๐ Lecture 40 โ Introduction to Services Marketing (Closing Gap 4)
๐ Overview: This lecture begins the discussion on closing Gap 4, the gap between service delivery and external communications. It explains why managing promises, expectations, customer education, and internal marketing are critical to avoiding broken promises. The lecture also introduces the need for coordinated communication and the objectives of marketing communication for services.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the four major causes of service communication problems: inadequate management of promises, inadequate management of expectations, inadequate customer education, and inadequate internal marketing communication. It then discusses the need to coordinate communication through Integrated Marketing Communication (IMC), distinguishing between external and interactive marketing. Finally, it lists the general and service-specific objectives of communication.
๐ Lecture Summary
Causes of service communication problems
There are four major causes of Gap 4: inadequate management of promises, inadequate management of expectations, inadequate customer education, and inadequate internal marketing communication.
Inadequate management of promises stems from a tendency to over-promise delivery, often due to pressure on employees to generate new business in a competitive environment. While this may work in the short run, it generates long-run disappointment. Lack of proper employee education and company advertising/promotions that work at odds with actual capabilities also cause over-promising. Supply and demand situations may further lead to non-fulfillment of promises.
Inadequate management of expectations occurs because over-promising builds unrealistic expectations, which disappoint customers during or after service encounters. Claims about marketing and operational capabilities are exposed when actual buying takes place. Marketing is a reflection of all quality dimensions (reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy), and operations is about delivering the service as promised. Lapses on both fronts converge and compound the gap.
Inadequate customer education is essential for first-time buyers who must be educated about precise service features, the sellerโs role, the customerโs role, and any limitations. Clarity of features is critical while the service is negotiated. For example, first-time HAJJ and UMRA performers must be educated about what will be offered during the rites and their own responsibilities. Customers should also be educated about the criteria to evaluate the service during pre-purchase, encounter, and post-purchase. Confident companies manage this aspect to minimize the gap and negative word of mouth.
Inadequate internal marketing communication reflects ill-coordinated efforts among different functions. Horizontal communication that should occur among departments (e.g., marketing, operations, HR) often does not, resulting in missing links and disintegrated communication. Until marketing communications are fully integrated and spread across the organization, it is difficult to keep all employees informed of real communication objectives. Informed employees get motivated to minimize the gap. Additionally, extraneous factors like competitive offerings, customer perceptions of those offerings, general word of mouth, and customer needs build unrealistic expectations. While the company cannot control these extraneous factors, it can control its communication tools to subside their impact.
๐ก Why this matters: These four causes show that Gap 4 is not just about advertising but involves internal coordination, realistic promises, and customer preparation. Each cause must be managed proactively.
๐ Definition โ Horizontal communication: Communication that should take place among different functions (departments) within an organization to keep everyone informed and get everyoneโs input.
The need to coordinate communication
The foremost objective of well-coordinated communication is to control its tools (advertising, personal selling, promises by service personnel) so they can influence customersโ expectations. By controlling these tools, the company can influence expectations that may have sprung up through extraneous factors. Given the vast variety of tools available (traditional advertising, promotions, personal selling, internet, web-based advertising, coupons, contests, etc.), the need to integrate marketing communication becomes pronounced.
Integrated Marketing Communication (IMC) forces sellers to consider all tools and vehicles and relate their application to any given service at a given point in time. Owing to a unified effort, customers receive just one consistent message with no conflicting meanings. Customers are targeted by two types of marketing communications: external marketing and interactive marketing.
External marketing involves advertising, personal selling, and all other vehicles that create awareness, persuade, remind, and induce action. This is where the action starts in making promises to customers. Interactive marketing is the stage where providers (employees), franchisees, and licensees communicate with customers. Supplier interaction with providers is also part of this. This is where real action takes place, and promises are either kept or broken.
Before Gap 4 is minimized, sellers must ensure there is no gap between external marketing and interactive marketing. Messages sent through external marketing must be consistent with actions during interactive marketing. Because internal, horizontal communication is critical for creating an enabling environment, internal marketing takes on added importance. Unless employees across the organization understand the rationale behind communication and their inputs are considered, they cannot communicate with one voice and a unified message.
