π Lecture 36 β Services Marketing (Continuation of Strategies for Having the Right People; Distribution)
π Overview: This lecture concludes the discussion on strategies for managing people by covering the need for supportive internal systems and employee retention. It then shifts focus to the role of distribution in services, explaining how availability and accessibility are achieved through different channel structures and options. Understanding these elements is critical for closing the service delivery gap (Gap 3).
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the final two strategies for having the right people: providing needed support systems (technology, internal processes, and measuring internal service quality) and retaining the best people through vision-sharing, treating employees as customers, and performance-based rewards. It then introduces the concept of developing a service culture. The latter half of the lecture transitions to distribution, covering its core meaning (availability and accessibility), channel structure (direct vs. indirect), four channel options (exclusive, selective, intensive, multichannel), and the concept of channel resizing due to technology.
π Lecture Summary
Provide Needed Support Systems
Without customer-oriented and customer-focused support systems, no organization can deliver high-quality service. These systems come from technology support and human support through teamwork. Internal support is a function of both the technology factor and the human factor.
Companies must measure internal service quality to ensure internal systems satisfy customers. This involves identifying internal customers and assessing how well departments support each other. For example, if department X provides support to department Y, then X defines its quality standards and lets Y, its customer, assess and score the reliability and overall quality of that support. If all internal suppliers satisfy all internal customers, the cumulative contribution leads to quality service for the final customer.
π Definition β Internal Customer: An employee or department within an organization that relies on another internal department for service or support. π‘ Why this matters: This concept applies the principles of external service quality to internal operations, fostering a chain of excellence.
Organizations must also provide supportive technology and equipment for service employees to work efficiently. This can include software from front office automation to CRM (customer relationship management) and ERP (enterprise resource planning) packages. Finally, firms must develop service-oriented internal processes designed with customer values and satisfaction in mind, rather than just controls and cost efficiency. This often requires process reengineering, which involves going back to the service blueprint to examine critical quality points or moments of truth.
Retain the best people
Once the right people are hired, trained, and supported, they must be retained. Many organizations take good people for granted, but retention requires a strategic approach.
First, companies should include employees in the companyβs vision. Sharing the companyβs destination and strategic moves with employees evokes a sense of bonding, commitment, and belongingness, making it more sensible for them to stay. Second, treat employees as customers. Top managers believe that a good employee culture and service culture complement each other. This interplay results in satisfied employees and customers, leading to revenue growth, profitability, and a strong service brand. Third, measure and reward strong service performance. Instead of only rewarding sales and productivity, companies should reward individuals for their efforts toward service excellence, for instance, by relating rewards to customer satisfaction scores, though this requires research.
π Definition β Service Climate: The shared perceptions of employees regarding the practices, procedures, and behaviors that are expected, supported, and rewarded with regard to customer service and service quality.
Developing a service culture
All the strategies discussed should help employees develop positive behaviors. The overall behavior of employees forms the organization's corporate culture, which is a set of shared values. For service companies, it is essential to develop a culture that is customer-focused, service-focused, and employee-focused. This culture promotes giving good service to both internal and external customers and appreciating good service, making it a βway of life.β This culture helps close Gap 3, which is the variation between service specifications/standards and the actual delivery of service.
Distribution
Distribution in services is about the availability and accessibility of a service to customers. Availability means the service exists, while accessibility means it is easy to find and transact with. A critical fundamental is operating hours, which must be compatible with the target segmentβs availability. Examples include banks extending working hours and installing ATMs, and the MCB bankβs mobile phone banking service (circa 2009) allowing transactions like balance checks and account transfers. The IT revolution has also transformed the travel industry, enabling ticket purchases over the internet.
π Definition β Availability: The condition of a service being present and ready for use by customers. π Definition β Accessibility: The ease with which a customer can find, contact, and conduct a transaction for a service.
Channel Structure
The basic objective of a channel structure is to make availability easy and widespread. Structures are of two types:
- Direct channels: No intermediary between the vendor and the customer.
- Indirect channels: Intermediaries exist between the vendor and the customer. Depending on the industry, companies use intermediaries that take different forms, from those rich in physical evidence to those requiring minimal evidence, like freelance agents.
