๐ Lecture 29 โ Benefits
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the comprehensive framework of employee compensation, focusing particularly on benefits (indirect financial compensation). It distinguishes between direct and indirect rewards, examines legally mandated and voluntary benefits, and covers incentive compensation, non-financial compensation factors, and workplace flexibilityโall essential for understanding how organizations attract, retain, and motivate employees.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a discussion of total compensation comprising direct and indirect rewards. It then covers employee benefits in detail, including mandated benefits (Social Security, unemployment compensation, workers' compensation, FMLA) and discretionary benefits (payment for time not worked, health/security benefits, employee services, premium pay). Other topics include benefit-related legislation (ERISA, OWBPA), communicating benefits information, incentive compensation plans (individual, team, companywide), non-financial compensation, the job as a total compensation factor, the job environment, workplace flexibility options, and other compensation issues like severance pay, comparable worth, pay secrecy, and pay compression.
๐ Lecture Summary
A. Total Compensation
Total compensation constitutes two types of rewards: direct rewards and indirect rewards. Direct rewards include salaries, wages, commissions, bonuses, and gainsharingโall paid directly to employees in monetary or financial terms. The second type of rewards are benefits provided by organizations, which are not direct payments in financial terms.
B. Employee Benefits
Benefits are all financial rewards that generally are not paid directly to an employee. Benefits absorb social costs for health care and retirement and can influence employee decisions about employers.
I. Benefits (Indirect Financial Compensation)
Most organizations recognize that they have a responsibility to provide their employees with insurance and other programs for their health, safety, security, and general welfare. These benefits include all financial rewards that generally are not paid directly to the employee.
II. Mandated Benefits (Legally Required)
Although most employee benefits are provided at the employerโs discretion, others are required by law. Legally required benefits include Social Security, unemployment compensation, and workers' compensation.
a) Social Security โ It is a system of retirement benefits that provides benefits like disability insurance, survivorโs benefits, and, most recently, Medicare.
b) Unemployment Compensation โ An individual laid off by an organization covered by the Social Security Act may receive unemployment compensation for up to 26 weeks. Although the federal government provides certain guidelines, unemployment compensation programs are administered by the states, and the benefits vary state by state.
c) Workersโ Compensation โ Workersโ compensation benefits provide a degree of financial protection for employees who incur expenses resulting from job-related accidents or illnesses.
d) Family And Medical Leave Act Of 1993 (FMLA) โ The Family and Medical Leave Act applies to private employers with 50 or more employees and to all governmental employers regardless of the number of employees. The act provides for up to 12 workweeks of unpaid leave per year for absences due to the employeeโs own serious health condition or the need to care for a newborn or newly adopted child or a seriously ill child, parent, or spouse.
III. Discretionary Benefits (Voluntary)
Organizations voluntarily provide numerous benefits. These benefits may be classified as (1) payment for time not worked, (2) health and security benefits, (3) employee services, and (4) premium pay. Generally speaking, such benefits are not legally required.
a) Payment For Time Not Worked โ In providing payment for time not worked, employers recognize that employees need time away from the job for many purposes, such as paid vacations, payment for holidays not worked, paid sick leave, jury duty, national guard or other military reserve duty, voting time, and bereavement time. Some payments are provided for time off taken during work hours, such as rest periods, coffee breaks, lunch periods, cleanup time, and travel time.
- Paid Vacations: Payment for time not worked serves important compensation goals. Paid vacations provide workers with an opportunity to rest, become rejuvenated, and hopefully, become more productive.
- Sick Leave: Each year many firms allocate, to each employee, a certain number of days of sick leave, which they can use when ill.
b) Health Benefits โ Health benefits are often included as part of an employeeโs indirect financial compensation. Specific areas include health, dental, and vision care.
