📘 Lecture 27 — Job Evaluation and Pricing
📖 Overview: This lecture covers two major HRM topics: the performance appraisal period and job evaluation methods. It explains how line managers and HRM departments contribute to effective appraisals, common reasons for appraisal failures, strategies for improving performance, and characteristics of an effective appraisal system. The second half focuses on job evaluation methods used to systematically determine the relative worth of jobs for compensation purposes.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the appraisal period, covering line manager responsibilities and the HRM department's role in performance appraisal. It then examines reasons for performance appraisal failures and strategies for improving performance, including positive reinforcement, punishment, self-management, and employee assistance programs. The characteristics of an effective appraisal system are detailed, followed by a comprehensive explanation of four job evaluation methods: ranking, classification, factor comparison, and point method, including the Hay guide chart-profile method.
📝 Lecture Summary
A. The Appraisal Period
Performance evaluations are typically prepared annually or semiannually. The appraisal period may begin with each employee's date of hire, or all employees may be evaluated at the same time.
I. The Line Manager and Performance Appraisal:
Line managers have several critical responsibilities in appraising performance. First, they complete the ratings by providing goals, comparing those goals with actual performance, and providing feedback for corrective actions. Second, they provide performance feedback — positive feedback acts as a positive reinforcement factor leading to more improvement, while poor performance also requires feedback so corrective steps can be taken. Third, they set performance goals that serve as standards or benchmarks against which performance can be evaluated.
II. Role of HRM Department in Performance Appraisal:
The HRM department performs three main functions during the performance appraisal process. First, it develops the appraisal system by formulating performance appraisal systems, facilitating different departments in setting performance standards, and acquiring appropriate appraisal methods. Second, it provides rater training because evidence indicates that training appraisers makes them more accurate raters — a poor appraisal is worse than no appraisal at all. Third, it monitors and evaluates the appraisal system to ensure authentic and fair results, since many decisions like promotions, demotions, and terminations are based on appraisal data.
III. Performance Appraisal Failures:
Performance appraisal processes sometimes fail to satisfy their purpose. The reasons include: (1) manager lacks information, (2) lack of appraisal skills, (3) manager not taking appraisal seriously, (4) manager not prepared, (5) employee not receiving ongoing feedback, (6) manager not being honest or sincere, (7) ineffective discussion of employee development, (8) unclear language, and (9) insufficient reward for performance.
IV. Strategies for Improving Performance:
When performance appraisal indicates poor performance, or even to maintain good performance, several strategies can be used.
a. Positive Reinforcement: Applying a valued consequence that increases the likelihood that the person will repeat the behavior that led to it. Examples include compliments, letters of recommendation, favorable performance appraisal, and pay raises.
b. Punishment: Administering an aversive consequence. Examples include criticizing or shouting at an employee, assigning an unappealing task, and sending a worker home without pay.
c. Self Management: Many companies empower employees to take responsibility for day-to-day functions in their areas, allowing them to work without direct supervision and take on administrative responsibilities previously performed by their supervisor.
d. Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs): Specific programs designed to help employees with personal problems such as job stress, legal, marital, financial, or health-related issues. These problems manifest at work as lowered productivity, increased absenteeism, or turnover.
🔑 Definition — Positive Reinforcement: Applying a valued consequence that increases the likelihood that the person will repeat the behavior that led to it. 🔑 Definition — Punishment: Administering an aversive consequence. 🔑 Definition — Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs): Specific programs designed to help employees with personal problems.
V. Characteristics Of An Effective Appraisal System (Designing An Appraisal System)
Systems that possess certain characteristics may be more legally defensible. These characteristics include:
a. Job-Related Criteria — The criteria used for appraising employee performance must be job related. b. Performance Expectations — Managers must clearly explain their performance expectations to subordinates in advance of the appraisal period. c. Standardization — Employees in the same job categories under a given supervisor should be appraised using the same evaluation instrument. d. Trained Appraisers — Responsibility for evaluating performance should be assigned to individuals who can directly observe a representative sample of job performance. e. Open Communication — A good appraisal system provides highly desired feedback on a continuing basis. f. Employee Access To Results — Employees will not trust a system they do not understand. g. Due Process — A formal procedure should be developed to permit employees the means for appealing appraisal results.
