π Lecture 15 β Bonds Valuation and Yield on Bonds
π Overview: This lecture explains how to value bonds as long-term debt instruments by discounting their future cash flows. It covers the present value formula for bonds, the impact of monthly compounding, and introduces the concept of Yield to Maturity (YTM) as a measure of overall return. Understanding bond valuation and yield is essential for making informed investment decisions in fixed-income securities.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers bond valuation using the present value formula, which combines an annuity stream of coupon payments and a single par value payment at maturity. It demonstrates the calculation with an example of Defense Savings Certificates, including monthly compounding. The lecture then explains the concept of Yield to Maturity (YTM), using the Trial and Error method to find the discount rate that equates the bond's market price to its present value. Finally, it decomposes YTM into interest yield and capital gains yield.
π Lecture Summary
Bond Valuation
Bonds are long-term debt instruments and direct claim securities, meaning their value is determined by the future cash flows they provide to bondholders. These cash flows are of two basic types: (1) Coupon Receipts, which are regular cash inflows over the life of the bond, and (2) Par Value, which is the principal amount returned at the bond's maturity date. The present value (PV) formula for a bond is:
n PV = β CFt / (1+rD)t = CF1/(1+rD) + CF2/(1+rD)Β² + ... + CFn/(1+rD)βΏ + PAR/(1+rD)βΏ t=1
The NPV (Net Present Value) is the intrinsic value or fair price of the bond. The rD is the bondholder's required rate of return, which is different from the coupon rate and the market interest rate. The Coupon (CF) is a fixed cash flow calculated as (Coupon Rate Γ Par Value). The par value is fixed, but the market price of the bond varies with supply, demand, and investor perception.
π Definition β NPV (Net Present Value): The intrinsic value or fair price of a bond, representing the expected or theoretical value that needs to be compared to the market price. It is different from the Par (or Face) Value. π Formula: PV = β CFt / (1+rD)t β The present value of a bond is the sum of all future cash flows (coupon payments and par value) discounted by the required rate of return (rD).
π Definition β Coupon (CF): A fixed cash flow paid to the bondholder, calculated as the product of the coupon rate and the par value. π Formula: CF = Coupon Rate Γ Par Value
π Example: Defense Savings Certificate. Par Value = Rs 100,000; Issuer = Government of Pakistan. Monthly coupon = Rs 1,000 for 12 months. Required Return (rD) = 10% p.a. The approximate annual solution (ignoring monthly compounding) gives PV = Rs 101,818. The accurate solution using monthly compounding gives PV = Rs 101,896. Since the PV (Rs 101,896) > Market Price (Rs 100,000), it is a good investment.
Bond Cash Flow Diagram
The cash flow diagram for bonds is a combination of two flows: an Annuity Stream (of coupon receipts) and a Single Par Receipt at maturity. The PV of the bond is calculated by finding the present value of the coupon annuity and adding it to the present value of the par value.
π Definition β Annuity Stream: A series of equal cash flows (coupon payments) received at regular intervals over the life of the bond.
π Example: For the Savings Certificate Example with Monthly Compounding:
- Periodic Monthly Required Return = rD/m = 10%/12 = 0.833% p.m.
- PV of Coupon Annuity: FV of coupons = Rs 1,000 Γ [(1.00833)ΒΉΒ² - 1] / 0.00833 = Rs 12,566; PV = Rs 12,566 / (1.00833)ΒΉΒ² = Rs 11,374
- PV of Par Value: PV = Rs 100,000 / (1.00833)ΒΉΒ² = Rs 90,522
- Total PV: PV (Coupons) + PV (Par) = Rs 11,374 + Rs 90,522 = Rs 101,896
π‘ Why this matters: When we consider multiple compounding (monthly), the present value of the bond increases. The NPV is greater than zero, so based on capital budgeting techniques, you should invest in this project.
Bond Yield to Maturity (YTM)
Yield to Maturity (YTM) is the most common way to compare the overall rate of return of different bonds. It is calculated by setting the bond valuation PV equation equal to the present market price of the bond and solving for "rD". This is done using Trial and Error or Iteration. The value of "rD" that gives PV = Market Price is the YTM.
π Definition β Yield to Maturity (YTM): The overall expected rate of return on a bond if it is held until maturity. It is the discount rate that equates the present value of the bond's future cash flows to its current market price.
π Formula: PV = Market Price = CFt / (1+rD)t β Set PV equal to the actual market price and solve for rD to find the YTM.
π Example: Term Finance Certificate (TFC) of Company ABC. Market Price = Rs 900; Par Value = Rs 1,000; Coupon Rate = 15% p.a. (annual coupon = Rs 150); Remaining life = 2 years.
- Equation: 900 = 150 / (1 + rD) + 1,150 / (1 + rD)Β²
- Trial & Error:
- Try rD = 20%: PV = Rs 924 (close)
- Try rD = 21%: PV = Rs 909 (closer)
- YTM = 21.7%: Gives PV = Rs 900
The total yield (YTM) has two components: Interest Yield and Capital Gains Yield.
