π Lecture 15 β Brand Based Customer Model
π Overview: This lecture continues building the brand-based customer model by exploring key factors that influence consumer perception and decision-making. It explains how to use rating scales to compare brands, discusses the psychological principles governing consumer perception, and emphasizes the importance of identifying who makes buying decisions and how to assess competition effectively.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Factor b - Rating buying criteria, including how to assign weights to characteristics and draw comparisons with competition. It then discusses six key research findings about brand perception. Next, it addresses Factor c - who makes buying decisions and why this is important for brand managers. Finally, it explores Question 2, which involves identifying competitors, understanding customer beliefs about them, and comparing your brand against competition.
π Lecture Summary
Factor b - Rating buying criteria
Rating is about drawing comparisons with competition. You compare two to three brands across pre-mentioned characteristics. By assigning weight to all characteristics, you can arrive at a conclusion about where your brand stands in terms of consumer perceptions. The process involves creating a table with buying criteria (e.g., price, accessibility, quality, customer service, reliability, consistent performance, price value relationship) and rating each brand on a scale of 1β5.
π Definition β Rating: Drawing comparisons with competition by assigning weights to characteristics across brands to determine consumer preferences.
π Formula: Rating Scale = 1β5 β Plain-English meaning: Higher weight indicates stronger preference for that brand on that criterion.
π Example: In the provided table, Brand B tops the list on price (weight 4) and on price value relationship (weight 4). However, it is poor on availability with a weight of 2 and sits on the average threshold of 3 on remaining attributes. Brand A scores high on accessibility (5), reliability (5), and consistent performance (5), while Brand C scores 3 or 4 across most criteria.
π‘ Why this matters: It is difficult to know why customers choose one brand over another because the decision process involves many psychological factors. However, through rating of criteria, we can understand the status of our brand.
Research has concluded six key findings about brand perception:
-
People perceive the brand as a whole: Psychologically, they form the concept as a whole, rather than forming impressions analytically on separate pieces.
-
Perception is selective: Not all information is absorbed. Information passes through a process of filtering; some is absorbed, some is forgotten.
-
Consumersβ perception is the reality: A deliveryman (of sandwiches) with unhygienic upkeep may tarnish the image of a wonderful product. The unhygienic setup becomes the customerβs belief.
-
The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Based on scientific study, humans cannot cope with more than seven items at a time. For low-involvement items (FMCGs), it may be minus two, which is five. You must be at least in those five.
-
The brand has a personality: Consumers can imagine brands that have distinct personalities with characteristics they can describe.
-
The more complete and balanced the brand identity, the stronger is the relationship between the customer and the brand, and the better the customer can describe the brand.
Consumers have a large amount of information from different sources β experience, word of mouth, observations, advertising, and retailers. They absorb some and forget some. Key findings about information usage include:
- They use very little info in routine purchases of low-involvement items.
- 25 percent spend no time in their decision making.
- 56 percent spend less than 8 seconds.
- They cannot cope with many items of info at a time.
- Implication: Brand messages must be simple and focused.
- This keeps their beliefs and decisions straightforward.
Factor c - who makes buying decisions?
It is important for brand managers to know the people involved in the decision-making process to buy a brand. Managers must know if there are more than one decision maker and influencer for buying the brand. The objective is to understand who they are so that brand managers can smartly involve them in the decision-making process. For many consumer goods, commercials present the whole family as potential buyers and communicate with all of them.
π‘ Why this matters: This understanding enables brand managers to better position their brand and hence maximize its influence and value in the category.
Question 2
This question requires understanding and clarity of the following areas:
- What brands customers think are our competitors?
- What do our customers believe about our competitors?
- What are the strengths and weaknesses of our competitive brands?
Identify your competitors: The understanding of the first factor (our competitive brands as per customersβ perception) will come in clarity if we consider all our direct and indirect competitors. The comprehensive industry analysis gives better insights into the category as a whole.
π Example 1: A company selling juices should consider all thirst quenchers including cola/un-cola drinks and mineral water as its competitors. Broadening the scope of the category gives better insights into the dynamics of competition.
π Example 2: A manufacturer of safety matches should not ignore all manufacturers involved in making disposable lighters, because they cater to the needs of a major segment of the overall "lights" market.
