π Lecture 07 β LAW OF TREATIES
π Overview: This lecture explains the law of treaties, a major source of international law governing agreements between states. It covers the definition, formation, types, procedural aspects like signing and ratification, and key concepts like reservations and declarations. Understanding treaties is essential because they create binding legal obligations and rights between states under international law.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining treaties and their importance as a source of international law, including the Vienna Convention's definition. It then explains the structure of treaties, different names used for treaties, and the critical distinction between signing and ratifying a treaty. Finally, it covers the concepts of accession, reservation, and declaration, providing examples to illustrate these procedural mechanisms.
π Lecture Summary
Law of Treaties
Treaties are an important and major source of international law, allowing states to deliberately enter into agreements. A treaty can be concluded between two states (bilateral) or more than two states (multilateral). The body of international law governing these procedural and substantive aspects is referred to as the "law of treaties". Treaties provide a comprehensive, certain, and stable legal body, and parties are legally bound, creating rights and obligations under international law.
π Definition β Treaty (per Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969): "an international agreement concluded between states in written form and governed by international law, whether embodied in a single instrument or in two or more related instruments and whatever its particular designation."
Formation and Structure
There are no obligatory formal requirements for a treaty to come into existence, but it must be concluded in written form for obligations to arise. A treaty consists of a preamble, which lays down the objective and rationale, along with substantive and procedural provisions. It also includes a dispute resolving mechanism, an amendment procedure, and a ratification method.
π Formula: Treaty Structure = Preamble + Substantive Provisions + Procedural Provisions (including amendment, ratification, and dispute resolution) β The preamble states the treaty's purpose; substantive provisions create the core rights/duties; procedural provisions govern how the treaty is operated, changed, and enforced.
π Example: Non-Proliferation Treaty β Articles 1 and 2 constitute the substantive part (e.g., obligations not to develop nuclear weapons), while Article 8 relates to the amendment procedure (known as a review conference).
Names and Types of Treaties
A treaty may also be referred to as a Convention, Protocol, Agreement, or Declaration. There are no legal reasons for using different names; rather, political reasons dictate the choice. When a treaty is amended, the new areas covered are known as a Protocol. The United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) determines the rules of negotiations between states regarding treaties.
π Example: Simla Agreement, Geneva Accord, Lahore Declaration, and Additional Protocol of Geneva Convention.
Signing vs. Ratification
The effect of a signature depends on whether a treaty is subject to ratification and approval. Signing shows a state's intention to consider the treaty at a later stage. States that have signed a treaty have an obligation to refrain from any state practice inconsistent with the treaty. Ratification means approval by the head of state or government of the signature. It is after ratification that the treaty actually comes into existence.
π‘ Why this matters: A state that signs a treaty before it is enforced has simply signed it; a state that ratifies a treaty before it is enforced has merely ratified it. A treaty cannot come into force until a specified number of states have ratified it.
π Example: If a treaty has been enforced and then a state ratifies it, this amounts to accession. Accession indicates that a state is to become a party to the whole treaty, distinguishing it from ratification which occurs before enforcement.
Reservation and Declaration
A reservation is defined as reserving the operation of a specific provision of a treatyβin other words, limiting a treaty in its application. A declaration refers to limiting the interpretation of a specific provision of a treaty. A state is not allowed to reserve or limit the interpretation of any provision that forms the core, spirit, or fundamental/substantive part of the treaty. The United Nations publishes the names of treaties and the states signing or ratifying them.
π Definition β Reservation: an act to exclude or modify the legal effect of a specific provision of a treaty in its application to the reserving state.
π Example: India ratified the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) but reserved a particular right regarding Article 1. This reservation resulted in objections by three other states, including France and Germany.
β Key Takeaways
Treaties are a major source of international law, defined by the Vienna Convention as written agreements between states governed by international law. The key procedural distinction is between signing (showing intention) and ratification (creating binding legal obligation), with accession occurring when a state joins after the treaty is in force. Reservation allows a state to limit the application of a specific provision, while declaration limits its interpretation, but neither can alter the treaty's fundamental/core provisions. A treaty's structure includes a preamble, substantive provisions, procedural provisions (including amendment and dispute resolution), and ratification requirements. The name of a treaty (Convention, Protocol, Agreement, Declaration) is politically determined, not legally significant.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969, what is the definition of a treaty?
- What is the difference between signing a treaty and ratifying it?
- What is accession, and how does it differ from ratification?