π Definition β Interest Yield (or Current Yield): The annual return from the coupon payment, expressed as a percentage of the bond's current market price. π Formula: Interest Yield = Annual Coupon / Market Price π Example: Interest Yield = Rs 150 / Rs 900 = +16.7% p.a.
π Definition β Capital Gains Yield: The portion of the total return from a bond that comes from the change in its market price. π Formula: Capital Gains Yield = YTM β Interest Yield π Example: Capital Gains Yield = 21.7% - 16.7% = +5%
If the bond is called (redeemed early) or sold before maturity, the calculation changes by replacing the par value with a Call Value. π Formula: Call Value = Par Value + 1 Year's Worth of Coupon Receipts
β Key Takeaways
The value of a bond is the sum of the present value of its coupon annuity and the present value of its par value, discounted by the investor's required rate of return. Monthly compounding increases the bond's present value compared to annual compounding, making it a more accurate valuation. Yield to Maturity (YTM) is the total expected return if the bond is held to maturity and is found by solving the PV equation for the discount rate. YTM is composed of interest yield (from the coupon) and capital gains yield (from the change in price). When a bond's market price is below its par value, it is selling at a discount, and its YTM will be higher than its coupon rate.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two types of cash flows from a bond, and at what times do they occur?
- What is the difference between the Coupon Rate and the Required Rate of Return (rD)?
- In the Defense Savings Certificate example, why is the PV with monthly compounding (Rs 101,896) higher than with annual compounding (Rs 101,818)?
- If a TFC has a market price of Rs 900, a par value of Rs 1,000, and an annual coupon of Rs 150, what is its approximate YTM if it matures in 2 years?
- If a bond has a YTM of 15% and an Interest Yield of 10%, what is its Capital Gains Yield?
π Lecture 16 β Introduction to Stocks and Stock Valuation
π Overview: This lecture introduces stocks (or shares) as equity securities representing ownership in a company, contrasting them with bonds (debt instruments). It explains the fundamental differences between common and preferred stock and provides the foundational valuation techniques for both, relating share value directly to the cash flows generated by underlying real assets.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers an introduction to stocks, distinguishing them from bonds, and explaining why companies raise money through equity. It defines the cash flows associated with shares (dividends and capital gains) and explores two types of equity: common stock and preferred stock. The core of the lecture focuses on share price valuation formulas for preferred stock (perpetual and finite investment) and common stock (finite and perpetual investment), using examples to calculate fair or expected prices.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction to Stocks
Stocks are equity paper representing ownership. Shareholders are part owners of the company. On a company's balance sheet, shares issued to raise money are shown on the liability side under the equity section, while shares purchased by the company are shown on the asset side as marketable securities. The share is a legal piece of paper showing the company's name, the par value (or face value) of the share, and confirms the shareholder's ownership. Shares are distinguished from bonds because shares represent ownership, whereas a bond is a debt instrument.
It is crucial to remember that the par value is the value when shares are first issued, while the market value changes with investor perception of the company's future and supply/demand conditions. The value of a direct claim security like a share is directly tied to the value of the underlying real asset.
π Example: A textile company needs to raise Rs 1 million to invest in weaving looms (the real asset). It can issue share certificates (equity) to investors. The value of the shares comes from the cash flows generated by the looms (e.g., fabric sales), which are paid out as dividends and capital gains.
Why raise money through Equity (i.e., Shares or Stocks) rather than Debt (i.e., Bonds or Loan)?
Equity financing provides flexibility because the company is not obligated to make regular fixed payments. Unlike bonds where a fixed interest (or mark-up) must be paid regularly or the company is declared a defaulter, dividends paid to common shareholders are not fixed and are paid according to the Board of Directors' decisions based on net income.
Share Concept
A limited company can raise money by issuing equity in the form of shares. In Pakistan, the par value of a share is generally Rs 10. The life of a share is considered perpetual (never-ending, "going concern") unless the company closes down. As the company's financial health changes over time, the market price of the share changes, even though its par value is fixed. Market prices also change due to supply-demand and speculation. Shares of listed public limited companies are traded on stock exchanges like the KSE, LSE, and ISE.
Types of Equity
Common Stock
This is the most common kind of equity. Common shareholders are owners who have voting rights in management decisions. They receive a dividend (a share of the profit or net income) which varies based on the company's net income for the year and the Board of Directors' decision on how much to retain and reinvest. The cash flows associated with common shares are:
- Dividend: Unpredictable and changing, unlike bond coupon receipts.
- Capital gains
Preferred Stock
This kind of equity is rare. Preferred shareholders get preference (or priority) over common shareholders in recovering their money if the company goes bankrupt. They may not get voting rights. It is also known as Hybrid Equity as it is a mix of a bond and a share. Preferred shareholders receive a fixed regular dividend, similar to the coupon for a bondholder.
