📝 Lecture Summary
Measurement: Providing Useful Implementation and Evaluation Feedback
This involves two activities: selecting the appropriate variables and designing good measures. The variables measured in OD evaluation should derive from the theory or conceptual model underlying the intervention. The model should incorporate key features of the intervention and expected results.
Selecting Variables
The general diagnostic models described earlier meet these criteria. For example, the job-level diagnostic model proposes several major features of work: task variety, feedback, and autonomy. The theory argues that high levels of these elements result in high levels of work quality and satisfaction. The strength of this relationship varies with the degree of employee growth need—the higher the need, the more job enrichment produces positive results.
The job-level diagnostic model suggests measurement variables for implementation and evaluation feedback. Implementation can be assessed by determining how many job descriptions include more responsibility or how many members received cross-training. Evaluation of immediate and long-term impact includes measures of employee performance and satisfaction over time.
Measuring both intervention variables and outcome variables is necessary. Unfortunately, OD has tended to measure only outcome variables while neglecting intervention variables. It is generally assumed the intervention has been implemented, but this must be empirically determined—it cannot simply be assumed. Implementation feedback serves this purpose, guiding the implementation process and helping interpret outcome data.
Outcome measures are ambiguous without knowledge of how well the intervention was implemented. A negligible change in performance and satisfaction could mean: (1) the wrong intervention was chosen, (2) the correct intervention was not implemented effectively, or (3) the wrong variables were measured.
The choice of outcome variables should be dictated by intervention theory, which specifies expected results. Outcome measures include job satisfaction, intrinsic motivation, organizational commitment, absenteeism, turnover, and productivity.
Historically, OD assessment focused on attitudinal outcomes (like job satisfaction) while neglecting hard measures like performance. Increasingly, managers call for behavioral measures of OD outcomes—specifically behaviors involving joining, remaining, and producing at work.
💡 Why this matters: Without measuring both intervention and outcome variables, it is impossible to determine whether an intervention failed because it was wrong, poorly implemented, or poorly measured.
Designing Good Measures
Each measurement method has advantages and disadvantages linked to whether a measurement is operationally defined, reliable, and valid.
1. Operational Definition
A good measure is operationally defined—it specifies the empirical data needed, how they will be collected, and how they will be converted from data to information.
Macy and Mirvis developed operational definitions for behavioral outcomes (see Table 9). They consist of specific computational rules for constructing measures. Most behaviors are reported as rates adjusted for the number of employees and possible incidents. These adjustments allow comparison across different situations and time periods. These definitions apply to both industrial and service organizations, though modifications may be needed.
🔑 Definition — Operational Definition: Specifies the empirical data needed, how they will be collected, and most importantly, how they will be converted from data to information.
Operational definitions are important because they provide precise guidelines about what characteristics to observe and how to use them. They tell OD practitioners and the client system exactly how diagnostic, intervention, and outcome variables will be measured.
2. Reliability
Reliability concerns the extent to which a measure represents the "true" value of a variable—how accurately the operational definition translates data into information.
For example, counting cars leaving an assembly line as a measure of plant productivity is highly reliable. However, asking people to rate job satisfaction on a scale of 1 to 5 has considerable room for variation. Events like arguments with supervisors, accidents, or rewards can sway responses. The individual's "true" satisfaction score is difficult to discern from one question—the measure lacks reliability.
🔑 Definition — Reliability: The extent to which a measure represents the "true" value of a variable; how accurately the operational definition translates data into information.
OD practitioners can improve reliability in four ways:
First, rigorously and operationally define chosen variables. Clear operational definitions contribute to reliability by explicitly describing how collected data will be converted into information.
Second, use multiple methods to measure a particular variable. Using questionnaires, interviews, observation, and unobtrusive measures can improve reliability. Because each method contains inherent biases, several methods can triangulate on dimensions of organizational problems. If independent measures converge or show consistent results, the dimensions are likely diagnosed accurately.
Third, use multiple items to measure the same variable on a questionnaire. For example, the Job Diagnostic Survey measures "autonomy" as the average of respondents' answers to three questions (measured on a seven-point scale):
- "The job permits me to decide on my own how to go about doing the work."
- "The job denies me any chance to use my personal initiative or judgment in carrying out the work." (Reverse scored)
- "The job gives me considerable opportunity for independence and freedom in how I do the work."
By asking more than one question, the survey increases accuracy. Statistical analyses called psychometric tests are available for assessing reliability of perceptual measures.
