π Lecture 08 β Action Research Model
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Action Research Model, a foundational framework in Organization Development that emphasizes a cyclical, collaborative process of data gathering, diagnosis, action, and evaluation. It details the seven key phases of this model, explains its distinction from steps, and explores contemporary adaptations including appreciative inquiry and participatory approaches that place greater emphasis on member involvement and positive organizational conversations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and cyclical nature of the action research model, its seven main phases from entry through evaluation, the concept of termination in OD work, the distinction between phases and steps, and contemporary adaptations including increased member involvement (participatory action research) and the appreciative inquiry model which focuses on an organization's strengths rather than its problems.
π Lecture Summary
Action Research Model
The action research model focuses on planned change as a cyclical process in which initial research about the organization provides information to guide subsequent action. Results of the action are then assessed to provide further information to guide further action, and so on. This iterative cycle involves considerable collaboration among organization members and OD practitioners, placing heavy emphasis on data gathering and diagnosis prior to action planning and implementation, as well as careful evaluation of results after action is taken.
Action research is traditionally aimed both at helping specific organizations implement planned change and at developing more general knowledge that can be applied to other change settings. The main steps involved are entry, contracting, diagnosis, feedback, planning change, intervention, and evaluation.
π Definition β Action Research Model: A planned change process that uses a cyclical process of research and action, where initial data gathering guides action, and results are assessed to inform further action.
1. Entry (Problem Identification)
This stage usually begins when a key executive in the organization or someone with power and influence senses that the organization has one or more problems that might be solved with the help of an OD practitioner. Contact between the consultant and client initiates the entry phase. After contact, the consultant and client explore the possibilities of a working relationship. During this process, the consultant assesses:
- The probability of relating with the client
- The motivation and values of the client
- The client's readiness for change
- The extent of resources available
- Potential leverage points of change
2. Contracting (Consultation with a Behavioral Science Expert)
During the initial contact, the OD practitioner and the client carefully assess each other. The practitioner has their own normative, developmental theory or frame of reference and must be conscious of those assumptions and values. Sharing them with the client from the beginning establishes an open and collaborative atmosphere.
Unlike other types of contracts, the OD contract states three critical areas:
- What each expects to get from the relationship
- How much time each will invest, when, and at what cost
- The ground rules under which the parties will operate
3. Diagnosis (Data Gathering and Preliminary Diagnosis)
This step is usually completed by the OD practitioner, often in conjunction with organization members. It involves gathering appropriate information and analyzing it to determine the underlying causes of organizational problems. The four basic methods of gathering data are interviews, process observation, questionnaires, and organizational performance data (unfortunately, often overlooked). One approach to diagnosis begins with observation, proceeds to a semi-structured interview, and concludes with a questionnaire to measure precisely the problems identified by the earlier steps. When gathering diagnostic information, OD practitioners may influence members from whom they are collecting data. In OD, "every action on the part of the consultant constitutes an intervention" that will have some effect on the organization.
4. Feedback (Feedback to a Key Client or Group)
Because action research is a collaborative activity, the diagnostic data are fed back to the client, usually in a group or work-team meeting. The feedback step helps members determine the strengths and weaknesses of the organization or department under study. The consultant provides the client with all relevant and useful data while protecting confidential sources of information and may even withhold data at times. Defining what is relevant and useful involves consideration of privacy and ethics as well as judgment about whether the group is ready for the information.
At this point, members discuss the feedback and explore with the OD practitioner whether they want to work on identified problems. A close interrelationship exists among data gathering, feedback, and diagnosis because the consultant summarizes the basic data and presents it for validation and further diagnosis. The action research process is very different from the doctor-patient model, in which the consultant comes in, makes a diagnosis, and prescribes a solution. Failure to establish a common frame of reference may lead to faulty diagnosis or a communications gap whereby the client is unwilling to believe the diagnosis or accept the prescription.
A feedback session generally has three steps:
- The consultant provides a summary of the data collected and some preliminary analysis
- A general discussion where questions of clarification are raised and answered
- Time devoted to interpretation, where changes may be made in the consultant's analysis
Case Example: An OD practitioner conducted interviews with a senior management group asking four questions about strengths, weaknesses, support for an off-site meeting, and meeting objectives.
