π Lecture 43 β Forensic Psychology
π Overview: This lecture introduces forensic psychology as the application of psychological knowledge to the legal system. It covers the field's definition, history, and major professional activities, from serving as expert witnesses in court to consulting on jury selection and witness preparation, highlighting both its growth and the controversies surrounding it.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a definition of forensic psychology and its historical development, notably the landmark Jenkins v. United States case. It then details eight major activities of forensic psychologists: serving as an expert witness (including qualifications, topics, and the process of testifying and cross-examination), involvement in criminal cases (insanity plea and competency to stand trial), civil cases (commitment to mental institutions and domestic issues like child custody), predicting dangerousness, and consultation (jury selection, witness preparation, and convincing the jury).
π Lecture Summary
Definition
Forensic psychology involves "the application of the methods, theories, and concepts of psychology to the legal system." A variety of settings and clients may be involved, including children and adults, as well as institutions like corporations, government agencies, universities, hospitals, clinics, and correctional facilities.
π Definition β Forensic psychology: The application of the methods, theories, and concepts of psychology to the legal system.
History
In 1962, judge Bazelon, writing for the majority on the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, held for the first time that psychologists who were appropriately qualified could testify in court as experts on mental disorder (Jenkins v. United States). This finally allowed the forensic psychologist to appear on the scene, even though psychiatrists had enjoyed this privilege for many years. Today, psychologists regularly testify as experts in virtually every area of criminal, civil, family, and administrative law. Even before MΓΌnsterberg, William Stern reported in 1901 that he was studying the "correctness" of recollection, an early precursor of today's research on eyewitness testimony. Sigmund Freud, in a 1906 speech, claimed that psychology has real applications to the law. Today, forensic psychology has arrived at a point where there are specialists in psycho-legal research, interdisciplinary training programs, and numerous specialty journals like Law and Human Behavior and the American Journal of Forensic Psychology.
Major Activities of Forensic Psychologists
The growth of forensic psychology has thrust the psychologist into many different roles. The lecture focuses on eight such roles.
1. The Expert Witness
The lecture presents a scenario involving Ms. Ferris, who filed sexual harassment charges against her supervisor, Mr. Smith, after being fired for refusing his proposition. Dr. Miller, a clinical psychologist, was retained by her attorney to conduct interviews and administer tests. The key difference is illustrated between a lay witness (Mr. Wright, who testifies only to events witnessed) and an expert witness (Dr. Miller, who may offer opinions and inferences within the scope of his training). The expert witness must help the court understand and evaluate evidence or determine a fact about an issue.
π Definition β Expert witness: Anyone who can provide information that, by its uniqueness in relation to some science, profession, training, or experience, is unlikely to be known to the average juror.
Qualification: An expert witness can be anyone who can provide unique information unlikely to be known to the average juror. The court decides if the witness may claim expert status. If opposing counsel objects, further evidence of competence is presented. The bases of clinical psychological expertise include: (1) education and formal training, (2) relevant experience, (3) research and publications, (4) knowledge and application of scientific principles, and (5) use of special tests and measurements.
Topics for expert testimony: Experts are not allowed to state opinions that are the legal prerogative of the jury. Therefore, expert witnesses are prevented from providing "ultimate opinion" testimony.
Testifying: Testifying in court can be a harrowing experience due to anxiety and self-doubt as the expert is tugged by attorneys on both sides. An important prelude is pretrial preparation, which can involve many hours of study, interviewing, testing, and conferences.
Cross Examination: The lecture provides examples of provocative questions asked during cross-examination, such as "You are not a real doctor, are you?" Schwitzgebel and Schwitzgebel (1980) summarize recommended strategies for coping with cross examination: Be prepared, be honest, admit weaknesses, talk in personally meaningful terms, and listen carefully to the wording of questions and take time to think.
2. Criminal Cases
The Insanity Plea: If the accused is judged to have been sane at the time of the crime, conviction brings punishment. An individual adjudged insane is regarded as not responsible and held for treatment. The insanity plea is seldom successful. Insanity is a legal term, not a medical one. The burden of proof is typically on the defense. Three standards typically prevail:
- The M'Naghten rule (1843): The person did not know the nature and quality of the act, or did not know it was wrong.
- The "irresistible impulse" test: It was impossible for the individual to resist the impulse.
