๐ Lecture 27 โ Efficiency and Productivity through Blueprinting
๐ Overview: This lecture builds on the concept of service blueprinting by exploring its role in achieving cost efficiency and productivity. It identifies operational bottlenecks as key constraints on output and explains how blueprinting helps streamline processes. The lecture also outlines important considerations for developing a comprehensive blueprint and details the multiple benefits such a blueprint offers an organization.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture first addresses how blueprinting is used to identify operational bottlenecks and improve efficiency and productivity through process time calculations. It then presents six key considerations for creating a complete and effective service blueprint, including clarity on process scope, customer segment focus, and team involvement. Finally, the lecture enumerates ten specific benefits of proper blueprinting, ranging from role clarity and fail point identification to cost assessment and improved communication.
๐ Lecture Summary
Efficiency and Productivity
One of the important objectives of blueprinting is to ensure maximum efficiency and productivity out of an operational service design. This is achieved by calculating process time for each task performed by an individual or group. That calculation, when related to output of different stages, reveals operational bottlenecks (OBs). OBs are the points in an operation that restrict the maximum output of a process.
๐ Definition โ Operational Bottleneck (OB): A point in an operation that restricts the maximum output of a process.
๐ Example: If the output of sandwiches in a kitchen is blocked at the point of packing, then packing becomes an OB. The operation must be streamlined either by employing more packers or utilizing the services of those who are underutilized. Through blueprinting, we can identify points of over- and underutilization and make adjustments to streamline the process.
When we remove the OB at the point of packing, we increase overall output. Dividing the total cost of production by increased output reveals a decline in cost per sandwich. By doing this, we cut costs on one hand and improve productivity on the other. Service blueprinting therefore becomes a good base for working out optimal efficiency and productivity.
๐ก Why this matters: This demonstrates the direct financial and operational value of blueprintingโit is not just a diagram but a tool for cost reduction and throughput improvement.
Considerations for a complete blueprint
For the sake of completeness, certain questions must be asked to keep the process of blueprinting comprehensive. The following considerations are essential:
-
We must be clear about the process to be mapped and why we map it. Where does it begin and end? Are we mapping just one component or the entire service? The focus must be on the customer. We must also know the touch points or interactions within and among various departments.
-
We must be clear about the segment we are dealing with. Every segment has its requirements in terms of service delivery, so only one segment should be portrayedโthat is, just one service and one segment on the blueprint. We must avoid blueprinting the in-house service and the direct delivery service offered by a restaurant, as these are two different processes with their own relevant dynamics.
-
It is a team effort and everyone who matters across departments should be involved. It is a multi-departmental exercise, not a task assigned to one individual or a section that may operate in isolation.
-
We must always map a design that is close to the desired level of service, meaning even if it requires more human resource and a longer sequence of service, we should consider doing that. Likewise, if a change becomes desirable in an existing process, we should be ready to incorporate that into the blueprint.
-
It may not be a bad idea to blueprint the possible fail points and incorporate the same in the process as a recovery exercise, whenever needed.
-
The blueprint ideally should contain all the details of the process unless it is being used in the concept development stage.
Benefits of blueprinting
If given proper considerations, a blueprint can offer the following benefits:
-
All personnel involved in the process can see their roles and relationships as part of an integrated effort.
-
It identifies possible fail points and, as such, companies can incorporate recovery strategies into the blueprint, making it a well-designed program of recovery.
-
It identifies all those points where customers experience quality and, as such, can be stressed in terms of internal marketing for staff training.
-
The line of visibility makes it a conscious effort on the part of the company to decide what customers should see and what they should not see.
-
The line of internal interaction and encounters makes the job of describing jobs easy and fruitful, not leaving anything to imagination and vagueness.
-
It kick-starts strategic discussion on all procedures by involving everyone, excluding chances of omissions and also making it realistic for everyone to realize and appreciate the roles and contributions of others.
-
It becomes the basis of assessing costs, revenues, and capital expenditure. Different tasks are representations of all fundamental financial elements.
-
It becomes the basis of both internal and external marketing.
-
It facilitates top-down and bottom-up communication, thus improving quality of delivery through interaction of all kindsโnot only procedural but also philosophical in terms of discussions on improved features.