Fourth, use standardized instruments. A growing number of standardized questionnaires are available for measuring OD intervention and outcome variables.
Table 9: Behavioral Outcomes for Measuring OD Interventions
| Behavioral Measure | Computational Formula |
|---|---|
| Absenteeism rate (monthly) | ∑ Absence days / (Average workforce size × working days) |
| Tardiness rate (monthly) | ∑ Tardiness incidents / (Average workforce size × working days) |
| Turnover rate (monthly) | ∑ Turnover incidents / Average workforce size |
| Internal stability rate (monthly) | ∑ Internal movement incidents / Average workforce size |
| Strike rate (yearly) | ∑ Striking Workers × Strike days / (Average workforce size × working days) |
| Accident rate (yearly) | ∑ Accidents, illnesses × 200,000 / Total yearly hours worked |
| Grievance rate (yearly) – Plant | ∑ Grievance incidents / Average workforce size |
| Grievance rate (yearly) – Individual | ∑ Aggrieved individuals / (Average workforce size × working days) |
| Productivity – Total | Output of goods or services (units or $) / Direct and/or indirect labor (hours or $) |
| Productivity – Below standard | Actual versus engineered standard |
| Productivity – Below budget | Actual versus budgeted standard |
| Productivity – Variance | Actual versus budgeted variance |
| Productivity – Per employee | Output / Average workforce size |
| Quality – Total | Scrap + customer returns + Rework – Recoveries ($, units or hours) |
| Quality – Below standard | Actual versus engineered standard |
| Quality – Below budget | Actual versus budgeted standard |
| Quality – Variance | Actual versus budgeted variance |
| Quality – Per employee | Output / Average workforce size |
| Downtime | Labor ($) + Repair costs or dollar value of replaced equipment ($) |
| Inventory, supply and material usage | Variance (actual versus standard utilization) ($) |
3. Validity
Validity concerns the extent to which a measure actually reflects the variable it is intended to reflect.
For example, the number of cars leaving an assembly line might be a reliable measure of plant productivity but may not be valid—cars may have been produced at unacceptably high cost. Because the number does not account for cost, it is not a completely valid measure.
🔑 Definition — Validity: The extent to which a measure actually reflects the variable it is intended to reflect.
OD practitioners can increase validity in several ways:
First, ask colleagues and clients if a proposed measure actually represents a particular variable. This is called face validity or content validity. If experts and clients agree the measure reflects the variable, confidence increases.
Second, use multiple measures of the same variable to make preliminary assessments of criterion validity or convergent validity. If several different measures of the same variable correlate highly (especially if validated in prior research), confidence increases.
A special case called discriminant validity exists when the proposed measure does not correlate with measures it should not correlate with. For example, there is no good reason for daily assembly-line productivity to correlate with daily air temperature—the lack of correlation indicates the measure is measuring productivity, not some other variable.
Third, predictive validity is demonstrated when the variable accurately forecasts another variable over time. For example, a measure of team cohesion is valid if it accurately predicts improvements in team performance in the future.
📌 Example: If team cohesion measured today predicts better team performance six months later, the measure has predictive validity.
It is difficult to establish validity until a measure has been used. OD practitioners should make heavy use of content validity processes and use measures that have already been validated. Presenting proposed measures to colleagues and clients prior to measurement builds ownership and commitment and improves the likelihood the client system will find the data meaningful.
Research Design
OD practitioners must make choices about how to design the evaluation to achieve valid results. The key issue is internal validity—whether the intervention produced the observed results. The secondary question of whether the intervention would work similarly in other situations is external validity.
🔑 Definition — Internal Validity: Whether the intervention did in fact produce the observed results.
External validity is irrelevant without first establishing internal validity. Unless managers have confidence that outcomes result from the intervention, they have no rational basis for decisions about accountability and resource allocation.
Assessing internal validity involves testing a hypothesis—that specific organizational changes lead to certain outcomes. This means alternative hypotheses or rival explanations must be rejected. For example, if job enrichment appears to increase performance, other explanations like new technology, improved raw materials, or new employees must be eliminated.
OD interventions have features making evaluation difficult: they are complex with several interrelated changes, they are long-term projects (the longer the time period, the greater the chance other factors emerge), and they are applied to existing work units rather than randomized groups.