- Distinguish between a reservation and a declaration in the context of treaties.
- Can a state make a reservation to a core or fundamental provision of a treaty? Why or why not?
π Lecture 8 β JURISDICTION
π Overview: This lecture defines jurisdiction in international law as the power of a state to make, declare, or apply law. It explains why jurisdiction is a core aspect of state sovereignty and how states exercise authority through legislative, executive, and judicial means. The lecture distinguishes between civil and criminal jurisdiction, covering key principles like nationality, territory, universality, and passive personality.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with Peter Stephen Du Ponceau's definition of jurisdiction and its importance in international law. It then explains jurisdiction as part of state sovereignty and identifies three types of state jurisdiction: prescriptive (legislative), executive, and judicial. The lecture further distinguishes domestic civil versus criminal jurisdiction, and details the four bases for exercising criminal jurisdiction: nationality, territory, universal jurisdiction, and the passive personality principle.
π Lecture Summary
Jurisdiction β Definition and General Concept
Jurisdiction, in its most general sense according to Peter Stephen Du Ponceau, means "the power to make, declare, or apply the law." When confined to the judiciary, it is the judicial powerβthe right of administering justice through the laws by the means provided for that purpose. Jurisdiction is limited to place or territory, to persons, or to particular subjects.
Jurisdiction is an important and extensive concept in international law. It provides clear norms as to the sphere of influence or authority of a state and includes the subjects that constitute part of that authority. It can also include circumstances where a state may assume jurisdiction over matters not ordinarily part of its influenceβfor example, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) can only exercise jurisdiction over a dispute when the states party to it have agreed to take the matter to the ICJ.
π Definition β Jurisdiction (general): The legal power of a state and the specific functions given to an entity. For example, the High Court is given power and authority to decide matters falling within its jurisdiction under the 1973 Constitution of Pakistan, and Banking Courts deal with banking issues.
π‘ Why this matters: Jurisdiction is an essential part of state sovereignty because it gives a state the competence to create, change, or terminate legal relationships, rights, and duties. It involves both the right to exercise it within the limit of a State's sovereignty (internal aspect) and the duty to recognize the same of other States (external aspect).
Types of State Jurisdiction (Legislative, Executive, Judicial)
State jurisdiction concerns essentially the extent of each State's right to regulate conduct or consequences of events. A state has the competence to regulate and exercise jurisdiction by legislative, executive, and judicial means.
-
Jurisdiction to Prescribe (Legislative Jurisdiction): This is the right of a State to make its laws applicable to the activities, relations, and status of persons or the interest of persons in things. For instance, the State of Pakistan cannot make laws with reference to individuals or property outside Pakistan through legislation, though the government may show concern about events outside its territory through foreign policy. This defines the reach of law regarding individuals and property.
-
Executive Jurisdiction: This refers to the capacity of the State to act within its borders. It works as an enforcement mechanismβmeaning the laws prescribed by the legislature are enforced by executive organizations. For example, Pakistan's customs authorities exercise their power to ensure carriage of goods via aircrafts and vessels follows correct legislative procedures. The United States enacted a law relating to scrutiny of containers entering US territory from outside to ensure safety; the empowerment lies within the executive.
-
Judicial Jurisdiction: This refers to the power of domestic courts to try cases in which a foreign factor is present. The judiciary handles issues pertaining both within and outside Pakistan. For example, Pakistan can make an order to freeze assets of an individual even if they reside outside Pakistan.
Civil and Criminal Jurisdiction β Distinction
Domestically, there are two types of jurisdictions:
- Civil Jurisdiction: Relates to civil matters between individuals and resolving their disputes, e.g., Dowry and Bride Restriction Act 1998 and Qanoon e Shahadat.
- Criminal Jurisdiction: Concerns criminal matters, e.g., Anti-Terrorism Act 1997, National Accountability Bureau Ordinance 1999, and Pakistan Penal Code.
Bases of Criminal Jurisdiction
Criminal jurisdiction is exercised on the basis of the following:
-
Nationality: Nationality is the legal concept that provides a link between a State and persons living within that State. It determines the rights and obligations which the State and the individuals owe to each other. A problem arises in countries providing for dual nationality, such as Canada, creating perplexity as to what laws apply to a citizen with dual nationality.
