๐ Lecture 23 โ Creating and Starting the Venture (Continued....)
๐ Overview: This lecture provides a detailed, step-by-step guide to writing a comprehensive business plan. It explains the purpose and contents of each major section of the plan, from the venture description to the appendix. Understanding how to construct each part is critical for securing investor funding and ensuring the venture's feasibility.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers writing the business plan by detailing each section: Description of the Venture, Production or Operations Plan, Marketing Plan, Organizational Plan, Assessment of Risk, Financial Plan, and the Appendix. It also lists other possible supporting documents to include.
๐ Lecture Summary
Description of the Venture
This section requires a detailed explanation of the new business. It must begin with the mission statement or company mission, which defines the nature of the business and the entrepreneurโs ultimate goals. The description should include the product, location, personnel, the entrepreneur's background, and the venture's history. The importance of location depends on the business type, and maps showing customers, competitors, or alternative sites can be useful. If the location involves legal issues, a lawyer should be hired.
๐ Definition โ Mission Statement: A statement that describes the nature of the business and what the entrepreneur hopes to accomplish.
Production Plan or Operations Plan
For a manufacturing venture, a production plan is needed. This must describe the complete manufacturing process, including whether any part will be subcontracted. If the entrepreneur handles manufacturing, the plan should detail the physical plant layout and required machinery and equipment. For non-manufacturing ventures, this section is titled the operations plan. It describes the chronological steps to complete a single business transaction.
Marketing Plan
The marketing plan describes how the products will be distributed, priced, and promoted. Potential investors consider this plan critical to the ventureโs success.
๐ Definition โ Marketing Plan: The section that describes how products will be distributed, priced, and promoted.
Organizational Plan
This section describes the venture's form of ownership (e.g., sole proprietorship, partnership, corporation). If the venture is a corporation, it should include the number of authorized shares, share options, and the names and addresses of directors and officers. An organization chart showing the line of authority is helpful, as it demonstrates who controls the organization and how members interact.
๐ Definition โ Organization Chart: A diagram indicating the line of authority, showing who controls the organization and how members interact.
Assessment of Risk
The entrepreneur must assess potential risks systematically. First, they should indicate the potential risks to the new venture. Second, they should discuss what might happen if these risks become reality. Finally, they should discuss the strategy to prevent, minimize, or respond to these risks. The plan must also provide alternative strategies should these risk factors occur.
Financial Plan
The financial plan determines the total investment needed and indicates whether the business plan is economically feasible. The entrepreneur should summarize the forecasted sales and expenses for the first three years. Cash flow figures for three years are needed, with the first yearโs projections provided monthly. A projected balance sheet shows the financial condition of the business at a specific time.
๐ Definition โ Financial Plan: The section that determines the investment needed for the new venture and indicates whether the business plan is economically feasible. ๐ Formula: Cash Flow = Cash Inflows - Cash Outflows โ Shows the net change in cash over a period. ๐ Example: A startup projects $10,000 in cash inflows (sales) and $7,000 in cash outflows (expenses) in January. Its January net cash flow is $3,000.
Appendix
The appendix contains any backup material not included in the main text of the document.
Other possible documents
Other supporting documents that can be included are letters from customers, distributors, or subcontractors; secondary or primary research data; leases and contracts; and price lists from suppliers and competitors.
โญ Key Takeaways
A formal business plan is structured into specific, mandatory sections that serve distinct purposes. Investors view the marketing and financial plans as the most critical for gauging success. The assessment of risk is not just about identifying problems but about showing the entrepreneur has proactive strategies and alternatives. Every financial projection must be backed by monthly cash flow data for the first year and three-year forecasts for sales, expenses, and cash flow. Finally, supporting documents should be placed in the appendix, not the main body of the plan.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the first document that must appear in the "Description of the Venture" section?
- For a non-manufacturing business, what is the name of the plan that replaces the "Production Plan"?
- Why do potential investors regard the marketing plan as critical to the venture's success?
- What three specific steps must an entrepreneur follow when creating the "Assessment of Risk" section?
- What are the two specific financial outputs required for the first year in the Financial Plan?
