π Lecture 20 β POSITIONING β GUIDING PRINCIPLES
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of repositioning by discussing the fifth and final principle. It also provides a comprehensive guide on how to choose a realistic positioning statement, including how to communicate the actual positioning, evaluate different considerations, and coin the brand's message. This is critical because positioning is the single most important activity in brand strategy, from which all operational strategies derive.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the fifth guiding principle of positioning (the IENCE model), the challenge of communicating actual positioning by selecting one key benefit, a framework of positioning considerations and evaluation criteria to choose the right position, and the process of coining the brand's message. It concludes with a summary of the entire positioning concept and its centrality to brand management.
π Lecture Summary
5. Strong brand positioning is customer-driven
A correct brand picture provides data and information on customer needs, strengths, and weaknesses of your brand versus competitors. Armed with this information, you can create the right promises, deliver them, and maintain the brand contract to have a strong position. The fifth principle is captured by the IENCE model, which outlines how to inspire and engage people within the organization to work for the brand's positioning.
π Definition β IENCE Model: A framework for internal branding success comprising Inspiration (results from research inspire colleagues), Engagement (right direction inspires everyone to feel involved), Naturalness (the right people work naturally toward objectives), Criteria (establish reward criteria for achieving objectives to motivate others), and Education (train people to become brand ambassadors).
π‘ Why this matters: Without internal buy-in and alignment from colleagues, even the best-positioned brand will fail in execution.
Communicating the actual positioning
The most challenging decision is choosing the actual positioningβthe communication directed toward the target. Having the right information does not guarantee the right statement and strategies. You must choose a position with the strongest appeal to the target audience that the company can sustain over a long time. The challenge stems from the fact that your brand carries more than one benefit. To keep your message straightforward and strong, you have to pick one benefit as the basis of your positioning statement.
π Example: For brand XYZ, the positioning statement is very clear, taking into account all componentsβthe category, competitive benchmarks, target market, and point of difference. Out of many benefits (good price, high quality, easy availability, good looks), the challenge is to choose the one that keeps the message simplest and strongest to position the brand in the oversimplified mind of the consumer.
Positioning considerations
The criteria against which you can measure the decision mechanism include: quality, price, accessibility, taste profile, appearance dimensions, service innovation (e.g., revolutionizing lunchtime service), variety, or any other relevant factor. All of these considerations sound convincing, but whichever the company chooses must stem from the customerβs point of view so that the customer can own it.
Evaluation criteria for each positioning consideration include:
- Are the productβs looks and appearance compatible with the positioning?
- How strong is the consumer motivation behind this positioning?
- What size of market is involved?
- Does it capitalize on competitors' weaknesses?
- Is this positioning distinctive and specific?
- What financial resources are required?
- Is this positioning sustainable, or will competitors imitate it quickly?
- Does this leave an alternative to switch to another positioning if this fails?
- Does this justify a price premium?
π Definition β Evaluation Criteria: A set of nine questions used to assess each potential positioning consideration against customer needs, market size, competitive advantage, sustainability, and financial feasibility. The best way to choose the right positioning is to pick each consideration and evaluate it against all criteria one by one.
Coining the message
Once you have decided the positioning, you can coin the brandβs message as the outward expression of the brandβs inner substance. This is the message (slogan or ad line) that appears in all communications, including the productβs package. You must take charge of positioning; otherwise, competitors will be quick to do that to your loss.
π Definition β Positioning: The single most important activity in developing your brand management strategy. If you craft it right, then your decisions to introduce new brands, extensions, pricing, and communication become fairly straightforward.
π‘ Why this matters: If you fail to position your brand actively, competitors will position it for youβlikely in a way that disadvantages your brand.
Summary - positioning
Positioning stems from the areas of segmentation and differentiation. Knowledge about the business you are in, the target market, and the point of difference that matters for your product lays the foundation for positioning. Once done, you communicate the position to the target market. Positioning is very central to brand strategyβall operational strategies stem out of it. Propounded as a concept by two advertising executives, it followed the product era and the image era.