-
It helps to balance output of various personnel. It indicates points where people are either over- or under-worked.
๐ก Why this matters: The benefits span operational, financial, strategic, and human resource domains, making blueprinting a foundational tool for service management.
โญ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that blueprinting is a practical tool for identifying operational bottlenecks (OBs), which are points restricting maximum output. By calculating process time and adjusting resource allocation around OBs, companies can reduce costs and improve productivity simultaneously. When creating a blueprint, it is critical to map only one segment per blueprint, involve all relevant departments as a team, and include fail points for recovery strategies. The benefits of a well-designed blueprint are extensive: it clarifies roles, identifies quality touchpoints, enables cost and revenue assessment, facilitates internal marketing, and balances workload across personnel. The line of visibility is a key design decision that determines what customers see versus what remains backstage.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is an operational bottleneck (OB) and how does blueprinting help address it?
- Why should only one service and one customer segment be portrayed on a single blueprint?
- List three of the ten benefits that a comprehensive service blueprint provides to an organization.
- What is the "line of visibility" in a blueprint and why is it strategically important?
- How does removing an operational bottleneck at the point of packing in a sandwich kitchen lead to lower cost per unit?
๐ Lecture 28 โ Establishing an Operational Position
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the concept of operational positioning in services marketing. Unlike manufacturing, services cannot leverage mass production due to their inseparable nature, but they can still adopt operational positions focused on cost efficiency, customization, or service quality. The lecture also explains how complexity and divergence of service processes must align with the chosen operational position for strategic success.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture introduces the three operational positions for services: cost efficiency, customization, and service quality. It explains that firms must excel in one position while maintaining competitive parity in the other two. The lecture then presents the concepts of complexity and divergence in service processes, showing how these dimensions relate to operational positioning through a matrix. Examples from fast food and consulting illustrate these concepts.
๐ Lecture Summary
Establishing an Operational Position
In manufacturing, tangible goods can be produced before consumption, allowing for mass production and economies of scale through unit production, batch production, mass production, or continuous process. Services, however, are inseparableโproduction and consumption occur simultaneouslyโpreventing providers from achieving the same efficiencies. Despite this, service firms can adapt manufacturing concepts into three operational positions: cost efficiency, customization, and service quality. Emphasizing one position does not mean neglecting the others; firms must maintain competitive parity on the two non-primary positions while excelling in their chosen focus.
๐ Definition โ Operational Position: The strategic emphasis a service firm chooses to differentiate itself, based on cost efficiency, customization, or service quality.
Cost efficiency involves industrializing procedures for high efficiency, controlling costs to keep them lower than competitors'. This approach is mandatory when offering high volumes, as it helps "do things right the first time," saving costs, time, and money.
Customization allows providers to tailor service design to individual customer needs, fulfilling heterogeneous needs within the same segment. This position is inevitable in industries with varied products, such as consultancies, and requires excellence in both technical and functional aspects. Costs can be high under this approach.
Service Quality emphasizes very high quality to outcompete rivals. Superior quality can be represented either by technical aspects or functional dimensions like responsiveness, adaptability, spontaneity, assurance, and empathy.
Every company should choose an operational position reflecting its expertise. For example, McDonald's specializes in industrializing burger making and delivery, ensuring consistency across locations (e.g., Lahore, London, Los Angeles). Subway, conversely, customizes sandwiches according to customer taste, with variations of ingredients prepared in front of the customer, addressing heterogeneity. Both companies also pursue cost efficiency and quality, but their operational positions highlight their unique strengths.
A figure in the lecture shows one firm positioned for "cost efficiency," two for "service quality" (one technical, one functional), and none for "customization." Four firms sit in the middle without a position, which is problematicโthey should choose a position aligning with their operational strengths.
๐ก Why this matters: Without a clear operational position, a service firm risks being "average" in all areas, failing to differentiate and build a sustainable competitive advantage.
Complexity and Divergence
Service processes can be analyzed based on complexity and divergence. Complexity refers to the number of steps and the sequence involved in executing those steps. Divergence refers to the variability and latitude involved in executing the service. A large number of steps makes the design more complex; fewer steps keep it less complex. High divergence offers many execution options; low divergence allows only one way to perform the service.
