π Lecture 32 β CUSTOMER RESPONSE HIERARCHY
π Overview: This lecture explores the importance of understanding customer response effects generated by communication campaigns. It explains the hierarchical model of awareness, comprehension, intention, and action, and discusses how brand managers can use this framework to develop effective brand-based communication strategies. Understanding these principles is critical for creating campaigns that drive customer behavior.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the customer response hierarchy (CRE) model showing how target customers move from awareness to action with diminishing response rates at each stage. It then introduces four guiding principles for a brand-based communication strategy, including using all communication tools, leveraging brand picture and positioning, integrating marketing communications, and executing across the organization. Two case studies (Ray-Ban and BMW) illustrate how companies applied these principles to overcome market challenges. Finally, the lecture addresses the question of budgeting and methods of resource appropriation.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
This lecture examines the importance of understanding response effects generated by a communication campaign. The understanding of these effects in relation to developing a strategic communication framework is important. The principles that come into play while creating a brand-based communication strategy will be discussed.
Awareness and comprehension β basic denominators
Regardless of the model, the starting point of any campaign is creation of awareness followed by comprehension. Unless awareness is created and comprehension developed, message cannot be reinforced and, hence, communication objectives cannot be fulfilled.
Customer response effects β CRE
Communication evokes a hierarchical set of customer response effects. Building awareness, comprehension, intentions, and actions are all steps in ascending order of the hierarchy. The graphic explanation shows that all those aware of the brand may not translate that awareness into an action to buy. As you move along the ascending order of the hierarchy, you see less and less target customers responding to the hierarchical effects. If the target population consists of 100 customers, then 75 of them (75%) are aware of the brand. Of those aware, 80% comprehend (60 customers). Of those who comprehend, 70% intend to buy (42 customers). Those who take action to buy are about 90% of that 70% who intended to buy, which is approximately 38 customers.
π Definition β Customer Response Effects (CRE): The hierarchical set of effects (awareness, comprehension, intention, action) that communication campaigns aim to generate in target customers, with diminishing response rates at each successive stage.
π Example: With 100 target customers: 75% (75) become aware β 80% of aware (60) comprehend β 70% of those who comprehend (42) intend to buy β 90% of those who intend (38) take action to buy.
π‘ Why this matters: This model shows that not all aware customers will buy, so brand managers must work to convert customers at each stage of the hierarchy.
It is difficult to think of major brands that have done well without communications β advertising in particular. We can make three statements about brand communications:
- Every brand must have some means of communicating with its buyers. The way to talk has to be direct, if not advertising.
- There can be many other ways apart from advertising. The message has to be new and interesting.
- All the means of communication and the messages transmitted must be coordinated to make sure they all talk about the same thing.
These fundamentals become the basis of a brand-based strategy for communication.
Brand-based strategy
Four guiding principles to implement the strategy are as follows:
- We have to use a combination of all communication strategies to realize our overall strategy and brand vision.
- We have to use the brand picture and positioning as the guiding force to determine our communication strategies.
- We have to integrate the communication strategies to use the same message and create impact all along the successive stages of customer response effects/hierarchy.
- We have to execute communication strategies all across the organization and create internal involvement for the success of the strategies.
Must couple the principles with hierarchy
These principles along with the understanding of customer response hierarchy give us leads into determining the right strategic framework for our communications. We must be mindful of the stage of the hierarchy that may need our attention. We must then determine the objectives of communication according to the stage of either introduction (awareness) or reinforcement to stimulate comprehension and motivate the final action to buy.
Must reach target customers along the hierarchy
If a marketing communication fails to reach its target customers and create awareness, the successive steps of the hierarchy will not emerge. A business must target its customers at each successive stage of the response hierarchy to improve its performance. Each stage lays the foundation for the next stage.
Example 1 β Ray-Ban Challenge: The sunglasses expert experienced decline as the brand was perceived outdated and too limiting, being too masculine, and hence not very competitive.
The strategy: The Company challenged consumersβ perception by kicking off a campaign with a renewed brand persona and positioning. The persona was created that of modern, intelligent, appealing to all, and hence confident products.
The result: The contract was delivered not only to men, but also to women and younger customers. The company approached its target market of existing users, non-users, and potential users. Brand resilience brought it back.