- Health care: Benefits for health care represent the most expensive and fastest-growing cost in the area of indirect financial compensation. Many factors have combined to create this situation: an aging population, a growing demand for medical care, increasingly expensive medical technology, a lack of price controls, and inefficient administrative processes. In addition to self-insurance and traditional commercial insurers, employers may utilize one of several options. Health maintenance organizations (HMOs) are one option in which all services are covered for a fixed fee; however, employers control which doctors and health facilities may be used. Point-of-service (POS) permits a member to select a provider within the network, or, for a lower level of benefits, go outside the network. Preferred provider organizations (PPOs) are a more flexible managed care system. Although incentives are provided to members to use services within such a system, out-of-network providers may be utilized at greater cost. Exclusive provider organizations (EPO) offer a smaller PPO provider network and usually provide little, if any, benefits when an out-of-network provider is used.
- Capitation: Typically, the reimbursement method used by primary care physicians is an approach to health care where providers negotiate a rate for health care for a covered life over a period of time. It presumes that doctors have an incentive to keep patients healthy and to avoid costly procedures when they are paid per patient rather than per service.
- Defined-Contribution health care system: Companies give each employee a set amount of money annually with which to purchase health care coverage.
- Utilization Review: A process that scrutinizes medical diagnoses, hospitalization, surgery, and other medical treatment and care prescribed by doctors.
- The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996: Provides new protections for approximately 25 million Americans who move from one job to another, who are self-employed, or who have preexisting medical conditions.
- Dental and Vision Care: Relative newcomers to the list of potential health benefits. Both types of plans are typically paid for entirely by the employers.
c) Security Benefits โ Security benefits include retirement plans, disability insurance, life insurance, and supplemental unemployment benefits.
- Retirement Plans: Private retirement plans provide income for employees who retire after reaching a certain age or having served the firm for a specific period of time. In a defined benefit plan, the employer agrees to provide a specific level of retirement income that is either a fixed dollar amount or a percentage of earnings. A defined contribution plan is a retirement plan that requires specific contributions by an employer to a retirement or savings fund established for the employee. A 401(k) plan is a defined contribution plan in which employees may defer income up to a maximum amount allowed. An employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) is a defined contribution plan in which a firm makes a tax-deductible contribution of stock shares or cash to a trust.
- Disability Protection: Workersโ compensation protects employees from job-related accidents and illnesses. Some firms, however, provide additional protection that is more comprehensive.
- Supplemental Unemployment Benefits (SUB): Supplemental unemployment benefits are designed to provide additional income for employees receiving unemployment benefits.
- Life Insurance: Group life insurance is a benefit commonly provided to protect the employeeโs family in the event of his or her death. Although the cost of group life insurance is relatively low, some plans call for the employee to pay part of the premium.
d) Employee Services โ Organizations offer a variety of benefits that can be termed employee services. These benefits encompass a number of areas including relocation benefits, child care, educational assistance, food services/subsidized cafeterias, and financial services.
- Relocation Benefits: Include shipment of household goods and temporary living expenses, covering all or a portion of the real estate costs associated with buying a new home and selling the previously occupied home.
- Child Care: Another benefit offered by some firms is subsidized child care. Here, the firm may provide an on-site child care center, support an off-site center, or subsidize the costs of child care.
- Educational Assistance: According to a recent benefits survey, 81 percent have educational benefits that reimburse employees for college tuition and books.
- Food Services/Subsidized Cafeterias: Most firms that offer free or subsidized lunches feel that they get a high payback in terms of employee relations.
- Financial Services: One financial benefit that is growing in popularity permits employees to purchase different types of insurance policies through payroll deduction.
- Unique Benefits: A tight labor market gives birth to creativity in providing benefits.
e) Premium Pay โ Compensation paid to employees for working long periods of time or working under dangerous or undesirable conditions.
- Hazard pay: Additional pay provided to employees who work under extremely dangerous conditions.
