π Lecture 13 β CONTINGENT CONTRACTS & PERFORMANCE OF CONTRACTS
π Overview: This lecture covers two major areas of contract law: contingent contracts (contracts whose enforceability depends on the happening or non-happening of an uncertain future event collateral to the contract) and the performance of contracts (how parties fulfill their obligations, including the effects of death, assignment, and offers of performance). Understanding these concepts is crucial for knowing when contractual obligations become absolute and how they are discharged through performance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining contingent contracts under Section 31 of the Contract Act and explains their scope, including the requirement that the contingency be collateral to the contract and a condition precedent. It then discusses enforcement of contingent contracts under Section 32, including when they become void. The second major part covers performance of contracts, starting with the obligation of parties under Section 37, including succession to the benefit of contracts, assignment of contracts, and the consequences of refusal to accept an offer of performance under Section 38. Various illustrations and case examples are provided throughout.
π Lecture Summary
CONTINGENT CONTRACTS
A "contingent contract" is defined in Section 31 of the Contract Act as a contract to do or not to do something, if some event, collateral to such contract, does or does not happen. This means the contract's enforceability depends on an uncertain future event that is not part of the main consideration but is external to it.
π Definition β Contingent Contract: A contract to do or not to do something, if some event, collateral to such contract, does or does not happen.
π Example: M/S ABC Insurance Company contracts with Mr. Z to pay Rupees 500,000 if his car is stolen by thieves. The theft is an event collateral to the insurance contract itself.
π Example: A contract between a client and their counsel regarding payment of agreed professional fee if the suit turns out to be successful.
π Example: A contracts to pay B Rs. 10,000 if B's house is burnt.
Scope of Contingent Contract
The scope has three main elements: (1) The contingency must be collateral to the contract; (2) The contingency must be a condition precedent (it must happen before the obligation arises); (3) A contingent contract leads to absolute obligations and is enforceable only when the event happens or the condition is fulfilled. The condition must be fulfilled completely and absolutely. If the condition in a contingent contract is not fulfilled, the contract is not enforceable.
Contingency Dependent on Act of Party
Words like "if promise amount to no promise at all" apply when their operation depends merely on the promisor's will and pleasureβfor example, a man saying he will pay whatever he himself thinks right or reasonable. However, the operation of a promise may well depend on a voluntary act other than a mere declaration of the promisor's will to be bound. The act may be that of a third person (e.g., a promise to pay what A shall determine is perfectly good). The act may also be that of the promisor himself, so long as it is not an act of mere arbitrary choice whether he will be bound or not, such as in goods sold on approval where the sale is not completed until the buyer has either approved the goods or kept them beyond the trial period.
On the same principle, if a clause in a contract provides that a party's disability to perform his promise shall be a cause for annulling the contract but shall give no remedy in damages, this does not apply to a disability brought about by the promisor's own conduct. A builder's right to recover for his work is often made conditional on the architect certifying that the work has been done properly, and such a condition is good. Conversely, penal clauses may depend not only on some default of one party but on the decision of a person appointed by the other party.
In contracts for sale or letting of immovable property, clauses are commonly inserted giving one or both parties an option to rescind the contract in specified events. In such cases, and where there is a complete active obligation from the first (subject to be defeated by matter subsequent), the contract is not properly called contingent.
π Example: A purchased B's land and leased it to B for six years with a forfeiture clause for failure to pay rent on due dates. It was agreed that if B paid rent regularly, A would reconvey the land to B. B failed to pay rent regularly, and A waived the right of re-entry but cancelled the agreement to reconvey. The court held that waiver of the right of re-entry did not affect the contract of reconveyance, and B, not having performed the condition precedent to his right to reconveyance, was not entitled to specific performance.
Requisites of Contingent Contract Explained
Contingent contracts cannot be enforced unless the contingent event happens. In one case, the appellants did not agree to execute a sale deed, so the contract of sale contingent upon such execution could not be enforced. However, the contention was repelled because the agreement also provided that the respondent shall have a right to obtain a sale deed through specific performance of contract, and thus such suit for specific performance did lie.
Enforcement of Contracts Contingent on an Event Happening: Section 32
Contingent contracts to do or not to do anything if an uncertain future event happens cannot be enforced by law unless and until that event has happened. If the event becomes impossible, such contracts become void.
π Example (a): A makes a contract with B to buy B's horse if A survives C. This contract cannot be enforced unless and until C dies in A's lifetime.
π Example (b): A makes a contract with B to sell a horse to B at a specified price if C, to whom the horse had been offered, refuses to buy him. The contract cannot be enforced unless and until C refuses to buy the horse.