๐ Lecture 24 โ Creating and Starting the Venture (Continued....)
๐ Overview: This lecture focuses on how entrepreneurs can effectively use, implement, and monitor a business plan after it has been created. It explains why many business plans fail, details the structure and purpose of a marketing plan, and distinguishes between different types of planning such as strategic and market planning.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the practical use and implementation of the business plan, including measuring progress through various control systems (inventory, production, quality, sales, disbursements) and updating the plan. It then analyzes common reasons why business plans fail, such as unreasonable goals and lack of commitment. Finally, it introduces the marketing plan, explaining its purpose, timing, and the three fundamental questions it must answer regarding past performance, future objectives, and the strategy to achieve them.
๐ Lecture Summary
Using and Implementing the Business Plan
The business plan is designed to guide the entrepreneur through the first year of operations and must contain control points to ascertain progress. Effective planning is critical because without it, employees will not understand company goals. Bankers state that most businesses fail due to the entrepreneurโs inability to plan effectively. The entrepreneur can enhance implementation by developing a schedule to measure programs and instituting contingency plans.
Measuring Plan Progress
While plan projections are typically made on a 12-month schedule, the entrepreneur should check key areas more frequently. Key control areas include:
- Inventory control: Ensures maximum service to the customer.
- Production control: Compares cost figures against day-to-day operating costs.
- Quality control: Depends on the type of production system used.
- Sales control: Collects information on units, dollars, and specific products sold.
- Disbursements: Controls the amount of money paid out.
Updating the Plan
Environmental factors and internal factors can change the direction of the plan. It is important to be sensitive to changes in the company, industry, and market.
Why Some Business Plans Fail
A poorly prepared business plan can be blamed on:
- Goals set by the entrepreneurs that are unreasonable.
- Goals that are not measurable.
To be successful, goals should be specific, should be measurable, and should be monitored over time. The entrepreneur who has not made a total commitment to the business will not be able to meet the ventureโs demands. Investors will not be positive about a venture that does not have a full-time commitment and will typically expect a significant financial commitment from the entrepreneur. Lack of experience will result in failure unless the entrepreneur can gain knowledge or team up with someone. The entrepreneur should also document customer needs before preparing the plan.
Marketing Plan: Purpose and Timing of the Marketing Plan
The marketing plan establishes how the entrepreneur will effectively compete and operate in the marketplace. Marketing planning should be an annual activity focusing on decisions related to the marketing mix variables. The plan should focus on strategies for the first three years of the venture:
- For the first year: Goals and strategies should be projected monthly.
- For years two and three: Market results should be projected based on longer-term goals. Preparing an annual marketing plan becomes the basis for planning other aspects of the business.
Understanding the Marketing Plan
The marketing plan should answer three basic questions:
- Where have we been? - The history of the marketplace, marketing strengths and weaknesses, and market opportunities.
- Where do we want to go (short term)? - Marketing objectives and goals in the next twelve months.
- How do we get there? - The specific marketing strategy that will be implemented.
The marketing plan should be a guide for implementing marketing decision-making, not a superficial document. The mere organization of the thinking process involved in preparing a marketing plan can be helpful in understanding and recognizing critical issues.
๐ Definition โ Control Points: Specific benchmarks or metrics within a business plan used to measure and ascertain progress.
๐ Definition โ Contingency Plans: Backup plans instituted to address potential changes or unforeseen problems that could derail the original business plan.
๐ Definition โ Marketing Mix Variables: The set of controllable, tactical marketing toolsโtypically product, price, place, and promotionโthat the firm blends to produce the response it wants in the target market.
๐ Formula: Successful Goals โ Specific + Measurable + Monitored over time. ๐ Example: Instead of a goal like "increase sales," a successful goal would be "increase sales of Product X by 15% in the next quarter," which is specific, measurable, and can be monitored.
โญ Key Takeaways
A business plan is not a static document; it must be actively used, monitored, and updated over the first year. Success depends on setting specific, measurable goals and the entrepreneurโs full-time commitment and financial investment. A failed plan often results from unreasonable goals, lack of measurement, and insufficient commitment or experience. The marketing plan is a critical, annual component that focuses on the marketing mix and answers key strategic questions about past performance, future objectives, and the implementation strategy for the first three years of the venture.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five key control areas an entrepreneur should check more frequently than the standard 12-month plan schedule?
- According to the lecture, what are the two primary reasons for a poorly prepared, failing business plan?
- For how many years should a marketing plan focus on strategies, and how do the projections differ between year one and years two and three?
- What are the three basic questions a marketing plan must answer?
- Why do investors typically expect the entrepreneur to make a significant financial commitment to the business?