Compare your brand with competition: This clarifies the last two areas (customersβ belief about our competition) and (strengths and weaknesses of our competitors). Unless compared against competition from customersβ point of view, we cannot realistically assess our brand. Drawing comparisons on what benefits and values competitors offer and how our brand stacks up offers a level ground from where we can have startling findings obscure to us without such a comparison.
π‘ Why this matters: Knowing where we realistically stand, we can devise realistic strategies and future direction.
β Key Takeaways
Rating buying criteria (on a 1-5 scale) is a powerful tool to compare brands against competition and understand consumer preferences across characteristics like price, quality, and reliability. Research shows that perception is holistic, selective, and constitutes realityβbrand messages must be simple and focused because most consumers spend less than 8 seconds on purchase decisions. Knowing who makes buying decisions (single or multiple decision-makers) helps brand managers position their brand effectively and involve all influencers. Identifying both direct and indirect competitors (e.g., a juice company must consider all thirst quenchers) broadens competitive understanding. Comparing your brand against competition from the customer's perspective reveals strengths and weaknesses, enabling realistic strategy development.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "magical number seven, plus or minus two" principle, and how does it apply to low-involvement items?
- When rating buying criteria, what does a weight of 5 signify compared to a weight of 1?
- Why is it important for brand managers to identify and involve multiple decision-makers or influencers in the buying process?
- Give an example of how a company must consider indirect competitors beyond its immediate product category.
- What percentage of consumers spend less than 8 seconds on purchase decisions, and what is the key implication for brand messaging?
π Lecture 16 β BRAND BASED CUSTOMER MODEL
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on building a brand-based customer model by exploring how to identify opportunities for growth and expansion through understanding customers' beliefs and unmet needs. It then transitions to the concept of positioning, tracing its historical evolution from the product era through the image era to the positioning era, and explains how to effectively position a brand in the prospect's mind.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the final component of the brand-based customer modelβhow to identify opportunities for growth by understanding customers' beliefs and unmet needs through structured or informal contact. It then introduces positioning, discussing the historical evolution from the product era (USP) through the image era to the positioning era, explaining how positioning works by manipulating what already exists in the prospect's mind and emphasizing things that are not.
π Lecture Summary
Question 3: Opportunities for Growth and Expansion
This question demands clarity on two factors: customers' beliefs about the segment and category, and what unmet needs exist that can be addressed. The focus remains on the customersβ perspective, not the company's own. You must unearth how customers feel about benefits and values that brands within the category must offer.
For example, a telephone company might discover that customers want telephone and internet through the same line without interference. Another example is an ISP (Internet Service Provider) starting wireless internet services to fulfill the need for a trouble- and frequency-distortion-free connection, based on customer contact.
The key to understanding customers' perspective is to stay in contact with them, through structured research or informal contact. A Japanese company practices senior managers visiting families through pre-arranged appointments to find out unmet needs. They seize the opportunity quickly because competition will occupy that slot if they hesitate.
π‘ Why this matters: Clarity on these two factors is a prerequisite to understanding expansion opportunities. In-depth analysis reveals blank areas in customers' beliefs, and knowing the customer's point of view strengthens strategic decisions.
Summary β Brand-Based Customer Model, Lecture 14 Through Here
A brand-based customer model is about creating, maintaining, and leveraging your brand by keeping the focus on customers. Stay close to the customer and make the customer the basis of all branding decisions. Seek customers' perspective of competitors' products, assess your brand vis-Γ -vis competition, keep it current through innovations, maintain the pinnacle of the brand value pyramid, and identify unmet needs for expansion.
Positioning
An understanding of the category and competition leads to developing positioning for our brand. Positioning is very central to having the right strategies for brand management and business goals. Positioning is an approach to communication that solves communication problems by highlighting very special features of your brand.
Product Era
Positioning started in the product era in the 1950s. New technologies and innovations led to new products and variations. Advertisers talked about differentiated features straightforwardly. This was the time of USP β Unique Selling Proposition. With technology reaching high levels across categories, the level of innovations decreased, leading to many "me-too" products, marking the end of the product era.
Image Era
Advertising experts changed strategy, marking the image era. The thinking was to talk of image, and the consumer would pay attention. If me-too products killed the product era, me-too companies killed the image era. Communication increased exponentially, leading to over-communication.