Positioning is what you do to the mind of a consumer. You communicate information about your product in a way that it gets lodged in the consumer's mind. If the product is full of promises and upholds the brand contract, it becomes difficult for competition to dislodge it. Every brand manager should strive to create a strong position by following certain principles. While improving the brand to keep it current, you must manage the desired shift in positioning in a subtle wayβthe brand must not lose credibility. You must position the brand from the platform of one benefit, as talking about all benefits confuses the consumer. Different benefits should be weighed against a set of criteria to choose the best position.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaway is that strong brand positioning must be customer-driven, meaning all data about customer needs and competitive weaknesses must inform the promises you make and deliver. Equally essential is the IENCE modelβInspiration, Engagement, Naturalness, Criteria, Educationβwhich ensures internal alignment and that colleagues become brand ambassadors. When communicating the actual positioning, you must select only one benefit as the basis of your positioning statement, despite the brand offering multiple benefits, to keep the message simple and strong in the consumer's oversimplified mind. The evaluation criteria (nine questions) provide a systematic method to assess each potential positioning consideration against consumer motivation, market size, sustainability, and financial resources. Finally, the brand's message (slogan or ad line) is the outward expression of the inner substance, and you must take charge of positioning proactively, or competitors will position your brand to your loss.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five components of the IENCE model and why is each important for implementing brand positioning?
- Why is it a challenge to communicate the actual positioning when a brand carries more than one benefit?
- List at least six of the nine evaluation criteria used to choose the right positioning consideration.
- What is the relationship between the brand's message (slogan) and the brand's inner substance?
- According to the summary, from what two areas does positioning stem, and why is positioning considered the single most important activity in brand strategy?
π Lecture 21 β BRAND EXTENSION
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of brand extension, distinguishing between line extensions (variants within the same category) and brand diversification (stretching into new categories). It explains why leveraging a strong brand name is a common, cost-effective strategy for launching new products, while cautioning against meaningless proliferation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing brand extension as a response to evolving customer needs and segment differentiation. It covers leveraging a strong brand name for new offerings, the risks of leveraging without purpose, and the economic rationale for brand extension. It then defines and contrasts line extension (within category) and brand diversification (across categories), detailing the forms and positive side of line extension.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
Positioning clarifies that one position cannot satisfy all varying needs within a category. To keep up with evolution, you must evolve new points of difference. Different needs refer to different segments, and every product has variants to address those segmental needs. Examples include regular and mild cigarettes, regular and fruit yogurt, and economy and executive car models. To let the market know you have something different to offer, you must differentiate between the existing offering and the new entry by either: A) Staying within the value framework of the original brand under the same name, or B) Creating a different identity altogether.
Brand extension
Brand extension is the study and practice of deciding what to do with existing brand names for new offerings. This covers two situations: 1) What to do in situations that evolve with changing needs (e.g., soups in different flavors, detergents in powder and liquid forms). 2) What to do in situations offering an opportunity to enter a new market altogether (e.g., juice manufacturers getting into milk, chocolate getting into ice cream). Both situations involve using the same existing brand name because it is strong.
Leveraging
The opportunity of using the same brand name for variants or new products takes us into the domain of leveraging β adding value to the company by capitalizing on the brand as an asset. Managers leverage brands under two circumstances: when they are led into genuine situations of satisfying evolving needs (e.g., light cigarettes, sugar-free gum), and when it is attractive to go across category with the confidence that the existing brand name will add value to the new introduction.
Leveraging without purpose
If managers attempt to leverage their brand only because it has high value, but it does not really have a specific need to satisfy, they end up introducing something with no substantive difference. This is merely brand proliferation. Over-proliferation is a serious threat to a brandβs future, as customers show resentment to brands with no real point of difference.
Why brand extension?
Brand extension is on the rise because most new product launches use existing strong brand names. The cost of launching a new brand in major markets is about US$1 billion, whereas launching under the same name is estimated to be one-fifth of that cost. Furthermore, 30% of new brands survive about three years, but the rate goes up to 50% if launched under an existing brand name. Therefore, brand extension is cheaper and securer.
Kinds of extensions
There are two kinds of extensions: line extension and brand diversification. Brand diversification is in effect brand extension, but this terminology is often used generically for both types.
π Definition β Line extension: getting into different versions of the same base product on the same market. The objective is to add more depth to your offerings within a definite market. This corresponds to practice 1 of brand extension (e.g., a spice manufacturer getting into more non-traditional spices, a cheese manufacturer getting into different kinds of packing and portions).
π Definition β Brand diversification/extension/stretching: stretching your brand into new product fields, where your brand becomes an umbrella covering very different segments and products (e.g., Mitsubishi, Philips, GE). This corresponds to practice 2 of brand extension and is real diversification toward different product categories, making it a highly sensitive and strategic choice.
