π Lecture 12 β VOID AGREEMENTS
π Overview: This lecture examines agreements that are void under the Contract Act, explaining the legal definition and various categories of void agreements. Understanding void agreements is critical for identifying enforceable contracts and avoiding legally invalid arrangements in business and personal dealings.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture defines void agreements under Section 2(g) of the Contract Act, then systematically explores agreements expressly declared void under Section 10. It covers agreements in restraint of marriage, restraint of trade with exceptions for goodwill sales and service terms, restraint of legal proceedings with arbitration exceptions, uncertain agreements with detailed illustrations, wagering agreements with the horse-racing exception, agreements contingent on impossible events, and agreements to do impossible acts, and introduces contingent contracts.
π Lecture Summary
Void Agreement
It has been defined in Sec. 2 (g) of the Contract Act which is reproduced below: βAn agreement not enforceable by law is said to be voidβ.
π Definition β Void Agreement: An agreement not enforceable by law.
Agreements expressly declared void (section 10)
What agreements are contracts? All agreements are contracts if they are made by the free consent of parties competent to contract, for a lawful consideration and with a lawful object, and are not hereby expressly declared to be void. Nothing herein contained shall affect any law in force in India, and not hereby expressly repealed, by which any contract is required to be made in writing or in the presence of witnesses, or any law relating to the registration of documents. The first paragraph of this section is developed and applied by the more specific provisions of several following sections, which will be considered as they occur.
Agreements in restraint of marriage (sec. 26)
Every agreement in restraint of the marriage of any person, other than minor, is void.
π Definition β Agreement in Restraint of Marriage: An agreement that restricts a person (other than a minor) from marrying is void.
π Example: An agreement between two adults not to marry each other or anyone else would be void under Section 26. π‘ Why this matters: This rule protects personal liberty in marriage, with the only exception being agreements involving minors (since minors cannot legally marry in some jurisdictions).
Agreements in restraint of trade (sec. 27)
Every agreement by which any one is restrained from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business of any kind, is to that extent void.
Exception 1: Saving of agreement not to carry on business of which good-will is sold. --- One who sells the good-will of a business may agree with the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business, within specified local limits, so long as the buyer, or any person deriving title to the goodwill from him, carries on a like business therein; Provided that such limits appear to the Court reasonable, regard being had to the nature of the business.
Restraint during term of service --- An agreement of service by which an employee binds himself, during the term of his agreement, not to compete with his employer directly or indirectly is not in restraint of trade. If it were otherwise, "all agreements for personal service for a fixed period would be void. An agreement to serve exclusively for a week, a day, or even for an hour, necessarily prevents the person so agreeing to serve from exercising his calling during that period for any one else than the person with whom he so agrees. It can hardly be contended that such an agreement is void. In truth, a man who agrees to exercise his calling for a particular wage and for a certain period agrees to exercise his calling and such an agreement does not restrain him from doing so. To hold otherwise would, I think, be a contradiction in terms." Such an agreement may be enforced by injunction where it contains a negative clause, express or implied, providing that the employee should not carry on business on his own account during the term of his engagement.
π Example: An employee contracted to serve as a weaving master for three years, and agreed not to serve anyone else in India during the period. He left the service after one year, and joined another mill as a weaving master. The Court, in the light of the intention of the parties, construed the prohibition as confined to the profession of weaving master, held the agreement reasonable, and issued an injunction against the employee.
Earnest money---When may be recovered by purchaser. If the respondent who was the seller is held guilty of breach of contract, obviously, the appellant who was the buyer would be entitled to recover the money paid to the seller as purchase price, on account of the failure of consideration. Thus, the buyer has a quasi-contractual right to claim the recovery of the price, which is paid to the seller, for the seller, in breach of his obligation, failed to pass good title to the goods sold. The buyer in such case has a right to sue in restitution to recover the price on the ground of total failure of consideration. Similarly, if the seller failed to deliver the goods the buyer may recover the deposit he paid to the seller. But in that case the buyer must terminate the contract. On the other hand, even if the buyer was in default he can, in certain circumstances, claim restitution of the advance payment made to the seller, even if the seller justifiably terminates the contract.
