π Lecture 01 β Introduction to International Law
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of international law, distinguishing between public and private international law. It explains the scope, functions, and relevance of international law in regulating relations between sovereign states, and discusses its application within Pakistan's legal framework.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and classification of international law into public and private domains, the scope of international law covering various areas from refugee laws to trade agreements, the application of international law in Pakistan through ratification and domestic legislation, and the relevance and limitations of international law in the modern globalized world including enforcement mechanisms like UN sanctions.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction to International Law
International law comprises a set of rules that govern international relations between sovereign states. It is classified into two domains: public international law and private international law. Public international law relates to laws between states and covers almost every aspect of inter-state activity, from the laws of the use of sea, outer space, carriage of goods, civil aviation, and postal services to the transfer of money. Private international law, often dubbed as conflict of laws, concerns relationships between individuals of two different states, such as divorce issues and trade problems between individuals.
International law is a vital mechanism without which an interdependent world cannot function properly within the bounds of law. It controls states by overseeing their conduct with other states, like the law prohibiting the use of armed force to settle disputes, and also maintains laws regarding individuals (e.g., human rights).
π Definition β Public International Law: Laws between states covering inter-state activity. π Definition β Private International Law: Laws concerning relationships between individuals of different states. π Definition β Conflict of Laws: Another term for private international law.
International law is intrinsically bound up with diplomacy, politics, and conduct of foreign affairs. It is not based on an adversarial system of law, meaning many rules have evolved from state practice and do not bind states in any single course, making international law more flexible. International law leaves a state with many options rather than merely one course of action, serving as an advantage for a system so bound up with politics and diplomacy.
π‘ Why this matters: The flexibility of international law allows states to navigate complex political and diplomatic relationships while maintaining legal order.
Scope of International Law
International law covers a wide range of laws including:
- Refugee laws
- Narcotics/Drugs treaties
- Human trafficking
- Obscene publication
- World health treaties
- International trade development
- Agreement relating to independent guarantee and letter of credit
- Protocol on road signs and signals 1947
- Contract of carriage of goods by roads
Scope of International Law in Pakistan
The scope of international law in Pakistan is expanding with time. Pakistan is under an obligation to follow its international commitments arising out of any treaty, convention, or international agreement ratified by it. After ratifying a treaty, it is mandatory for Pakistan to incorporate it into domestic laws by enacting implementing legislations. For instance, the Dangerous Cargos Act and Maritime Zones Act, 1996 of Pakistan aim at translating its international obligations into domestic laws. Similarly, the United Nations Convention on Law of the Sea has been ratified by Pakistan, and corresponding domestic legislation is required to ensure its enforcement.
π Definition β Treaty: A formally ratified agreement between states. π Definition β Implementing Legislation: Domestic laws enacted to translate international obligations into national law.
π Example: Pakistan's Dangerous Cargos Act and Maritime Zones Act, 1996 are examples of implementing legislation that translate international obligations into domestic law.
Relevance and Limitations of International Law
Keeping in view the need for a stable and orderly international society, the relevance of international law is emphasized. In this age of globalization and increased interdependence between countries, international law can provide a viable regime to regulate inter-state relations and activities. However, international law has its limitations owing to concepts like state sovereignty β a sacred norm of international law.
Despite these limitations, recent developments have proved that international law can play a vital role in regulating international affairs through various treaties and conventions, which upon ratification, bind the state parties. Although there is no effective tool/forum to implement these international treaties, compliance can be ensured by means of sanctions such as trade embargos or diplomatic cut off, which are of great relevance for life in the comity of nations.
π Definition β State Sovereignty: The sacred norm of international law that gives states supreme authority within their territory. π Definition β Sanctions: Enforcement measures such as trade embargos or diplomatic cut off used to ensure compliance with international law.
π Example: UNSC Resolution 1373/01 prevents and suppresses the financing of terrorist acts, while UNSC Resolution 1566/04 makes it mandatory for worldwide implementation.
The importance of sanctions can be traced to factors such as increased economic (trade) activity at a global level, free flow of information, formation of regional/global blocks, increased immigration, and natural/human resource sharing. All these factors have contributed to the growth of international law and highlighted its need.