Example 2 β BMW challenge: 1997 was the first year that the company lost its number 1 position in the high-performance luxury car market. BMW had no new launches in the pipeline whereas competitors like Mercedes, Lexus, and Infinity had many.
The strategy: BMW being aware of a strong brand picture decided to strengthen/reinforce its existing position with an intensive communication campaign.
The result: BMWβ campaign βUltimate Driving Machineβ brought the car back on top, thus solidifying its strategic position.
The first example of Ray-Ban relates to brand persona and brand extension. The company identified a few gaps (needs) that could have been fulfilled. It created a renewed awareness about extending its line. The BMW example is sheer reinforcement, reminding the targets to act upon something great they were not paying attention to.
Principles of response hierarchy
1. Use all communication strategies to achieve corporate strategy and brand vision All possible tools or a combination of communication tools are to be used to achieve the corporate strategy and brand vision. Since the overall strategy, the vision, and the brand vision are all established already, they give rise to compatible communication strategies. Brand managers must have the managementβs commitment to exercise strategic execution. The amount of time needed to see results depends on the type of the market and the amount of resources employed. It is brand vision that dictates the strategy.
π Definition β Brand Vision: The overarching aspiration and direction for the brand that guides all strategic decisions, including communication strategies.
2. Brand picture and brand positioning help determine the right strategies The image defines the actual associations customers have with the brand, and the persona suggests the personality traits customers think your brand has. If the brand has not been able to evoke the right associations and customers do not rightly understand the persona, then there is a gap. You must fill the gap in order to fill brandβs picture, fulfill its vision, and achieve the intended position.
π Example: HP printers lost their compatible position due to decentralization of the organization and fragmentation of communication strategies. Through research, the company reassured itself of positive associations (innovative, reliable, scientific). It kicked off a campaign emphasizing inventiveness, which was a huge success. The gap between where the brand was and where the company wanted it was closed through centralizing the campaign.
3. Use an integrated marketing communications strategy Experience has shown that advertising and promotions when used together create a compound impact. A mix of all communications has a better chance of achieving synergy. If synergy is to be achieved, then advertising and promotions have to be mutually consistent, so that they can complement each otherβs effect.
π Definition β Integrated Marketing Communication (IMC): A strategic approach that coordinates all communication tools and messages to deliver a consistent, unified brand message across all channels.
Principles of IMC:
- Always look for opportunities to blend various possibilities of communication.
- Ensure that all of them convey the same message, consistently.
- Track all expenditure by product, promotional tools, and relate the observed effects with improvements in future applications.
- Create a philosophy of capabilities and cost effectiveness of each tool.
The question of budgeting
Before budgets could be allocated, you have to carry out situation analysis - where we are and why? This analysis has to be related with objectives - what the brand is aiming for in sales and share? On the basis of these two elements, the communication strategy is crafted. Long term brand building is of utmost importance.
Methods of appropriations
You allocate resources as percent of sales. Some argue this is not good because it gives the impression that sales drive communications, when in reality it is the other way around. But this remains the most popular method of appropriations. Once you have the budget, you must break that into allocations to different tools β advertising, promotions, and any other. The tools must fit well into the brand-based strategies.
β Key Takeaways
Understanding the customer response hierarchy is paramount because it reveals that not all customers who become aware will ultimately take action β brand managers must strategically address each stage. Four guiding principles for brand-based communication strategy are: using all communication tools aligned with corporate strategy and vision, leveraging brand picture and positioning to guide strategies, integrating communications for consistent messaging, and executing across the organization. Case studies of Ray-Ban (brand persona renewal and extension) and BMW (reinforcement) demonstrate how understanding response effects allows strategic adjustments to close perception gaps or remind customers of existing strengths. Budgeting must follow situation analysis and objectives, with the percent-of-sales method being most common though potentially backwards in logic. Effective integration requires that all communication tools work together synergistically to create cumulative impact in customersβ minds.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four stages of the customer response hierarchy, and what percentage of customers typically remain at each stage according to the lecture's example?
- What are the four guiding principles of a brand-based communication strategy?
- How did Ray-Ban use the response hierarchy to address its decline, and what was the outcome?
- Why is integration of marketing communications important, and what are the four principles of IMC?