Scope of Section 27: Section 27 prohibits all agreements in restraint of trade.
Agreements in restraint of legal proceedings void (sec 28)
Every agreement, by which any party thereto is restricted absolutely from enforcing his rights under or in respect of any contract, by the usual legal proceedings in the ordinary tribunals, or which limits the time within which he may thus enforce his rights, is void to that extent.
Exception I: Saving of contract to refer to arbitration dispute that may arise: --- This section shall not render illegal a contract by which two or more persons agree that any dispute which may arise between them in respect of any subject or class of subjects shall be referred to arbitration, and that only the amount awarded in such arbitration shall be recoverable in respect of the dispute so referred.
Suits barred by such contracts. When such a contract has been made, a suit may be brought for its specific performance, and if a suit, other than for such specific performance, or for the recovery of the amount so awarded, is brought by one party to such contract against any other such party in respect of any subject which they have so agreed to refer, the existence of such contract shall be a bar to the suit.
Exception 2: Saving of contract to refer questions that have already arisen.--- Nor shall this section render illegal any contract in writing by which two or more persons agree to refer to arbitration any question between them which has already arisen, or affect any provision of any law in force for the time being as to references to arbitration.
Agreement in restraint of legal proceedings: "This section applies to agreements which wholly or partially prohibit the parties from having recourse to a court of law. If, for instance, a contract were to contain a stipulation that no action should be brought upon it, that stipulation would, under the first part of S. 28, be void, because it would restrict both parties from enforcing their rights under the contract in the ordinary legal tribunals, and so if a contract were to contain a double stipulation that any dispute between the parties should be settled by arbitration, and that neither party should enforce his rights under it in a court of law; that would be a valid stipulation so far as regards its first branch, viz., that all disputes between the parties should be referred to arbitration."
"Rights under or in respect of any contract" --- This section applies only to cases where a party is restricted from enforcing his rights under or in respect of any contract. It therefore presumably does not apply if the Court holds that the parties did not intend that their agreement should give rise to any legal relations. It does not apply to cases of wrongs or torts. Nor does it apply to decrees. The expression "contract" does not include rights under a decree. The Code of Civil Procedure contains express provisions as to adjustment of a decree and postponement of rights under a decree by mutual agreement of parties of a suit.
Limitation of time to enforce rights under a contract --- Under the provisions of this section, an agreement which provides that a suit should be brought for the breach of any terms of the agreements within a time shorter than the period of limitation prescribed by law is void to that extent. The effect of such an agreement is absolutely to restrict the parties from enforcing their rights after the expiration of the stipulated period, though it may be within the period of limitation.
Uncertain agreements (sec. 29)
Agreements, the meaning of which is not certain, or capable of being made certain, are void.
Illustrations (a) A agrees to sell to B "a hundred tons of oil." There is nothing whatever to show what kind of oil was intended. The agreement is void for uncertainty. (b) A agrees to sell to B one hundred tons of oil of a specified description, known as an article of commerce. There is no uncertainty here to make the agreement void. (c) A, who is a dealer in coconut-oil only, agrees to sell to B "one hundred tons of oil." The nature of A's trade affords an indication of the meaning of the words, and A has entered into a contract for the sale of one hundred tons of coconut-oil. (d) A agrees to sell to B "all the grain at Rahimyar Khan." There is no uncertainty here to make the agreement void. (e) A agrees to sell to B "one thousand maunds of rice at a price to be fixed by C." As the price is capable of being made certain, there is no uncertainty here to make the agreement void. (f) A agrees to sell to B "my white horse for rupees five hundred or rupees one thousand." There is nothing to show which of the two prices was to be given. The agreement is void.