Effectiveness of the appraisal can be created by considering these steps: gain support for the system, choose the appropriate rating instrument, choose the raters, determine the appropriate timing of appraisals, and ensure appraisal fairness.
B. Job Evaluation
Job evaluation means systematically determining the relative worth of jobs to create a job structure. It is an attempt to identify inputs that are most valuable to the organization and to develop a job hierarchy based on which jobs have more or less of those dimensions.
🔑 Definition — Job Evaluation: Systematically determining the relative worth of jobs to create a job structure.
Job Evaluation Methods: The essence of compensation administration is job evaluation and the establishment of the pay structure. Job evaluation uses information from job analysis to systematically determine the value of each job in relation to all jobs within the organization. It seeks to rank all jobs and place them in a hierarchy reflecting relative worth. There are four general job evaluation methods.
a. Ranking method: Raters examine the description of each job being evaluated and arrange the jobs in order according to their value to the company. A committee — typically composed of both management and employee representatives — arranges jobs in a simple rank order from highest to lowest. No attempts are made to break down jobs by specific weighted criteria. The committee members merely compare two jobs and judge which one is more important or difficult to perform.
The most obvious limitation is its inability to be managed with a large number of jobs. Other drawbacks include subjectivity (no definite or consistent standards to justify rankings) and the fact that because jobs are only ranked in order, we have no knowledge of the distance between the ranks.
🔑 Definition — Ranking Method: Raters examine the description of each job being evaluated and arrange the jobs in order according to their value to the company.
b. Classification method: A job evaluation method by which a number of classes or grades are defined to describe a group of jobs. Classifications are created by identifying some common denominator — skills, knowledge, responsibilities — with the desired goal being a number of distinct classes or grades of jobs. Once established, classifications are ranked in overall order of importance according to chosen criteria, and each job is placed in its appropriate classification by comparing each position's job description against the classification description and benchmarked jobs.
The classification method shares most disadvantages of the ranking approach, plus the difficulty of writing classification descriptions, judging which jobs go where, and dealing with jobs that appear to fall into more than one classification.
🔑 Definition — Classification Method: A job evaluation method by which a number of classes or grades are defined to describe a group of jobs.
c. Factor comparison method: Raters make decisions on separate aspects, or factors, of the job rather than keeping the entire job in mind. A basic underlying assumption is that there are five universal job factors: (1) Mental Requirements, (2) Skills, (3) Physical Requirements, (4) Responsibilities, and (5) Working Conditions. The committee first ranks each selected benchmark job on the relative degree of difficulty for each of the five factors. Then, the committee allocates the total pay rates for each job to each factor based on the importance of the respective factor to the job. A job comparison scale, reflecting rankings and money allocations, is developed. Raters compare each job, factor by factor, with those on the job comparison scale and place the jobs on the chart in an appropriate position.
d. Point method: Raters assign numerical values to specific job components, and the sum of these values provides a quantitative assessment of a job's relative worth. The point method requires selection of job factors according to the nature of the specific group of jobs being evaluated. After determining the group of jobs, analysts conduct job analysis and write job descriptions. Next, analysts select and define factors (e.g., education, experience, job knowledge, mental effort, physical effort, responsibility, working conditions). The committee establishes factor weights according to their relative importance, determines the total number of points to be used, distributes point values to job factor degrees, and prepares a job evaluation manual.
Hay guide chart-profile method: A highly refined version of the point method that uses the factors of know-how, problem solving, accountability, and, where appropriate, working conditions.
🔑 Definition — Point Method: Raters assign numerical values to specific job components, and the sum of these values provides a quantitative assessment of a job's relative worth.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that performance appraisal involves distinct roles for line managers (completing ratings, providing feedback, setting goals) and the HRM department (developing systems, providing rater training, monitoring the system). Appraisal failures often stem from lack of information, skills, honesty, or ongoing feedback. Four strategies to improve performance are positive reinforcement, punishment, self-management, and employee assistance programs. For job evaluation, the four methods (ranking, classification, factor comparison, and point method) each have unique approaches and limitations — ranking is simple but subjective and unmanageable for large numbers, while the point method provides quantitative assessments. The Hay guide chart-profile method is a refined version of the point method using know-how, problem solving, accountability, and working conditions.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main responsibilities of line managers in performance appraisal?