- The ALI standard (American Law Institute): The act was the result of mental disease or defect such that substantial capacity to appreciate the criminality of the act or to conform to the law was lacking.
The famous Hinckley case (attempted assassination of President Reagan) encouraged a return to the M'Naghten rule, allowed for indefinite confinement of those acquitted by insanity, introduced the verdict "guilty but mentally ill," and placed the burden of proving insanity on the defense.
To conduct an evaluation for criminal insanity, the psychologist must address three questions: (1) Does the person have a mental disorder or defect? (2) What is the person's present mental status? (3) What was the person's mental status at the time of the alleged crime?
Competency To Stand Trial: This issue concerns the defendant's state of mind at the time of the trial, not when the offense was committed. Three basic issues come to the fore: (1) Can the person appreciate the nature of the charges and report factually on their behavior? (2) Can the person cooperate in a reasonable way with counsel? (3) Can the person appreciate the proceedings of the court?
3. Civil Cases
Two particularly important areas are commitment to mental institutions and domestic issues like child custody disputes.
Commitment To Mental Institutions: Hospitalization against an individual's will is involuntary commitment. The permissible length varies. After that, a hearing must be held. In voluntary commitment, the individual agrees to admission and may leave at any time. For the court to commit someone, a hearing must determine if the person: (1) is dangerous to self or others, (2) is so disturbed as to be incapable of making responsible decisions, or (3) requires treatment. The person must be determined to be mentally ill.
4. Domestic Issues
Child custody is a major issue. The doctrine of the "best interests of the child" always takes precedence in custody disputes.
5. Predicting Dangerousness
Therapists have a duty to protect potential victims from their patients' violent behavior. However, accurately predicting dangerous behavior is difficult. To truly protect against dangerous individuals, a very large net would be needed that would also confine many who are not dangerous, as the incidence of violence relative to the total population is quite low.
6. Consultation
Jury Selection: A consulting psychologist may work with attorneys during the voir dire phase, where a jury is impaneled. The consultant helps attorneys discover biases in potential jurors and achieve better jury selection or deselection.
Witness Preparation: The goal is to help witnesses present their testimony better without changing the facts. Because this is a delicate matter, some consultants will not work with witnesses in criminal proceedings, only in civil cases.
Convincing The Jury: Consultants can help attorneys predict how jurors will respond to certain kinds of evidence or methods of presentation to find the best way to present their cases.
π‘ Why this matters: The role of the forensic psychologist is multifaceted, requiring expertise not only in clinical assessment but also in the specific legal contexts and procedures of the courts.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that forensic psychology applies psychological principles to the legal system, a right established in 1962 by Jenkins v. United States. The expert witness can offer opinions and inferences, unlike a lay witness, but cannot provide "ultimate opinion" testimony. In criminal cases, the insanity plea is a legal term with three main standards (M'Naghten, Irresistible Impulse, ALI), while competency to stand trial is a separate issue concerning the defendant's state at trial. Finally, the duty to protect potential victims from dangerous patients is complicated by the low base rate of violence, making accurate prediction difficult.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What was the landmark 1962 case that allowed psychologists to testify as expert witnesses on mental disorder?
- What is the key difference between a lay witness and an expert witness in a court of law?
- Name the three standards used to determine an insanity plea for a criminal defendant.
- What are the three basic issues that are assessed to determine a defendant's competency to stand trial?
- Why is it difficult for psychologists to accurately predict a patient's dangerousness?
π Lecture 44 β Pediatric and Child Psychology: History and Perspective
π Overview: This lecture introduces the two key subfields of clinical psychology focused on children: clinical child psychology and pediatric psychology. It covers their definitions, historical development, the crucial developmental perspective, the concept of resilience, and the major professional activitiesβassessment, intervention, prevention, and consultationβincluding specific assessment methods for children and adolescents.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by distinguishing between clinical child psychology and pediatric psychology, followed by a brief history of both specialties. It then emphasizes the importance of a developmental perspective and the concept of resilience. The core of the lecture details the major activities of these psychologists, starting with general issues like epidemiology and the client, and then provides an in-depth overview of assessment methods including interviewing, behavioral observation, intelligence and achievement tests, projective tests, neuropsychological assessment, and family assessment.