- Shift differentials: Paid to employees for the inconvenience of working undesirable hours.
f) Benefits for Part-Time Employees โ Recent studies indicate that employers are offering this group more benefits than ever. Growth in the number of part-timers is due to the aging of the workforce and also to an increased desire by more employees to balance their lives between work and home.
IV. Other Benefit-Related Legislation
a) Employee Retirement Income Security Act Of 1974 (ERISA) โ The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) was passed to strengthen existing and future retirement programs. Mismanagement of retirement funds was the primary factor in the need for this legislation.
b) Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA) โ The Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA) is a 1990 amendment to the ADEA and extends its coverage to all employee benefits. The act has an equal benefit or equal cost principle.
V. Communicating Information about the Benefits Package
Employee benefits can help a firm recruit and retain a quality workforce. Management depends on an upward flow of information from employees in order to know when benefit changes are needed, and, because employee awareness of benefits is often severely limited, the program information must be communicated downward.
VI. Incentive Compensation
Incentive compensation refers to compensation programs that relate pay to productivity.
a) Individual Incentive Plans โ A specific form of performance-based pay is an individual incentive plan called piecework. In such a plan, employees are paid for each unit produced.
b) Team-Based Compensation Plans โ Team performance consists of individual efforts. Therefore, individual employees should be recognized and rewarded for their contributions. However, if the team is to function effectively, a reward based on the overall team performance should be provided as well.
c) Companywide Plans โ Companywide plans offer a feasible alternative to the incentive plans previously discussed. They may be based on the organizationโs productivity, cost savings, or profitability.
- Profit Sharing: A compensation plan that results in the distribution of a predetermined percentage of the firmโs profits to employees. There are several variations, but the three basic forms are current, deferred, and combination. Current plans provide payment to employees in cash or stock as soon as profits have been determined. Deferred plans involve placing company contributions in an irrevocable trust to be credited to the account of individual employees. The funds are normally invested in securities and become available to the employee (or his/her survivors) at retirement, termination, or death. Combination plans permit employees to receive payment of part of their share of profits on a current basis, whereas payment of part of their share is deferred. Profit sharing tends to tie employees to the economic success of the firm.
- Employee Stock Option Plan (ESOP): A defined contribution plan in which a firm contributes stock shares to a trust.
- Gain Sharing: Plans that are designed to bind employees to the firmโs performance by providing an incentive payment based on improved company performance.
- Scanlon Plan: Provides a financial reward to employees for savings in labor costs that result from their suggestions.
VII. Non-financial Compensation
Compensation departments in organizations do not normally deal with non-financial factors. However, non-financial compensation can be a very powerful factor in the compensation equation.
VIII. The Job
Some jobs can be so exciting that the incumbent can hardly wait to get to work each day.
IX. The Job as a Total Compensation Factor
The job itself is a central issue in many theories of motivation, and it is also a vital component of a total compensation program.
a) Skill Variety โ The extent to which work requires a number of different activities for successful completion.
b) Task Identity โ The extent to which the job includes an identifiable unit of work that is carried out from start to finish.
c) Task Significance โ The impact that the job has on other people.
d) Autonomy โ The extent of individual freedom and discretion employees have in performing their jobs.
e) Feedback โ The amount of information employees receive about how well they have performed the job.
f) Cyber-work โ A possibility of a never-ending workday created through the use of technology.
X. The Job Environment as a Total Compensation Factor
Employees can draw satisfaction from their work through several non-financial factors.
a) Sound Policies โ Human resource policies and practices reflecting managementโs concern for its employees can serve as positive rewards.
b) Competent Employees โ Successful organizations emphasize continuous development and assure that competent managers and non-managers are employed.
c) Congenial Coworkers โ Although the American culture has historically embraced individualism, most people possess, in varying degrees, a desire to be accepted by their work group.
d) Appropriate Status Symbols โ Organizational rewards that take many forms such as office size and location, desk size and quality, private secretaries, floor covering, and title.
e) Working Conditions โ The definition of working conditions has been broadened considerably during the past decade.