-
Territory: The territorial principle provides that the courts of the State where a crime is committed may exercise jurisdiction over the alleged criminal even if the accused is not a national of that state. It permits a state to exercise jurisdiction over all activities carried out within its territories and, in some cases, even outside. A main complexity arises regarding areas where jurisdiction is curtailedβfor example, in Pakistan, different laws apply to Federally Administrated Tribal Areas (FATA) and Provincially Administrated Tribal Areas (PATA).
π Definition β Territorial Principle: The principle that a state's courts may exercise jurisdiction over a crime committed within its territory, even if the accused is not a national of that state.
- Universal Jurisdiction: This is concerned with the application of a State's criminal jurisdiction in respect of offences committed against the international community. Any state that captures the offender may prosecute and punish that person on behalf of the world community, regardless of the nationality of the offender. The logic is that the nature of the rights violated are of concern to all Statesβexamples include hijacking, genocide, violation of the Geneva Conventions, and piracy. Where there is an extradition treaty, extradition to the State particularly affected may be resorted to, or a State with custody of the alleged offender may be permitted to exercise jurisdiction.
π Definition β Universal Jurisdiction: The principle that a state may prosecute an offender for serious international crimes (e.g., genocide, piracy, hijacking) regardless of where the crime was committed or the nationality of the offender, because the crimes offend the international community as a whole.
- Passive Personality Principle: This principle states that jurisdiction may be exercised in respect of events occurring outside a State's own territory when these events harm or target the nationals of that state.
π Definition β Passive Personality Principle: The principle that a state may exercise jurisdiction over crimes committed outside its territory that harm or target its own nationals.
Despite these identified rules and principles, complexities remain regarding jurisdiction. The civil and criminal jurisdictions pose problems, and even though the ingredients of criminal jurisdiction are defined, they still create ambiguities in certain matters. A lot more needs to be done at both domestic and international levels to ensure a more comprehensive regime that not only holds the offender responsible but also encompasses mechanisms to deter recurrence.
β Key Takeaways
Jurisdiction is a core attribute of state sovereignty, defined as the power to make, declare, or apply law, and it operates through legislative, executive, and judicial means. A student must remember that there are three main types of state jurisdiction: prescriptive (law-making), executive (enforcement), and judicial (court trials). For criminal jurisdiction, the four recognized bases are nationality, territory, universal jurisdiction, and passive personalityβeach with its own scope and complexities. Universal jurisdiction applies to crimes against the international community like piracy and genocide, allowing any state to prosecute regardless of location or nationality. Finally, passive personality permits a state to assert jurisdiction when its nationals are harmed abroad, and issues like dual nationality and special territorial zones (e.g., FATA/PATA) can create jurisdictional ambiguities.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three ways a state can exercise jurisdiction, and how do they differ?
- On what four bases can a state exercise criminal jurisdiction internationally?
- What is universal jurisdiction, and to which types of crimes does it typically apply?
- How does the passive personality principle differ from the territorial principle?
- Why does dual nationality create complexity in the exercise of criminal jurisdiction based on nationality?
π Lecture 9 β Immunity from Jurisdiction
π Overview: This lecture examines the concept of immunity from jurisdiction under international law, explaining that immunity is from enforcement rather than from the law itself. It covers various types of immunities including diplomatic immunity, immunities of international organizations, sovereign state immunity, and the act of state doctrine, providing historical context and key legal principles.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers diplomatic immunity under the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, including inviolability of mission premises and personal immunity for diplomats. It addresses immunities of international organizations through headquarters agreements and host state obligations. The lecture also explores sovereign state immunity, distinguishing between absolute and restrictive immunity, and examines the complex distinction between acts jure imperii and acts jure gestionis.
π Lecture Summary
IMMUNITY FROM JURISDICTION
States have authority over people, things, and events within their territory and may exercise jurisdiction over them. However, certain subjects of domestic laws may be granted immunity from jurisdiction. It is important to note that immunity is from the enforcement of the law rather than from the law itself. The main types of immunities include: diplomatic immunity, immunities of international organizations, sovereign of state immunity, and the acts of state doctrine.
Diplomatic Immunity
Diplomatic immunity relates to the protection of representatives of another state to ensure they perform their international political functions without fear of persecution or prosecution. Diplomats are immune from the enforcement of the domestic laws of the host country, not from the laws themselves. For example, in Pakistan, an ambassador representing another state is exempted from paying taxes. Similarly, the police of the host country cannot raid an embassy β premises are immune from jurisdiction.
