📘 Lecture 11 — Creating a Climate for Change
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the foundational conditions necessary for successful organizational change, focusing on the relationship between the OD practitioner and the client system. It explores various practitioner styles, client relationship modes, and the critical importance of establishing trust, openness, and collaboration. Understanding these dynamics is essential for any OD practitioner seeking to diagnose and improve organizational effectiveness.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing the practitioner’s role in creating a positive climate for participation and learning, including potential value conflicts with the client organization. It then defines who the true client is in OD consultation—not any individual or group, but the relationships and interfaces between units. The text categorizes five distinct practitioner styles (Stabilizer, Cheerleader, Analyzer, Persuader, Pathfinder) based on their emphasis on effectiveness and member morale. Next, it presents four practitioner-client relationship modes (Apathetic, Gamesmanship, Charismatic, Consensus) that describe how openly members share information and take responsibility. Finally, important dimensions for a successful relationship are listed, and the Grayson Chemical Company case study is introduced to apply these concepts.
📝 Lecture Summary
Creating a Climate for Change
Most OD practitioners agree that an open, give-and-take relationship with the client is desirable. This depends on the practitioner’s ability to form relationships of openness and trust. Good relationships do not fit into a formula, but practitioners have noted recognizable characteristics. The change agent should act congruently, in accordance with the values he or she is attempting to superimpose upon the client system’s value system. The practitioner must “practice what they preach” and think and act in ways that create a positive climate for participation and learning.
The basic value system of the OD practitioner may not be compatible with the organization’s culture, leading to conflict. An assessment of the degree of difference and the likelihood of working through these differences should be part of the initial intervention. The practitioner may desire openness, authenticity, and trust, while client system managers may feel threatened. The practitioner also examines the degree of conflict and collaboration between organization units to avoid being party to existing conflicts.
🔑 Definition — Congruent behavior: Acting in accordance with the values one is attempting to promote. Example: An OD practitioner advocating for transparency must be transparent with the client.
Who is Client?
The client in OD consultation is never one individual, regardless of position, or any particular group or subsystem. The correct answer to “who is the client?” is “none of the above.”
💡 The client is the relationship and/or interface between individuals and units within and related to the system. The arrows in the figure depict the true client—the connections between parts of the organization. The consultant’s effectiveness depends on maintaining a social distance between self and other individuals, operating on the boundaries of units rather than exclusively within them, thereby maintaining an objective stance.
OD Practitioner Styles:
The OD practitioner is the person who initiates, stimulates, or facilitates a change program and may come from inside or outside the organization. Intervention refers to the practitioner’s entry into the client system and includes several different roles and activities.
Practitioners have a variety of styles based on the degree of emphasis placed upon two goals: effectiveness (goal accomplishment) and morale (relationships and participant satisfaction).
🔑 Definition — Intervention: The practitioner’s entry into the client system, including several different roles and activities.
The Stabilizer Style:
The goal of the Stabilizer Style is neither effectiveness nor participant satisfaction. The practitioner aims to keep from rocking the boat and maintain a low profile. The underlying motivation is often survival or following top management’s directives. This style is typically forced upon the practitioner by organizational pressures.
The Cheerleader Style:
The Cheerleader Style places emphasis on member satisfaction and is chiefly concerned with employee motivation and morale. It seeks warm working relationships and avoids confrontation. Effectiveness is not emphasized, based on the assumption that high satisfaction leads to high effectiveness, though evidence contradicts this.
The Analyzer Style:
The Analyzer Style places great emphasis on efficiency and little on member satisfaction. It relies on rational assessment of problems, using authority to resolve conflicts and rational problem-solving processes. The practitioner has specialized expertise and takes responsibility for solving specific problems, based on the belief that the client cannot learn these skills.
The Persuader Style:
The Persuader Style focuses on both effectiveness and morale but optimizes neither. It provides a low-risk strategy, avoiding direct confrontation. A great deal of effort is applied to satisfy different forces, often resulting in a watered-down change program where organization improvement is unlikely.
The Pathfinder Style:
The Pathfinder Style seeks both a high degree of effectiveness and a high degree of member satisfaction, believing that greater effectiveness is possible when all members are involved and problem-solving is done through teamwork. There is awareness that confrontation and conflict can lead to a more effective organization. The pathfinder practitioner uses collaborative problem solving and challenges underlying patterns of member behavior.
