๐ Lecture 31 โ Job Stress
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the complex phenomenon of job stress, which costs the American economy an estimated $200โ300 billion annually. It defines stress, distinguishes between positive (eustress) and negative (distress) forms, explains the General Adaptation Syndrome model, and explores the causes and consequences of stress in organizational settings. Understanding stress is critical for organizational psychologists to help employees and organizations mitigate its harmful effects.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining stress and identifying its key componentsโadaptation, the stimulus (stressor), and excessive demands. It then distinguishes between eustress (positive stress) and distress (negative stress). The concept of burnout is explored as a consequence of prolonged stress. The General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS) is introduced as a three-stage model of how individuals respond to stressors. Individual consequences of stress are categorized into physiological, psychological, and behavioral outcomes. Finally, the causes of stress are classified into three main categories: extra-organizational stressors, organizational stressors, and group stressors.
๐ Lecture Summary
Job Stress
Stress is defined as a personโs adaptive response to a stimulus that places excessive psychological or physical demands on him or her. The key components of this definition are: (1) adaptationโpeople may adapt to stressful circumstances in various ways; (2) the stimulus, generally called a stressor, which is anything that induces stress; (3) stressors can be psychological or physical; and (4) the demands must be excessive for stress to resultโwhat is excessive for one person may be tolerable for another, as the person must perceive the demands as excessive. A simpler definition of stress is โexcessive physical and psychological demands on a person.โ
๐ก Why this matters: Job stress is a major financial burdenโestimated to cost the American economy $200โ300 billion annually due to overburdening, employee turnover, and the need for counseling.
๐ Definition โ Stress: a personโs adaptive response to a stimulus that places excessive psychological or physical demands on him or her. ๐ Formula: Stress = Stimulus (Stressor) + Perceived Excessive Demands + Adaptive Response โ Individual Outcome ๐ Example: A manager is assigned to write a lengthy report overnight. If the manager perceives this demand as excessive (e.g., "How will I ever get this done by tomorrow?"), the resulting panic and adaptive coping efforts represent the stress response.
Distress and Eustress
Hans Selye is recognized as the father of stress who discovered that tissue damage results from stress. He pointed out that sources of stress need not be bad. Eustress is positive stress that can lead to a number of positive outcomesโfor example, receiving a bonus and deciding what to do with the money, getting a promotion, gaining recognition, or getting married. Distress is negative stress, which is what most people think of when they hear the word "stress." Excessive pressure, unreasonable demands on time, and bad news all fall into this category, generally resulting in negative consequences for the individual.
๐ Definition โ Eustress: positive stress that can lead to a number of positive outcomes for the individual. ๐ Definition โ Distress: negative stress that generally results in negative consequences for the individual. ๐ Example: A promotion can be a source of eustress (positive challenge and growth) or distress (excessive pressure and unreasonable demands), depending on the individual's perception.
Burnout
Burnout is a general feeling of exhaustion that develops when a person simultaneously experiences too much pressure and has too few sources of satisfaction. In other words, it is the stage of losing a sense of direction and control. Burnout generally develops in the following way: First, people with high aspirations and strong motivation to get things done are prime candidates for burnout, especially when the organization suppresses or limits their initiative while constantly demanding that they serve the organizationโs own needs. In such a situation, the individual puts too much of himself or herself into the job, trying to meet personal and organizational expectations simultaneously. The likely effects are prolonged stress, fatigue, frustration, and helplessness under the burden of overwhelming demands. The person literally exhausts his or her aspirations and motivationโmuch as a candle burns itself outโfollowed by loss of self-confidence and psychological withdrawal. At this point, the individual may start dreading going to work in the morning, put in longer hours but accomplish less, and display mental and physical exhaustion.
๐ Definition โ Burnout: a general feeling of exhaustion that develops when a person simultaneously experiences too much pressure and has too few sources of satisfaction. ๐ Example: A highly motivated employee whose initiative is constantly suppressed by rigid organizational policies, while still expected to meet demanding targets, may eventually dread coming to work, work longer hours with less output, and feel mentally and physically drained.
