๐ Lecture 21 โ 2-Stock Portfolio Theory, Risk and Expected Return
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on risk measurement using probability, applies these concepts to portfolios comprised of multiple investments, and introduces the fundamental distinction between diversifiable and market risk. Understanding portfolio theory matters because it explains how investors can reduce risk without necessarily sacrificing expected return.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by recapping basic risk concepts such as standard deviation and the bell curve assumption, then defines a portfolio and explains why risk is relative in the context of multiple investments. It introduces the principle of diversification and the two types of stock-related risk: diversifiable and market risk. The lecture then provides the formula for calculating a portfolioโs expected rate of return and the more complex formula for calculating a two-stock portfolioโs risk, including a full numerical example with a correlation coefficient.
๐ Lecture Summary
Recap of Risk Basics
Risk arises because of Uncertainty, Volatility, and Spread in possible outcomes. There are many possible outcomes (pi) for Expected Rate of Returns (ri). It is measured using Standard Deviation or Variance.
๐ Definition โ Risk: Std Dev = ฯ = โ ฮฃ ( r i - < r i > )ยฒ p i = โSigmaโ
Bell Curve Assumption: It is assumed that the forecasted outcome of events will be distributed in the shape of a Normal Probability Distribution. The advantage is that after calculating the standard deviation for any investment, you know the distribution or spread of possible outcomes. If you use a normal distribution, you are sure that 68.26% of the time the Actual Future Rate of Return will lie within -1ฯ and +1ฯ range.
Coefficient of Variation: An Investment Comparison Criterion used to simultaneously account for Risk & Return.
๐ Formula: CV = ฯ / < r >
The objective is to minimize Risk & maximize Return. < r > = Exp or Weighted Avg ROR = ฮฃ pi ri
Portfolio Risk & Return
Portfolio: A portfolio is defined as a Collection of Multiple Investments. Most organizations maintain a large collection of investments. When we talk about risk and return, we must consider the overall risk and return for the entire portfolio. Portfolios may have 2 or more stocks, bonds, other securities, or a mix of all. This lecture focuses on Stock Portfolios.
Risk is Relative: The RISK from investing in Stock of Company ABC usually decreases as you make more Investments in other stocks of different unrelated companies. If you already have a large number of investments and then invest in a particular share in company ABC, the risk will be different.
Diversification: Investing in many Different Shares and Bonds and Projects of Different Companies in Different Countries can reduce risk. Diversified portfolios can reduce risk. The level of risk generally reduces as the size of the portfolio increases.
Portfolio Risk & Return: What matters is the Overall Risk & Return on the entire Portfolio (or Collection) of Investments. The Risk & Return of an Individual Investment in a Stock or Bond should be seen in terms of its Incremental Effect on the Overall Portfolio.
Investment Rule: An investor will try to Maximize Portfolio Return and Minimize Portfolio Risk. An investor will NOT take on Additional Portfolio Risk UNLESS compensated with Additional Portfolio Return.
Types of Risks for a Stock
There are two types of Stock-related Risks which cause Uncertainty in future possible Returns & Cash Flows: Total Stock Risk = Diversifiable Risk + Market Risk
๐ Definition โ Diversifiable Risk: Known as Company-Specific or Unique or Non-Systematic Risk. It is associated with random events associated with Each Company whose stocks you invest in (e.g., winning a major contract, losing a court case). Diversifiable Risk can be Reduced using Diversification. The bad random events affecting one stock will offset the good random events affecting another stock in your portfolio.
๐ Definition โ Market Risk: Known as Non-Diversifiable or Systematic (Country-wide) or Beta Risk. It is associated with Macroeconomic or Socio-Political or Global events that systematically affect stock investments in every Stock Market in the country (e.g., Inflation, Macro Market Interest Rates, Recession, War). Market Risk can NOT be reduced by Diversification.