Given these problems, practitioners use quasi-experimental research designs. These are not as rigorous as randomized experimental designs but allow evaluators to rule out many rival explanations. Designs with three features are particularly powerful:
-
Longitudinal measurement: Measuring results repeatedly over relatively long time periods. Data collection should start before change implementation and continue for a period reasonable for producing expected results.
-
Comparison unit: Comparing results in the intervention situation with those in another situation where no change occurred. Most organizations include similar work units for comparison.
-
Statistical analysis: Using statistical methods to rule out the possibility that results are caused by random error or chance.
Table 10: Quasi-Experimental Research Design
Monthly Absenteeism (%)
| Group | SEP | OCT | NOV | DEC | JAN | FEB | MAR | APR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Intervention group | 2.1 | 5.3 | 5.0 | 5.1 | Start of intervention → | 4.6 | 4.0 | 3.9 |
| Comparison group | 2.5 | 2.6 | 2.4 | 2.5 | 2.6 | 2.4 | 2.5 |
The intervention aims to reduce absenteeism. Measures are taken from company records for both groups—similar yet geographically separate subsidiaries. The intervention plant shows a marked decrease in absenteeism following intervention, while the control plant shows comparable levels in both periods. Statistical analyses suggest the downward shift was not attributable to chance variation.
Quasi-experimental designs with longitudinal data, comparison groups, and statistical analysis permit reasonable assessments. Repeated measures from company records are unobtrusive measures that do not interact with the intervention and affect results. More obtrusive measures (questionnaires, interviews) are reactive and can sensitize people to the intervention.
Multiple measures of intervention and outcome variables should be applied to minimize measurement-intervention interactions. Obtrusive measures could be used sparingly (once before and once after), while unobtrusive measures (like behavioral outcomes in Table 9) can be used repeatedly.
Types of Change in Perceptual Measures
Considerable research identifies three types of change that occur when using self-report, perceptual measures:
Alpha Change: A difference that occurs along some relatively stable dimension of reality. This is typically a comparative measure before and after an intervention. For example, comparative measures of perceived employee discretion showing an increase after job enrichment—if this represents alpha change, the program actually increased perceptions of discretion. Similarly, if comparative measures of trust among team members increase after teambuilding, we conclude the intervention made a difference.
🔑 Definition — Alpha Change: A difference that occurs along some relatively stable dimension of reality; a simple before-and-after change on the same measurement scale.
Beta Change: When a decrease in trust occurs—or no change at all. One study showed no measurable increase in trust after teambuilding, but change may have occurred differently. As a result of the intervention, team members may view trust very differently—their basis for judging trust changed, rather than a simple increase or decrease along a stable continuum.
🔑 Definition — Beta Change: A change in the respondent's basis for judging the variable; the measurement scale is recalibrated.
📌 Example: Before-and-after measures of perceived employee discretion can decrease after job enrichment. The first measure may reflect belief about moving around and talking to fellow workers in the immediate work area. During implementation, the employee learns ability to move around is not limited to the immediate area. At the second measurement, using this recalibrated understanding, the employee rates discretion lower than before.
Gamma Change: Fundamentally redefining the measure as a result of an OD intervention. The framework within which a phenomenon is viewed changes. For example, after teambuilding, team members might conclude trust was not relevant—they believe the gain in clarity and responsibility was the relevant factor, and improvement had nothing to do with trust.
🔑 Definition — Gamma Change: A fundamental redefinition of the measure itself; the framework for viewing the phenomenon changes.
📌 Example: The term "discretion" may originally refer to ability to move about the department and interact with others. After job enrichment, discretion might be defined as ability to make decisions about work rules, schedules, and productivity levels. The intervention changed how discretion is perceived and evaluated.
These three types apply to perceptual measures. When other than alpha changes occur, interpreting measurement changes becomes difficult. Potent OD interventions may produce beta and gamma changes, complicating interpretations. The distinctions suggest heavy reliance on questionnaires should be balanced by using other measures like interviews and unobtrusive records.
Case: The Farm Bank
The Farm Bank is one of the state's oldest banks, located in a regional marketing center, specializing in farm loans. President Frank Swain, 62, has been with the bank for many years. The bank is organized into six departments, each headed by a senior vice president—all stable and conservative.
The Management Information System
Two years ago, Swain decided to modernize operations by designing and installing a comprehensive Management Information System (MIS). The primary goal was to improve internal operations by supplying information on a more expedited basis, decreasing customer service time. The system was also to provide economic data for top management planning. Swain selected Al Hassler, 58, to head this department.
