๐ Lecture 40 โ Applications of Health Psychology
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the practical applications of health psychology in addressing major health-damaging behaviorsโcigarette smoking, alcohol abuse, and obesity. It examines why people engage in these behaviors despite known risks, evaluates treatment and prevention approaches, and discusses the future prospects, training issues, and challenges facing the field of health psychology.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three major behavioral health problems: cigarette smoking (its prevalence trends, reasons for initiation and maintenance, and cessation/prevention programs); alcohol abuse and dependence (treatment approaches including controlled drinking and relapse prevention, and school-based prevention programs); and obesity (behavioral treatments, genetic components, and early prevention projects). It also discusses other applications including coping with medical procedures and preparation for surgery, then examines healthcare trends, training issues in health psychology, and various challenges including role ambiguity, status issues, competing goals with physicians, and the need to address ethnicity and health.
๐ Lecture Summary
1. CIGARETTE SMOKING
Increased awareness of smoking dangers has led to a steady decline since the mid-1960s in Americans who smoke habitually, yet rates differ by gender, education, and income. A concerning trend is that smoking rates for women have shown much less decline than for men; among white-collar workers, women's rates now exceed men's.
Cigarette smoking is linked to increased risk of cardiovascular disease and cancer, the two leading causes of death in the U.S., along with coronary heart disease, respiratory tract cancers, emphysema, and bronchitis. People still smoke for reasons including tension control, social pressure, rebelliousness, the addictive nature of nicotine, and genetically influenced personality traits like extraversion. Tension control and social pressure are thought to initiate smoking, while rebelliousness, addiction, and personality primarily maintain it.
Various cessation techniques have been used: educational programs, aversion therapy (such as rapid smoking), behavioral contracts, acupuncture, cognitive therapy, and group support. Relapse rates are high (70-80%), and research findings on which cessation approach is best are conflicting. Most smokers who quit do so on their own.
The best approach appears to be prevention. Education alone (like warning messages on packages) does not deter young people from smoking. More effective approaches focus on immediate rather than delayed negative consequences, teaching coping skills, and increasing feelings of self-efficacy.
An early multiple-component prevention program based on social learning principles used peer role models (R. I. Evans, 1976). It employed videotaped presentations, peer modeling, discussion groups, role playing, smoking monitoring, and repeated checking of attitudes and knowledge with elementary school children. This approach proved superior to those focusing on long-term negative effects. The key is focusing on immediate negative consequences (e.g., from peers) rather than delayed ones (e.g., emphysema).
๐ก Why this matters: Smoking prevention requires addressing social dynamics and immediate consequences, not just long-term health warningsโthis changes how public health campaigns are designed.
2. ALCOHOL ABUSE AND DEPENDENCE
About 70% of men and 50% of women in the U.S. consume alcoholic beverages. While some studies suggest positive health benefits for light or moderate drinkers, heavy alcohol use is associated with increased risk of liver or neurological damage, certain cancers, cardiovascular problems, fetal alcohol syndrome, physical aggression, suicide, motor vehicle accidents, and violence. This extensive list makes treatment and prevention of alcohol abuse and alcohol dependence a high priority.
Most treatment approaches preach total abstinence, ranging from medical treatments and medications like disulfiram (Antabuse) and naltrexone to traditional psychotherapy and group supportive strategies like Alcoholics Anonymous. However, alcoholism has been extremely resistant to virtually all interventions, and relapse rates are high.
A controversial alternative is controlled drinking (Sobell & Sobell, 1978), with the goal of light to moderate (but controlled) drinking. Clients learn to develop alternative coping responses (other than drinking) and closely monitor alcohol intake. The field is divided on its merits, but research suggests it is a viable option for some alcoholics.
Many programs incorporate relapse prevention training (Marlatt & Gordon, 1985). Since most clients have a relapse episode soon after treatment ends, rather than seeing this as failure, clients are taught coping skills for "high-risk" situations to make total relapse less likely.
Alcohol abuse and dependence are complex problems requiring multimodal treatment strategies. Due to difficulties with secondary and tertiary approaches, professionals have turned to primary prevention. Programs similar to those preventing adolescent smoking are being developed, often through school-based health education or media campaigns. Components include: affective education (building self-esteem, decision-making skills); life skills (communication, assertiveness); resistance training (resisting peer pressure); and correction of erroneous perceptions about peer norms. Current research suggests programs combining peer resistance training and correction of misperceptions about peer norms show the most promise.
3. OBESITY
Obesity has received more behavioral treatments than any other condition. It is associated with medical disorders like diabetes, hypertension, cardiovascular disease, and certain cancers. It is also a socially stigmatizing condition that impairs self-concept and inhibits functioning in social settings. Weight problems often trace to childhood: 10-25% of children are obese, and 80% of these become obese adults.