๐ Lecture 25 โ THE MARKETING PLAN
๐ Overview: This lecture explains how entrepreneurs create a marketing plan to compete effectively. It covers the differences between business, strategic, and marketing planning, the role of marketing research, and the steps to prepare a practical marketing plan. Understanding this lecture is essential for building a ventureโs go-to-market strategy and ensuring long-term survival.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by distinguishing business planning, strategy plans, and market planning, then discusses the purpose and timing of the marketing plan. It explains market research for new ventures, including defining objectives, gathering secondary and primary data, using focus groups, and analyzing results. Finally, it outlines the characteristics of an effective marketing plan and describes the marketing system including internal and external environmental factors.
๐ Lecture Summary
PURPOSE AND TIMING OF THE MARKETING PLAN
The marketing plan establishes how the entrepreneur will effectively compete and operate in the marketplace. Marketing planning should be an annual activity focusing on decisions related to the marketing mix variables. The marketing plan section should focus on strategies for the first three years of the venture. For the first year, goals and strategies should be projected monthly. For years two and three, market results should be projected based on longer-term goals. Preparing an annual marketing plan becomes the basis for planning other aspects of the business.
MARKET RESEARCH FOR THE NEW VENTURE
Marketing research involves the gathering of data in order to determine such information as who will buy the product, what price should be charged, and what is the most effective promotion strategy. Marketing research may be conducted by the entrepreneur or by an external supplier or consultant. Market research begins with definition of objectives. Many entrepreneurs donโt know what they want to accomplish from a research study.
Defining the Purpose or Objectives
One effective way to begin the marketing plan is to make a list of the information that will be needed to prepare the marketing plan.
Possible objectives:
- Determine what people think of the product or service and if they would buy it.
- Determine how much customers would be willing to pay for the product.
- Determine where the customer would prefer to purchase the product.
- Determine where the customer would expect to hear about such a product or service.
Gathering Data from Secondary Sources
An obvious source is data that already exists, or secondary data, found in trade magazines, libraries, government agencies, and the Internet. The Internet can provide information on competitors and the industry, plus can be used for primary research. Commercial data may also be available, but the cost may be prohibitive. Free secondary information is available through: The U.S. Bureau of Census and the Department of Commerce; state departments of commerce, chambers of commerce, and local banks; private sources of data, such as Predicasts, the Business Index, and the SBAโs Directory of Business Development Publications. A local business library can also provide access to reference sources and articles about competitors and the industry. The entrepreneur should exhaust all possible secondary data sources, observation, and networking before beginning costly primary data research.
Gathering Information from Primary Sources
Information that is new is primary data. Observation is the simplest approach. Networking is an informal method to gather primary data from experts in the field and can be a valuable low-cost research method. A recent study found that the most successful ventures were focused on information about competitors, the customer, and the industry. Less successful ventures were more focused on gathering information on general economic and demographic trends. Interviewing or surveying is the most common approach, but is more expensive. The questionnaire used by the entrepreneur should include questions designed to fulfill one or more of the objectives. Questions should be designed so they are clear and concise, without bias, and easy to answer. If the entrepreneur lacks experience, he or she should seek help in developing the questionnaire through Small Business Development Centers or a local education institution.
Focus groups
A focus group is a sample of 10 or 12 potential customers who participate in a discussion. Groups discuss issues in an informal, open format. These groups should be led by an experienced monitor. Experimentation involves control over specific variables in the research process.
Analyzing and Interpreting the Results
The entrepreneur can enter the results on a computer or hand-tabulate the results. Summarizing the answers to questions will give preliminary insights. Data can then be cross-tabulated to provide more focused results.
UNDERSTANDING THE MARKETING PLAN
The marketing plan should answer three basic questions:
- Where have we been? โ The history of the marketplace, marketing strengths and weaknesses, and market opportunities.
- Where do we want to go (short term)? โ Marketing objectives and goals in the next twelve months.
- How do we get there? โ Specific marketing strategy that will be implemented.
The marketing plan should be a guide for implementing marketing decision-making and not a superficial document. The mere organization of the thinking process involved in preparing a marketing plan can be helpful in understanding and recognizing critical issues.
CHARACTERISTICS OF A MARKETING PLAN
An effective marketing plan should:
- Provide a strategy to accomplish the company mission.
- Be based on facts and valid assumptions.
- Provide for the use of existing resources.
- Describe an organization to implement the plan.
- Provide for continuity.
- Be simple and short.
- Be flexible.
- Specify performance criteria that can be monitored and controlled.