The graph of Portfolio Size vs Risk shows that about 100% of the Diversifiable Risk (and 50% of the Total Risk) can be removed by Diversification across 40 stocks. Just 7 carefully chosen Un-Correlated Stocks might be enough to remove 30% of the Total Risk.
Portfolio Rate of Return
The Portfolioโs Expected Rate of Return ( rP * ) is the weighted average of the expected returns of each individual investment in the portfolio. The formula is similar to the Expected Return for an Individual Investment but the interpretation is different.
๐ Portfolio Expected ROR Formula: rP * = r1 x1 + r2 x2 + r3 x3 + ... + rn xn
Where there are โnโ different investments in your portfolio. r1 represents the expected return (in % pa) on Investment No. 1 and x1 represents the weight of Investment No. 1 (fraction of the Rupee value of the total portfolio that Investment No. 1 represents).
๐ Example: Suppose you hold a Portfolio of 2 Stock Investments: Stock A: Value = Rs 30, Exp Individual Return = 20% Stock B: Value = Rs 70, Exp Individual Return = 10% Total Value = Rs 100
Expected Portfolio Return Calculation:
rP * = rA xA + rB xB
= 20% (30/100) + 10% (70/100)
= 6% + 7%
= 13%
2-Stock Investment Portfolio Risk
Portfolio Risk is generally not the weighted average risk of the Individual Investments. In fact, it is usually less.
๐ Stock (Investment) Portfolio Risk Formula:
ฯp = โ ( XAยฒ ฯAยฒ + XBยฒ ฯBยฒ + 2 (XA XB ฯA ฯB ฯAB) )
Definition of Terms:
XA: Investment Aโs weight in the total value of the Portfolio.ฯA: Investment Aโs Individual Risk (or standard deviation).ฯAB: The Correlation Coefficient that measures the correlation in the returns of the two investments.- The last term is a Covariance term.
๐ Example: Complete 2-Stock Investment Portfolio Data:
Stock A: Value = Rs 30, Exp Return = 20%, Risk (Std Dev) = 20%
Stock B: Value = Rs 70, Exp Return = 10%, Risk (Std Dev) = 5%
Total Value = Rs 100, Correlation Coeff ฯAB = + 0.6
2-Stock Portfolio Risk Calculation:
ฯp = โ ( XAยฒ ฯAยฒ + XBยฒ ฯBยฒ + 2 (XA XB ฯA ฯB ฯAB) )
= โ {(30/100)ยฒ(20%)ยฒ + (70/100)ยฒ(5%)ยฒ + 2[(30/100)(70/100)(20%)(5%)(0.6)]}
= โ {(0.09)(0.04) + (0.49)(0.0025) + 2[ (0.0021) (0.6) ] }
= โ {0.0036 + 0.001225 + 0.00252}
= โ {0.007345}
= 0.0857 = 8.57%
The Risk vs. Return Graph for a 2-Stock Portfolio with Positive Correlation shows a curve connecting the points of Stock A (Higher Risk, Higher Return) and Stock B (Lower Risk, Lower Return). The Portfolio's return of 13% and risk of 8.57% lies on this curve, demonstrating the risk-reducing benefit of diversification. The graph also illustrates that as Risk INCREASES, the Investorsโ Required Return INCREASES.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is that total stock risk is composed of diversifiable risk, which can be eliminated by holding a portfolio of multiple unrelated stocks, and market risk, which cannot be eliminated. The portfolio's expected return is simply a weighted average of individual returns. However, the portfolio's risk is far more important and is not a simple weighted average; it is reduced by the degree of correlation between the investments, as shown by the two-stock portfolio risk formula. The key investment rule is that an investor will not take on additional portfolio risk unless compensated with higher expected portfolio return.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating the expected return of a 2-stock portfolio, and how is it different from calculating an individual stock's expected return?
- Write down the formula for the risk (standard deviation) of a 2-stock portfolio. What does each variable represent?
- If the correlation coefficient between two stocks is +1.0, what does this mean about the portfolioโs risk compared to the weighted average of the individual risks?