Channel Options
Service sellers have four main channel options to meet goals of sustainability and growth:
- Exclusive distribution: Appointing a limited number of agents/outlets that can carry just one brand. Example: An American insurance company appointing MCB as its exclusive distributor for selling insurance through the bankβs network.
- Selective distribution: Appointing a few select parties as agents who might also work for other companies. Example: An American insurance company partnering with a couple of smaller banks.
- Intensive distribution: Placing the service with as many agents and third parties as possible to achieve very intensive and extensive outreach. Example: Credit card companies having retailers, restaurants, and hotels as agents. Fast food companies get into malls, airports, and campuses.
- Multichannel systems: Using more than one channel to reach more than one segment. This increases coverage and lowers distribution costs. Example: An airline selling tickets through its own reservation office, agents, and the internet, or using telemarketing alongside other networks.
Channel Resizing
Channels are constantly resized and reshaped due to advancements in IT and telecommunications. This has had both negative and positive effects. Negatively, some channels become squeezed, like travel agents whose existence is challenged by internet-based reservations, because airlines save on distribution costs by selling tickets online. Positively, technology has empowered courier companies to offer inventory management solutions, effectively taking over parts of the supply chain for manufacturers by shipping parts and equipment effectively.
β Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must remember that people management strategies extend beyond hiring to include providing support systems (technology and internal processes) and retaining talent by sharing the vision and rewarding service performance. The ultimate goal is to develop a service culture that closes Gap 3. For distribution, you must differentiate between availability and accessibility, and be able to define and provide an example for each of the four channel options: exclusive, selective, intensive, and multichannel systems. Finally, understand that technology drives channel resizing, negatively impacting some intermediaries (like travel agents) while creating new opportunities for others (like courier companies).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two key components of support systems for service employees, and why is measuring internal service quality important?
- Describe three strategies for retaining the best employees in a service organization.
- What is the difference between availability and accessibility in the context of service distribution? Give an example of each.
- Name and briefly define the four channel options available to service sellers, providing an example for each.
- Explain how technological advancement has caused channel resizing, citing one positive and one negative example from the lecture.
π Lecture 37 β Electronic Channels, Distribution Growth Options, and Franchising
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of electronic channels (ECs) in services marketing, highlighting their benefits and challenges. It then examines strategic options for distribution growth, including multi-site, multi-service, and multi-segment strategies. Finally, the concept of franchising is discussed as a rapid growth method, along with its benefits and constraints.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers four main areas: first, the definition and role of electronic channels in reshaping service distribution, including their ability to address inseparability and standardization. Second, the benefits of electronic channels such as low costs, customer convenience, customization, and feedback. Third, the challenges of electronic channels, including active customers, price competition, and design complexity. Fourth, distribution growth options/strategies like multi-site, multi-service, and multi-segment strategies. Finally, the lecture explains the concept of franchising, its benefits (capital, management, low risk), and its constraints (lower income, quality control).
π Lecture Summary
Electronic Channels-ECs
Electronic channels are playing a significant role in resizing channels of distribution. These channels are becoming popular, giving new shape and form to services in areas like education, entertainment, banking, music or movies on demand, media libraries, videoconferencing, and information dissemination. These services are pre-designed and pre-produced, which helps address the challenges of inseparability and allows for a form of standardization. The more these services are technology-supported, the more they mitigate problems of inseparability and non-standardization because there is no face-to-face interaction between providers and customers.
π Definition β Electronic Channels (ECs): Channels of distribution that are technology-based, pre-designed, and pre-produced, allowing for service delivery without direct face-to-face interaction.
Benefits of electronic channels
Low costs: Electronic channels offer several benefits. Apart from being standardized and pre-produced like tangible goods, they are quite low on costs. The cost of reaching the target audience is much lower than costs involved in personal selling or interpersonal services. However, to make the service output effective and powerful, sellers must make them interactive so customers can ask questions, interact, and assess the service as credible.
Customer convenience: Electronic channels provide convenience to customers by allowing them to access sellers anytime. Vendors are available 24/7 to take customer orders or offer the promised service.
Customization and feedback: Customers can customize services from their home or workplace without visiting a facility by selecting suitable features. This requires sellers to offer as many choices as possible for customization.
Customer feedback: Obtaining customer feedback is easy due to customers' online presence. Building a system to collect customer opinions and reactions is quick and productive. Problems can be identified, recovery fixed, and learning imbibed for future improvements.