๐ Definition โ Complexity: The number of steps and sequence in a service process. ๐ Definition โ Divergence: The variability and latitude in executing a service.
A fast food service is low in both complexity and divergence, as processes are standardized and sequential. A consulting service is high in both, involving many variable steps and latitude in execution. Complexity and divergence must correspond with the firm's chosen operational position.
A matrix with four quadrants (figure 46 in the lecture) reflects the complexity-divergence relationship. Different businesses fall into different quadrants, and blueprinting helps clarify the intensity of complexity and divergence. An accompanying chart (figure 47) details how specific businesses relate their complexity and divergence to their operational position.
๐ Example: A fast food restaurant like McDonald's, with low complexity and low divergence, aligns with a cost efficiency operational position, while a high-complexity, high-divergence consulting firm aligns with customization or service quality.
โญ Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must remember that service firms have three operational positionsโcost efficiency, customization, and service qualityโand must choose one to excel in while maintaining parity on the other two. The concepts of complexity (number of steps) and divergence (variability in execution) are critical for analyzing service processes. These two dimensions must logically correspond with the operational position; for instance, low complexity and low divergence suit cost efficiency. Blueprinting helps determine where a service falls in the complexity-divergence matrix, and firms that do not choose an operational position risk lacking specialization. Real-world examples like McDonald's (cost efficiency) and Subway (customization) illustrate how operational positions are implemented.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three operational positions a service firm can choose from, and why must they maintain parity on the other two?
- How does the inseparable nature of services prevent mass production efficiencies, and what concept from manufacturing can still be adapted?
- Define complexity and divergence in the context of service processes. Give one example each of a high-complexity/high-divergence service and a low-complexity/low-divergence service.
- Why is it important for a firm to align its complexity and divergence with its chosen operational position?
- Provide an example of a firm that emphasizes customization as its operational position, and explain how it addresses heterogeneity.
๐ Lecture 29 โ Operational Position
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the four critical elements of an operational position: goals, facility location, facility layout, and job design. It explains how these elements must be coherently aligned with the chosen operational positionโCost Efficiency, Customization, or Service Qualityโto bring that position to life. Understanding this alignment is essential for translating a business position into tangible, effective operations.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture introduces the four elements of an operational position and then examines each element specifically for the three positions: Cost Efficiency, Customization, and Service Quality. It covers goals, facility location, facility layout, and job design for each position. The lecture concludes with a discussion of the role of service personnel in service design, including the importance of retention.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction
This lecture covers the important elements of an operational position (OP). Each service setup, regardless of its position, must have goals that are achieved through identifying the correct location, the right layout, and a specific job design. Only by taking coherent steps toward these elements can a company bring its operational position to life. The OP is supported by the business position (BP), which provides a platform to work on the four elements: goals, facility location, facility layout, and job design. These elements must correspond completely to the essence of the position taken; elements fitting a "Cost Efficiency" position should not be used for a "Customization" position and vice versa.
Cost Efficiency Operational Position
Goals The main goal is to achieve high efficiency and productivity. Companies need high volumes to maximize both. They look for operational bottlenecks and try to remove them with astute design. Following techniques are employed:
- automation
- high standardization
- job specialization
Facility Location The location must offer the opportunity to generate volumes and lower the unit cost for productivity. If the line of business allows, one may keep the above-the-line-of-visibility operations at one location and the support component elsewhere (a cheaper place). This arrangement must not compromise the fundamentals of an efficient supply chain and good financial sense. This is well exemplified by bakeries and coffee shops, which have their show rooms and kitchens at places far apart to achieve cost efficiencies.
Facility Layout The layout should be designed to maximize the number of customers served in the onstage component, while the support component should be industrialized to maximize worker productivity and control costs.
Job Design The foremost objective is to be efficient and productive. Companies try to minimize the contact component by making it less complex for efficiency, while working hard to maximize the support functions. This thinking leads to self-service at fast food, ATMs at banks, and computerized systems at travel services. All supports lead to high efficiency, consistent quality, and controlled costs. It is easier to maximize the support function than the contact side because of customer involvement. Techniques employed include division of labor, job specialization, and cross-training of employees. For hybrid services like fast food, a company may produce sandwiches in advance (batch production) or outsource parts of the production process.