General Adaptation Syndrome
Dr. Hans Selye made pioneering contributions including the identification of the general adaptation syndrome (GAS) and the concepts of eustress and distress. According to this model, each person has a normal level of resistance to stressful events and a threshold at which stress starts to affect them. The GAS begins when a person first encounters a stressor:
- Stage 1: Alarm โ The person feels some degree of panic and begins to wonder how to cope, resolving the "fight-or-flight" question (Can I deal with this, or should I run away?).
- Stage 2: Resistance โ The individual gathers strength (physical or emotional) and begins to resist the negative effects of the stressor. Often, this phase ends the GAS if the stressor is resolved.
- Stage 3: Exhaustion โ Prolonged exposure to a stressor without resolution brings on this stage, where the person literally gives up and can no longer fight the stressor.
๐ Definition โ General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS): a three-stage model of the body's response to stress: alarm, resistance, and exhaustion. ๐ Example: A manager assigned a lengthy report overnight experiences alarm ("How will I ever get this done by tomorrow?"), then resistance (calming down, calling home, rolling up sleeves, ordering dinner, and getting to work), and potentially exhaustion (falling asleep at the desk at 3 A.M. and failing to finish the report) if prolonged exposure occurs without resolution.
Individual Consequences of Stress
The individual consequences of stress are categorized into three types:
- Physiological consequences affect a person's physical well-being. Heart disease and stroke, among other illnesses, have been linked to stress. Other common medical problems include headaches, backaches, ulcers and related stomach and intestinal disorders, and skin conditions such as acne and hives.
- Psychological consequences relate to a person's mental health and well-being. When people experience too much stress at work, they may become depressed, sleep too much or not enough, face family problems, or exhibit aggression.
- Behavioral consequences may harm the person under stress or others. Smoking increases under stress. Alcohol and drug abuse are linked to stress, though this relationship is less well documented. Other possible consequences include accident proneness, violence, and appetite disorders.
Causes of Stress
Causes of stress are categorized into three main types:
Extra-organizational Stressors โ Stressors outside the person's job or organization. Common examples include:
- Life/Social/Technical Change: Any meaningful change in a person's personal or work situation; too many life changes can lead to health problems. Lack of ability to adapt to technical change also causes stress.
- Economical/Financial Condition: The economic or financial condition of the country or the individual may serve as a cause of stress.
- Class Conditions: The feeling of belonging to a class or development of complexes such as inferiority complex may cause stress.
Organizational Stressors โ Various factors in the workplace that can cause stress. Examples include:
- Organizational Policies: People may feel treated unfairly and perceive policies as inadequate.
- Physical Conditions: Working environment and physical conditions in organizations may be a potential source of stress.
- Process: Organizational processes such as poor communication and inadequate information may cause stress.
Group Stressors โ Factors that cause stress among group members. Examples include:
- Lack of Cohesiveness: A common cause of group stress since people develop grudges for each other.
- Lack of Social Support: Support from peers is an important desire; if not provided, it becomes a source of group stress.
- Conflicts Within and Inter-group: Conflicts among group members or between groups are a common source of stress.
โญ Key Takeaways
Stress is defined as an adaptive response to excessive psychological or physical demands, and it must be perceived as excessive by the individual. Stress can be positive (eustress) or negative (distress), and Hans Selye pioneered our understanding of both types. Burnout results from prolonged pressure with insufficient satisfaction, often affecting highly motivated individuals whose initiative is suppressed, leading to exhaustion and loss of direction. The General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS) outlines three stages of stress response: alarm (fight-or-flight), resistance (coping), and exhaustion (giving up). Consequences of stress are physiological (e.g., heart disease, headaches), psychological (e.g., depression, aggression), and behavioral (e.g., smoking, substance abuse). Causes of stress are categorized into extra-organizational (e.g., life changes, financial conditions), organizational (e.g., policies, physical conditions, processes), and group stressors (e.g., lack of cohesiveness, lack of social support, conflicts).