π Example (c): A contracts to pay B a sum of money when B marries C. C dies without being married to B. The contract becomes void.
π Example (d): Yasir contracts with Mr. Aslam to sell his car for Rs 600,000 if Mr. Akmal, to whom he has already made the offer, doesn't buy the said car. This contract cannot be enforced unless Mr. Akmal refuses to buy the car.
Explanation: Some cases may be dealt with under either Section 32 or Section 56 (doctrine of frustration), for it may be equally true that performance of a material part of the contract has become impossible and that the contract was made on a contingency that has become impossible. Whether a contract is of the kind specified in this section may be a question of fact or construction.
π‘ Why this matters: Distinguishing between a contingent contract and an unconditional undertaking determines when and if a party can be compelled to perform. If the document operates as an unconditional undertaking, Section 32 does not apply.
PERFORMANCE OF CONTRACTS
Obligation of the Parties to a Contract β Section 37
The parties to a contract must either perform, or offer to perform, their respective promises, unless such promises are dispensed with or excused under the provisions of the Contract Act or any other law. Promises bind the representatives of the promisor in case of death of such promisors before performance, unless a contrary intention appears from the contract.
π Example (a): A promises to deliver goods to B on a certain day on payment of Rs. 1,000. A dies before that day. A's representatives are bound to deliver the goods to B, and B is bound to pay the Rs. 1,000 to A's representatives.
π Example (b): A promises to paint a picture for B by a certain day at a certain price. A dies before the day. The contract cannot be enforced either by A's representatives or by B (because it is a personal contract requiring A's skill).
π Example (c): Mr. X promises to deliver goods to Mr. Z on a given date against payment of a specified amount. Mr. X dies before the specified date. The representatives of Mr. X shall be bound to deliver the goods to Mr. Z, and Mr. Z shall be bound to pay the agreed amount to the representatives of Mr. X.
Explanation β Performance and Discharge: A contract creates a legal obligation which subsists until discharged. Performance of the promise or promises remaining to be performed is the principal and most usual mode of discharge. When enforceability is dispensed withβfor example, a contract of payment of Rs. one million by B to A on arrival of a ship, and the ship is sunk before arrivalβenforceability is dispensed with.
Succession to Benefit of Contract
Section 37 does not lay down rules about how persons other than the original promisee may become entitled to enforce a promise. Generally, representatives of a deceased promisee may enforce subsisting contracts with him for the benefit of his estate. However, an architect's executor cannot insist on completing an unfinished design (even if he is skilled) because he cannot fulfill the personal conditions for payment. But a builder's executors may be entitled and bound to perform his contracts for ordinary building work because they only need to procure workmen of ordinary competence. All such rules are in aid of the presumed intention of the parties, and if the parties have expressed a special intention, it must prevail.
Payments actually earned and due to a man before his death (though for services of a confidential or personal kind) are part of his estate, and his representatives succeed to his right of action for them. The same rule applies to rights of action for conventional damages or penalties. However, a cause of action for damages for injuries of a merely personal nature, though arising out of a breach of contract, cannot be sued upon by or against executors.
π Key Point: A contract to pay a certain sum of money to a near relative during his life, the consideration being natural love and affection and the document being registered, is enforceable against the heirs of the deceased promisor by virtue of Section 25(1) read with Section 37, unless a contrary intention appears.
Assignment of Contracts
The benefit of a contract can be assigned, but not the burden, subject to the same exception of strictly personal contracts. A debtor cannot relieve himself of liability by assigning the burden to someone elseβthis requires the consent of all three parties and involves the release of the original debtor. On the other hand, the benefit of a contract can be assigned, and whenever the consideration has been executed and nothing more remains but to enforce the obligation, the right to enforce it can be assigned and put in suit by the assignee in his own name after notice.
However, for contracts with mutual obligations still to be enforced (executory contracts), the burden cannot really be assigned, but sometimes it may be discharged by delegated performance (where it does not matter to the promisee what the exact relations of agency are between the promisor and his delegate).
The Contract Act has no section dealing generally with assignability of contracts. A contract which under Section 40 is such that the promisor must perform it in person has been held not to be assignable. When considerations connected with the person with whom a contract is made form a material element of the contract, it cannot be assigned without the promisor's consent.
π Example: A contract for the future delivery of goods (like rapeseed, cotton, or gunny bags) can be assigned while still executory, enabling the assignee to maintain an action in his own name.