π Lecture Summary
DEFINITIONS
Clinical child psychology traditionally involves work with children and adolescents after psychopathological symptoms have developed, often in private practice or outpatient clinic settings. In contrast, pediatric psychology (or child health psychology) is clinical child psychology conducted in medical settings like hospitals and clinics. Pediatric psychologists often intervene before full-blown psychopathology develops and receive referrals from pediatricians. While there is considerable overlap, surveys show pediatric clinicians tend to have a more behavioral orientation and use short-term interventions, while clinical child psychologists have more diverse orientations and emphasize assessment, developmental processes, and family therapy. Pediatric psychologists place greater emphasis on medical and biological issues.
π Definition β Pediatric Psychology: "A field of research and practice that has been concerned with a wide variety of topics in the relationship between the psychological and physical well-being of children, including behavioral and emotional concomitants of disease and illness, the role of psychology in pediatric medicine, and the promotion of health and prevention of illness among healthy children." π‘ Why this matters: This distinction is crucial because it determines the setting, referral source, and timing of intervention for a child psychologist.
HISTORY
The history of clinical child psychology dates to 1896 when Lightner Witmer started the first psychological clinic, devoted to treating children with learning or behavioral problems. The scientific study of childhood psychopathology began in the early 1900s, when children were still often viewed as "miniature adults." Key developments included the identification and care of those with mental retardation, intelligence testing, psychoanalysis, behaviorism, the child study movement, and child guidance clinics. The classification of childhood disorders has also evolved. Early editions of the DSM (I and II) viewed childhood problems as extensions of adult disorders, but starting with DSM-III and continuing with DSM-IV, there are now 43 specific diagnoses in ten groups that are relevant to children. Pediatric psychology emerged because neither pediatrics nor clinical child psychology could handle all childhood problems. By 1966, 300 psychologists worked in pediatric settings, and by 1999, the Society of Pediatric Psychology became Division 54 of the APA.
A DEVELOPMENTAL PERSPECTIVE
From a developmental perspective, psychological problems in children and adolescents result from deviations in one or more areas of development (cognitive, biological, physical, emotional, behavioral, social) compared to same-age peers. Key principles include:
- Development is an active, dynamic process best assessed over time.
- Similar developmental problems may lead to different outcomes.
- Different developmental problems may lead to the same outcome.
- Developmental processes or failures may interact.
- Developmental processes and the environment are interdependent. This perspective means children are not viewed as miniature adults. Their age, stage of development, and family/social context must be considered to avoid inaccurate assessments and inappropriate treatments. For example, bedwetting is a problem at age 12 but not at age 2.
π Definition β Developmental Perspective: A viewpoint that psychological problems in children are seen as deviations from normal developmental trajectories, assessed in the context of age, stage, and environment.
RESILIENCE
Resilience refers to qualities in individuals associated with their ability to overcome adversity and achieve good developmental outcomes, even when faced with incredible hardship. Research on at-risk children (e.g., from war or violent homes) shows that factors promoting strong attachments between child and parent and the capacity for good problem-solving skills help buffer against adverse circumstances. While these factors are only associated with (not causal of) good outcomes, resilience studies can inform interventions aimed at preventing risk factors, building resources, and enhancing processes like self-efficacy and self-regulation.
π Definition β Resilience: Qualities in individuals that help them overcome adversity and achieve positive developmental outcomes despite unfavorable environments.
MAJOR ACTIVITIES
GENERAL ISSUES REGARDING MAJOR ACTIVITIES:
- Epidemiology: Knowing how common problems are across age groups and populations is vital. For example, feeding and sleeping problems are common between ages 1-2, and hyperactivity/conduct disorders are more frequent in boys.
- The Situation: Behavior is often situation-specific. A child may be withdrawn at home but not with peers, so the interaction between the environment and general personality must be considered.
- Who Is the Client?: The most effective treatment is often directed at parents. Children do not refer themselves, and the clinician's first task is to determine if a problem actually exists.
- Diagnosis and Classification: The DSM-IV has ten major groups of disorders usually first diagnosed in infancy, childhood, or adolescence. Diagnostic criteria are often modified for children (e.g., one year duration of irritable mood for dysthymia vs. two years for adults). Problems are often subdivided into internalizing disorders (anxiety, depression, social withdrawal) and externalizing disorders (aggressive, impulsive, conduct problems).