- What is the most popular method of budget appropriation in communications, and what criticism does the lecture offer about this method?
π Lecture 33 β ADVERTISING
π Overview: This lecture delves into the mechanics of advertising as a vital communication tool. It explains the strategic process of developing advertising, focusing on the concepts of copy and copy strategy. Understanding these fundamentals is crucial for brand managers to effectively communicate a brand's promise and achieve its positioning objectives.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining advertising as a dynamic form of communication that emotionalizes facts to drive sales. It then breaks down the process into two fundamentals: developing and executing advertising. The core of the lecture explains the "copy" of advertising, followed by a detailed exploration of "copy strategy," including its definition, purpose, and components. The responsibility for copy effectiveness is clarified as a shared role between the agency (execution) and the brand manager (oversight). Finally, the lecture lists the factors considered in developing copy and the six key purposes a clear copy strategy serves.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
This lecture examines the mechanics of advertising, described as the most visible and dynamic form of communication. A good advertisement works by emotionalizing facts, turning them into positive feelings that motivate consumers to take action, specifically to buy. The core purpose of advertising is sales, with emotion being the means to that end.
Advertising
The lecture presents two fundamental aspects of advertising: developing advertising and executing advertising. Developing advertising is a strategic process that must originate from the brand picture (present state) and brand positioning (future state). The gap between these two reflects the sales volumes needed to achieve the desired positioning.
Copy is the essential part of advertising, referring to all information communicated to customers. For a TV commercial, this is called a "story board" (SB) , which draws its essence from the copy. The copy must be precise, imaginative, creative, and reflect the brand contract and positioning, while being easy in content and catchy in visual.
π Definition β Copy: All the information that we communicate through the advertisements to our customers, including the story board for TV commercials.
Copy Strategy is the next level, an extension and elaboration of the brand's marketing strategy into the advertising area. It is a long-term document stating the net impressionβthe basic selling idea or end result the brand promises, which is the principal reason for consumers to purchase it over competitors.
π Formula: Copy Strategy = Net Impression (the core promise) + Reason Why (evidence the promise is deliverable) + Brand Persona (character and tone of voice)
Examples of Net Impression:
- For a soap: extra mildness.
- For another soap: superior cleansing cream and softer skin.
- For a detergent: cleaner wash.
Examples of Reason Why:
- For toothpaste: the fluoride ingredient or clove oil.
- For a detergent: high-quality chlorine with unique cleansing, bleaching, and disinfecting properties.
Examples of Brand Persona ("tone of voice"):
- A soap for workers: clean, wholesome, honest, and caring.
- A tea brand: mood atmosphere of leadership, vigor, and vitality (e.g., Tapal tea's TV commercial with a man riding a horse, getting energized).
π‘ Why this matters: The copy strategy defines the core message and personality of the brand's advertising, ensuring consistency and effectiveness over time.
Whose responsibility?
The effectiveness of the copy is the advertising agency's responsibility, but ensuring that the copy is effective is the brand manager's responsibility. The major responsibilities of the brand manager in this area are:
- Define the basic marketing problem and develop the basic copy strategy with the agency's support.
- Gain management approval for the copy strategy.
- Ensure the agency works on longer-range experimental copies for future brand evolution.
- Develop an understanding of the principles of good copy to evaluate submissions effectively.
- A good copy should have: i) attention-getting value, ii) relevance, iii) simplicity, iv) visualizes the story, and v) integrates audio-visual elements for a competitive bite (is effective and cannot be ignored).
- Evaluate the total effectiveness of the commercial and the basic selling idea.
- Not ignore the story board.
- Analyze copy-related research and track competitors' advertising.
Factors considered in development of copy
- The product's appearance, form, and basic performance characteristics.
- The competitive situation and what other brands offer.
- Blind tests, usage and attitude studies, and consumer reaction to the product.
- Marketing experience of the brand and other brands in the field.
What purpose does a copy serve?
A clear copy strategy serves six key purposes:
- Provides continuity, helping the brand stand for something specific in the consumer's mind over time.
- Helps a brand achieve distinctiveness and stature in a competitive market.
- Provides guidance and direction to the agency's creative people, prescribing limits for their imagination.
- Is sufficiently concrete yet flexible to allow for fresh and varied presentations that keep the brand current.