Customization Operational Position
This position is high on both complexity and divergence. Professional services in legal, medical, and engineering fields are located here.
Goals The main goal is to satisfy individual customers by customizing the service as they require. Productivity at the customer interaction level is not an objective; costs become secondary.
Facility Location and Layout Location is important but not critical. The layout is important because the customer component and support component are difficult to separate. Mostly professionals, they all must be at the same place. The layout should emphasize prestige.
Job Design Professionals need to be bifurcated. Some must be highly people-oriented to maximize impact on customers during interactions. Those in the support component must be very productive to gain cost advantages, which are generally difficult to achieve as the process does not offer industrialization.
Service Quality Operational Position
Goals Goals stem from the position takenโtechnical quality or functional dimensions. If technical quality is opted for, the goal is outcome and productivity, emphasizing complexity with low divergence. For example, an insurance company may streamline its processes for quick claim reimbursement. If the functional position is taken, the goal is toward customization and emphasizes quality interaction with customers. Another insurance company may specialize in relationship marketing with emphasis on customer contact and one-to-one relationships. A third may emphasize service product diversity (e.g., agriculture insurance and livestock insurance), prompting customers to develop relationships to educate themselves.
Location and Layout The location must reflect image in either case. The layout will be similar to that of "Cost Efficiency" for a technical outcome, and similar to "Customization" if the emphasis is on interaction.
Job Design A technical position will minimize the customer contact component. If the position is functional, the goal will be to enhance the customer contact component. Job specialization is the most important denominator of the quality-position job design. In bigger organizations, cross-training, computerization, and automation also figure prominently.
Fundamentals Regardless of Position: A technical position should strive for cost efficiencies. A functional orientation should always require improvement of productivity to control costs in the absence of an industrialized process. On the technical side, industrialization can be achieved through division of labor and specialization of tasks. In a functional position, productivity can be enhanced by supporting front line contact personnel with vital information processing technology.
๐ก Why this matters: The Service Quality Operational Position shows that "quality" is not a single concept but can be pursued through different operational strategies (technical vs. functional), each requiring different approaches to goals, location, layout, and job design.
Role of Service Personnel in Service Design
Customer contact personnel and support personnel are two important components of the overall design. Contact personnel must be good at people skills along with knowledge of their core jobs, while the support component must be at least good at their core jobs. Contact personnel positively influence customers toward satisfaction while getting support from support staff. The functional integration of the two must be excellent, as it reflects the inseparability of the functions of marketing and operations.
Retention of Personnel The ability to retain good staff is a challenging job. If personnel are not treated as human capital but as parts of a process that will go on anyway, people may not feel motivated to stay. Retaining staff is as important as retaining customers; staff turnover causes costs to soar. Replacements cost more and take time for a smooth transition to system efficiency. Any hiccups cause cost escalation and possible loss of workers. Good workers, when they leave, take with them some good customers. Besides costs, there is a disruption of productivity, which is a goal for all operational positions, though in varying degrees.
โญ Key Takeaways
The four core elements of an operational positionโgoals, facility location, facility layout, and job designโmust be coherently aligned with the chosen position (Cost Efficiency, Customization, or Service Quality) to bring that strategy to life. The Cost Efficiency position prioritizes volume, automation, and standardization. The Customization position prioritizes individual client needs, prestige, and people-oriented professionals, with costs as secondary. The Service Quality position can be technical (focusing on efficiency and outcomes) or functional (focusing on relationships and interaction), each dictating different layouts and job designs. Finally, customer contact and support personnel are vital to service design and delivery, and retaining good staff is as crucial as retaining customers, as turnover disrupts productivity and can lead to customer loss.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four elements of an operational position that must be coherently aligned with the chosen strategy?
- How do the goals for a Cost Efficiency operational position differ from those of a Customization operational position?
- In the context of facility layout, what is the primary design objective for the onstage component in a Cost Efficiency position versus in a Customization position?
- For the Service Quality Operational Position, explain the difference in goals between a "technical quality" focus and a "functional" focus.
- Why is retaining service personnel considered as important as retaining customers, according to the lecture?