- List five reasons why performance appraisal processes fail.
- What is the difference between positive reinforcement and punishment as strategies for improving performance?
- What are the four general job evaluation methods, and what is the main limitation of the ranking method?
- What are the five universal job factors used in the factor comparison method, and what is the Hay guide chart-profile method a refined version of?
📘 Lecture 28 — Compensation System
📖 Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive overview of compensation systems in human resource management. It explains how organizations determine pay, the concept of compensation equity, and the various factors—organizational, labor market, job-related, and employee-specific—that influence individual financial compensation. Understanding these concepts is crucial for designing fair and effective reward systems that attract, motivate, and retain talent.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers job pricing and developing a base pay system, including pay grades, wage curves, pay ranges, broad banding, and single-rate systems. It then provides an overview of compensation, explaining direct, indirect, and non-financial compensation, followed by a detailed discussion of equity in compensation. Determinants of individual financial compensation are explored through organizational factors (policies, politics, ability to pay), labor market factors (surveys, cost of living, unions, society, economy, legislation), job factors (job analysis, job evaluation), and employee factors (performance-based pay, seniority, experience, membership, potential). Finally, executive compensation, professional compensation, and sales compensation are discussed.
📝 Lecture Summary
Job Pricing & Developing a Base Pay System
Job Pricing means placing a dollar value on the worth of a job. This process involves several key components.
Pay Grades involve the grouping of similar jobs together to simplify the job pricing process. Plotting jobs on a scatter diagram is often useful in determining the appropriate number of pay grades.
Wage Curve refers to the fitting of plotted points in order to create a smooth progression between pay grades.
Pay Ranges include a minimum and maximum pay rate with enough variance between the two to allow some significant pay difference.
Broad Banding is a technique that collapses many pay grades (salary grades) into a few wide bands in order to improve organizational effectiveness.
Single-Rate System applies when pay ranges are not appropriate for some workplace conditions. When single rates are used, everyone in the same job receives the same base pay, regardless of seniority or productivity. This rate may correspond to the midpoint of a range determined by a compensation survey.
Adjusting Pay Rates—when pay ranges have been determined and jobs assigned to pay grades, it may become obvious that some jobs are overpaid and others underpaid. Underpaid jobs normally are brought to the minimum of the pay range as soon as possible.
Compensation: An Overview
Compensation is the total of all rewards provided employees in return for their services.
Direct Financial Compensation consists of the pay that a person receives in the form of wages, salaries, bonuses, and commissions.
Indirect Financial Compensation includes all financial rewards that are not included in direct compensation.
Non-financial Compensation consists of the satisfaction that a person receives from the job itself or from the psychological and/or physical environment in which the person works. All such rewards comprise a total compensation program.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding these three categories helps organizations design a holistic compensation package that addresses both monetary and non-monetary employee needs.
I. Equity in Financial Compensation
Organizations must attract, motivate, and retain competent employees. Because achievement of these goals is largely accomplished through a firm's compensation system, organizations must strive for compensation equity.
🔑 Definition — Equity: Workers' perceptions that they are being treated fairly. Compensation must be fair to all parties concerned and be perceived as fair.
🔑 Definition — External Equity: Exists when a firm's employees are paid comparably to workers who perform similar jobs in other firms.
🔑 Definition — Internal Equity: Exists when employees are paid according to the relative value of their jobs within an organization.
🔑 Definition — Employee Equity: Exists when individuals performing similar jobs for the same firm are paid according to factors unique to the employee, such as performance level or seniority.
🔑 Definition — Team Equity: Achieved when more productive teams are rewarded more than less-productive teams.
II. Determinants of Individual Financial Compensation
Compensation theory has never been able to provide a completely satisfactory answer to what an individual is worth for performing jobs. Four main factors have an impact: The Organization, The Labor Market, The Job, and The Employee.
a. The Organization as a Determinant of Financial Compensation
Compensation Policies—An organization often establishes—formally or informally—compensation policies that determine whether it will be a pay leader, a pay follower, or strive for an average position in the labor market.