π‘ Why this matters: International law helps bridge gaps of dissenting ideologies and divergent policies of sovereign states by bringing them together on commonly agreed laws, reducing friction and ensuring a more orderly and peaceful world.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember is that international law comprises rules governing relations between sovereign states and is divided into public and private international law. International law is flexible and bound up with diplomacy, allowing states multiple options rather than a single course of action. For Pakistan, international obligations from ratified treaties must be incorporated into domestic law through implementing legislation. While international law lacks a central enforcement mechanism, compliance can be ensured through sanctions like trade embargos. Despite limitations from state sovereignty, international law remains vital for regulating inter-state relations in an increasingly globalized world.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between public international law and private international law?
- List five areas covered by international law mentioned in this lecture.
- How does Pakistan incorporate its international obligations into domestic law? Give an example.
- What is the role of sanctions in enforcing international law, and what are two examples mentioned?
- Why is international law described as flexible and not based on an adversarial system?
π Lecture 2 β Whether International Law is a law or not
π Overview: This lecture addresses the fundamental debate about whether international law qualifies as "true law." It examines the common criticisms that international law lacks the three essential organs of a legal systemβlegislature, executive, and judiciaryβand systematically refutes these objections by demonstrating how treaties, enforcement mechanisms, and international tribunals fulfill equivalent functions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining law and presenting John Austin's positivist challenge that international law lacks sovereignty. It then systematically addresses three core criticisms: the absence of a world legislature, the lack of an enforcement mechanism, and the absence of a judicial forum for dispute resolution. For each criticism, the lecture draws parallels between domestic law-making processes (readings of bills, committee stages) and international treaty formation, enforcement through diplomatic pressure and treaty organizations, and dispute resolution through mechanisms like the ICJ and specific treaty frameworks such as the Indus Water Treaty.
π Lecture Summary
WHETHER INTERNATIONAL LAW IS A LAW OR NOT
Law is defined as rules established by a governing authority to institute and maintain orderly coexistence. Sovereign states possess three organsβexecutive, legislature, and judiciaryβto enact, enforce, and interpret laws. International law is said to lack all three elements. There are two reasons for this misconception: firstly, people believe states have little respect for international law because there is no world government, no enforcement mechanism, and no sanctions for violations. Secondly, John Austin, a positivist, argued that international law is not really law because it lacks sovereignty; he defined laws as "commands of a sovereign." In domestic law, a legislature enacts laws, the executive enforces them, and the judiciary supervises enforcementβfor example, in Pakistan, the Pakistan Code lists various acts and Civil Major Acts describe the nature of laws.
π Definition β Law: rules established by a governing authority to institute and maintain orderly coexistence.
π Definition β Sovereignty: the quality that Austin argued international law lacks, making it not true law in his positivist view.
The Legislative Function in International Law
The functions performed by the three organs of a state are similarly performed by various treaties and multilateral conventions. The procedure for formulating/enacting a treaty is the same as establishing domestic law. A treaty is formed through negotiations between states, where a series of readings takes place for scrutiny and finalization. The first and second readings involve negotiation where states incorporate or delete clauses. The opinion of experts and technocrats plays a vital role. A Standing Committee prepares the work of the Assembly between sessions and ensures efficient operation, along with Adhoc Committees addressing specific issues. All treaties and conventions are drafted after extensive negotiations and deliberations before being opened for accession or ratification. This parallels domestic law-making, such as the three readings of a bill, the committee stage, and subsequent presentation for voting before parliament.
π Definition β Treaty: an international agreement formed through negotiations between states, equivalent to domestic legislation.
π Example: The process of drafting a treaty involves first and second readings for negotiation, expert and technocrat input, standing committee preparation, and adhoc committee workβexactly mirroring how a domestic bill goes through three readings and a committee stage before becoming a law/statute.