The marketing system identifies the major interacting components, both internal and external, that enable the firm to provide products to the marketplace. Environment factors, although largely uncontrollable, should be studied.
Internal environmental factors are more controllable by the entrepreneur:
- Financial resources: The financial plan should outline the financial needs for the venture.
- Management team: An effective management team with responsibilities assigned is needed for implementing the marketing plan.
- Suppliers: Suppliers used are generally based on a number of factors, such as price, delivery time, and quality.
- Company mission: Every new venture should define the nature of its business and what it hopes to accomplish.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must understand that the marketing plan is an annual guide for competing in the marketplace, focusing on the first three years with monthly projections for year one. Marketing research begins with clear objectives and should exhaust low-cost secondary data before moving to expensive primary data collection like surveys or focus groups. The most successful ventures focus research on competitors, customers, and the industry rather than general economic trends. An effective marketing plan must be simple, flexible, based on facts, and include performance criteria for monitoring. Finally, the marketing system includes both uncontrollable external environmental factors and controllable internal factors like financial resources, management team, suppliers, and company mission.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three basic questions that a marketing plan should answer?
- List four possible objectives an entrepreneur might define before conducting marketing research.
- What is the difference between secondary data and primary data? Give an example of each.
- What is a focus group, and how many participants typically are involved?
- Name at least four characteristics of an effective marketing plan.
๐ Lecture 26 โ THE MARKETING MIX
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the four components of the marketing mixโProduct, Price, Distribution, and Promotionโand then provides a detailed, step-by-step framework for preparing a complete marketing plan. It emphasizes the importance of situation analysis, target market definition, strategy formulation, and ongoing monitoring to ensure a new venture's marketing efforts are effective and coordinated.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the marketing mix (Product, Pricing, Distribution, and Promotion) as the core short-term marketing decisions. It then presents a comprehensive ten-step process for developing a marketing plan, covering: defining the business situation through situation and industry analysis; defining the target market via market segmentation; analyzing strengths and weaknesses; establishing goals and objectives; detailing the marketing strategy for product, customer service, pricing, distribution, and promotion; coordinating the planning process; assigning implementation responsibility; budgeting; implementing the plan; and monitoring progress.
๐ Lecture Summary
THE MARKETING MIX
The actual short-term marketing decisions in the marketing plan consist of four important marketing variables, called the marketing mix. Each variable should be described in detail in the strategy section of the marketing plan.
The four variables are:
- Product or service
- Pricing
- Distribution
- Promotion
STEPS IN PREPARING THE MARKETING PLAN
Step 1: Defining the Business Situation
The situation analysis is a review of where the company has been and considers many of the environmental factors. The entrepreneur should provide a review of past performance of the product and the company. Industry analysis should include information on market size, growth rate, suppliers, new entries, and economic conditions.
Step 2: Defining Target Market/Opportunities and Threats
The entrepreneur should have a good idea of who the customer or target market will be. The defined target market will usually represent one or more segments of the entire market. Market segmentation is the process of dividing the market into smaller homogeneous groups.
The process of segmenting is: a. Decide what general market or industry you wish to pursue. b. Divide the market into smaller groups based on characteristics of the customer. c. Select segment or segments to target. d. Develop a marketing plan integrating the parts of the marketing mix.
Step 3: Considering Strengths and Weaknesses
It is important for the entrepreneur to consider its strengths and weaknesses.
Step 4: Establishing Goals and Objectives
Before strategy decisions can be outlined, the entrepreneur must establish realistic marketing goals and objectives. These answer the question "Where do we want to go?" These goals should specify such things as market share, profit, sales, market penetration, pricing policy, and advertising support. Not all goals and objectives must be quantified. It is a good idea to limit the number of goals to between six and eight.
Step 5: Defining Marketing Strategy and Action Programs
Strategy and action decisions respond to the question "How do we get there?" It incorporates:
1. Product or Service This includes a description of the product and may involve more than the physical characteristics. It involves packaging, brand name, price, warranty, image, service, features, and style.
2. Customer Service Meeting customer needs and creating loyalty involves a number of low-cost steps:
- In writing, develop a statement of customer service principles.
- Train those employees who have direct contact with customers.
- Establish a process for evaluating customer service.
- Reward employees who are most effective in providing quality customer service.
- Make regular contact with customers.
- Invest in quality telephone equipment.
- Meet customer expectations.
- Customer service is especially important for e-businesses.