Obesity has a genetic component (Meyer & Stunkard, 1993), but its causes represent complex interactions among biological, social, and behavioral factors. Traditional medical and dietary treatments have not been very effective; individuals lose weight but quickly regain it, and dropout rates are high. Most behavior modification programs include restricting certain foods, teaching when and under what conditions to eat, encouraging regular exercise, and maintaining modified eating patterns after the program ends.
Early prevention is the best approach. The Stanford Adolescent Obesity Project (Coates & Thoresen, 1981) used strategies of self-observation, cue elimination, and social and family support with adolescents to prevent adult obesity. These interventions were noticeably more effective when parents were involved. Peer group discussion is also being explored. A ten-year outcome study of family-based behavioral treatment for childhood obesity showed early intervention can produce lasting changes in weight control (Epstein, Valoski, Wing, & McCurley, 1994).
OTHER APPLICATIONS: COPING WITH MEDICAL PROCEDURES
Treatment and preventive initiatives must be supplemented with techniques encouraging patients to cope with medical procedures and follow medical advice. The prospect of surgery, dental visits, or medical examinations strikes fear in many patients, causing them to delay or forgo visits. Health psychologists specializing in behavioral medicine have developed interventions to help patients deal with stress surrounding such procedures.
Preparation for Surgery research has identified interventions including: (1) relaxation strategies, (2) basic information about procedures, (3) information about bodily sensations during procedures, and (4) cognitive coping skills.
HEALTH PSYCHOLOGY: PROSPECTS FOR THE FUTURE
Health psychology is growing, with more psychologists entering each year. The field must decide how best to train health psychologists and structure programs to achieve training goals.
Health Care Trends: By 1997, 85% of Americans belonged to managed care plans, where cost containment is a priority. Health psychologists, often working in medical centers or primary care settings, are well-suited to provide interventions that cut medical costs. As business and industry absorb costs from employee habits causing absenteeism, inefficiency, and turnover, they will likely use health psychologists' skills more often.
There appears to be a surplus of mental health professionals: approximately 32.8 social workers, 22.8 psychologists, 13.1 psychiatrists, and 4.3 psychiatric nurses per 100,000 Americans (73 total). The problem lies in overlapping definitions of each discipline. As economic stakes rise, each discipline's self-definitions will likely incorporate concepts once thought unique to health psychology and behavioral medicine. Frank and Ross (1995) call for more coordination of health workforce planning at the national level. Establishing psychology's role requires delineating unique contributions amid increasing supply of other health professions, with efforts based on dialogue, coordination, and cooperation.
Training Issues: A major source of health psychologists continues to be clinical psychology programs. The scientist-practitioner and clinical scientist models train clinicians well-suited for health psychology. Until recently, no other psychology specialty offered the combination of academic, scientific, professional, and hospital experiences required for medical settings. Stroebe and Stroebe (1995) make a case for social psychologists, emphasizing methodology, quantitative analysis, and research design. Other subspecialties like experimental and physiological psychologists are also well represented.
For the most part, health psychology remains an ad hoc appendage to doctoral programs. Students enter clinical, social, or experimental programs and add specialized research or a practicum in health-related topics, possibly augmented by an internship at a healthcare site. Many now call for health psychology to be a standard, core training component for all professional psychologists. Training in psychopharmacology, neuropsychology, and psychoneuroimmunology is considered essential. Future health psychologists must be trained to design and conduct studies to empirically evaluate health outcomes. Some programs offer "tracks" in health psychology, but this is the exception.
OTHER CHALLENGES
New fields have problems defining their members' roles. S. E. Taylor (1984) identified several:
First, role ambiguity: No one is fully prepared to say what a health psychologist should do, especially in practical work settings. Health psychologists may find themselves without psychology colleagues or role models in health settings, adding to confusion.
Second, status issues: In health settings, physicians are at the top. Psychologists sometimes enjoy much less status in medical centers than in academic settings.
Third, competing goals: Healthcare professionals may be interested only in immediately helping the patient, while psychologists may be more tentative and contemplative about research, theoretical models, and interventions.
Health psychologists need to document the cost-effectiveness of their interventions to establish their identity in physician-dominated settings. In this era of healthcare reform, insurance companies and government agencies are scrupulously examining ways to reduce costs.
Friedman et al. (1995) ask why successful and cost-efficient health psychology interventions haven't been integrated more fully into the healthcare system, suggesting several reasons:
- Many data supporting health psychology are unknown to physicians.
- Biological origins of diseases have been emphasized, causing many to overlook psychosocial explanations and behavioral interventions.