Share Price Valuation - Preferred Stock
π Definition β Perpetual Investment: Considering buying a stock and keeping it forever.
π Formula: PV = Po* = DIV1 / rPE
- PV = Present Market Value or Estimated Present Price
- DIV1 = Forecasted Future Dividend in the next period (and all other years, as DIV1 = DIV2 = DIV3 = ...)
- rPE = Minimum Required Rate of Return on Preferred Stock Equity for the individual investor
This is essentially the Perpetuity Formula.
π Definition β Finite Investment: You plan to buy a stock and then sell it after a few days or years (n).
π Formula: PV = Po* = DIVt / (1 + rPE)^t + Pn / (1 + rPE)^n
- t = year (sum from t=1 to n)
- Pn = Final Expected Selling Price
- PV (Share Price) = Dividend Value + Capital Gain/Loss
π Example: Company ABC Preferred Stock has a Market Price of Rs 13, a fixed Dividend of Rs 2 per share, and a Par Value of Rs 10. You expect the Price to be Rs 13 after 2 years. Your Minimum Required Return for this risky stock is 15% (higher than the 10% risk-free bank deposit).
-
Perpetual Investment:
PV = DIV1 / rPE = Rs 2 / 0.15 = Rs 13.33The Fair Value is Rs 13.33. The Market Value is Rs 13. So, the share is undervalued and you will gain value by buying it. -
Finite Investment (2 years):
PV = 2 / (1.15) + 2 / (1.15)^2 + 13 / (1.15)^2PV = Rs 13.08In this example, the Perpetual Investment is worth more than the Finite Investment because the present value of the infinite stream of Rs 2 dividends is greater than the present value of the expected future selling price (Rs 13).
π‘ Why this matters: The choice between perpetuity and finite valuation depends on the investor's holding period. The perpetuity model only uses the dividend stream, while the finite model also considers the capital gain from selling the stock.
Share Price Valuation - Common Stock
Finite (Limited Life) Investment in Common Stock: This is more common. The formula accounts for cash flows from variable dividends and an estimated selling price (Pn). Note that Pn depends on DIVn+1 (the price at any point in time depends on the dividend in the following year).
Perpetual Investment in Common Stock:
This is an idealized case. The final cash flow term (containing Pn) takes place at Year n = infinity. The present value of this term is almost zero because the discount factor (1+rE)^n becomes very large. Therefore, you can ignore the last cash flow term.
Simplified Formula (Perpetual Investment):
PV = DIV1/(1+rE) + DIV2/(1+rE)^2 + ... + DIVn/(1+rE)^n
This equation is still impractical because it requires forecasting dividends for every year forever.
π Example: The Common Stock of Company ABC has a Market Price of Rs 13. You forecast future Dividends as Rs 2 in the first year and Rs 4 in the second year. You forecast the Market Price to be Rs 13 after 2 years. The Risk-Free Return is 10% p.a., but your expected Minimum Required Return from this risky Common Stock (rCE) is 20% (higher than the 15% for the company's Preferred Stock).
-
Finite Investment for 2 Years:
PV = 2/1.2 + 4/(1.2)^2 + 13/(1.2)^2 = Rs 13.47 -
Perpetual Investment: This cannot be determined without dividend forecast data for every year forever. We need special models like the Zero Growth Model and Constant Growth Model (to be discussed in the next lecture) to approximate future dividend cash flow streams.
β Key Takeaways
- Stocks (equity) represent ownership in a company, unlike bonds (debt), and their value is derived from the cash flows (dividends and capital gains) generated by the company's underlying real assets.
- Preferred stock is a hybrid security paying a fixed, regular dividend, making it suitable for valuation using the perpetuity formula, while common stock has variable dividends, making its valuation more complex.
- For a perpetual investment in preferred stock, the price is simply the dividend divided by the required rate of return. For a finite investment, the price is the present value of the dividend stream plus the present value of the expected selling price.
- The simplified perpetual investment formula for common stock removes the final selling price term, but still requires dividend forecasts for every year, necessitating the use of growth models.
- The required rate of return for common stock (rCE) is generally higher than that for preferred stock (rPE) and risk-free assets, reflecting the higher risk associated with common stock ownership.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the fundamental difference between a stock (share) and a bond in terms of what they represent for the investor?
- What are the two main sources of cash flow for a shareholder from a stock investment?
- What is the key difference between the dividends paid to preferred shareholders and those paid to common shareholders?
- Using the perpetuity formula, what is the fair price of a preferred stock that pays a fixed annual dividend of Rs 5 if your required rate of return is 12.5%?
- In the context of a finite investment in common stock, what does "Pn" represent in the present value formula, and on what variable is it fundamentally dependent?
π Lecture 17 β Common Stock Pricing and Dividend Growth Models
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on stock price valuation, focusing specifically on common stock pricing methods. It introduces two key Dividend Growth ModelsβZero Growth and Constant Growthβthat simplify the complex task of forecasting future dividends for perpetual investments, allowing investors to estimate a theoretical fair price for common shares.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the distinction between preferred and common stock, the concepts of finite versus perpetual investment time horizons, and the calculation of theoretical fair value versus market price. It then delves into the Zero Growth Dividends Model and the Constant Growth Dividends Model for valuing common stock under perpetual investment, including their formulas and a numerical example comparing both models.