Explanation: S. 93 of the Evidence Act provides that when the language of a document is ambiguous or defective no evidence can be given to explain or amend the document. Neither will the Court undertake to supply defects or remove ambiguities according to its own notions of what is reasonable; for this would be not to enforce a contract made by the parties, but to make a new contract for them. The only apparent exception to this principle is that when goods are sold without naming a price, the bargain is understood to be for a reasonable price.
Where the defendants, describing themselves as residents of a certain place, executed a bond and hypothecated as security for the amount "our property, with all the rights and interest", it was held that the hypothecation was too indefinite to be acted upon. The mere fact that the defendants describe themselves in the bond as residents of a certain place is not enough to indicate their property in that place as the property hypothecated. If they had described themselves as the owners of certain property it would then have been reasonable to refer the indefinite expression to the description. And where the defendant passed a document to the Savings Bank whereby he promised to pay to the manager of the bank the sum of Rs. 10 on or before a certain date "and a similar sum monthly every succeeding month," it was held that the instrument could not be regarded as a promissory note, as it was impossible from its language to say for what period it was to subsist and what amount was to be paid under it.
Similarly, where in an agreement for the sale of goods, the seller reserves the right to vary the price at will, there is no contract. A compromise stating: "The following five gentlemen shall decide all matters relating to our movable and immovable property" was held to be too ambiguous to be enforced. An agreement to grant a lease when no date of commencement is expressly or impliedly fixed cannot be enforced. But when the commencement of a lease is dependent upon a contingency, which has occurred, the agreement can be enforced. An agreement to pay a certain amount after deductions as would be agreed upon between the parties is void for uncertainty. It has also been held that an agreement to refer arbitration to a person, who has been described in uncertain terms, is void. But where the proprietor of an indigo factory mortgaged to B all the indigo cakes that might be manufactured by the factory from crops to be grown on lands of the factory from the date of the mortgage up to the date of payment of the mortgage debt, it was held that the terms of the mortgage were not vague, and that the mortgage was not void in law.
Void agreement, connotation of --- Agreements meaning whereof is not certain or capable of being made certain, held, would be void --- Where both contracting parties are at consensus ad idem with regard to essential terms of contract, any uncertainty or vagueness which is incapable of being ascertained, would have effect of vitiating contract --- In letter of guarantee there was no vagueness or uncertainty, which could vitiate contract.
π Definition β Consensus ad idem: Meeting of the minds; both parties agree to the same thing in the same sense.
Lease---Agreement that rent will be fixed by Chief Officer of Corporation and will be paid from date of possession---Not valid. The terms of the allotment of a shop by the Karachi Municipal Corporation provided that the lease would commence from the date from which possession will be handed over to the respondent. Held; the agreement was not void under section 29 of the Contract Act, because the terms of the agreement it was agreed between the parties that the respondent will pay such rent as will be fixed by the Chief Officer and the lease will commence on delivery of possession of the shop. These two terms were quite plain and simple.
Applicability---Agreement is void only when it is uncertain and unascertainable---Agreement capable of being ascertained---Not void. Under section 29 of the Contract Act, it is only when the meaning of an agreement is not certain or capable of being made certain that the agreement becomes void. When, therefore, the sellers told the buyers that each shipment shall be treated as if separate contracts were made for it and they shall be bound to accept it even if this shipment was only in respect of a part of the goods and the buyers agreed to this condition, the agreement is not void as it is capable of being ascertained.
Vague contract---When not enforceable: Section 29 is based upon the principle that the contracting parties must be shown to be at ad idem with reference to the essential terms of the contract and, therefore, if there is any vagueness or uncertainty incapable of being made certain the contract fails for vagueness. For, in that case the parties cannot be said to agree to the same thing in the same sense. Therefore merely because the terms of the arbitration agreement are capable of different and various interpretations it cannot ipso facto be liable to be struck down as void. It can only be regarded as void for uncertainty if its meaning is not certain or capable of being made certain as provided by section 29.