A survey of 1,000 OD practitioners found that listening, integrity, and organizational diagnosis were rated as the most important OD skills. The pathfinder practitioner focuses on six processes essential for effective performance: (1) communication, (2) member roles and functions in groups, (3) group problem-solving and decision-making, (4) group norms and growth, (5) leadership and authority, and (6) inter-group cooperation and competition.
💡 These five practitioner styles are not mutually exclusive. A practitioner may transition from one style to another to meet changing client system needs.
Practitioner-Client Relationship Modes:
Eric H. Neilsen identified basic dimensions in the practitioner-client relationship. To collaboratively change the organization’s culture, members need to (1) share their ideas, assumptions, perceptions, and feelings, and (2) accept personal responsibility for their own behavior. Based on these two dimensions, four possible modes are identified:
The Apathetic Mode: Members keep true ideas to themselves, assuming sharing will not make a difference. They follow routines, take no responsibility, and do as they are told.
The Gamesmanship Mode: Members keep true feelings to themselves, assuming sharing may threaten desired outcomes. They conform outwardly but manipulate strategic factors to gain personal goals. Members may favor change if it serves their personal interest.
The Charismatic Mode: A limited number of members openly share ideas and feelings based on perceptions of leadership. Followers look for cues from leaders, so responsibility is low for most members. Change is seen as desirable if leaders approve.
The Consensus Mode: Members continuously share perceptions and feelings openly. Personal viewpoints are expressed and seen as relevant. Decisions are made and differences resolved through sharing viewpoints, involving both sharing data and maintaining responsibility for actions. Members find the OD process consistent with their way of operating.
Important dimensions in practitioner-client relationship:
- The practitioner’s attitudes and behavior enable a climate where feelings can be freely expressed
- Ability to listen effectively and express ideas clearly
- The practitioner is honest with the client
- Operating based on power equalization to ensure the power differential is not too great
- This is particularly important for internal practitioners who may be in a subordinate position
- All key parties must be involved in the OD program to some extent
- A good relationship increases the probability of a successful OD program; a superficial relationship increases the probability of failure
Case: The Grayson Chemical Company
The Grayson Chemical Company manufactured industrial chemicals. The company was about 40 years old with stable management but declining earnings and sales had brought pressure from the board. The company had become increasingly stagnant and had steadily lost market standing and profitability. The board recruited a new CEO, Tom Baker, from another company. Baker needed to develop a top management team to turn the company around, but the situation was unfavorable—decisions were made by the book, things were done because “they have always been done this way,” and incompetent managers were often promoted.
The Meeting Baker met with three board members who each offered different advice:
- Robert Temple advised developing performance goals with existing people and rewarding achievement
- James Allen advised bringing in a new top management team (6 people) that Baker knew and trusted
- Hartley Ashford advised bringing in managers with proven track records from different industries for a synergistic effect
Case Solution: The Grayson Chemical Company
I. Problems: A. Macro: (1) Grayson has become stagnant, failed to change, and is no longer competitive; (2) current people are not acceptable to change; (3) culture of doing things by the book B. Micro: (1) incompetent managers promoted; (2) board does not have a consensus of opinion
II. Causes: (1) Grayson has not been proactive with its environment; (2) corporate culture is very resistant to change; (3) board does not speak with one voice, leading to disorganized operations with no clear direction
III. Systems affected: The entire organization is affected. Structural system could be radically altered. Psychosocial system shows status quo and contentment. Technical system has “fairly” competent managers but not enough for required changes. Managerial system faces turmoil from changes. Goals and values system values putting in time rather than excellence.
IV. Alternatives: (1) Maintain status quo; (2) develop a pathfinder style, involving board and organization members in renewing the company; (3) develop a persuader style to avoid rocking the boat
V. Recommendations: Develop pathfinder style, involve entire corporation in change process, establish open communications with board and consensus on what the board wants, and make personnel changes after thorough analysis
⭐ Key Takeaways
The client in OD is never a single individual or group but the relationship and interface between individuals and units within the system. An OD practitioner’s style can be classified based on emphasis on effectiveness and morale into five types: Stabilizer (low, low), Cheerleader (low effectiveness, high morale), Analyzer (high effectiveness, low morale), Persuader (moderate both), and Pathfinder (high both). The Pathfinder style is most ideal as it seeks high effectiveness through collaborative problem solving and member involvement. The practitioner-client relationship can exist in four modes (Apathetic, Gamesmanship, Charismatic, Consensus), with the Consensus mode being most conducive to successful OD. The practitioner must maintain power equalization, ensure key parties are involved, and model the values of openness, honesty, and collaboration they wish to see in the client system.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Who is the true client in OD consultation, and why is this distinction important?
