๐ Lecture 23 โ Management of Quality
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concept of quality in production and operations management, explaining its evolution from craftsmanship to modern strategic approaches. It covers key quality determinants, the philosophies of renowned quality gurus, various dimensions of product and service quality, and the associated costs, providing a foundation for understanding Total Quality Management.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and importance of quality, contrasting American and Japanese industrial philosophies. It traces the historical evolution of quality management from pre-industrial craftsmanship through the contributions of key figures like Shewhart and Deming. The lecture then details the philosophies of seven major quality gurus, outlines eight dimensions of quality for products and services, and provides examples of service quality dimensions.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction
Quality is defined as the ability of a product or service to consistently meet or exceed customer expectations. It is a key determinant of revenue, contrary to the common belief that it is associated with high price. The American industry in the 1970s and 1980s focused on cost cutting and productivity, neglecting quality management, which was the โHoly Grailโ for the Japanese industry. When Japanese manufacturers entered American markets, their superior quality led to increased revenues and productivity, proving that quality is a prime source of profit.
Evolution of Quality Management
- Prior to Industrial Revolution: Skilled craftsmen performed all stages of production, with pride in workmanship and reputation forming the basis for quality.
- Frederick Winslow Taylor: The "father of scientific management" brought back quality by incorporating product inspection and focusing on manufacturing management.
- G.S. Radford: Introduced quality in the product design stage and linked high quality with increased productivity and lower costs.
- 1924 โ W. Shewhart: Introduced Statistical process control charts at Bell Technologies.
- 1930 โ H.F. Dodge and H.G. Romig: Introduced tables for acceptance sampling at Bell Technologies.
- 1940's: Statistical sampling techniques were used for training engineers; the American Society for Quality Control (ASQC, now ASQ) was formed.
- 1950's: The era of Quality assurance/TQC (Deming, Juran, Feigenbaum) changed quality concepts forever.
- 1960's: Zero defects championed by Phillip Crosby, producing the perfect missile for the US Army.
- 1970's: Quality assurance expanded into services like health care, banking, and the travel industry.
- Late 1970s: The concept shifted to a Strategic quality approach, advocated by Harvard Professor David Garvin, focusing on preventing mistakes from occurring altogether.
Quality Assurance vs. Strategic Approach
- Strategic Approach is the superlative form of Quality Assurance.
- Quality Assurance places emphasis on finding and correcting defects before reaching the market.
- Strategic Approach is Proactive, focusing on preventing mistakes from occurring and placing greater emphasis on customer satisfaction.
Quality Guru
The Quality Gurus are recognized as key contributors to quality management:
- Walter Shewhart: Known as the โFather of statistical quality controlโ.
- W. Edwards Deming: Presented 14 points for quality management, focusing primarily on common cause of variation.
- Joseph M. Juran: Famous for the concept โQuality is the fitness for useโ.
- Armand Feigenbaum: Stated โQuality is a total field or total functionโ.
- Philip B. Crosby: Famous for the philosophy โQuality is freeโ.
- Kaoru Ishikawa: Presented the โfish bone diagramโ or โcause effect diagramโ.
- Genichi Taguchi: Advocated robust design for designing products insensitive to change in environment; his contribution was the โTaguchi loss functionโ.
Dimensions of Quality
Customers value a product considering different dimensions. Quality and Operations Managers must understand these customer perceptions:
- Performance - main characteristics of the product/service
- Aesthetics - appearance, feel, smell, taste
- Special Features - extra characteristics
- Conformance - how well product/service conforms to customerโs expectations
- Reliability - consistency of performance
- Durability - useful life of the product/service
- Perceived Quality - indirect evaluation of quality (e.g., reputation)
- Serviceability - service after sale
Examples of Quality Dimensions
For a product (Automobile) and a service (Auto Repair):
- Performance (Product): Everything works, fit & finish. (Service): All work done, at agreed price.
- Aesthetics (Product): Ride, handling, grade of materials used. (Service): Friendliness, courtesy, competency, quickness.
- Special features (Product): Interior design, soft touch, Gauge/control placement. (Service): Clean work/waiting area, Location, call when ready.
- Reliability (Product): Infrequency of breakdowns. (Service): Work done correctly, ready when promised.