Strengths identified:
- Senior management highly experienced in business (7 mentions)
- Commitment of work force (5)
- Good people throughout (3)
- Last four years' success (3)
- Technological superior & market leader (3)
Weaknesses identified:
- Marketing & Servicing System (6)
- Do not establish priorities (3)
- Organizational priorities always secondary to individual managers (3)
- Lack of management depth (3)
- Little planning (3)
Objectives for off-site meeting:
- Agree on regional structure (7)
- Set financial objectives for next two years (6)
- List of things to do & stop doing (4)
- Hear from GM about team notions, ideas, expectations (4)
5. Planning Change (Joint Action Planning)
The OD practitioner and the client members jointly agree on further actions to be taken. This is the beginning of the moving process (described in Lewin's change model), as the organization decides how best to reach a different quasi-stationary equilibrium. At this stage, the specific action depends on the culture, technology, and environment of the organization; the diagnosis of the problem; and the time and expense of the intervention. The purposes of this planning phase are to generate alternative steps for responding to problems identified in the diagnosis and to decide on the order of steps to take.
π‘ Why this matters: Good diagnosis determines the intervention β the quality of diagnosis directly influences the effectiveness of the planned change actions.
6. Intervention (Action)
This stage involves the actual change from one organizational state to another. It may include installing new methods and procedures, reorganizing structures and work designs, and reinforcing new behaviors. Such actions typically require a transition period as the organization moves from the present to a desired future state.
Examples of interventions at the individual level: job redesign and enrichment, training and management development, changes in quality of working life, management by objectives, and career development. Examples of interventions at the group level: team building, installation of autonomous work groups or quality control circles.
7. Evaluation (Data Gathering After Action)
Because action research is a cyclical process, data must be gathered after the action has been taken to measure and determine the effects of the action and to feed the results back to the organization. This may lead to re-diagnosis and new action.
Termination of the OD Effort
An organization has a constant need for periodic, objective diagnostic check-ups by external consultants. Termination is not an applicable phase for internal OD practitioners. Although they may conclude specific programs and projects with their clients, they should not terminate the relationship. A primary role of internal practitioners is to serve as guardians of the new culture.
Phases not Steps
Phases are a more appropriate term than steps for describing the flow of events in OD work. Steps imply discrete actions, while phases connote a cycle of changes. Although useful for understanding OD practice to conceive of distinct phases, in actual practice they blend, overlap, and do not follow one from the other. For example, when collecting information for diagnostic purposes, an intervention is occurring simultaneously β when the OD practitioner asks questions, they are intervening.
Phases is appropriate also because of the cyclical nature of the OD process. As the process continues, new or undisclosed data are discovered, affecting organization members and creating additional information for diagnosis.
Contemporary Adaptations of Action Research
The action research model underlies most current approaches to planned change. Recent trends include movement from smaller subunits to total systems and communities, where action research is more complex and political and must be coordinated across multiple change processes with diverse stakeholders. Action research is also applied increasingly in international settings, requiring tailoring to fit cultural assumptions.
Two key adaptations:
First: Increased member involvement. Contemporary applications have substantially increased the degree of member involvement in the change process. Referred to as "participatory action research," "action learning," "action science," "self-design," or "appreciative inquiry," this approach emphasizes the need for organization members to learn firsthand about planned change. Both parties are "co-learners" in diagnosing the organization, designing changes, and implementing and assessing them. Neither party dominates the change process.
Second: Integration of an interpretive or social constructionist approach. Called "appreciative inquiry," this model proposes that words and conversations determine what is important and meaningful in organizational life. It suggests that the most important change an organization can make is to begin conversations about what the organization is doing right, rather than focusing on problems and gaps.
π Definition β Appreciative Inquiry: A model of planned change that focuses on an organization's strengths and positive attributes, where members understand and describe the organization when it is working at its best, and that knowledge is applied to create a powerful and guiding image of what the organization could be.