After installation, Hassler hired Valerie Wyatt, a young MBA with strong systems analysis background. She was the only woman, considerably younger than other managers, and the only MBA.
Since installation, the MIS printed thousands of pages of operating information—weekly, monthly, and quarterly summaries including cost of productions, projected labor costs, overhead costs, and projected earnings.
The MIS Survey
Swain noticed little improvement in management operations—most older vice presidents made decisions as before. Swain asked Wyatt to conduct a survey to evaluate the system's impact. Wyatt sent questionnaires to department heads and branch managers.
Survey results showed:
- 93% did not regularly use reports because information was not in useful form
- 76% reported printouts were hard to interpret
- 72% stated they received more data than wanted
- 57% reported finding errors and inaccuracies
- 87% still kept manual records because they did not fully trust the MIS
The Meeting
Wyatt gave the report to Hassler, who said: "You've done a good job here, Val. But now that we have the system operating, I don't think we should upset the apple cart... Let's just keep this to ourselves... I'm sure Frank wouldn't want to hear this kind of stuff."
Wyatt returned to her office feeling uncomfortable, wondering what to do.
Case Solution
I. Problems A. Macro:
- Client system unprepared for change
- Client system unfamiliar with and unprepared for MIS
B. Micro:
- Top-down approach (Swain's) excluded staff from decision and preparation
- Survey should have preceded, not followed, MIS
- Hassler not assertive enough to keep Swain informed
- MIS particulars need changing (limit info, change format)
- Wyatt charged by Swain to make survey but told by Hassler not to give report
II. Causes
- Conservative nature of firm (and age of staff)
- Lack of education regarding MIS
- Lack of planning regarding MIS functions for managers and firm
- Hassler more interested in personal security than fulfilling his purpose
III. Systems Affected
- Structural – Chain of command prohibited Wyatt from improving MIS
- Technical – MIS needs new form and limitations not being carried out
- Behavioral – Wyatt's fulfillment restricted; other staff's expectations frustrated; Swain's hopes unfulfilled; Hassler not fulfilling role
- Managerial – Hassler uncomfortable about upward communication; Swain may have intimidated subordinates
- Goals and values – Excellence and improvement not valued by most managers except possibly Wyatt
IV. Alternatives
- Wyatt could convince Hassler it's in his best interest to show Swain results
- Wyatt could go along with Hassler's inaction
- Wyatt could go around Hassler and tell Swain
V. Recommendations Wyatt needs to submit the report to Swain since he assigned the survey. She needs to explain tactfully to Hassler the importance of giving Swain the report. Once submitted, The Farm Bank needs an integrated strategy involving MIS users to identify specific problems and corrective steps. Hassler needs to be involved in making changes along with Wyatt.
⭐ Key Takeaways
For OD evaluation to be meaningful, both intervention and outcome variables must be measured—never assume an intervention was implemented without empirical verification. Good measures require operational definitions, reliability (consistency of measurement), and validity (measuring what is intended), which can be improved through multiple methods, multiple items, and standardized instruments. Quasi-experimental designs with longitudinal measurement, comparison groups, and statistical analysis provide the most defensible way to establish internal validity in real organizational settings. Perceptual measures are subject to alpha, beta, and gamma changes, requiring careful interpretation and the use of unobtrusive measures alongside questionnaires. The Farm Bank case demonstrates that even well-intentioned interventions fail without proper diagnosis, stakeholder involvement, and honest evaluation feedback.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three criteria for a good measure, and what does each mean in practice?
- How can OD practitioners improve the reliability of their measures? List and explain all four ways.
- What is the difference between alpha, beta, and gamma change in perceptual measures? Give an example of each.
- What three features make quasi-experimental research designs powerful for assessing OD interventions, and why is each important?
- What were the five key findings from the Farm Bank MIS survey, and what do they reveal about the failure of the intervention?
📘 Lecture 27 — Evaluating and Institutionalizing Organization Development Interventions
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how OD interventions become permanent parts of an organization's normal functioning through institutionalization. It presents a comprehensive framework identifying organizational and intervention characteristics, institutionalization processes, and indicators that determine the degree to which change programs persist over time.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the concept of institutionalizing interventions within the context of Lewin's three-stage change model (unfreezing, moving, refreezing). It presents an institutionalization framework that includes organization characteristics (congruence, stability of environment and technology, unionization), intervention characteristics (goal specificity, programmability, level of change target, internal support, sponsorship), five institutionalization processes (socialization, commitment, reward allocation, diffusion, sensing and calibration), and five indicators of institutionalization (knowledge, performance, preferences, normative consensus, value consensus).