- What are the five practitioner styles, and on which two dimensions are they based?
- Describe the four practitioner-client relationship modes identified by Eric H. Neilsen.
- What are the six essential processes for effective organization performance that the pathfinder practitioner focuses on?
- In the Grayson Chemical Company case, which practitioner style is recommended and why is it most appropriate?
📘 Lecture 12 — OD Practitioner Skills and Activities
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the skills, competencies, and knowledge required for effective Organization Development practice. It explores the core competencies needed by all OD practitioners, the specific abilities of consultants, the differences between internal and external consulting roles, the concept of marginality, emotional demands of the role, and how practitioners use knowledge and experience along a client-centered to consultant-centered continuum.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the competencies of effective OD practitioners, including two major projects defining OD skill sets. It details four basic skill areas: intrapersonal, interpersonal, general consultation, and OD theory. The lecture also examines six key practitioner skill areas, ten primary consultant abilities, the roles and differences between internal and external consultants, the concept of marginality, emotional intelligence demands of OD practice, and the continuum of knowledge use from client-centered to consultant-centered approaches.
📝 Lecture Summary
OD Practitioner Skills and Activities
Much of the literature about the competencies of an effective OD practitioner reveals a mixture of personality traits, experiences, knowledge, and skills presumed to lead to effective practice. Research on successful change practitioners yields attributes including diagnostic ability, basic knowledge of behavioral science techniques, empathy, knowledge of theories and methods within the consultant's own discipline, goal-setting ability, problem-solving ability, ability to perform self-assessment, ability to see things objectively, imagination, flexibility, honesty, consistency, and trust. Two ongoing projects are attempting to define and categorize the skills and knowledge required of OD practitioners. The first effort, updated annually by fifty well-known practitioners and researchers, has grown to 187 statements in nine areas of OD practice including entry, start-up, assessment and feedback, action planning, intervention, evaluation, adoption, separation, and general competencies. The second project, sponsored by the Organization Development and Change Division of the Academy of Management, seeks to develop a list of competencies to guide curriculum development in graduate OD programs. This project identifies foundation competencies oriented toward descriptions of an existing system, including knowledge from organization behavior, psychology, group dynamics, management and organization theory, research methods, and business practices, and core competencies aimed at how systems change over time, including knowledge of organization design, organization research, system dynamics, OD history, and theories and models for change.
Basic Skills and Knowledge for All OD Practitioners
Based on available studies, all OD practitioners should have the following basic skills and knowledge to be effective:
1. Intrapersonal skills. Despite the growing knowledge base, organization development is still a human craft. As the primary instrument of diagnosis and change, practitioners often must process complex, ambiguous information and make informed judgments. Practitioners must have the personal centering to know their own values, feelings, and purposes as well as the integrity to behave responsibly in a helping relationship. Because OD is a highly uncertain process requiring constant adjustment and innovation, practitioners must have active learning skills and a reasonable balance between their rational and emotional sides. Finally, OD practice can be highly stressful, so practitioners need to know how to manage their own stress.
🔑 Definition — Intrapersonal skills: The ability to know one's own values, feelings, and purposes, and to manage oneself effectively in the helping relationship, including stress management and maintaining integrity.
2. Interpersonal skills. Practitioners must create and maintain effective relationships with individuals and groups within the organization and help them gain the competence necessary to solve their own problems. Group dynamics, comparative cultural perspectives, and business functions are considered foundation knowledge, and managing the consulting process and facilitation as core skills. All of these interpersonal competencies promote effective helping relationships. Practitioners must establish trust and rapport with organization members so they can share pertinent information and work effectively together. To help members learn new skills and behaviors, practitioners must serve as concrete role models and provide counseling and coaching. Because the helping relationship is jointly determined, practitioners need to be able to negotiate an acceptable role and to manage changing expectations and demands.