The five steps of appreciative inquiry are:
- Discover: Members choose to look for what is working well
- Dream: Gather data about the "best of what is" and find stories presenting an exciting picture of the future
- Design: Develop "possibility propositions" β statements bridging current best practices with ideal possibilities
- Destiny: Bring stakeholders together to construct a vision of the future and devise action plans (creating "what should be")
- Implementation: Make changes, assess results, and make adjustments toward the vision
β Key Takeaways
The action research model is the foundational framework for OD practice, operating as a cyclical process of entry, contracting, diagnosis, feedback, planning, intervention, and evaluation β with phases that blend together rather than discrete steps. A critical distinction is that the model is collaborative, unlike the doctor-patient model, requiring shared frames of reference between consultant and client for successful change. Contemporary adaptations emphasize participatory action research where both parties are co-learners, and appreciative inquiry which shifts focus from organizational problems to organizational strengths and positive conversations. The cyclical nature means termination is never truly complete, especially for internal practitioners who serve as guardians of the new culture, and every diagnostic question constitutes an intervention in itself.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the seven main phases of the action research model, and why is "phases" more appropriate than "steps"?
- How does the action research model differ from the doctor-patient model of consulting?
- What three critical areas must an OD contract state, and why is establishing a common frame of reference important?
- What are the five steps of appreciative inquiry, and how does it differ from traditional problem-focused action research?
- Why is termination not an applicable phase for internal OD practitioners, and what role do they serve instead?
π Lecture 09 β General Model of Planned Change
π Overview: This lecture presents a comprehensive general framework for planned change in organizations, building on Lewin's model, action research, and contemporary adaptations. It details the four core activities of the OD processβentering/contracting, diagnosing, planning/implementing, and evaluating/institutionalizingβand explores how planned change varies across situations based on magnitude, degree of organization, and cultural context. Understanding this model is critical for effectively managing organizational change in diverse settings.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the general model of planned change with four sequential yet overlapping activities: entering and contracting, diagnosing, planning and implementing change, and evaluating and institutionalizing change. It then examines three key dimensions along which planned change varies: magnitude of change (incremental vs. quantum), degree of organization (over organized vs. under organized), and domestic vs. international settings. Finally, it provides a critique of planned change in terms of both its conceptualization and practice, concluding with a detailed case analysis of The Dim Lighting Company.
π Lecture Summary
Entering and Contracting
The first set of activities in planned change concerns entering and contracting. These events help managers decide whether to engage further in a planned change program and commit resources. Entering involves gathering initial data to understand the organization's problems or positive opportunities. Once collected, these problems or opportunities are discussed to develop a contract or agreement spelling out future change activities, resources to be committed, and how OD practitioners and organization members will be involved. Organizations often do not get beyond this stage due to disagreements about the need for change, resource constraints, or more feasible alternatives. In nontraditional and international settings, this process must be sensitive to the context.
π Definition β Contract: An agreement that spells out future change activities, the resources committed, and how OD practitioners and organization members will be involved. π‘ Why this matters: The entering and contracting stage sets the foundation for the entire change effort; if poorly handled, the change process may fail before it truly begins.
Diagnosing
In this stage, the client system is carefully studied to understand organizational problems (including causes and consequences) or to identify positive attributes. Diagnosis includes choosing an appropriate model for understanding the organization and gathering, analyzing, and feeding back information. Diagnostic models explore three levels of activities: organization issues (most complex, involving the total system), group-level issues (department and group effectiveness), and individual-level issues (job design). Data can be gathered through interviews, observations, survey instruments, or archival sources like meeting minutes and organization charts. Organization members, often with an OD practitioner, jointly discuss data and implications for change.
π Definition β Client system: The organization or part of the organization being studied in the diagnosis stage. π‘ Why this matters: Diagnosis is one of the most important OD activities because accurate problem identification prevents costly and ineffective interventions later.
Planning and Implementing Change
In this stage, members and practitioners jointly plan and implement OD interventions to achieve the organization's vision or goals. Design criteria include the organization's readiness for change, current change capability, culture and power distributions, and the change agent's skills. There are four major types of interventions:
- Human process interventions at individual, group, and total system levels.