3. Pricing One of the difficult decisions is determining the appropriate price for the product. Factors such as costs, discounts, freight, and markups must be considered. Marketing research can help determine a reasonable price that consumers are willing to pay.
4. Distribution This factor provides utility or makes the product convenient to purchase when it is needed. This variable must be consistent with other marketing mix variables. Type of channel, number of intermediaries, and location of members should be described. Regardless of the type of business, it is usually necessary for the new venture to have a website. The Internet will become an increasingly important medium for information and distribution. Direct mail or telemarketing may be considered. Direct mail marketing is one of the simplest and lowest in entry costs. The entrepreneur should evaluate all possible options for distribution.
5. Promotion The entrepreneur needs to inform customers as to the productโs availability using advertising media such as print, radio, or television. Usually television is too expensive unless cable television is a viable option. Larger markets can be reached using direct mail, trade magazines, or newspapers. A website may also create awareness and promote the product and services. It is possible to make use of publicity as a means of introduction. It is important that the marketing strategy and action programs be specific and detailed enough to guide the entrepreneur through the first year.
Step 6: Coordination of the Planning Process
The management team must coordinate the planning process. The entrepreneur may be the only person involved but may lack experience. Assistance is available from many sources, such as the SBA (Small Business Administration).
Step 7: Designing Responsibility for Implementation
The plan must be implemented effectively to meet all of the desired goals and objectives. Someone must take the responsibility for implementing each decision made in the marketing plan.
Step 8: Budgeting the Marketing Strategy
Planning decisions must also consider the costs involved in the implementation of these decisions. This budgeting will be useful in preparing the financial plan.
Step 9: Implementation of the Marketing Plan
The marketing plan is meant to be a commitment to a specific strategy. A commitment to make adjustments as needed by market conditions is also valuable.
Step 10: Monitoring Progress of Marketing Actions
Monitoring of the plan involves tracking specific results of the marketing effort. What is monitored is dependent on the specific goals and objectives outlined.
โญ Key Takeaways
The core marketing mix consists of four interdependent variablesโProduct, Pricing, Distribution, and Promotionโthat must be detailed in the strategy section. Developing a marketing plan is a systematic ten-step process that begins with a situation analysis, proceeds through defining the target market via segmentation, and culminates in strategy, budgeting, and monitoring. Key strategy components include product description, customer service principles, pricing research, distribution channel selection (including the internet and direct mail), and promotion via appropriate media. The plan is a living commitment that requires clear assignment of implementation responsibility and ongoing monitoring against established goals.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four components of the marketing mix?
- What is the primary purpose of a situation analysis in the first step of the marketing plan?
- Describe the four-step process for segmenting a market as presented in the lecture.
- List at least four specific low-cost steps that an entrepreneur can take to improve customer service.
- Besides the product and price, what other elements are included in the "Product or Service" component of the marketing strategy?
๐ Lecture 27 โ The Organizational Plan
๐ Overview: This lecture focuses on the critical components of the organizational plan for a new venture. It explains the importance of the management team to investors and details the various legal forms of business ownershipโproprietorship, partnership, corporation, and limited liability companyโcomparing their advantages and disadvantages regarding ownership, liability, and continuity.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers developing the management team and why investors scrutinize it closely. It then compares the legal forms of business, focusing on ownership, liability of owners, costs of starting a business, and continuity of business. The management team's commitment, salary, and the role of boards of directors/advisors are also discussed.
๐ Lecture Summary
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
This lesson aims to help students understand the importance of the management team for a new venture. It explains the pros and cons of different legal forms of incorporation, including the S Corporation and limited liability company. It also covers how to prepare a job analysis, job description, and job specification, and how a board of directors or board of advisors can support management.
DEVELOPING THE MANAGEMENT TEAM
Potential investors are primarily interested in the management team's ability and commitment. They usually demand the team operates the business full-time and does not draw a large salary. The entrepreneur should consider using a board of directors or board of advisors to support the venture.
LEGAL FORMS OF BUSINESS
There are three basic legal forms: proprietorship, partnership, and corporation. A newer form is the limited liability company. The entrepreneur must evaluate each form's pros and cons before submitting a business plan, considering factors like image to suppliers and customers.
Ownership
- In a proprietorship, the owner has full responsibility.
- In a partnership, there may be general or limited partners.
- In a corporation, ownership is reflected by shares of stock.
Liability of Owners
- Proprietors and general partners are liable for all business aspects.