A. Assessment
Assessment with children differs from adults because they rarely seek treatment themselves and information must be gathered from multiple sources (parents, teachers, etc.). Obtaining the child's permission is crucial for building trust. A key challenge is that these multiple sources may disagree. The goal is to estimate the nature and severity of the problem early on by generating a case history. A comprehensive assessment includes information from multiple informants and multiple methods.
Interviewing: Interviews with parents elicit information about behavior, gauge parental feelings, and establish a therapeutic relationship. Interviews with children allow them to "tell their own story." It is critical to find out what the child understands about the visit to address anxiety. Interviewing children is difficult as they may be suggestible, fearful, or have limited communication skills. The length of the interview depends on the child's age and intellectual level.
Behavioral Observation: Direct observations of the child at home and school are undertaken using methods like naturalistic, analogue, participant, and self-observational techniques. The Behavioral Coding System (BCS), developed by Patterson for use with pre-delinquent boys with aggression, involves trained observers spending 1-2 hours in the home recording family interactions.
Intelligence Tests: Used when questions of intellectual achievement or academic deficits arise. Common tests include the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-III), the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (K-ABC), and the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale. These are well-suited for assessing learning disabilities, mental retardation, and neurological dysfunction.
Achievement Tests: These assess past learning from school programs, covering subjects from reading to arithmetic. Examples include the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised and the Wide Range Achievement Test-3 (WRAT-3).
Projective Tests: Their use is controversial, but some clinicians argue they are less threatening for highly anxious children. Examples include the TAT, Rorschach, Children's Apperception Test, and Draw-A-Person Test. Clinicians must consider the reliability and validity of their interpretations and guard against interpretive errors.
Neuropsychological Assessment: This specialty has grown due to increased focus on neurodevelopmental disorders, spurred by the Education for All Handicapped Children Act. Current research includes assessing neurophysiologic correlates of disorders like conduct disorder and ADHD.
Family Assessment: Because a child's problems are embedded in the family context, understanding the family system is essential. Common measures include the Family Environment Scale (FES) and the Family Adaptability and Cohesion Evaluation Scales (FACES III).
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points to remember are the clear distinction between clinical child and pediatric psychology, and the overarching importance of the developmental perspective, which dictates that children are not merely "miniature adults." You must know the historical milestones (Witmer, DSM evolution) and the concept of resilience. For assessment, remember that children rarely self-refer, requiring data from multiple, potentially conflicting, informants. Finally, be familiar with the different assessment methodsβinterviews, behavioral observation, intelligence/achievement tests, and the rationale for family and neuropsychological assessment.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary difference between a clinical child psychologist and a pediatric psychologist in terms of setting and timing of intervention?
- List three key historical developments that increased the focus on children before the 20th century.
- Why is the "developmental perspective" critical in pediatric and child psychology, and how does it differ from treating a child as a "miniature adult"?
- What are the two broad categories of childhood disorders (internalizing and externalizing), and provide one example of each.
- Name three major challenges that differentiate the assessment of children from the assessment of adults.
π Lecture 45 β Interventions & Training in Pediatric and Clinical Child Psychology
π Overview: This lecture explores the diverse intervention approaches used in clinical child and pediatric psychology, including psychodynamic, behavioral, cognitive-behavioral, and pharmacological treatments. It also covers prevention strategies, consultation models, and the specific training requirements for psychologists working with children and adolescents, highlighting the unique challenges of treating minors who rarely refer themselves for treatment.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers multiple intervention approaches including psychoanalytically oriented therapy, play therapy, behavior therapy, behavioral pediatrics, cognitive-behavioral therapy, group and family therapy, and psychopharmacological treatment. It then discusses prevention approaches (primary and secondary prevention, anticipatory guidance), consultation models in pediatric settings (independent functions, indirect consultation, collaborative team model), and concludes with detailed training recommendations for clinical child and pediatric psychologists across 11 topic areas.
π Lecture Summary
INTERVENTIONS
In the case of children, the intervention approaches are equally diverse and generally similar to those used with adults. However, child therapy differs because "children do not typically refer themselves for treatment, nor do they possess the same capacity for introspection and self-report as do most adults." Kazdin (1988) has conservatively estimated that more than 230 therapeutic techniques are used in treating children or adolescents, though the majority of these treatments have not been subjected to empirical investigation regarding their efficacy and effectiveness.