The Positioning Era
The two authors of the concept believe you have to touch base with realityβwhat is already in the mind of the prospect. Creativity for its own sake does not help. Creating something that doesn't already exist in the consumer's mind is very difficult. The thrust of positioning is to do something effectively with what already exists in the prospect's mind and capitalize on it. The basic approach is not to create something new, but to manipulate what is already there and retie existing connections.
As a defense against over-communication, the mind rejects a lot of information and accepts only what matches or complements prior knowledge. The only defense mechanism is an oversimplified mind. Marketing people should ignore the sending side and work with the receiving sideβthe prospect's mind. Concentrate on perceptions and simplify the process.
π Definition β Positioning: It is not something you do to the product. It is something you do to the prospect's mind. You position the product in the mind of the prospect.
How Positioning Works
Positioning works best when you emphasize on things that are not. If you introduce chewing gum for health-conscious people, you position it as "sugar-free"βmeaning it is not sugar. The first car was advertised as the "horseless" carriageβit had no horse, positioning it against the transportation of the time. This highlights the differentiated feature by talking of something that is not there but is in the prospect's mind. Things-that-are-not can also be found in areas other than the basic product itself.
π Formula: Emphasize "things that are not" β Manipulate what already exists in prospect's mind β Position the product effectively
π Example: A low-price item can be positioned from a price point of view as "not a high-price item." Improving distribution with a new product can position it as having hassle-free distribution.
An Important Factor
The most important thing is that you have to be the first one to get into the consumer's mind with the position you want occupied. Market research from the customer-based model helps identify areas of growth and unmet needs. You must take the lead, start talking of the unmet need(s), and be the first to get into the minds of the prospects.
β Key Takeaways
The brand-based customer model requires staying close to customers through structured or informal contact to identify unmet needs and opportunities for growth before competition seizes them. Positioning evolved from the product era (USP) through the image era to the positioning era, where the key is to manipulate what already exists in the prospect's mind rather than creating something new. Positioning is not about the product but about the prospect's mind, and it works best by emphasizing "things that are not" to highlight differences. The most critical factor is being the first to occupy the desired position in the consumer's mind, which requires acting quickly on insights from customer research.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two factors that must be clarified when assessing opportunities for growth and expansion in the brand-based customer model?
- How did the product era and the image era each come to an end, and what problem did they create for marketers?
- What is the basic approach of positioning according to Ries and Trout, and how does it differ from previous advertising strategies?
- How does emphasizing "things that are not" work as a positioning strategy, and what example from the lecture illustrates this?
- What is the single most important factor for successful positioning, and how does it relate to the brand-based customer model?
π Lecture 17 β POSITIONING
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of brand positioning and what constitutes a strong market position. It explains how competition drives customers through a comparison and selection process governed by four fundamental questions, and provides a clear definition of positioning with its three primary components.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the properties of strong positioning, including the need for a unique valued place in customers' minds and benefits that make a brand stand apart. It discusses four fundamental positioning questions addressing brand purpose, target audience, usage occasion, and competitive context. The lecture defines positioning as a concise statement summarizing a brand's promise and advantage, and examines three components through an example positioning statement and map.
π Lecture Summary
Strong Positioning
A strong brand position means a brand has a unique, credible, sustainable, and valued place in customers' minds. It revolves around a benefit that makes the brand stand apart from competition. Positioning provides focus for organizational resources and is externally driven, meaning it must be owned by customers. Good positioning opens new avenues for brand leveraging and is the key determinant of operational strategies that form a company's strategic direction.
Through positioning, you distinguish your brand by communicating its distinctive characteristics. The prospects already have a picture in their minds, and you capitalize on that. For a new brand, you must create a unique position and communicate it by being the first to start the communication process and keep communicating until you have created a position in customers' minds.
What is different about your brand appeals to customers, resulting from an analytical process based on four fundamental questions:
-
A brand for what? This refers to brand promise and the benefit. For example, an orange drink having real orange pulp can be positioned by claiming that benefit against no-pulp, which is the market norm.
-
A brand for whom? This refers to the target segment. It is important to understand the category in absolute clarity and the segments it consists of. You position your brand for the right target segment and not others.
-
A brand for when? This refers to the occasion when the product will be used. For example, if you introduce milk with features offering special benefits to tea drinkers, you position that milk for that purpose and communicate with tea drinkers not to deny themselves the benefit of enjoying the best milk good tea deserves.
-
A brand against whom? In the competitive context, this explains competitors from whom we expect to capture business.