π Lecture Summary
Common Stock Pricing
Both stocks (preferred and common) represent ownership of Real Assets in a company. Dividends are the shareholderβs portion of the distributed net income. The value of a direct security (the share certificate) is derived from the cash flows generated by the underlying real assets. There are two types of Investment Time Horizons: Finite Investment (limited duration, requiring a forecasted selling price) and Perpetual Investment (very long term, where the forecasted selling price is not significant).
A numerical example compares preferred and common stock. Company ABC issued both shares (Par Value = Rs 10). The market risk-free return is 10% pa. For Preferred Shares (riskier, required return rPE = 15%): Perpetual investment PV = DIV1 / rPE = 2 / 0.15 = Rs 13.33. For a 2-Year Finite investment: PV = 2/1.15 + 2/(1.15)Β² + 13/(1.15)Β² = Rs 13.08.
For Common Shares (more risky, required return rCE = 20%): Forecasted dividends are Rs 2 (year 1) and Rs 4 (year 2), with an expected selling price of Rs 13 after 2 years. For a 2-Year Finite investment: PV = 2/1.2 + 4/(1.2)Β² + 13/(1.2)Β² = Rs 13.47. The common stock has a higher intrinsic present value because its higher expected dividends more than compensate for its higher risk.
π Definition β Fair Value: The estimated theoretical market price calculated from the PV equation using the investorβs personal required rate of return as the discount rate. It varies depending on the investor's risk profile.
π Definition β Market Price: The actual price at which a share is bought or sold, determined by the shareβs demand/supply and investor perceptions. It is almost identical for everyone.
π Example: If Market Price < Fair Value, the stock is undervalued (a bargain), and investors will rush to buy it, causing the Market Price to rise towards Fair Value. If Market Price > Fair Value, the stock is overvalued.
Zero Growth Dividends Model
For perpetual investment in common stock, forecasting dividends for every future year is not feasible. The Zero Growth Dividends Model simplifies this by assuming perpetual dividends at zero growth, meaning constant perpetual dividends (DIV1 = DIV2 = DIV3). This is a simple perpetuity model, similar to the preferred stock (perpetual investment) formula.
π Definition β Zero Growth Dividends Model: A valuation model that assumes a fixed regular dividends cash flow stream for every year in the future.
π Formula: PV = Po* = DIV1 / (1 + rCE) + DIV1 / (1 + rCE)Β² + DIV1 / (1 + rCE)Β³ + ... = DIV1 / rCE Plain English: The present value (theoretical price) of a common stock with zero growth dividends is the next year's expected dividend divided by the investor's required rate of return.
Constant Growth Dividends Model
The Constant Growth Dividends Model assumes that dividends grow at a constant Inflationary Growth Rate "g" (typically 5-10% pa). Dividends grow according to the discrete compound growth formula: DIVt+1 = DIVt Γ (1 + g)^t. The growth rate can be estimated from financial statements or the inflation rate of the economy.
π Definition β Constant Growth Dividends Model: A valuation model that assumes dividends grow at a constant rate "g" forever, allowing the use of a growing perpetuity formula.
π Formula: PV = Po* = DIV1 / (1 + rCE) + DIV1(1+g) / (1 + rCE)Β² + DIV1(1+g)Β² / (1 + rCE)Β³ + ... = DIV1 / (rCE - g) Plain English: The present value of a common stock with constantly growing dividends is the next year's expected dividend divided by the difference between the required rate of return and the constant growth rate.
π Example: Company ABC common stock, required return rCE = 20%, present dividend = Rs 4. Zero Growth Model: PV = 4 / 0.20 = Rs 20. Constant Growth Model (g = 10%): PV = 4 / (0.20 - 0.10) = Rs 40. π‘ Why this matters: The Constant Growth Model gives a higher price estimate because it assumes perpetual compounded growth in dividends (at 10% per year forever).
β Key Takeaways
The valuation of common stock depends heavily on the investment time horizon, with perpetual investments requiring simplified dividend growth models. The Zero Growth Model assumes constant dividends and uses a simple perpetuity formula (DIV1 / rCE). The Constant Growth Model assumes dividends grow at a constant rate "g" and uses a growing perpetuity formula (DIV1 / (rCE - g)). The required rate of return (rCE) is personal to each investor and reflects the stock's risk, making "Fair Value" subjective, while "Market Price" is objective and determined by supply and demand. The Constant Growth Model consistently yields a higher theoretical price than the Zero Growth Model because it factors in future dividend growth.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main types of dividend growth models used for perpetual investment in common stock?
- Write the formula for the Zero Growth Model and explain what each variable represents.
- Write the formula for the Constant Growth Model. How does it differ from the Zero Growth Model formula?