PSYCHOANALYTICALLY ORIENTED THERAPY
Although psychoanalytically oriented treatments are frequently used with children and adolescents, modification of traditional techniques is often necessary. Children are unlikely to understand or adhere to the strict requirements of orthodox analysis as adults can. They usually cannot deal with the highly verbal, abstract, and introspective nature of the process. Children with particularly weak egos or those living in extremely threatening home situations with unsupportive parents are not good candidates for psychoanalytic procedures.
Modified psychoanalytic approaches have been widely applied to children. Anna Freud (1946b) believed children in therapy must achieve insight into their troubled feelings and defenses, but other less traditional analysts have proceeded differently. The frequency of meetings is usually reduced to once or twice per week. The approach is more symptom-oriented and designed to teach the child that certain behaviors are really defenses against anxiety. This may help the child negotiate a certain developmental stage rather than "cure" a fixation. Daydreams rather than nocturnal dreams might be solicited, and play rather than direct verbalization may be used as a communication vehicle.
PLAY THERAPY
Rather than use dreams or free associations, some therapists study the psychic life of the child through play β either free or structured variety. The child is brought to a playroom containing materials such as a sandbox, clay, puppets, dolls, and toys of all kinds. How children play, what objects they choose, and the nature of their verbalizations can all be revealing, cathartic, and therapeutic. Sometimes the therapist enters into the play and makes comments and suggestions, guiding the child toward certain conflict or problem areas. Play becomes a substitute for verbalization.
π Definition β Play therapy: A therapeutic approach where play is used as a communication vehicle to understand and treat children's psychological problems, revealing how they relate to significant figures and handle anxieties.
π Example: Solomon's (1955) approach β He brings the child into a room with a table on which dolls are placed. He selects one and asks the child what to do with it. Sometimes dolls are arranged to represent the child's family. As the child arranges and plays, the therapist interprets what the child is doing, facilitating expression of feelings. Concrete family experiences, wishes, and even unconscious urges may be expressed.
Play therapy has evolved into an eclectic, amorphous set of techniques and is no longer associated solely with a psychodynamic orientation. It has also been used with a cognitive-behavioral approach. Knell (1998) argues that cognitive-behavioral play therapy can effect cognitive and behavioral changes in children through techniques such as modeling adaptive coping skills, indirectly communicating cognitive change through play, and providing opportunities for the child to reenact problem situations and gain mastery over them.
BEHAVIOR THERAPY
Behavioral techniques have overtaken psychodynamic methods as the treatment of choice for childhood problems. Children's problems seem to be direct outgrowths of environmental factors or people in control of the child's life. Either respondent principles (behavior acquired through classical conditioning) or operant principles (behavior maintained by its consequences) are ideally suited to account for childhood behaviors. These principles can easily be applied by parents and teachers as part of the therapeutic plan.
Most behavioral procedures β whether systematic desensitization, aversion therapy, or contingency management techniques β are highly efficient compared to traditional psychodynamic methods. Changes that once took months or years can be achieved in 20 or fewer sessions. Parents and teachers can be trained to enhance effectiveness and help ensure changes generalize outside the therapist's office.
π Definition β Parent management training: A set of therapeutic procedures designed to "train" parents to modify a child or adolescent's behavior at home. Parents master basic learning principles (contingency management, reinforcement) and implement them at home.
π Example: Barkley (1987) developed a program for teaching child management skills to parents of children who are defiant and noncompliant. Enlisting parents in treatment makes behavior change more likely.
BEHAVIORAL PEDIATRICS
Clinical child psychologists and pediatric psychologists contribute greatly to the management of children during hospital stays. This includes preparing children for medical procedures and assisting the child and family in coping with medical problems. Techniques range from behavioral rehearsal and stress inoculation to various methods of cognitive reappraisal. Whether the problem is a simple fear of needles or stress and pain from repeated bandage changes for burn patients, behavioral methods can be helpful. Management of pain, headaches, and ensuring compliance with medical regimens are also important provinces of behavioral pediatrics.
COGNITIVE-BEHAVIORAL THERAPY
Cognitive-behavioral therapy has increasingly been applied to problems such as impulsivity, hyperactivity, anxiety, depression, and conduct disorders. The basic idea is to improve problem solving and enhance planning and delay of gratification. Through internal assessments and self-statements, children are taught to bring their previously distressing or problematic behavior under rational control. The vehicle is the alteration of cognitions, and the ultimate goal is the creation of a new, more adaptive "coping template".