The Enforcement Mechanism in International Law
Under domestic law, the executive implements and executes laws passed by the legislature. Critics argue international law lacks proper enforcement and has no responsible body to ensure its application. However, states are influenced to follow international law through diplomatic and political pressures. Foremost among enforcement methods are international treaties, which when established create agencies for enforcement. Professor Kelsen, an Austrian-American legal philosopher, argued that international law does have machinery for enforcement. The system established under the UN Charter was designed to ensure member states obey and respect international obligations. Violations of certain treaties are dealt with by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), and the scope of enforcement actions by the UN is steadily growing.
π Definition β Diplomatic and political pressures: the primary enforcement mechanism in international law, influencing state compliance.
π Example: Yasir Arafat was invited by the United Nations (UN) in New York to give suggestions but his visa was rejected by the United States (US) . The UN later issued a resolution condemning the US act because a pact between the US and UN already existed clearly stating that anyone invited by the UN would be allowed a visit for official purposes.
π Example: The Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty Organization (CTBTO) implements the treaty on states that have ratified it.
π‘ Why this matters: The enforcement mechanism in international law operates through political and diplomatic pressures rather than coercive force, but it is nonetheless effective in maintaining state compliance.
The Judicial Forum in International Law
Critics argue there is no international judicial forum controlling and responsible for resolving disputes between states, unlike domestic law where a proper judicial system exists. However, this is not completely the case. Various treaties focus on implementation and provide a judicial forum to settle disputes. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is established within the framework of the UN Charter and hears disputes between states, provided those states have agreed to its jurisdiction. Disputes can also be resolved by the ICJ if a reference is made through the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) . This shows that although the scope and jurisdiction of international law differ from domestic laws, the procedure for settling disputes exists.
π Definition β International Court of Justice (ICJ): the principal judicial organ of the UN, established to hear and resolve disputes between states.
π Example: The Indus Water Treaty between Pakistan and India entails a detailed mechanism to resolve any dispute that may arise between the state parties.
π‘ Why this matters: While the ICJ requires state consent for jurisdiction, treaty-based dispute resolution mechanisms provide robust alternatives for settling international conflicts.
β Key Takeaways
International law qualifies as true law because it possesses functional equivalents of all three organs of a stateβthe legislative function is fulfilled through treaty-making processes involving negotiations, readings, and committees; the executive function operates through diplomatic pressures, treaty organizations like the CTBTO, and enforcement actions by the UN Security Council; and the judicial function is served by the International Court of Justice and treaty-specific dispute resolution mechanisms like those in the Indus Water Treaty. The positivist challenge by John Austinβthat international law lacks sovereigntyβis refuted by demonstrating that domestic law should not be regarded as the appropriate standard for judging international law, given their fundamentally different nature and purpose. Students must remember the Yasir Arafat visa example for diplomatic enforcement and the Indus Water Treaty example for judicial mechanisms.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What were John Austin's arguments against international law being considered true law?
- How does the treaty-making process parallel the domestic legislative process regarding readings and committee stages?
- What two examples are provided to demonstrate enforcement mechanisms in international law?
- How does the Indus Water Treaty illustrate dispute resolution in international law, and what role does the ICJ play?
- According to the lecture, why should domestic law not be the standard for judging international law?
π Lecture 3 β The Subjects of International Law
π Overview: This lecture defines who or what can be a subject of international law β entities capable of possessing international rights and duties. It establishes that while states are the primary subjects, international organizations, certain territorial entities, and increasingly individuals also hold international legal personality. Understanding this classification is foundational for grasping who is bound by and who can enforce international law.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing that man is the ultimate subject of all laws, then moves to international law's requirement that an entity possess international personality capable of exercising international rights and duties. It examines the four criteria for statehood under the Montevideo Convention (permanent population, defined territory, government, capacity to enter relations), discusses non-state territorial entities like Jammu Kashmir and Guantanamo Bay, explains international organizations as treaty-created subjects, addresses state extinction through lawful and unlawful means, and concludes with the evolution of individuals from objects to subjects of international law through international criminal tribunals and human rights conventions.