- Patients may be resistant to psychological interventions and explanations.
- Clinical health psychology and behavioral medicine are still confused with traditional, long-term psychotherapy.
Physicians, insurance companies, the federal government, and the public need education about the role of health psychologists and the financial and clinical benefits of their interventions.
Another challenge concerns ethnicity and health. Health profiles of various ethnic minority populations in the U.S. differ greatly. More research is needed on health-promoting and health-damaging behaviors among these groups (N. B. Anderson, 1995). Recent reports in a special issue of Health Psychology address health status of African Americans, Asian Americans, and Hispanic Americans, behavioral risk factors related to chronic diseases in ethnic minorities, and use of healthcare systems by ethnic minorities, pointing to the need to further assess relations between behavior and health in special populations.
There remains a gap between the field's promise and accomplishment. It is very hard to change human behavior over the long haul. Nonetheless, health psychology deserves both enthusiasm and caution. Many are optimistic about the future, given pressing demands for improved healthcare. Belar (1997) and others believe health psychology is uniquely suited to be the specialty for professional practice psychology in the twenty-first century.
๐ก Why this matters: The challenges facing health psychologyโrole ambiguity, status issues, competing goals with physicians, and the need for cost-effectiveness documentationโdirectly affect how behavioral health interventions are actually delivered in medical settings.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture demonstrates that while simple behaviors like reducing salt/fat consumption, exercising, avoiding cigarettes, and decreasing stress would dramatically reduce healthcare costs and human suffering, giving advice and having people follow it are very different. For smoking, alcohol abuse, and obesity, prevention focusing on immediate consequences, peer resistance training, and social support is more effective than education about long-term health risks. Treatment approaches show high relapse rates (70-80% for smoking), highlighting the need for multimodal strategies and relapse prevention training. The field of health psychology faces significant challenges including role ambiguity in medical settings, status differences between physicians and psychologists, the need to document cost-effectiveness of interventions, and the critical need for more research on ethnicity and health in diverse populations. Despite these challenges, health psychology is uniquely positioned to be a central specialty for professional psychology in the twenty-first century, especially as managed care systems prioritize cost-containing behavioral interventions.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three major behavioral health problems discussed in the lecture, and what common challenge do all their treatment approaches face?
- Why is focusing on immediate rather than delayed negative consequences more effective for preventing smoking in young people?
- What is controlled drinking, and why is it controversial in the treatment of alcohol problems?
- What four components are typically included in school-based prevention programs for alcohol abuse, and which two show the most promise?
- List the four types of interventions used to prepare patients for surgery, and explain why health psychologists must document the cost-effectiveness of their interventions.
๐ Lecture 41 โ Neuropsychological Perspectives And History
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the field of neuropsychology, which examines the relationship between brain function and behavior. It covers the historical development of theories about brain functioning, the roles of neuropsychologists in diagnosis and rehabilitation, the structure and functions of the brain, causes of brain damage, and principles of neuropsychological assessment and intervention. Understanding neuropsychology is critical for clinical psychologists as it bridges neurological and psychological domains in assessment and treatment.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture defines neuropsychology and describes the roles of neuropsychologists. It traces the history of neuropsychology from ancient theories through phrenology and localization to equipotentiality and the functional model. It reviews brain structure, including hemispheres and lobes, and their functions. It covers seven causes of brain damage: trauma, cerebrovascular accidents, tumors, degenerative diseases, nutritional deficiencies, toxic disorders, and chronic alcohol abuse. It discusses symptoms of brain damage and brain-behavior relationships, including localization, equipotentiality, and functional models. It concludes with intervention and rehabilitation guidelines.
๐ Lecture Summary
NEUROPSYCHOLOGY PERSPECTIVES AND HISTORY
Clinical neuropsychology has grown significantly, reflected in increased professional memberships, training programs, and publications. The field faces challenges from healthcare reform requiring lower costs and higher effectiveness.
Definition: Neuropsychology is the study of the relation between brain function and behavior. It deals with the understanding, assessment, and treatment of behaviors directly related to the functioning of the brain (Golden, 1984).
Neuropsychological assessment is a non-invasive method of describing brain functioning based on a patient's performance on standardized tests that are accurate and sensitive indicators of brain-behavior relationships. The neuropsychologist may address issues of cerebral lesion lateralization, localization, and cerebral lesion progress. Evaluations provide useful information about the impact of a patient's limitations on educational, social, or vocational adjustment.
ROLE OF NEUROPSYCHOLOGISTS
Neuropsychologists function in several roles:
- They help establish or rule out diagnoses, such as distinguishing between neurological and emotional bases for symptoms.
- They make predictions regarding prognosis for recovery based on understanding of functional brain systems.