Positioning means that all consumer choices are based on comparison and a selection process defined by these four questions.
π Definition β Positioning: "It is a concise statement that summarizes brand's commitment or promise to target consumers and actively communicates the advantage over competing brands."
π‘ Why this matters: These questions help position a new brand by making the brand's contribution obvious to consumers in a competitive marketplace.
Definition
Going by the definition, positioning has three primary components:
- The component of company business
- The component of target market
- The component of point of difference and key benefits
Understanding of components through an example
Let's develop and discuss the positioning statement of a fast food set-up:
"Brand XYZ seeks to be perceived as top quality player in the area of fast food of international standards. It intends to sell price-effective, high-quality, cold gourmet sandwiches delivered free primarily at lunch time."
XYZ is talking about company business, the category, and promising its target market fullest value for their money through differentiated features, while fulfilling three fundamental determinants of consumer purchase:
- Affordability - A
- Quality - Q
- Accessibility - A
π Formula: A-Q-A Framework β Consumer purchase is determined by Affordability, Quality, and Accessibility
π Example: The positioning map shows a gap between low and high quality at various price points. XYZ fills this gap by offering high-quality sandwiches at a price-effective (low) price, creating a unique position where no other competitor exists.
Clarity about business
To understand the components better, consider these questions:
-
What exactly is the category and who are the players? Know your competitors, assess their roles, and understand the category for an accurate definition of your own business.
-
What is the size and growth rate? Refer to industry analysis and see how different players have been playing the game. What have been the growth patterns in terms of the industry, major players, and your own firm?
-
What are the entry barriers? Are there any resource constraints? Is the company fully capable of deploying resources for a comprehensive communication campaign? Without communication, positioning will not come to life.
-
Will the market value our participation? Is there something missing from the market? Are we really going to fulfill a need that genuinely seeks fulfillment? If yes, then the market will definitely value our participation.
-
Are there promises for multi-segment growth? Company XYZ should know from the start that the potential to get into small restaurants (after having started delivery business) offers itself in all its forms, and the company should be formulating moves, adjusting promises and positioning its products in a way that multi-segmental growth becomes its hallmark.
β Key Takeaways
Positioning is a concise statement summarizing a brand's commitment to target consumers and actively communicating advantage over competitors. The four fundamental questions β brand for what, for whom, for when, and against whom β guide all consumer comparison and selection processes. Strong positioning requires a unique, credible, sustainable, and valued place in customers' minds, revolving around a benefit that makes the brand stand apart. The three components of positioning are company business, target market, and point of difference and key benefits. Without communication, positioning will not come to life, and clarity about the category, competitors, entry barriers, and growth potential is essential.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four fundamental questions that govern the consumer comparison and selection process in positioning?
- Name the three primary components of a positioning statement as discussed in the lecture.
- What does the A-Q-A framework stand for, and why is it important in the fast food positioning example?
- Why is communication described as essential for positioning to come to life?
- Explain what is meant by "positioning is externally driven" and why this matters for brand management.
π Lecture 18 β Positioning
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on the components of positioning definition. It focuses on achieving clarity about the target market and clarity about the point of difference. The lecture also examines why the need arises to reposition a brand for considerations of growth and expansion, and the critical ramifications of such a shift.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the second and third components of the positioning definition: clarity about the target market and clarity about the point of difference. It then explores the ramifications caused by a change in positioning, emphasizing the importance of maintaining credibility during growth and expansion. A real-life example of Volvo's unsuccessful shift in positioning is provided to illustrate the pitfalls of mismanaging such a change.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
This lecture continues to discuss the components of the definition of positioning. The first component of "clarity about business and category" having been discussed in the previous lecture, the discussion now moves on to "clarity about target market" and "clarity about point of difference". An effort is also made to discuss why does the need arise to reposition the brand for considerations of growth and expansion.