Line Extension in detail
Extending the line is an evolutionary step in the life of a brand and occurs to address changing needs. In the words of Kapferer, just as human species survive by adapting to the environment, brands that start as single products have to adapt to the marketing environment by breaking into sub-species. Examples include Toyota cars, Coca-Cola, and National and Shan βMasalasβ.
Forms of line extension
Line extension takes on the following forms: multiplication of formats and sizes (cars, soft drinks); multiplication of variety of tastes and flavors (yogurt, juice); multiplication of the type of ingredients (caffeine-free coffee, sugar-free juice); multiplication of generic forms of medicines (extra-strength, without drowsiness); multiplication of physical forms (detergents in powder and liquid, deodorants in sticks, spray, and roll-ons); multiplication of product add-ons satisfying closely related needs of the same consumer (mascara, lipstick, skin-care creams by one company); multiplication of versions having a specific application (shoe cream for regular leather, powder or spray for suede leather).
Positive side of line extension
As said earlier, each brand starts as a single product and becomes sub-divided into variants that respond to differentiated expectations. The positive aspects include:
- Increases Usage: multiplication of versions increases the consumer base (e.g., cola in family size bottle, can, returnable bottles).
- Reinforces Sales: with each version designed for one particular usage mode, the brand reinforces its sales with a wider market base.
- Friendly and Caring: it shows sensitivity to consumerβs needs and the brand energizes itself by responding to those needs, maintaining an interesting, friendly, and caring character (e.g., a small tub of jam).
- Pushes Boundaries: it pushes the boundaries of the market and strengthens the brandβs domination by increasing visibility through successive launches.
- Revitalizes failing Brands: line extension helps ailing and tired brands by introducing new offerings with a meaningful point of difference.
- Maintain relationship between market share and shelf-space share: it is always good to introduce something by the existing name and keep competition pushed out of limited retail shelf space.
β Key Takeaways
Brand extension involves leveraging a strong existing brand name, which is cheaper and has a higher survival rate than launching a new brand. The critical distinction is between line extension (new variants within the same category) and brand diversification (stretching into new categories). Leveraging must have a genuine purpose and a meaningful point of difference; otherwise, it becomes damaging brand proliferation. Line extension offers several advantages including increasing usage, reinforcing sales, and revitalizing failing brands.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between line extension and brand diversification?
- What is leveraging in the context of brand extension, and what are the two circumstances for it?
- What is the risk of leveraging a brand without a specific need to satisfy?
- What are the six forms or types of line extension mentioned in the lecture?
- Why is brand extension considered both cheaper and securer than launching a new brand?
π Lecture 22 β Line Extension
π Overview: This lecture examines the negative sides of line extensions that brand managers must understand to realistically manage them. It discusses retailer power issues, lack of scale economies, and uncontrolled cannibalization, followed by strategic actions to counter these negative effects, including de-segmentation and improved cost management.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the negative side of line extensions including retailer power, lack of scale economies, and non-controlled extension weakening the range. It then discusses reactions to these negatives such as de-segmentation and counter-segmentation strategies. Finally, it outlines four immediate actions for better managing line extensions: improving cost accounting systems, allocating resources to high-margin items, defining the role of each extension through salespeople, and encouraging product withdrawal.
π Lecture Summary
Negative side of line extension
The lecture begins by exploring three major negative consequences of line extensions that brand managers must recognize to manage them effectively.
1. Retailer power When all managers extend their lines with similar objectives, the result is bottlenecks at the retail level. This clutter leads to a selective attitude on the part of retailers, who become more receptive toward more powerful brands. Those brands that get discriminated against try to react by engaging in promotions, which makes both retailers and consumers happy in the short term. What ensues is price wars and erosion of brand loyalty, which is ultimately not good for the brand.
2. Lack of scale economies As against a mono product, handling and managing a variety of products is cumbersome from production, logistics, inventory, and costing perspectives. Smaller runs deprive the company of scale economies and are more expensive. According to one study, compared with an index of 100 as the cost of production for a mono product, the corresponding cost index for differentiated products is: Food β 145, Hosiery β 132, Car β 135. Economies of scale take on added importance if the brand sells in high volumes across a huge geographic area positioned on consumer-friendly pricing.