An actionable claim is defined in Section 3 as a claim to any debt (except secured debts) or to any beneficial interest in movable property not in the possession of the claimant, whether existent, accruing, conditional, or contingent. An actionable claim can always be assigned, but the assignment must be effected by an instrument in writing. Upon execution of such instrument, all rights and remedies of the assignor vest in the assignee, who may sue in his own name without making the assignor a party.
π Key Point: An option to repurchase property sold is prima facie assignable, but the contract may be so worded as to show it was personal to the grantee and not assignable.
Condition Attached to Contract vs. Contingent Contract
Where a term in a contract of sale states that on registration of the document after taking permission, the defendants would take the balance from the plaintiffs, that condition to take permission is not collateral to the contract but forms part of the consideration. Therefore, the contract cannot be regarded as contingent.
Rule of law: A contract must be brought into existence by at least two parties. Termination of contract, being the converse of its creation, demands that it should not be recognized unless it is what both parties intend.
π Performance of Contract: If the plaintiff fails to prove he was prepared to perform his part of the contract and in fact did not perform it at all, he is not entitled to any relief.
Mutual Obligations in Contract
A contract is considered performed only when the respective obligations have been fulfilled. A contract with mutual obligations cannot be treated as wholly executed until the respective obligations have been discharged. In a contract for the supply of goods, the contractor must make supplies and the other party must make paymentsβuntil payments have been made, the contract is not at an end and liability subsists.
π Insurance Case Example: An insurance company (appellant) undertook to compensate a transport company (respondent) if goods stored in the respondent's godown were destroyed by fire. A fire broke out, and goods were burned. The respondents examined consignees who produced vouchers showing goods and their value. A surveyor appointed by the appellants visited the site two days after the fire, examined actual damage, and estimated loss. The appellants, unhappy with this report, appointed another surveyor after four months but did not produce them as witnesses. The court held that the second surveyor's version was belated, inconclusive, and carried no weight. The claim was proved and the appellants were found liable to the extent of the insurance cover.
Consequence of Refusal to Accept Offer for Performance: Section 38
Where a promisor has made an offer of performance to the promisee, and the offer has not been accepted, the promisor is not responsible for non-performance, nor does he thereby lose his rights under the contract.
Every such offer must fulfill the following conditions:
- It must be unconditional;
- It must be made at a proper time and place, and under such circumstances that the person to whom it is made may have a reasonable opportunity of ascertaining that the person by whom it is made is able and willing there and then to do the whole of what he is bound by his promise to do;
- If the offer is to deliver anything to the promisee, the promisee must have a reasonable opportunity of seeing that the thing offered is the thing which the promisor is bound to deliver.
An offer to one of several joint promisees has the same legal consequences as an offer to all of them.
π Example: X enters into a contract on 1st July 2007 to supply 1000 tons of rice to Y at Y's specified warehouse. X should ensure the specified quantity of rice is available on the due date under such circumstances that Y has a reasonable opportunity to satisfy himself regarding the quantity and quality of the rice.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are: (1) A contingent contract under Section 31 involves a promise conditional on an uncertain future event collateral to the contractβit cannot be enforced unless that event happens, and if the event becomes impossible, the contract becomes void under Section 32. (2) Under Section 37, parties must perform their promises, and upon death, representatives are bound to perform unless the contract is of a personal nature requiring the promisor's special skill. (3) The benefit of a contract can be assigned, but the burden cannot be shifted without the consent of all parties, and personal contracts are not assignable. (4) An actionable claim (debt or beneficial interest in movable property) can be assigned by a written instrument. (5) Under Section 38, an offer of performance must be unconditional, made at a proper time and place, and give the promisee a reasonable opportunity to verify that the promisor can and will perform the whole obligation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of a contingent contract under Section 31, and what is the key requirement regarding the event on which it depends?
- Under Section 32, what happens if the uncertain future event on which a contingent contract depends becomes impossible?
- According to Section 37, are the representatives of a deceased promisor always bound to perform the contract? What exception exists?
- Can the burden of a contract be assigned without the consent of the contractee, and what is the general rule regarding assignment of contracts?
- What are the three conditions that an offer of performance must satisfy under Section 38 for the promisor to be relieved from responsibility for non-performance?
π Lecture 14 β PERFORMANCE OF RECIPROCAL PROMISES
π Overview: This lecture examines the legal framework governing how reciprocal promises are performed under contract law. It covers crucial rules about what happens when a party refuses to perform, who must perform the promise, and how joint liabilities are handled, providing foundational knowledge for understanding contractual obligations and breach remedies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the effect of a party's refusal to perform under Section 39, including anticipatory breach and the promisee's options. It explains who must perform the contract under Section 40, the effect of accepting performance from a third person under Section 41, joint liabilities and their devolution under Section 42, and the time for performance when no time is specified under Section 46.