๐ Formula: Consistent Communication = External Marketing Messages = Interactive Marketing Actions โ This means that what is promised through advertising and selling must exactly match what employees deliver during service interactions.
Objectives of communication
Communication objectives are divided into general objectives and objectives that are typically reflective of services.
General objectives include:
- Identify the target market (potential and existing buyers and influencers)
- Determine communication objectives (awareness, knowledge, liking, preference, conviction, purchase)
- Decide on a budget (allocation to total campaign and individual parts)
- Create a message (what to say, how to say, who will deliver)
- Choose media (personal selling, non-personal, targeted vehicles, direct mail)
- Collect feedback (researching how effective communication was)
Service-specific objectives include:
- Reduce purchase risk
- Reduce cognitive dissonance
- Increase purchase probability
- Reinforce repeat purchase behavior
- Enhance customer satisfaction
- Develop company image and brand equity
๐ Definition โ Cognitive dissonance: A conflicting and disagreeable state that causes inconsistency and lack of clarity. In services, cognitive dissonance keeps customers from fully understanding the service, making it an important objective to reduce through clear communication.
๐ก Why this matters: Service-specific objectives address the unique intangibility and variability of services. Reducing cognitive dissonance and purchase risk directly helps close Gap 4 by aligning customer expectations with reality.
โญ Key Takeaways
The four major causes of Gap 4 are inadequate management of promises, expectations, customer education, and internal marketing communication. Over-promising leads to unrealistic expectations, which are exposed when actual delivery fails to match. Coordinating all communication through Integrated Marketing Communication (IMC) is essential to ensure that external marketing messages are consistent with interactive marketing actions. Internal marketing and horizontal communication across departments are critical for employees to deliver a unified message. Finally, communication objectives for services must specifically address reducing purchase risk and cognitive dissonance, while reinforcing repeat purchase behavior and building brand equity.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four major causes of service communication problems (Gap 4)?
- Why does inadequate management of promises lead to long-term disappointment even if it generates short-term sales?
- How does inadequate internal marketing communication create a gap between external marketing and interactive marketing?
- What is the difference between external marketing and interactive marketing, and why must they be consistent?
- List three service-specific objectives of communication and explain why they are particularly important for services.
๐ Lecture 41 โ Introduction to Managing Communication Gaps in Services Marketing
๐ Overview: This lecture addresses the four critical areas that cause communication problems in services marketing, all of which must be managed to prevent the communication gap. It provides detailed strategies for managing promises, coordinating external communication, making realistic promises, offering guarantees, and managing customer expectations through choices, line extensions, and service evaluation criteria.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining why the communication gap must be closed by managing all four problem areas. It then explores strategies for managing promises, including effective advertising that overcomes intangibility, using narratives, presenting vivid information, showing tangibles through association, physical representation, documentation, and visualization. The discussion moves to featuring employees and customers in communication, encouraging word of mouth, using transformational and banner advertising. It continues with coordinating external communication, making realistic promises, offering guarantees, managing expectations by offering choices, developing line extensions, and communicating criteria for service effectiveness.
๐ Lecture Summary
Managing promises
Effective advertising requires overcoming the challenge of intangibility, which makes ad-making more creative for services than for goods. The reasons for this challenge are: services are incorporeal (neither made of physical matter nor occupying physical space, though the delivery mechanism does); services are abstract (not objects and therefore more difficult to visualize); services are characterized by generality (described in general terms like "a wonderful service" or "unique experience"); services are non-searchable (cannot be previewed, especially those rich in experience and credence properties); and services carry mental impalpability (complex and difficult to understand, causing cognitive dissonance due to lack of exposure and early experience).
๐ Definition โ Intangibility: The characteristic of services that they are incorporeal, abstract, general, non-searchable, and mentally impalpable, making them difficult to visualize and evaluate before purchase.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding the five dimensions of intangibility lets managers design appropriate advertising strategies that make the service tangible and communicable to customers.
Use narratives to demonstrate service experience: Story-based narratives are more convincing than merely talking about service attributes. For example, a banking corporation giving the story of a money-transfer from a foreign country to a remote location in Pakistan will communicate all features and imprint pictures and visuals in customers' minds.