- Durability (Product): Useful life in miles, resistance to rust & corrosion. (Service): Work holds up over time.
- Perceived quality (Product): Top-rated car. (Service): Award-winning service department.
- Serviceability (Product): Handling of complaints and/or requests for information. (Service): Handling of complaints.
Service Quality
The dimensions of service quality include:
- Tangibles
- Convenience
- Reliability
- Responsiveness
- Time
- Assurance
- Courtesy
Examples of Service Quality
| Dimension | Example |
|---|---|
| 1. Tangibles | Were the facilities clean, personnel neat? |
| 2. Convenience | Was the service center conveniently located? |
| 3. Reliability | Was the problem fixed? |
| 4. Responsiveness | Was customer service personnel willing and able to answer questions? |
| 5. Time | How long did the customer wait? |
| 6. Assurance | Did the customer service personnel seem knowledgeable about the repair? |
| 7. Courtesy | Were customer service personnel and the cashier friendly and courteous? |
โญ Key Takeaways
Quality is formally defined as consistently meeting or exceeding customer expectations, and its strategic importance is a key driver of revenue and market success, as demonstrated by the Japanese manufacturing dominance. The evolution of quality management moved from inspection-focused approaches to a proactive, strategic approach aimed at preventing defects, with significant contributions from gurus like Deming (14 points), Juran ("fitness for use"), and Crosby ("quality is free"). Product quality is measured across eight distinct dimensions, including performance, reliability, and durability, while service quality has its own set of dimensions like tangibles, responsiveness, and assurance. For the exam, you must be able to define quality, distinguish between quality assurance and strategic approach, correctly attribute a major concept to each quality guru, and list and explain the eight dimensions of quality.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formal definition of "quality" as taught in this lecture?
- What is the key difference between the Quality Assurance and Strategic Approach to quality?
- Which quality guru is famous for the philosophy "Quality is free"?
- List the four of the eight dimensions of quality for a product.
- In the context of service quality, what does the dimension of "Responsiveness" refer to?
๐ Lecture 24 โ Service Quality
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the five dimensions of service qualityโReliability, Responsiveness, Assurance, Tangibles, and Empathyโand how they shape customer perceptions. It introduces the Service Quality Gap Model (SERVQUAL) to diagnose quality problems and discusses quality by design concepts like Taguchi methods, Poka-Yoke, and Quality Function Deployment to improve service operations.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the definition of Moments of Truth and the five Dimensions of Service Quality (RATE). It explains Perceived Service Quality through the Gap between Expected and Actual Service, followed by the detailed SERVQUAL Gap Model (Gaps 1-5). The discussion then moves to Quality Service by Design, including Taguchi Methods, Poka-Yoke, and the House of Quality (QFD). Finally, it covers the Costs of Service Quality with a bank example and a Control Chart for departure delays.
๐ Lecture Summary
Moments of Truth
Each customer contact between the service provider and customer is called a moment of truth. An organization has the ability to either satisfy or dissatisfy customers during these contacts. A service recovery is satisfying a previously dissatisfied customer and making them a loyal customer.
Dimensions of Service Quality
The five dimensions for Service Quality help customers rate and distinguish one service provider from another. Organizations often use a performance measure matrix called RATE based on these dimensions:
- Reliability: Perform promised service dependably and accurately.
- Responsiveness: Willingness to help customers promptly.
- Assurance: Ability to convey trust and confidence.
- Tangibles: Physical facilities and facilitating goods.
- Empathy: Ability to be approachable.
In RATE, R represents Reliability and Responsiveness, A represents Assurance, T represents Tangibles, and E represents Empathy.
Perceived Service Quality
A customer's required service is often not provided primarily because of a gap between Service Quality Dimensions and Service Quality Assessment by the customer. The assessment is based on:
- Word of mouth, personal needs, and past experience.
- Comparison of Expected Service (ES) vs. Perceived Service (PS).
- Three outcomes: Expectations exceeded (ES < PS = Quality surprise), Expectations met (ES ~ PS = Satisfactory quality), or Expectations not met (ES > PS = Unacceptable quality).
๐ Definition โ Perceived Service Quality: The customer's overall impression of the relative inferiority/superiority of the organization and its services, based on the gap between expected and perceived service.