- Provides a common benchmark for the company and agency to evaluate advertising submissions.
- Saves creative time and energy by identifying basic copy decisions that don't need to be rethought constantly.
β Key Takeaways
Advertising is the most vital communication tool, and its success hinges on a well-defined copy strategy. A copy strategy is a long-term document that articulates the brand's net impression, the reason why the promise is deliverable, and the brand's personality or tone of voice. While the advertising agency is responsible for executing the copy effectively, the brand manager holds the critical responsibility of ensuring its effectiveness by defining the strategy, gaining approval, and evaluating submissions. Developing a good copy requires focusing on attention-getting value, relevance, simplicity, visual storytelling, and a competitive bite. Ultimately, a copy strategy brings continuity, distinctiveness, and direction to a brand's advertising efforts.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary purpose of advertising, and how does emotionalizing facts serve that purpose?
- Define "copy strategy" and explain its three core components as described in the lecture.
- Who is responsible for the effectiveness of the copy, and who is responsible for ensuring the copy is effective?
- List at least four of the five principles that dictate a good copy.
- What are two key purposes that a clear copy strategy serves for a brand's advertising over time?
π Lecture 34 β ADVERTISING
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the pre-launch evaluation of advertising campaigns to gauge their potential effectiveness before they reach the consumer. It moves beyond impact assessment to outline a five-point framework for evaluation and then addresses the critical fundamentals of executing an advertising campaign to maximize customer response and build brand awareness.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the evaluation of a new advertising campaign based on five fundamental points: a strong single idea, natural growth of the idea, appeal to self-interest, a custom-made approach, and staying on message. It then transitions to the execution of advertising, focusing on the customer response hierarchy (awareness, comprehension, intention, purchase) and the key factors that influence it, including target market reach, media selection, message frequency, ad copy, and message reinforcement strategies like pulsing and heavy-up.
π Lecture Summary
Evaluating new advertising campaign
This section details a pre-launch evaluation of an advertising campaign, based not on impact assessment but on five fundamental points. A good campaign is built on a strong single basic idea, which is a reflection of the brandβs positioning based on one strong benefit. This selling idea can be based on newness, a solution to a problem, or being thought-provoking. The idea must also show natural growth, capitalizing on the product's inherent virtues that the consumer can readily see. It must appeal to self-interest, allowing the consumer to associate the product with a service to them. The campaign should follow a custom-made approach that is distinctive, memorable, and readily associated with the brand, not competitors. Finally, the execution must not wander off from the main selling idea, sticking to the positioning. A few straightforward miscellaneous considerations include checking if the ad is simple, reflects the product's character, is interesting, takes advantage of the medium, demonstrates its point, and is specific and thought-provoking.
π Definition β Strong single basic idea: The central, benefit-driven concept around which a successful advertising campaign revolves, directly reflecting the brand's positioning. π Example: If a shampoo is positioned for "damage repair," the campaign should not also try to sell it as a volumizing or color-safe product. The single idea is repair, and all ads should reinforce that benefit.
Executing advertising is all about ensuring a high level of customer response effects.
Execution involves ensuring a high level of customer response effects, which are hierarchical: Awareness β Comprehension β Intention β Purchase. The "why-not" factor explores why campaigns may fail to generate the required level of response. A key insight from the accompanying graphic (Figure 41) is that for any level of awareness, the levels of comprehension, intention, and purchase are consecutively lower. Furthermore, as awareness increases, purchase does not increase by the same proportion. Therefore, to achieve a higher level of purchase, a very high level of awareness must first be built. The basic objective of communication is to increase awareness within the target market, not the general public.
π Formula/Model: Customer Response Hierarchy β Awareness β Comprehension β Intention β Purchase π‘ Why this matters: This hierarchy shows that just being known (Awareness) isn't enough; you must move customers through each stage. It also highlights that increasing purchase requires a disproportionately large increase in awareness, making awareness-building the critical first step toward profitability.
Target Market Reach - Media Selection and Customer Awareness
To reach target customers effectively, a brand must have a deep understanding of their media habits. This includes knowing what TV channels, newspapers, magazine sections, and radio stations they consume, their exposure to outdoor media during commutes, and their internet usage. All these factors must be considered before buying a combination of media. The incremental cost of each media addition must be related to the incremental economic benefits it is expected to generate.