π Lecture Summary
Refusal by a party to perform under the contract β effect thereof: Section 39
When a party to a contract has refused to perform, or disabled himself from performing his promise in its entirety, the Promisee may put an end to the contract, unless he has signified, by words or conduct, his acquiescence in its continuance.
π Definition β Promisee: The party to whom a promise is made, who has the right to enforce the contract.
π Example (a): A, a singer, enters into a contract with B, the manager of a theatre, to sing at his theatre two nights in every week during the next two months, and B engages to pay her 100 rupees for each night's performance. On the sixth night A willfully absents herself from the theater. B is at liberty to put an end to the contract.
π Example (b): A, a singer, enters into a contract with B, the manager of a theatre, to sing at his theatre two nights in every week during the next two months, and B engages to pay her at the rate of 100 rupees for each night. On the sixth night A willfully absents herself. With the assent of B, A sings on the seventh night. B has signified his acquiescence in the continuance of the contract, and cannot now put an end to it, but is entitled to compensation for the damage sustained by him through A's failure to sing on the sixth night.
π Example (c): Mr. X, a cricket player, enters into contract with cricket board to play 5 tests and 4 one day international matches as per schedule against payment of agreed amount. Mr. X willfully refuses to play in second one day international. The cricket board has a right to put an end to the contract.
Explanation of refusal to perform: No positive general rule can be laid down as to the effect of failure in performing particular terms. The question is in every case whether the conduct of the party in default amounts to an abandonment of the contract or a refusal to perform it, or evinces an intention not to be bound by the contract. The intention which is material is not that with which the contract is broken, but that with which it was made. Parties can make any term essential or non-essential; they can provide that failure to perform it shall discharge the other party or shall only entitle him to compensation in damages.
The section applies when the contract is still executory and the time for performance has not yet arrived. This restricts the section to cases of anticipatory breach or cases of continuing contracts under which obligations remain to be performed, such as installment contracts. Where two transactions are separate, the repudiation of one cannot affect the other.
A buyer who has refused to receive goods on the ground that they were not tendered within the agreed time cannot afterwards change his ground and raise the objection that the goods were not according to contract; for the election to rescind, once made, is conclusive.
An unsuccessful attempt to perform a contract which does not disable the promisor from still performing it effectually within the time limited, or a reasonable time, and does not cause any damage to the promisee, cannot be treated as a refusal.
"Disabled himself from performing" β Disability due to the party's own fault must be distinguished from inability to perform a contract. It is very old law that if a promisor disables himself from performance, even before the time for performance has arrived, it is equivalent to a breach.
"Promisee may put an end to the contract" β The promisee may treat the notice of intention as inoperative and await the time when the contract is to be executed, then hold the other party responsible for all consequences of non-performance. However, in that case he keeps the contract alive for the benefit of the other party as well as his own, and remains subject to his own obligations and liabilities.
Alternatively, the promisee may treat the repudiation as a wrongful putting an end to the contract and may at once bring his action as on a breach of it. In such action he will be entitled to damages subject to abatement in respect of any circumstances affording him the means of mitigating his loss. When the promisee has so determined his choice, it is not open to the promisor to go back on his refusal. Similarly, if he elects not to accept the repudiation, he cannot go back on this election.
Arbitration clause β When a contract is terminated by acceptance of the repudiation, an agreement to refer all disputes to arbitration does not become void.
Measure of damages β The measure of damages for "anticipatory breach" is not necessarily the same as for failure occurring at the time when performance was due. The injured party is under an obligation to take all reasonable steps to mitigate the loss flowing from the breach.
Insolvency of promisor β This is not of itself equivalent to a total refusal to perform the contract, though it may be accompanied by conduct amounting to a notice of intention not to pay debts or perform contracts. A seller, however, is not bound to go on delivering goods to an insolvent buyer.
Contract of sale β Breach β Subject of contract sold away to third party β The repudiating party is not prevented from invoking the arbitration clause in the contract for the purpose of settling all questions to which his repudiation has given rise.
Breach of condition, waiving of β An insurer can waive breach of condition in writing or orally.
Refusal of buyer to pay contract price β Repudiation of contract β If a buyer refuses to pay the contracted price, this amounts to repudiation of the contract, entitling the sellers to put an end to it and claim damages. Once a buyer repudiates the price, it is not necessary for the seller to go about doing things for the performance of the contract. Upon such repudiation, they would be entitled to treat this as an anticipatory breach and put an end to the contract.