Service Quality Gap Model (SERVQUAL)
The model captures the gaps between service provided and service demanded. The most popular assessment tool is SERVQUAL (SERVICE QUALITY), involving the 5 dimensions of quality and 5 gaps representing the difference between customers' expectations and perceptions.
SERVQUAL Model Gaps:
Gap 1: The difference between actual customer expectations and management's idea or perception of customer expectations. Managers have an internal process-oriented view, making it tough to see things the way the customer does.
Gap 2: Mismatch between manager's expectations of service quality and service quality specifications. To improve this gap, management must first understand exactly what the customer wants.
Gap 3: Poor delivery of service quality. Once specifications are aligned, the next step is to deliver services perfectly during interaction with the customer. Employees responsible for these actions are called contact personnel. Reasons for lack of quality include poor training, communication, and preparation.
Gap 4: Differences between service delivery and external communication with customer. Customers are influenced by what they hear and see about a company's service through word-of-mouth and advertising. The difference between what a customer hears and what is actually delivered represents this gap.
Gap 5: Differences between Expected and Perceived Quality. This gap is directly related to everyone's perception of service quality. If gaps 1 through 4 are closed to a minimum, then gap 5 should follow. The way to close these gaps is through thorough systems design, precise communication with customers, and a well-trained workforce.
๐ Definition โ SERVQUAL: A service quality assessment tool involving a set of the 5 most important dimensions of quality according to customer rankings, along with 5 gaps representing the difference between expected and actual service levels.
๐ Example: When a customer goes into a McDonald's to order a Big Mac, they expect exactly what they are accustomed to getting (a quick, no hassle, tasty big burger). If it takes 15 minutes to get a Big Mac that doesn't have the famous special sauce, the customer's perceived service of McDonald's will plummet.
Quality Service by Design
Quality in the design of services includes four key approaches:
-
Quality in the Service Package: Quality-based service should be offered at the same price. An airline that does not add quality would lose out to its competitors.
-
Taguchi Methods (Robustness): Relate to quality-based methods being able to deliver under all possible environments. If a company cannot offer after-sales service at any particular place, it loses out to competitors.
-
Poka-Yoke: The Japanese word for mistake proof. In services, a simple mistake can have dire consequences. These devices/strategies/mechanisms are used either to prevent the special causes that result in defects, or to inexpensively inspect each item to determine whether it is acceptable or defective.
๐ Definition โ Poka-Yoke: Mistake-proofing methods that prevent defects from occurring or inexpensively detect them in service processes.
๐ Example: A hairdresser giving a wrong haircut cannot be rectified because service is based on the transaction between the service provider and receiver. A Poka-Yoke device could prevent this error.
- Quality Function Deployment (QFD): Also known as the House of Quality. It allows a company to benchmark itself with industry leaders and review its internal operations critically. QFD helps an organization focus on critical characteristics from the viewpoints of customer market segments, company, or technology-development needs.
Classification of Service Failures with Poka-Yoke Opportunities
| Server Errors | Customer Errors |
|---|---|
| Task: Doing work incorrectly | Preparation: Failure to bring necessary materials |
| Treatment: Failure to listen to customer | Encounter: Failure to follow system flow |
| Tangible: Failure to wear clean uniform | Resolution: Failure to signal service failure |
House of Quality Diagram
The diagram shows relationships between Customer Expectations (Reliability, Responsiveness, Assurance, Empathy, Tangibles) and Service Elements, with weighted scores and improvement difficulty rank. It includes comparison with Volvo Dealers.
Costs of Service Quality (Bank Example)
This example shows how a weak design service can incur loss in customer service, leading to revenue loss. Prevention costs are half the detection costs and about 12 to 16% of failure costs.
| Prevention costs | Detection costs | Failure costs |
|---|---|---|
| Quality planning | Process control | External failure: Loss of future business, negative word-of-mouth |
| Training program | Peer review | Liability insurance, legal judgments |
| Quality audits | Supervision | Interest penalties |
| Data acquisition/Analysis | Customer comment card | Internal failure: Scrapped forms, rework |
| Recruitment and selection | Inspection | Recovery: Expedite disruption, labor and materials |
| Supplier evaluation |
Control Chart of Departure Delays
The dimension of Tangibility can be applied to airline services. During winter months in northern Pakistan, flight delays are common. A Statistical Process Control (SPC) chart can identify an Upper Control Limit (UCL) and Lower Control Limit (LCL) to monitor and improve service quality.