XI. Workplace Flexibility
Flexible work arrangements do more than just assist new mothersโ return to full-time work. They comprise an aspect of non-financial compensation that allows many families to manage a stressful work/home juggling act.
a) Flextime โ The practice of permitting employees to choose, with certain limitations, their own working hours.
b) Compressed Workweek โ Any arrangement of work hours that permits employees to fulfill their work obligation in fewer days than the typical five-day workweek.
c) Job Sharing โ An approach to work that is attractive to people who want to work fewer than 40 hours per week.
d) Flexible Compensation (Cafeteria Compensation) โ Plans that permit employees to choose from among many alternatives in deciding how their financial compensation will be allocated.
e) Telecommuting โ Telecommuting is a work arrangement whereby employees are able to remain at home, or otherwise away from the office, and perform their work over telephone lines tied to a computer.
f) Part-Time Work โ Use of part-time workers on a regular basis has begun to gain momentum in the United States. This approach adds many highly qualified individuals to the labor market by permitting both employment and family needs to be addressed.
g) Modified Retirement โ An option that permits older employees to work fewer than regular hours for a certain period of time preceding retirement. This option allows an employee to avoid an abrupt change in lifestyle and more gracefully move into retirement.
XII. Other Compensation Issues
Several issues that relate to compensation deserve mention. These issues include comparable worth, pay secrecy, and pay compression.
a) Severance Pay โ Although some firms are trimming the amount of severance pay offered, typically, one to two weeks of severance pay is given for every year of service, up to some predetermined maximum. Severance pay is generally shaped according to the organizational level of the employee.
b) Comparable Worth โ Requires the value for dissimilar jobs, such as company nurse and welder, to be compared under some form of job evaluation and pay rates for both jobs to be assigned according to their evaluated worth.
c) Pay Secrecy โ Organizations tend to keep their pay rates secret for various reasons. If a firmโs compensation plan is illogical, secrecy may indeed be appropriate because only a well-designed system can stand careful scrutiny. An open system would almost certainly require managers to explain the rationale for pay decisions to subordinates.
d) Pay Compression โ Occurs when workers perceive that the pay differential between their pay and that of employees in jobs above or below them is too small.
๐ Definition โ Flextime: The practice of permitting employees to choose, with certain limitations, their own working hours.
๐ Definition โ Capitation: Typically, the reimbursement method used by primary care physicians is an approach to health care where providers negotiate a rate for health care for a covered life over a period of time.
๐ Definition โ Disability protection: Workersโ compensation protects employees from job-related accidents and illnesses. Some firms, however, provide additional protection that is more comprehensive.
๐ Definition โ ESOP: A defined contribution plan in which a firm contributes stock shares to a trust.
๐ Definition โ Gain sharing: Plans that are designed to bind employees to the firmโs performance by providing an incentive payment based on improved company performance.
๐ Definition โ Scanlon plan: Provides a financial reward to employees for savings in labor costs that result from their suggestions.
๐ Definition โ Telecommuting: Telecommuting is a work arrangement whereby employees are able to remain at home, or otherwise away from the office, and perform their work over telephone lines tied to a computer.
๐ Definition โ Autonomy: The extent of individual freedom and discretion employees have in performing their jobs.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are the distinction between direct and indirect compensation, with benefits being indirect financial rewards. Students must understand the difference between mandated benefits (Social Security, unemployment compensation, workers' compensation, FMLA) and discretionary benefits (payment for time not worked, health/security benefits, employee services, premium pay). Key legislation includes ERISA (protecting retirement funds) and OWBPA (protecting older workers' benefits). Incentive compensation plans include individual (piecework), team-based, and companywide plans (profit sharing, ESOP, gain sharing, Scanlon plan). Finally, non-financial compensation factorsโthe job itself, job environment, and workplace flexibility (flextime, compressed workweek, telecommuting)โare powerful motivators and essential for attracting and retaining talent.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four types of mandated (legally required) benefits discussed in this lecture, and what does each provide to employees?