Rescission β Repudiation of contract must be total, absolute and clear.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding anticipatory breach and the promisee's options is critical for knowing when you can end a contract and claim damages before the actual performance date arrives.
By whom contract to be performed (Section 40)
If it appears from the nature of the case that it was the intention of the parties to any contract that any promise contained in it should be performed by the Promisor himself, such promise must be performed by the Promisor. In other cases, the Promisor or his representatives may employ a competent person to perform it.
π Example: A contract between X and Y for the sale/purchase of goods. X being a seller is required to deliver the goods at the agreed place and according to the time fixed for delivery against payment of the agreed amount by Y. In case X dies before the fixed time, it is the duty of the representatives to perform the promise or to engage some other person for the performance of the said promise.
π Example: Mr. Aslam enters into a contract with Mr. Zaighum, a renowned painter for painting the picture of a monument. In this case Mr. Zaighum must perform; he cannot assign this responsibility to some other person.
Personal contracts β Contracts involving the exercise of personal skill and taste, or otherwise founded on special personal confidence between the parties, cannot be performed by deputy. A contract for personal agency or other service entered into with partners is generally determined by the death of a partner. A contract with a firm which has nothing really personal about it, for example a contract to perform at a music-hall belonging to the firm, is not generally determined by the death of one member of the firm. Every case must be judged on its own circumstances.
Accepting performance from third person β effect thereof (section 41)
When a Promisee accepts performance of the promise from a third person, he cannot afterwards enforce it against the Promisor.
π Example: If a consignee under the contract recovers the loss from an insurance company, he does not have the right to sue the supplier of goods for the loss/damages caused to him.
Concept of joint liabilities (section 42)
When two or more persons have made a joint promise, then unless a contrary intention appears by the contract, all such persons during their joint lives, and after the death of any of them, his representative jointly with the survivor or survivors, and after the death of last survivor, the representatives of all jointly, must fulfill the promise.
π Illustration 1: Mr. Aslam, Mr. Yasir and Mr. Usman jointly promise to pay Rs. 100,000 to Mr. Kamal. Mr. Kamal has a right to demand the said amount either from Mr. Aslam or Mr. Yasir or Mr. Usman.
π Illustration 2: Mr. Aslam, Mr. Yasir and Mr. Usman jointly promise to pay Rs. 150,000 to Mr. Omar. Mr. Usman is compelled to pay the entire amount of Rs. 150,000. Mr. Aslam has been declared insolvent but his assets are sufficient to pay 1/3rd of the debt. Mr. Usman is entitled to receive Rs. 50,000 from the estate of Mr. Aslam and Rs. 50,000 from Mr. Yasir.
π Illustration 3: Mr. Aslam, Mr. Yasir and Mr. Usman have jointly promised to pay Rs. 300,000 to Mr. Omar. Mr. Aslam is unable to pay any amount and Mr. Yasir is compelled to pay the entire amount. Mr. Yasir is entitled to receive Rs. 150,000 from Mr. Usman.
π Illustration 4: Mr. Aslam, Mr. Yasir and Mr. Usman have jointly promised to pay Rs. 900,000 to Mr. Omar. Mr. Aslam and Mr. Yasir are also the sureties for Mr. Usman. Mr. Usman fails to pay then Mr. Aslam and Mr. Yasir are compelled to pay the entire amount. Mr. Aslam and Mr. Yasir have the right to recover the amount from Mr. Usman.
Devolution of joint liabilities (Sec. 42) β When two or more persons have made a joint promise, then, unless a contrary intention appears by the contract, all such persons, during their joint lives, and after the death of any of them, his representative jointly with the survivor or survivors, and after the death of the last survivor, the representatives of all jointly, must fulfill the promise.
Time for performance where no application is to be made and no time is specified: Section 46
Where, by the contract, a Promisor is to perform his promise without application by the Promisee, and no time for performance is specified, the engagement must be performed within a reasonable time. The question "what is a reasonable time" is, in each particular case, a question of fact.
π Definition β Reasonable time: The period within which a promise must be performed when no specific time is mentioned; determined as a question of fact based on the circumstances of each case.
Breach of contract (Sec. 46 & 73) β Party not bound to allow other party time to perform the contract even when time is not the essence of the Contract β If goods are not according to specification, the buyer can reject them and with his rejection the contract comes to an end. The plaintiff, therefore, had a right of repudiating the contract and no question of reprint arises.
Sale of land (Sec. 46) β Time is not of the essence of the contract of sale. Ordinarily time is not of the essence of the contract in an agreement for sale of land.