Challenges
Active and selective customers: Customers who use web-based applications do so at will, meaning they can opt out or not be enticed at all. Unlike TV audiences, web audiences are selective and active, not passive and captive. Sellers must design webs and channels to be attractive and enticing, often offering prizes through contests.
Price competition: The traditional service characteristic of being available only with the seller, hiding competitor prices, is no longer true with ECs. Just like tangible goods sitting side by side at a retail store, customers can access prices of e-services sold through the internet and draw comparisons.
Making it interactive and hence customized: A challenge is sellers' ability to customize highly standardized and pre-designed services like distance education. The solution lies in offering courses students want and making the process as interactive as possible to simulate a real classroom environment.
Simplify difficult and frustrating designs: Sellers must make websites user-friendly so users do not feel offended or intimidated by a challenging, time-consuming, or incomprehensible web experience. To make customer involvement pleasing, webs should be easy and inviting, not giving the impression they are only for a select few.
Requires a fundamental change: Using ECs requires a fundamental change in customer behavior. Customers must be enticed into web-based programs to play a more active role. This also requires a well-aligned coordinative relationship between selling companies and banks through which payments are routed.
Distribution Growth Options/Strategies
There are three primary strategies for distribution growth:
Multi-site strategy: This involves expanding locations by having more than one site as growth dictates. This strategy is generally adopted by businesses specializing in a cost efficiency position. A highly standardized operation is easy to duplicate, so sites are added to the existing network. A caution is that expansion should be well-deliberated and not pushed, as undue pushing may thin out resources and compromise quality standards.
Multi-service strategy: This is the option to sell more services than one at the same facility. It is logical for businesses to add product extensions to optimize revenues and growth opportunities. Businesses with positions of customization and service functional quality often choose this strategy. However, it is important to distinguish between core products and peripheral products. Core products are the mainstay of the business; adding new core products is like starting a new business, which taxes resources and may hamper efficiency. Peripheral services support the core and are derived from it. For example, a courier service adding home/office cleaning is adding a new core product, while adding select retail items like gifts is a peripheral addition.
π Definition β Core Products: The main line of business and the primary service offering. π Definition β Peripheral Products: Services that support the core product and are derived from it.
Multi-segment strategy: This allows companies to make adjustments between high and low demand periods, helping utilize underutilized capacity for additional segments. For example, a wedding hall unused during the day can offer business meetings with lunch. Challenges include dealing with different demand structures, modifying the existing environment, and training people for differences in demand structures. This strategy lets companies develop without new locations by utilizing existing ones better.
Companies can use variations and combinations of these strategies, but fundamentals include improving revenues and returns, improving cost efficiency, and not letting overhead costs go out of control. Growth should not happen at the cost of quality and operating costs.
Franchising
Franchising is the selling of a service concept to a third party who agrees to establish and operate a service facility according to the franchiserβs specifications. Since capital investment is the franchiseeβs responsibility, it is a rapid way of growing through multi-site strategy with minimal capital. The facility must be designed per franchiserβs guidelines.
Benefits:
- Capital cost benefit: Brings in outside capital without pressure on the business, allowing faster growth.
- Franchiseeβs management: The franchisee brings additional management, often with prior experience and local market knowledge.
- Low risk to franchisee: Offers lower risk as the franchisee benefits from an established brand name and successful business plans.
- Advertising support to franchisee: The franchisee receives support in advertising, promotions, and technical issues, while the franchiser gets a fee.
Constraints:
- Lower income: This relationship offers lower returns to both parties compared to an independent business, but this is offset by bigger overall income from a strong brand name.
- Quality control: Quality control and operational issues become a challenge because the franchiser does not have total control.
- Physical environment: The franchisee may want to deviate from the franchiser's standards, compromising the blueprint.
- Motivation: Motivating the franchisee can be a problem if their goals differ from those of the franchiser.
- Line extension constraints: The franchisee may be unable to add beneficial peripheral services due to the franchiser's stringent policies.
- Operational position: Franchising is suitable for a cost efficiency position with standardized operations; a customized business may not find it suitable.
π Definition β Franchising: Selling a service concept to a third party who agrees to establish and operate a service facility according to the franchiser's specifications.