- Explain the difference between diversifiable risk and market risk. Which one can be reduced by adding more stocks to a portfolio?
- In the portfolio risk example, if the percentage of Stock A was increased to 50% and Stock B decreased to 50%, based on the Risk vs. Return graph, what would likely happen to the portfolioโs risk and return?
๐ Lecture 22 โ Portfolio Risk Analysis and Efficient Portfolio Maps
๐ Overview: This lecture examines how portfolio risk is analyzed through correlation between stocks and how efficient portfolio maps visualize the trade-off between risk and return. It expands from 2-stock portfolios to multi-stock portfolios, providing the mathematical framework for calculating portfolio risk using the matrix approach.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a recap of portfolio fundamentals including total stock risk, diversification, and the 2-stock portfolio return formula. It then covers the correlation coefficient and its three critical values (โ1, 0, +1), followed by a complete numerical example of 2-stock portfolio risk calculation. Negatively correlated investments are explored with a risk-return table for different portfolio mixes. The concept of the Efficient Portfolio Map is introduced for both 2-stock and 3-stock portfolios, culminating in the 3x3 matrix approach for calculating multi-stock portfolio risk.
๐ Lecture Summary
Recap: Portfolio Fundamentals
A portfolio is a collection of investments in different stocks, bonds, or other securities designed to minimize overall risk and maximize return. There are two types of stock risk: Total Stock Risk = Diversifiable Risk + Market Risk. Diversification expands the number of investments across different industries so random events in one industry offset random effects in another. Market risk arises from macroeconomic factors like interest rates and inflation that affect all shares similarly. Seven stocks provide good diversification, while 40 stocks are enough to minimize total risk.
Expected 2-Stock Portfolio Return: ๐ Formula: rP* = xA rA + xB rB โ The expected portfolio return equals the weighted average of individual stock returns, where x represents the fraction invested in each stock.
Correlation Coefficient (ฯAB or โRoโ)
The risk of a 2-stock portfolio depends on the correlation coefficient between the stocks, which measures how closely the investments move together.
๐ Definition โ Correlation Coefficient (ฯ): A statistical measure ranging from โ1.0 to +1.0 that indicates the degree to which two investments move in relation to each other.
If ฯ = 0, investments are uncorrelated and the risk formula simplifies to a weighted average formula. If ฯ = +1.0, investments are perfectly positively correlated and diversification does not reduce risk. If ฯ = โ1.0, investments are perfectly negatively correlated and returns move in exactly opposite directions โ in this ideal case, all risk can be diversified away. In reality, the overall ฯ for most stock markets is approximately +0.6.
๐ก Why this matters: The correlation coefficient determines how much risk reduction is possible through diversification โ the lower the correlation, the greater the risk reduction.
2-Stock Portfolio Risk โ Example Recap
Complete data for a 2-stock investment portfolio:
- Stock A: Value = Rs 30, Expected Return = 20%, Risk (Std Dev) = 20%
- Stock B: Value = Rs 70, Expected Return = 10%, Risk (Std Dev) = 5%
- Total Value = Rs 100, Correlation Coefficient ฯ = +0.6
Stock weights: xA = 30/100 = 0.3, xB = 70/100 = 0.7
๐ Formula: ฯP = โ[xAยฒฯAยฒ + xBยฒฯBยฒ + 2(xA xB ฯA ฯB ฯAB)]
๐ Example: ฯP = โ[0.3ยฒ ร 0.20ยฒ + 0.7ยฒ ร 0.05ยฒ + 2(0.3 ร 0.7 ร 0.20 ร 0.05 ร 0.6)] = โ[0.0036 + 0.001225 + 0.00252] = โ0.007345 = 0.0857 = 8.57%
Portfolio Return: rP* = 0.3(20%) + 0.7(10%) = 6% + 7% = 13%
Interpretation: Assuming a normal probability distribution, there is a 68.26% chance that the future portfolio return will be between (13% โ 8.57%) and (13% + 8.57%), i.e., between +4.43% and +21.57%. Portfolio risk (8.57%) lies between the individual risks of the two stocks: 5% < 8.57% < 20%.