3. General consultation skills. OD starts with diagnosing an organization or department. OD practitioners need to know how to carry out an effective diagnosis at least at a rudimentary level. They should know how to engage organization members in diagnosis, how to help them ask the right questions, and how to collect and analyze information. Practitioners should know basic diagnostic questions, some methods for gathering information such as interviews or surveys, and some techniques for analyzing it such as force-field analysis or statistical means and distributions. In addition to diagnosis, OD practitioners should know how to design and execute an intervention, define an action plan, gain commitment to the program, tailor the intervention to the situation, and use information about how the change is progressing to guide implementation.
4. Organization development theory. OD practitioners should have a general knowledge of organization development, including appreciation for planned change, the action research model, and contemporary approaches to managing change. They should be familiar with the range of available interventions and the need for evaluating and institutionalizing change programs. Perhaps most important is that OD practitioners should understand their own role in the emerging field of organization development, whether as an OD professional, a manager, or a specialist in a related area.
Key Skill Areas for Internal Practitioners (Gebelein's Framework)
The role of the OD practitioner is changing and becoming more complex. Ellen Fagenson and W. Warner Burke found that the most practiced OD skill or activity was team development, whereas the least employed was the integration of technology. OD practitioners of today are no longer just process facilitators but are expected to know something about strategy, structure, reward systems, corporate culture, leadership, human resource development, and the client organization's business. Susan Gebelein lists six key skill areas critical to the success of the internal practitioner:
- Leadership: Leaders keep members focused on key company values and on opportunities and need for improvement.
- Project Management: Involving all the right people and departments to keep the change program on track.
- Communication: Vital to communicate the key values to everyone in the organization.
- Problem-Solving: The real challenge is to implement a solution; focus constantly on the next set of problems.
- Interpersonal: Giving everybody in the organization the tools and confidence to be involved in the change process, including facilitating, building relationships, and process skills.
- Personal: The confidence to help the organization make tough decisions, introduce new techniques, try something new, and see if it works.
The OD practitioner's role is to help employees create their own solutions, systems, and concepts. When the practitioner uses these skills, the employees will work hard to make them succeed because they are the owners of the change programs.
Consultant's Abilities
Ten primary abilities are key to an OD consultant's effectiveness. Most can be learned, but individual differences in personality or basic temperament may make some easier to learn than others:
- The ability to tolerate ambiguity: Every organization is different, and what worked before may not work now; every OD effort starts from scratch.
- The ability to influence: Unless the OD consultant enjoys power and has some talent for persuasion, he or she is likely to succeed in only minor ways.
- The ability to confront difficult issues: Much OD work consists of exposing issues that organization members are reluctant to face.
- The ability to support and nurture others: Particularly important in times of conflict and stress, and just before and during a manager's first experience with team building.
- The ability to listen well and empathize: Especially important during interviews, in conflict situations, and when client stress is high.
- The ability to recognize one's feelings and intuition quickly: Important to distinguish one's own perceptions from those of the client and use these feelings as interventions when appropriate.
- The ability to conceptualize: Necessary to think and express in understandable words certain relationships such as cause-and-effect and if-then linkages within the systemic context of the client organization.
- The ability to discover and mobilize human energy: Both within oneself and within the client organization; interventions are most effective when they tap existing energy and provide direction for productive use.
- The ability to teach or to create learning opportunities: Should be utilized on the job, during meetings, and within the mainstream of the overall change effort.
- The ability to maintain a sense of humor: Useful for reducing tension; not taking oneself too seriously is critical for maintaining perspective.
Role of Organization Development Professionals: Internal vs. External
Organization development professionals have positions that are either internal or external to the organization. Internal consultants are members of the organization and often are located in the human resources department. They may perform the OD role exclusively or combine it with other tasks such as compensation practices, training, or labor relations. External consultants are not members of the client organization; they typically work for a consulting firm, a university, or themselves. Organizations generally hire external consultants to provide particular expertise that is unavailable internally and to bring a different and potentially more objective perspective.
During the entry process, internal consultants have clear advantages: ready access to clients, knowledge of organizational language, and insights about root causes of problems, saving time in identifying culture, informal practices, and sources of power. External consultants have the advantage of being able to select clients according to their own criteria. During diagnosis, internal consultants already know most organization members and enjoy basic rapport and trust, but external consultants often have higher status, allowing them to probe difficult issues and assess the organization more objectively. During intervention, both types must rely on valid information, free and informed choice, and internal commitment, but an internal consultant's strong ties may make them overly cautious. A promising approach is to include both as members of an internal-external consulting team, combining special expertise and objectivity with inside knowledge and acceptance.