β Key Takeaways
Section 39 gives the promisee the right to end the contract when the promisor refuses or disables themselves from performing, with the crucial distinction that the promisee can either accept the repudiation immediately and claim damages, or keep the contract alive and await performance. Section 40 establishes that contracts requiring personal skill must be performed by the promisor personally, while other promises can be delegated to competent persons. Under Section 41, once a promisee accepts performance from a third party, they cannot later enforce the promise against the original promisor. Section 42 creates joint liability, meaning each joint promisor can be held liable for the entire debt, with rights of contribution among them. Section 46 requires that when no time is specified for performance, the promise must be performed within a reasonable time, which is a question of fact determined by circumstances.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under Section 39, what two options does the promisee have when the promisor refuses to perform the contract?
- Under Section 40, when must a promise be performed by the promisor personally rather than by a deputy?
- Under Section 41, what happens if a promisee accepts performance of the promise from a third person?
- Under Section 42, if three persons jointly promise to pay Rs. 300,000 and one is unable to pay, how much can the second promisor recover from the third if the second pays in full?
- Under Section 46, what standard governs the time for performance when no time is specified in the contract?
π Lecture 15 β Performance & Discharge of Contracts
π Overview: This lecture explains how contracts are performed and discharged under business and labour law. It covers the rules regarding time, place, and order of performance of reciprocal promises, as well as the various modes by which a contract can be discharged, including performance, impossibility, agreement, operation of law, and breach.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture addresses time and place for performance of promises under Sections 47 and 49, reciprocal promises and their simultaneous performance under Section 51, order of performance under Section 52, liability for preventing performance under Section 53, and the five modes of discharge of contract including performance, impossibility, agreement, operation of law, and breach. It also covers tender of performance and its essentials under Section 38.
π Lecture Summary
Regarding Time and place for performance of PromiseβSection 47
When a promise is to be performed on a certain day and the promisor has undertaken to perform it without application by the promisee, the promisor may perform it at any time during the usual hours of business on such day and at the place where the promise ought to be performed.
π Example: A promises to deliver goods at B's warehouse on the 1st January. On that day A brings the goods to B's warehouse but after the usual hour for closing it, and they are not received. A has not performed his promise.
Absence of time β Mere absence of time in fulfillment of contract does not rob contract of its basic characteristics.
Time cannot be made essence of contract by unilateral action β Whenever time is made essence of contract, courts must look into circumstances to determine if the time proposed by one party is reasonable, and a higher duty devolves where the subject-matter is substantial and very valuable.
Time essence of contract β In cases of sale of land, a party can make time essence of contract but only by giving notice to the other side, in case that other side is guilty of undue delay in performance of contract within a reasonable time.
Place for performance of promiseβSection 49
When a promise is to be performed without application by the promisee, and no place is fixed for its performance, it is the duty of the promisor to apply to the promisee to appoint a reasonable place for the performance of the promise, and to perform it at such place.
π Example: A undertakes to deliver a thousand maunds of jute to B on a fixed day. A must apply to B to appoint a reasonable place for receiving it, and must deliver it to him at such place.
Place of payment of debt β It is the duty of the debtor to find out the creditor. Where the parties have not stipulated the place of discharge of the debt, it will be presumed that the amount will be paid at the place of the creditor.
Payment to creditor β Debtor must make payment where creditor is found. If the contract does not stipulate to the contrary, it is the duty of the debtor to find out the creditor and to make payment at the place where he resides.
Reciprocal Promises: Section 51
When a contract consists of reciprocal promises to be simultaneously performed, no promisor need to perform his promise unless the promisee is ready and willing to perform his reciprocal promise.
π Illustration (a): A and B contract that A shall deliver goods to B to be paid for by B on delivery. π Illustration (b): A need not deliver the goods unless B is ready and willing to pay for the goods on delivery. π Illustration (c): B need not pay for the goods unless A is ready and willing to deliver them on payment.
π Example: A and B contract that A shall deliver goods to B at a price to be paid by installments, the first installment to be paid on delivery. A need not deliver unless B is ready and willing to pay the first installment on delivery.
Agreement regarding sale/purchase of goods β Seller has to deliver goods and purchaser to pay the amount simultaneously as per agreement.
π Definition β Simultaneous performance: This section expresses the settled rule of law that in a contract by mutual promises, the promises on either side are the consideration for one another. The terms of a promise may express or imply conditions, and the other party's performance or at least readiness and willingness to perform may be a condition.