When Pakistan entered the Iraq embassy in Karachi and confiscated weapons, this act was examined under international law and found to be ultra vires (exceeding its powers). If a diplomat conducts an illegal act, they can be declared persona non grata, meaning the host state cannot adjudicate but instead the sending state must recall the diplomat and investigate the matter itself.
The Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations provides the legal framework for diplomatic immunity. Key provisions include:
π Definition β Diplomatic immunity: Protection of state representatives from enforcement of host country's domestic laws to ensure free performance of their international political functions.
π Vienna Convention Provisions:
- Article 2: There is no right to diplomatic relations under international law; these exist by mutual consent. However, once established, certain rights must be guaranteed to a permanent diplomatic mission.
- Article 22: The premises of the mission are inviolable β agents of the receiving State cannot enter without mission consent. The receiving State must protect diplomatic missions, their staff, archives, means of communication, and free movement of staff.
- Article 29: A member of a diplomatic mission enjoys immunity from arrest or prosecution.
- Article 30: The diplomat's private residence, papers, correspondence, and property are all inviolable.
π Example: A Pakistani ambassador residing outside Pakistan is free from the imposition of local laws of the host country.
Immunities of International Organizations
The immunities of international organizations are almost always specified in a treaty between the organization and the host state β the headquarters agreement. The headquarters and offices of international organizations in another country are immune from the municipal laws of the host State.
Treaties entered into by two or more states have legally binding effect on states that have ratified them. It is the responsibility of the host state to ensure protection of these organizations to maintain and abide by the treaty rules.
π Example: United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) offices based in Pakistan are entitled to receive full security by the Pakistani government. Not only the organizations but also their staff and employees benefit from such agreements.
Sovereign State Immunity and Act of State Doctrine
This is the most complicated type of immunity and relates to immunity given to another state. State immunity is categorized into two types: absolute immunity and restrictive immunity.
The traditional doctrine of state immunity was absolute β immunity attached to all actions of foreign states, meaning foreign states had absolute immunity from the territorial jurisdiction of other states. However, with increasing state engagement in commercial trading, the absolute immunity principle gradually eroded and the restrictive immunity approach emerged, though many developing countries remain opposed to restrictive immunity.
The difficult issue with restrictive immunity is distinguishing between:
- Acts jure imperii: Acts in public authority in respect of which there would still be immunity
- Acts jure gestionis: Commercial or private acts in respect of which there is no longer any immunity
Since much overlapping exists between these categories, states must take reasonable steps to ensure and be liable for their actions and should not enjoy traditional immunity.
π UN Convention on Jurisdictional Immunities of States and their Property: States that immunity must be given to diplomats, and Article 5 relates to absolute immunity.
π Example: Macedonia killed illegal immigrants from Pakistan, violating the principle of state immunity. The question was whether this was an act of State immune from jurisdiction and whether the individual behind the act could be ascertained.
π‘ Why this matters: State immunity concepts are often misunderstood and confused with act of state doctrine and non-justifiability. The trend limits the scope of absolute immunity and reverts toward restrictive immunity.
β Key Takeaways
Immunity from jurisdiction means immunity from enforcement of law, not from the law itself, and it applies to diplomats, international organizations, and states in different ways. Diplomatic immunity under the Vienna Convention protects diplomats from arrest, prosecution, and intrusion into premises, but misbehaving diplomats can be declared persona non grata. International organizations gain immunity through headquarters agreements that obligate host states to protect their premises and staff. State immunity has evolved from absolute to restrictive immunity, creating the critical distinction between public acts (jure imperii) and private/commercial acts (jure gestionis). The most important trend in modern international law is the erosion of absolute immunity as states engage increasingly in commercial activities.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between being immune from a law versus immune from enforcement of a law in the context of diplomatic immunity?
- Under the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, what happens when a diplomat commits an illegal act in the host state?
- How do international organizations obtain immunity, and what document typically specifies this?
- What is the key difference between absolute immunity and restrictive immunity for states?
- How are acts jure imperii different from acts jure gestionis, and why is this distinction important?
π Lecture 10 β Territory
π Overview: This lecture examines territory as a cardinal element of statehood in international law. It explains the comprehensive scope of territorial sovereignty, covering land, sea, airspace, and subsoil, and analyzes the five main modes of acquiring territory. Understanding territory is fundamental because concepts like sovereignty and jurisdiction depend on its existence, and territorial security underpins all other aspects of national security.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining a state and establishing territory as its essential element, distinguishing states from nomadic tribes. It then explains the comprehensive scope of territorial sovereignty, including land, territorial sea, seabed, subsoil, and airspace. The main body covers the five modes of acquiring territory: occupation, accession, adjudication, accretion, and prescription, with detailed examples for each. It concludes by linking territorial security to overall state security and sovereignty.