GROUP AND FAMILY THERAPY
Many problems are learned and nourished in the family setting; relieving them often requires cooperation and understanding of the family unit. Because children are influenced by and are products of their families, treating the entire family can be effective. However, evidence suggests family therapy might be used selectively in cases where there is evidence supporting its effectiveness. Recent reviews suggest certain forms of family therapy effectively treat anxiety disorders and conduct disorders in children and adolescents.
A recent meta-analysis indicated that group treatments for children and adolescents were more effective than wait-list and placebo control groups. The overall effect size across treatments averaged .61, indicating that a child or adolescent who received treatment was better off than 73% of those in control groups. Hoag and Burlingame (1997) found that some forms of group treatment for specific clinical problems (for example, cognitive-behavioral group treatment for depression) are more effective.
PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGICAL TREATMENT
Medications may be used as adjuncts to psychotherapy in treating children. The medication most frequently used is those that treat attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). The most frequently prescribed medication for ADHD is the psychostimulant methylphenidate (Ritalin). Although studies have demonstrated positive effects of Ritalin in treating ADHD symptoms, not all children and adolescents have a positive response. The costs, in the form of side effects, may outweigh the benefits, and there have been few demonstrations of long-term benefit in improved prognosis. These points apply to other medications used to treat clinical problems in children and adolescents.
The research literature suggests that, in general, psychological treatments for childhood and adolescent problems are effective, and recent reviews have identified specific interventions with empirical support.
PREVENTION
Clinical child and pediatric psychologists are especially concerned about prevention of childhood problems. Prevention and treatment are activities that blend and merge.
π Definition β Primary prevention: Counteracting problems before they have a chance to develop.
π Definition β Secondary prevention: The prompt treatment of problems in order to minimize their impact.
The stance of the pediatric or clinical child psychologist is a proactive one. Roberts (1986) uses the term anticipatory guidance β the use of counseling and education in advance of difficulties.
π Example: Parents may be counseled about "childproofing" their home at various stages of development (covering electrical outlets, blocking stairways). At a psychological level, it may involve providing information on preparing the child for the birth of a sibling or death of a grandparent. For a child with cystic fibrosis, it might involve counseling on how to respond to teasing about physical limitations.
One tenet of community psychology is identification of people at risk. For example, programs have been designed for hospitalized children to provide information, encourage emotional expression, offer coping strategies, or build trusting relationships. Films and videotapes help children cope with medical interventions.
To aid prevention of physical problems, safety programs address issues from crossing the street safely to avoiding abduction or molestation. Programs for "latchkey children" have been developed. Research suggests pediatric counseling increases use of safety car seats. Recent attempts integrate child injury and child abuse/neglect research because similar interventions may prevent harm in both domains.
Prevention is not the sole province of pediatric psychologists; clinical child psychologists are increasingly involved. Examples outside medical settings include an early intervention program to reduce anxiety disorders in 7-14 year olds at risk, and the Children of Divorce Intervention Program aimed at improving adjustment to divorce.
CONSULTATION
Consultation-liaison relationships have long been typical in pediatric psychology. Drotar (1995) and Roberts (1986) describe the consultation process. Because of problems in pediatric settings, consultation has become integral to the psychologist's role. Consultation occurs with parents, pediatricians, medical school systems, welfare agencies, juvenile systems, and other agencies. Subjects range from psychiatric, psychosomatic, or developmental problems to illness-related difficulties.
Pediatric psychologists consult with pediatricians who call upon the psychologist as they would consult with cardiologists or oncologists. Pediatricians encounter a wide range of children and often face problems for which they lack training or interest. Consultation may occur in hospital or outpatient settings, involve immediate brief help or long-term interventions, and come as hallway chats, quick telephone calls, or written reports.
Independent Functions Model: The psychologist functions as a specialist, independently carrying out diagnostic and treatment activities on referred patients. This model is familiar to medical professionals, efficient, and cost-effective, but limited contact may lead to less comprehensive consultation and fewer training opportunities.
Indirect Consultation Model: The pediatrician retains chief responsibility for patient management. The psychologist has limited contact with the patient and contributes through analysis of information provided. This model is characteristic of medical center settings where teaching is a major function. It may involve brief contacts (phone calls, informal consultations), presentations (seminars, workshops), or situations where another professional carries out interventions recommended by the psychologist.