Present vivid information: This calls for creating strong impressions by establishing a distinct mental picture and evoking certain emotions. One way is through dramatizing socio-cultural customs, arousing patriotic feelings, and presenting product features with visuals strong enough to make features clear and vivid. Such evocation leaves strong impressions on the senses, arouses emotions, develops association with the service brand, and activates trial of the service. Mobile telephone companies' commercials (Mobilink, Ufone, Telenor, Zong) exemplify this strategy.
Show the tangibles: This pertains to tangibilizing the intangible by showing tangibles associated with the service to create a positive impression about service credibility. There are four strategies:
- Association (linking a service with a person, place, or object)
- Physical representation (showing tangibles as part of the service)
- Documentation (featuring data and factual information)
- Visualization (creating a vivid mental picture of a service's benefits)
๐ Example โ VU Distance Learning: Association can be made with the founder rector and governmental functionaries, or the grand campus. Physical representation involves showing IT, telecom paraphernalia, and support systems. Documentation includes accreditation from HEC and associations with other institutions. Visualization features ex-students working as professionals with expressions of achievement and testimonials.
Feature service employees in communication: This creates a good impact on both the primary audience (customers) and secondary audience (employees). Employees talking about their services provide a realistic view of delivery, making the promise credible. It creates sanity by making promises that have company-wide support and sets examples for others to emulate.
Promise what is possible: Good communication should promise only what can be delivered. Making attractive advertisements should not be the objective; delivering on the promise is the objective. Therefore, only what can be delivered should be the focus of communication.
Encourage word of mouth: Because services are rich in experience and credence qualities, customers turn to other customers for referrals. Only satisfied customers give referrals. Testimonials should be created and made part of communication. When found credible, people talk about them and word proliferates.
Feature service customers in communication: This featuring also leads to generating positive word of mouth.
Use transformational advertising: This involves creating strong visuals that capture the complete consumption and customer experience. Hotels generally follow this approach by showing real-life visuals to attract customers.
Banner advertising: This refers to banners posted on various websites with appeal to target segments. Utility is judged by click-through frequency โ how many prospects click the banner to reach the company site. Click-through frequency has receded over the years due to banner clutter, which has taken a toll on novelty. Research indicates that to revive interest, advertisers must increase banner size to create interest.
Coordinate external communication
External communication consists of advertising, public relations, personal selling, and internet. For services, this also includes service encounters, customer service desks, and telecommunication. Two important elements are: consistency of message through external communication, and complete consistency between external and interactive marketing. If the interactive area can deliver what is promised, it reflects an effective enabling environment practicing good internal marketing. Much of the brand image and equity are developed through consumer experiences.
Make realistic promises
High expectations result from great promises. Customers entering a facility with high expectations expect high-level service; if not received, it leads to customer dissatisfaction. Companies must know their own history of employee behavior and service delivery levels. Salespeople must have complete data about percentages of successful and unsuccessful deliveries before discussing reliability in advertising campaigns. The service level must reflect what is communicated.
Offer guarantees
This strategy is generally found reliable by customers. They feel convinced that the company truly means what it says. Knowing the company will stand behind its promise infuses trust into customers.
Managing expectations
The objective is to create conditions where companies can tell customers that the service is not what they think and expect. However, this must be done not as plain talk but by developing service products that fit customers' specific requirements for different situations, then communicating accordingly. The following strategies reflect this area's management.
Offer choices: Sellers can align customer expectations with service delivery by offering meaningful choices in absolute clarity. Choices are made on time and money. Customers wanting faster service should pay more; the choice of lower price with delayed delivery can be offered to those willing to accept it. When choices and related price/timeframe are transparently communicated, customers reset their expectations.
Develop line extensions: Just as goods manufacturers develop different versions of models ranging in price and value, service sellers should follow suit. For premium services of good reputation, premium prices should be charged; less valued services should carry lesser price tags. The objective is to let customers know the limits of their expectations. Credit cards and membership cards carrying different tiers of benefits exemplify this idea.
๐ Example โ Credit Cards: Different tiers (e.g., standard, gold, platinum) carry varying benefits, letting customers know what to expect at each level.