Message Frequency and Customer Awareness
After choosing the media mix, the next decision is message frequencyβhow many times to expose the target customer to the message. Too few exposures will fail to make inroads into memory. The right frequency must be decided to make the message meaningfully effective. This can be a βconcentrated communication strategyβ (e.g., for seasonal products) or a βdistributed communication strategyβ (e.g., for products that sell year-round).
Ad Copy and Customer Response
The ad copy plays a crucial role in creating awareness and comprehension. It is essential to ensure the message is rightly received and interpreted by the customer. One approach is to test the copy before launching a nationwide campaign, especially for TV commercials. Fragmented media provides an advantage for such testing. Ad copy is most effective when it is based on real customer needs and situations familiar to them.
Message Reinforcement
Communication must be continuous, repetitive, and reinforcing; otherwise, awareness, comprehension, and intention will diminish. This is why advertising for soaps, ice cream, and cell phones runs year-round. Maintaining high awareness is expensive. One approach is βpulsingβ, which uses alternating exposure periods to maintain a base awareness and reduce copy wear-out. Another approach is βheavy-upβ for seasonal items, where message frequency is increased before and during high sales periods.
π Definition β Pulsing: An advertising strategy that uses alternating periods of high and low (or no) advertising exposure to maintain a base level of awareness throughout the year while avoiding "copy wear-out." π Definition β Heavy-up: An advertising strategy that dramatically increases message frequency for a specific, limited period, typically before and during a product's high sales season.
β Key Takeaways
For the exam, remember that a successful advertising campaign is built on a single, strong idea that grows naturally from the product's character and appeals to consumer self-interest. The execution must be custom-made and never wander from the main positioning. Understanding the customer response hierarchy (Awareness β Comprehension β Intention β Purchase) is critical; you must build disproportionately high awareness to drive purchase. Effective execution requires careful selection of target market reach and media, determining the right message frequency, and using reinforcement strategies like pulsing and heavy-up to maintain awareness over time.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five fundamental points for evaluating an advertising campaign before its launch?
- According to the customer response hierarchy, what is the relationship between a high level of awareness and the resulting level of purchase?
- What is the difference between a "concentrated communication strategy" and a "distributed communication strategy" in terms of message frequency?
- Define the advertising reinforcement strategy called "pulsing." Why is it used?
- Why is it more important to focus on target market awareness rather than general public awareness when executing an advertising campaign?
π Lecture 35 β SALES PROMOTIONS
π Overview: This lecture explores the critical role of sales promotions in complementing advertising to drive consumer action. It emphasizes that promotions create the necessary "push" to convert awareness and comprehension into actual purchases, and examines both trade-directed and customer-directed promotions, along with their effects and strategic considerations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture examines the role of sales promotions as a complement to advertising, explaining how promotions create a "push" effect to drive consumer action. It covers the allocation of promotional budgets between trade and customer promotions, the importance of involving sales staff, and the main types of customer-directed promotions. The lecture also analyzes the key effects of promotions, including short-term sales increases, potential unprofitability, the importance of short duration, and the risk of brand devaluation.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
For communication to be effective, it is important to rely on more than one tool. Promotions complement advertising to create the desired effectβthe final action of the consumer to buy.
Sales promotions
No matter how good the copy and the response effects like awareness and comprehension, they may still not actuate the target customers to go for the action. It is there that the role of promotions comes in. It becomes essential, especially in case of new products, to have those products tried by the customers so that they can know the benefits the brand offers. In other words, advertising does its part by creating awareness and comprehension that form a level of customer pull.
Having created the pull, you then have to create a push so that the pull-and-push effect results in the desired action. To create that push, you have to involve intermediaries. Without their help, marketing communication programs will not succeed. According to one estimate, one-third of communication budgets are spent on advertising and two-thirds on promotions. Of promotions, 37% is spent on channel intermediaries and 63% on customer promotions. Push communications are directed toward channel members (37%) so that they have an incentive in carrying stocks and making sure there are no stock-outs. The second step toward the push is customer incentives (63%) that actuate the customers to test the product either as frees or through other inducements.