π Lecture Summary
Territory as a Cardinal Element of State
A state is defined as a population living in a definite territory with a supreme government. This definition reveals four essential elements: population, territory, government, and sovereignty. If any element is missing, there can be no state. Territory remains a cardinal element because even a nomadic tribe has population, a leader (government), and sovereignty (supreme authority over members), but fails to qualify as a state due to the absence of a definite territory.
π Definition β State: a population, living in a definite territory, that has a government which is supreme.
Scope of Territorial Sovereignty
Territorial sovereignty includes the land territory, the territorial sea, the seabed and the subsoil of the territorial sea. It also includes the airspace above and the subsoil beneath it. The state has the right to assert its legislation over all these areas. Where the airspace ends begins outer space, which is governed by a different set of laws. Territory is a comprehensive term β reservoirs and mines are also part of territory.
π Definition β Territorial sovereignty: the comprehensive authority of a state over its land, territorial sea, seabed, subsoil, and airspace.
Modes of Acquiring Territory
Before 1948, many territories were unknown and undefined, making acquisition easier. After the adoption of the United Nations Charter, modes of acquisition became limited. The five main modes are: occupation, accession, adjudication, accretion, and prescription.
Occupation is acquiring territory that belongs to no other entity. The occupation must be effective and must be intended as a claim of sovereignty. Initially, force was used to occupy land, but Article 2(4) of the UN Charter now prohibits using force to occupy territory. For example, Israel occupied territory in the West Bank and Gaza, but this was not given legal acceptability.
π Definition β Occupation: a means by which a State can acquire territory which belongs to no other entity, requiring effective control and intent to claim sovereignty.
Accession involves peaceful transfer of territory from one sovereign to another. The acquiring state cannot gain more rights over the land than possessed by its predecessor. Examples include: Lord Mountbatten's promise of a land sector to Pakistan regarding Kashmir (still disputed); Hong Kong leased by China to Britain and reverted upon expiry; and Pakistan giving Ladakh to China under a 1965 treaty.
π Definition β Accession: the peaceful transfer of territory from one sovereign to another, where the acquiring state gains no greater rights than the predecessor held.
Adjudication is a process where States consult an international forum and the dispute is resolved by an arbitrator chosen with the consent of the States party to it. The arbitrator's decision, known as an "award," is binding on the States. Adjudication is a sub-species of accession because both require a treaty, though adjudication specifically involves third-party resolution.
π Definition β Adjudication: a process in which States consult an international forum and the dispute is resolved by an arbitrator chosen with consent of the States party to it, with the award being binding.
Accretion describes the geographical process whereby new land forms and becomes attached to existing land β for example, the creation of an island in a river mouth. No formal act of appropriation is necessary.
π Definition β Accretion: the geographical process of new land formation becoming attached to existing land, requiring no formal appropriation.
Prescription (res nullius β an asset susceptible of acquisition but under no legal person's ownership or sovereignty) is a mode of establishing title to territory. It legitimizes a doubtful title by the passage of time and the acquiescence of the former sovereign. For acquisitive prescription to be effective, there must be: display of State authority, absence of recognition of competing State, and the possession must be adverse, peaceful, uninterrupted, and done publicly. If a territory is occupied without interference from other States, it automatically becomes part of that State.
π Definition β Prescription: a mode of establishing title to territory that legitimizes a doubtful title by passage of time and acquiescence of the former sovereign. π Example β The Pakistan-India dispute over Siachen Glacier relates to prescription. If Pakistan had not contested India's effective control over Siachen, following prescription, it would have become part of India. One State can assert legal rights over territory not belonging to another State and legally occupy it under prescription. π Example β In the Clipperton Island Case (1887), an arbitration award resolved a dispute between France and Mexico over an uninhabited Pacific island. A French plane flew over the unoccupied island and asserted rights. Years later, another state contested, but the court found for France following the principle of prescription.