Clarity about target market
To have clarity about the target market, you must answer several key questions. First, does the market we are trying to reach fall within the target range? The product must have complete compatibility with the likes and preferences of the target market. Creating a taste profile and visual aspects of cold sandwiches by company XYZ in dissonance with the taste of professionals wanting to have sandwiches at lunch time will keep the product out of the range of the target market. The product must look like the one created for the target, it must taste like the one preferred by the target, and it must be priced within a range acceptable to the target. Second, do they consider themselves as part of the target market? Offering cold sandwiches that basically have western taste and looks may not appeal to a working class that does not prefer any side of western culture. Such customers may not look upon themselves as the target for the product being offered to them. Third, are they reachable? The target market must be reachable through the channels that a company may use as a chain of supply. Not having effective distribution in a geographical area will deprive many potential customers of using your product and hence undermine a brand's value. Fourth, will the target market be interested in the point of difference? The question of "a product for whom" is applicable here. Fabricating a driver's cabin on an agricultural tractor may not attract many customers as another feature, for the agriculturists may be looking for something with better application to tilling of land. You have to have complete clarity about the point of difference the prospects are interested in. The positioning of the brand otherwise will not be very effective. Finally, why have they not been approached before? In case the target market has not been approached for features that you may find attractive for them, think about any constraints that may impede your efforts. Working on product features requiring exorbitant investment may not be worth the effort. The objective is to offer value to the customer and also create value for the company to improve profitability. You have to maintain a balance between the two.
π Definition β Target Market: The specific group of consumers most likely to buy a particular product, requiring complete compatibility with their likes, preferences, and price range.
Clarity about point of difference
To have clarity about the point of difference, you must answer several key questions. First, is the key benefit important to customers? Very much in line with the preceding discussion, you have to determine that the key benefit is relevant for the customers. The target market of a small-sized family car may not be interested in benefits offered by sports models. Such benefits may be very attractive, but they are not important to the target customers. Second, can we really deliver it? Does it have any elements of wishes? If the company does not have the capability, due to any given reasons, then the point of difference remains just a wish devoid of reality. Brand managers should not tax their energies on such wishful ventures. Third, can we sustain this point of difference over time? A very important question, it must be asked and answered a lot of times before positioning a brand. Company XYZ has to make it absolutely sure that it can deliver the sandwiches as it promises to its customers. Sustainable ability and effort are more important than the initial enthusiasm to undertake the project. The company must be able to always deliver the way it envisages while defining the position of its brand. Fourth, can we further fortify it? The beauty of creating a position for the brand lies in further fortifying it. Fortification of positioning comes through factors like having a technology edge, quality human resource, and financial resource to name a few. At the same time, the market must offer you the opportunity to involve your resources in fortifying the position of your brand. Entering with a quality product and all the resources in a market that is shrinking may not offer you the opportunity to fortify your brand's position. Finally, where can it place us on the brand value pyramid? Clarity about which stage of the value pyramid the product belongs is important. It enables you to formulate compatible strategic moves to work on the position of the brand.
π Definition β Point of Difference: The unique benefit or attribute that makes a brand stand out from competitors and is important, deliverable, sustainable, and fortifiable.
Ramifications caused by a change in positioning
Subtle (not very obvious) changes are caused to positioning of your brand as and when you grow and expand. The very factor of staying current and contemporary brings such slight changes. You are getting into innovations and raising your standards to keep occupying the brand pinnacle position. A change in features and attributes will and should cause a change in price. An upward change in price is taken for granted. A downward change can also occur due to changing market conditions. You must stay sensitive to any ramifications in terms of segmental changes. If such changes occur, then you must be ready to make adjustments to your communication tactics. Sheer reinforcement of the delivery concept at company XYZ may necessitate new equipment and better logistics. Growth potential will necessitate (part of the vision) putting up of small utility restaurants. It will cause a change in the positioning of the brand, which before the introduction of restaurants is all about delivering free to customers. The company with the induction of restaurants is now attracting customers to its points of sale. This shift may call for a change in positioning, which in turn means adjusting your communication strategies. Adjusting and then strengthening your brand's position becomes an objective, because that brings the brand more and more credibility. This becomes a case of meeting growth with credibility. That is why it is said that positioning is the determinant of key operational strategies. The factors that we have discussed definitely have a bearing on pricing, distribution, and investment strategies as primary strategies and also on a few other associated strategies like location of restaurants and the decision to go or not go for franchising etc. Ramifications of a shift in positioning must be considered very carefully. Credibility must never be lost, for the established position in the mind of the customer has to be not only maintained but fortified, whenever possible. A real life example of a shift in positioning by a major European car manufacturer Volvo explains the phenomenon with authenticity. This maker of cars is known for safety standards. Communication about those features has always been the hallmark of Volvoβs advertising and brand contract to maintain that particular position of safety. The maker decided to change the position to high-performance cars instead of maintaining the position of intelligent design with focus on safety features. It was such a departure from the original position that prospects could not accept that information on high performance. Their over-simplified mind had safety features as the established position occupied by Volvo. A sudden departure from the original position to the one adopted made the prospects think the company probably had compromised the safety features. The shift in positioning was not managed with credibility. Sales dropped!