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Define stress according to this lecture and identify its four key components.
- What is the difference between eustress and distress? Provide an example of each.
- Describe the three stages of the General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS) in order.
- List the three categories of individual consequences of stress and give one example for each category.
- Identify the three main categories of stressors and provide one specific stressor from each category.
๐ Lecture 32 โ Individual Stressors
๐ Overview: This lecture examines key individual-level factors that influence workplace stress, including personality types (Type A and Type B), role-related stressors, and personal characteristics. It explores how these individual differences affect stress vulnerability, coping ability, and conflict dynamics, providing managers with insights for improving employee well-being and organizational effectiveness.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Type A and Type B personality profiles and their relationship to stress and heart disease, followed by role ambiguity and four types of role conflict. It then discusses personal control, learned helplessness, self-efficacy, and hardiness as individual factors affecting stress. The final sections address stress due to interpersonal conflict (with four sources) and inter-group conflicts (with four causes), including their positive and negative organizational effects.
๐ Lecture Summary
Personality Type: Type A and Type B
Type A and Type B profiles were first observed by cardiologists Meyer Friedman and Ray Rosenman. They noticed that waiting-room chairs were worn only on the front, suggesting heart patients were anxious and sat on the edges of their seats.
The extreme Type A individual is extremely competitive, very devoted to work, and has a strong sense of time urgency. This person is likely to be aggressive, impatient, and highly work oriented, with a lot of drive and motivation to accomplish as much as possible in as short a time as possible.
The extreme Type B person, in contrast, is less competitive, less devoted to work, and has a weaker sense of time urgency. This person feels less conflict with either people or time and has a more balanced, relaxed approach to life, able to work at a constant pace.
๐ Definition โ Type A: a behavior pattern characterized by extreme competitiveness, devotion to work, time urgency, aggression, and impatience ๐ Definition โ Type B: a behavior pattern characterized by less competitiveness, less work devotion, weaker time urgency, and a more balanced, relaxed approach to life
A common-sense expectation might be that Type A people are more successful than Type B people. In reality, however, this is not necessarily true. Type A people may alienate others because of their drive and may miss out on important learning opportunities. Type Bโs may have better interpersonal reputations and may learn a wider array of skills.
Friedman and Rosenman pointed out that people are not purely Type A or Type B; instead, people tend toward one or the other type.
Their initial research suggested that Type Aโs were much more likely to get coronary heart disease than Type Bโs. However, follow-up research has suggested the relationship is not straightforward. Recent findings suggest Type Aโs are likely to be depressed and hostile, and different approaches to measuring Type A tendencies have yielded different results. One study found Type Aโs to be less susceptible to heart problems, with researchers explaining that because Type Aโs are compulsive, they seek treatment earlier and are more likely to follow their doctorโs orders.
๐ก Why this matters: The Type A/Type B distinction is fundamental to understanding how personality influences both stress levels and health outcomes in the workplace.
Role Ambiguity/ Role Conflict
Role ambiguity arises when a role is unclear. If your instructor tells you to write a term paper but refuses to provide more information, you will probably experience ambiguity. In work settings, role ambiguity can stem from poor job descriptions, vague instructions from a supervisor, or unclear cues from co-workers. The result is likely to be a subordinate who does not know what to do. Role ambiguity can thus be a significant source of stress.
๐ Definition โ Role ambiguity: a stressor that occurs when the expectations and requirements of a role are unclear or poorly defined
Role conflict occurs when the messages and cues from others about the role are clear but contradictory or mutually exclusive.
There are four types of role conflict:
Inter-role conflict is conflict between different roles. For example, if a personโs boss says to get ahead one must work overtime and weekends, and the same personโs spouse says more time is needed at home, conflict may result.
Intra-role conflict occurs when a person gets conflicting demands from different sources within the context of the same role. A managerโs boss may tell her to put more pressure on subordinates to follow new work rules, while subordinates indicate they expect the manager to get the rules changed.