Territorial Security and State Sovereignty
Territory, its scope, and the means of acquiring it form an important part of international law. This concept has given rise to many controversies, including the Kashmir and Palestine disputes. Territory is synonymous with a state's security β the geographical or territorial security of any country is fundamental to its existence as a free and viable sovereign state. All other aspects of national security β people, ideological security, economic security β can only be enjoyed if a state is territorially secure.
π‘ Why this matters: Specific modes of acquiring territory exist precisely to ensure and protect the territorial sovereignty of states and all the basic securities associated with it.
β Key Takeaways
Territory is the essential element that distinguishes a state from a nomadic tribe, making it the most fundamental concept in international law. Territorial sovereignty is comprehensive, extending beyond land to include the territorial sea, seabed, subsoil, and airspace above. The five modes of acquiring territory β occupation, accession, adjudication, accretion, and prescription β have been significantly limited since the UN Charter, particularly by prohibiting the use of force. Prescription remains a critical but controversial mode, as demonstrated by the Siachen Glacier dispute and the Clipperton Island Case. Ultimately, territorial security is the foundation upon which all other aspects of national security depend.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why does a nomadic tribe not qualify as a state, even though it has population, government, and sovereignty?
- What are the five components included within a state's territorial sovereignty?
- What did the UN Charter Article 2(4) prohibit regarding occupation of territory?
- What four conditions must be met for acquisitive prescription to be effective?
- How did the Clipperton Island Case illustrate the principle of prescription in international law?
π Lecture 11 β Recognition
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of recognition in international law, which involves a State's acceptance or acknowledgment of facts or situations in its relations with other States. It covers the recognition of States, governments, and disputes, explaining the theories, types, and practical complexities involved, which are crucial for understanding statehood and international relations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and categorization of recognition into States, governments, and disputes. It explains the constitutive and declaratory theories of state recognition with examples. The lecture also distinguishes between de jure and de facto recognition of governments and discusses the recognition of disputes, particularly those related to self-determination, using examples like the Kashmir dispute and relevant UN resolutions.
π Lecture Summary
Recognition
Recognition under international law means and involves the acceptance or acknowledgment of the existence by a State of any fact or situation occurring in its relations with other States. It is categorized into recognition of States, Governments, and Disputes.
To States
Recognition of States pertains to whether a new entity has fulfilled the criterion for statehood (territory, population, government, and sovereignty). Once these requirements are satisfied, legal sanction is conferred, and formal recognition is extended.
π Definition β Constitutive theory: A political act of recognition is required as a precondition for the existence of legal rights. π Definition β Declaratory theory: The recognition of a new State is a political act, which is, in principle, independent of the existence of the new State as a full subject of international law.
There is an antithesis: by virtue of mere non-recognition of a State, it doesn't cease to exist, emphasizing the inherent weakness of the constitutive theory. In 1988, the constitutive theory came to the forefront, but after analyzing its flaws, most States reverted to the declaratory theory.
π Example: The Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) created a State but had no control over it. Other States issued a declaration and gave recognition to the PLO even though an essential element of statehood was missing, raising the question of whether an act of recognition can make up for the deficiency.
π Example: In 1971, after the Indo-Pakistan war, there was an issue regarding the recognition of Bangladesh by Pakistan as an independent State. π Example: The US recognizes Cuba as meeting all elements of statehood. π Example: The US and other States never recognized the statehood of the South African homelands/Bantustans (Bophuthatswana, Ciskei, Transkei) that the apartheid government tried to create in the 1970s and 1980s. π Example: Most Arab countries refused to recognize the state of Israel, believing its creation was illegal under international law. π Example: Greece refused to recognize the state of Macedonia, created from part of Yugoslavia. π Example: After the partition of India and Pakistan in 1947, the first state to recognize Pakistan as an international entity was Iran.
To Government and
Recognition of government relates to recognizing a government as the legitimate representative of the people of that country. This poses a unique challenge as governments change, and not always in conformity with regular constitutional requirements.
π Definition β De jure recognition: In the opinion of the recognizing State, the State or government recognized has fulfilled the requirements laid down in international law for effective participation in the international community. π Definition β De facto recognition: A more provisional and temporary recognition, with the reservation for the future, that the State or government has fulfilled those requirements in fact.
π Example: The US refused to recognize the communist regime of the United Soviet Socialist Republic after 1917 and mainland China after 1949. The State continues to exist even when there is a change of government or a revolutionary change.
Article 3 of the Montevideo Convention states: "The political existence of the state is independent of recognition by other States. Even before recognition the state has the right to defend its integrity and independence - and to organize itself as it sees fit."