๐ Lecture 30 โ Job Design Process
๐ Overview: This lecture focuses on the critical process of job design in services marketing, emphasizing how tasks are divided into jobs to create efficient organizational structures. It explores the importance of job design for managers, its impact on process flows and blueprinting, and the specific techniques of simplification, enlargement, and enrichment that can be applied based on an organization's operational position.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the job design process as the first step toward organizational design, explaining how tasks are divided into jobs with specific examples like a sandwich preparation process. It examines three key design options: division of labor (simplification), job enlargement, and job enrichment, with comparisons between companies like McDonald's and Subway. The lecture also details five critical job characteristics (skill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, and feedback) that make jobs purposeful and motivating for employees, particularly in service roles.
๐ Lecture Summary
Job Design Process
Job design is the first step toward organizational design. Through this process, managers decide how to divide different tasks into jobs. Not only do they come up with the integrated process that lets them define each and every job, they also develop job descriptions and the organization design. The collection of all descriptions reflects the description of total jobs to be performed by the organization, along with a web of relationships among all of them.
Figure 48 depicts a task divided into four major jobs: receiving cash, preparing sandwiches, packing them, and handing them over. Task A is about cash handling and preparation of the ordered sandwiches, while Task B is centered on packing and delivery. All jobs require one person each, except preparation that takes three persons to complete the job. After preparation, one person is adequate to manage the output from the preparation step to packing. Similarly, one person is required to handover the finished product to the customer. From this presentation, we see not only division of tasks into jobs, but also the number of people to efficiently follow the process for a balanced input-output relationship, thus working out the strength of staff required to complete the task.
๐ก Why this matters: Job design directly determines staffing requirements, cost structures, and operational efficiency, making it a foundational managerial skill.
Job Design Options
In relation to the design, there are certain techniques to follow: division of labor, specialization, and cross training. These techniques form design options which can be exercised keeping in view the operational position (OP). These can be better understood with the help of figure 49, which should be viewed in continuation of the previous figure 48. The techniques of division of labor, specialization, and cross training can be better appreciated with the understanding of the three important components of job simplification, job enlargement, and job enrichment.
Simplification through Division of Labor
Division of labor is the grouping of similar jobs into related tasks. The objective remains that of high coordination, smooth working, and therefore high efficiency. McDonald's exemplifies this concept comprehensively. The tasks associated with chef and food server are split into different jobs for the sake of efficiency. As part of their job design, each employee is given fewer tasks so that s(he) can become more efficient and productive in an industrialized process.
Within the groups put together by applying the concept of division of labor, companies try to simplify the tasks, make them less complex and less divergent. But they do not stretch the concept of simplification too far. Appropriate division of labor lets them go ahead with a proper job design and organizational design. This division of labor shows itself on the blueprint (BP), which allows companies to develop the job design, job content, and job relationships. Another benefit, in addition to simplification of the process, it offers is that of the choice to either enlarge or enrich a job, in relation to the OP.
๐ Definition โ Division of Labor: Grouping of similar jobs into related tasks to achieve high coordination, smooth working, and high efficiency. ๐ Key Concept: Simplification โ Low complexity and low divergence โ Predictable and standardized behavior of task performance. ๐ Example: McDonald's splits the tasks of chef and food server into different jobs, giving each employee fewer tasks to increase efficiency and productivity.
Job Enlargement
Job enlargement is characterized by enlarging the steps and hence jobs as part of one job design, thereby giving employees added responsibility to perform. This adds to their importance and satisfaction. Subway (the cold sandwich chain) exemplifies this concept. Owing to customization of sandwiches, Subway has one person who performs all the steps of preparation of sandwiches to the heterogeneous taste of its customers. There is no division of labor among the people who make the sandwiches, wrap the sandwiches, give them to customers, and take the money. The role of chef and food server is combined into one.
๐ Definition โ Job Enlargement: Enlarging the steps and jobs as part of one job design, giving employees added responsibility to perform. ๐ Example: At Subway, one person handles all steps from sandwich preparation to wrapping, delivery, and cash handling, combining the roles of chef and food server.