📝 Lecture Summary
Institutionalizing interventions
Institutionalization refers to making changes a permanent part of the organization's normal functioning. According to Lewin's change model, change occurs in three stages: unfreezing, moving, and refreezing. Institutionalizing an OD intervention concerns the refreezing stage — it involves the long-term persistence of organizational changes. Such changes are not dependent on any one person but exist as part of the culture of an organization, meaning numerous others share norms about the appropriateness of the changes.
💡 Why this matters: Rapidly changing environments have challenged the utility of the institutionalization concept, with consultants advising to "change constantly." However, change itself has become the focus of institutionalization in interventions like total quality management, organizational learning, integrated strategic change, and self-design interventions, all aimed at enhancing the organization's capability for change.
Institutionalization Framework
Figure 37 presents a framework identifying two key antecedents — organization characteristics and intervention characteristics — that affect different institutionalization processes operating in organizations. These processes, in turn, affect various indicators of institutionalization. The model also shows that organization characteristics can influence intervention characteristics; for example, organizations having powerful unions may have trouble gaining internal support for OD interventions.
Organization Characteristics
Three key dimensions of an organization can affect intervention characteristics and institutionalization processes:
- Congruence: This is the degree to which an intervention is perceived as being in harmony with the organization's managerial philosophy, strategy, structure, current environment, and other changes taking place. When an intervention is congruent with these dimensions, the probability of institutionalization improves because it facilitates gaining member commitment and diffusion to wider organizational segments.
🔑 Definition — Congruence: The degree to which an intervention is perceived as being in harmony with the organization's managerial philosophy, strategy, and structure; its current environment; and other changes taking place.
📌 Example: Many OD interventions promote employee participation and growth. When applied in highly bureaucratic organizations with formalized structures and autocratic managerial styles, participative interventions are not perceived as congruent with the organization's managerial philosophy.
- Stability of environment and technology: This involves the degree to which the organization's environment and technology are changing. Unless the change target is buffered from these changes or unless the changes are dealt with directly by the change program, it may be difficult to achieve long-term intervention stability.
📌 Example: Decreased demand for the firm's products or services can lead to reductions in personnel, changing the composition of groups involved in the intervention. Conversely, increased product demand can curtail institutionalization by bringing new members on board faster than they can be socialized effectively.
- Unionization: Diffusion of interventions may be more difficult in unionized settings, especially if the changes affect union contract issues such as salary, fringe benefits, job design, and employee flexibility. However, unions can be a powerful force for promoting change, particularly when a good relationship exists between union and management.
📌 Example: A rigid union contract can make it difficult to merge several job classifications into one, as might be required to increase task variety in a job enrichment program.
Intervention characteristics
Five major features of OD interventions can affect institutionalization processes:
- Goal specificity: This involves the extent to which intervention goals are specific rather than broad. Specificity of goals helps direct socializing activities (e.g., training and orienting new members) to particular behaviors required to implement the intervention and helps operationalize new behaviors so rewards can be linked clearly to them.
📌 Example: An intervention aimed only at increasing product quality is likely to be more focused and readily put into operation than a change program intended to improve quality, quantity, safety, absenteeism, and employee development simultaneously.
- Programmability: This involves the degree to which the changes can be programmed or the extent to which different intervention characteristics can be specified clearly in advance to enable socialization, commitment, and reward allocation.
📌 Example: Job enrichment specifies three targets of change: employee discretion, task variety, and feedback. The change program can be planned and designed to promote those specific features.
- Level of change target: This concerns the extent to which the change target is the total organization, rather than a department or small work group. Each level has facilitators and inhibitors of persistence. Departmental and group changes are susceptible to countervailing forces from others in the organization, which can reduce diffusion and lower impact on organization effectiveness.
💡 Why this matters: Targeting the intervention to wider segments can help or hinder persistence. A shared belief about the intervention's value can be a powerful incentive to maintain the change, but targeting the larger system can also inhibit institutionalization if the intervention becomes mired in political resistance because of the "not invented here" syndrome or powerful constituencies opposing it.