- In the provided numerical example, why does the Constant Growth Model give a higher present value (Rs 40) compared to the Zero Growth Model (Rs 20)?
- What is the difference between a stock's "Fair Value" and its "Market Price"?
π Lecture 18 β Common Stocks β Rate of Return and EPS Pricing Model
π Overview: This lecture completes the discussion on common stock valuation by examining how to compute the required rate of return (ROR) for equity investments. It then introduces the Earnings Per Share (EPS) Pricing Model as an alternative to the dividend approach, which values shares based on the cash flows generated by the company's underlying assets rather than direct dividend payments.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers two main areas: first, calculating the Required Rate of Return for Common Equity (rCE) by rearranging dividend pricing models (zero growth and constant growth), introducing Gordon's Formula which splits return into dividend yield and capital gain yield. Second, it presents the EPS Pricing Model, which values a share by discounting earnings per share and adding the Present Value of Growth Opportunities (PVGO), demonstrated with a worked example.
π Lecture Summary
Common Stocks β Rate of Return
In capital budgeting, both Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) are important. Similarly, for common stock, we need to compute both the fair price (value) and the Required Rate of Return (ROR). The estimated required rate of return for investment in Common Equity (rCE) can be calculated by rearranging the dividend pricing model equations.
For the Zero Growth Model:
- Fair Price: Po* = DIV1 / rCE
- Required Return: rCE* = DIV1 / Po
For the Constant Growth Model:
- Fair Price: Po* = DIV1 / (rCE - g)
- Required Return: rCE* = (DIV1 / Po) + g
The formula for rCE in the constant growth model is known as Gordon's Formula.
π Definition β Gordon's Formula: A method to calculate the required rate of return on a common stock, where rCE* = (DIV1 / Po) + g. π Formula: rCE* = (DIV1 / Po) + g π‘ Why this matters: This formula splits the total return into two components.
- (DIV1 / Po) is the Dividend Yield, which is the fraction of the present price represented by dividends.
- g is the Capital Gain Yield, which is the lumped measure of the expected increase in dividend over the life of the asset.
Earnings per Share (EPS) Pricing Model
Up to now, stock valuation has used forecasted dividends (the "dividend yield approach"). The EPS Pricing Model takes a different perspective, valuing shares based on the cash flows generated by the company. The logic is that for direct claim securities like stocks, the value of the security can be calculated from the cash flows of the underlying assets (the company's assets).
The EPS Stock Price Estimation Formula is: PV = Po = EPS1 / rCE + PVGO*
- Po* = Estimated Present Fair Price
- EPS1 = Forecasted Earnings per Share in the next year (Year 1)
- rCE = Required Rate of Return on Common Stock Equity
- PVGO = Present Value of Growth Opportunities, representing the present value of potential growth in business from reinvestments in new positive NPV projects and investments.
PVGO is calculated using a perpetuity formula: PVGO = NPV1 / (rCE - g)
Where:
- NPV1 = [-Io + (C/rCE)] / (rCE - g)
- -Io = Value of Initial Reinvestment (not paid to shareholders) = Pb x EPS
- Pb = Ploughback ratio = 1 β Payout ratio
- Payout ratio = DIV / EPS
- C = Forecasted Net Cash Inflow from Reinvestment = Io x ROE
- ROE = Return on Equity = NI / Book Equity of Common Stock Outstanding
- g = Growth rate in NPV of new reinvestment projects = Plowback x ROE
π‘ Why this matters: The PVGO component captures the value derived from a company's future growth opportunities, which is critical for valuing "growth stocks". In the EPS approach, 'g' is the growth in NPV of new projects, while in the dividend approach, 'g' is the growth rate in dividends.
Example: Common Stock of Company ABC
Market Price = Rs 105. Data:
- Forecasted Dividend Next Year (DIV1) = Rs 10
- Expected Dividend Growth (g) = 10% pa
- Forecasted Earnings per Share (EPS1) = Rs 12
- Required Return (rCE) = 20% pa
Dividend Pricing (Gordon's) Approach: PV = Po* = DIV1 / (rCE - g) = 10 / (20% - 10%) = 10 / 0.10 = Rs 100 (Estimated Fair Price of Rs 100 is less than Market Price of Rs 105, so the share is overvalued).
Earnings Per Share (EPS) Pricing Model: PV = Po* = EPS1 / rCE + PVGO PV = (12 / 0.20) + PVGO = Rs 60 + PVGO
First, calculate Plowback (Pb) and ROE: Pb = 1 - Payout = 1 - (DIV / EPS) = 1 - (10 / 12) = 1 - 5/6 = 1/6 g = Pb x ROE => 10% = (1/6) x ROE => ROE = 10% x 6 = 60% or 0.60
Now, calculate PVGO: NPV1 = [-Io + (C / rCE)] / (rCE - g) Io = Pb x EPS = (1/6) x 12 = Rs 2 C = Io x ROE = 2 x 0.60 = Rs 1.2 NPV1 = [-2 + (1.2 / 0.20)] / (0.20 - 0.10) = [-2 + 6] / 0.10 = 4 / 0.10 = Rs 40
Finally, PV = Rs 60 + Rs 40 = Rs 100.