Job Enrichment
Job enrichment is expanding the scope and degree of responsibility of one's job. This could be:
- Empowering workers to experiment new ways to perform the tasks
- Allowing employees to be flexible in responding to special situations using their judgment
- Developing special skills
- Allowing workers to monitor and measure their own performance against pre-established standards
The idea behind job enrichment is to increase employees' involvement and thus their interest in the service they provide. Job enlargement and enrichment are more conducive to organizational structures that are flexible and decentralized. This also has a logical correlation with customization.
Conversely, job simplification represents low complexity and low divergence and hence signifies a predictable and standardized behavior of task performance. Figures 50 and 51 clearly exhibit the enlarged and enriched jobs. These figures represent hypothetical situations only for the sake of better understanding and do not represent any specific organizations.
๐ Definition โ Job Enrichment: Expanding the scope and degree of responsibility of one's job through empowerment, flexibility, skill development, and self-monitoring. ๐ก Why this matters: Job enrichment increases employee involvement and interest, particularly in customized service environments with flexible, decentralized structures.
Job Characteristics
The basic responsibility of managers is to come up with a design that maximizes output, lowers costs, and optimizes the working relationships. This can be achieved only if the right job design is in place. For the right design, following are certain motivational characteristics about the jobs that have to be considered to make any job purposeful:
- Skill Variety
- Task Identity
- Task Significance
- Autonomy
- Feedback
Skill Variety
People responsible for customer contact have to have a variety of skills to be able to do many jobs if need be. Apart from the core knowledge, they need to have good listening and speaking skills. Since they are the front and visible organ of the organization, they need to exercise such skills more than their counterparts below the line of visibility or the support component. Their listening and speaking prowess matters in cases of complaint registration and staging recovery strategies. Effective communication with clarity matters a lot in resolving matters with the help of their support component colleagues.
Another important skill is the ability of employees to empathize with customers. This is an ability to identify with the feelings and thoughts of another person โ employee or customer. The mere feeling on part of the customer that the employee is considerate and willing to solve his problem, no matter what the circumstances, brings satisfaction. An empathetic employee with good communication skills can be given an enlarged job.
Ability to deal with all kinds of customers โ soft spoken, difficult, demanding, and even rude โ is another variety of skills that can make a front-end employee very successful.
Since the support staff is meant to work in a way that reduces costs and increases efficiency and productivity, people should be working as specialists of their particular jobs. Job specialization therefore is an important pillar of people's role. However, to break monotony, people among such staff could be cross-trained and rotated for motivational purposes. This also highlights the company's ability to surmount the challenge of inseparability. Another skill that can be motivational is enlargement of the job that makes people feel more important.
๐ Definition โ Empathy: The ability to identify with the feelings and thoughts of another person โ employee or customer.
Task Identity
Task identity is a condition that results in identifiable units of work and a specific outcome. In other words, if the outcome of a job cannot be defined, then it is considered low on identity and hence less fulfilling.
The job of a telephone receptionist falls into this category, which requires getting and passing on the information for delivery of a service. The job of an attendant at a call center meant for taking orders is just another description of a similar identity. The job of an on-line banker, however, is a little more fulfilling in that such bankers are in a position to pass on to the customer and share with him a certain level of meaningful information.
One way to overcome this limitation is to enlarge the job and make it high on identity. The implication for providers therefore is to look into different tasks and see which should be done by individuals as single tasks and which ones should be lumped to make those individuals motivated.
๐ Definition โ Task Identity: A condition that results in identifiable units of work and a specific outcome; low identity means the outcome cannot be defined, making the job less fulfilling.
โญ Key Takeaways
The job design process is the foundational step toward organizational design, where managers divide tasks into jobs, determine staffing requirements, and develop job descriptions that reflect the total work of the organization. Three key design options exist: division of labor/simplification (as seen at McDonald's) which groups similar tasks for efficiency; job enlargement (as seen at Subway) which combines multiple steps into one person's role for customization; and job enrichment which expands responsibility through empowerment and flexibility. The five motivational job characteristicsโskill variety, task identity, task significance, autonomy, and feedbackโmust be considered to make jobs purposeful, with particular emphasis on communication skills and empathy for customer-contact employees. Understanding the balance between simplification for efficiency and enlargement/enrichment for motivation is critical for designing service jobs that align with the organization's operational position and strategic goals.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is job design and why is it considered the first step toward organizational design?