In other words, just like we created a media-mix in terms of advertising, we again have to create a promo-mix in order to ensure the desired action on part of the customer.
π‘ Why this matters: The pull-and-push mechanism is fundamental to understanding how promotions work in concert with advertising to drive sales.
Promotions β trade-directed
The reason it costs to involve traders in the promo game is because they know their role and power. While you offer something to customers, the retailers expect something to themselves also, for they are stocking your product more than the normal levels in the hope that push will work. You may also need extra space or prime space in order to make your promo-based offerings stand out for the customers not to miss those. For that, you have to offer some incentives to retailers to do what you want.
Involvement of sales staff
Involvement of your sales staff is of high importance. They were involved while you were building the brand picture. You also involve them while you review the picture. Being close to the customers and trade, the sales people understand the market better than anyone else, and hence, must be involved in working out the levels of discounts and incentives. They understand the purchasing criteria and the overall process through which not only customers, but also traders go. Keep them involved amounts to keeping everyone in the company close to reality. Relationship marketing takes on an added importance here. Sales people take on the role of customer relationship managers as well.
Promotions β customer-directed
Such promos are on the increase. The main types used are:
- Store price reduction
- Multi buy/Multi-save
- Additional quantity in pack
- Manufacturerβs price reduction
- Coupons
- Rewards and gifts
- Free items (sampling)
Involvement of sales staff becomes important here also. Extremely important here for brand managers is to stay in close coordination with sales and finance. Working out accounting modalities while promotions are to start is important to keep records straight. Let sales people inform members of the channel through company circulars about the campaign.
Effects of promotions
1. Promo increases sales in short-term According to one source, the elasticity (the increase in sales as a result of a certain expenditure on promotions) of sales to promotions is much bigger than that of advertising. It is 20 times as much. This doesn't mean that every promo is successful. But, a well chosen and well planned promo certainly increases sales in the short term. The effect of promo is, therefore, short lived. It may not last beyond the period of activity. The period after that may see a drop in sales, for customers buy in excess of their requirements. This is what can be termed as "borrowed sales syndrome" β borrowing high sales from future at a certain point in time and then seeing a drop at a later stage.
π Definition β Borrowed Sales Syndrome: A phenomenon where promotions cause customers to buy in excess of their current requirements, borrowing future sales, which leads to a subsequent drop in sales after the promotion period.
2. Promos may be unprofitable All promotions cost money. They definitely cut into your contribution margins, leaving the company less profits. When you add the costs of disrupted production schedules, distribution and logistics, the net effect may well take you into a loss situation. Businesses, according to one argument, exchange profits for volumes, which may slide immediately after the promo is over. You must see to it that promos do not land you in a loss situation.
3. Duration should be short Duration should be short and promos should not be repeated too often, giving the consumer the feeling that your brand is not worth regular purchasing and needs crutches all the time to sell. Instead of the fact that brand should generate value by charging premium, which must be central to its core, it devalues itself if subjected to prolonged or very frequent promotions. You have to be careful about the response effect stage, determine your goals, and then see how best you can create customer value by also ensuring profitability for the company in the long run. The devaluation occurs all the more so because promos are easy to imitate by competitors. Imitation leads to a cycle of escalation and eventually to price war. The whole category suffers and the brands are reduced to commodities with no winners.
π‘ Why this matters: Frequent or prolonged promotions can erode brand equity, turning a differentiated brand into a commodity competing only on price.
4. Other Effects Promos, though expensive, have a lot of power to do good things to brands. Getting a brand trial in itself is an achievement. If the product is good, then consumers will hook on to that. In other words, it depends on the brand what promise it carries and how it delivers that. Brand with a good contract along with other factors of marketing-mix will do well if promoted sensibly. Marketing people should relate the extra expenditure with the extra volume that can offset the expense.
Summary
Effective consumer promotions drive traffic, enhance awareness, increase trial, and build the brand. All you need do is be very clear about your objectives and goals, which are to gaining and keeping customers, and enhance brand's image instead of focusing on cutting price.