π Lecture Summary
The Subjects of International Law
Laws are the finest creation of the human mind, intended not only to regulate conduct but also to make possible the enjoyment of various rights, including the right to life itself. Man is the ultimate subject of all laws. At an international level, where different state actors exist, laws regulate their conduct and affairs. To be a subject of international law, an entity must possess an international personality capable of exercising international rights and duties. International law is concerned with the rights and duties of states, but other legal persons exist, such as international organizations, pre-independent territorial entities, and individuals.
π Definition β International Personality: The capacity of an entity to possess international rights and duties and to exercise them on the international plane.
Criteria for Statehood
There are various criteria laid down by international law which must be fulfilled before a "state" can come into existence. International law is defined as rules governing the relations of states amongst themselves. Article 1 of the Montevideo Convention on the Rights and Duties of States defines the state as "the state as a person of international law should possess the following qualifications: (a) a permanent population; (b) a defined territory; (c) government; and (d) capacity to enter into relations with the other states." Therefore, a state is a territory with a population, a government able to exercise effective control of that territory, and independence in external matters. It is not clear what counts as population, but there must be some population linked to a specific territory on a permanent basis regarded as its inhabitants. A state must have some definite physical existence marking it out from its neighbors. The airspace superjacent to land territory and the territorial sea is part of state territory, and other states may only use such airspace for aviation or other purposes with the agreement of that state. Moreover, a state requires a government controlling the population and executing rights and obligations under international law.
π Definition β Montevideo Convention (Article 1): The treaty defining statehood by requiring a permanent population, defined territory, government, and capacity to enter relations with other states. π Formula: State = Permanent Population + Defined Territory + Government + Capacity to Enter International Relations β An entity possessing all four criteria is a state under international law. π‘ Why this matters: These four criteria are the universally accepted test for whether a new entity qualifies as a state, determining whether it can join the UN, make treaties, or claim sovereignty.
Other Territorial Entities
States are not the only subjects of international law. Certain other territorial entities may be classified as subjects of international law, created by an international treaty, depending on the acquiescence of states involved in their administration. For example, Jammu Kashmir has unique features and is not regarded as a state. Similarly, Guantanamo Bay, as a non-state entity, is controlled by the US.
π Example: Jammu Kashmir β despite having territory and population, it is not considered a state under international law due to its disputed status and lack of independent government capacity.
International Organizations
International organizations are also considered subjects of international law. They are fundamentally created by treaties and must satisfy certain criteria to attain legal capacity under international law. Firstly, there must be a permanent association of states to fulfill their objectives; they must exercise some powers distinguished from those of sovereign states; and lastly, those powers must be exercised on an international level. For example, United Nations, World Health Organization, and International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) are all considered international organizations.
π Definition β International Organization: A permanent association of states created by treaty, exercising powers at the international level that are distinct from the sovereign powers of its member states.
State Extinction
If a state is extinguished through an illegal action of another state based on a right of self-determination, it will remain a state under international law. For example, Iraq exists as a state, but there may be real doubts as to claims of the US government to represent that state internationally. On the other hand, it is possible for an entity to cease to be an independent state through lawful means β by voluntary submission to the sovereignty of another state or by merger of two states into one. For example, the union of Gulf States to form United Arab Emirates.
π Example: United Arab Emirates β two or more states lawfully merging into one, voluntarily surrendering separate sovereignty.
Individuals as Subjects of International Law
Before the Second World War, individuals were not regarded to have an international personality and were considered to fall under the heading of a state, not as separate subjects of international law. Recently, individuals are responsible personally for certain crimes such as war crimes, hijacking, crimes against humanity, and genocide. The reason is that an individual is responsible behind a state's activity, so an individual should be tried for his own actions. International courts have been established to hold individuals liable for their acts, for example, International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia and International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. Similarly, international conventions and treaties have imposed rights and obligations on them, including:
- Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations
- Convention on Prevention and Punishment of Crime of Genocide 1945
- International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966
- International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 1966
- Convention on Status of Refugees
- World Health Organization
- Convention against Torture
- Convention on Rights of Children
- Migration Conventions
- Convention on Suppression of Trafficking of Women and Children
Thus, international law deals with States and non-State subjects (international organizations and individuals) alike. Even though States possess a full measure of international legal personality, other entities possess capacity to act as a legal person, provided it is conferred on them by the States.