- They provide guidance for intervention and rehabilitation, indicating which domains of functioning may support rehabilitative efforts.
- They evaluate patients with mental disorders to predict the course of illness based on cognitive impairment and to tailor treatment strategies to patient strengths and weaknesses.
HISTORY OF NEUROPSYCHOLOGY
Theories of brain functioning extend back to ancient times, including the Edwin Smith Surgical Papyrus (1700-3000 B.C.), Pythagoras, and Galen. The nineteenth century laid the most significant early base.
Franz Gall proposed phrenology, arguing that individual differences could be measured by noting bumps and indentations of the skull. This was the first popularization of localization of function.
Paul Broca's surgical work in 1861 from autopsies of patients who lost expressive speech convinced him he had found the location of motor speech.
Pierre Flourens and Karl Lashley argued for equipotentialityโthe cortex functions as a whole, and any brain injury will impair higher intellectual functions, with one area able to substitute for another.
Problems with both theories: Localizationalists could not explain why different lesions produced the same deficit; equipotentialists could not account for specific deficits from small lesions.
The functional model, proposed by neurologist Jackson and adapted by Soviet neuropsychologist Luria, integrates both perspectives. It holds that areas of the brain interact to produce behavior. Behavior results from several functional systems rather than discrete brain areas. Disruption at any stage immobilizes a given functional system. The nature of behavioral deficit depends on which functional system (arousal, perception, planning) has been affected and the localization of damage within that system. Through reorganization, recovery from brain damage is sometimes possible.
NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
Early neurology was influenced by mass action notions, making localization a secondary goal. Tests like the Benton Visual Retention Test and Graham-Kendall Memory-for-Designs Test assessed only presence or absence of brain damage.
Neuropsychology grew after World War II due to head injuries from the war and the development of clinical psychology.
Ward Halstead identified behavioral characteristics of brain-damaged people in natural settings and administered tests to assess them. Through factor analysis, he settled on ten measures for his test battery.
Ralph Reitan refined this into the Halstead-Reitan Neuropsychological Test Battery, relating test responses to discrete aspects of brain lesions.
By 1980, the Luria-Nebraska Neuropsychological Battery was developed as an alternative.
Contemporary neuropsychologists increasingly use flexible batteries tailored to individual patients, as standard batteries may be too time-consuming and not easily modifiable.
THE BRAIN: STRUCTURE, FUNCTION, AND IMPAIRMENT
Structure and Function:
The brain consists of two hemispheres. The left hemisphere controls the right side of the body and is involved in language, logical inference, and detail analysis. The right hemisphere controls the left side of the body and is involved in visual-spatial skills, creativity, musical activities, and perception of direction. Some left-handers may reverse this pattern. The corpus callosum connects the hemispheres.
Each hemisphere has four lobes:
- Frontal lobes: Most recently developed; enable observing and comparing behavior; associated with executive functions (formulating, planning, carrying out goal-directed initiatives) and emotional modulation (monitoring and controlling emotional state).
- Temporal lobes: Mediate linguistic expression, reception, analysis; auditory processing of tones, sounds, rhythms.
- Parietal lobes: Related to tactile and kinesthetic perception, spatial perception, body awareness, language understanding.
- Occipital lobes: Mainly oriented toward visual processing and visually mediated memory.
- Cerebellum: Associated with motor coordination, equilibrium control, and muscle tone.
ANTECEDENTS OR CAUSES OF BRAIN DAMAGE
1. Trauma: Over 2 million Americans experience head injuries yearly. Major effects:
- Concussions: Jarring of the brain; momentary disruptions; permanent damage uncommon unless repeated.
- Contusions: Brain shifted and pressed against skull; tissue bruised; outcomes can be severe with comas and deliriums.
- Lacerations: Actual ruptures and destruction of brain tissue from bullets or flying objects; exceedingly serious.
2. Cerebrovascular Accidents (Stroke): Blockage and rupture of cerebral blood vessels; leading cause of death.
- Occlusions: Blood clot blocks vessel feeding brain area; can result in aphasia (language impairment), apraxia (inability to perform voluntary movements), or agnosia (disturbed sensory perception).
- Cerebral hemorrhage: Blood vessel ruptures; blood escapes onto brain tissue; symptoms depend on site and severity.
- Prompt treatment with clot-busting medications can limit permanent damage.
3. Tumors: May grow outside the brain, inside the brain, or from metastatic cells. Initial signs include headaches, vision problems, and gradually developing judgment problems. Tumors can be removed surgically but may cause more brain damage; radiation is used for inoperable tumors.
4. Degenerative Diseases: Characterized by degeneration of neurons in the central nervous system.
- Alzheimer's disease: Most common; onset typically 65+ years old.