β Key Takeaways
Sales promotions are essential for creating the "push" that turns consumer awareness into actual purchase, with budgets typically two-thirds allocated to promotions and one-third to advertising. A crucial distinction exists between trade-directed promotions (37% of promo budget, incentivizing channel members) and customer-directed promotions (63% of budget, including price reductions, multi-buys, coupons, and sampling). However, promotions carry significant risks: they primarily increase short-term sales but often suffer from the "borrowed sales syndrome" where future sales are pulled forward, they can be unprofitable by cutting into contribution margins, and if used too frequently or for too long, they devalue the brand and can trigger price wars. The strategic key is to use promotions to build the brand through trial and enhanced image, not as a crutch for price-cutting.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "pull-and-push" effect, and what role do promotions play in it compared to advertising?
- According to the lecture, what percentage of communication budgets is spent on promotions, and how is the promotion budget split between trade and customer promotions?
- Explain the "borrowed sales syndrome" and why it is a risk of promotions.
- Why is it important to keep the duration of promotions short and avoid repeating them too often?
- What are the four main effects of promotions discussed in the lecture, and which one poses the greatest long-term risk to brand equity?
π Lecture 36 β OTHER COMMUNICATION TOOLS
π Overview: This lecture covers communication tools beyond advertising and promotions, including public relations, event marketing, sponsorships, and direct marketing. It explains how these tools complement each other and fit different situations, with particular emphasis on managing negative PR and building long-term customer relationships through direct marketing. The lecture concludes with a summary of how communication brings positioning to life.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture explores public relations including positive and negative PR situations, event marketing and sponsorships as cost-effective promotional tools, direct marketing through catalogs and technological advances, the foundations of one-to-one customer relationships, internal communication and organizational involvement, and concludes with a summary of communication's role in brand management.
π Lecture Summary
PUBLIC RELATIONS, EVENT MARKETING, AND SPONSORSHIPS
Public relations (PR) can generate favorable coverage for your brand in relevant magazines, newspapers, and television shows. You can share your success story, arrange interviews with senior company leaders, or publicize good social deeds done without tangible commercial gains. This strategy brings good publicity and positive attention to your brand. As you increase advertising, your relationship with the media should strengthen, as media outlets generally help clients gain importance, limelight, and promotion. Every brand manager must capitalize on public relations opportunities and serve as the key connection between their company and the media.
π Definition β Public Relations (PR): The practice of generating favorable coverage for a brand through media outlets like magazines, newspapers, and television shows, including positive stories and social deeds.
PR for Negative situations: Not all PR is positive; you must sometimes counter negative situations. The bird flu crisis of 2006 is a key example, where companies in the branded chicken business educated customers about vital facts through both advertising and PR exercises that complemented each other. The fundamental principle in managing crises is to proceed in a planned way. You should develop if-then relationships (contingency plans) and be honest and straightforward in communication with your target market. Straightforwardness is the key to making PR effective in negative situations.
π Example: During the 2006 bird flu crisis, branded chicken companies educated customers through advertising and PR exercises to counter negative perceptions and provide vital facts.
Event marketing: Event marketing and sponsorships are other ways of creating goodwill. You must be well connected in the market not to miss opportunities. When known for undertaking such promotions, many organizations will contact you. Examples include award ceremonies on TV, sponsorships of regular TV programs like cooking shows, and sports events. The positive side is they are economical and cost less than regular TV or high-end print advertising. Brand managers should not get subdued by the event's glamour. The most important question is whether these efforts will reach your target market? The answer lies in planning activities from the standpoint of reaching the target market.
Direct Marketing
This mode of marketing relies on well-structured communications in the form of catalogs. This has been quite popular in Western markets. Lack of time for shopping, coupled with good reputation of direct selling brands, are two factors making this a trustworthy buying method. However, recent technological advances have given this concept impetus, creating what is called "new marketing". What has given the concept strength is its ability to allow businesses to develop a long-term relationship with customers through credible communication.
Businesses have realized that the lifetime value of a buyer is huge compared to a single purchase. Acquiring a new buyer is much more costly, providing businesses a logical reason not to lose that buyer and the "relationship". Technology provides means through the internet to stay in contact with customers and maintain data banks for various research models.
π‘ Why this matters: Direct marketing shifts focus from single transactions to lifetime customer value, making customer retention more profitable than constant acquisition.
Foundations of one-to-one relationship
- Companies must maintain records for each customer showing not only classification data (name, address, demographics) but also responses to previous communications.
