π Lecture 30 β The Financial Plan
π Overview: This lecture explains the structure and purpose of a financial plan for a new venture, including how to prepare operating and capital budgets. It covers why profitability does not guarantee positive cash flow and introduces key financial statements and the break-even point.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the role and components of a financial plan, the importance of cash flow versus profits, the preparation of operating and capital budgets, and the development of pro forma financial statements including income, cash flow, balance sheet, and sources and uses of funds. It also addresses break-even analysis and software tools for financial planning.
π Lecture Summary
THE FINANCIAL PLAN
A financial plan provides a complete picture of how much and when funds are coming into the organization, where the funds are going, how much cash is available, and the projected financial position of the firm. It provides the short-term basis for budgeting and helps prevent a common problemβlack of cash. The financial plan must explain how the entrepreneur will meet all financial obligations and maintain liquidity. In general, the financial plan will need three years of projected financial data for outside investors.
π‘ Why this matters: Even if a business shows positive profits on paper, it can still fail if it runs out of cash to pay bills. The financial plan helps anticipate cash shortfalls.
π Definition β Financial plan: A comprehensive projection of a firmβs financial position, including inflows, outflows, cash availability, and future financial status, used for budgeting and investor communication.
OPERATING AND CAPITAL BUDGETS
Before developing the pro forma income statement, the entrepreneur should prepare operating and capital budgets. If the entrepreneur is a sole proprietor, they will be responsible for budgeting decisions. In a partnership or where employees exist, the initial budgeting process may begin with one of these individuals. Final determination of budgets will ultimately rest with the owners or entrepreneurs.
In preparing the pro forma income statement, the entrepreneur must first develop a sales budgetβan estimate of the expected volume of sales by month. From sales forecasts, the entrepreneur will determine the cost of these sales. Estimated ending inventory will also be included.
A production or manufacturing budget provides a basis for projecting cash flows for the cost of goods produced. The important information in this budget is the actual production required each month and the needed inventory to allow for changes in demand. This budget reflects seasonal demand or marketing programs, which can increase demand and inventory. The operating budget is an important document, as the pro forma income statement will only reflect the actual costs of goods.
Next the entrepreneur can focus on operating costs. Fixed expenses (incurred regardless of sales volume) include rent, utilities, salaries, interest, depreciation, and insurance. The entrepreneur will need to calculate variable expenses, which may change from month to month depending on sales volume, such as advertising and selling expenses.
Capital budgets are intended to provide a basis for evaluating expenditures that will impact the business for more than one year. A capital budget may project expenditures for new equipment, vehicles, or new facilities. These decisions can include the computation of the cost of capital and the anticipated return on investment using present value methods. The entrepreneur should enlist the assistance of an accountant.
π Definition β Pro forma income statement: A projected financial statement showing expected revenues and expenses over a future period. π Definition β Sales budget: An estimate of expected monthly sales volume used as the foundation for other budgets. π Definition β Fixed expenses: Costs that remain constant regardless of sales volume (e.g., rent, salaries). π Definition β Variable expenses: Costs that change month-to-month based on sales volume (e.g., advertising, selling costs). π Definition β Capital budget: A plan for evaluating long-term expenditures (over one year) such as equipment or facilities.
β Key Takeaways
The financial plan is essential for both internal cash management and external investor communication, requiring three years of projected data. Positive profits do not guarantee positive cash flow; the financial plan helps prevent cash shortages. The foundation of financial planning is a sales budget, from which production, operating, and capital budgets are developed. Fixed expenses are independent of sales volume, while variable expenses fluctuate with sales. Capital budgets focus on long-term investments and should involve professional accounting assistance.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why can a business report positive profits yet still face negative cash flow?
- What is the first budget an entrepreneur should prepare before developing the pro forma income statement?
- Name three examples of fixed expenses and two examples of variable expenses.
- What is the purpose of a capital budget, and what types of expenditures does it cover?
- How many years of projected financial data do outside investors typically require?
π Lecture 31 β The Financial Plan (Continued...)
π Overview: This lecture continues the financial planning process for a new venture, covering operating and capital budgets, pro forma financial statements (income statement, cash flow, and balance sheet), and break-even analysis. It emphasizes the importance of realistic projections and cash flow management for entrepreneurial success.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers operating and capital budgets including sales, production, operating, and capital budgets. It then details the preparation of pro forma income statements, focusing on revenue projections and operating expenses. The pro forma cash flow section explains the difference between profit and cash flow and the two methods for projecting cash flow. Finally, the lecture covers the pro forma balance sheet (assets, liabilities, and owners equity) and break-even analysis, including the formula and its application.