- Distinguish between a defined benefit plan and a defined contribution plan in retirement benefits. What is a 401(k) plan?
- Name and briefly explain the three basic forms of profit sharing plans.
- What is the difference between an HMO, PPO, POS, and EPO in health care benefits?
- List five types of workplace flexibility arrangements and explain how each helps employees manage work-life balance.
๐ Lecture 30 โ Role of Money in Performance of Employees
๐ Overview: This lecture examines how money functions as a motivational tool in organizations and explores the design and implementation of pay-for-performance systems. It covers the major challenges managers face when linking pay to performance, offers recommendations for overcoming these challenges, and analyzes specific types of pay-for-performance plans. Understanding these concepts is critical for designing compensation systems that truly motivate employees and align their interests with organizational goals.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers pay-for-performance systems, including their definition as compensation methods tying pay to work quantity or quality, and variable pay plans that put employee pay at risk for additional earning opportunities. It addresses eight major challenges of pay-for-performance systems, seven strategies for meeting those challenges, four types of plans (individual-based, team-based, plantwide, and corporate wide), executive and sales personnel plans, reasons for plan failures, and the role of money as a motivator including improving reward effectiveness and reducing employee turnover through recognition, positive reinforcement, and empowerment.
๐ Lecture Summary
A. Pay-for-Performance
Pay for performance refers to any compensation method that ties pay to the quantity or quality of work the person produces. Variable pay plans are pay for performance plans that put a portion of the employeeโs pay at risk, in return for the opportunity to earn additional pay. Gain-sharing plans are group incentive plans that engage many or all employees in a common effort to achieve productivity goals. Stock options are rights to purchase company stock at a discount some time in the future.
A compensation philosophy of higher pays for higher contributions means performance will be calculated on both corporate performance and personal performance.
I. Challenges of Pay-for-Performance System
a) Pay for Performance: The Challenges This section covers the attitudes that employees have about pay, the difficulties in measuring performance, the psychological contract, lack of flexibility, the importance of credibility, job satisfaction, stress, and the potential reduction of intrinsic drives.
i. The โDo Only What You Get Paid Forโ Syndrome: The closer pay is tied to particular performance indicators, the more employees tend to focus on those indicators and neglect other important job components.
ii. Negative Effects on the Spirit of Cooperation: Employees may withhold information from a colleague if they believe that it will help the other person get ahead.
iii. Lack of Control: Employees often cannot control all of the factors affecting their performance.
iv. Difficulties in Measuring Performance: Assessing employee performance is one of the thorniest tasks a manager faces, particularly when the assessments are used to dispense rewards.
v. Psychological Contracts: Once implemented, a pay-for-performance system creates a psychological contract between the employee and firm, and it is very resistant to change.
vi. The Credibility Gap: Employees often do not believe that pay-for-performance programs are fair or that they truly reward performance.
vii. Job Dissatisfaction and Stress: Pay-for-performance systems may lead to greater productivity but lower job satisfaction.
viii. Potential Reduction of Intrinsic Drives: Pay-for-performance systems may push employees to the point of doing whatever it takes to get the promised monetary reward and in the process stifle their talents and creativity.
II. Meeting the Challenges of Pay for Performance Systems
Appropriately designed pay-for-performance systems offer managers an excellent opportunity to align employees' interests with the organizations. Pay for performance programs are not likely to achieve the desired results unless complementary HRM programs are implemented at the same time.
a) Link Pay and Performance Appropriately: There are few cases in which managers can justify paying workers according to a pre-established formula or measure.
b) Use Pay for Performance as Part of a Broader HRM System: Pay-for-performance programs are not likely to achieve the desired results unless complementary HRM programs accompany them.
c) Build Employee Trust: Even the best conceived pay-for-performance program can fail if managers have a poor history of labor relations or if the organization has a cutthroat culture.