Conditions precedent β Performance of one party's promise may have to be completed or tendered before he can sue on the other's reciprocal promise. This is called a condition precedent to the right of action on the reciprocal promise.
Concurrent conditions β Where the performances are intended to be simultaneous (goods to be delivered in exchange for cash), they are said to be concurrent conditions, and the promises are dependent. Concurrent conditions are only a modified form of conditions precedent.
Independent promises β Promises which can be enforced without showing performance of the plaintiff's own promise, or readiness or willingness to perform it, are said to be independent.
π‘ Why this matters: To apply the rule of Section 51, we must determine whether the promises are "to be simultaneously performed." This is a question of construction depending on the intention of the parties collected from the agreement as a whole.
π Example β Installment contract: Where goods were to be delivered in installments and paid for as per delivery, and the buyer did not pay for the first installment, the seller was justified in rescinding the contract and refusing further delivery because there was a likelihood of non-payment for subsequent deliveries.
Willingness to perform by purchaser β Willingness to perform one's contract in respect of purchase of property implies the capacity of the purchaser to pay the requisite sale consideration within a reasonable time. Even if a purchaser had capacity to pay, the question remains whether he had the intention to purchase the property. The capacity to pay the balance of sale consideration cannot be considered apart from the time when the sale consideration was payable.
Order of performance of reciprocal promises: Section 52
Where the order in which reciprocal promises are to be performed is expressly fixed by the contract, they shall be performed in that order. Where the order is not expressly fixed by the contract, they shall be performed in that order which the nature of the transaction requires.
π Illustration 1: Mr. Yasir enters into a contract with Mr. Faisal to construct a house according to the site plan against payment of the agreed amount. If not otherwise agreed, Mr. Yasir shall first perform his part of promise and then demand payment from Mr. Faisal, as per practice in such contracts.
π Illustration 2: If it is agreed that Mr. Yasir will construct the building on availability of material which is to be made available by Mr. Faisal, then Mr. Faisal shall have to make the material available first, after that Mr. Yasir shall perform his part of promise.
π Illustration 3: A and B contract that A should build a house for B at a fixed price. A's promise to build the house must be performed before B's promise to pay for it.
π Illustration 4: A and B contract that A shall make over his stock in trade to B at a fixed price, and B promises to give security for the payment of money. A's promise need not be performed until the security is given, for the nature of the transaction requires that A should have security before he delivers up his stock.
Liability of party preventing performance: Section 53
When a contract contains reciprocal promises and one party prevents the other from performing his promise, the contract becomes voidable at the option of the party so prevented, and he is entitled to compensation from the other party for any loss which he may sustain in consequence of the non-performance of the contract.
π Illustration: A and B contract that B shall execute certain work for A for a thousand rupees. B is ready and willing to execute the work accordingly, but A prevents him from doing so. The contract is voidable at the option of B, and if he elects to rescind it, he is entitled to recover from A compensation for any loss which he has incurred by its non-performance.
π Definition β Impossibility created by act of party: No man can complain of another's failure to do something which he has himself made impossible. This principle extends not only to acts of direct or forcible prevention but also to default or neglect in doing or providing anything which a party ought under the contract to do or provide, and without which the other party cannot perform his part.
π Example: A man agrees to sell standing wood; the seller is to cut and cord it, and the buyer to take it away and pay for it. The seller cords only a very small part of the wood and neglects to cord the rest; the buyer may determine the contract and recover back any money he has paid on account.
If the prevention by default goes only to one particular term or condition of the contract, the party so prevented from fulfilling that term or condition is entitled to treat it as fulfilled and insist on payment or other reciprocal performance accordingly.
Discharge of Contract
A contract shall be treated to have been discharged in the following situations:
(a) By Performance (b) By Impossibility of performance (c) By Agreement of parties (d) By Operation of law (e) By Breach of contract
Discharge by performance of contract
Actual performance (Section 37)
π Definition β Obligation of parties to contracts (Section 37): The parties to a contract must either perform or offer to perform their respective promises, unless such performance is dispensed with or excused under the provisions of this Act or of any other law.
Promises bind the representatives of the promisors in case of the death of such promisors before performance, unless a contrary intention appears from the contract.
π Illustration (a): A promises to deliver goods to B on a certain day on payment of Rs. 1,000. A dies before that day. A's representatives are bound to deliver the goods to B, and B is bound to pay the Rs. 1,000 to A's representatives.
π Illustration (b): A promises to paint a picture for B by a certain day at a certain price. A dies before the day. The contract cannot be enforced either by A's representatives or by B.
Performance and discharge β A contract creates a legal obligation which subsists until discharged. Performance of the promise or promises remaining to be performed is the principal and most usual mode of discharge.