🔑 Definition — Internal-external consulting team: A collaborative arrangement where both internal and external OD consultants work together, combining the external consultant's specialized expertise and objectivity with the internal consultant's organizational knowledge and acceptance.
Marginality
A promising line of research on the professional OD role centers on the issue of marginality. The marginal person is one who successfully straddles the boundary between two or more groups with differing goals, value systems, and behavior patterns. Evidence suggests that people who are good at taking marginal roles have personal qualities of low dogmatism, neutrality, open-mindedness, objectivity, flexibility, and adaptable information-processing ability. Individuals with marginal orientations are more likely to develop integrative decisions that reconcile viewpoints among opposing groups and remain neutral in controversial situations. For the OD consultant, being marginal means becoming involved enough to understand the client's feelings and perceptions yet distant enough to see them objectively.
There are two relevant boundaries: the activities boundary and the membership boundary. With respect to change activities, the consultant must help but not be directly involved. With respect to membership, the OD consultant is never quite in nor quite out — being a member means vested interest and lack of objectivity, while being totally removed means inability to sense and empathize. Being marginal is critical for both external and internal consultants. The major concern for internal OD practitioners is that they can never be a consultant to their own group or to any group within the same vertical path of the managerial hierarchy.
Emotional Demands
The OD practitioner role is emotionally demanding. Emotional intelligence refers to the ability to recognize and express emotions appropriately, to use emotions in thought and decisions, and to regulate emotion in oneself and in others. In tandem with traditional knowledge and skill, emotional intelligence affects and supplements rational thought; emotions help prioritize thinking by directing attention to important information not addressed in models and theories. Some researchers argue that emotional intelligence is as important as cognitive intelligence.
OD practitioners must relate to and help organization members adapt to resistance, commitment, and ambiguity, which raises emotions such as fear of failure or rejection. Ambiguity or denial of emotions can lead to inaccurate and untimely interventions. For example, a practitioner uncomfortable with conflict may intervene to diffuse conflict because of personal discomfort, not because the conflict is destructive, acting to address a personal need rather than to improve system effectiveness. Emotional intelligence increases with age and experience and can be developed through personal growth processes such as sensitivity training, counseling, and therapy.
🔑 Definition — Emotional intelligence: The ability to recognize and express emotions appropriately, to use emotions in thought and decisions, and to regulate emotion in oneself and in others, which is considered as important as cognitive intelligence for effective OD practice.
Use of Knowledge and Experience
The professional OD role has been described in terms of a continuum ranging from client-centered (using the client's knowledge and experience) to consultant-centered (using the consultant's knowledge and experience). Traditionally, OD consultants have worked at the client-centered end, relying mainly on sensitivity training, process consultation, and team building, remaining neutral and refusing to offer expert advice. The consultant would listen and reflect upon members' perceptions and ideas, helping clarify and interpret their communications and behaviors.
With the recent proliferation of OD interventions in structural, human resource management, and strategy areas, the limited definition of the professional OD role has expanded to include the consultant-centered end. In many newer approaches, the consultant may take on a modified role of expert, with the consent and collaboration of organization members. For example, in major structural redesign, the consultant might present basic concepts and ideas and then struggle jointly with managers to select an approach. This expertise, however, is always shared rather than imposed. The OD professional's role needs to be seen as falling along the entire continuum from client-centered to consultant-centered, with the consultant sometimes relying mainly on members' knowledge and at other times taking on the role of expert, withdrawing as managers gain more knowledge and experience.
💡 Why this matters: This continuum concept acknowledges that modern OD practice requires flexibility — practitioners must know when to facilitate client discovery and when to provide expert guidance, adapting their approach based on the organization's needs and the nature of the intervention.
⭐ Key Takeaways
All OD practitioners must possess four basic skill sets: intrapersonal skills (self-awareness and stress management), interpersonal skills (building trust, rapport, and helping relationships), general consultation skills (diagnosis and intervention design), and knowledge of OD theory. The ten consultant abilities, including tolerance for ambiguity, ability to influence, ability to confront difficult issues, and ability to maintain humor, form the core competencies for effective OD consulting. Internal and external consultants have distinct advantages and disadvantages at each stage of the change process, and combining them into internal-external consulting teams can leverage both sets of strengths while requiring strong team building and continuous feedback. The concept of marginality — straddling boundaries without being fully inside or outside — is critical for maintaining objectivity while remaining empathetic. Finally, emotional intelligence is as important as cognitive knowledge, and the use of knowledge ranges from client-centered facilitation to consultant-centered expertise, with the practitioner adapting along this continuum based on the situation.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four basic skill and knowledge areas that all OD practitioners should possess based on available studies?