- Compare and contrast McDonald's approach to job design (simplification/division of labor) with Subway's approach (job enlargement).
- List the five motivational job characteristics that make jobs purposeful, and explain how skill variety applies to customer-contact employees versus support staff.
- What is task identity, and why might a telephone receptionist's job be considered low on this characteristic?
- How does job enrichment differ from job enlargement, and what are the four specific ways a job can be enriched?
๐ Lecture 31 โ Services Marketing
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of job characteristics that form the basis for provider understanding toward job design and establishing the right service standards. It examines the two fundamental types of standardsโhard and softโand discusses the challenges organizations face in setting customer-defined standards.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the continuation of job characteristics including task significance, autonomy, and feedback, then moves into service standards by discussing challenges to setting standards and the two types of standards: hard standards which are quantifiable and can be counted, and soft standards which are based on customersโ perceptions of quality attributes.
๐ Lecture Summary
Job Characteristics (Continued)
Task Significance: The degree to which a worker may think his job has a definite impact on others, within and outside of the organization, forms task significance of the job. Jobs performed by contact personnel with high task identity carry high levels of significance. Workers having jobs with high significance seem to work harder in the belief that their input is more important. While such jobs have the inherent character of keeping the jobholders motivated, it is the responsibility of management to ensure that there are no failings on significant jobs; if failings occur, then the recovery is done efficiently. Another implication may as well be to cross-train more people for significant jobs to ensure fail-safe strategies and their implementation.
๐ Definition โ Task Significance: The degree to which a worker believes their job has a definite impact on others within and outside the organization. ๐ Example: A contact employee handling customer complaints at a bank may feel high task significance because resolving a complaint directly affects customer satisfaction and the bank's reputation, motivating them to work harder.
Autonomy: The degree of freedom and discretion one feels toward executing oneโs role is the level of autonomy one has. People like to have freedom of making decisions about work scheduling and determining their moves accordingly. This is possible only if their jobs are enriched. Going by the operational position, it is clear that employees working for cost efficiency and productivity have little autonomy due to industrialization of the process. Conversely, employees working for functional quality and customization have greater autonomy of their roles. It is the responsibility of management to see where they can enlarge jobs with autonomy so that employees can do their best to satisfy their customers.
๐ Definition โ Autonomy: The degree of freedom and discretion an employee feels toward executing their role, including decision-making about work scheduling. ๐ Example: An employee in a fast-food chain (cost efficiency focus) has little autonomy in how they prepare orders, while a consultant in a management firm (customization focus) has greater autonomy in scheduling client meetings and deciding the approach.
Feedback: The degree of direct information an employee receives from his superiors about his performance on the job forms this characteristic. Management must not wait to start talking about performances only when they have a complaint or there is a need to stage recovery strategies. Performance feedback should be made a regular feature for employees to know how they are doing. This helps realistic communication to take place for the betterment of service and customer satisfaction.
๐ Definition โ Feedback: The degree of direct information an employee receives from superiors about their job performance. ๐ Example: A call center manager provides weekly feedback to agents on their call handling time and customer satisfaction scores, rather than only addressing issues when complaints arise.
The five job characteristics (task significance, autonomy, feedback, plus skill variety and task identity from earlier lectures) lead, in different situations and at different jobs, to meaningful psychological states that are positive in nature. This positivity results in three important outcomes of motivation, performance, and satisfaction of high levels.
Service Standards
After expectations have been understood and service design is well captured by considering all steps of the strategic process, the next challenge for providers is to come up with the customer-defined standards. All those well-defined behaviors and actions on part of the providers that better equip them to deliver the service in a standardized manner to the benefit of customers as well as organizations are known as standards.
๐ Definition โ Customer-Defined Standards: Well-defined behaviors and actions that equip providers to deliver service in a standardized manner that benefits both customers and organizations.
Challenges to Set Standards
The challenge for such standards stems from the fact that standards defined by organizations in terms of cost efficiency and productivity may not be adequate for customers to be satisfied, for those are established from a typical commercial point of view in which the company is the dominant factor and not the customer. Another reason for the lack of customer-defined standards is the fact that functional integration of marketing and operations does not take place in the true inseparable sense. Working in an inseparable manner that requires performance of the two functions at the same time by people from two different functions of marketing and operations is a challenge that not many organizations meet easily. Therefore, employees find it a deviation from what they are accustomed to working. A change becomes difficult to stage.