- Parkinson's disease: Onset 50-60 years old.
- Huntington's chorea: Onset 30-50 years old. All show progressive cerebral degeneration with motor, speech, language, memory, and judgment difficulties.
5. Nutritional Deficiencies: Observed in Korsakoff's psychosis (from poor eating in alcoholics), pellagra (niacin/B-3 deficiency), and beriberi (thiamin/B-1 deficiency).
6. Toxic Disorders: Metals, toxins, gases, and plants absorbed through skin produce toxic effects causing brain damage; common symptom is delirium (disruption of consciousness).
7. Chronic Alcohol Abuse: Results in tolerance and dependence with neurological correlates including changes in neurotransmitter sensitivity and brain tissue shrinkage. Vulnerable regions include:
- Limbic system: Memory formation, emotional regulation, sensory integration.
- Diencephalon: Including mammillary bodies of hypothalamus; shrinkage or lesions.
- Cerebral cortex: Atrophy.
- Cerebellum: Motor coordination damage.
CONSEQUENCES AND SYMPTOMS OF BRAIN DAMAGE
Common symptoms (vary by disorder and patient):
- Impaired orientation: Inability to identify oneself, time, or surroundings.
- Impaired memory: Forgetting recent events, confabulation (inventing memories), impaired learning and retention.
- Impaired intellectual functions: Comprehension, speech production, calculation, general knowledge affected.
- Impaired judgment: Difficulty with decisions.
- Shallow and labile affect: Inappropriate laughing or crying; rapid emotional shifts.
- Loss of emotional and mental resilience: Function under normal circumstances but deterioration under stress.
๐ก Why this matters: Many symptoms of brain damage overlap with traditional mental disorders, complicating differential diagnosis.
BRAIN-BEHAVIOR RELATIONSHIPS
Localization of function: Specific brain areas control specific behaviors; location of injury is primary concern. Same-sized lesions in different regions produce different deficits.
Equipotential theory: All brain areas contribute equally to overall intellectual functioning; location is secondary to amount of injury. Emphasis on deficits in abstract, symbolic abilities accompanying all brain damage.
Functional model (Jackson/Luria): Very basic skills can be localized, but observable behavior is a complex amalgamation of numerous basic skills involving the brain as an integrated whole. Complex behaviors involve complex functional systems overriding simple area locations.
Intellectual deterioration assessment involves comparing present functioning to prior level. Two types:
- Decline from psychological factors (psychosis, lack of motivation, emotional problems).
- Decline from brain injury.
Premorbid data (tests taken before injury) would provide a baseline but is seldom available. Clinicians infer previous functioning from case history (education, occupation).
INTERVENTION AND REHABILITATION
Two principal questions: (1) What is the nature of deterioration? (2) Is there real brain damage?
- Focal damage: Specific, limited behavioral effects.
- Diffuse damage: Wide-ranging effects.
- Progressive damage: Often in diffuse brain involvement or disease.
- Nonprogressive damage: Often in strokes or head traumas.
Rehabilitation involves:
- Thorough assessment of strengths and deficits.
- Development of a maximally beneficial and efficient program.
Rehabilitation can occur through spontaneous recovery, relearning via developmentally older functional systems, development of new functional systems, or environmental changes.
Guidelines for rehabilitation tasks (Golden et al., 1992):
- Include the impaired skill; other requirements should be in areas with little trouble.
- Vary difficulty from simple to normal performance.
- Quantifiable for objective progress.
- Provide immediate feedback.
- Control number of errors.
๐ก Why this matters: Rehabilitation design directly affects patient outcomes and quality of life after brain injury.
โญ Key Takeaways
Neuropsychology bridges brain function and behavior through non-invasive standardized assessment. Three main theoretical modelsโlocalization, equipotentiality, and the functional modelโguide understanding brain-behavior relationships. The brain's structure (hemispheres, lobes, cerebellum) maps to specific functions, with frontal lobes governing executive functions and emotional control. Brain damage has diverse causes including trauma, stroke, tumors, degenerative diseases, nutritional deficiencies, toxins, and chronic alcohol abuse, each producing distinct patterns of symptoms. Accurate assessment requires distinguishing neurological from psychological origins of impairment, and effective rehabilitation follows structured guidelines for treating cognitive and behavioral deficits while considering whether damage is focal or diffuse, progressive or nonprogressive.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the definition of neuropsychology according to Golden (1984)?
-
What are the four roles of neuropsychologists described in the lecture?
-
Compare and contrast localization of function, equipotentiality, and the functional model of brain functioning.
-
List the four lobes of the brain and describe the primary function associated with each.