π Example: Volvo's shift in positioning: The car maker, known for safety, tried to reposition as a high-performance car. This drastic departure from its established position of safety made customers believe safety had been compromised, leading to a drop in sales. The core lesson is that a repositioning shift must be managed with credibility.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture defines two critical components for effective positioning: clarity about the target market and clarity about the point of difference. For the target market, a brand must ensure the product is compatible, the customers see themselves as the target, they are reachable, they are interested in the point of difference, and any constraints for approaching them are considered. For the point of difference, it must be important to customers, deliverable by the company, sustainable over time, fortifiable through resources, and must place the brand on an appropriate stage of the brand value pyramid. A change in positioning, often necessitated by growth, has major ramifications for pricing, distribution, investment, and communication strategies, but must never sacrifice brand credibility. The Volvo example serves as a critical warning that a poorly managed shift in positioning can lead to customer confusion and declining sales.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five key questions a brand manager must ask to achieve "clarity about the target market"?
- What are the five key questions a brand manager must ask to achieve "clarity about the point of difference"?
- Why is it critical to ask if a point of difference can be "sustained over time" rather than just delivered initially?
- According to the lecture, what is the most important factor that must not be lost when a brand undergoes a shift in positioning?
- What was the specific error Volvo made when it tried to change its brand positioning from safety to high-performance cars, and what was the result?
π Lecture 19 β Positioning β Guiding Principles
π Overview: This lecture presents five guiding principles for repositioning and maintaining an established brand position. It explains how to assess whether a current position needs updating and provides a structured framework using five criteria: value, uniqueness, credibility, sustainability, and fit. The lecture also covers how positioning drives strategy, the role of senior management, and the importance of employees in bringing positioning to life through internal marketing.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers five guiding principles for brand positioning: updating your position as necessary using five criteria (value, uniqueness, credibility, sustainability, fit); ensuring brand positioning drives all brand strategies; requiring senior management to lead the charge; recognizing that employees bring positioning to life; and using the AUDIENCE acronym for internal marketing to maximize positioning effectiveness.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
This lecture is devoted to the guiding principles, as Scot Davis puts them, relating how to reposition and maintain an established position. Five principles are discussed.
1. Update your position as necessary
Before updating positioning, one must take a look at the present position to see if it is still relevant to the target audience, fulfills needs, customer shifts, market dynamics, and company goals. Generally speaking, the moment you realize that there are unmet needs, you must start thinking about re-positioning the brand. According to Davis, it takes about three to five years to change the position. There are five different criteria to judge if there is need for updating.
Value
Does the target market value our positioning? To realistically assess, ask: Do customers feel motivated to buy? Any drop in sales indicates a drop in motivation. Do they really prefer over competition? Continued preference indicates no change needed. Do they really feel getting benefits? A change in perception about benefits signals time for study. Do they feel their needs are being met? This requires finding out any unmet needs from evolving changes. Does the market allow us to charge a premium? If the brand is at the pinnacle, it should enjoy price premium. Does the positioning cut across segments? A strong position takes the brand into multi-segmental situations.
Uniqueness
Does the position make our brand unique and exclude competition? The moment customers stop considering our brand as unique, we should cause a shift. Ask: Do customers consider our brand positioning as something really unique? Does our brand really offer a unique value proposition? Research should determine if customers still perceive the USP. Do customers immediately recall our brand when we tell them the position? If not, the brand has lost uniqueness.
Credibility
Is our brand positioning credible in the marketplace? Credibility comes with keeping the brand contract while innovating to stay current. Ask: What must be done to make our positioning credible? Analyze promises made and delivered. Are there competitive brands that are as much credible? If so, offer even higher value through other marketing mix variables. Is the positioning credible enough to let management commit financial resources? An exceptionally strong positioning should allow more resource commitment.