π Example: The EPS approach yields the same estimated fair price (Rs 100) as the dividend approach. Importantly, the EPS approach shows that 40% (Rs 40 out of Rs 100) of the value is growth-based (PVGO). This identifies Company ABC's stock as a Growth Stock, where a significant portion of the price is determined by the company's potential to grow its business. For high-growth companies like IT/internet firms, the PVGO term typically represents a very large percentage of the share price.
β Key Takeaways
For the exam, remember that Gordon's Formula (rCE = DIV1/Po + g) is essential for calculating the required rate of return, splitting it into dividend yield and capital gain yield. The EPS Pricing Model (Po = EPS1/rCE + PVGO) is a powerful alternative that values shares based on the company's earnings and growth opportunities. The PVGO term captures the value from future positive NPV projects and is calculated using a perpetuity formula (NPV1/(rCE-g)). Crucially, both the dividend and EPS models are designed to yield the same estimated fair price for a stock.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two components of the required rate of return in Gordon's Formula, and what does each represent?
- In the EPS Pricing Model (Po = EPS1/rCE + PVGO), what does the term PVGO represent?
- How is the Ploughback ratio (Pb) calculated, and what is its relationship to the Payout ratio?
- In the EPS model's PVGO calculation, what does 'C' represent, and how is it calculated?
- If a stock's estimated fair price from the EPS model is Rs 100, and its EPS1/rCE is Rs 40, what percentage of its value is growth-based?
π Lecture 19 β Introduction to Risk, Risk and Return for a Single Stock Investment
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concept of risk in financial management, explaining how risk is defined, measured, and its relationship with return. It focuses on stand-alone risk for a single stock investment, covering probability distributions, expected return calculation, and the basics of risk measurement using standard deviation.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the introduction to risk including the Chinese definition of risk and its components of danger and opportunity, types of risk (stand-alone vs. portfolio risk, diversifiable vs. market risk), causes of risk, measurement of risk using standard deviation and variance, the fundamental rule of risk and return, diversification principles, and detailed calculation of expected rate of return using probability distributions with a practical example of investing in Company ABC stock.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction to Risk
Risk is defined as the combination of danger and opportunity. In finance, risk refers to the uncertainty in the outcome of an investment, specifically the variability, spread, or volatility in expected future value (cash flows) or returns. For example, investing Rs 1,000 today to buy a share involves uncertainty about its price one year from nowβthere is no guarantee, so risk exists.
The difference or variation in possible outcomes of a particular investment represents its riskiness. Risk can be understood with reference to the uncertainty of future cash flows produced by assets (both physical and financial securities). Businesses make forecasts based on assumptions, but these forecasts are not 100% accurate, and actual cash flows may differ significantly from forecasted values.
Types of Risk
There are two major categories of assets: Real Physical Assets and Financial Assets (stocks & bonds). When discussing risk in investing in direct claim securities, we must distinguish between:
- Stand Alone Risk (or Single Investment Risk) β risk of a particular investment considered alone
- Market or Portfolio Risk (or Collection of Investments Risk) β overall risk of the entire collection of investments
Within portfolio risk, we further distinguish:
- Diversifiable Risk: random risk specific to one company that can be virtually eliminated
- Market Risk: uncertainty caused by broad movement in market or economy; more significant
Causes of Risk
Causes can be Company-Specific or General. These may include cash losses from operations, poor financial management, company debt, inflation, economy, politics, war, or fate. Ultimately, risk involves elements of chance.
Measurement of Risk
Risk is measured in terms of standard deviation or variance. Even after calculating numbers, risk remains subjective. Important considerations include:
- What kind of risk? Stand Alone or Portfolio? Market or Diversifiable? Stock Price or Earnings?
- Time Horizon: Are you investing over 1 year or 30 years? The level of risk may change with time period.
Fundamental Rule of Risk & Return
The rule is summed up as "No Pain - No Gain". Investors will not take on additional market risk unless they expect to receive additional return. Most investors are Risk Averse.
π Definition β Risk Aversion: The tendency of investors to prefer less risk, requiring higher expected returns to take on additional risk.
Diversification
Diversification states: "Don't put all your eggs in one basket." By spreading money across many different investments, markets, industries, and countries, you can avoid the weakness of each. Ensure investments are Uncorrelated so they don't suffer from the same bad news.
π Definition β Diversification: A risk management strategy that mixes a wide variety of investments within a portfolio to reduce overall risk.
Range of Possible Outcomes, Expected Return
Overall Return on Stock = Dividend Yield + Capital Gains Yield (Gordon's Formula)
Return is proportional to Capital Gain, which is proportional to Selling Price. The wider the range of possible outcomes, the greater the risk. The chance that a future event will actually occur is measured using Probability.