π Example: The psychologist may develop guidelines for handling temper tantrums, bedwetting, mealtime problems, or general behavioral management. These are given to the pediatrician who implements them or supervises parents doing the intervention.
Drotar (1995) notes indirect consultation is more effective if the focus is on clinical relevance with practical applications. Limitations include being time-consuming and medical personnel often wanting immediate solutions to complex problems.
Collaborative Team Model: This represents true collaboration where pediatrician, psychologist, nurse, and others work together sharing responsibility and decision making. This is "conjoint case management" where professionals act as functional equals. This model is especially appropriate for cases involving both medical and psychological features. Effective collaborative consultation evolves over time among those who work closely, respect each other's viewpoints, and offer complementary expertise. The biggest challenge is for team members to learn from each other, develop new skills, and maintain professional identities.
Training
Training issues in both clinical child and pediatric psychology have come to the forefront due to growing interest in health and medical issues and developing collaboration between medicine and psychology.
Roberts et al. (1998) presented a training model for psychologists providing services to children and adolescents. These recommendations apply to those seeking to become clinical child psychologists or pediatric psychologists, though specialized training might be required. The 11 topic areas are:
- Life span developmental psychology: Knowledge and expertise in developmental processes (social, cognitive, emotional, behavioral, physical) and how they influence assessment, diagnosis, treatment, and outcome.
- Life span developmental psychopathology: Exposure to information about mental, emotional, and developmental disorders and abnormal development.
- Child, adolescent, and family assessment methods: Learning to administer and interpret assessments (intellectual, personality, behavioral, family, socio-cultural context) with empirical support, appreciating how assessments are influenced by ethnic/cultural background or disability.
- Intervention strategies: Exposure to leading child, adolescent, parent, family, school, and community interventions and research on their effectiveness.
- Research methods and systems evaluations: Familiarity with research methods for critical evaluation of assessments, treatments, and services; ability to conduct research.
- Professional, ethical, and legal issues: Familiarity with issues pertaining to children, adolescents, and families including child abuse reporting, custody, confidentiality, duty to protect, and relevant laws.
- Issues of diversity: Appreciating the role of ethnicity and culture and how diverse beliefs affect assessment, intervention, and service delivery interactions.
- Multiple disciplines and service delivery systems: Exposure to other disciplines (pediatrics, family practice, social work) and how professionals address problems.
- Prevention, family support, and health promotion: Expertise in interventions that improve quality of life and prevent future problems.
- Social issues affecting children, adolescents, and families: Knowledge of natural disasters, abuse and neglect, violence, and other adversities.
- Specialized experience in assessment, intervention, and consultation: Broad range of applied experiences with diverse children, adolescents, and families in multiple settings (medical hospitals, public-sector mental health agencies).
Roberts et al. (1998) believe training should occur through didactic coursework, observation in applied or research settings, and supervised service delivery at pre-doctoral, internship, and postdoctoral phases.
Regarding specialized training in pediatric psychology, Drotar (1998) notes needs are complex. Pediatric psychologists must learn to consult and collaborate with physicians, recognize and manage clinical problems in pediatric settings, teach primary care providers about behavior and development, and engage in interdisciplinary research. These goals may be attained through didactic coursework, observation, and hands-on field experience.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that intervention approaches for children must be adapted to their developmental level, with play therapy substituting for verbalization and behavior therapy being particularly effective due to children's responsiveness to environmental contingencies. Over 230 therapeutic techniques exist for children, but many lack empirical validation, making evidence-based practice crucial. Prevention through anticipatory guidance and early intervention is a proactive stance central to both clinical child and pediatric psychology. Consultation in pediatric settings follows three models (independent functions, indirect, and collaborative team), with the collaborative model representing ideal interdisciplinary practice. Training requires comprehensive coverage of 11 areas including lifespan development, assessment, intervention, ethics, diversity, and specialized applied experiences across multiple settings.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why do children require modified psychoanalytic therapy compared to adults, and what two modifications are commonly made?
- How does cognitive-behavioral play therapy differ from traditional psychodynamic play therapy according to Knell (1998)?
- What is parent management training, and why does enlisting parents in treatment increase the likelihood of behavior change in children?
- Distinguish between the three consultation models (independent functions, indirect consultation, and collaborative team model) in pediatric settings β which represents true collaboration?
- List at least five of the 11 training topic areas recommended by Roberts et al. (1998) for psychologists working with children and adolescents.