Communicate criteria and effectiveness of service: Sellers should develop criteria for customers to assess their service. This makes evaluation easy and helps customers feel comfortable about their purchase decision. A software development company should let customers know the package's effectiveness, its competitive advantage, and a step-by-step approach to evaluate it. Once customers have evaluation criteria, they can determine whether the product meets technical quality dimensions and addresses fears regarding experience and credence properties.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that the communication gap is prevented by managing four areas simultaneously: managing promises through effective advertising that overcomes intangibility via narratives, vivid information, and showing tangibles through association, physical representation, documentation, and visualization; coordinating external communication with consistency across all channels; making realistic promises and offering guarantees that build trust; and managing expectations by offering meaningful choices based on time and money, developing line extensions with different tiers of service, and communicating clear criteria for service evaluation. The fundamental principle is to promise only what can be delivered, and to ensure that all communicationโadvertising, employee interactions, and customer testimonialsโreflects actual service capabilities and performance levels.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five characteristics of intangibility that make services advertising challenging, and how does each affect advertising strategy?
- Describe the four strategies for "showing the tangibles" (tangibilizing the intangible) and provide an example of each using a service of your choice.
- Why is featuring service employees in communication important for both primary and secondary audiences?
- Explain how offering choices based on time and money helps manage customer expectations and reset their service expectations.
- What is banner advertising, and what trend has affected its effectiveness according to the lecture?
๐ Lecture 42 โ Managing Communication and Introduction to Pricing in Services
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on managing communication in services marketing, focusing on improving customer education and managing internal marketing communications. It then transitions to introduce the concept of pricing as it should apply in services, highlighting the strategic importance of these elements in closing gap 4.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two main areas: improving customer education through preparing customers for the service process and teaching customers to avoid peak-hours, and managing internal marketing communications through vertical (downward and upward) and horizontal communication across departments. A summary of the four areas causing communication problems is provided, followed by a brief introduction to pricing concepts for services.
๐ Lecture Summary
Improve customer education
Customer education is done by sellers in order for customers to clearly know the features of the service along with the criteria to evaluate that service relating its competitive position. It therefore is the responsibility of the seller to fully update the customer during encounter(s) about how the service fulfills customer needs and offers various features to the benefit of the customer. The strategic recourse to the areaโs management includes preparing customers for the service process and teaching customers to avoid peak-hours.
Prepare customers for the service process
In order for complex services to be understood by customers, it is the responsibility of the seller to explain the whole process in detail. For example, if a consultancy firm knows it is beyond the customerโs capability to install the new systems and procedures that are backed by sophisticated technology, the firm must recommend to the customer to buy the service in two parts: one, in development of systems, and two, in having the systems implemented by the seller to train customersโ employees. Although it will be expensive for the customer, yet it is beneficial for him to make the best use of the newly installed systems toward process improvement. Ignoring part two of the deal will cause more harm than do good to the customer.
The seller also should inform the customer when the training will end. At the end, the seller must prove that performance has been according to the standards that were jointly established earlier. The seller and the customer must be convinced that the seller is leaving while the process stands complete.
Teach customers to avoid peak-hours
Experience shows that informing customers of the peak hours helps best in shifting demand than any other strategy like putting more people to serve customers.
Manage internal marketing communications
Following are the two effective ways of doing this:
- Create vertical communication, and
- Create horizontal communication
Vertical communication is the downward and upward communication. Downward communication flows top-down, while upward flows bottom-up. The one that flows downward consists of newsletters, magazines, internal TV networks, and employee recognitions etc. The objective is to keep the employees informed of what is being communicated to customers along with any internal measures that affect all. Good companies let their employees see the advertisements and commercials before those are published or aired.
There is a great benefit that flows out of this approach. Employees communicate what customers hear from the external communication. Another benefit is that employees do not feel surprised or uninformed to find out anything new or strange from the customers, for they already have the knowledge of what company is doing.
Upward communication is also beneficial, for it allows the front end employees send upwards to the top management very useful information about customers. For being at the front, they are the ones who understand how customers think, what delights them, what is deliverable from customersโ perspective. Top management can then make some useful decisions of strategic nature.
Horizontal communication is a well-coordinated effort among different departments to improve the delivery of the service. The need arises from the fact that different departments have different outlooks and philosophies about customers and hence their own perspective of service delivery. This leads towards a gap among all of them. Therefore, better coordination between marketing and operations can lead to better delivery, between marketing and HR toward creating better marketers, and between marketing and finance toward working out the best price for the service to sell at.