The chart shows the percentage of flights on time over time (199 units), with the expected level at 80%, the Lower Control Limit, and an Upper Control Limit calculated as: ๐ Formula:
- UCL = p + 3โ(p(1-p)/n)
- LCL = p โ 3โ(p(1-p)/n)
Where p is the average proportion of flights on time, and n is the sample size.
โญ Key Takeaways
The five dimensions of service qualityโReliability, Responsiveness, Assurance, Tangibles, and Empathy (RATE)โform the core framework for assessing service performance. The SERVQUAL model identifies five critical gaps between customer expectations and actual service delivery, with Gap 5 being the ultimate measure of perceived quality that can only be closed by minimizing Gaps 1 through 4. Quality must be designed into services from the start using Taguchi methods for robustness, Poka-Yoke for mistake-proofing, and QFD for aligning customer needs with operational capabilities. Prevention costs are significantly lower (12-16%) than failure costs, making proactive quality investment far more economical than reactive correction. Statistical Process Control charts with upper and lower control limits are essential tools for monitoring and maintaining service quality over time.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five dimensions of service quality, and what does the acronym RATE stand for?
- Explain how Perceived Service Quality is assessed based on the gap between Expected Service (ES) and Perceived Service (PS).
- Describe each of the five gaps in the SERVQUAL model and how they relate to each other.
- What is Poka-Yoke, and how does it apply to service failures? Give an example from the lecture.
- What is the relationship between prevention costs, detection costs, and failure costs in the context of service quality?
๐ Lecture 25 โ Total Quality Management
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces Total Quality Management (TQM) as a comprehensive philosophy that involves every individual in an organization in a continual effort to improve quality and achieve customer satisfaction. It covers the TQM approach across departments, common criticisms, key elements including continuous improvement and quality at the source, determinants of quality, and the costs associated with quality management. Understanding TQM is critical for aligning organizational strategy with quality goals.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the TQM approach and its departmental implementation, common criticisms of TQM philosophy, the key elements of TQM including continuous improvement (Kaizen) and quality at the source, determinants of quality (design, conformance, ease of use, service after delivery), consequences of poor quality, departmental responsibility for quality, and the costs of TQM including failure costs (internal and external), appraisal costs, and prevention costs. It concludes with the relationship between quality and ethics.
๐ Lecture Summary
The TQM Approach
TQM is a philosophyโa common viewpoint and attitude shared by the whole organizationโthat helps achieve the prime objective of increased revenue and continuous customer relationships by providing quality-based service that fulfills customer needs. The TQM approach identifies roles played by various departments and interfaces; if these are not aligned with organizational strategy, TQM cannot be pursued.
๐ Definition โ TQM Approach: A systematic method to identify departmental roles that contribute to quality and customer satisfaction. ๐ Framework โ TQM Approach by Department:
| Sr.# | TQM Approach | Department |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Find out what the customer wants | Marketing |
| 2 | Design a product or service that meets or exceeds customer wants | Design Dept |
| 3 | Design processes that facilitates doing the job right the first time | Operations Dept |
| 4 | Monitor and Audit (Keeping track of) results | Senior/GM Managers |
| 5 | Extend these concepts to suppliers | SCM / Logistics / Warehouse / Materials |
๐ Example: The marketing department identifies customer needs, the design department creates a product that meets those needs, operations ensures processes are efficient, senior managers monitor results, and the supply chain extends quality concepts to suppliers.
TQM CRITICISMS
TQM Philosophy is often criticized for reasons that show weak implementation or poor management perspective. Common criticisms include: TQM program not linked to overall organizational strategy (a weakness of top management, not TQM); quality-based decisions not attached to revenue or marketing strategies; incomplete planning with no clear cut road map for TQM implementation; rigid and impractical TQM goals; and non-training of employees about TQM philosophy.
๐ก Why this matters: These criticisms highlight that TQM failures are typically due to poor implementation rather than flaws in the philosophy itself.
๐ Example: An organization that sets unrealistic quality targets without training employees or linking quality to revenue will fail to implement TQM effectively, leading to criticism of the philosophy rather than the implementation strategy.