π‘ Why this matters: Franchising allows rapid expansion with minimal capital, but it requires careful management of quality and alignment between franchiser and franchisee goals.
β Key Takeaways
- Electronic channels (ECs) help overcome service inseparability and non-standardization by being pre-designed and pre-produced, but they require attractive, user-friendly designs to engage active and selective web audiences.
- Benefits of ECs include low costs, 24/7 customer convenience, customization, and easy feedback collection, but challenges include price competition, the need for interactivity, and requiring a fundamental change in customer behavior.
- Three primary distribution growth strategies are multi-site (expansion via standardized duplication for cost efficiency), multi-service (adding services, distinguishing core from peripheral), and multi-segment (using underutilized capacity for different demand segments).
- Franchising enables rapid multi-site growth with minimal capital by leveraging outside investment, but it comes with constraints like lower income for both parties and challenges in quality control, motivation, and physical environment.
- When growing, businesses must improve revenues and returns, achieve cost efficiencies, and avoid letting overhead costs go out of controlβgrowth should never compromise quality.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are electronic channels, and how do they address the challenges of inseparability and non-standardization in services?
- List three benefits and three challenges of using electronic channels for service distribution.
- What are the three primary distribution growth strategies? Explain when each is most suitable.
- What is the difference between a core product and a peripheral product in the context of a multi-service strategy?
- What are three benefits and three constraints of franchising as a distribution growth method?
π Lecture 38 β Distribution Management & Managing Supply and Demand
π Overview: This lecture explores the critical components of distribution management for multi-site service organizations, focusing on organizational structures and economies of scale. It then transitions into the vital topic of managing supply and demand, addressing the unique challenges posed by the perishability of services and providing strategies to match capacity with fluctuating demand.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by examining distribution management, focusing on organizational structure (centralized vs. decentralized) and economies of scale (service-specific, site-specific, firm-specific) as key components for growth. It emphasizes the importance of maintaining quality and a tri-focus on customers, employees, and the service itself during expansion. The lecture then shifts to managing supply and demand, explaining the concept of optimal capacity (70-80%) and outlining steps to analyze demand patterns. Finally, it details seven strategies for managing supply, including using part-time employees, overtime, peak-time operating procedures, cross-training, and increasing customer participation.
π Lecture Summary
Distribution Management
When a business grows to have more than one site, managing distribution channels becomes important. Companies must focus on two key components: organizational structure and economies of scale.
Organization structure
The structure can be either centralized or decentralized. For highly standardized, multi-site services, a centralized structure is more appropriate, where most decision-making and authority rest with the top management. Tasks are simple and predictable. For multi-service setups defined by functional quality, the structure tends to be decentralized. A five-star hotel offering different services locally would want authority for pricing and strategic decisions to be made locally, given local market realities. Authority of each branch should be high because of the functional quality attributes at play.
Economies of Scale
Economies of scale are cost advantages associated with operations. They result when companies produce or buy in large quantities and make more effective use of organizational resources, including employee skills and knowledge. Growth should offer scale economies in more than one area:
- Financial area: Profitability from expansion should reach a point where the company can reinvest a portion to finance more growth, reducing dependence on outside sources.
- Marketing area: Growth should reduce the need to spend on advertising for new sites. The brand image should optimize marketing expenditure.
- Operations area: Expansion should offer three types of economies:
- Service-specific economies: From division of labor and specialization. Replicating the business model increases these chances.
- Site-specific economies: When a company offers more than one service at one particular site. Capital expenditure on physical assets is already accrued.
- Firm-specific economies: A combination of the preceding two, plus an additional economy from the size of management. A given management size can be optimal for a number of sites. Outsourcing could be another advantage if cheaper than producing in-house.
π Definition β Economies of Scale: cost advantages associated with operations that result when companies produce in large quantities, buy in large quantities, and make more effective use of organizational resources than competitors, including the collective skills and knowledge of their employees. π Example: A chain of coffee shops opens 5 new outlets. Economies of scale would be achieved if the company's marketing department does not need to double its budget to promote the new outlets because the existing brand reputation already attracts customers. Meanwhile, the same regional management team can oversee all new locations, and bulk coffee bean purchases reduce the cost per cup.