In addition to opening channels among different departments, communication can also take place between these departments and customers for the former to understand what the latter exactly want.
Such communication gives the non-marketing people a true perspective of customers and let them work in a better coordinated way with marketing. They serve marketing people well as their internal customers. Some good companies have started the practice of exposing their back-end people to the customers to acquire such a perspective. Actually, featuring employees in advertisements is also an effort toward achieving the goal of having non-marketing people committed to goals.
Another strategy could be that of creating cross-functional teams that communicate with the customers in the presence of marketing people. It serves two purposes: one, marketing people cannot over-promise, and two, marketing people get the required support from other departments toward a service that gets aligned with customersโ expectations.
The four areas, if managed the way the above strategies dictate, effectively lead toward minimizing gap 4 as shown in figure 61.
Summary โ Communication
The four areas causing communication problems are over-promising, unrealistic expectations, lack of customer education, and the lack of integrated marketing communication. It is only logical to manage these areas smartly to be able to close gap 4.
Managing promises is all about coordinating communication efforts by effective external and interactive marketing. Managing expectation is a realistic effort by sellers to tell customers they cannot always get what they expect. Educating customers is all about making them aware of the service process and giving them criteria to evaluate service. Internal marketing communication is transmitting information across organizational boundaries to align all functions with customer expectations.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture concludes that effectively managing communication requires addressing four critical areas: over-promising, unrealistic expectations, lack of customer education, and lack of integrated marketing communication. To close gap 4, sellers must coordinate promises, manage expectations realistically, educate customers about the service process and evaluation criteria, and foster internal communication through vertical and horizontal channels. Internal communication is vital, as it aligns all departments with customer expectations and prevents surprises for employees. Ultimately, successful communication in services marketing requires a coordinated effort across the entire organization to ensure consistent and realistic messaging.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two key strategies for improving customer education as discussed in the lecture?
- Explain the difference between downward and upward vertical communication in the context of internal marketing communications.
- What is the primary purpose of horizontal communication between departments like marketing and operations?
- List the four areas that cause communication problems, which must be managed to close gap 4.
- According to the lecture, what are the two benefits of creating cross-functional teams that communicate with customers?
๐ Lecture 43 โ Introduction
๐ Overview: This lecture enhances our understanding about the concept of pricing, familiar from fundamental marketing courses. The learning centers upon the role of pricing in services, determinants of pricing, price elasticity of demand, and the approaches service managers have available to them as strategic pricing options.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture first explores the role of pricing as both a quality indicator and a demand-supply balancing agent. It then details the key determinants of price for services, including pricing objectives, cost analysis, demand-price schedules, price elasticity, competition, and operational position. Finally, it examines three major approaches to pricing: cost-based, competition-based, and demand-based.
๐ Lecture Summary
Role of pricing
Quality indicator In the words of an expert, pricing is both an attraction variable and a repellent. Both high and low prices can be interpreted by customers as carrying services of good and not so good qualities. Actually, when service cues (signals) are strong, then high price gets accepted. Signals like brand image, advertising claims made for brands, guarantees offered, and overall reputation support high price. Customers take such signals as that of good quality and hence draw a relationship between good quality and high price. They feel more comfortable spending more on services that take away the psychological costs and fears.
When signals are weak or non-existent, customers do not want to spend money more than they think the service is worth. They would go for low price and try the service with not much money losing risk attached to it. In such situations, customers take low price as an indicator of low quality.
Customers, therefore, think there definitely is a relationship between price and the level of quality; the higher the price the better the quality and vice versa. However, an unknown company introducing a service without good reputation and the requisite communication support may not be able to attract customers toward a high price. High price, in other words, has to be supported by the signals discussed above.
Balances supply and demand Another important role played by price is that of a balancing agent in peak demand situations. It shifts demand to low demand periods, and we have learnt the role played by techniques like โDifferential Pricingโ and โYield Managementโ. While high price keeps demand at the optimal level, low price stimulates demand during slow periods.