-
What are the seven causes of brain damage discussed in the lecture, and what is one key symptom or characteristic of each?
๐ Lecture 42 โ Methods of Neurological Assessment
๐ Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive introduction to neurological assessment in clinical neuropsychology. It explains the goals, methods, and applications of evaluating brain-behavior relationships, covering both traditional lesion localization and modern psychometric approaches. Understanding these assessment techniques is essential for diagnosing cognitive impairments, planning rehabilitation, and distinguishing neurological from psychiatric conditions.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and objectives of neuropsychological assessment, the types of information such assessments provide, and four major approaches to neurological evaluation: level of performance, pattern analysis, pathognomonic signs, and right-left differences. It also details the clinical uses of assessment (diagnostic clarification, measuring change, and evaluating functional status), applications in vocational, academic, family, and competency contexts, specific methods including medical history and psychometric tests, and major neurodiagnostic procedures. Finally, it reviews testing areas for specific cognitive functions including intellectual functioning, abstract reasoning, memory, visual-perceptual processing, and language.
๐ Lecture Summary
WHAT IS A NEUROLOGICAL ASSESSMENT?
Neurological assessment has traditionally assessed the extent of impairment to a particular skill and attempted to locate an area of the brain damaged after brain injury or neurological illness. With modern brain imaging techniques, location can now be accurately determined, so the focus has moved onto the measurement of cognition and behavior. A core part is the administration of neurological tests for formal assessment of cognitive functioning, including orientation, new-learning/memory, intelligence, language, visuoperception, and executive-control/self-awareness.
Miller outlined three broad goals: firstly, diagnosis, to determine the nature of the underlying problem; secondly, to understand the nature of any brain injury or cognitive problem and its impact on the individual; and thirdly, assessments may measure change in functioning over time.
๐ Definition โ Neuropsychology: "the study of brain-behavior relationships." Clinical Neuropsychology combines the knowledge base developed through classical, localizationalist neurology with the modern methods of American psychometric psychology.
The objectives are to assess and diagnose disturbances of mentation and behavior and relate these findings to neurological implications and issues of clinical treatment and prognosis. At a time when interest in traditional psychological assessment techniques (Rorschach, Thematic Apperception Test, Bender Gestalt) has decreased, interest in clinical neuropsychological evaluation procedures has risen markedly.
Historically, the field evolved from a lesion localization model (e.g., trauma to a particular part of the brain leads to a particular kind of deficit). At present, behaviors are further defined through new technologies like neuroimaging. The neuropsychologist assesses different domains of functioning (attention, memory, problem solving) to generate a profile of strengths and weaknesses.
Cognitive functions typically assessed include: Sensory perceptual and motor functions, Attention, Memory, Auditory and visual processing, Language, Concept formation and problem solving, Planning and organization, Speed of Processing, Intelligence, Academic skills, and Behavior, emotions, and personality.
WHAT INFORMATION DOES NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT PROVIDE?
A comprehensive assessment can assist in distinguishing one disorder from another and clarifying its nature. The diagnostic referral question may involve discriminating between neurological and psychiatric disorders. Based on knowledge of brain-behavior relationships, evidence for dysfunction in one brain region may indicate other difficulties that might be present.
Knowing more about strengths and weaknesses assists in interpreting behaviors and guiding treatment planning. For example, a parent may observe: 'It feels like I have to teach Sara everything, every time.' Underlying this may be deficits in identifying rules for abstract concepts, discovering common principles, discriminating relevant versus irrelevant information, or memory.
A written report should follow completion of the assessment, including: Reasons for referral, Background information, Tests administered, Behavioral observations, Test results and interpretation, Summary of impressions, and Recommendations.
APPROACHES TO NEUROLOGICAL EVALUATION
Neuropsychologists make inferences regarding neurological functioning based on measures of behavior (neuropsychological test performance). An attempt is made to elicit the individual's best performance to measure their maximum capability.
Another important conceptual issue is the premorbid level of functioning. Inferences regarding present neurological condition are based on an assumed change in neurological status. An estimate of premorbid ability can be reconstructed from academic and employment history, family reports, and previous standardized test scores.
Lezak (1976) discusses two methods for estimating premorbid functioning. The first assumes that certain well-established abilities, such as vocabulary skills and fund of general information, are frequently preserved in brain injury. A clinician examines performance on tasks like the Vocabulary and Information subtests of the WAIS. However, caution is needed since localized left hemisphere injuries may compromise verbal skills.
The second method assumes that the individual's best current performance provides the closest approximation to original ability level. Again, caution is warranted, as some patients are so severely impaired that all test scores are depressed. Lezak warns that a single high test score on a memory task may not be a good estimate of premorbid functioning, since memory is the least reliable indicator of general intellectual ability.