The Quality Aspect
Growing in a way that compromises quality is against the fundamentals of customer-focused service. If quality declines, sales will go down due to customer defection. Recovery is a huge challenge. Companies must have the right people and financial resources to meet this challenge. They must specialize in creating a culture that is customer-focused, service-focused, and employee-focused β a tri-focus. The beauty of the growth pattern should show itself in the development of a culture that ensures this tri-focus along with good financial results.
Managing supply and demand
Services are perishable and cannot be stored; they must be generated real-time on demand. Demand fluctuation poses a challenge. Sometimes demand exceeds capacity, while at other times capacity is underutilized. Both are bad: unmet demand deprives the company of added revenue, while underutilized capacity can lead to outright loss.
Maximum and Optimal capacity
Empirical evidence shows that 100% capacity utilization stresses a companyβs capability to deliver total quality. A lower utilization between 70-80% is considered optimal capacity utilization, enabling the best possible resource use without stress. This rule of thumb may not apply to all industries (e.g., a sports stadium or utility company), but the challenge remains to estimate the optimal level of demand.
π Definition β Optimal Capacity Utilization: A level of capacity utilization, typically between 70-80%, that enables a company to use its resources in the best possible way without the stress that can compromise total quality.
Steps in managing supply and demand
The steps involved are:
- Determining the demand pattern
- Assessing the causes of variation in demand
- Developing methods for managing supply
- Developing methods for managing demand
Managing demand
Determining pattern of demand: Since all purchases are recorded, companies have complete historical data. Historical data becomes the basis for determining demand patterns across different periods. The highs and lows of demand are caused by season, weather, or particular occasions (e.g., HAJJ causing an upsurge in air travel; northern area hotels experiencing increased demand during hot months and winter).
Managing Supply
Managing supply involves altering a company's output capabilities. During high demand, companies expand supply; during low periods, they contract output. This is done by adopting the following strategies:
- Part-time employees: An economical approach to meet excess demand during high season without the cost of regulars during lean periods. However, from a marketing perspective, there are concerns about their training, knowledge, productivity, and service orientation, which can increase GAP 3. The solution is to treat them fairly and give them adequate training to optimize their service orientation.
- Employees working overtime: This uses regulars for extended hours. It is costlier than part-timers (one and a half to two times regular pay) and can lead to fatigue and reduced productivity. However, regulars are more knowledgeable and know the customers. The trick is to have regulars perform optimally and train part-timers if needed.
- Peak time operating procedures: This involves shifting non-essential tasks (e.g., cleaning in a fast-food facility) to non-peak hours to free up staff for customer service. While it optimizes capacity, it may compromise cleanliness, creating a negative perception. Companies should use perception management to distract customers (e.g., with TVs or music) or get their input on which tasks can be shifted.
- Cross-training employees: This lets firms flex capacity by having people knowledgeable about different jobs to help complete tasks quickly and keep bottlenecks away. The quality challenge is that inputs may be from those who are not real experts, calling for proper training via internal marketing.
- Increasing customer participation
- Sharing facilities with other firms
- Outsourcing
π Definition β Perception Management: Techniques used by companies to make customers perceive that the time they have spent waiting is less than it actually has been, often through environmental improvements and distractions like TVs or music.
β Key Takeaways
- For multi-site service firms, the choice between a centralized or decentralized structure must align with the service's standardization and the need for local decision-making.
- Growth must be planned to achieve economies of scale in financial, marketing, and operational areas (service-specific, site-specific, and firm-specific). The quality triangle (customer, service, employee focus) must never be compromised.
- Services cannot be stored, so managing the mismatch between supply and demand is critical. The optimal capacity utilization is 70-80% to maintain quality without stress.
- Managing supply involves strategies like hiring part-timers, using overtime, and cross-training, each with trade-offs between cost, quality, and service delivery. Perception management is a key tool when using peak-time procedures.
- The first step to managing supply and demand is to analyze historical data to determine demand patterns and understand their causes (e.g., seasonality, events).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main components of distribution management for a growing multi-site company?
- Explain the difference between service-specific, site-specific, and firm-specific economies of scale in operations.
- What is the optimal range for capacity utilization for most service businesses, and why is 100% utilization not ideal?
- List four strategies that a service firm can use to expand its supply during periods of high demand.