π Lecture Summary
Operating and Capital Budgets
Before developing the pro forma income statement, the entrepreneur should prepare operating and capital budgets. If the entrepreneur is a sole proprietor, they are responsible for budgeting decisions. In a partnership or where employees exist, the initial budgeting process may begin with one of these individuals, but final determination of budgets ultimately rests with the owners or entrepreneurs.
In preparing the pro forma income statement, the entrepreneur must first develop a sales budget, an estimate of the expected volume of sales by month. From sales forecasts, the entrepreneur will determine the cost of these sales. Estimated ending inventory will also be included.
π Definition β Production or Manufacturing Budget: A budget that provides a basis for projecting cash flows for the cost of goods produced; it reflects the actual production required each month and the needed inventory to allow for changes in demand, seasonal demand, or marketing programs.
Next, the entrepreneur can focus on operating costs. Fixed expenses (incurred regardless of sales volume) include rent, utilities, salaries, interest, depreciation, and insurance. The entrepreneur will need to calculate variable expenses, which may change from month to month depending on sales volume, such as advertising and selling expenses.
Capital budgets are intended to provide a basis for evaluating expenditures that will impact the business for more than one year. A capital budget may project expenditures for new equipment, vehicles, or new facilities. These decisions can include the computation of the cost of capital and the anticipated return on investment using present value methods. The entrepreneur should enlist the assistance of an accountant.
π‘ Why this matters: Budgets form the foundation for all financial projections, ensuring that the entrepreneur has a realistic plan for sales, production, and long-term investments before creating income statements.
Pro Forma Income Statements
Sales is the major source of revenue; since other activities relate to sales, it is usually the first item defined. In preparing the pro forma income statement, sales by month must be calculated first. Market research, industry sales, and trial experience might provide the basis for these figures. Forecasting techniques, such as a survey of buyersβ intentions or expert opinions, can be used to project sales. The costs for achieving increases in sales can be higher in early months.
Sales revenues for an Internet start-up are often more difficult to project. A giftware Internet start-up could project the number of average hits expected per day or month based on industry data. From the number of "hits," it is possible to project the number of consumers who will buy products and the average dollar amount per transaction.
The pro forma income statements also provide projections of all operating expenses for each month of the first year. Selling expenses as a percentage of sales may also be higher initially. Salaries and wages should reflect the number of personnel employed, as well as their roles in the organization. Any unusual expenses, such as those for a key trade show, should be flagged and explained at the bottom.
In addition to the first yearβs statement, projections should be made for years 2 and 3. Investors generally prefer to see three years of income projections. Some expenses will remain stable over time, like depreciation, utilities, rent, insurance, and interest. When calculating the projected operating expense, it is important to be conservative for initial planning purposes.
For the Internet start-up, capital budgeting and operating expenses will involve equipment purchasing or leasing, inventory, and advertising expenses. Many of the recent Internet start-ups have not earned a profit.
π‘ Why this matters: The pro forma income statement translates budgets into anticipated profitability, allowing the entrepreneur and investors to assess the ventureβs potential financial performance over time.
Pro Forma Cash Flow
Cash flow is not the same as profit. Profit is the result of subtracting expenses from sales. Cash flow results from the difference between actual cash receipts and cash payments. Cash flows only when actual payments are made or received.
For an Internet start-up, the same transaction would involve the use of a credit card, in which a percentage of the sale would be paid as a fee to the credit card company. On many occasions, profitable firms fail because of lack of cash; therefore, using profit as a means of success may be deceiving.
There are two standard methods used to project cash flow:
- Indirect method: Some adjustments are made to the net income based on the fact that actual cash may not have actually been received or disbursed.
- Direct method: A simple determination of cash in less cash out gives a fast indication of the cash position of the new venture at a point in time.
It is important for the entrepreneur to make monthly projections of cash, pro forma cash flow. If disbursements are greater than receipts in any time period, funds will have to be borrowed or cash reserves tapped. Large positive cash flows may need to be invested in short-term sources. Usually the first few months of start-up will require external cash to cover cash outlays.
The most difficult problem with projecting cash flows is determining the exact monthly receipts and disbursements. Some assumptions will need to be made and should be conservative so enough funds can be maintained to cover the negative cash months. These cash flows will also assist in determining how much money will need to be borrowed. The pro forma cash flow is based on best estimates and may need to be revised to ensure accuracy. It is useful to provide several scenarios, each based on different levels of success.