- Interventions modifying structure and technology.
- Human resource interventions improving member performance and wellness.
- Strategic interventions managing external relationships and internal structure/process to support business strategy.
Implementing interventions involves managing the change process: motivating change, creating a desired future vision, developing political support, managing the transition, and sustaining momentum.
π Definition β OD interventions: Activities designed to improve the organization's functioning and achieve its vision or goals.
Evaluating and Institutionalizing Change
The final stage evaluates the effects of the intervention and manages institutionalization of successful change programs. Feedback about the intervention's results tells members whether changes should be continued, modified, or suspended. Institutionalizing successful changes involves reinforcing them through feedback, rewards, and training. This stage demonstrates how traditional planned change activities (entry, survey feedback, change planning) can combine with contemporary methods (large-group interventions, high participation).
π Definition β Institutionalization: The process of reinforcing successful changes through feedback, rewards, and training to make them lasting.
Different Types of Planned Change
Planned change varies enormously depending on the client's needs, the change agent's skills, and the organization's context. Three key dimensions contrast these differences: the magnitude of organizational change, the degree to which the client system is organized, and whether the setting is domestic or international.
Magnitude of Change
Planned change falls along a continuum from incremental changes (fine-tuning the organization) to quantum changes (fundamentally altering operations). Incremental changes involve limited dimensions/levels, occur within existing strategy/structure/culture, and aim to improve the status quo. Quantum changes alter how the organization operates, involve multiple dimensions (structure, culture, reward systems, etc.) and multiple levels (top management through individual jobs). Traditional OD focused on incremental change (e.g., improving communication in a work team). In recent years, OD increasingly addresses quantum change driven by competitiveness and uncertainty β this is more complex, extensive, and long-term, typically driven from the top with change agents helping create a vision and manage the transition. Quantum change may not be developmental; firms may simply downsize or tighten controls without developing capacity. However, the OD approach to quantum change seeks to make organizations more competitive by developing human resources and promoting flexibility.
π Example: Organizations in the 1960s-70s used planned change mainly for incremental change (fine-tuning bureaucratic structures). In contrast, modern firms like General Electric, Kimberly-Clark, and Hewlett-Packard use OD for quantum change, transforming from control-oriented bureaucracies to high-involvement organizations capable of continuous self-improvement.
Degree of Organization
Planned change varies depending on whether the organization is over organized or under organized. In over organized situations (mechanistic bureaucracies), leadership, job designs, structure, and policies are too rigid. Communication is suppressed, conflicts avoided, and employees apathetic. Planned change here aims to loosen constraints: changes in leadership, job design, and structure liberate suppressed energy, increase information flow, and promote conflict resolution. The OD practitioner shares leadership, encourages open communication, and maintains flexibility.
In under organized situations, there is too little constraint for effective performance. Leadership, structure, and policies are poorly defined; communication is fragmented; job responsibilities are ambiguous. These are found in product development, project management, and community development. Planned change here aims to increase organization through four modified steps:
- Identification: Identify relevant people/groups to involve in the change program.
- Convention: Bring relevant people together to begin organizing for task performance.
- Organization: Create organizing mechanisms (new leadership positions, communication channels, plans/policies).
- Evaluation: Assess outcomes and signal need for adjustments.
In under organized situations, the consultant develops a well-defined, possibly autocratic leadership role in the early stages, with clearly defined and tightly specified consulting relationships.
Domestic vs. International Settings
Developed in western societies, the action research model reflects values of equality, involvement, and short-term time horizons. In other cultures (e.g., Asian countries) that are more hierarchical, status conscious, less open to discussing personal issues, and more concerned with saving "face," traditional OD steps become problematic. The cultural values guiding OD practice in the U.S. include tolerance for ambiguity, equality, individuality, and achievement motives. When OD is applied outside North America/Europe, the action research process must be adapted to fit the cultural context β for example, diagnosis can involve only senior managers, be directed from the top, or use internal consultants and documents instead of face-to-face interviews. To succeed, OD practitioners must develop awareness of their own cultural biases, be open to other perspectives, be fluent in host country values/assumptions, and understand the economic/political context. Most adopt a "cultural guide" (often an organization member) to navigate cultural, operational, and political nuances.