π Definition β Individual as Subject: A natural person who can be held directly responsible under international law for crimes such as genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity, and who also possesses rights under international human rights treaties. π‘ Why this matters: This shift from states-only to individual accountability is one of the most significant developments in modern international law, making leaders personally liable for atrocities.
β Key Takeaways
The core criteria for statehood are the four elements from the Montevideo Convention: permanent population, defined territory, government, and capacity to enter international relations. States are the primary subjects of international law but are not alone β international organizations like the UN, territorial entities like Guantanamo Bay, and individuals all possess varying degrees of international legal personality. State extinction through illegal means does not terminate statehood if based on self-determination, but lawful merger or voluntary submission does end it. The most critical evolution is that individuals are now personally responsible for international crimes and can be tried by international tribunals, and they also enjoy rights under numerous international human rights conventions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four criteria for statehood under Article 1 of the Montevideo Convention?
- Why is Jammu Kashmir not regarded as a state under international law?
- What three criteria must an international organization satisfy to attain legal capacity?
- How does the legal status of a state differ when it is extinguished through illegal action versus lawful means?
- What changed after World War II regarding the status of individuals in international law, and what international tribunals exemplify this change?
π Lecture 4 β Sources of International Law
π Overview: This lecture examines the formal sources of international law, primarily through Article 38(1) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice. It explains how treaties and customs constitute the two major foundations of international legal obligations, why they matter for state behavior, and how conflicts between them are resolved.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture introduces Article 38(1) of the ICJ Statute as the authoritative framework listing sources of international law: international conventions (treaties), international custom, general principles of law, and subsidiary means like judicial decisions and teachings. It then elaborates on treatiesβcategorizing them into law-making, codifying, and constituent treatiesβand explores international custom, emphasizing the two essential elements: state practice and opinio juris. Finally, it discusses the interplay and hierarchy between treaties and customs, including the concept of jus cogens.
π Lecture Summary
Sources of International Law
International law lacks formal legislative institutions, but rules and methods exist to determine its sources. Article 38(1) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) is accepted as the most authoritative list. It states the Court shall apply: (a) international conventions, (b) international custom as evidence of general practice accepted as law, (c) general principles of law recognized by civilized nations, and (d) judicial decisions and teachings of highly qualified publicists as subsidiary means.
π Definition β International Court of Justice (ICJ): the principal judicial organ of the United Nations that settles legal disputes between states.
Treaties (International Conventions)
Treaties, also called conventions or pacts, are created through negotiations between states. They may be bilateral (between two states) or multilateral (between more than two states). Once a state signifies consent (e.g., by ratification), it is bound by the treaty's terms vis-Γ -vis all other parties. Therefore, treaties only impose obligations on states that have ratified them.
Types of Treaties
Treaties are categorized into three types: law-making treaties, codifying treaties, and constituent treaties.
Law-making treaties arise when customary laws on a particular issue are lacking. They create general norms for the future conduct of parties. Examples include the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) (prohibiting nuclear testing) and the World Trade Organization (WTO) agreements.
Codifying treaties codify existing customary laws into written form. They develop international law and bind both signatory and non-signatory states. Examples include the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations and the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
Constituent treaties serve as the statute of an international organization. For instance, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) and the International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia (ICTY) were established under a United Nations Security Council (UNSC) resolution. The Universal Declaration on Human Rights (UDHR) is also considered a source due to its wide application.
International Custom (Customary International Law)
Customs are traditions consistently practiced by states for a long time. They mature into norms and achieve the status of law. A controversial aspect is that not every state practice qualifies as custom. For a custom to form, two elements are necessary.
π Definition β Opinio juris: the belief of states that a practice is obligatory rather than merely convenient or habitual. It is the essential element that turns state practice into binding customary law.
Two requirements for customary law:
- State practice: general, consistent, and uniform.
- Opinio juris: the belief that the practice is legally obligatory.
π Example: The Geneva Convention of 1949 is cited as an example of customary law.