Intra-sender conflict occurs when a single source sends clear but contradictory messages. For example, the boss says one morning there can be no more overtime for the next month but after lunch tells someone to work late that same evening.
Person-role conflict results from a discrepancy between the role requirements and the individualโs personal values, attitudes, and needs. If a person is told to do something unethical or illegal, person-role conflict is likely.
๐ Definition โ Role conflict: a stressor that occurs when role expectations are clear but contradictory or mutually exclusive ๐ Example: Inter-role conflict โ A manager is told by his boss to work overtime but by his spouse to spend more time at home; the two roles (employee and family member) provide contradictory demands.
Role conflict of all varieties is of particular concern to managers. Research has shown that conflict may lead to stress, poor performance, and rapid turnover.
Personal Control
Personal control refers to the control over the environment. Research has shown that if people are given more control over their environment, for instance if employees are involved in decision making, they tend to have lesser stress and vice versa.
๐ Definition โ Personal control: the degree of influence an individual has over their environment, which inversely affects stress levels
Learned Helplessness
Learned helplessness is a psychological condition in which an animal has learned to believe that it is helpless. It has come to believe that it has no control over its situation and that whatever it does is futile. As a result, the animal will stay passive in the face of an unpleasant, harmful or damaging situation, even when it does actually have the power to change its circumstances.
๐ Definition โ Learned helplessness: a psychological condition where an individual believes they have no control over their situation, leading to passivity even when change is possible
Learned helplessness theory is the view that depression results from a perceived lack of control over the events in one's life, which may result from prior exposure to uncontrollable negative events. It is also a source of potential stress.
Self Efficacy
Self efficacy refers to an individual's belief in their ability to succeed in specific situations. Research has shown that people high in self-efficacy are less prone to stress while those low in self-efficacy are more prone to stress.
๐ Definition โ Self efficacy: a personal belief in one's capability to organize and execute courses of action required to achieve goals; inversely related to stress vulnerability
Hardiness
Hardiness is a personโs ability to cope with stress. People with hardy personalities have an internal locus of control, are strongly committed to the activities in their lives, and view change as an opportunity for advancement and growth. Such people are seen as relatively unlikely to suffer illness if they experience high levels of pressure and stress. On the other hand, people with low hardiness may have more difficulties in coping with pressure and stress.
๐ Definition โ Hardiness: a personality characteristic that enables a person to cope with stress, characterized by internal locus of control, commitment, and viewing change as opportunity
Stress Due To Conflict
Interpersonal Conflict
Research shows that people attribute othersโ behavior to personal factors such as intelligence, ability, motivation, attitudes, or personalities. This causes interpersonal conflicts. Whetton and Cameron identified four major sources of interpersonal conflict:
Personal Differences: Every individual comes from a different background and has experienced different patterns of socialization. Therefore, conflicts arise based on these individual differences.
Information Deficiency: Information deficiency means either lack of information or misinformation. This also results in development of conflicts. However, such conflicts are easily resolved once the information is corrected.
Role Incompatibility: Role incompatibility is a situation when people performing different roles in an organization find the requirements of their jobs opposing to each other. It also leads to conflicts but can be corrected using advanced technology.
Environmental Stress: Conflicts arise due to harsh environment; often in organizations, the environment is highly competitive, tough, etc. This is a cause of stress which may lead to conflict.
๐ Definition โ Interpersonal conflict: conflict between individuals arising from personal differences, information deficiency, role incompatibility, or environmental stress
Inter-Group Conflicts
These are conflicts between groups. Following are the reasons identified by researchers for inter-group conflicts:
Competition for Resources: Groups in organizations tend to maximize their share of limited resources available in the organization. This causes conflicts between them.
Task Interdependence: Research shows that if performance of groups depends on the tasks performed by each other, there tends to be more conflict between groups.
Jurisdictional Ambiguity: These are ambiguities regarding the area of control of groups. Groups in organizations may take credit for performance of another group which causes conflicts of this sort.
Status Struggle: Status struggle is the struggle among groups in organizations to be ranked higher than others. It is also a source of conflict between groups.