- What are the six key skill areas critical to the success of internal OD practitioners according to Susan Gebelein?
- List five of the ten primary abilities key to an OD consultant's effectiveness and explain why each matters.
- What are the key differences between internal and external consultants during the entry, contracting, diagnosing, intervening, and evaluating stages of the change process?
- Explain the concept of marginality in OD practice and why it is critical for both internal and external consultants to maintain a marginal position.
📘 Lecture 13 — Professional Values
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the foundational values and ethical frameworks that guide Organization Development practice. It traces the evolution from traditional humanistic values rooted in sensitivity training to contemporary concerns with organizational effectiveness, and explores the ethical dilemmas practitioners face in balancing human needs with organizational demands.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers professional values in OD including their origins in sensitivity training, the spirit of inquiry and democratic values, the tension between freedom and constraint, the challenge of optimizing both human benefits and production objectives, value conflicts with external stakeholders, professional ethics, ethical guidelines, and five types of ethical dilemmas: misrepresentation, misuse of data, coercion, value and goal conflict, and technical ineptness.
📝 Lecture Summary
Professional Values
Values have played an important role in organization development from its beginning. Traditionally, OD professionals promoted a set of values under a humanistic framework, including a concern for inquiry and science, democracy and being helpful. They sought to build trust and collaboration; to create an open, problem-solving climate; and to increase the self-control of organization members. More recently, OD practitioners have extended those humanistic values to include a concern for improving organizational effectiveness (for example, to increase productivity or to reduce turnover) and performance (for example, to increase profitability). They have shown an increasing desire to optimize both human benefits and production objectives.
We can gain understanding of OD values by referring to sensitivity training. This method of education and change has a humanistic value orientation, the belief that it is worthwhile to have the opportunity throughout life to learn and develop personally toward full realization and actualization of individual potential. Another OD value from sensitivity training is that people's feelings are just as important a source of data for diagnosis and have as much implication for change as do facts or so-called hard data. Yet another OD value stemming from sensitivity training is that conflict, whether interpersonal or inter-group, should be brought to the surface and dealt with directly, rather than ignored, avoided, or manipulated.
When sensitivity training was at the height of its popularity, two main value systems considered were: a spirit of inquiry, and democracy. The spirit of inquiry comes from the values of science. Two parts are relevant: the hypothetical spirit – being tentative, checking on the validity of assumptions, and allowing for errors; and experimentation – putting ideas or assumptions to the test. The second main value system, the democratic value, has two elements: collaboration, and conflict resolution through rational means. The learning process in sensitivity training is collaborative, not a traditional authoritarian student-teacher relationship. By conflict resolution through rational means, it is meant that "there is a problem-solving orientation to conflict rather than the more traditional approaches based on bargains, power plays, suppression, or compromise."
💡 Why this matters: Understanding these foundational values helps practitioners recognize the ethical tension between treating employees humanely while also meeting organizational performance goals.
Freedom vs. Constraint
It is painfully obvious that most organizations treat their most valued resources – employees – as if they were expendable. If OD helps correct these imbalances, it is long overdue, but what about the organization? If it doesn't survive, there will be no jobs, no imbalances to correct. Of the two words represented by OD, practitioners have spent more time on development than on organization. They are equally important; however, if either is out of balance, the OD consultant's goal is to redress the imbalance.
OD's right goal grows from its proper setting. If the proper setting is organizations, then there is only one right goal for OD, i.e. to confront an issue that is the tension between freedom and constraint. There is always tension between the two – the autonomy of the individual and the requirements of the organization. It is practically impossible to determine the proper balance but, when either factor is obviously out of balance, the OD consultant's goal is to work toward reducing the heavier side.