Relationship Between Treaty and Custom
Treaty and custom are the two major sources with separate existence and identity. When conflict arises:
- A treaty may prevail over custom if the state has ratified the treaty, because treaties represent deliberate law creation.
- Jus cogens (a fundamental norm from which no derogation is permitted) overrides contrary treaties or customary rules.
- If a treaty is later in time than a custom (subject to jus cogens), the treaty prevails.
- The position reverses if contrary customary law develops after the treaty's adoption.
- Non-parties to a treaty remain bound by customary rules.
- Where treaty and custom are identical in content, states may face parallel obligations under both.
π Definition β Jus cogens: a fundamental norm of general international law from which no derogation is permitted; it overrides contrary treaties or customary rules. The criterion for identifying jus cogens is stated under the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.
π‘ Why this matters: These rules resolve potential conflicts between the two main sources, ensuring legal certainty in state relations.
β Key Takeaways
The four sources of international law listed in Article 38(1) are treaties, customs, general principles of law, and subsidiary sources (judicial decisions and teachings). Treaties are binding only on ratifying states and are categorized as law-making, codifying, or constituent instruments. Customary law requires both consistent state practice and opinio juris (the belief that the practice is legally obligatory). Jus cogens norms override all other rules, including contrary treaties. In conflicts between treaty and custom, the later-in-time treaty generally prevails, but non-parties remain bound by custom, and states may face parallel obligations when both sources contain identical rules.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four categories of sources listed in Article 38(1) of the ICJ Statute?
- Distinguish between law-making treaties, codifying treaties, and constituent treaties. Provide one example of each.
- What are the two essential elements required for the formation of customary international law?
- Define opinio juris and explain why it is necessary for a custom to become binding law.
- If a treaty conflicts with a customary rule, under what circumstances will the treaty prevail? When will custom prevail?
π Lecture 5 β Sources of International Law Part II
π Overview: This lecture explores the additional sources of international law beyond treaties and customs, as listed under Article 38(1) of the ICJ Statute. It examines general principles of law, judicial decisions, writings of publicists, and resolutions of international organizations, highlighting their role in developing and clarifying international law.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers general principles of law as gap-fillers from domestic systems, judicial decisions as material sources for interpreting international law, writings of publicists as subsidiary means for determining rules, and resolutions of international organizations as emerging material sources. It includes examples such as nuclear weapons opinions, UNGA resolutions on aggression, and human rights declarations.
π Lecture Summary
Apart from Treaty and Customs
The Statute of International Court of Justice (ICJ) under its Article 38 (1) mentions other sources of international law beyond treaties and customs. Treaty represents state consensus and customs are laws practiced by states that later evolve as customary law. Both are formal sources, whereas various other informal, material and evidential sources are also mentioned in the Statute.
General Principles of Law
The General Principles of Law in Article 38(1) of ICJ Statute refers to those legal principles which exist in all or most domestic systems of law. Its purpose is to fill in the gaps left by treaty and customs, applying principles which do not have their origin in either treaty or custom.
π Definition β General Principles of Law: Legal principles common to all or most domestic legal systems, used by international courts to fill gaps when no treaty or custom applies.
π Example: India and Pakistan agreed on the general principle of law before an arbitrator on the basis of the principle of equity β principles of equity are considered to constitute a part of international law and rely on fairness and justice, and have been applied by the ICJ to resolve law of the sea disputes. Similarly, the Islamic concept of international law includes customary norms relating to prisoners and the treatment of prisoners after war.
Judicial Decisions
Judicial decisions are law identifying or material sources of international law. The ICJ is involved in the process of law making, and its opinions are referred to resolve uncertainty prevailing in specific areas of law. Decisions by judges are comprehensive and used as an aid to interpret international laws.
π Example: In 1996, the ICJ gave a judgment regarding the illegality of the use of nuclear weapons because it relates to International Humanitarian Law. It was argued by various publicists whether the usage of nuclear weapons is legal under self-defence or not. The ICJ issued an opinion stating that the use of nuclear weapons amounts to a crime under international humanitarian law, thus ignoring the debate regarding its legality under self-defence.