π Definition β Cash Flow: The difference between actual cash receipts and actual cash payments; it is distinct from profit because it reflects actual cash movements rather than accounting accruals.
π‘ Why this matters: Cash flow management is criticalβprofitable firms can fail if they run out of cash, making this projection more important than the income statement for short-term survival.
Pro Forma Balance Sheet
The entrepreneur should also prepare a projected balance sheet depicting the condition of the business at the end of the first year. The pro forma balance sheet summarizes the assets, liabilities, and net worth of the entrepreneurs. Every business transaction affects the balance sheet. The balance sheet is a picture of the business at one moment in time and does not cover a period of time.
Assets represent everything of value that is owned by the business. The assets are categorized as current or fixed. Value is not necessarily replacement costβit is the actual cost expended for the asset. Current assets include cash and anything that will be converted into cash within a year. Fixed assets are those that will be used over a long period of time. Management of receivables, or money owed by customers, is important to the businessβs cash flow.
Liabilities accounts represent everything owed to creditors. Current liabilities are due within a year. Others are long-term debts. It is often necessary to delay payments of bills to more effectively manage cash flow.
Owners Equity represents the excess of all assets over all liabilities. Owners equity represents the net worth of the business. Any profit from the business will also be included in the net worth as retained earnings.
π Definition β Balance Sheet: A financial statement that summarizes the assets, liabilities, and net worth of a business at a specific moment in time, providing a snapshot of its financial condition.
Break-Even Analysis
It is helpful for the entrepreneur to know when a profit may be achieved. Break-even analysis is a technique for determining how many units must be sold to break even. The firm has fixed cost obligations that must be covered by sales volume for a company to break even. The break-even point is that volume of sales at which the business will neither make a profit nor incur a loss. The break-even sales point is the volume of sales needed to cover total variable and fixed expenses.
π Definition β Break-Even Point: The volume of sales at which total revenue equals total costs, resulting in neither profit nor loss.
π Formula: B/E (Q) = TFC / (SP - VC/unit) Where:
- B/E (Q) = Break-even quantity (units)
- TFC = Total Fixed Costs
- SP = Selling Price per unit
- VC/unit = Variable Cost per unit
- (SP - VC/unit) = Marginal contribution per unit
β Plain-English meaning: This formula tells you how many units you need to sell so that the contribution from each unit (selling price minus variable cost) covers all your fixed costs exactly.
π Example: If a business has total fixed costs of $50,000, a selling price of $100 per unit, and variable costs of $60 per unit, then B/E (Q) = 50,000 / (100 - 60) = 50,000 / 40 = 1,250 units. This means the business must sell 1,250 units just to cover all costs.
As long as the selling price is greater than the variable costs per unit, some contribution can be made to cover fixed costs. The major weakness in calculating break-even is determining whether a cost is fixed or variable. Costs such as depreciation, salaries and wages, rent, and insurance are usually fixed. Materials, selling expenses, and direct labor are most likely variable costs.
When the firm produces more than one product, break-even may be calculated for each product. The entrepreneur can try different states of nature, such as different selling prices, to see the impact on break-even and profits.
π‘ Why this matters: Break-even analysis provides a clear target for entrepreneurs, showing the minimum sales volume required to avoid losses and enabling them to test different pricing and cost scenarios.
β Key Takeaways
First, the entrepreneur must prepare operating budgets (sales, production, and operating) and capital budgets before developing pro forma financial statements, as these provide the foundational estimates for revenue and costs. Second, cash flow is fundamentally different from profitβprofitable firms can fail due to insufficient cashβso monthly pro forma cash flow projections using the direct or indirect method are essential for survival. Third, the pro forma income statement should span three years, with conservative expense estimates, and unusual items should be explained. Fourth, the break-even point is calculated using the formula B/E(Q) = TFC / (SP - VC/unit), and its accuracy depends on correctly classifying costs as fixed or variable. Finally, the pro forma balance sheet provides a snapshot of the business's financial position (assets, liabilities, and equity) at the end of the first year, which helps evaluate overall financial health.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the first budget an entrepreneur must develop before preparing the pro forma income statement?
- Why might a profitable firm still fail, according to the lecture?
- What are the two methods for projecting cash flow, and how do they differ?