d) Promote the Belief that Performance Makes a Difference: Unless an organization creates an atmosphere in which performance makes a difference, it may end up with a low-achievement organizational culture.
e) Use Multiple Layers of Rewards: Because all pay-for-performance systems have positive and negative features, providing different types of pay incentives for different work situations is likely to produce better results than relying on a single type of pay incentive.
f) Increase Employee Involvement: When employees do not view a compensation program as legitimate, they will usually do whatever they can to subvert the system.
g) Use Motivation and Non-financial Incentives: Some people are more interested in the non-financial aspects of their work.
III. Types of Pay-for-Performance Plans
When a pay-for-performance system has multiple layers, it can increase the motivation of individual employees and simultaneously improve cooperation. For example, bonuses given to teams or work units promote cooperation. Bonuses given to individual employees are more motivating because they allow employees to see how their personal contributions lead to direct rewards. With a multiple-layers-of-rewards system, the organization can realize the benefits of each incentive plan while minimizing its negative side effects.
a. Individual-Based Plans Individual-based plans are the most widely used pay-for-performance plans in industry. Plans include merit pay, bonus programs, and awards. Advantages: rewarded performance is likely to be repeated; financial incentives can shape an individual's goals; they help the firm achieve individual equity; they fit in with an individualistic culture. Disadvantages: they may promote single-mindedness; employees do not believe pay and performance are linked; they may work against achieving quality goals; they may promote inflexibility.
b. Team-Based Plans Team-based plans attempt to support other efforts to increase the flexibility of the work force within a firm. These plans normally reward all team members equally based on group outcomes. Advantages: they foster group cohesiveness and facilitate performance measurement. Disadvantages: possible lack of fit with individualistic cultural values; the free-riding effect; social pressures to limit performance; difficulties in identifying meaningful groups; intergroup competition leading to a decline in overall performance.
c. Plant wide Plans These plans reward all workers in a plant or business unit based on the performance of the entire plant or unit. Plant wide plans are generally referred to as gain sharing programs because they return a portion of the company's cost savings to the workers, usually in the form of a lump-sum bonus. Three major types: Scanlon Plan, Rucker Plan, and Improshare. Advantages: eliciting active employee input; increasing the level of cooperation; fewer measurement difficulties; improving quality. Disadvantages: protection of low performers; problems with the criteria used to trigger rewards; management-labor conflict.
d. Corporate wide Plans This is the most macro type of incentive program based on the entire corporation's performance. The most widely used program is profit sharing, which differs from gain sharing: no attempt is made to reward workers for productivity improvements; they are very mechanistic; typically used to fund retirement programs. Employee stock ownership plans are another type. Advantages: financial flexibility for the firm; increased employee commitment; tax advantages. Disadvantages: risk for employees; limited effect on productivity; long-run financial difficulties.
IV. Designing Pay-For-Performance Plans for Executives and Salespeople
Executives and sales personnel are usually treated very differently than other types of workers in pay-for-performance plans. A number of plans link executives' pay to a firm's performance, but there is little agreement on which is best. Sales professionals may be paid in the form of straight salary, straight commission, or a combination plan. The relative proportion of salary versus incentives varies widely across firms.
V. Reasons for Pay-For-Performance Failures
Common factors blamed for the failure of individual-based pay-for-performance systems:
- Performance appraisal is inherently subjective, with supervisors evaluating subordinates according to their own preconceived biases.
- Regardless of the appraisal form used, rating errors are rampant.
- Merit systems emphasize individuals rather than group goals, leading to dysfunctional conflict.
- Specified time periods (normally one year) encourage short-term orientation at the expense of long-term goals.
- Supervisors and employees seldom agree on the evaluation, leading to interpersonal confrontations.
- Increments in financial rewards are spaced so that their reinforcement value is questionable (e.g., waiting a whole year for review).
- Individual merit pay systems are not appropriate for the service sector.