Terms of contract not ascertainable---Contract void and enforceable. Held: The document being incomplete, as its terms are not ascertainable with reasonable certainty, it comes within the mischief of section 29 and is void and by virtue of the provisions of S. 21 (a) of the Specific Relief Act cannot be enforced specifically.
Wagering agreements (sec. 30)
Agreements by way of wager are void; and no suit shall be brought for recovering anything alleged to be won on any wager, or entrusted to any person to abide the result of any game or other uncertain event on which any wager is made.
Exception in favour of certain prizes for horse-racing: This section shall not be deemed to render unlawful a subscription or contribution, or agreement to subscribe or contribute, made or entered into for or toward any plate, prize or sum of money, of the value or amount of five hundred rupees or upwards to be awarded to the winner or winners of any horse-race.
Section 294-A of the Pakistan Penal Code not affected: Nothing in this section shall be deemed to legalise any transaction connected with horse racing, to which the provisions of section 294-A of the Pakistan Penal Code apply.
π Definition β Wagering Agreement: An agreement where one party promises to pay money or money's worth on the happening of an uncertain event, and the other party promises to pay if the event does not happen; each party has a chance of winning or losing.
Agreements contingent on impossible events void (sec 36):
Contingent agreements to do or not to do anything, if an impossible event happens, are void, whether the impossibility of the event is known or not to the parties to the agreement at the time when it is made.
Illustrations (a) A agrees to pay B 1,000 rupees if two straight lines should enclose a space. The agreement is void. (b) A agrees to pay B 1,000 rupees if B will marry A's daughter C. C was dead at the time of the agreement. The agreement is void. (c) The two last foregoing sections explain themselves. We note that somewhat similar provisions as to transfers of property made subject to conditions occur in the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, see especially Ss. 25-34. A conditional transfer of property, though it may be, and often is, made in pursuance of a contract, is not, of course, itself a contract. It was therefore necessary to lay down distinct and independent, though more or less analogous, rules for such transactions.
Agreements to do impossible acts (sec. 56)
An agreement to do an act impossible in itself is void.
π Example: An agreement to walk on water would be void under Section 56 because it is an act impossible in itself.
Contingent Contract (Sec. 31)
A contingent contract is a contract to do or not to do something, if some event, collateral to such contract, does or does not happen.
Illustrations: M/S ABC insurance company contracts with Mr. Z to pay Rupees 500,000 if his car is lifted by thieves.
Contract between the client and his counsel regarding payment of agreed professional fee if the suit turns out to be successful would also come under the ambit contingent contract.
π Definition β Contingent Contract: A contract to do or not to do something, if some event, collateral to such contract, does or does not happen.
β Key Takeaways
The key takeaway is that a void agreement is one that is not enforceable by law (Section 2(g)), and the Contract Act expressly declares several types of agreements void. These include agreements in restraint of marriage (except for minors), agreements in restraint of trade (with specific exceptions for goodwill sales and non-compete clauses during the term of service), agreements in restraint of legal proceedings (with arbitration exceptions), uncertain agreements whose meaning is not certain or capable of being made certain, and wagering agreements (with an exception for horse-racing prizes over 500 rupees). Additionally, agreements contingent on impossible events and agreements to do impossible acts are void. The concepts of consensus ad idem (meeting of the minds) and the distinction between void agreements and contingent contracts are fundamental to understanding contract validity.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of a void agreement under Section 2(g) of the Contract Act?
- Under Section 26, are all agreements in restraint of marriage void? What is the only exception?
- What two exceptions are provided under Section 27 for agreements that would otherwise be in restraint of trade?
- When does an agreement become void for uncertainty under Section 29, and what must be true for it to be enforceable?
- What is the difference between a wagering agreement under Section 30 and a contingent contract under Section 31?