- Internal support: This refers to the degree to which there is an internal support system to guide the change process. Internal support, typically provided by an internal consultant, can gain commitment for the changes and help organization members implement them. External consultants can also provide support, especially on a temporary basis during early implementation stages.
📌 Example: In many interventions aimed at implementing high-involvement organizations, both external and internal consultants provide change support. The external consultant typically brings expertise on organizational design and trains members to implement the design. The internal consultant generally helps members relate to other organizational units, resolve conflicts, and legitimize change activities within the organization.
- Sponsorship: This concerns the presence of a powerful sponsor who can initiate, allocate, and legitimize resources for the intervention. Sponsors must come from levels high enough to control appropriate resources and must have the visibility and power to nurture the intervention and see that it remains viable.
📌 Example: There are many examples of OD interventions that persisted for several years and then collapsed abruptly when the sponsor, usually a top administrator, left the organization. There are also numerous examples of middle managers withdrawing support for interventions because top management did not include them in the change program.
Institutionalization Processes
Five institutionalization processes directly affect the degree to which OD interventions are institutionalized:
- Socialization: This concerns the transmission of information about beliefs, preferences, norms, and values with respect to the intervention. Because implementation of OD interventions generally involves considerable learning and experimentation, a continual process of socialization is necessary to promote persistence of the change program.
📌 Example: Employee involvement programs often include initial transmission of information about the intervention, as well as retraining of existing participants and training of new members. Such processes are intended to promote persistence of the program as both new behaviors are learned and new members are introduced.
- Commitment: This binds people to behaviors associated with the intervention. It includes initial commitment to the program, as well as recommitment over time. Opportunities for commitment should allow people to select the necessary behaviors freely, explicitly, and publicly. These conditions favor high commitment and can promote stability of the new behaviors.
📌 Example: In many early employee involvement programs, attention was directed at gaining workers' commitment to such programs. Unfortunately, middle managers were often ignored, and considerable management resistance to the interventions resulted.
- Reward allocation: This involves linking rewards to the new behaviors required by an intervention. Organizational rewards can enhance the persistence of interventions in at least two ways. First, a combination of intrinsic rewards (internal rewards from opportunities for challenge, development, and accomplishment) and extrinsic rewards (such as money) can reinforce new behaviors. Second, new behaviors will persist to the extent that rewards are perceived as equitable by employees.
📌 Example: Many employee involvement programs fail to persist because employees feel that their increased contributions to organizational improvements are unfairly rewarded. This is especially true for interventions relying exclusively on intrinsic rewards. People argue that an intervention that provides opportunities for intrinsic rewards also should provide greater pay or extrinsic rewards for higher levels of contribution.
- Diffusion: This refers to the process of transferring interventions from one system to another. Diffusion facilitates institutionalization by providing a wider organizational base to support the new behaviors. Many interventions fail to persist because they run counter to the values and norms of the larger organization.
💡 Why this matters: Diffusion of the intervention to other organizational units reduces counter-implementation force. It tends to lock in behaviors by providing normative consensus from other parts of the organization. Moreover, the act of transmitting institutionalized behaviors to other systems reinforces commitment to the changes.
- Sensing and calibration: This involves detecting deviations from desired intervention behaviors and taking corrective action. Institutionalized behaviors invariably encounter destabilizing forces such as changes in the environment, new technologies, and pressures from other departments to nullify changes. Organizations must have some sensing mechanism to detect variation and take corrective actions.
📌 Example: If a high level of job discretion associated with a job enrichment intervention does not persist, information about this problem might initiate corrective actions such as renewed attempts to socialize people or to gain commitment to the intervention.
Indicators of Institutionalization
Institutionalization is not an all-or-nothing concept but reflects degrees of persistence of an intervention. Five indicators indicate the degree of institutionalization:
- Knowledge: This involves the extent to which organization members have knowledge of the behaviors associated with an intervention. It concerns whether members know enough to perform the behaviors and to recognize the consequences of that performance.
📌 Example: Job enrichment includes a number of new behaviors, such as performing a greater variety of tasks, analyzing information about task performance, and making decisions about work methods and plans.
- Performance: This is concerned with the degree to which intervention behaviors are actually performed. It may be measured by counting the proportion of relevant people performing the behaviors or the frequency with which new behaviors are performed.
📌 Example: 60 percent of the employees in a particular work unit might be performing the job enrichment behaviors described above. In assessing frequency, it is important to account for different variations of the same essential behavior.