1. Level Of Performance:
In this approach, the patient is administered tests sensitive to cerebral impairment. The patient's scores are compared to normative levels with established accuracy in differentiating brain-damaged from non-brain damaged persons. If a patient scores lower than the cutoff score, this performance is considered typical of organically impaired individuals. Problems include non-brain damaged patients scoring in the brain damaged range. In the past, many psychologists inappropriately used the Bender Gestalt as a single measure of organicity. Another problem is that a patient may do well on one test despite significant deficits in other areasโbrain damage effects can be pervasive or highly circumscribed.
2. Pattern Analysis:
Pattern analysis means the patient is given a battery of tests with known association to higher cortical functioning, and the neuropsychologist looks at the pattern of test performanceโwhich tests showed poor versus good performance. The classic example is examination of verbal-performance discrepancies on the WAIS. The problem is that a low score on a given test may occur for numerous reasons and does not necessarily mean a localized problem.
3. Pathognomonic Signs:
A pathognomonic sign is a problem that is an absolute indication of organic brain disorder. If present, the patient is, by definition, suffering from an organic neurological disorder. Examples include visual field deficits, spatial inattention or neglect, apraxia, and alexia. Other strongly indicative signs include profound difficulty perceiving numbers written on the tops of the patient's fingers, difficulty naming certain fingers touched while blindfolded, and consistent deficits in perception of stimuli under bilateral simultaneous stimulation. The major advantage is that if the sign is present, the patient definitely has organic impairment. The major disadvantage is that absolute pathognomonic signs are seen rather infrequently.
4. Right-Left Differences:
To use this approach, the clinician examines test scores on tasks requiring performance or participation of both sides of the body. Tests on the Halstead Battery involve the patient performing a task with the dominant hand and then the non-dominant hand. For example, on the Tactual Performance Test, a right-handed patient who takes significantly longer for block placement with the left hand might suggest a lesion in the parietal area of the right hemisphere. A problem is that measuring right-left differences typically means measuring motor and sensory-motor deficit, so the number of tests is limited.
๐ก Why this matters: These four approachesโlevel of performance, pattern analysis, pathognomonic signs, and right-left differencesโare the methods most frequently used in clinical practice. No single approach is satisfactory alone, but when used together, each supplements the other.
USES OF CLINICAL NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
1. Diagnostic Clarification: In complex cases, assessment can tease out the relative contributions of neurological conditions, emotional states (e.g., anxiety, depression), and psychiatric illnesses. It can help localize brain damage. 2. Measuring Change: Repeat assessment charts progress (e.g., recovery from cerebrovascular accident or closed head injury) and recognizes decline in mental status (e.g., following the course of various dementias). 3. Evaluating Cognitive And Functional Status: Testing delineates an individual's pattern of cognitive strengths and weaknesses relative to their own ability and compared to normative samples of age-matched peers.
APPLICATIONS OF NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
1. Vocational Interventions: A patient's ability to rejoin the work force can be evaluated, and specific routines tailored to existing strengths can be developed. 2. Academic Interventions: Results may plan a special educational program, useful with developmental disorders and patients recovering from illness or injury. 3. Family Interventions: Accurate knowledge of functional status assists the patient to adjust their role within a family system and enables family members to recognize the need for changes and accommodations. 4. Competency Issues: Neuropsychological status plays an important role in determining overall competency, involving one's ability to exercise rational judgment, make competent decisions, and live independently. Assessment of the patient's awareness of their limitations is also important.
METHODS OF NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT
- Medical History: All relevant medical records, especially neurological examination, imaging studies, and electrophysiological (EEG) results.
- Clinical Interview: Includes review of cognitive, sensorimotor, and neurovegetative complaints, plus medical, psychiatric, and substance abuse history. Family members may be interviewed.
- Behavioral Observations: Qualitative assessment of mentation, motor function, speech, motivation, emotion, manner of relating, and humor.
- Psychometric Tests: These may be "paper and pencil" tasks or measures requiring performance of a relevant skill (e.g., assembly of blocks, reaction time tasks). Major cognitive domains assessed include: Attention, Memory, Intelligence, Visual-Spatial-Perceptual functions, Psychosensory and Motor abilities, "Executive" or "Frontal Lobe" functions, and Personality or Emotional Functioning.
INTERPRETATION OF RESULTS
An effort is made to integrate test data, history, clinical interview, behavioral observations, and available laboratory and radiological evidence into one cohesive summary report arriving at a neurobehavioral diagnosis. There are several ways to interpret test data. First, a patient's level of performance may be interpreted in the context of normative data. Second, some calculate difference scores between two tests. Third, pathognomonic analysis of scores has been reliably associated with specific neurological injuries. Finally, statistical formulas that weight test scores differently may be available. Many neuropsychologists combine qualitative evaluations of patient's responses with quantitative approaches.