Elements of TQM
TQM is a philosophy whose elements consist of various strategies and tactics including: Continual improvement, Competitive benchmarking, Employee empowerment, Team approach, Decisions based on facts, Knowledge of tools, Supplier quality, Champion, Quality at the source, and Suppliers.
๐ Definition โ Continuous Improvement: Philosophy that seeks to make never-ending improvements to the process of converting inputs into outputs. The Japanese term for continuous improvement is Kaizen.
๐ Definition โ Quality at the Source: The philosophy of making each worker responsible for the quality of his or her work.
๐ Example: A manufacturing plant implements Kaizen by holding weekly team meetings where workers suggest small process improvements, and each worker is trained to inspect their own output before passing it to the next stage.
Determinants of Quality
The determinants associated with quality in general and TQM philosophy in particular are:
- Quality of design: Intention of designers to include or exclude features in a product or service
- Quality of conformance: The degree to which goods or services conform to the intent of the designers
- Quality of Ease of Use: Ease of use and instructions increase the chances but do not guarantee that a product will be used for its intended purpose and function properly and safely
- Quality of Service after Delivery: The degree to which goods or services can be recalled and repaired, adjusted, replaced, or bought backโor reevaluation of service
๐ Example: A smartphone with excellent design features (quality of design) that is manufactured to exact specifications (quality of conformance) but has confusing instructions (poor ease of use) will still result in poor customer satisfaction.
The Consequences of Poor Quality
The common consequences of poor quality are:
- Loss of business: Loss in sales, revenues and customer base
- Liability: A poor quality product or service comes with the danger of the organization being taken to court by an unhappy or affected customer
- Productivity: Loss in productivity as more time is spent in rectifying errors or shortcomings than producing more
- Costs: Increase in costs as a poor quality product is repaired, replaced, or made new
๐ก Why this matters: Poor quality has cascading effects that damage an organization financially and reputationally.
๐ Example: A car manufacturer that discovers a brake defect after delivery faces loss of customer trust (loss of business), potential lawsuits (liability), time spent fixing brakes instead of building new cars (productivity loss), and costs of repairs and replacements (costs).
Responsibility for Quality
The Quality Control Department cannot be held responsible for quality alone. Quality is the responsibility of each and every individual working for the organization. Departments responsible for achieving quality include:
- Top management
- Design Department
- Procurement Department
- Production/Operations Department
- Quality Assurance Department
- Packaging and Shipping Department
- Marketing and Sales Department
- Customer Service Department
๐ Example: In a restaurant, quality depends on top management setting standards, design creating a good menu, procurement sourcing fresh ingredients, operations cooking properly, packaging ensuring proper presentation, and customer service handling complaints.
Costs of Total Quality Management
There is a difference of opinion among experts about how to categorize costs. The three main categories are:
-
Failure Costs โ costs incurred by defective parts/products or faulty services. On average, an organization loses 20 to 30% of its revenue because of poor quality. Failure costs are of two types: a. Internal Failure Costs: Costs incurred to fix problems detected before the product/service is delivered to the customer b. External Failure Costs: All costs incurred to fix problems detected after the product/service is delivered to the customer Of the two, Internal Failure Costs are less painful and help an organization register increase in revenue without compromising its product or service in the eyes of customers or competitors.
-
Appraisal Costs: Costs of activities designed to ensure quality or uncover defects
-
Prevention Costs: All TQM training, TQM planning, customer assessment, process control, and quality improvement costs to prevent defects from occurring
๐ Example: A software company spends $50,000 on testing (appraisal costs) and $100,000 on developer training (prevention costs). If a bug is found before release, fixing it costs $10,000 (internal failure cost); if found by customers after release, it costs $200,000 in patches, customer support, and lost reputation (external failure cost).
Quality and Ethics
Quality is closely associated with Ethics. A good service always fulfills customer needs if it follows ethics in its true spirit. A poorly designed product or service carries liability. Conversely, if the organization follows ethics to manufacture a product or service, it can provide a quality product or service to its customer.
๐ก Why this matters: Ethical manufacturing and service delivery are foundational to qualityโwithout ethics, quality assurance is undermined.
๐ Example: A pharmaceutical company that ethically tests its drugs and honestly reports side effects produces a quality product that builds customer trust, while one that cuts corners risks liability and loss of business.