- Preferences: This involves the degree to which organization members privately accept the organizational changes, as opposed to acceptance based primarily on organizational sanctions or group pressures. Private acceptance usually is reflected in people's positive attitudes toward the changes.
📌 Example: A questionnaire assessing members' perceptions of a job enrichment program might show that most employees have a strong positive attitude toward making decisions, analyzing feedback, and performing a variety of tasks.
- Normative consensus: This focuses on the extent to which people agree about the appropriateness of the organizational changes. This indicator reflects how fully changes have become part of the normative structure of the organization.
📌 Example: A job enrichment program would become institutionalized to the extent that employees support it and see it as appropriate to organizational functioning.
- Value consensus: This is concerned with social consensus on values relevant to the organizational changes. Values are beliefs about how people ought or ought not to behave — they are abstractions from more specific norms.
📌 Example: Job enrichment is based on values promoting employee self-control and responsibility. Different behaviors associated with job enrichment, such as making decisions and performing a variety of tasks, would persist to the extent that employees widely share values of self-control and responsibility.
These five indicators follow a specific developmental order: knowledge → performance → preferences → norms → values. People must first understand new behaviors before they can perform them effectively. Such performance generates rewards and punishments, which affect people's preferences. As many individuals come to prefer the changes, normative consensus develops. Finally, if there is normative agreement reflecting a particular set of values, over time there should be value consensus. An OD intervention is fully institutionalized only when all five factors are present.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Institutionalization is the process of making OD changes permanent through refreezing, ensuring they become part of organizational culture rather than dependent on any single person. The degree of institutionalization depends on three organizational characteristics (congruence, stability of environment/technology, unionization) and five intervention characteristics (goal specificity, programmability, level of change target, internal support, sponsorship). Five institutionalization processes — socialization, commitment, reward allocation, diffusion, and sensing/calibration — directly affect persistence, with reward allocation being particularly critical as both intrinsic and extrinsic rewards must be perceived as equitable. The five indicators of institutionalization follow a developmental sequence (knowledge → performance → preferences → norms → values), and full institutionalization requires all five to be present. Students must remember that institutionalization is a matter of degree rather than an all-or-nothing state, and that modern OD practice focuses on institutionalizing the capacity for change itself rather than static changes.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three stages of Lewin's change model, and where does institutionalization fit?
- What are the five intervention characteristics that affect institutionalization processes, and how does goal specificity differ from programmability?
- Explain the five institutionalization processes — which one involves detecting deviations from desired behaviors and taking corrective action?
- What is the developmental order of the five indicators of institutionalization, and why does the presence of value consensus automatically imply the presence of all previous indicators?
- How can reward allocation both help and hinder the persistence of OD interventions, particularly when relying exclusively on intrinsic rewards?
📘 Lecture 28 — Process Interventions: Interpersonal and Group Process Approaches
📖 Overview: This lecture focuses on process interventions, a core OD skill used to help work groups become more effective by increasing their awareness of how they operate and interact. It covers four key types of interventions—T-groups, Process Consultation, Third-party Intervention, and Team Building—with detailed exploration of T-groups and Process Consultation, including communication analysis and the Johari Window model.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and purpose of process interventions, then introduces four types: T-groups (including goals and application stages), Process Consultation (covering group processes like communication, functional roles, problem-solving, norms, and leadership), the Johari Window model for understanding communication at overt and covert levels, and the concepts of disclosure and feedback for improving interpersonal effectiveness.
📝 Lecture Summary
Process Interventions: Interpersonal and Group Process Approaches
Process interventions are OD skills used by practitioners to help work groups become more effective. The purpose is to help the group become more aware of its own processes—the way it operates and how members work together—and use this knowledge to develop its own problem-solving ability. The manager practicing process intervention observes individuals and teams, helps them diagnose and solve their own problems by asking questions, focusing attention on how they work together, teaching, providing resources, and listening, rather than telling them how to solve problems.
The four types of interventions related to interpersonal relationships and group dynamics are: T-group, Process consultation, Third-party intervention, and Team building.
1. T-Groups
Sensitivity training, or the T-group, is an early forerunner of modern OD interventions, though its direct use in OD has lessened. T-groups can help OD practitioners become more aware of how others perceive them and increase their effectiveness. They also help organization members learn how their behaviors affect others.