π Definition β Cultural guide: A member of the organization who helps the OD practitioner navigate the cultural, operational, and political nuances of change in that society.
Critique of Planned Change
Despite refinements, planned change models and practice remain in a formative stage with considerable room for improvement.
Conceptualization Problems: Porras and Robertson argued that planned change should be guided by information about (1) organizational features that can change, (2) intended outcomes, (3) causal mechanisms, and (4) contingencies. They noted the key to change is individual behavior change, but causal mechanisms are poorly understood. Additional deficiencies include: lack of knowledge about how stages differ across situations (contingency thinking needed), the portrayal of change as rationally controlled when it actually has a chaotic quality with shifting goals and unexpected events, and poor understanding of the relationship between planned change and organizational performance/effectiveness.
Practice Problems: OD practitioners often specialize in specific techniques (team building, TQM, large-group interventions) leading to myopia β they favor particular methods and ignore more appropriate strategies. Some organizations skip careful diagnosis and rely on preconceptions, hiring consultants for the wrong problems. Organizations demanding quick fixes often receive prepackaged programs that fail to gain support or produce advertised results. Many organizations fail to recognize the systemic nature of change, believing intervention in one part suffices when supporting changes elsewhere are needed (e.g., at GTE of California, employee involvement only succeeded after reward systems were redesigned to support cross-functional collaboration).
π Example: At GTE of California, the positive benefits of an employee involvement program did not appear until the organization redesigned its reward system to support cross-functional collaboration necessary to solve complex problems.
Case: The Dim Lighting Co.
The Dim Lighting Company, a subsidiary producing electric lamps with 2,000 workers, is run by General Manager Jim West. Last year, profit margins dropped 15%, and West feels pressure for a good year to protect his career advancement. Robert Spinks, Director of R&D, has submitted a budget request for a major research project on micro-miniaturization of lighting sources requiring $250,000/year for two years plus $300,000 to begin production, with a 70% chance of success and $1 million net cash flow by year three. Corporate headquarters praised the idea but is reluctant to spend. At a budget meeting, the accountant (Carol Preston) and production manager (Bill Boswell) oppose the project due to high risk and immediate bottom-line needs, while marketing (Pete Newell) supports it. Spinks may resign if the project is rejected. West must decide between immediate profitability and long-term innovation, while managing conflicting departmental interests and his own career concerns.
β Key Takeaways
The general model of planned change consists of four interconnected activities β entering/contracting, diagnosing, planning/implementing, and evaluating/institutionalizing β that are not strictly linear but involve overlap and feedback. Planned change varies dramatically across three dimensions: incremental vs. quantum change (magnitude), over organized vs. under organized situations (degree of organization), and domestic vs. international settings (cultural context). Critics have identified significant deficiencies in both the conceptualization (lack of contingency thinking, overly rational portrayal, poor performance measurement) and practice (technique myopia, diagnostic shortcuts, quick fixes, failure to recognize systemic change) of planned change. The Dim Lighting case illustrates how organizational politics, conflicting departmental interests, resource constraints, and personal career concerns complicate the entering and contracting stage.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four basic activities in the general model of planned change, and why are they described as overlapping rather than strictly linear?
- How does planned change differ between over organized and under organized situations in terms of goals and consultant behavior?
- What are the four major types of OD interventions, and what criteria guide the design of interventions?
- According to Porras and Robertson's critique, what four types of information should guide planned change activities, and why is individual behavior change considered key?
- In the Dim Lighting case, what are the macro and micro problems, and what alternatives does the case analysis suggest for resolving the budget conflict?
π Lecture 10 β The Organization Development Practitioner: A closer look at OD practitioners
π Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive examination of who organization development practitioners are, including the three main categories of practitioners and the distinctions between internal and external practitioners. It matters because understanding the roles, styles, and relationship-building strategies of OD practitioners is essential for anyone seeking to implement effective organizational change.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining who qualifies as an OD practitioner across three categories: OD professionals, specialists in related fields, and managers practicing OD. It then examines the differences between external and internal practitioners, including their respective advantages and disadvantages. The lecture also covers the external-internal practitioner team approach, the practitioner style model and its components, and finally discusses how to develop a trust relationship with the client system.