โญ Key Takeaways
TQM is a philosophy requiring organization-wide commitment, not just a quality control department function. The most critical exam points are: (1) The TQM approach assigns specific departmental roles for quality, from marketing finding customer wants through supply chain extending concepts to suppliers. (2) Common TQM criticisms stem from poor implementation (not linking to strategy, no clear roadmap, untrained employees), not from flaws in the philosophy itself. (3) Key elements include continuous improvement (Kaizen) and quality at the source, where each worker is responsible for their own output. (4) The four determinants of qualityโdesign, conformance, ease of use, and service after deliveryโmust all be addressed. (5) Quality costs fall into three categories: failure costs (internal and external), appraisal costs, and prevention costs, with internal failure costs being far less damaging than external failure costs.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five steps in the TQM approach and which department is responsible for each?
- List three common criticisms of TQM philosophy and explain why these are typically implementation failures rather than flaws in the philosophy itself.
- Define continuous improvement (Kaizen) and quality at the sourceโhow do these two elements differ?
- What are the three categories of quality costs? Give one example of each.
- Why is external failure cost more damaging to an organization than internal failure cost?
๐ Lecture 26 โ Total Quality Management (Contd.)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of Total Quality Management (TQM) by delving into the Six Sigma concept from both managerial and technical perspectives. It covers essential quality tools like the Deming Wheel, seven basic quality tools, statistical process control, and benchmarking, providing a comprehensive framework for achieving and sustaining quality improvements in operations.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers ISO certifications (ISO 14000 and ISO 9000), Six Sigma as a statistical and managerial concept including its team structure and process stages, obstacles to implementing Six Sigma/TQM, criticisms of TQM, basic steps in problem solving, process improvement approaches, the PDSA Cycle (Deming Wheel), seven basic tools of quality, quality circles, and the benchmarking process.
๐ Lecture Summary
ISO Certifications
Quality certifications ensure that an organization has achieved the TQM philosophy. The two popular certifications pursued by organizations are ISO 14000 and ISO 9000. ISO 14000 is a set of international standards for assessing a companyโs environmental performance. ISO 9000 is a set of international standards on quality management and quality assurance, critical to international business.
๐ Definition โ ISO 9000: A set of international standards on quality management and quality assurance, critical to international business.
Six Sigma
Statistically, a process is said to be in Six Sigma stage if it does not have more than 3 or 4 defects per million. Most organizations measure their quality program in terms of Six Sigma. Conceptually, the Six Sigma Program is designed to reduce defects and requires the use of certain tools and techniques. Six Sigma Programs are always directed towards quality improvement, cost cutting, and time saving. They are employed in: Design, Production, Service, Operation management, Inventory management, and Delivery.
The Six Sigma Management characteristics include: providing strong leadership, defining performance merits, selecting projects likely to succeed, and selecting and training appropriate people. The Technical aspects of Six Sigma include: improving process performance, reducing variation, utilizing statistical models, and designing a structured improvement strategy.
๐ Definition โ Six Sigma (statistical): A process state where the process does not have more than 3 or 4 defects per million opportunities.
Six Sigma Team
Six Sigma Teams are formed for the implementation of Six Sigma in true spirit, keeping in mind both managerial and technical aspects. The team hierarchy includes: Top management, Program champions, Master โblack beltsโ, โBlack beltsโ, and โGreen beltsโ.
Six Sigma Process
The Six Sigma Process has various stages; organizations often combine one or two stages for better monitoring and control. Quality Experts normally identify the following 5 stages: Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control (DMAIC).
Obstacles to Implementing Six Sigma (TQM) include the lack of: company-wide definition of quality, strategic plan for change, customer focus, real employee empowerment, strong motivation, time to devote to quality initiatives, leadership, and the presence of poor inter-organizational communication, view of quality as a โquick fixโ, emphasis on short-term financial results, and internal political and โturfโ wars.
Criticisms of TQM
Criticisms of TQM include: blind pursuit of TQM programs, programs may not be linked to strategies, quality-related decisions may not be tied to market performance, and failure to carefully plan a program.
Basic Steps in Problem Solving
The problem-solving method involves analyzing the problem, generating pragmatic solutions, and implementing the best solution. The steps are:
- Define the problem and establish an improvement goal.