๐ Definition โ Inter-group conflict: conflict between groups in organizations, caused by competition for resources, task interdependence, jurisdictional ambiguity, or status struggle
Group conflicts create stress and give rise to โin groupโ versus โout groupโ feeling. Group conflict/rivalry may be good for the organization as well.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must understand that Type A personality is characterized by competitiveness, time urgency, and aggression, while Type B is more relaxed and balanced, but neither type is inherently more successful. The four types of role conflict โ inter-role, intra-role, intra-sender, and person-role โ each have distinct sources and all lead to stress, poor performance, and turnover. Personal control, self-efficacy, and hardiness buffer against stress, while learned helplessness increases stress vulnerability. Finally, interpersonal conflicts arise from personal differences, information deficiency, role incompatibility, and environmental stress, while inter-group conflicts stem from competition for resources, task interdependence, jurisdictional ambiguity, and status struggles โ and group conflict can sometimes benefit the organization.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key behavioral differences between Type A and Type B personalities, and why is Type A not necessarily more successful than Type B?
- Name and describe the four types of role conflict discussed in this lecture, giving a brief example of each.
- How do personal control, learned helplessness, self-efficacy, and hardiness each affect an individual's vulnerability to stress?
- What are the four major sources of interpersonal conflict identified by Whetton and Cameron, and which one is most easily resolved?
- List the four causes of inter-group conflict in organizations and explain why group conflict can sometimes be beneficial.
๐ Lecture 33 โ Effects of Stress
๐ Overview: This lecture examines how stress manifests in physical, psychological, and behavioral symptoms within organizational contexts. It then explores both individual and organizational strategies for coping with stress, and concludes with an introduction to negotiation as a fundamental conflict resolution skill.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the physical, psychological, and behavioral effects of stress on employees, followed by detailed coping strategies at both individual and organizational levels. It also introduces negotiation as a key interpersonal skill, defining its nature, elements, and applications in organizational and everyday settings. The Harvard Negotiating Project's four elements of good negotiations are presented.
๐ Lecture Summary
Effects of Stress
Stress shows itself in numerous ways, including high blood pressure, ulcers, irritability, difficulty making routine decisions, loss of appetite, and accident proneness. These effects can be categorized as physical, psychological, and behavioral.
Physical Effects
Most early concern with stress was directed at physiological symptoms, primarily researched by health and medical science specialists. This research concluded that stress could create changes in metabolism, increase heart and breathing rates, increase blood pressure, bring on headaches, and induce heart attacks. The link between stress and specific physiological symptoms is not clear, with few consistent relationships due to the complexity of symptoms and difficulty in objectively measuring them.
Psychological Effects
Stress can cause job dissatisfaction, which is described as "the simplest and most obvious psychological effect" of stress. Other psychological states include tension, anxiety, irritability, boredom, and procrastination. Evidence indicates that jobs making multiple and conflicting demands, or lacking clarity about duties, authority, and responsibilities, increase both stress and dissatisfaction. Jobs providing low levels of variety, significance, autonomy, feedback, and identity create stress and reduce satisfaction and involvement. Additional psychological effects include anger, depression, lower self-esteem, resentment to supervision, and lack of concentration.
Behavioural Effects
Behaviourally related stress symptoms include changes in productivity, absence, and turnover. Also included are changes in eating habits, increased smoking or consumption of alcohol, rapid speech, fidgeting, sleep disorders, drug abuse, absenteeism, and tardiness.
Coping With Stress
From the organization's point of view, management may not be concerned with low to moderate stress levels because these may be functional and lead to higher performance. However, high levels of stress, or low levels sustained over long periods, can reduce performance and require management action. From the individual's standpoint, even low levels of stress are likely perceived as undesirable, leading employees and management to have different notions of acceptable stress levels.
Individual Strategies
An employee can take personal responsibility for reducing stress through several proven strategies:
-
Time-management techniques: Many people manage time poorly. A well-organized employee can accomplish twice as much as a poorly organized one. Understanding and utilizing time-management principles helps cope with tension from job demands.