- In a corporation, owners are liable only for their investment, as the corporation is a separate legal entity that absorbs liability.
- Creditors can seize personal assets of owners in proprietorships or regular partnerships to satisfy debts.
- In a partnership, general partners share personal liability equally, regardless of capital contribution.
- In a limited partnership, limited partners are liable only for their capital contributions.
Costs of Starting a Business
- A proprietorship is the least expensive; costs may only involve filing for a business name.
- A partnership requires a formal agreement, needing legal advice to define responsibilities.
- A limited partnership is more complex, strictly complying with statutory requirements.
- A corporation is created by statute, requiring registration of name and articles of incorporation, filing fees, and legal advice.
Continuity of Business
- In a sole proprietorship, the owner's death terminates the business.
- In a partnership, the death or withdrawal of a partner terminates the partnership unless the agreement specifies otherwise. The partnership may buy out the partner's share or let a family member take over.
- The death of a limited partner in a limited partnership has no effect, but the death of a general partner terminates it unless the agreement specifies otherwise.
- The corporation has the most continuity; the owner's death or withdrawal has no impact, except in a closely held corporation.
โญ Key Takeaways
- Investors prioritize a committed, full-time management team that does not take a large salary.
- The three basic legal forms are proprietorship, partnership, and corporation, with the limited liability company as a newer option.
- Liability is a critical difference: proprietors and general partners have unlimited personal liability, while corporate shareholders are only liable for their investment.
- The cost and complexity of starting are lowest for a proprietorship and highest for a corporation.
- The corporation offers the most continuity of business, unaffected by the owner's death or withdrawal.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Why do potential investors demand that the management team not operate the business part-time while employed full-time elsewhere?
- What is the difference in personal liability between a general partner and a limited partner in a limited partnership?
- What happens to a sole proprietorship upon the death of the owner?
- Which legal form generally has the lowest cost of starting a business?
- What is the main advantage of a corporation regarding the continuity of the business?
๐ Lecture 28 โ The Organizational Plan (Continued ....)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of the organizational plan by comparing different forms of business ownership across multiple critical factors. It examines how proprietorships, partnerships, limited partnerships, corporations, and S corporations differ in terms of transferring ownership, raising capital, retaining management control, distributing profits, and attracting investment. Understanding these differences helps entrepreneurs choose the best legal structure for their venture.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five key comparative factors across business forms: transferability of interest, capital requirements, management control, distribution of profits and losses, and attractiveness for raising capital. Each factor is examined for proprietorships, general partnerships, limited partnerships, corporations, and S corporations.
๐ Lecture Summary
Transferability of Interest
Each form of business offers different advantages regarding how easily ownership interests can be transferred. In a proprietorship, the entrepreneur has the right to sell any assets without restriction. In a limited partnership, limited partners can sell their interests at any time without consent of the general partners, but a general partner cannot sell any interest unless specified in the partnership agreement. In a corporation, shareholders may transfer their shares at any time freely. In the S Corporation, transfer of interest can occur only as long as the buyer is an individual.
๐ Definition โ Transferability of Interest: The ease with which ownership rights in a business can be sold, assigned, or passed to another party. ๐ Example: A shareholder in a corporation can sell their shares on the stock market at any time, but a general partner in a partnership must follow the partnership agreement to sell their interest.
Capital Requirements
The need for capital during the early months can become one of the most critical factors in keeping a new venture alive. For a proprietorship, any new capital can only come from loans or by additional personal contributions โ often an entrepreneur will take a second mortgage as a source of capital. Any borrowing from an outside investor may require giving up some equity, and failure to make payments can result in foreclosure and liquidation of the business. In a partnership, loans may be obtained from banks or additional funds may be contributed by each partner, but both methods require a change in the partnership agreement. In a corporation, new capital can be raised by selling stock as either voting or nonvoting, selling bonds, or borrowing money in the name of the corporation.
๐ก Why this matters: The ability to raise capital directly affects a startup's survival and growth potential. Corporations have the most flexibility, while proprietors face the most personal risk when seeking funds.
Management Control
The entrepreneur will want to retain as much control as possible over the business. In a proprietorship, the entrepreneur has the most control and flexibility in making business decisions. In a partnership, the majority usually rules unless the partnership agreement states otherwise. In a limited partnership, limited partners have no control over business decisions โ control of day-to-day business is in the hands of management. In a corporation, major long-term decisions may require a vote of the major stockholders. As the corporation increases in size, the separation of management and control is probable. Stockholders can indirectly affect the operation by electing someone to the board of directors.