- All information about previous purchases should be maintained, including at what price and in response to what offer or communication the purchase occurred. A good database allows managers to analyze down to the individual level in terms of buying behavior, meaning companies can now target individuals or groups accurately.
- Firms can measure the effects of communication campaigns accurately, with ability to improve the database and interpretation methods continuously. Example: company XYZ maintaining data and contacting customers regularly.
- FMCG companies are developing direct marketing models via the internet, experimenting with millions on their lists. Based on these models, they can tailor offers more closely to individuals' known preferences. Direct delivery services offered by restaurants and food chains are excellent examples.
π Formula: Lifetime value of buyer > Cost of one purchase β Cost of acquiring new buyer > Cost of retaining existing buyer β Direct marketing is logical
π Example: Direct sales through catalogues and internet have topped US$500 billion. Even store chains sell through this mode without visible dents to their store sales. Companies specializing in B2C internet sales have databases so large they rent that information to others for research purposes.
Since use is increasing rapidly, many advertisements now contain internet addresses of company websites. This offers new opportunities in a global market. Customers can see products with pricing and details. Depending on purchase value, companies decide whether delivery is free or charged. The delivery responsibility lies with the seller.
The main question remains: with such wide internet access, how many people want to be interactive? Can you see such people on the action stage of customer response effects? What products do they buy and how often? Many surf for fun without buying. The evidence suggests this concept will multiply, but you must plan campaigns integrating all vehicles of communication in line with goals and objectives.
Communicate across the organization and create internal involvement
Unless everyone in the organization knows what you are trying to do with the brand and its communication strategies, the communication either may not fully come to life, or may assume meanings contrary to the brand's promise. Consider operations people not being on the same wavelength as marketing people for sandwiches XYZ. Operations build the promise while marketing deliver it, and they may work at cross-purposes if the promise does not match what the ad copy claims. You must interact with all touch points that brand management has within the company. Education across functional boundaries about your communication objectives in light of your brand's vision is essential.
Building this awareness creates a sense of ownership among all relating to the brand and brand's communication. You will also gain support in areas you may have overlooked, adding meaning to your communication. In developing brand-based communication plans, you must think of every stage of communication a customer has with your brand. Strategies must emphasize all possible encounters the brand will have with the customerβbefore buying, during the sale, and after the sale.
Summary of communication
Communication brings positioning to life and deals with four major strategic elements of brand management:
- Corporate vision
- Brand vision
- Brand promise
- Brand positioning
Different communication tools are available. Advertising and promotions are the most widely used tools; both must complement each other, and you must remember the pull and push properties. When dealing with advertising, follow these fundamentals:
- Copy
- Copy strategy
- Brand-based strategy
You must understand the rules that lay the foundation for developing the right copy in light of all strategic elementsβthe product's basic character, its values, the promises it makes, and why they are deliverable. Following these rules correctly bridges the gap between promise and positioningβthe present and the future. You must also understand the philosophy of customer response effects and then craft your communication strategy in relation to different effects using different tools, which gives the right brand-based strategy.
β Key Takeaways
Public relations can be positive (generating favorable coverage) or negative (managing crises), with the fundamental principle being honest, straightforward communication and contingency planning. Event marketing and sponsorships are economical alternatives to traditional advertising but must be evaluated based on whether they reach the target market. Direct marketing has evolved through technology to enable long-term customer relationships, with companies realizing that lifetime customer value far exceeds single transaction value, making customer retention more profitable than constant acquisition. Foundations of one-to-one marketing include maintaining detailed customer records, purchase history, and the ability to measure campaign effects, while internal communication across the organization is essential to ensure all touch points deliver the brand promise. Communication brings positioning to life through corporate vision, brand vision, brand promise, and brand positioning, with advertising and promotions needing to complement each other while understanding copy strategy, customer response effects, and brand-based strategy.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental principle in managing negative PR situations, and why is it important?
- Why should brand managers not get subdued by the glamour of event marketing, and what is the most important question to ask?
- How has technology changed direct marketing, and what is the relationship between lifetime value and customer retention?
- What are the three foundations of one-to-one customer relationships as described in the lecture?
- Why is it important to communicate across the organization and create internal involvement regarding brand communication?