🔑 Definition — Pay Leaders: Those organizations that pay higher wages and salaries than competing firms.
🔑 Definition — Market Rate or Going Rate: The average pay that most employers provide for the same job in a particular area or industry.
🔑 Definition — Pay Followers: Companies that choose to pay below the market rate because of poor financial condition or a belief that they simply do not require highly capable employees.
Organizational Politics—Political considerations may also enter into the equation. A sound, objective compensation system can be destroyed by organizational politics. Managers should become aware of this possibility and take appropriate action.
Ability to Pay—An organization's assessment of its ability to pay is also an important factor in determining pay levels. Financially successful firms tend to provide higher-than-average compensation. However, an organization's financial strength establishes only the upper limit of what it will pay.
b. The Labor Market as a Determinant of Financial Compensation
Potential employees located within the geographical area from which employees are recruited comprise the labor market.
Compensation Surveys—Large organizations routinely conduct compensation surveys to determine prevailing pay rates within labor markets. These provide information for establishing both direct and indirect compensation.
🔑 Definition — Benchmark Job: A job that is well known in the company and industry, one that represents the entire job structure, and one in which a large percentage of the workforce is employed.
Cost of Living—A pay increase must be roughly equivalent to the cost of living increase if a person is to maintain a previous level of real wages.
Labor Unions—When a union uses comparable pay as a standard for making compensation demands, the employer must obtain accurate labor market data. When a union emphasizes cost of living, management may be pressured to include a cost-of-living allowance (COLA) —an escalator clause in the labor agreement that automatically increases wages as the cost-of-living index rises.
Society—Compensation paid to employees often affects a firm's pricing of its goods and/or services. Consumers may also be interested in compensation decisions.
Economy—In most cases, the cost of living will rise in an expanding economy. Thus, the economy's health exerts a major impact on pay decisions.
Legislation—The amount of compensation a person receives can also be affected by certain federal and state legislation.
c. The Job as a Determinant of Financial Compensation
Organizations pay for the value they attach to certain duties, responsibilities, and other job-related factors. Techniques used to determine a job's relative worth include job analysis, job descriptions, and job evaluation.
Job Analysis and Job Descriptions—Before an organization can determine the relative difficulty or value of its jobs, it must first define their content, which it normally does by analyzing jobs. Job analysis is the systematic process of determining the skills and knowledge required for performing jobs. The job description is the primary by-product of job analysis, consisting of a written document that describes job duties and responsibilities. Job descriptions are used for many different purposes, including job evaluation.
Job Evaluation—That part of a compensation system in which a firm determines the relative value of one job compared with that of another.
d. The Employee as a Determinant of Financial Compensation
In addition to the organization, the labor market, and the job, factors related to the employee are also essential in determining pay and employee equity.
Performance Based Pay—Performance appraisal data provide the input for such approaches as merit pay, variable pay, skill-based pay, and competency-based pay.
🔑 Definition — Merit Pay: A pay increase given to employees based on their level of performance as indicated in the appraisal.
🔑 Definition — Bonus: The most common type of variable pay for performance and is a one-time award that is not added to employees' base pay.
🔑 Definition — Skill-based Pay: A system that compensates employees on the basis of job-related skills and knowledge they possess, not for their job titles.
🔑 Definition — Competency-Based Pay: A compensation plan that rewards employees for their demonstrated expertise.
Seniority—The length of time an employee has been associated with the company, division, department, or job is referred to as seniority.
Experience—Regardless of the nature of the task, very few factors have a more significant impact on performance than experience.
Membership in the Organization—Some components of individual financial compensation are given to employees without regard to the particular job they perform or their level of productivity.
Potential—Organizations do pay some individuals based on their potential.
Political Influence—Political influence is a factor that obviously should not be used as a determinant of financial compensation. However, to deny that it exists would be unrealistic.
Luck—The expression "It certainly helps to be in the right place at the right time" has more than a little truth as it relates to the determination of a person's compensation.
Special Employee Classes—These include pay for executives, professionals, and sales employees.