Value Dilemmas
The joint values of humanizing organizations and improving their effectiveness have received widespread support. But in practice OD professionals face serious challenges in simultaneously pursuing greater humanism and organizational effectiveness. More practitioners experience situations where there is conflict between employees' needs for greater meaning and the organization's need for more effective and efficient use of its resources. For example, expensive capital equipment may run most efficiently if it is highly programmed and routinized, but people may not derive satisfaction from working with such technology. Should efficiency be maximized at the expense of people's satisfaction? Can technology be changed to make it more humanly satisfying while remaining efficient? What compromises are possible? These are the value dilemmas often faced when trying to optimize both human benefits and organizational effectiveness.
In addition to value issues within organizations, OD practitioners deal more with value conflicts with powerful outside groups. Organizations are open systems existing within increasingly turbulent environments. External groups often have different and competing values for judging the organization's effectiveness. For example, stockholders may judge the firm in terms of earnings per share, the government in terms of compliance with equal employment opportunity legislation, patients in terms of quality of care, and ecology groups in terms of hazardous waste disposal. Because organizations must rely on these external groups for resources and legitimacy, they cannot simply ignore these competing values.
Recent attempts to help firms manage external relationships suggest the need for new interventions and competence in OD. Practitioners must have not only social skills but also political skills. They must understand the distribution of power, conflicts of interest, and value dilemmas inherent in managing external relationships. Interventions promoting collaboration and system maintenance may be ineffective in this larger arena, especially when there are power and dominance relationships among organizations. Under those conditions, OD practitioners may need more power-oriented interventions, such as bargaining, coalition forming, and pressure tactics.
Professional Ethics
Ethical issues in OD are concerned with how practitioners perform their helping relationship with organization members. Inherent in any helping relationship is the potential for misconduct and client abuse. OD practitioners can let personal values stand in the way of good practice or use the power inherent in their professional role to abuse (often unintentionally) organization members.
Ethical Guidelines
To its credit, the field of OD always has shown concern for the ethical conduct of its practitioners. Statements of ethics governing OD practice have been sponsored by the Organization Development Institute, the American Society for Training & Development, and a consortium of professional associations in OD. The consortium jointly sponsored an ethical code derived from a large-scale project conducted at the Center for the Study of Ethics in the Professions at the Illinois Institute of Technology.
Ethical Dilemmas
Although adherence to statements of ethics helps prevent ethical problems, OD practitioners still encounter ethical dilemmas. Figure 17 is a process model explaining how ethical dilemmas can occur in OD. The antecedent conditions include an OD practitioner and a client system with different goals, values, needs, skills, and abilities. During the entry and contracting phase these differences may or may not be addressed. If the contracting process is incomplete, the subsequent intervention process or role episode is subject to role conflict and role ambiguity. Neither the client nor the OD practitioner is clear about respective responsibilities. The role conflict and ambiguity may produce five types of ethical dilemmas: misrepresentation, misuse of data, coercion, value and goal conflict, and technical ineptness.
Misrepresentation
Misrepresentation occurs when OD practitioners claim that an intervention will produce results that are unreasonable for the change program or the situation. The client can contribute by portraying inaccurate goals and needs. In either case, one or both parties are operating under false pretenses. For example, in "The Undercover Change Agent" case, an attempt was made to use laboratory training in an organization whose top management did not understand it and was not ready for it. The OD consultant sold T-groups as the intervention that would solve the organization's problems. After the president made a surprise visit, the consultant was fired because the nature and style of the T-group contradicted the president's concepts about leadership. To prevent misrepresentation, OD practitioners need to gain clarity about goals and explore openly with the client expected effects, relevance, and the practitioner's competence.
Misuse of Data
Misuse of data occurs when information gathered during the OD process is used punitively. Large amounts of information are obtained during the entry and diagnostic phases. Although most OD practitioners value openness and trust, it is important to be aware of how data will be used. It is a human tendency to use data to enhance a power position. Openness is one thing, but leaking inappropriate information can be harmful. To minimize misuse, practitioners should reach agreement up front about how data will be used, and review this agreement periodically.
Coercion
Coercion occurs when organization members are forced to participate in an OD intervention. People should have freedom to choose whether to participate. In team building, for example, team members should have the option of deciding not to become involved. Management should not decide unilaterally that team building is good for members. However, freedom to choose requires knowledge about OD, making it imperative for practitioners to educate clients about interventions before choices are made.