- Using the break-even formula, if total fixed costs are $30,000, selling price is $50 per unit, and variable cost is $30 per unit, how many units must be sold to break even?
- On a pro forma balance sheet, what is the relationship between assets, liabilities, and owners equity?
π Lecture 32 β Pro Forma Sources and Uses of Funds
π Overview: This lecture explores the various sources of financing available to entrepreneurs, distinguishing between debt and equity financing as well as internal and external funds. Understanding these options is critical for entrepreneurs to effectively fund their ventures at different stages of growth.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an overview of debt versus equity financing and internal versus external funds. It then examines specific sources of capital: personal funds, family and friends, commercial banks and their lending decisions, Small Business Administration (SBA) loans, research and development limited partnerships, government grants including Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) grants, and private placement as a source of funds.
π Lecture Summary
An Overview
Different sources of capital are generally used at different times in the life of the venture. The choice between debt financing and equity financing depends on availability of funds, assets of the venture, and prevailing interest rates. In a market economy, all ventures have some equity as all are owned by someone.
π Definition β Debt Financing: An interest-bearing instrument, usually a loan, where payment is only indirectly related to sales and profits. It requires some asset to be used as collateral. The entrepreneur must repay the borrowed amount plus a fee expressed as interest.
π Definition β Equity Financing: Financing that offers the investor some form of ownership position in the venture; the investor shares in the profits.
Debt financing (also called asset-based financing) has the advantage of letting the entrepreneur retain a large ownership position and have greater return on equity. However, if the debt is too great, payments become difficult and growth is inhibited. Short-term debt provides working capital, while long-term debt (over one year) is used to purchase assets, with part of the asset value as collateral.
Equity may be entirely provided by the owner or may require multiple owners. This equity funding provides the basis for debt financing, which makes up the capital structure of the venture. Usually a combination of debt and equity is used.
Internal or External Funds
The most often used type of funds is internally generated funds, which come from sources within the company such as profits, sale of assets, reduction in working capital, and accounts receivable. Start-up years usually involve plowing all profits back into the venture. Little-used assets can be sold or leased. Assets, whenever possible, should be on a rental basis, not an ownership basis. One short-term internal source is reducing short-term assets or through extended payments from suppliers. Another method is collecting accounts receivable more quickly.
External sources should be evaluated by: (i) length of time funds are available, (ii) costs involved, and (iii) amount of control lost.
Personal Funds
Few new ventures are started without the personal funds of the entrepreneur. In terms of cost and control, these are the least expensive. They are essential in attracting outside funding because outside investors want the entrepreneur to demonstrate financial commitment. This level of commitment is reflected in the percentage of total assets the entrepreneur has committed. An outside investor wants an entrepreneur to have committed all available assets. It is not the amount but the fact that all monies available are committed that makes outside investors feel comfortable.
π‘ Why this matters: Personal funds signal to potential investors that the entrepreneur has "skin in the game," which is often a prerequisite for securing external financing.
Family and Friends
After the entrepreneur, family and friends are the next most common source of capital. They provide a small amount of equity funding for new ventures. It is relatively easy to obtain money from family and friends, but the amount provided may be small. If it is in the form of equity funding, the family member or friend has an ownership position in the venture. If they have direct input into operations, it may negatively affect employees or profits.
To avoid potential future problems, the entrepreneur must present the positive and negative aspects and the nature of the risks of the investment. To minimize problems: keep business arrangements strictly business; any loan should specify the rate of interest and repayment schedule; settle everything up front and in writing; a formal agreement specifying details helps avoid future problems. The entrepreneur should carefully consider the impact of the investment on the family member or friend before accepting it.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical understanding from this lecture is that entrepreneurs must match financing sources to the venture's stage and needs, with personal funds being essential for demonstrating commitment to attract outside investors. Debt financing allows the entrepreneur to retain ownership but requires collateral and regular payments, while equity financing brings in partners who share profits and control. Internally generated funds are the most common and least costly source, but external funds become necessary as the venture grows. Family and friends are a common early source but require formal agreements to prevent future conflicts. The choice between debt and equity depends on availability of funds, venture assets, and prevailing interest rates, with most ventures using a combination of both.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three key factors in choosing between debt and equity financing?
- Why are personal funds considered essential even when they are a small amount?
- What are the three criteria for evaluating external sources of funds?
- What is the main advantage and the main disadvantage of debt financing for an entrepreneur?
- What four steps should an entrepreneur take to minimize future problems when accepting funding from family and friends?