-
Increasing physical exercise: Non-competitive physical exercise such as aerobics, walking, jogging, swimming, and riding a bicycle have been recommended to deal with excessive stress. These forms increase heart capacity, lower at-rest heart rate, provide a mental diversion from work pressures, and offer a means to let off steam.
-
Relaxation training: Individuals can teach themselves to reduce tension through meditation, hypnosis, and biofeedback. The objective is to reach a state of deep relaxation where one feels physically relaxed, detached from the immediate environment, and detached from body sensations.
-
Expanding the social support network: Networking with friends, relatives, or work colleagues provides an outlet when stress levels become excessive. Having someone to hear problems and offer an objective perspective helps reduce tension. Research demonstrates that social support moderates the stress-burnout relationship; high support reduces the likelihood that heavy work stress results in job burnout.
Organizational Strategies
Several stress-causing factors (task/role demands and organization structure) are controlled by management and can be modified:
-
Improved personnel selection and job placement: Individuals differ in stress responses. Those with little experience or an external locus of control tend to be more stress-prone. Selection should consider these facts, as individuals with experience and an internal locus may adapt better to high-stress jobs.
-
Use of realistic goal setting: Individuals perform better with specific and challenging goals and feedback on progress. Goals reduce stress by clarifying performance expectations, while goal feedback reduces uncertainties about actual performance, resulting in less frustration, role ambiguity, and stress.
-
Redesigning jobs: Giving employees more responsibility, meaningful work, autonomy, and increased feedback can reduce stress by giving greater control over work activities and lessening dependence on others.
-
Additional measures: Creating a supportive organizational climate (decentralized, participative environment), reducing conflict and clarifying organizational roles, planning and developing career paths, and providing counselling.
Negotiation
Negotiation is something we do all the time, not only for business but for everyday life, such as deciding a meeting time or where to go. It requires an open mind, good preparation, and tremendous creativity. Negotiation is a process we use from infancy until death; the real goal is to understand how to negotiate effectively to reach wise solutions. In ancient times, disputes were settled by waging war, then by waging law; negotiation is a means to "wage peace."
๐ Definition โ Negotiation: The process where interested parties resolve disputes, agree upon courses of action, bargain for individual or collective advantage, and/or attempt to craft outcomes serving their mutual interests. It is usually considered a form of alternative dispute resolution.
Communication is always the link used to negotiateโface-to-face, by telephone, or in writing. Negotiation can involve several members from two parties and successful negotiation generally results in a contract between parties. Oliver (1996) described negotiation as "negotiators jointly searching a multidimensional space and then agreeing to a single point in the space."
Negotiation applies knowledge from communications, sales, marketing, psychology, sociology, politics, and conflict resolution. It occurs whenever an economic transaction takes place or a dispute is settled (e.g., consumers purchasing automobiles or businesses negotiating salaries with employees).
The Harvard Negotiating Project identified four elements of good negotiations:
- Separate people from problem
- Focus on interest not positions
- Generate a variety of options
- Insist on objective standards for results
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding negotiation as a structured process with clear elements transforms it from a vague interpersonal skill into a systematic approach for resolving conflicts and reaching mutually beneficial agreements in both organizational and personal contexts.
โญ Key Takeaways
Stress manifests through physical symptoms (metabolism changes, heart issues, headaches), psychological effects (dissatisfaction, anxiety, depression), and behavioral changes (productivity shifts, absenteeism, substance use). Coping strategies exist at both individual levels (time management, exercise, relaxation, social support) and organizational levels (better selection, goal setting, job redesign, supportive climate). Negotiation is a fundamental life skill defined as a process for resolving disputes and reaching joint agreements, guided by the Harvard Negotiating Project's four elements: separating people from problems, focusing on interests over positions, generating options, and using objective standards.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main categories of stress effects discussed in this lecture, and provide one example of each?
- List four individual strategies for coping with stress described in the lecture.
- What four elements does the Harvard Negotiating Project identify for good negotiations?