- What is "perception management," and in which supply management strategy is it most commonly used?
π Lecture 39 β Services Marketing Strategic Demand and Supply Management
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on managing supply side and examines strategies for managing demand. It covers tools for strategic demand management, including when to stimulate demand with incentives during low periods and when to shift demand from peak to low periods. The important concepts of differential pricing and yield management are also discussed in depth.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture explores increasing customer participation and sharing facilities as capacity enhancement methods, followed by outsourcing strategies. It then covers three demand management strategies (shifting usage, decreasing usage, stimulating usage), tools for managing demand including reservations, differential pricing, and communication. The lecture concludes with coping with fluctuating demand through part-timers, overtime, cross-training, and outsourcing, followed by a detailed explanation of yield management and its challenges.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction
The lecture continues with management of supply side and looks into strategies for managing demand. Toward strategic formulation, the tools for managing demand are discussed. The thrust of the lecture is toward learning when to stimulate demand with incentives in low periods and when to shift demand from peak period to low period. The important concepts of differential pricing and yield management are also discussed.
Supply Side Management Strategies
Increase customer participation: To serve more customers and optimize revenues, companies like to involve customers in the delivery process to hasten it. Examples are self-service cafeterias and buffet lunches or dinners. The idea is to keep their employees at a number not exceeding the one that exists during lean hours and let customers do the job through their involvement.
Whereas it may work for buffets and cafeterias and ATMs, it may arouse feelings of dislike for certain other jobs that customers may have to do by themselves. Just think of a minor service of checking the tire pressure of your car or motorbike. Your involvement as a customer who has to do it himself may take you to another location where you are fully served. Businesses have found many services getting choked up due to customers' inexperience or dislike, and therefore they have to be sensitive to the nature of business they are in.
Sharing facilities: Many firms may like to share facilities with other firms to improve their capacity. To internationalize its service, a courier service may like to get into such an agreement with another firm that may offer to handle the wishing company's business internationally, as long as it is not a threat to the offering company's business and offers viable commercial attractions. Actually, the offering company may get into some other kind of venture with the wishing company to make gains on another account.
Outsourcing: Yet another important approach to capacity enhancement, outsourcing works well for certain industries like catering and data processing. A better decision is to outsource to another outfit the peripheral services and not the core. A catering service outsourcing part of the food is not doing it for the core product, which is a composite of specializations in different kinds of foods, menu management, and a unique style of delivery.
Outsourcing frees up a company's time for the core service products and hence giving it more capacity. Outsourcing jobs like data processing is very popular for the reason that it may not be the company's core product. Call centers are a classic example of outsourcing of voice data handling and management. Think of a call center that handles the operations of huge retail stores and airlines.
Even HR function is nowadays being outsourced to HR consultants who specialize in functions like hiring, staffing, keeping employee records, and maintaining other HR information systems.
π‘ Why this matters: These supply-side strategies allow service firms to expand capacity without making permanent investments in infrastructure or full-time employees.
Demand Management Strategies
There are basically three strategies that companies can use to manage demand:
- Shift usage to a lean period
- Decrease usage at the peak period
- Stimulate usage during lean period
Shifting usage to a lean period has some advantages. By shifting usage we do not lose business. Service quality is not affected. Income is not lost. Efficiency improves, for we can bring the business to an optimal level. However, whether or not we can shift usage is a question. The answer lies in understanding the demand pattern and the causes of variation.
Shifting the usage depends, in many cases, on customers' ability to have control over the causes of fluctuation. If customers use a particular bus service for commuting to office in the morning and back home in the evening, this business cannot be shifted, for customers do not have control over the cause that may actuate them to shift the usage β getting to office and home at timings of their choice.
Services on which customers can exercise control relating the cause of shift, sellers should try to actuate that shift with certain incentives. Incentive-based shift may work for air travel in the case of those travelers who may opt to travel during the week days at lower rates. In such a situation, airlines can shift the week end rush to the week days for those who are willing to accept the shift.
Decreasing usage becomes inevitable when usage cannot be shifted and demand has exceeded the supply.
Stimulating demand during the lean period is done in a bid to utilize the resources and ensure there is no wastage. Hotels at resorts can get into this mode during slow periods. Restaurants do the same thing if demand is low for lunch; they may opt to start a breakfast service to fully utilize all the resources that stand committed to the operation.