π Lecture 33 β Pro Forma Sources and Uses of Funds
π Overview: This lecture examines commercial banks as the most frequently used source of short-term funds for entrepreneurs. It details the types of bank loans available, including accounts receivable loans, inventory loans, equipment loans, and real estate loans, as well as cash flow financing options. Understanding these funding sources is critical for entrepreneurs to secure the capital needed for business operations and growth.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers commercial banks as a primary source of short-term debt financing, requiring collateral such as business assets, personal assets, or cosigner assets. It details four main types of bank loans: accounts receivable loans (up to 80% value, factoring arrangements), inventory loans (up to 50% finished goods value, trust receipts), equipment loans (3β10 year terms, sale-leaseback financing), and real estate loans (up to 75% value). It also covers cash flow financing options including lines of credit, installment loans, straight commercial loans, long-term loans, and character loans.
π Lecture Summary
COMMERCIAL BANKS
Commercial banks are the most frequently used source of short-term funds. This is debt financing and requires some collateral, some asset with value. This collateral can be business assets, personal assets, or the assets of the cosigner of the note.
Types of Bank Loans
1. Accounts Receivable Loans
Accounts receivable provide a good basis for a loan, especially if the customer base is creditworthy. A bank may finance up to 80% of the value of the accounts receivable. A factoring arrangement can be developed whereby the factor (bank) actually buys the accounts and collects the money. If any of the receivables are not collectible, the factor sustains the loss, not the business. The cost of factoring is higher than the cost of securing a loan against the accounts receivable.
π Definition β Factoring: A financial arrangement where a factor (bank) buys the accounts receivable and collects the money, sustaining the loss if receivables are uncollectible.
π‘ Why this matters: Factoring provides immediate cash flow but at a higher cost than a secured loan. Entrepreneurs must weigh the trade-off between speed of cash access and cost.
π Example: A business has $100,000 in accounts receivable from creditworthy customers. A bank may finance up to $80,000 (80% of value) as a loan secured by these receivables. Alternatively, under factoring, the bank buys the receivables for a discounted amount (e.g., $85,000) and collects payments directly, absorbing any bad debts.
2. Inventory Loans
Inventory is often a basis for a loan, particularly when inventory is liquid and can be sold easily. Finished goods inventory can be financed up to 50% of value. Trust receipts are a type of inventory loan used to finance floor plans of retailers such as auto dealers. The bank advances a large percentage of the invoice price of the goods and is paid a pro rata basis as the inventory is sold.
π Definition β Trust Receipt: A type of inventory loan where the bank advances a large percentage of the invoice price of goods, and the business repays the loan on a pro rata basis as inventory is sold.
π Example: An auto dealer needs $200,000 to purchase vehicles. Using a trust receipt loan, the bank advances funds (e.g., $180,000, or 90% of invoice price). As each car is sold, the dealer repays the bank a corresponding percentage of the loan.
3. Equipment Loans
Equipment can be used to secure longer term financing up to 3 to 10 years. When new equipment is bought, 50 to 80% of value can be financed. In sale-leaseback financing, the entrepreneur "sells" the equipment to a lender and then leases it back.
π Definition β Sale-Leaseback Financing: An arrangement where the entrepreneur sells equipment to a lender and then leases it back, freeing up capital while retaining use of the equipment.
π Example: A manufacturing company owns a $500,000 machine. It sells the machine to a lender for $400,000 (80% of value) and then leases it back for monthly payments over 5 years, gaining immediate cash while continuing production.
4. Real Estate Loans
Real estate loans are easily obtained to finance land, plant, or building, usually up to 75% of value.
π Example: A business wants to purchase a warehouse valued at $1,000,000. A bank may provide a loan of up to $750,000 (75% of value), secured by the property.
Cash Flow Financing
Cash flow financing β or conventional bank loans β includes lines of credit, installment loans, straight commercial loans, long-term loans, and character loans.
1. Lines of Credit
Lines of credit are the most frequently used form of cash flow financing. The company pays a "commitment fee" at the start, then pays interest on outstanding borrowed funds.
π Definition β Line of Credit: A flexible loan arrangement where a company pays a commitment fee upfront and then pays interest only on the amount borrowed.
2. Installment Loans
Installment loans can be obtained by a going venture with a track record of sales and profits. These funds are used to cover working capital needs, usually for 30 to 40 days.
π Example: A profitable retail business needs $50,000 to purchase inventory for the holiday season. It obtains an installment loan repayable in 35 days, using expected sales revenue to repay.