π Lecture Summary
Who is the Organization Development Practitioner?
The term organization development practitioner refers to at least three sets of people. The most obvious group are those specializing in OD as a profession, who may be internal or external consultants offering professional services to organization clients including top managers, functional department heads, and staff groups. OD professionals traditionally share a common set of humanistic values promoting open communications, employee involvement, and personal growth and development. They tend to have common training, skills, and experience in social processes of organizations such as group dynamics, decision making, and communications. In recent years, OD professionals have expanded those traditional values and skill sets to include more concern for organizational effectiveness, competitiveness, and bottom-line results.
Second, the term OD practitioner applies to people specializing in fields related to OD, such as reward systems, organization design, total quality, information technology, and business strategy. These content-oriented fields increasingly are becoming integrated with OD's process orientation, particularly as OD projects have become more comprehensive. Professionals in these related fields gain experience and competence in OD mainly through working with OD professionals on large-scale projects and through attending OD training sessions. They practice OD when they apply their special competence within an OD-like process or when they apply OD competence to their own specialties.
Third, the term OD practitioner applies to the increasing number of managers and administrators who have gained competence in OD and apply it to their own work areas. Studies argue that OD applied by managers rather than OD professionals is growing rapidly, suggesting that the faster pace of change affecting organizations today is highlighting the centrality of the manager in managing change. Consequently, OD must become a general management skill. Managers tend to gain competence in OD through interacting with OD professionals in actual change programs, supplemented with more formal OD training. In practice, the distinctions among the three sets of OD practitioners are blurring as cross-training and integration produce a more comprehensive and complex kind of OD practitioner.
External and Internal Practitioners
In every large-scale planned change program, some person or group is usually designated to lead the change; sometimes it is the OD practitioner. The practitioner is the change leader, the person leading or guiding the process of change in an organization. Internal practitioners are already members of the organization, either managers practicing OD with their work groups or OD specialists from the human resources or organization development department. External practitioners are brought in from outside the organization as OD specialists and are often referred to as consultants. Both the use of external and internal practitioners have advantages and disadvantages.
The OD practitioners who are specialists, whether from within or outside the organization, are professionals who have specialized and trained in OD and related areas such as social sciences, interpersonal communications, decision making, and organization behavior. These specialists, often referred to as OD consultants, have a more formal and involved process when they enter the client system than managers who are doing OD with their work group.
The External Practitioner
The external practitioner is someone not previously associated with the client system. Coming from the outside, the external practitioner sees things from a different viewpoint and from a position of objectivity. Because they are invited into the organization, they have increased leverage (the degree of influence and status within the client system) and greater freedom of operation than internal practitioners. Research evidence suggests that top managers view external practitioners as having a more positive role in large-scale change programs than internal practitioners.
Since external practitioners are not part of the organization, they are less in awe of the power wielded by various organization members and do not depend upon the organization for raises, approval, or promotions. They tend to have a more independent attitude about risk-taking and confrontations with the client system. The disadvantages of external practitioners result from the same factors as the advantage β outsiders are generally unfamiliar with the organization system, its technology, culture, communication networks, and formal or informal power systems.
The Internal Practitioner
The internal practitioner is already a member of the organization: a top executive, an organization member who initiates change in his or her work group, or a member of the human resources or organization development department. Many large organizations have established offices specifically responsible for helping the organization implement change programs. Internal practitioners have certain advantages: they are familiar with the organization's culture and norms, know the power structure and how to apply leverage, are already known to employees, and have a personal interest in seeing the organization succeed.
The position of an internal practitioner also has disadvantages. These may include a lack of specialized skills needed for organization development, lack of objectivity (they may accept the organizational system as given and accommodate change tactics to management's needs), and being known to the workforce can work against them. Finally, the internal practitioner may not have the necessary power and authority, as they are sometimes in a remote staff position reporting to a mid-level manager.