Tools for Managing Demand
Sellers have at their disposal the following tools they can use as strategic moves to better manage demand:
- Reservations
- Differential pricing
- Communication
Reservations are used as a standard practice by professional services like medical, legal, and consultancies of different kinds with the basic objective of managing a consistent customer inflow and hence demand. Services like hotels, restaurants, and airlines also do the same to ensure availability for their customers upon arrival and thus managing demand in an optimal manner. In addition to guaranteeing availability of the service, sellers can shift demand and hence the usage to periods which are desired by sellers for being more practical. They will never let the customers know of this move, who will upon revelation of this maneuver be annoyed.
Differential pricing is another interesting tool available for managing demand. A low price for low demand period and a high price during high demand period are reflections of a differential pricing model.
Incentives during low demand periods and higher prices at peak demand periods are the moves companies make. Incentives during low demand period may stimulate demand, while higher prices during peak periods help to curtail excessive demand and shift it to low demand periods. Demand will decrease in the case customers are not willing to pay a higher price. This may not cause a loss to the company that in any case is not in a position to entertain the excess demand.
Using high differential pricing is a good strategy, for it brings in more revenue regardless of whether demand can be shifted or not. It is even better if demand consistently exceeds supply. And, it is best if the shift takes place!
It is for this reason that airlines have a unique system of charging you a higher price as and when plane capacity increases. Same is the case with hotels and business centers.
Communication of the strategic moves lets customers know what companies are up to. Whether they are stimulating demand or shifting usage, there has to be communication from the seller directed at customers to know what is going on. Communication by employees can also be undertaken to educate customers about scheduling their activities in a manner most conducive to the sellers' work schedules. In an auto garage, workers can convincingly tell their customers the best time of the day they should prefer. In other words, the frontline or onstage component can easily convince customers to alter their demand.
Advertising can do a trick when companies announce their long working hours. The objective is to give customers the flexibility of visiting the facility by altering their demand pattern. When people know they can avail of a certain service after office hours, they will flex their schedules. The problem, however, will occur if most of the customers shift their usage after office hours.
Communication by customers to other customers is yet another way of spreading the word around for the intended strategy. Customers tell other customers from their experience about which time of the day or the season is the best time to buy a particular service.
Coping with Fluctuating Demand
It basically relates to flexing supply and expanding it to absorb an upsurge in demand. There are a few strategies at the disposal of sellers, but the ones that are most common among many of them are:
- Going for part-timers
- Having existing staff work overtime
- Cross-training
- Outsourcing
Part-timers are good for low-skill jobs that are offered by sellers of cost efficiency position. Conversely, regulars are not good for such positions, for they add to costs. Regulars are best suited to businesses that are into customization and functional quality positions.
For services like tax consultancies or accountancy firms, part-timers may not be as useful as regular ones putting in overtime. This owes to special skills and knowledge about the jobs that are undertaken by the staff.
Outsourcing is another popular strategy that works in both cost-efficiency and customization positions. Cost efficiency position can relate to catering and janitorial services etc. Customization can relate to consultancies and HR etc. Many consultancy firms hire freelance, but highly qualified personnel whenever there is an upsurge in demand making expansion of capacity inevitable.
The fact remains that fluctuating demand can best be managed by a mix of both supply side and demand side strategies. This implies expanding supply and curtailing demand at peak time. Most companies will expand their capacity first to the maximum. Thereafter, they get into curtailing the peak demand. By doing so, they can maximize their revenues. The phenomenon is illustrated graphically in the accompanying figure 59.
Figure 59 Presentation: The presentation is self-explanatory. However, what is of interest here is the shift that is shown taking place from "high period" to "low period".
Yield Management
This concept is about balancing capacity utilization, pricing, market segmentation, and financial returns. Basically a pricing tool, it seeks help of a methodology that maximizes revenues based on a detailed analysis of the past purchase behavior of different segments a company serves.
The analysis is carried out with the help of computer-based models that use historical data and sophisticated mathematical algorithms to come up with a mix of pricing for different segments. By selling at differential pricing, organizations find the best balance among the prices charged, available capacity, and the segments to which the capacity is sold. The objective remains to maximize financial returns from the capacity.