3. Straight Commercial Loans
In this hybrid of the installment loan, funds are advanced to the company for 30 to 90 days. These self-liquidating loans are used for seasonal financing.
π Definition β Self-Liquidating Loan: A short-term loan where the borrowed funds are used to generate revenue that repays the loan, typically for seasonal business cycles.
π Example: A landscaping company borrows $30,000 for 60 days in spring to buy equipment and supplies, and repays the loan from summer service revenue.
4. Long Term Loans
These loans are usually only available to more mature companies. Funds are available for up to 10 years with the debt repaid according to a fixed interest and principal schedule.
π Example: A 10-year-old manufacturing firm borrows $2,000,000 to expand its facility, repaying with 8% annual interest over 120 months.
5. Character Loans
When the business does not have assets to support a loan, the entrepreneur may need a character loan. These loans must have assets of an individual pledged as collateral, or have the loan cosigned by another.
π Definition β Character Loan: A loan based on the entrepreneur's personal reputation and creditworthiness, requiring personal assets as collateral or a cosigner.
π‘ Why this matters: Character loans highlight the importance of the entrepreneur's personal financial standing, especially for startups without substantial business assets.
β Key Takeaways
Commercial banks are the primary source of short-term debt financing, requiring collateral from business or personal assets. Four main types of asset-based loans exist: accounts receivable loans (up to 80% of value, with factoring as a higher-cost alternative), inventory loans (up to 50% of finished goods, using trust receipts for retailers), equipment loans (3β10 year terms, with sale-leaseback option), and real estate loans (up to 75% of value). Cash flow financing includes lines of credit (most common, with commitment fees), installment loans (30β40 days for working capital), straight commercial loans (30β90 days, self-liquidating for seasonal needs), long-term loans (up to 10 years for mature companies), and character loans (for businesses without sufficient assets, requiring personal collateral or cosigner). Entrepreneurs must match the loan type to the asset and business stage, understanding that factoring is costly but quick, while long-term and character loans are harder to obtain but offer flexibility.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the maximum percentage of accounts receivable value that a bank may finance, and what is factoring, including who bears the loss if receivables are uncollectible?
- What does "trust receipts" mean in inventory loans, and how does the repayment work as inventory is sold?
- Explain sale-leaseback financing for equipment loans and why an entrepreneur might choose this option.
- How do lines of credit differ from installment loans in terms of upfront costs and interest payment?
- What is a character loan, and what two conditions must be met if the business has no assets to support the loan?
π Lecture 34 β Bank Lending Decisions
π Overview: This lecture examines how banks make lending decisions, particularly for new ventures, and introduces the Small Business Administration (SBA) Guaranty Loan as an alternative when conventional bank financing is unavailable. Understanding these lending criteria is crucial for entrepreneurs seeking capital to start or grow their businesses.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the five Cβs of bank lending decisions (Character, Capacity, Capital, Collateral, and Conditions), the typical loan application format as a "mini" business plan, guidelines on borrowing the maximum repayable amount, and a detailed explanation of SBA Guaranty Loans including eligibility, loan terms, interest rates, and processing procedures.
π Lecture Summary
BANK LENDING DECISIONS
Banks are very cautious in lending money, particularly to new ventures. Commercial loan decisions are made only after the loan officer does a careful review of the borrower. Decisions are based on both quantifiable and subjective judgments.
Bank lending decisions can be summarized by the five Cβs: Character, Capacity, Capital, Collateral, and Conditions. Past financial statements are reviewed in terms of key ratios and the entrepreneurβs capital invested. Future projections on market size, sales, and profitability are evaluated. Intuitive factors β Character and Capacity β are also taken into account and become more important when there is little or no track record.
The loan application format is generally a "mini" business plan. This provides the loan officer with information on the creditworthiness of the individual and the ability of the venture to repay the loan. Presenting a positive business image and following procedure are important in obtaining the funds.
The entrepreneur should borrow the maximum amount possible that can be repaid, as long as the prevailing interest rates and terms are satisfactory. Care must be taken to ensure that the venture will generate enough cash flow to repay the interest and principal on the loan. The entrepreneur should evaluate the track record and lending policies of several banks in the area.
π Definition β Five Cβs of Credit: Character, Capacity, Capital, Collateral, and Conditions β the five key criteria banks use to evaluate loan applications. π‘ Why this matters: The five Cβs framework helps entrepreneurs understand exactly what banks are looking for, allowing them to prepare stronger loan applications and anticipate potential concerns.
SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION LOANS
When an entrepreneur is unable to secure a regular commercial bank loan, an alternative is a Small Business Administration (SBA) Guaranty Loan. The SBA guarantees that 80% of the loan will be repaid to the bank by the SBA if the company canβt pay. This allows the bank to make loans that have higher risks. This procedure is the same as for securing a bank loan, except that government forms and documentation are required.
Both long and short-term loans can be guaranteed by the SBA. A maximum loan period of 15 years on existing buildings and 20 years on new construction can be obtained. For inventory, equipment, or working capital, a maximum of 10 years is available, although five years is the usual. Once the application has been filled out, it usually is processed within 15 days. There are additional reporting requirements beyond those for a conventional bank loan. Since there is no difference in interest rates charged between conventional bank loans and SBA-guaranteed loans, a commercial bank loan is usually better. A good banking relationship is very valuable as the venture grows.
For most SBA loans, there is no limit to the amount of loan money requested, but there is a practical limit of $1 million. The vast majority of small businesses are eligible for financial assistance from the SBA. As defined by the Small Business Act, a small business is independently owned and operated and not dominant in its field of operation. The size limits of a small business vary from industry to industry. The proceeds of the loans can be used for almost any business purpose. The interest rates are negotiated between the entrepreneur and the bank, but they are subject to SBA maximums.
π Definition β SBA Guaranty Loan: A loan guaranteed by the Small Business Administration, where the SBA promises to repay 80% of the loan to the bank if the borrower defaults. π Formula: Maximum SBA Loan Amount β $1 million practical limit π Example: An entrepreneur unable to secure a conventional bank loan for $500,000 applies for an SBA-guaranteed loan. The bank can now approve the loan because the SBA guarantees 80% ($400,000) repayment. The loan term for working capital is typically 5 years. The interest rate is negotiated between the entrepreneur and the bank, subject to SBA maximums.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember the five Cβs of lending (Character, Capacity, Capital, Collateral, Conditions) as the core framework banks use to evaluate borrowers. The SBA Guaranty Loan is a backup option when conventional loans are denied, with the SBA guaranteeing 80% of repayment, allowing banks to take higher risks. Commercial bank loans are generally preferable to SBA loans since interest rates are the same but SBA loans have additional reporting requirements. The practical SBA loan limit is $1 million, with varying maximum terms depending on the purpose (15 years for existing buildings, 20 years for new construction, 10 years for inventory/equipment/working capital). Entrepreneurs should borrow the maximum amount they can repay and evaluate multiple banksβ lending policies.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five Cβs of bank lending decisions, and which two are considered intuitive factors?
- What percentage of an SBA Guaranty Loan is guaranteed to be repaid to the bank?
- What is the maximum loan period for new construction under an SBA-guaranteed loan?
- Why is a commercial bank loan usually better than an SBA-guaranteed loan?
- What is the practical monetary limit for most SBA loans?
π Lecture 35 β Sources of Capital
π Overview: This lecture examines two key sources of capital for entrepreneurial ventures: Research and Development Limited Partnerships and Government Grants. Understanding these funding mechanisms is crucial for technology-based startups seeking non-dilutive financing and support for high-risk innovations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the identification of types of financing available, the aspects of research and development limited partnerships including their major elements, procedure, benefits, costs, and examples, and government grants, particularly the Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) grant program and its three phases and procedure.
π Lecture Summary
RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT LIMITED PARTNERSHIPS
This method of financing provides funds from inventors looking for tax shelters. A typical R&D partnership arrangement is established with a sponsoring company developing the technology with funds being provided by a limited partnership of individual investors. Research and development limited partnerships are particularly good when the project involves a high degree of risk or significant expense.
Major Elements The three components are the contract, the sponsoring company, and the limited partnership. The contract specifies the agreement between the sponsoring company and the limited partnership. The sponsoring company does not guarantee results, but performs work on a best-effort basis. The typical contract specifies that the liability for any loss be borne by the limited partners. There are some tax advantages for both the partnership and the company. This tax deduction is based on two authorizations: Section 174 of the Internal Revenue Code and the Snow vs. Commissioner case of 1974. Limited partners may deduct their investments in the R&D contract under Section 174 in the year their investments are made, significantly increasing the rate of return of the investment. The limited partners have limited liability but are not a taxable entity. Any tax benefits of the losses are passed directly to the limited partners. When the technology is successfully developed, the partners share in the profits. The sponsoring company acts as the general partner developing the technology. The sponsoring company usually has the base technology but needs to secure partners for commercial success. The company usually retains the rights to use this technology to develop other products.