Price Determinants
The following factors help companies determine the final price of services for their better marketability:
- Pricing objectives
- Cost analysis
- Demand-price schedule
- Price elasticity
- Competition
- Operational position
Pricing Objectives: Pricing is done in line with achievement of four different objectives:
- Profit maximization
- Sales maximization
- Market share maximization
- Competitive parity
When objective is profit maximization, companies go for a price that yields the highest potential profits; when the objective is sales maximization, the pricing should yield the highest possible revenue with profit constraints; when the objective is market share, the price should get the highest share again with profit constraints; and competitive parity gets companies a price very close to that of competition.
Cost Analysis: This analysis is basically done to take into consideration two groups of costs โ variable costs and fixed costs - in order for the company to arrive at the most appropriate gross margin figure. Gross margin must offer the company the opportunity of covering the variable costs and also ensuring a good return toward the fixed costs. How much margin is desirable is a function of the objectives. The margins will be lower in case of market share maximization.
It, however, is the objective of every company to improve margins regardless of the overall pricing objective. Companies undertake continual process improvement programs to improve margins and maintain prices. Banks, nowadays, are a case in point. With internet banking, banks find it more economical to do online consumer banking.
Demand/Price Schedule: To check the sensitivity of demand at various price levels, companies must work with different price levels and see how much demand is affected. They gauge the margins that different price levels offer the service. For that it is important that companies work out total revenue and variable costs to see how much is left to cover their fixed costs.
Depending upon the pricing objective, we go for the schedule that is best in line with it. From the schedule that appears as figure 62, it is obvious that schedule I is ideal for profit maximization, while schedule II is suitable for sales maximization.
Price Elasticity: PE of demand is the percentage change in demand as a ratio of a percentage change in price. This is described as under:
๐ Formula: Percentage change in demand / Percentage change in price
If the change in demand is greater than the change in price, then the price is elastic. If the change in demand is less than the change in price then the price is inelastic.
๐ Example: If a 5% increase in price leads to an 8% drop in demand, then the change in demand is greater than the change in price, hence price is elastic.
Obviously, businesses do not want to see price elasticity when they increase price. They like to see the volumes stick around the same level and add to their profits by selling the same volumes at a higher price.
For the obvious reasons again, businesses like to see price elasticity when they decrease prices, that is, they like to see demand surge greater than the decrease in price, so that total revenue increases. In this situation, firms, however, have to be careful not to increase volumes and revenues in a way that they lose contribution margins, which cannot compensate for the costs. If price decrease does not generate greater profits, it may not be worth the decision. It is important for the suppliers to determine the nature of demand their service carries and then make any pricing variations.
Competition: If prices of a companyโs services are adjusted at great variance from that of competition, then its services will have great price elasticity. Customers will opt for competition.
Operational Position: Cost-efficiency firms will opt for lower prices; their objective is to maximize market share. This means high volume, which is the lifeline of cost-efficiency position. Customization and quality positions will carry high prices, but then they also have to be careful about the existence of competition and the realities of the marketplace.
๐ก Why this matters: The operational position of a firm directly dictates its pricing strategy, linking internal efficiency or quality focus to external market positioning.
Approaches to pricing
We can easily conclude from the pricing determinants that the following three approaches seem quite common:
- Cost-based pricing
- Competition-based pricing
- Demand-based approach
Cost-based pricing is a reflection of the cost analysis and the demand-price schedule. It is based on the premise that companies add all the costs and a portion of profit to it and arrive at the final price. However, there are some difficulties inherent in this approach with regard to tracing and identifying variable costs. Such costs are input units of labor from different employees and are difficult to identify and cost when different levels of expertise are contributed by a host of employees to produce heterogeneous services at the same time. This costing approach is common among those industries in which pricing has to be worked out in advance, like advertising, engineering and construction.
It is not too challenging to have the variable and fixed costs associated with an engineering project worked out in advance. Same is the case with advertising, for agents know all the rates for different communication tools charged by the media.
It also is in vogue in services like medical, legal, and consultancies of the kind that need to bill their customers on hourly or a basis of time frame. Here, the sellers have to be a little careful and marketing savvy to charge according to the complexity of the case in addition to the input of time as units of labor.