The model is extensively used by the airlines industry and works opposite to the concept of running out stocks of tangible goods. In case of tangibles, the arrival of a new model or design may make the existing stocks less attractive and force sellers to start reducing their prices in order to make room for the new model. Yield management, conversely, starts with selling at the lowest price and gradually builds up on pricing as capacity starts receding.
π Definition β Yield Management: "The process of allocating the right capacity to the right segment at the right price" to maximize revenues. Yield is a measure of the extent to which a company's capacities can exploit its revenue generating potential.
π Example: An airline instead of selling all 200 seats at PKR 5,000 each and generating PKR 1 million would like to maximize this level of revenue by keeping the base price of 5,000 for a certain segment and charging higher price to other segments.
People who buy tickets early pay less; they are price conscious customers. Those who come later pay more. They may still be price conscious customers or leisure travelers; they pay a little higher for buying a little late. The ones who are further late pay even more. And, those who are the last ones to buy tickets are the ones whose schedules are inflexible; they have to fly for business or emergencies due to which they buy almost at the last moment and at the highest price.
The interesting phenomenon about yield management is its ability to maximize revenues in any situation. If it is low period and sales are projected to be half the plane's capacity, yield management still has the potential to bring the company more revenue than cutting the price to stimulate demand. Instead of giving a straight price cut, airlines offer different pricing even in a low period by offering different pricing to different segments and maximize revenues.
π‘ Why this matters: Yield management represents the most sophisticated approach to revenue optimization in services, particularly for industries with perishable capacity like airlines, hotels, and rental car companies.
How does the model work? Once the model has worked out the potential capacities for different segments, the information is passed on to sales people and representatives who make bookings accordingly. Since the model is most successful in airlines and has been in existence for more than 20 years, decisions are continuously made on how many seats to give to which segment at what price; it may change on hourly basis.
There are two important conditions for this model to work:
- A service seller has more than one segment to serve and those segments arrive for reservations at different times.
- Those who arrive early for reservations are more price conscious than those who arrive late.
Over-bookings are done to compensate for "no shows". In case they are more than it was projected or cancellations take place, the last minute sale at low pricing is initiated to stimulate demand generally through internet and also agents.
Challenges
Along with benefits of revenue maximization, yield management also carries some disadvantages:
- Too much revenue focusing may result in a loss of competitive focus and hence quality of service
- Customers get annoyed upon revelation of having paid more than others. Customer education is important for them to understand the reasons and rationale behind it
- Employees feel a little down for not being able to use their judgment and discretion because of restrictions inherent in the working of the model
- Employees may also not find it compatible with the rewards that they get against bookings
- Employees may feel they have not been trained to effectively use the model
Summary
The greatest challenge that sellers face is expansion of supply when demand for the service soars and filling capacity when demand drops. Tools to deal with both situations should be carefully considered and then applied to cope with the emerging situation. Differential pricing is an exciting idea that helps sellers look into the variations of demand patterns and then come up with the relevant price with the objective of optimizing revenues. It should reflect that proper considerations of flexing supply, shifting of usage, and offering customer-suitable timings have been taken into account.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture emphasizes that managing fluctuating demand requires a dual approach: expanding supply during peak periods and curtailing or shifting demand when supply is constrained. The three core demand management strategiesβshifting usage, decreasing usage, and stimulating usageβmust be matched with appropriate tools like reservations, differential pricing, and communication. Yield management is the most advanced pricing tool that allocates the right capacity to the right segment at the right price to maximize revenues, working opposite to tangible goods pricing by starting low and increasing as capacity decreases. However, yield management carries challenges including customer dissatisfaction upon discovering price differences and employee frustration with reduced discretion. Ultimately, the most effective approach combines both supply-side and demand-side strategies for optimal resource utilization and revenue generation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main demand management strategies discussed in this lecture, and when should each be applied?
- How does yield management differ from traditional pricing of tangible goods, and what two conditions are necessary for it to work effectively?
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of using part-timers versus having regular staff work overtime for coping with fluctuating demand?
- Explain the concept of differential pricing and provide an example of how an airline might use it to manage demand across different customer segments.
- What are the five challenges associated with yield management, and how might a company address the issue of customer annoyance upon discovering differential pricing?