Coercion also poses ethical dilemmas for the helping relationship. Kelman pointed out that behavior change "inevitably involves some degree of manipulation and control, and at least an implicit imposition of the change agent's values." This places the practitioner on two horns of a dilemma: (1) any attempt to change is itself a manipulation, and (2) there exists no formula to structure a change situation so that manipulation can be totally absent. Kelman stressed freedom of choice, seeing any action that limits freedom of choice as ethically ambiguous. An effective way to resolve this dilemma is to make the change effort as open as possible, with free consent and knowledge of individuals involved.
The second facet of coercion involves dependency. Helping relationships invariably create dependency. A major goal in OD is to lessen clients' dependency on consultants. To resolve dependency issues, consultants can openly discuss how to handle the dependency problem, focus on problem finding rather than solutions, and change the client's expectation from being helped to managing the problem themselves.
Value and Goal Conflict
This ethical conflict occurs when the purpose of the change effort is not clear or when the client and practitioner disagree over how to achieve goals. The important practical issue is whether it is justifiable to withhold services unilaterally from an organization that disagrees with their values or methods. OD pioneer Gordon Lippitt suggested that assuming some kind of change will occur anyway, the consultant has a responsibility to guide change in the most constructive fashion possible. Argyris takes an even stronger stand, maintaining that professional OD practitioners' responsibilities to clients are comparable to those of lawyers or physicians who may not refuse to perform their services. He suggests providing "first aid" as long as it doesn't compromise the consultant's values.
Technical Ineptness
This final ethical dilemma occurs when OD practitioners try to implement interventions for which they are not skilled or when the client attempts a change for which it is not ready. Critical to success is selecting an appropriate intervention, which depends on careful diagnosis of the organization. In solving organizational problems, many OD consultants emphasize a favorite intervention or technique, such as team building, total quality management, or self-managed teams. They let their own values and beliefs dictate the change method. Technical ineptness also occurs when interventions do not align with the organization's ability to implement them.
🔑 Definition — Ethical Dilemmas: Situations in OD practice where practitioners face conflicts between different values, goals, or obligations, arising from incomplete contracting, role conflict, and role ambiguity between the practitioner and client system.
📐 Formula — Ethical Dilemma Model: Antecedent Conditions (different goals, values, needs, skills) → Entry & Contracting (incomplete) → Role Conflict & Role Ambiguity → Five Dilemmas (misrepresentation, misuse of data, coercion, value/goal conflict, technical ineptness)
📌 Example — The Undercover Change Agent: An OD consultant sold T-groups to an organization whose top management did not understand them. The president made a surprise visit and fired the consultant because the T-group's nature contradicted the president's leadership concepts. This illustrates misrepresentation — claiming an intervention would produce results unreasonable for the situation.
⭐ Key Takeaways
OD values have evolved from humanistic foundations in sensitivity training — emphasizing the spirit of inquiry, democracy, collaboration, and conflict resolution — to include organizational effectiveness and performance optimization. The central tension in OD is between individual freedom and organizational constraint, with the practitioner's goal being to redress imbalances. Ethical dilemmas arise from incomplete contracting and role ambiguity, producing five problems: misrepresentation, misuse of data, coercion, value/goal conflict, and technical ineptness. Practitioners must develop political skills to manage external stakeholder conflicts and power dynamics. The profession's ethical guidelines stress freedom of choice, open contracting, data confidentiality, competence, and managing dependency in the helping relationship.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five types of ethical dilemmas in OD as described in the process model?
- How did sensitivity training influence the core values of organization development?
- What is the "right goal" of OD according to the lecture, and what tension does it address?
- According to Kelman, what are the two horns of the dilemma regarding coercion in helping relationships?
- What did Argyris suggest about the responsibility of OD practitioners toward clients who hold different values?
📘 Lecture 14 — Entering and Contracting
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the initial steps of the Organization Development (OD) process: entering and contracting. It explains how OD practitioners and client organizations establish a collaborative relationship, clarify the nature of the problem to be addressed, and set the ground rules for the change effort. Understanding these foundational stages is critical because they shape the success of all subsequent diagnostic, intervention, and evaluation phases.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and importance of entering and contracting in OD, including how they vary in complexity depending on whether the practitioner is internal or external. It then details the three main activities involved in entering an OD relationship: clarifying the organizational issue, determining the relevant client system or team members, and selecting an appropriate OD practitioner. The lecture explains the contracting process, focusing on mutual expectations, time and resource commitments, and ground rules for collaboration. A detailed application example (Charity Medical Center) illustrates how these concepts work in practice.