Competition-based approach makes it imperative for sellers to follow and stay close to each other as part of the market dynamics. This approach is used predominantly in two situations: 1) when the services are highly standardized like courier services or dry cleaning; 2) when there is an oligopoly of sellers in a certain market, meaning a few large suppliers. Industries in both the situations work by โprice signalingโ and the โgoing-rateโ policies. Price signaling is any price offered by one company and it is matched by others, for example in transportation industry on different routes in most of the cases. Going-rate is charging the rate most prevalent in the market place.
There is a disadvantage inherent in this policy from the standpoint of small providers, who may not be able to afford either of the policies for the reason both may offer smaller margins than are mandatory for them to sustain and exist.
Demand-based approach takes into consideration the issues of reference pricing, non-monetary costs, and judging quality on the basis of price. The price is established in line with customersโ perception of value. What customers value the most becomes the basis of pricing.
Different customers look at value from a different perspective, and therefore companies should have different strategies to price services in line with different values of customers. One factor that companies must consider is the non-monetary costs. If taken care of, these cost factors may also become benefits for customers.
In other words, if a service causes time, inconvenience, search, and psychological costs, price should be adjusted accordingly to compensate for such costs; if service saves time, search, inconvenience, and psychological costs, then customers should pay a higher price. The challenge is to determine the value of each non-monetary cost so that such factors along with the costs sellers incur are built into the pricing from a value standpoint. Sellers must understand what is valued!
โญ Key Takeaways
Pricing in services plays a dual role: it signals quality when supported by strong brand or reputation signals, and it balances supply and demand through differential pricing. The six key price determinantsโobjectives, costs, demand-price schedules, elasticity, competition, and operational positionโmust be carefully analyzed together. Price elasticity measures demand sensitivity to price changes; businesses desire inelastic demand for price increases and elastic demand for price decreases. The three major pricing approaches are cost-based (adding costs plus profit margin), competition-based (using price signaling or going-rate policies), and demand-based (aligning price with customer perceived value and compensating for non-monetary costs). Ultimately, clarity on pricing objectives is essential before selecting the appropriate pricing determinants and approach.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two roles of pricing in services marketing, and how do strong service cues support a high-price strategy?
- Name the four pricing objectives and explain which demand-price schedule (Schedule I or II) corresponds to profit maximization versus sales maximization.
- Using the formula for price elasticity of demand, determine whether a 10% price cut that causes a 15% increase in demand makes the service elastic or inelastic.
- In which two market situations is the competition-based pricing approach predominantly used, and what are the policies (price signaling and going-rate) that govern it?
- What are non-monetary costs in the demand-based approach, and how should a seller adjust the price if the service reduces these costs for the customer?
๐ Lecture 44 โ Pricing Approaches & Customer Categories
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of pricing approaches in services marketing by categorizing customers based on their perception of value. It provides strategic pricing directions tailored to four distinct customer groups, enabling sellers to align their pricing strategies with what customers truly value.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers four customer categories based on value perception: customers who care about low price, customers who want everything they want, customers who believe in a trade-off between price and quality, and customers who demand maximum benefits for all costs. For each category, specific pricing strategies are discussed, including discounting, prestige pricing, skimming, bundling, and result-based pricing. The lecture concludes with the basis of demand-based pricing and guidance on selecting the appropriate approach.
๐ Lecture Summary
Customer categories
Four distinct scenarios define what constitutes value for customers:
- Customers who care about low price
- Customers who must get everything they want in a service
- Customers who think they will get the quality for the price they pay
- Customers who think they must get all for all they pay
Customers who care about low price:
For these customers, the greatest value comes through the lowest possible price. The less they pay or the more money they save, the more value they perceive. These customers are not necessarily quality-unconscious; they simply seek the seller offering the lowest price.
Strategies to offer value include:
- Discounting โ Making deals look special at various occasions. Fast food restaurants commonly use this strategy.
- Odd pricing โ Charging 19.99 instead of a full 20 (not rounding off the last currency unit).
- Synchro-pricing โ Creating a balance between supply and demand through differential pricing: โ Place differential โ Charging based on location sensitivity (e.g., front row seats at a performance, seats next to the players' pavilion in cricket command higher prices). โ Time differential โ Lower rates during off-peak times (e.g., lower phone rates post 11 PM). โ Quantity differential โ Special rates for bulk contracts (e.g., corporate customers with hotels and car rental companies).