π Formula: Cost Index (Differentiated) > 100 β differentiated products always cost more to produce than mono products (e.g., Food = 145, Hosiery = 132, Car = 135)
π Example: If a company produces only one type of soap (mono product), the production cost is indexed at 100. If the same company produces 10 different variants of soap (differentiated products), the production cost index rises to 145 for food products, meaning 45% higher costs due to lack of scale economies.
3. Non-controlled extension weakens range Extensions without strong rationale can become counter-productive, because creating meaningful positioning for a variety of products within the same line becomes challenging. All positions have to be created with subtle yet distinct differences. Without meaningful differences, products tend to eat into each otherβs volume and cause cannibalization.
π‘ Why this matters: Cannibalization means new products steal sales from existing products in the same brand line, rather than attracting new customers, so total brand profitability may not increase despite more offerings.
π Definition β Cannibalization: The situation where products within the same line eat into each otherβs volume because they lack meaningful distinct positioning, resulting in no net gain for the brand.
Reaction to negative side of extensions
There has been a tendency on the part of companies to de-segment or counter-segment their markets. Proctor and Gamble reduced their line by about 15 to 25 percent in 1992 only because those entries were not turning in requisite volumes and profitability. It also leads to consumer frustration and what was previously learned as consumer revolt. The factor of scale economies takes a turn for the better under the circumstances of de-segmentation. A lesser number of offerings leads to higher volumes, which result in lower costs of producing.
π Definition β De-segmentation: The strategy of reducing the number of product variants in a line to focus on higher-volume, more profitable items, thereby improving scale economies and reducing consumer frustration.
π Example: Proctor and Gamble cut 15-25% of their product line in 1992 because those entries were not generating sufficient volumes and profitability, demonstrating the need for disciplined product portfolio management.
Immediate actions for better managing line extensions
This section presents four concrete actions brand managers should take to improve the management of line extensions.
1. Improve cost accounting systems Management experts emphasize improving cost accounting systems. Experience shows that many companies are system-deficient in this regard. You must have accurate figures to charge every range item that you produce. The objective is to determine which items are more profitable than others.
2. Allocate resources more to high-margin items As brand managers and good businesspeople, you must allocate marketing resources to different items in line with their contribution to the overall profitability. The extensions that give higher margins must get priority over those that attract occasional buyers.
3. Salespeople must define the role of each extension Each extension has to be seen in the context of its sales value. The salespersons responsible for each must produce figurative evidence of what they sell is worth its existence. Salespeople must understand the costing angle and then produce results out of the extensions that account for most of the profitable business. They must be able to relate profitability with high volume items. Their education as part of AUDIENCE is of significance, for mostly salespeople go after volumes no matter how high is the cost. They must understand the actual positioning of the product along with the strategic goals of financial growth. Volumes just for the sake of a high market share with low profitability may not be the companyβs priority at all times. Small volumes adding up to a certain total volume cost a lot more than the same total arrived at by less number of products.
π‘ Why this matters: Salespeople often chase volume at any cost. This action ensures they align their selling efforts with profitability goals rather than just market share.
4. Encourage product withdrawal Implement this philosophy and withdraw low volume items in a phased way so that your existing customers do not turn away to competition; they should rather switch over to another attractive offering within your range.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points for exam preparation are: Line extensions have significant negative consequences including retailer power leading to price wars, lack of scale economies (as shown by cost indices of 145 for food, 132 for hosiery, 135 for cars compared to 100 for mono products), and uncontrolled cannibalization of the brandβs own products. Companies like Proctor and Gamble have responded by de-segmenting their lines by 15-25% to improve profitability. To better manage extensions, brand managers must improve cost accounting systems, allocate resources to high-margin items, ensure salespeople define the role and profitability of each extension, and withdraw low-volume items in a phased manner. The fundamental lesson is that more products do not automatically mean more profit; disciplined management and strategic withdrawal are essential.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three negative sides of line extensions discussed in this lecture, and how does each harm the brand?
- According to the study cited, what are the production cost indices for differentiated products in food, hosiery, and car categories compared to a mono product (indexed at 100)?
- Why did Proctor and Gamble reduce their product line by 15-25% in 1992, and what strategy does this action represent?
- List the four immediate actions recommended for better managing line extensions.
- What does "encourage product withdrawal" mean in practice, and why should it be done in a phased way?