The United Kingdom in 1980 stated it would no longer expressly accord recognition to governments. The United States in 1977 issued a statement de-emphasizing the concept of recognition of government.
π Example: Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) is a State under a constituent instrument given by Pakistan but cannot enter into independent treaties because it has no bearing as a legal entity. π Example: United Nations Security Council Resolution 1267/1999 was passed under Chapter VII, imposing limited sanctions against the Taliban and condemning the use of Afghan territory for sheltering and training terrorists.
To Disputes
Recognition of disputes relates to a State not recognizing a certain dispute. However, if the whole world acknowledges a dispute, it becomes necessary for that particular State to recognize it.
π Example: The Kashmir dispute is recognized by the US government and therefore has been recognized as a dispute by both Pakistan and India.
Disputes are further categorized into two kinds: territorial and individual. Recognition of a dispute can be determined and inferred from State practice, demonstrated by resolutions passed by the UNSC.
π Example: UNSC Resolution 1172/1998 recognized the dispute between India and Pakistan and urged them to exercise maximum restraint and avoid threatening military movements.
π‘ Why this matters: Recognition appears from the arguments to be no more than a formal obligation, with the UK and USA departing from the concept, showing it has lost importance over the years. Recognition relating to states, governments, and disputes is comprehensively complicated and confusing, now inferred from state practice. The recognition of States and Governments is a device for international law with both legal and political implications.
β Key Takeaways
Recognition involves the acceptance of facts or situations between States and is categorized into recognition of States, governments, and disputes. The two main theories for recognizing states are the constitutive theory, which requires recognition for legal existence, and the declaratory theory, where recognition is a political act independent of statehood. Governments are recognized as de jure (fulfilling international law requirements) or de facto (provisional and temporary), and states may change their policies on formally recognizing governments, as seen with the UK and USA. Recognition of disputes is often inferred from state practice and UN resolutions, with examples like the Kashmir dispute. Ultimately, recognition has become less of a formal obligation and more of a political device with legal implications, often inferred from state practice.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main theories for recognizing a State under international law, and how do they differ?
- Give an example of a situation where a State was recognized despite missing an essential element of statehood.
- What is the difference between de jure and de facto recognition of a government?
- How did the UK and USA change their policies on the recognition of governments in the late 20th century?
- What is the significance of the UN Security Council resolution 1172 (1998) in the context of recognition of disputes?
π Lecture 12 β State Succession
π Overview: This lecture examines the complex area of international law governing what happens when sovereignty over territory changes from one state to another. It covers the legal consequences for treaties, international organization membership, debts, and property, explaining why different types of succession (new state creation vs. territorial enlargement) follow different legal rules.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining state succession and explaining its various forms, including loss of part or all of a territory. It then examines the specific legal issues that arise: treaties and the 1978 Vienna Convention rules; international organization membership illustrated by the USSR/Russia UN Security Council seat; debts and loans; public property as shown in the Atlantique Incident case; and finally, relevant Pakistani legislation and ongoing work by the International Law Commission.
π Lecture Summary
Definition and Types of State Succession
International law regulating state succession deals with changes in sovereignty over a particular territory. According to Akehurst, the term describes the branch of international law dealing with the legal consequences of a change of sovereignty over territory. State succession occurs when a new state or group of states takes the place of a former state or group of states. The core question is: when one state acquires territory from another, what rights and obligations of the predecessor state pass to the successor state? This includes treaties, membership of international organizations, international claims, nationality of affected persons, public and private property, national archives, contractual rights, and national debt. The problem is complicated because it can arise in several forms: a state may lose part of its territory or all of it; the loss may result in enlargement of existing states or creation of new states. These distinctions are vital because different rules apply to different situations. For example, the partition of India and Pakistan in 1947 resulted in a calamity where the new government (Pakistan) suffered various tribulations regarding applicable laws.
π Definition β State Succession: The replacement of one state by another in the responsibility for the international relations of territory (Article 2(1)(b), Vienna Convention on Succession of States in Respect of Treaties 1978).
π Example: The partition of India and Pakistan (1947) β Pakistan succeeded laws of India applicable before partition, adopted some laws, and amended others to run an independent state.