Judicial decisions not only concern international court decisions but also refer to local court decisions. For example, 2002 SCMR 1694 relates to treaty applications and its implications.
π‘ Why this matters: Judicial decisions create precedent and clarify ambiguous areas of international law, helping resolve disputes and guide future state behavior.
Writings of the Publicists
The writings of the publicists are regarded as a subsidiary means for the determination of the rules of law. Writings of various authors and experts are considered significant. Textbooks and publications represent a quick and easy way to discover the content of law. They are only a material source and do have a tangible effect on state practice, remaining the first references of international lawyers.
π Example: The situation of Bangladesh and India in 1971 and the Iran revolution in 1986 led to much debate by authors and publicists, resulting in clarity of the situation. Further, a British Yearbook of International Law is issued incorporating articles of well-known international lawyers and experts. Similarly, the American Society of International Law publishes the American Journal of International Law.
Resolutions of International Organizations
Resolutions of International Organizations are argued to be a new source of international law, although the ICJ Statute does not include this as a source. They are considered as material and evidential sources. Some states regulate their conduct through international organizations by issuing declarations and giving statements with reference to international law.
π Example: The United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) passed a resolution defining aggression and developed a different approach towards it. This resolution later became an important source of international law in order to ascertain the acts amounting to aggression.
The resolutions of the UNGA are not binding on states, even if adopted unanimously, except for those concerned with internal matters of the United Nations, e.g., resolution on the admittance of new states or election of the Security Council. The Friendly Declaration was also issued by UNGA stating that the sovereignty of states must be kept intact and must not be destroyed by any other state.
π Example: The Universal Declaration on Human Rights (UDHR) was passed by UNGA, entailing a comprehensive concept pertaining to rights of individuals, and later a number of other conventions followed, including:
- International Convention on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) 1966
- International Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) 1966
- Convention on Rights of Children (CRC)
The UDHR is considered as a source of international law relating to human rights. Apart from UNGA resolutions, the decisions of the Security Council under Chapter VII have a binding effect as well.
β Key Takeaways
International law can be ascertained from various sources under Article 38(1) of the ICJ Statute. General principles of law fill gaps where no treaty or custom exists, drawing from common domestic legal systems and principles like equity. Judicial decisions serve as material sources to interpret and clarify international law, while writings of publicists provide accessible guidance for determining legal rules. Resolutions of international organizations, particularly UNGA resolutions like the UDHR, have become important material sources even though they are generally non-binding, with Security Council Chapter VII decisions being the exception as binding instruments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the purpose of "general principles of law" under Article 38(1) of the ICJ Statute?
-
In the 1996 ICJ case on nuclear weapons, why did the Court rule that their use was illegal?
-
Are judicial decisions limited to international courts only, or do local court decisions also count as sources?
-
Why are resolutions of the UNGA generally not binding on states, and what are the exceptions?
-
Which three major human rights conventions followed the Universal Declaration on Human Rights (UDHR)?
π Lecture 6 β International Law and Municipal Law
π Overview: This lecture examines the relationship between international law and municipal (domestic/national) law, focusing on how states implement international obligations within their own legal systems. It is crucial because the effectiveness of international law depends entirely on state compliance and proper domestic incorporation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and relationship between international law and municipal law, the two major schools of thought (monism and dualism), the different approaches taken by civil law versus common law countries in incorporating international treaties, methods of implementation including identifying existing laws, amending laws, or enacting new legislation, and the role of UN Security Council resolutions in creating compliance obligations.
π Lecture Summary
International Law and Municipal Law
International law is defined as law between sovereign states, governing state actions and implemented to subjects such as states. Municipal law (also called national/domestic law) regulates relationships between citizens within a particular state. Member states bear the responsibility to ensure correct enforcement of international laws within their territory. The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) has passed various resolutions, creating obligations on states to enforce them under Chapter VII of the UN Charter.