- Supervisors control limited compensation, so merit pay differentials are normally quite small.
- Bureaucratic factors influencing merit pay size and frequency have little to do with performance.
- Performance appraisals serve multiple purposes (training, development, selection, compensation), making it questionable whether any objective is achieved well.
B. The Role of Money
Money can be used as a motivational tool because it fulfills different needs, affecting several needs beyond just existence needs. Money is used to prove and enhance identity and influences self-perceptions.
Improving Reward Effectiveness Effectiveness of rewards can be improved by:
- Link rewards to performance
- Ensure rewards are relevant
- Use team rewards for interdependent jobs
- Ensure rewards are valued
- Beware of unintended consequences
I. Money as a Motivator
According to Maslow and Alderfer, pay should prove especially motivational to people who have strong lower-level needs. If pay has the capacity to fulfill a variety of needs, it should have good potential as a motivator.
II. Why People Leave Organizations
Mostly people leave organizations due to dissatisfaction with benefits or lack of recognition for extraordinary performers. Following ways can avoid high turnover:
Use Recognition: Some employees highly value day-to-day recognition from supervisors, peers, and team members. Recognition helps satisfy the need people have to achieve and be recognized for their achievement.
Use Positive Reinforcement: Positive reinforcement programs rely on operant conditioning principles to supply positive reinforcement and change behavior. Experts claim it is better to focus on improving desirable behaviors rather than decreasing undesirable ones. Consequences include social consequences (e.g., peer approval or praise), intrinsic consequences (e.g., enjoyment from challenging tasks), or tangible consequences (e.g., bonuses or merit raises).
Empower Employees: Empowerment means giving employees the authority, tools, and information they need to do their jobs with greater autonomy, as well as the self-confidence to perform new jobs effectively. Empowerment boosts employees' feelings of self-efficacy and enables them to use their potential more fully.
๐ Definition โ Pay for Performance: Any compensation method that ties pay to the quantity or quality of work the person produces.
๐ Definition โ Empowerment: Giving employees the authority, tools, and information they need to do their jobs with greater autonomy.
๐ Formula โ Reinforced Behavior Cycle: Positive consequence (reinforced by reward) โ Behavior repeated โ Negative consequence (no reward) โ Behavior not repeated.
๐ Example: If an employee performs beyond standards and receives a bonus (positive consequence/reward), that high-performance behavior is likely to be repeated. If the same employee performs beyond standards and receives no recognition (negative consequence), that behavior will not be repeated as shown in the figure.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding this reinforcement cycle is critical because it explains why organizations must consistently recognize and reward desired behaviors to maintain high performance, and why failing to do so leads to declining performance over time.
โญ Key Takeaways
Pay-for-performance systems tie compensation directly to work quantity or quality but face significant challenges including the "do only what you get paid for" syndrome, damage to cooperation, measurement difficulties, credibility gaps, and potential reduction of intrinsic motivation. Success requires linking pay appropriately, building trust, using multiple layers of rewards, and increasing employee involvement. There are four main types of plansโindividual-based, team-based, plantwide (gain sharing), and corporate wide (profit sharing)โeach with distinct advantages and disadvantages. Money serves as a powerful motivator because it fulfills multiple needs, but organizations must also use recognition, positive reinforcement, and empowerment to prevent turnover and maintain performance. The reinforcement principle shows that rewarded behaviors are repeated while unrewarded behaviors decline, making consistent recognition essential.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the eight challenges of pay-for-performance systems and which one specifically refers to employees doing only what they are measured on?
- How do gain-sharing plans differ from profit-sharing plans in terms of purpose, reward basis, and typical use?
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of individual-based pay-for-performance plans versus team-based plans?
- List the ten reasons why individual-based pay-for-performance systems commonly fail according to the lecture.
- According to the reinforcement cycle shown in the figure, what happens to behavior that receives a positive consequence versus behavior that receives no reward?