Treaties and State Succession
The general rule is that a new state is bound to follow treaties entered into by the former state relating to boundaries. The new state has no alternative but to follow boundary treaties. All treaties not relating to boundaries are not enforceable on the new state β the new state has a prerogative of whether to enter into them (e.g., human rights treaties). The Vienna Convention on the Succession of States in Respect of Treaties (1978) clarified this ambiguity. Article 16 states that a newly independent state is not bound to maintain in force, or become a party to, any treaty by reason only that at the date of succession the treaty was in force for the predecessor state.
π Example: The Durand Line β demarcated 100 years ago between Pakistan and Afghanistan. After partition in 1947, the question was whether it still applied to the newly independent state. The answer was affirmative: Pakistan is bound to follow the principle since treaties relating to boundaries are applicable on new states.
π Principle: Boundary treaties survive state succession β New states must respect boundaries established by predecessor state's treaties.
International Organizations and State Succession
With over 30,000 treaties entered into between states, international organizations are established to ensure conformity. When states become members of these organizations, problems pertaining to state succession arise. The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics (USSR) consisted of fifteen constituent republics. Three declared and were granted independence a few months before the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991; the remaining twelve became independent when the USSR fell completely on December 26, 1991. The issue was who would serve as a permanent member in the United Nations Security Council (UNSC). In 1991, Russia, being the legal successor state to the Soviet Union, acquired the originally-Soviet seat, including the Soviet Union's former representation in the Security Council.
π‘ Why this matters: This shows that international organizations determine successor state rights on a case-by-case basis, not by automatic succession rules.
Debts and Loans
When a new state comes into existence, the question arises regarding payment of debt owed by the former state. There is no general rule regarding the solution of this problem. The more followed and better approach is that the new state would have to pay off the loan. Both the former and new state undertake a bilateral agreement to settle the issue and procedure for paying off the debt owed to other states.
Public Property
When a new state takes over a former state, issues arise regarding public property β property given to embassies, railway tracks, roads, and all immovable assets owned by the government. The Atlantique Incident (1999) illustrates this: a Pakistan Navy Breguet Atlantique patrol plane carrying 16 people was shot down by the Indian Air Force citing violation of airspace. Pakistan lodged a compensation claim at the International Court of Justice (ICJ). India argued the court did not have jurisdiction, citing an exemption it filed in 1974 excluding disputes between India and other Commonwealth States, and disputes covered by multilateral treaties. Mr. Hafeez Pirzada, a prominent Pakistani lawyer, argued that since the League of Nations was succeeded by the United Nations, India had accepted the ICJ's jurisdiction. On 21 June 2000, the decision was given in favour of India, upholding that the court did not have jurisdiction.
Relevant Pakistani Legislation
Certain legislations were passed regarding state succession, including:
- The Continuance of Legal Proceedings Act 1950
- The Pakistan Currency Act 1950
- The Pakistan Citizenship Act
- The Pending Proceeding Indian Courts Act 1952
- The Transfer of Property Ordinance 1947
- The Pakistan Control of Entry Act 1947
- The Pakistan Exchange of Prisoners Act 1947
Conclusion and Ongoing Developments
State succession is a complicated, controversial area with much uncertainty in international law. Complexities have been to a certain extent resolved by the Vienna Convention on the Succession of States. Issues and problems are under scrutiny by the International Law Commission (ILC), showing that the law on state succession is improvising and progressive improvement is taking place. The United Nations General Assembly Sixth Committee (Legal Committee) also reviewed laws relating to nationality of natural persons in relation to succession of states, significantly signifying improvisation of laws and issues relating to state succession.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are that state succession involves the transfer of rights and obligations when sovereignty changes, with different rules applying depending on whether a new state is created or an existing one is enlarged. Boundary treaties automatically bind successor states, but other treaties (like human rights treaties) are optional for new states to adopt. International organization membership, like Russia acquiring the USSR's UN Security Council seat, is decided on a case-by-case basis rather than by automatic succession. Debts and public property issues require bilateral agreements between predecessor and successor states. The 1978 Vienna Convention and ongoing work by the International Law Commission continue to develop and clarify this complex area of international law.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to Akehurst, what does the term "state succession" describe in international law?
- Under the Vienna Convention on Succession of States in Respect of Treaties (1978), are newly independent states automatically bound by all treaties their predecessor state signed?
- What was the outcome regarding Russia's permanent membership in the UN Security Council after the dissolution of the USSR?
- Why did the ICJ rule that it had no jurisdiction over the Atlantique Incident compensation claim?
- Name three pieces of Pakistani legislation passed in relation to state succession after the partition of India in 1947.