Sustainability
Can we sustain the position for a long time? Uniqueness of the selling proposition brings sustainability. Ask: Is it that we can no longer sustain the position? If others are catching up, introduce newer features. Is it that needs and wants will remain the same? Japanese cars shifted from fuel efficiency positions to environment-friendly technologies; Toyota and Honda's hybrid models are excellent examples of sustaining positions with credibility. Is it that the position might be copied quickly? Shift either by increasing value or repositioning competition. The ice cream clash between Yummy and Wall's centered on Yummy's claim that its ice cream was not non-dairy, meaning Wall's was. Why do we need to sustain the position internally and externally? A company must be clear about internal mobilization and sensitive to customer-driven marketing.
Fit
Does it have a perfect fit with the organization? No matter how attractive, a position is not worthy if it lacks fit. Ask: Does it promise fulfilling our goals? Positioning stems from understanding the category, segmentation, and differentiation, and must flow from strategic vision. Does it have the potential to fill the growth gap? Good positioning contributes to filling the growth gap. Will it really enhance value and profitability? If not, changes are required.
π‘ Why this matters: These five criteria β value, uniqueness, credibility, sustainability, and fit β provide a systematic diagnostic tool to decide whether to maintain or change a brand's position.
π Definition β Brand contract: The set of promises made and delivered by a brand to its customers. π Formula: (Value + Uniqueness + Credibility + Sustainability + Fit) = Decision to maintain or change position π Example: For a tea brand sustaining its position on color, aroma, and taste from a special variety and blending expertise, knowing that competitors find it hard to follow doubles confidence that the position can be sustained.
2. Brand positioning should drive all brand strategies
As long as the company has thrust on free delivery, its strategy will be to have a credible delivery system in place. The moment growth necessitates branching out into restaurants, the strategy changes to highlight presence through utility restaurants while supplementing the existing delivery system. A changed position in response to growth and expansion causes changes in strategies. The job of managers is to ensure that change takes place with credibility and no disturbances.
π Definition β Strategy driven by positioning: The brand's position determines the marketing strategies required to deliver on that position. π Example: A fast-food restaurant positioning on free delivery must build a credible delivery system; when it shifts to restaurant expansion, strategy changes to highlight physical presence while maintaining delivery.
3. Senior management must lead the charge
Total commitment on part of the management is essential. They must prove their support is based on sincerity to the brand, setting an example for the rest of the company. Their support to strategies will mark their commitment to those strategies and goals, and others will follow.
4. Employees bring positioning to life
Despite being externally driven, positioning has to be internally sold to all employees. Internal and interactive marketing is required to bring everyone on the same wavelength. All employees must become brand ambassadors and work for bringing the positioning to life internally first and externally later.
Scot Davis puts the requisite internal marketing in an effective way by coining the acronym AUDIENCE. It stands for awareness, understanding, direction, inspiration, engagement, naturalness, criteria, and education.
AUDIENCE:
- A: Awareness: All in the company should be able to clearly state brand positioning.
- U: Understanding: They must understand why the positioning was chosen and how it affects daily operational routines. If positioning is about consumer-friendly pricing, all must be sensitive to achieving cost efficiencies. If positioning is about high quality, all must pay attention to creating it from purchasing to production to logistics.
- D: Direction: Provides a sense of direction in standardizing operations and service standards. The standards make it easy to deliver the promise and lay foundation for quality management.
π Definition β AUDIENCE: An acronym for Awareness, Understanding, Direction, Inspiration, Engagement, Naturalness, Criteria, and Education β the elements of internal marketing to maximize positioning. π‘ Why this matters: Internal marketing through AUDIENCE ensures employees become brand ambassadors who consistently deliver the brand promise.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that repositioning requires evaluating five criteria: value (do customers value the position), uniqueness (is it distinct from competition), credibility (can promises be delivered), sustainability (can the position be maintained long-term), and fit (does it align with organizational goals). Positioning must drive all brand strategies, and when a brand's position changes, all corresponding strategies must change accordingly. Senior management must lead with total commitment and sincerity to set an example for the organization. Employees bring positioning to life through internal marketing, and the AUDIENCE acronym (Awareness, Understanding, Direction, Inspiration, Engagement, Naturalness, Criteria, Education) provides a framework for maximizing positioning internally before externally.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five criteria to judge if a brand's position needs updating?
- How does uniqueness contribute to sustainability of a brand's position?
- What does the acronym AUDIENCE stand for, and why is it important for brand positioning?
- Why must senior management lead the charge in brand positioning changes?
- How does a change in brand positioning drive changes in brand strategies?