The External-Internal Practitioner Team
The implementation of a large-scale change program is almost impossible without the involvement of all levels and elements of the organization. One approach uses a team formed of an external practitioner working directly with an internal practitioner, known as the external-internal practitioner team. This is probably the most effective approach. The partners bring complementary resources to the team; each has advantages and strengths that offset the disadvantages and weaknesses of the other.
The external practitioner brings expertise, objectivity, and new insights to organization problems. The internal practitioner brings detailed knowledge of organization issues and norms, a long-time acquaintance with members, and an awareness of system strengths and weaknesses. The collaborative relationship serves as a model for the rest of the organization, embodying qualities such as trust, respect, honesty, confrontation, and collaboration. The team makes it possible to divide the workload and share in diagnosis, planning, and strategy. Another reason for using this team approach is to achieve greater continuity over the entire OD program, as the internal practitioner provides a continuing point of contact whenever problems or questions arise.
π‘ Why this matters: The external-internal team approach is considered the most effective because it combines the advantages of both types of practitioners while minimizing their respective disadvantages.
Practitioner Style Model
There is often a gap between the practitioner's and the client's understandings about OD and change. The practitioner needs to assess the degree of this gap because a relationship is possible only if the practitioner can be flexible enough to understand where the client is and help the client learn about the OD change process. The practitioner brings certain knowledge, skills, values, and experience to the situation, while the client system has its own values and expectations for the practitioner.
The practitioner's task and the scope, difficulty, and complexity of the changes to be implemented affect the relationship. Finally, the target organization's readiness for change, level of resistance, and culture influence the practitioner's style and the change approaches that may be successful. The OD practitioner needs to involve organization members at all levels and convince them to "buy in" on the change program.
Developing a Trust Relationship
The development of openness and trust between practitioner and client is an essential aspect of the OD program because trust is necessary for cooperation and communication. When there is no trust, people tend to be dishonest, evasive, and not authentic with one another, and communication is often inaccurate, distorted, or incomplete. There are several basic responses that the practitioner may use in the communication process aimed at developing a trust relationship:
- Questions β "How do you see the organization?"
- Applied expertise (advising) β "One possible intervention is team building."
- Reflection β "It sounds like you would like to see a participative form of leadership."
- Interpretation β "From your description, inter-team conflict could be the problem."
- Self-disclosure β "I've felt discouraged myself when my ideas were rejected."
- Silence β Say nothing, let the client sort out his or her thoughts.
How these basic responses are used is important in developing the practitioner-client relationship. In general, the more balanced the practitioner's use of these responses and the more open the range of responses, the higher the level of trust. Some practitioners rely almost exclusively on questions without sharing their own ideas and feelings, which tends to create a one-way flow of information. Other practitioners rely heavily on advising responses, which may tend to develop a dependency relationship.
During the first several contacts with the client system, the practitioner should reflect on questions such as: What is the attitude of the client system toward OD? What is the gut-level meaning of the client's problem? What are the possibilities that an OD program will alleviate the problem? What is the practitioner's potential impact on the system? Once these questions are answered, the practitioner can decide whether to continue the change efforts or to discontinue and terminate the relationship.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical things to remember are that there are three distinct categories of OD practitioners β OD professionals, specialists in related fields, and managers β and these distinctions are increasingly blurring. External practitioners bring objectivity and leverage but lack insider knowledge, while internal practitioners bring cultural familiarity but may lack objectivity and power; the external-internal team approach combines the best of both. The practitioner style model emphasizes the need to assess the gap between practitioner and client understanding, and developing trust through balanced use of communication responses (questions, advising, reflection, interpretation, self-disclosure, and silence) is essential for effective OD practice.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three sets of people to whom the term "organization development practitioner" refers?
- What are the key advantages and disadvantages of external practitioners compared to internal practitioners?
- Why is the external-internal practitioner team considered the most effective approach for implementing large-scale change programs?
- What are the six basic responses a practitioner can use in the communication process to develop a trust relationship?
- What questions should a practitioner reflect upon during the first several contacts with the client system?