make a good form. However, the idea of "good form" is a little vague and subjective. Most psychologists think good form is whatever is easiest or most simple. For example, what do you see here: : ) โ do you see a smiling face? There are simply 3 elements from my keyboard next to each other, but it is "easy" to organize the elements into a shape that we are familiar with or which is meaningful.
Perceptual Selection
From a purely biological standpoint our senses are utilized to perceive the world around us and to help us learn about it (Kerby, 1975). We take in stimuli from this world by tasting, touching, smelling, hearing and seeing what's going on around us. Since stimulation comes at us from several directions at once, we have the biological capability to physically 'tune out' most of what we do not need for the task at hand.
The human body receives a number of stimuli. The noise of the environment, the sound of the home appliances etc. are a few of the stimuli affecting the senses plus the impact of the total environmental situation. Sometimes the stimuli are below the person's conscious threshold, a process called subliminal perception. Despite the presence of all these stimuli, only few are registered by the body.
The principles of perceptual selection involve two types of factors:
- Objective Factors
- Subjective Factors
Objective Factors
Intensity: According to this principle, the more intense the stimulus, more its chances of being perceived. A loud noise is more likely to be perceived as compared to a softer one.
Size: According to this principle, the larger the object, the more likely it will be perceived. The tallest building in a bird-eye view of a city is more likely to be perceived than a smaller one.
Contrast: This principle states that external stimuli that stand out against the background will receive greater attention. For example, warning signs on road with black colour on yellow background are based on the principle of contrast.
Repetition: Repeated external stimulus is more attention getting than a single one. Advertisement efforts are often based on same principle.
Motion vs Stationary: The motion principle says that people pay more attention to moving objects in the field of vision than they will to stationary objects.
Novelty/Familiarity: The novelty familiarity principle states that either a novel or a familiar external situation can serve as attention getter.
Subjective Factors
Motivation and Habits: Motivation and habits play a vital role in determining the perceptions of individuals in an organization. In most cases, however, learning motivation and personality lead to extreme individual differences because of the way the individual is set to perceive. People may make wrong perceptions or perceive the same stimulus or stimulation in entirely different ways.
โญ Key Takeaways
For the exam, remember that perception is an active cognitive process distinct from passive sensation, and that the same stimulus can produce vastly different reactions in different employees due to perceptual differences. Master the five Gestalt laws of grouping (proximity, similarity, continuity of direction, closure, and simplicity/pragnanze) and understand figure-ground segregation as a fundamental organizing principle. Know the six objective factors of perceptual selection (intensity, size, contrast, repetition, motion vs. stationary, novelty/familiarity) and the subjective factors (motivation and habits) that shape individual perception. Finally, remember that perception creates a unique picture that may differ significantly from reality, which is why organizational psychology emphasizes understanding perceived versus real images.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between sensation and perception, and why is this distinction important in organizational psychology?
- Name and describe all five Gestalt principles of perceptual organization identified by Wertheimer.
- What is figure-ground segregation, and how does the black vase/white profiles illusion demonstrate this concept?
- List the six objective factors that influence perceptual selection and provide a workplace example for each.
- How do subjective factors like motivation and habits create individual differences in perception within an organization?