- Collect data
- Analyze the problem
- Generate potential solutions
- Choose a solution
- Implement the solution
- Monitor the solution to see if it accomplishes the goal.
Process Improvement
A systematic approach to improving a process will always result in process improvement. Common approaches include: Process mapping, Analyze the process, and Redesign the process.
- Process mapping consists mainly of collecting information about the process, identifying the process for each step, and determining the inputs and outputs.
- Analyze the process: Ask questions about the process, such as if the process flow is logical, if any steps are missing, or if there are duplicate activities. Questions about each step include: Is it necessary? Does it add value? Does it generate waste? Can the time be reduced? Can steps be combined?
- Redesign the process: Takes a fresh approach to solve an issue.
The PDSA Cycle (Shewhart Cycle/Deming Wheel)
The concept of the PDCA Cycle was first introduced by Walter Shewhart. It is often referred to as โthe Shewhart Cycleโ. It was promoted effectively from the 1950s by W. Edwards Deming and is consequently known as โthe Deming Wheelโ. It is a continuous process and enables the operations manager to check the work at various stages. The four stages of the PDCA Cycle are:
- PLAN: Study & Document the existing process. Collect data to identify problems. Survey data and develop a plan for improvement. Specify measures for evaluating the plan.
- DO: Implement the plan on a small scale. Document any changes made during this phase. Collect data systematically for evaluation.
- CHECK: Evaluate the data collection during this phase. Check how closely the results match the original goals of the plan phase.
- ACT: If the results are successful, standardize the new method and communicate it to all people associated with the process. Implement training for the new method. If results are unsuccessful, revise the plan and repeat the process or cease this project.
๐ Definition โ Deming Wheel (PDSA Cycle): A continuous four-stage cycle (Plan, Do, Check/Study, Act) for process improvement and problem-solving.
Seven Basic Tools
The seven basic tools of quality are: Check Sheet, Flow Chart, Histogram, Pareto Chart, Scatter Diagram, Cause & Effect Diagram (also known as a Fishbone Diagram), and Statistical Process Control (SPC).
Quality Circles
Quality Circles use a team approach for problem-solving and include techniques such as: List reduction, Balance sheet, and Paired comparisons.
๐ Definition โ Quality Circle: A team-based approach to problem-solving that involves employees from the same work area who volunteer to meet regularly to discuss and solve work-related problems.
Benchmarking Process
The Benchmarking Process involves the following steps:
- Identify a critical process that needs improving.
- Identify an organization that excels in this process.
- Contact that organization.
- Analyze the data.
- Improve the critical process.
๐ Definition โ Benchmarking: The process of identifying, understanding, and adapting outstanding practices and processes from other organizations to help your own organization improve its performance.
โญ Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must remember that Six Sigma aims for fewer than 3.4 defects per million and uses the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) process. The PDSA (Plan, Do, Study, Act) Cycle, also known as the Deming Wheel, is a fundamental continuous improvement model. You should be able to list the seven basic tools of quality and explain their general purpose. Finally, understand the steps of the benchmarking process and distinguish between ISO 14000 (environmental) and ISO 9000 (quality management) certifications.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the statistical definition of a process being at the "Six Sigma" level?
- List the five stages of the Six Sigma Process (DMAIC).
- What are the four stages of the Deming Wheel (PDSA Cycle)?
- Name three of the seven basic tools of quality.
- What is the key difference between ISO 14000 and ISO 9000 certifications?
๐ Lecture 27 โ Quality Control & Quality Assurance
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of quality control (QC) and quality assurance, focusing on how organizations monitor and maintain process quality. It explains the evolution from simple inspection to building quality into processes, and details the use of statistical process control (SPC) and control charts to distinguish between random and assignable variation in production or service outputs.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the introduction to quality control and assurance, the phases of quality assurance from least to most progressive (inspection before/after production, inspection during production, quality built into the process), the elements of the control process (Define, Measure, Compare, Evaluate, Correct, Monitor results), how control charts are used to monitor a process, the interpretation of control charts (UCL, LCL, sample means), and the use of run tests to check for non-randomness in process output. It also addresses inspection strategies (how much/often, where/when, centralized vs. on-site, variables vs. attributes) and the concept of acceptance sampling.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction to Quality Control and Assurance
Quality Control (QC) is โconcerned with quality of conformance of a process.โ Its prime purpose is to assure that processes are performing in an acceptable manner. Organizations accomplish QC by monitoring process outputs using statistical techniques. A practical QC-based Operations Strategy focuses on the principle of quality in design.