π Formula β Expected Rate of Return: [ \text{Expected ROR} = \langle r \rangle = \sum p_i r_i ] Where ( p_i ) = Probability of Outcome "i" occurring, and ( r_i ) = Rate of Return if Outcome "i" occurs. The expected ROR is the sum of weighted returns for ALL possible outcomes.
Example: Investing in Company ABC Stock
Suppose you are deciding whether to invest in the Stock of Company ABC. The current market price ( P_0 = \text{Rs 100} ). Future or forecasted price after 1 year could reach any one of 3 possible values.
Payoff Table & Expected ROR:
| Outcomes (After 1 Yr) | Probability (p) | ROR ( r = (P_1^* - P_0)/P_0 ) |
|---|---|---|
| Price Rises (Pβ*=140) | 0.3 | +40% = (140-100)/100 |
| Price Same (Pβ*=110) | 0.4 | +10% = (110-100)/100 |
| Price Falls (Pβ*=80) | 0.3 | -20% = (80-100)/100 |
| Total | 1.0 |
Calculation of Expected ROR: [ \langle r \rangle = p_1(r_1) + p_2(r_2) + p_3(r_3) ] [ \langle r \rangle = 0.3(40%) + 0.4(10%) + 0.3(-20%) ] [ \langle r \rangle = 12% + 4% - 6% = 10% ]
π‘ Why this matters: The expected ROR of 10% represents the most likely or mean return. However, the actual return could be +40%, +10%, or -20%, showing the risk (variability) involved.
Probability Distribution
In the probability distribution diagram, probability is graphed on the y-axis and rate of return on the x-axis. The largest probability occurs at the expected rate of return (10%). If the top of each vertical bar is connected, a bell curve is formed. After calculating expected rate of return, risk can be calculated using standard deviation.
Stand Alone Risk of Single Stock Investment
The wider the range of possible outcomes (greater variability in potential returns), the greater the risk.
π Formula β Stand Alone Risk (Standard Deviation): [ \text{Risk} = \text{Std Dev} = \sqrt{\sum (r_i - \langle r_i \rangle)^2 p_i} ] Where ( r_i ) = return for outcome "i", ( p_i ) = probability of occurrence, and ( \langle r_i \rangle ) = Expected (weighted average) Return.
π‘ Why this matters: Standard deviation quantifies the dispersion of possible returns around the expected return. A higher standard deviation means greater risk.
β Key Takeaways
Risk is the combination of danger and opportunity, representing uncertainty in investment outcomes, and can be categorized as stand-alone risk or portfolio risk (which further divides into diversifiable and market risk). The fundamental rule of risk and return states that investors require additional expected return for taking on additional risk, as most investors are risk averse. Diversification reduces risk by spreading investments across uncorrelated assets. Expected return is calculated using probability-weighted outcomes, and risk is measured using standard deviation, which captures the variability of possible returns around the expected return. The wider the range of possible outcomes, the greater the risk, making probability distributions and standard deviation essential tools for investment analysis.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the Chinese definition of risk, and how does it apply to financial investments?
- Explain the difference between diversifiable risk and market risk. Which one is more significant for investors?
- Calculate the expected rate of return for a stock with the following outcomes: 30% probability of 25% return, 50% probability of 10% return, and 20% probability of -5% return.
- Why is diversification important in portfolio management? What condition must investments meet for effective diversification?
- What does standard deviation measure in the context of investment risk, and how is it calculated from a probability distribution?
π Lecture 20 β RISK FOR A SINGLE STOCK INVESTMENT, PROBABILITY GRAPHS AND CO-EFFICIENT OF VARIATION
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on risk and return for a single stock investment. It focuses on how to measure stand-alone risk using standard deviation, interpret it through the Normal Probability Distribution, and compare different investments using the Coefficient of Variation. These tools are essential for making informed investment decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture revisits the example of a stock investment with three possible outcomes to calculate standard deviation as a measure of risk. It then interprets the standard deviation using the Normal Distribution curve, explaining the 68.26% probability range. Finally, it compares three different investments (Stock A, T-Bill B, and Project C) using risk-return analysis and introduces the Coefficient of Variation as a tool for choosing the best investment on a risk-per-unit-return basis.
π Lecture Summary
3 Possible Outcomes Example Continued: Measuring Stand Alone Risk for Single Stock Investment
The lecture continues with the example from the previous lecture, where a stock investment has three possible outcomes after one year. This uncertainty in the future price creates a probability distribution, which allows us to calculate risk. The formula for Standard Deviation (Ξ΄) is used to measure this stand-alone risk.