Distribution of Profits and Losses
Proprietors receive all profits from the business and bear all losses personally. In a partnership, the distribution of profits and losses depends on the partnership agreement and can be allocated in any agreed-upon proportion. Corporations distribute profits through dividends to stockholders, and losses are retained at the corporate level or passed through in certain entity types.
Attractiveness for Raising Capital
In both the proprietorship and partnership, the ability to raise capital depends on the success of the business and personal capability of the entrepreneur. Because of its limitations on personal liability, the corporation is the most attractive form for raising capital from outside investors who want limited risk.
โญ Key Takeaways
For exam purposes, memorize the five comparative factors: transferability of interest, capital requirements, management control, distribution of profits/losses, and attractiveness for raising capital. Know that proprietors have total control but limited capital sources and personal liability; partnerships require agreements for most changes; corporations offer the best capital-raising ability with limited liability but less direct control for owners. The corporation is consistently the most attractive form for raising external capital. Limited partners have no management control but can freely transfer their interests.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- In which business form must a general partner obtain consent before selling their interest?
- What are the three ways a corporation can raise new capital according to the lecture?
- How does the distribution of profits differ between a proprietorship and a corporation?
- Why is the corporation considered the most attractive form for raising capital?
- What restriction applies to the transfer of interest in an S Corporation?
๐ Lecture 29 โ The Organizational Plan (Continued ....)
๐ Overview: This lecture covers the tax attributes of various business forms โ proprietorship, partnership, corporation, S corporation, and limited liability company โ explaining their advantages and disadvantages. It also discusses how to design an organization from start-up through growth stages, including job analysis and hiring strategies, which are critical for entrepreneurs planning their business structure.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins with tax issues for proprietorship, partnership, and corporation, then moves to S corporations โ their features, advantages, and disadvantages โ followed by the limited liability company (LLC). The second half covers designing the organization, including stages of development (Stage 1 and Stage 2), manager roles, and building a successful organization through job analysis, hiring procedures, and compensation planning.
๐ Lecture Summary
TAX ATTRIBUTES OF FORMS OF BUSINESS
A. Tax Issues for Proprietorship
For the proprietorship, the IRS treats the business as the individual owner. All income is personal income and the business is not taxed as a separate entity. The proprietorship has some tax advantages compared to the corporation:
- There is no double tax on profits.
- There is no capital stock tax or penalty for retained earnings.
B. Tax Issues for Partnership
The partnershipโs tax advantages and disadvantages are similar to the proprietorship. Limited partnerships can provide unique tax advantages. Both the partnership and proprietorship have a legal identity distinct from the partners, but this identity is only for accounting purposes. The income is distributed based on the partnership agreement, and the owners then report their share as personal income.
C. Tax Issues for Corporation
The corporation has the advantage of being able to take many deductions not otherwise available. The disadvantage is that dividends are taxed twice. This double taxation can be avoided if the income is distributed as salary. The corporation tax may also be lower than the individual rate.
S CORPORATIONS
The S Corporation combines the tax advantages of the partnership and the corporation. It is designed so that the venture income is declared as personal income on a pro rata basis. Shareholders benefit from all of the income and the deductions of the business.
Prior to passage of the 1996 Small Business Protection Act, rules governing the S corporation were considered too rigid. The new law provides more flexibility with regard to:
- Number of shareholders.
- Who can be allowed to own shares.
- The role of trusts as stockholders.
- The ability of S corporations to own more than 90 percent of stock of another corporation.
- Distribution of profits.
- Issuance of different classes of stock.
- Rules affecting the tax basis of incurred losses.
Limited liability corporations are still more flexible than the S corporation, but conversion entails a significant cost. More than half of all S corporations have only one shareholder, which would not be possible as an LLC.
ADVANTAGES OF AN S CORPORATION
- Capital gains or losses are treated as personal income.
- Shareholders retain limited liability protection.
- It is not subject to a minimum tax, as C corporations are.
- Stock may be transferred to low-income-bracket family members.
- Stock may be voting or nonvoting.
- This form may use the cash method of accounting.
- Corporate long-term capital gains and losses are deductible by the shareholders.
DISADVANTAGES OF AN S CORPORATION
- Even with the new regulations, there are still some restrictions.
- If the corporation earns less than $100,000, then the C Corporation would have a lower tax liability.
- The S Corporation may not deduct most fringe benefits for shareholders.