Phases of Quality Assurance
The lecture outlines three progressive phases:
- Inspection Before / After Production: The least progressive approach, often involving Acceptance Sampling.
- Inspection & Corrective Action during Production: A more progressive approach, involving Process Control.
- Quality built into the Process: The most progressive approach, focusing on Continuous Improvement.
Inspection
Inspection is any method, device, or tactic used to minimize defects in products or services. As an Operations Manager, you must answer four key questions:
- How Much / How Often: Determined by cost trade-offs. No inspection is needed for low-value, high-volume items (e.g., common pins), while automated inspection may be necessary for high-value items.
- Where / When: Key points include raw materials/purchased parts, finished products, before a costly operation, before an irreversible process (e.g., pottery, PC chips), and before a covering process (e.g., painting, plating).
- Centralized vs. On-site: On-site inspection is used for large items (ships, nuclear plants), while lab tests (blood tests, material testing) are centralized.
- Whether to inspect Variables or Attributes: Variables are measured characteristics (e.g., weight), while attributes are counted (e.g., pass/fail).
๐ Inspection Cost Graph: The optimal amount of inspection is found where the total cost (cost of inspection + cost of undetected defects) is minimized. As inspection increases, the cost of undetected defects decreases, but the cost of inspection increases.
Quality Control in Terms of Statistical Process Control (SPC)
- Statistical Process Control (SPC): The statistical evaluation of the output of a process during production.
- Quality of Conformance: A product or service conforms to specifications.
- Controllable Characteristics: Only those which can be counted or measured.
- Main Task of QC: To distinguish random variability from non-random (assignable) variability. Non-random variability indicates the process is out of control.
๐ Definition โ Random Variation: Natural variations in the output of a process, created by countless minor factors. Also called common/chance variation. It is inherent and part of the process (e.g., slight differences between old and new machines). ๐ Definition โ Assignable Variation: A variation whose source can be identified and corrected.
Control Chart
A Control Chart is a time-ordered plot of representative sample statistics obtained from an ongoing process (e.g., sample means). Its purpose is to monitor process output to see if it is random. Upper Control Limit (UCL) and Lower Control Limit (LCL) define the range of acceptable variation.
๐ Example: Soft drink bottles are never exactly 250 ML; there are slight differences among the means. A control chart would track these sample means over time. As long as the means fall between the UCL and LCL, the process is considered to have only random variation.
๐ก Why this matters: Control charts are based on the sampling distribution. Theoretically, 99.7% of all sample values will fall within ยฑ3 standard deviations of the mean. We draw lines at this point (UCL and LCL). A sample statistic that falls between UCL and LCL suggests randomness; a value outside suggests non-randomness (assignable cause).
The Control Process
The control process consists of these stages:
- Define
- Measure
- Compare
- Evaluate
- Correct
- Monitor results
๐ Example: If a control chart shows a sample mean above the UCL, you would Define the problem, Measure the current output, Compare it to the control limits, Evaluate the cause (e.g., a worn tool), Correct it (replace the tool), and Monitor the results to ensure the process is back in control.
โญ Key Takeaways
Quality Control is fundamentally about monitoring processes to ensure conformance to specifications, using statistical tools to distinguish between natural random variation and correctable assignable variation. The most progressive quality strategy is not just to inspect but to build quality into the process itself. Control charts are the primary tool for this, with Upper and Lower Control Limits calculated from the process sampling distribution; any point outside these limits signals a potential out-of-control situation requiring investigation. The optimal level of inspection balances the cost of inspection against the cost of undetected defects. For exam purposes, you must be able to explain the phases of quality assurance, the four key inspection questions, and the interpretation of control charts.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the main difference between "random variation" and "assignable variation" in a process?
- What are the three phases of Quality Assurance, listed from least to most progressive?
- A sample mean on a control chart falls above the Upper Control Limit. What does this suggest?
- In the context of inspection, what is the principle behind the "optimal amount of inspection"?
- What is the purpose of a control chart, and what do the Upper and Lower Control Limits define?