π Definition β Standard Deviation (Ξ΄): A measure of the dispersion or spread of possible returns around the expected return. It quantifies the total risk of an investment. π Formula: Ξ΄ = β Ξ£ (rα΅’ - rΜ)Β² pα΅’ Where:
- rα΅’ = each possible return
- rΜ = expected (mean) return
- pα΅’ = probability of each return
π Example Calculation: For a stock with returns of 40%, 10%, and -20% with probabilities 0.3, 0.4, and 0.3 respectively, and an expected return of 10%: Ξ΄ = β{[(40-10)Β² Γ 0.3] + [(10-10)Β² Γ 0.4] + [(-20-10)Β² Γ 0.3]} Ξ΄ = β{270 + 0 + 270} Ξ΄ = β540 = 23.24%
π‘ Why this matters: The standard deviation of 23.24% tells us about the volatility of the stock's return. Higher standard deviation means higher risk.
Standard Deviation Interpretation
The units of Standard Deviation are the same as the units of the return, which is in percentage (%). Assuming a Normal Probability Distribution that is symmetric about the expected return, we conclude that 68.26% of the time, the actual return will lie within -1 and +1 standard deviation of the expected return.
- Expected Return = 10%
- Range within Β±1 Std Dev = 10% Β± 23.24%, which is from -13.24% to 33.24%
- There is a 68.26% chance that the actual return after one year will be somewhere between -13.24% and 33.24%. This is because in a normal distribution, the area under the curve from -1 to +1 standard deviation is always 68.28%. This means two-thirds of the time, the actual return will fall in this range.
- The lower bound of -13.24% indicates a potential loss, which is a risk because the required rate of return is 10%.
Example: Comparison of 3 Investments in terms of Risk & Return
The lecture compares three different investments to determine which is the best.
| Investment | Risk (Std Dev) | Expected Return |
|---|---|---|
| Stock A | 23.24% | 10% |
| T-Bill/Bond B | 5% | 10% |
| Project C | 30% | 30% |
- T-Bill B is the least risky (lowest Std Dev = 5%) and Project C has the highest return (=30%).
- Rule 1: Given 2 Investments with Identical Expected Return, choose the Investment with the Lower Risk.
- Between Stock A and T-Bill B, T-Bill B is better because both have a 10% return, but T-Bill B has less risk (5% vs. 23.24%).
- Rule 2: Given 2 Investments with Identical Risk, choose the Investment with the Higher Expected Return.
- Comparing T-Bill B and Project C is difficult because T-Bill B has lower risk but Project C has higher return.
Combined Risk & Return Graphical Comparison of Investments
The lecture uses a graph with two probability distributions:
- T-Bill B: Plotted on the left, it shows a low risk (narrow, sharp peak) and low return.
- Project C: Plotted on the right, it shows a high risk (broader, flatter curve) and high return.
- To decide which is better, we must look at risk and return simultaneously using the Coefficient of Variation.
Comparison of Different Investments: Coefficient of Variation
The Coefficient of Variation (CV) is a measure of risk per unit of return.
π Definition β Coefficient of Variation (CV): A standardized measure of the risk per unit of expected return. It is used to compare investments with different risk and return profiles. π Formula: CV = Standard Deviation / Expected Return π Example:
- CV for T-Bill B = 5% / 10% = 0.5
- CV for Project C = 30% / 30% = 1.0
- Decision Rule: Choose the project with the Lowest CV.
- In this case, choose T-Bill B because it carries the lowest risk per unit of return (0.5 < 1.0).
Risk Aversion Assumption
Most investors are psychologically Risk Averse. If two investments offer the same expected return, most investors would choose the one with the lower risk (or standard deviation). Most investors are not major gamblers. Note that gamblers would choose Project C, which appeals to greed by offering an upside return of 40%. The consequence on share price is that the higher the risk of a share, the higher its rate of return, but the lower its market price.
β Key Takeaways
- Standard deviation is the primary measure of stand-alone risk for a single stock, calculated from the probability distribution of possible returns. A higher standard deviation indicates higher volatility and risk.
- Under a Normal Distribution, there is a 68.26% probability that the actual return will fall within one standard deviation above and below the expected return. This range (e.g., -13.24% to 33.24%) provides a concrete estimate of future return variability.
- When comparing investments, if returns are equal, choose the one with lower risk (lower standard deviation). If risk is equal, choose the one with the higher expected return.
- The Coefficient of Variation (CV) is the key metric for comparing investments with different risk and return profiles. It measures risk per unit of return (CV = Std Dev / Expected Return), and the investment with the lowest CV is preferred.
- The assumption of risk aversion explains why investors demand a higher return for taking on higher risk. This relationship also dictates that higher-risk shares will have higher required rates of return but lower market prices.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for calculating the standard deviation for a single stock investment with multiple possible outcomes?
- If a stock has an expected return of 15% and a standard deviation of 20%, between what two values will the actual return fall 68.26% of the time, assuming a normal distribution?
- Given two investments, one with a 12% return and 8% risk, and another with a 12% return and 15% risk, which is the better investment?
- How is the Coefficient of Variation calculated, and what does it tell an investor?
- Two projects have the following data: Project X (Return: 25%, Risk: 20%) and Project Y (Return: 18%, Risk: 9%). Which project is the better investment based on the Coefficient of Variation? Show your calculations.