- How can organizational goal setting reduce employee stress according to the lecture?
- What is the definition of negotiation provided by Oliver (1996), and how does it relate to the concept of "waging peace"?
๐ Lecture 34 โ POWER AND POLITICS
๐ Overview: This lecture defines power in organizational contexts, exploring its types and the dynamics of influence. It explains that power is the capacity to influence others despite resistance, focusing on the dependency relationship between individuals. Understanding these concepts is crucial for analyzing leadership, organizational effectiveness, and the ethical use of authority.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition of power, introduces five distinct types of power (reward, coercive, legitimate, referent, and expert), and examines six factors that determine a person's susceptibility to influence (influencibility). It also distinguishes between two faces of power (negative and positive) and discusses the beneficial outcomes of employee empowerment for organizational performance.
๐ Lecture Summary
Power may be defined as getting things done in spite of opposition and resistance: get a person/group to change.
Power is defined as the capacity that A has to influence the behaviour of B, so B does something he or she would not do otherwise. This definition implies three key components: a potential that need not be actualized to be effective, a dependency relationship between A and B, and the assumption that B has some discretion over his or her own behaviour.
๐ Definition โ Power: getting things done in spite of opposition and resistance; the capacity of A to influence the behaviour of B so that B does something they would not otherwise do.
Types of Power
There are five distinct types of power: reward, coercive, legitimate, referent, and expert.
Reward Power
Reward power is the ability to change people because one controls their rewards. People comply with the wishes or directives of another because it produces positive benefits. Therefore, one who can distribute rewards that others view as valuable will have power over them. These rewards can be anything another person values, such as money, favourable performance appraisals, promotions, interesting work assignments, friendly colleagues, important information, and preferred work shifts or sales territories.
๐ Definition โ Reward Power: the ability to influence others by controlling rewards they value.
Coercive Power
Coercive power is the ability to create fear in people; it can inflict pain or punishment. One reacts to this power out of the fear of the negative results that might occur if one failed to comply. It rests on the application, or the threat of application, of physical sanctions such as the infliction of pain, the generation of frustration through restriction of movement, or the controlling by force of basic psychological or safety needs. At the organizational level, A has coercive power over B if A can dismiss, suspend, or demote B, assuming B values his or her job.
Coercive and reward power are actually counterparts of each other. If you can remove something of positive value from another or inflict something of negative value upon him or her, you have coercive power. If you can give someone something of positive value or remove something of negative value, you have reward power.
๐ Definition โ Coercive Power: the ability to influence others through fear, punishment, or the threat of negative consequences.
Legitimate Power
In formal groups and organizations, probably the most frequent access to one or more of the power bases is oneโs structural position. This is called legitimate power. It represents the power a person receives as a result of his or her position in the formal hierarchy of an organization. Positions of authority include coercive and reward powers, but legitimate power is broader. It includes the acceptance by members of an organization of the authority of a position. When school principals, bank presidents, or army captains speak; teachers, tellers, and officers listen and usually comply.
๐ Definition โ Legitimate Power: power a person receives as a result of his or her position in the formal hierarchy of an organization.
Referent Power
Referent power is based on identification with a person who has desirable resources or personal traits. If I admire and identify with you, you can exercise power over me because I want to please you. Referent power develops out of admiration for another and a desire to be like that person. It is similar to charisma. If you admire someone to the point of modelling your behaviour and attitudes after him or her, this person possesses referent power over you. Referent power explains why celebrities are paid huge sums of money to endorse products.
๐ก Why this matters: Marketers leverage referent power, as people like Imran Khan or Shahrukh Khan can influence consumer choices. In organizations, being articulate, domineering, physically imposing, or charismatic provides personal characteristics used to get others to do what you want.
๐ Definition โ Referent Power: influence based on identification with, admiration for, and a desire to be like another person.