Also, for the fact that many managers look upon services from a customization standpoint, they think it is not practical to have standards for services โ they may have a point when it comes to accounting, tax, management, and a few other types of consultancies. The fact remains that even services demanding high customization may offer an opportunity to standardize certain portions of it only to come up with behaviors and actions needed to satisfy customers. Such managers also argue that setting standards compromises employee empowerment; in the absence of which they feel constrained to perform a service with extra responsiveness and empathy.
Proponents of the standards argue that standards should not make a service unnecessarily rigid to perform, losing its essence in terms of quality dimensions of reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy, and tangibles. All good companies need such standards. By setting routines to different steps, they know exactly how long it takes to deliver and complete a transaction, to identify failures, and to fix complaints. By having such standards they develop certain measures against which customers can evaluate them.
Types of Standards
There are two types of standards โ hard and soft.
Hard Standards: Those standards that are quantifiable and can be counted in terms of time and audit are โhard standardsโ. For example, a good company will ensure to do the service right the first time (as a standard) or deliver within a specified time (as a standard) to establish reliability. It will also specify response time to attend to a complaint and prove its responsiveness.
๐ Definition โ Hard Standards: Standards that are quantifiable and can be counted in terms of time and audit. ๐ Formula: Hard Standard = Measurable metric (e.g., time, count, audit result) โ Plain-English meaning: Standards that can be numerically verified and measured. ๐ Example: A courier company sets a hard standard of delivering packages within 24 hours within the same city; this can be audited by tracking delivery times.
Soft Standards: These standards are translated from customersโ perceptions of quality attributes and lead providers to define behaviors and actions in light of those attributes. These are basically values that stress dimensions of quality that are abstract in nature. Professing to be reliable and responsive is abstract in nature. If a hard standard of service outcome of a car repair can be audited at the end of the service (tune-up, brakes check-up, oil change, and other mechanical and electronic features), it is hard to measure the standard of courteousness and assurance (soft standards) demonstrated by the company staff.
In short, standards that are ascertained only on the basis of customersโ perception of satisfaction are โsoft standardsโ. These cannot be counted or audited. The only way out is to talk with customers to find out their perceptions. One of the best ways of determining perceptions is to use SERVQUAL method of marketing research. The soft sides of standards deal with things that are abstract in nature and do not offer us the opportunity to measure them numerically, unless we adopt an approach like SERVQUAL and Trailer calls.
๐ Definition โ Soft Standards: Standards that are ascertained only on the basis of customersโ perception of satisfaction; these cannot be counted or audited. ๐ Example: A hotel cannot audit "courteousness" of its staff numerically; instead, it must use customer surveys (like SERVQUAL) to measure perceptions of friendliness and politeness.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding the distinction between hard and soft standards helps service providers balance measurable operational efficiency with customer-perceived quality, which is critical for both satisfaction and continuous improvement.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that job characteristicsโespecially task significance, autonomy, and feedbackโdirectly influence employee motivation, performance, and satisfaction, and are foundational to designing effective service jobs. The challenge in setting customer-defined standards lies in moving beyond company-centric cost-efficiency metrics and overcoming functional silos between marketing and operations. Hard standards are quantifiable and auditable (e.g., response time, doing it right the first time), while soft standards are based on customer perceptions and require tools like SERVQUAL to measure abstract qualities like courtesy and assurance. Even highly customized services can benefit from standardizing certain portions without compromising employee empowerment. Ultimately, good companies need both types of standards to establish measures against which customers can evaluate their performance.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three job characteristics discussed in this lecture, and how does each contribute to employee outcomes?
- Why might standards defined from a cost-efficiency perspective fail to satisfy customers?
- What is the difference between hard standards and soft standards, and provide one example of each from a service context?
- Why do some managers argue that setting standards is impractical for services, and how do proponents of standards counter this argument?
- How can SERVQUAL be used to measure soft standards that cannot be counted or audited?