- The S Corporation must adopt a calendar year for tax purposes.
- Only one class of stock, common stock, is permitted.
- The net loss of the S Corporation is limited.
THE LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY
The limited liability company (LLC) is a popular new entity that offers similar advantages as the S Corporation but with more liberal tax rules under subchapter K. This form is a partnership-corporation hybrid with the following characteristics:
- Where the corporation has shareholders, the LLC has members.
- No shares are issued, and each member owns an interest in the business.
- Liability does not extend beyond the memberโs capital contribution.
- Members may transfer their interest only with the unanimous written consent of the remaining members.
- The standard acceptable term of an LLC is 30 years.
The laws governing formation of the LLCs differ from state to state. The LLC is similar to an S corporation but is more flexible. A major concern with LLCs is in international business, where the context of unlimited liability is still unclear. The primary differences between the limited partnership and the LLC are that the limited partnership must have at least one general partner with unlimited liability for partnership debts. The acceptability of the LLC should grow as state statutes are clarified and international rules established. With the assistance of a tax attorney, owners should compare alternative forms of ownership.
๐ก Why this matters: Choosing the right business form affects taxation, liability, and flexibility โ a decision that has long-term financial and legal consequences for the entrepreneur.
DESIGNING THE ORGANIZATION
The design of the initial organization will be simple. The entrepreneur may perform all of the functions alone. He or she sometimes is unwilling to give up responsibility to others. The entrepreneur may have difficulty making the transition from a start-up to a growing well-managed business that maintains its success over a long period of time. As the workload increases the organizational structure will need to expand to include additional employees with defined roles. Interviewing and hiring procedures will need to be implemented. For many new ventures, part-time employees may be hired, raising commitment and loyalty issues.
The organization must identify the major activities required to operate effectively. The design of the organization will indicate to employees what is expected of them in five areas: Organizational structure, which defines membersโ jobs and the relationship these jobs have to one another. Rewards are in the form of bonuses, promotion, and praise. A selection criterion is the set of guidelines for selecting individuals for each position. The organizationโs design can be simple or complex.
There are two stages of development in an organization:
- Stage 1: The new venture is operated by one person, the entrepreneur, with no need for sub managers.
- Stage 2: As the business expands, the organization may be described as Stage 2. Sub managers are hired to coordinate, organize, and control aspects of the business. Measurement, evaluation, rewards, selection, and training become necessary.
Stage 3 may exist when the firm is large enough that a third level of managers is added. As the organization evolves, the managerโs decision roles become more critical. The primary concern is to adapt to changes in the environment and seek new ideas. The manager will also need to respond to unexpected pressures, referred to as "putting out fires." Another role is that of allocation of resources, delegating budgets and responsibility. The final role is that of negotiator, as the entrepreneur can be the only person with the appropriate authority.
BUILDING THE SUCCESSFUL ORGANIZATION
Before writing the organization plan, it is helpful to prepare a job analysis. The job analysis serves as a guide in determining hiring procedures and job descriptions and specifications. As the size of the venture changes, the process becomes more complex.
The place to start is with the tasks that need to be performed to make the venture viable. After this list is made, then determine how many positions and what types of persons will be needed. Other decisions to be made early in the planning process:
- Where to advertise for employees.
- How they will be trained.
- How they will be compensated.
Searching for senior talent requires a different strategy. Usually networking provides the best source of candidates. Some recruiting firms are also specializing in placing senior people in start-ups. The most important issues in the business plan are the job descriptions and specifications.
โญ Key Takeaways
The choice of business form critically affects taxation โ proprietorships and partnerships avoid double taxation, while corporations face double taxation on dividends, though they offer more deductions. S corporations and LLCs provide hybrid benefits: S corporations combine partnership tax treatment with limited liability but have restrictions like one class of stock and calendar-year accounting; LLCs offer greater flexibility but vary by state law. Organization design must evolve from a simple single-person Stage 1 structure to a more complex Stage 2 with sub-managers as the venture grows, requiring careful job analysis, hiring, training, and compensation planning. Entrepreneurs must transition from doing everything alone to delegating responsibilities through proper organizational structure and manager roles.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is double taxation and which business form(s) are subject to it?
- List four key differences between an S corporation and a limited liability company (LLC).
- Under what condition would a C corporation have a lower tax liability than an S corporation?
- What are the three decision roles a manager must perform as an organization evolves?
- What is the first step in building a successful organization according to the lecture?