NEURODIAGNOSTIC PROCEDURES
These include the traditional neurological examination, spinal taps, X rays, electroencephalograms (EEGs), computerized axial tomography (CAT) scans, positron emission tomography (PET) scans, and nuclear magnetic resonance imaging (NMR or MRI). Not all procedures work equally well, and some pose risks (spinal taps can be painful, X rays have dangers). Single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) imaging is based on cerebral blood flow and provides a "picture" of how the brain is working. Functional MR imaging (fMRI) assesses blood flow changes in the brain. Many procedures are expensive and some are invasive, so neuropsychological tests may be used as screening measures to indicate whether more expensive tests are needed.
TESTING AREAS OF COGNITIVE FUNCTIONING
A. Intellectual Functioning:
Many neuropsychologists use the WAIS-3 and subtests from a modified version called the WAIS-R-NI (Kaplan, 1991). Modifications include changes in administration and additional subtest items, providing more information regarding cognitive strategies. The Information, Comprehension, and Vocabulary subtests are believed to be least affected by brain trauma and thus provide estimates of premorbid intelligence.
B. Abstract Reasoning:
Patients with schizophrenia or cognitive impairment often find it difficult to think abstractly. Commonly used tests include the Similarities subtest of the WAIS-3 (requires describing how 2 objects are alike) and the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (WCST) (Heaton, 1981). The WCST consists of decks of cards differing by shapes, colors, and number of shapes. The patient places each card under a stimulus card according to a principle deduced from the examiner's feedback, which changes during the test.
C. Memory:
Brain injury is often marked by memory loss. Wechsler developed the Wechsler Memory Scale (WMS), with the WMS-3 being the most recent revision. WMS-3 subtest scores combine into 8 primary indexes: Auditory Immediate, Visual Immediate, Immediate Memory, Auditory Delayed, Visual Delayed, Auditory Recognition Delayed, General Memory, and Working Memory. Four supplementary Auditory Process Composites assess memory processes when stimuli are presented auditorily.
D. Visual-Perceptual Processing:
Visual-spatial skills are necessary for activities like reading a map and parallel parking. In addition to the Rey-Osterrieth Complex Figure Test, neuropsychologists examine performance on the Block Design subtest of the WAIS-3. The Judgment of Line Orientation Test requires examinees to indicate the pair of lines on a response card that match the stimulus lines.
E. Language Functioning:
Brain injury can affect language production or comprehension. Tests requiring patients to repeat words, phrases, and sentences assess articulation difficulties and paraphasias (word substitutions); naming tests diagnose anomias (impaired naming). Language comprehension can be assessed using the Receptive Speech Scale of the Luria-Nebraska, requiring patients to respond to verbal commands. Speech and language pathologists comprehensively assess language dysfunction, and the neuropsychologist may refer patients if screening indicates problems.
CONCLUSION
The neuropsychological assessment is a method of examining the brain by studying its behavioral product. It includes comprehensive study of behavior using standardized tests sensitive to brain-behavior relationships, offering an understanding of the relationship between the structure and function of the nervous system. The goal is to evaluate the full range of basic abilities represented in the brain. In practice, the neuropsychological assessment is multidimensional (evaluating different aspects of neurofunctioning from basic to complex), reliable, and valid.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture defines neuropsychology as the study of brain-behavior relationships and establishes that modern neurological assessment has shifted from lesion localization to measuring cognition and behavior using psychometric tests. The four main interpretive approachesโlevel of performance, pattern analysis, pathognomonic signs, and right-left differencesโmust be used in concert, as no single method is sufficient. Estimating premorbid functioning is critical for determining change, typically using preserved abilities like vocabulary or a patient's best current performance. The lecture emphasizes that neuropsychological assessment is multidimensional, assessing domains from sensory-motor functions to executive control, and has broad applications in diagnosis, measuring change, and planning vocational, academic, and family interventions. Finally, while neurodiagnostic procedures like MRI and PET scans can locate brain damage, neuropsychological tests serve as valuable screening measures before expensive or invasive medical procedures.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three broad goals of neurological assessment as outlined by Miller?
- Describe the four main approaches to neuropsychological evaluation and identify one advantage and one disadvantage of each.
- How can a clinician estimate an individual's premorbid level of functioning when baseline test data are unavailable?
- What are the specific cognitive functions assessed in a typical neuropsychological evaluation, and which tests are used to measure intellectual functioning, abstract reasoning, and memory?
- Explain the difference between level of performance approach and pattern analysis in interpreting neuropsychological test results.