- Penetration pricing โ Attracting customers with a low introductory price. This is tricky because customers may resist later price increases to regular levels. It works best when competition is intense, customers are unwilling to pay more, and sales volume is price-sensitive.
Customers who want to have everything they want:
These customers do not see price as the primary value; they focus on benefits the service offers and derive value from that. In education, some people prefer the highest tuition fee schools because they associate high price with high quality. Strategies include:
- Prestige pricing โ Charging a high price for a service that carries prestige and high quality. Hotels, airlines, and exclusive restaurants use this. Demand may actually soar with an increase in price. Examples: flying first class, presidential suites, restaurants with limited seats.
- Skimming pricing โ Charging a high price when a new, prestigious service is introduced, provided it has meaningful improvement over existing services. Example: When Airbus 380 (double-decker plane) was introduced, customers were willing to pay any price for the inaugural flight by Air Singapore from Singapore to Sydney.
Customers who think they will get the quality for what they pay:
These pragmatic customers believe in a trade-off between price and quality. Providers use segmentation to offer services with varying value tiers through:
- Customer category โ Charging lower than regular price for a specific segment (e.g., cafeteria pricing at a university versus restaurant pricing). The seller may lower operational costs or even absorb costs to offer value to that segment.
- Service category โ Adding more value-related attributes to a basic service and charging a compatible price. Example: A cafeteria business might expand into a full restaurant (moving from customer category to service version).
Customers who think they must get all for all they pay:
These customers are sharp assessors who want maximum benefits against all costs, including non-monetary costs. They are less loyal and prefer suppliers offering better value at attractive prices. Strategies include:
- Price bundling โ Combining several services and selling them as a package rather than individually. This simplifies purchase decisions for customers and allows sellers to include slow-moving items within the package. Bundling can be: โ Pure bundling โ Products that cannot be separated and are sold only as a bundle (e.g., Hajj and Umra packages with tickets, lodging, and transportation together). โ Mixed bundling โ Products that can be purchased separately but cost less when bought together (e.g., combo meals at fast food restaurants, mobile packages with calls, SMS, and internet).
- Complementary pricing โ Offering value on the front end of the service (e.g., mobile phone connection without security deposit) while generating revenue through subsequent usage (e.g., monthly billing). This works for services used on a continual basis.
- Result-based pricing โ Tagging pricing to the outcome the buyer wants, reducing uncertainty. Workable when high uncertainty prevents purchase decisions. Example: An advertising agency or attorney may get paid only if the outcome is positive. Different pricing levels can be tied to different outcome levels (e.g., 100% fee for 10% increase in sales, with a sliding scale).
The basis of demand-based pricing
The basis of demand-based pricing is the total value perception of customers about the service. Sellers must understand what different customer types value. Key questions include:
- What benefits are they looking for?
- How important are the benefits to them?
- In what context do customers want to enjoy the benefits?
- How do they relate particular benefits with a certain level of pricing?
The answers reveal that customers want value first, then relate that to a price level. Sellers gain clarity on customers' point of view (reflecting technical and functional quality dimensions) and then quantify monetary and non-monetary value.
Summary - Which approach to follow?
Sellers must understand customers by categorizing them into the four value propositions. Sellers have a mixed bag of pricing offers to choose from. Not all situations warrant one standard approach; most cases require a combination of all three approaches learned. The nature of service, competitive dynamics, and marketing mix options guide the appropriate approach.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is that pricing strategy must be driven by what the customer values, not by cost or competition alone. Customers fall into four distinct value perceptions: low price seekers, prestige/benefit seekers, pragmatic trade-off seekers, and maximum-benefit seekers. Each category demands a specific strategic responseโfrom discounting and penetration pricing to prestige, skimming, bundling, and result-based pricing. Sellers must remember that penetration pricing is risky because customers resist later price increases, and that demand may rise with price increases under prestige pricing. Finally, in practice, a combination of approaches is usually needed, with the basis being the customer's total value perception.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four categories of customers based on their perception of value?
- Explain the difference between "odd pricing" and "prestige pricing," and give an example of when each would be appropriate.
- What is synchro-pricing, and what three differentials does it use to balance supply and demand?
- Describe the difference between pure bundling and mixed bundling, and provide an example of each.
- Under what conditions would a seller use result-based pricing, and how might it be structured?