Note: If ฯ = โ0.6 (negative correlation), portfolio risk = +4.8%, which is lower than both individual investments!
Negatively Correlated Investments
Data: Stock A โ 20% return, 20% risk; Stock B โ 10% return, 5% risk; Correlation ฯ = โ0.6
Portfolio Risk & Return Table for Different Portfolio Mixes:
| Fraction of Stock A | Portfolio Risk | Expected Portfolio Return |
|---|---|---|
| 100% | 20% | 20% |
| 80% | 15% | 18% |
| 50% | 9% | 15% |
| 30% | 4.8% | 13% |
| 15% | 3.4% | 11.5% |
| 0% (100% Stock B) | 5% | 10% |
Efficient Portfolio Map
An Efficient Portfolio Map shows all possible efficient combinations (mixes) of stocks. Efficient Portfolios are those whose risk and return values match the ones computed using theoretical probability formulas.
๐ Definition โ Efficient Portfolio: A portfolio that offers the highest expected return for a given level of risk, or the lowest risk for a given expected return.
The incremental risk contribution of a new stock to a fully diversified portfolio of 40 uncorrelated stocks will be the market risk component of the new stock only. The diversifiable risk of the new stock would be entirely offset by random movements in the other 40 stocks.
3-Stock Portfolio Risk โ Matrix Approach
Expected return for a 3-stock portfolio: ๐ Formula: rP* = xA rA + xB rB + xC rC
3ร3 Matrix for Portfolio Risk Calculation:
| Stock A | Stock B | Stock C | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stock A | XAยฒ ฯAยฒ | XA XB ฯA ฯB ฯAB | XA XC ฯA ฯC ฯAC |
| Stock B | XB XA ฯB ฯA ฯBA | XBยฒ ฯBยฒ | XB XC ฯB ฯC ฯBC |
| Stock C | XC XA ฯC ฯA ฯCA | XC XB ฯC ฯB ฯCB | XCยฒ ฯCยฒ |
To compute the portfolio variance, add up all terms in every box. To compute the portfolio risk (standard deviation), take the square root of the variance.
Terms in boxes on the diagonal (top left to bottom right) are called "VARIANCE" terms โ they represent the individual magnitude of risk for each stock. Terms in all other (non-diagonal) boxes are called "COVARIANCE" terms โ they account for the effect of one stock's movement on another stock's movement.
๐ก Why this matters: This matrix approach can be extended to calculate risk for a portfolio consisting of any number of stocks, making it a scalable tool for portfolio analysis.
โญ Key Takeaways
The correlation coefficient (ranging from โ1 to +1) is the critical determinant of how much risk reduction is possible through diversification โ negative correlation provides the greatest risk reduction. For the 2-stock portfolio example with ฯ = +0.6, portfolio risk (8.57%) falls between the individual risks of the two stocks (5% and 20%), while with negative correlation (ฯ = โ0.6), portfolio risk can drop below both individual risks to as low as 3.4%. The Efficient Portfolio Map visually demonstrates that as you adjust the mix between stocks, you can achieve different risk-return combinations, and adding more stocks creates new efficient frontier curves. Portfolio risk is calculated using the 3ร3 matrix approach where diagonal boxes contain variance terms and off-diagonal boxes contain covariance terms โ this method is scalable to any number of stocks.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three key values of the correlation coefficient and what does each imply about the possibility of risk reduction through diversification?
- In the 2-stock portfolio example with ฯ = +0.6, what is the portfolio risk and return, and how does the portfolio risk compare to the individual stock risks?
- What happens to portfolio risk when the correlation coefficient is negative (e.g., ฯ = โ0.6) compared to when it is positive?
- What is an Efficient Portfolio Map and what does it show about different combinations of stocks?
- In the 3ร3 matrix approach for calculating portfolio risk, what is the difference between variance terms and covariance terms?