Succession to benefit of contract β Neither Section 37 nor anything else in the Act lays down any rule as to the manner in which or the extent to which persons other than the original promisee may become entitled to enforce a promise.
Tender of performance (Section 38)
π Definition β Effect of refusal to accept offer of performance (Section 38): Where a promisor has made an offer of performance to the promisee, and the offer has not been accepted, the promisor is not responsible for non-performance, nor does he thereby lose his rights under the contract.
Every such offer must fulfill the following conditions: (1) It must be unconditional (2) It must be made at a proper time and place, and under such circumstances that the person to whom it is made may have a reasonable opportunity of ascertaining that the person by whom it is made is able and willing there and then to do the whole of what he is bound by his promise to do (3) If the offer is an offer to deliver anything to the promisee, the promisee must have a reasonable opportunity of seeing that the thing offered is the thing which the promisor is bound by his promise to deliver (4) An offer to one of several joint promisees has the same legal consequences as an offer to all of them
Essentials of valid tender: (a) The tender should be unconditional β There is no obligation on the counter party to accept a conditional tender (b) Tender to be made at proper time and proper place (c) Tender should be in entirety as per stipulations of the agreement (d) In case of tender relating to delivery of goods, the promisee should be provided opportunity to examine the goods according to the stipulations of the contract (e) Tender must be offered to a person who is able to perform the promise under the contract (f) Tender to be made to the promisee or his agent (g) In case of joint promisee, tender can be made to any of the joint promisees (h) In case of tender of money, the exact amount should be mentioned
π Illustration: A contracts to deliver to B at his warehouse, on the 1st March, 1997, 100 bales of cotton of a particular quality. To make an offer of performance with the effect stated in this section, A must bring the cotton to B's warehouse on the appointed day, under such circumstances that B may have a reasonable opportunity of satisfying himself that the thing offered is cotton of the quality contracted for, and that there are 100 bales.
Discharge by impossibility of performance of contract
Agreement to do impossible act (Section 56)
π Definition β Agreement to do impossible act: An agreement to do an act impossible in itself is void.
Contract to do act afterwards becoming impossible or unlawful β A contract to do an act which, after the contract is made, becomes impossible, or by reason of some event which the promisor could not prevent, unlawful, becomes void when the act becomes impossible or unlawful.
Compensation for loss through non-performance of act known to be impossible or unlawful β Where one person has promised to do something which he knew, or with reasonable diligence might have known, and which the promisee did not know to be impossible or unlawful, such promisor must make compensation to such promisee for any loss which such promisee sustains through the non-performance of the promise.
π Illustration (a): A agrees with B to discover treasure by magic. The agreement is void. π Illustration (b): A and B contract to marry each other. Before the time fixed for the marriage, A goes mad. The contract becomes void. π Illustration (c): A contracts to marry B, being already married to C, and being forbidden by law to practice polygamy. A must make compensation to B for the loss caused to her by the non-performance of his promise. π Illustration (d): A contracts to take in cargo for B at a foreign port. A's Government afterwards declares war against the country in which the port is situated. The contract becomes void when war is declared. π Illustration (e): A contracts to act at a theatre for six months in consideration of a sum paid in advance by B. On several occasions A is too ill to act. The contract to act on those occasions becomes void.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that performance of contracts requires adherence to specific rules regarding time, place, and order. For Section 47, performance must occur during usual business hours on the stipulated day, and time can only be made essence of contract in land sales through proper notice. Section 51 establishes that reciprocal promises require simultaneous performanceβneither party need perform unless the other is ready and willing. Section 52 clarifies that the order of performance follows either the express contract terms or the nature of the transaction. For discharge, there are five modes: performance, impossibility, agreement, operation of law, and breach. Valid tender under Section 38 must be unconditional, at proper time and place, for the entire performance, with opportunity for examination. Under Section 56, agreements to do impossible acts are void, and contracts become void if subsequent impossibility or illegality occurs beyond the promisor's control.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
Under Section 47, if a promisor brings goods to the promisee's warehouse after the usual hours of closing on the stipulated day, has the promisor performed his promise?
-
What are the four conditions that a valid offer of performance (tender) must fulfill under Section 38?
-
Under Section 51, if A contracts to deliver goods to B for payment on delivery, when must A deliver the goods and when must B pay?
-
Under Section 53, what happens when one party to a contract prevents the other from performing their reciprocal promise?
-
According to Section 56, what is the legal effect if A contracts to marry B but A was already married to C and forbidden by law to practice polygamy?