Expert power
Expert power is the influence wielded as a result of expertise, special skills, or knowledge. Expertise has become one of the most powerful sources of influence as the world has become more technologically oriented. As jobs become more specialized, we become increasingly dependent on "experts" to achieve goals. While physicians have expert power, computer specialists, accountants, engineers, psychologists, and other specialists can also wield power as a result of their expertise.
๐ Definition โ Expert Power: influence wielded as a result of expertise, special skills, or knowledge.
Influencibility and Power
There are six factors of influencibility that are responsible for developing power: dependence, uncertainty, personality, intelligence, culture, and sex.
-
Dependence โ The greater Bโs dependency on A, the greater the power A has over B. When you possess anything that others require but you alone control, you make them dependent on you. Dependency is inversely proportional to the alternative sources of supply. If something is plentiful, possession of it will not increase your power.
-
Uncertainty โ Uncertainty refers to the doubt in the minds of the people about a particular behaviour being correct or incorrect. Therefore, the more uncertain people are, the more likely they are to be influenced.
-
Personality โ People who are anxious and ambiguity intolerant are easy to influence, while people who have high self-esteem are less likely to be influenced.
-
Intelligence โ People who are more intelligent are less likely to be influenced, though they may pay more attention. People with lower levels of intelligence are easily influenced.
-
Sex โ Research has shown that women are more likely to be influenced as compared to men.
-
Culture โ Cultural values of a society play a vital role in determining the influencibility of a person. Eastern cultures are more influenceable as compared to Western cultures.
๐ Definition โ Influencibility: the degree to which a person is susceptible to being influenced by others.
Two Faces of Power
Two types of power have been identified by the works of David McClelland: Negative Power and Positive Power.
Negative Power: Also called personal power. This occurs when people try to use their abilities to get ahead of others and are only oriented towards personal goals rather than organizational goals. In organizations, people try to find reasons to convince the boss for a promotion, using power for personal motives rather than the objective of the organization.
Positive Power: Also called social power. This is characterized by the concern for others, groups, and society. In the context of the organization, it has the concern for organizational goals. According to McClelland, social power is a "we" oriented power as compared to personal power which is an "I" oriented power. Socially powerful leaders and managers are more effective in organizations.
๐ Definition โ Negative/Personal Power: power used for personal gain, oriented towards personal goals rather than organizational goals.
๐ Definition โ Positive/Social Power: power characterized by concern for others, groups, and society; a "we" oriented power.
Employeesโ perception of their own power or empowerment in an organization is critical to the success of an organization.
Empowermentโemployeesโ perception of their own powerโincreases three key organizational outcomes:
- Innovation: Innovation is increased by employeesโ perception of being powerful because they feel they can take the liberty of trying and inventing. They feel they have resources at their own disposal which they can use responsibly for the organization's benefit.
- Cooperation: When employees feel they have power in the organization, they are more willing to cooperate and share knowledge, information, and experiences. Therefore, the performance of the organization is enhanced.
- Responsibility: When employees have power, they also have a sense of responsibility and can be held responsible for their actions. This is not meant to punish employees but to ensure they put in their best efforts to improve the working of the organization.
๐ Definition โ Empowerment: employeesโ perception of their own power in an organization.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture defines power as the capacity to influence behavior despite resistance, emphasizing the dependency relationship between individuals. Five types of power are crucial to understand: reward (based on controlling valued outcomes), coercive (based on fear and punishment), legitimate (based on formal position), referent (based on admiration and charisma), and expert (based on special knowledge and skills). Influencibility, or susceptibility to influence, is determined by six factors: dependence, uncertainty, personality, intelligence, culture, and sex. A critical distinction exists between negative/personal power (focused on self-interest) and positive/social power (focused on group and organizational goals). Finally, employee empowermentโthe perception of having powerโsignificantly enhances organizational innovation, cooperation, and responsibility.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three key implications of the definition of power?
- Explain how reward power and coercive power are counterparts of each other.
- Why is expert power considered increasingly important in today's world?
- According to David McClelland, what is the difference between negative (personal) power and positive (social) power?
- List the six factors of influencibility and explain how culture affects a person's likelihood of being influenced.