π‘ Why this matters: R&D limited partnerships allow startups to fund high-risk technology development without giving up significant equity, while offering investors valuable tax deductions.
Procedure In the funding stage, a contract is established and the money invested for the proposed R&D effort. In the development stage, the company performs the actual research, using the funds of the limited partners. If the technology is successfully developed, the exit stage begins, with both parties reaping the benefits. In the typical agreement, the sponsoring company and limited partners form a new jointly owned corporation. An alternative is a royalty partnership in which a royalty based on the sale of the products is paid by the company to the limited partnership. The company and limited partners may form a joint venture to manufacture and market the product.
π Definition β R&D Limited Partnership: A financing arrangement where a sponsoring company develops technology using funds from a limited partnership of individual investors seeking tax shelters. π Definition β Royalty Partnership: An alternative exit arrangement where the sponsoring company pays a royalty to the limited partnership based on product sales.
Benefits and Costs Benefits: R&D limited partnerships provide the needed funds with a minimum of equity dilution while reducing the risks. The sponsoring companyβs financial statements are strengthened. Costs: There is considerable time and money involved. Most R&D limited partnerships are unsuccessful. The restrictions placed on the technology may be substantial. The exit from the partnership may be too complex.
Examples Successful R&D limited partnerships include Syntex Corporation, Genetech, and Trilogy Limited. R&D limited partnerships offer one alternative to funding technological development.
GOVERNMENT GRANTS
The Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) grant program helps entrepreneurs obtain federal grant money to develop an innovative idea. The act requires all federal agencies to share a portion of the R&D funds with small businesses. This provides a uniform method of soliciting, evaluating, and selecting research proposals. Eleven agencies are involved in the program. Small businesses submit proposals directly to each agency. The agencies evaluate each proposal on a competitive basis and make awards. The SBIR grant program has three phases.
- Phase I: Awards are up to $50,000 for six months of feasibility-related experimental or theoretical research.
- Phase II: This is the principal R&D effort. Awards are up to $500,000 for 24 months of further research and development. The money is to be used to develop prototype products.
- Phase III: Funds from other sources, such as the private sector or regular government contracts, are needed to commercialize the developed technologies.
Procedure The agencies publish solicitations describing the areas of research they will fund. The second step is submission of the proposal by a company or individual. Each agency screens the proposals it receives, and those passing are evaluated by experts. Awards are granted to those projects that have the best potential for commercialization. Any patent rights, research data, and software generated are owned by the company, not the government. The SBIR grant program is one alternative for a technically based entrepreneurial company that is independently owned and operated and employs 500 or fewer individuals.
π Definition β SBIR Grant Program: A federal grant program that requires all agencies to share R&D funds with small businesses, providing up to $50,000 for Phase I feasibility research and up to $500,000 for Phase II prototype development.
π Formula: SBIR Phase Structure β Phase I (6 months, up to $50,000) β Phase II (24 months, up to $500,000) β Phase III (commercialization from other sources) π Example: A small biotech company with 50 employees submits an SBIR proposal to the NIH for developing a new diagnostic device. If awarded, Phase I provides $50,000 for 6 months to test feasibility. Upon success, Phase II provides $500,000 for 24 months to build a prototype. Phase III requires finding private investors or government contracts to bring the product to market.
β Key Takeaways
R&D Limited Partnerships offer a tax-advantaged financing method for high-risk technology development, involving three components (contract, sponsoring company, limited partnership) and three stages (funding, development, exit). The major benefits are minimal equity dilution and strengthened financial statements, while the costs include complexity and high failure rates. The SBIR program is a three-phase federal grant system providing up to $50,000 for feasibility research and up to $500,000 for prototype development, with the critical advantage that the company retains all patent rights and research data. Both sources are specifically valuable for technology-based entrepreneurial ventures seeking non-dilutive capital to fund innovation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of an R&D Limited Partnership and what role does each play?
- What two legal authorizations allow limited partners to deduct their R&D investments in the year made?
- What are the three stages in the procedure of an R&D Limited Partnership?
- What are the maximum award amounts and durations for Phases I and II of the SBIR grant program?
- Who owns the patent rights and research data generated from an SBIR-funded project?