π Definition β International law: a law between sovereign states that governs state actions π Definition β Municipal law: national/domestic laws prevailing in a state that regulate relationships between citizens within that state π Example: UNSC resolutions 1373, 1267, 1540, 1566 and 1617 create binding obligations on member states to enforce international law domestically
Two Schools of Thought: Monism and Dualism
There are two schools of thought describing the relationship between international law and municipal law: monism and dualism. According to monism, municipal law and international law are part of a universal legal order, with international law being part of the same system as domestic law. According to dualism, there are two distinct systems of law, each having its own sphere of application, meaning international law and municipal law operate separately.
π Definition β Monism: the view that municipal law and international law are part of a single universal legal order π Definition β Dualism: the view that international law and municipal law are two distinct systems, each with its own sphere of application
Implementation Methods: Civil Law vs. Common Law Countries
A state can enforce international law either by adopting administrative measures or through legal measures, depending on whether it is a civil law country or common law country. In civil law countries, whenever a state has signed a treaty, it automatically becomes part of domestic law and is incorporated automatically. In contrast, common law countries (like Pakistan, India, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, and the UK) require formal incorporation of international law into national laws to ensure applicability and compliance. The problem arises when the government is not ready to make laws in accordance with international laws.
π Definition β Civil law approach: treaty ratification automatically incorporates it into domestic law π Definition β Common law approach: requires formal legislative incorporation for international law to have domestic effect
Methods of Incorporating International Law into Domestic Law
There are three ways international law can become part of domestic law: (1) the government can identify an existing law that is already in compliance with international obligations; (2) amend existing laws to align with international law provisions; or (3) enact new legislation to comply with international law provisions.
π Example: The judgment in SCMR 2002 1694 stated that if treaty provisions are not incorporated through legislation, such provisions will have no effect and treaty rights will not be enforced. π Example: Warsaw Convention on Carriage of Goods by Air was ratified by Pakistan, which passed a small legislation to incorporate it into domestic law.
π‘ Why this matters: A treaty represents a specific commitment where the state partially surrenders its sovereignty, making proper domestic incorporation essential.
Making New Laws vs. Amending Existing Laws
The more appropriate method is to make new laws in compliance with international laws because this approach not only helps in better understanding but also leads to more efficient legislative measures, which are beneficial for implementation. If international law concerns a new issue with no existing legislation, the government must make new laws covering that specific issue. If existing law exists, it should be amended to bring it in accordance with international laws.
π Example: Pakistan Penal Code Section 302 relating to murder is in compliance with the International Genocide Convention without needing new legislation. π Example: The Chemical Weapons Convention Implementation Order 2000 was ratified by Pakistan, making it mandatory to abide by it and refrain from production and transportation of chemical weapons. π Example: After 9/11, the Anti Terrorism Act 1997 Section 11 underwent 25 amendments regarding terrorism, entirely changing the basic form of legislation to bring domestic law in line with international law.
Role of UNSC Resolutions and Compliance Issues
Several treaties create specific implementation organizations to ensure enforcement and create obligations on states. Resolutions passed by the UNSC create obligations on states to follow certain international laws. Every state has its own domestic laws according to which they determine their relationship with international laws. The resolutions work as a watchdog, ensuring compliance of domestic law with international laws and inquiring into implementation by various organizations. The traditional relationship between international law and domestic law does create problems based on whether implementation is done through administrative measures or legal measures.
π Example: UNSC Resolution 1267 and Resolution 1373 created binding obligations on states regarding counter-terrorism measures.
β Key Takeaways
The fundamental distinction between monism and dualism determines how states incorporate international law domestically. Civil law countries automatically incorporate treaties upon ratification, while common law countries require formal legislative incorporation. States have three methods for implementation: identifying existing compliant laws, amending existing laws, or enacting new legislation. Making new laws is considered more efficient for better understanding and implementation. UNSC resolutions under Chapter VII create binding obligations and serve as a watchdog mechanism to ensure domestic compliance with international law.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between monism and dualism regarding international law and municipal law?
- Why do common law countries like Pakistan require formal incorporation of treaties into domestic law?
- What are the three methods through which international law can become part of domestic law?
- According to SCMR 2002 1694, what happens if treaty provisions are not incorporated through legislation?
- How did Pakistan modify its domestic legislation after 9/11 to comply with international law requirements?