III. Executive Compensation
Executive skill largely determines whether a firm will prosper, survive, or fail. Therefore, providing adequate compensation for these managers is vital. A critical factor in attracting and retaining the best managers is a company's program for compensating executives.
a) Determining Executive Compensation—In determining executive compensation, firms typically prefer to relate salary growth for the highest-level managers to overall corporate performance. In general, the higher the managerial position, the greater the flexibility managers have in designing their jobs.
b) Types of Executive Compensation—Executive compensation often has five basic elements: (1) Base Salary, (2) Short-Term Incentives or Bonuses, (3) Long-Term Incentives and Capital Appreciation Plans, (4) Executive Benefits, and (5) Perquisites. The way an executive compensation package is designed is partially dependent on ever-changing tax legislation.
- Base Salary: Salary is obviously important. It is a factor in determining standard of living. Salary also provides the basis for other forms of compensation.
- Short-Term Incentives or bonuses: Payment of bonuses reflects a managerial belief in their incentive value. Today, virtually all top executives receive bonuses that are tied to base salary.
- Long-Term Incentives and Capital Appreciation: The stock option is a long-term incentive designed to integrate further the interests of management with those of the organization. The typical stock option plan gives the manager the option to buy a specified amount of stock in the future at or below the current market price.
- Executive Benefits: Executive benefits are generally more generous than those received by other employees because the benefits are tied to their higher salaries. However, current legislation (ERISA) does restrict the value of executive benefits to a certain level above those of other workers.
- Perquisites (Perks): Any special benefits provided by a firm to a small group of key executives that are designed to give the executives something extra. A "golden parachute" contract is a perquisite that protects executives in the event that their firm is acquired by another.
IV. Compensation for Professionals
People in professional jobs are initially compensated primarily for the knowledge they bring to the organization. Because of this, the administration of compensation programs for professionals is somewhat different than for managers. Many professional employees eventually become managers. For those who do not desire this form of career progression, some organizations have created a dual track of compensation. The dual track provides a separate pay structure for professionals, which may overlap a portion of the managerial pay structure.
V. Sales Compensation
Designing compensation programs for sales employees involves unique considerations. For example, job content, relative job worth, and job market value should be determined. The straight salary approach is at one extreme in sales compensation—salespersons receive a fixed salary regardless of their sales levels. At the other extreme, the person whose pay is totally determined as a percentage of sales is on straight commission. Between these extremes, there are endless part salary–part commission combinations. The possibilities increase when various types of bonuses are added to the basic compensation package. In addition to salary, commissions, and bonuses, salespersons often receive other forms of compensation that are intended to serve as added incentives.
Role of Line Managers and HRM Department in Compensation
Line managers perform the function of job evaluation that is the base for compensation systems. According to the worth of the job, negotiation regarding salaries and other benefits is conducted with potential employees through line managers. Basic compensation packages are mostly recommended by line managers in organizations. All this information is communicated to employees by the HRM department. Besides communicating this information, the HRM department also facilitates departments in establishing rates of pay, monitoring the job evaluation process, conducting salary surveys to establish procedures for administering pay plans, and ensuring compliance with antidiscrimination laws.
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that compensation is the total of all rewards provided to employees and is a critical tool for attracting, motivating, and retaining talent. The key to effective compensation is achieving multiple forms of equity—external, internal, employee, and team equity—so that employees perceive fairness. Individual financial compensation is determined by four major factors: the organization (policies, ability to pay), the labor market (surveys, cost of living, unions), the job (job analysis and evaluation), and the employee (performance, seniority, experience, potential). Special compensation considerations apply to executives (base salary, bonuses, long-term incentives, benefits, and perquisites), professionals (dual track systems), and sales employees (salary, commission, and bonus combinations), with line managers and HR playing distinct roles in administering these systems.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five types of compensation equity discussed in this lecture, and how do they differ from each other?
- Explain the difference between a pay leader, a pay follower, and the market rate or going rate in compensation policy.
- What are the five basic elements of executive compensation, and what is a "golden parachute" contract?
- How does skill-based pay differ from competency-based pay, and what distinguishes them from merit pay?
- What is the role of line managers versus the HRM department in the compensation system according to this lecture?