What Are the Goals? T-groups provide members with experiential learning about group dynamics, leadership, and interpersonal relations. A basic T-group consists of ten to fifteen strangers meeting with a professional trainer. Modifications have moved in two directions:
- Intrapersonal focus (encounter/personal-growth groups) – generally outside OD boundaries.
- Group focus using T-group techniques to explore dynamics within intact work groups – leading to team building.
Six overall objectives common to most T-groups:
- Increased understanding, insight, and self-awareness about one's own behavior and its impact on others.
- Increased understanding and sensitivity about the behavior of others, including interpretation of verbal and nonverbal clues.
- Better understanding of group and inter-group processes (facilitating and inhibiting factors).
- Increased diagnostic skills in interpersonal and inter-group situations.
- Increased ability to transform learning into action.
- Improvement in individuals' ability to analyze their own interpersonal behavior and help achieve more effective relationships.
Application Stages In a typical unstructured strangers T-group, participants who do not know each other meet. The trainer makes a brief, ambiguous statement and lapses into silence, creating a leadership and agenda dilemma. The group must work out its own methods. Individual behaviors become the "here-and-now" basic data for learning. As appropriate, the trainer makes an "intervention" —an observation about group behavior. The primary emphasis is on the here-and-now experience, with openness and leveling in a supportive environment.
2. Process Consultation
Process consultation (PC) is a general framework for carrying out helping relationships. It is oriented to helping managers, employees, and groups assess and improve processes like communication, interpersonal relations, decision making, and task performance. Schein argues that effective consultants and managers should be good helpers.
🔑 Definition — Process Consultation: "the creation of a relationship that permits the client to perceive, understand, and act on the process events that occur in (her/his) internal and external environment in order to improve the situation as defined by the client."
The process consultant does not offer expert solutions (doctor-patient model) but works to develop relationships, observe groups, help diagnose how tasks are carried out, and help members learn to be more effective. PC is a more general approach than team building, which focuses explicitly on helping groups perform tasks. Team building consists of process consultation plus task-oriented interventions.
Group Process Process consultation deals with five important interpersonal and group processes:
- Communications
- The functional roles of group members
- Ways the group solves problems and makes decisions
- Group norms development
- The use of leadership and authority
Communications The process consultant analyzes communication at both overt and covert levels.
At the overt level, issues involve who talks to whom, for how long, and how often. Methods include keeping a time log, noting who talks and who interrupts. Descriptive feedback (not evaluative) is given. Body language and other nonverbal behavior are also informative—e.g., folded arms and leaning backward indicate blocking out messages, while leaning forward indicates involvement.
Techniques for analyzing communication:
- Observe: How often and how long does each member talk? Record on paper.
- Identify: Who are the most influential listeners? Notice eye contact.
- Interruptions: Who interrupts whom? Is there a pattern?
At the covert level, double messages occur—saying one thing but meaning another. This is described using the Johari Window.
🔑 Definition — Johari Window: A model describing communication and interpersonal awareness, consisting of four cells:
- Cell 1 (Open/Public): Known to self and others
- Cell 2 (Hidden/Closed): Known to self but concealed from others
- Cell 3 (Blind): Unknown to self but communicated clearly to others (e.g., saying "I'm not angry" while slamming a fist)
- Cell 4 (Unknown): Unknown to both self and others
💡 Why this matters: The goal is to enlarge Cell 1 (the public area) by reducing Cell 2 through openness and Cell 3 through feedback.
Disclosure and Feedback of Johari Window Movement along vertical and horizontal dimensions enables individuals to change interpersonal styles by increasing communication in the public/shared area.
- Disclosure (vertical movement): Reducing the closed area by behaving less defensively, becoming more open, trusting, and risk-taking. This involves open disclosure of one's feelings and candid feedback to others.
- Feedback (horizontal movement): Reducing the blind area by having others give information or feedback about our behavior. This requires willingness to invite and accept such feedback.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Process interventions help work groups become more aware of their own processes and develop problem-solving ability. T-groups provide experiential learning about group dynamics, leadership, and interpersonal relations, with the trainer intervening by making observations about here-and-now behavior. Process Consultation is a philosophy of helping relationships where the consultant helps groups diagnose and improve processes like communication without offering expert solutions. The Johari Window is a critical tool for understanding communication at overt and covert levels, where enlarging the open area through disclosure and feedback is essential for effective interpersonal relationships. Poor communication is identified as the most important problem preventing organizational effectiveness.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four types of interventions related to interpersonal relationships and group dynamics in process interventions?
- What are the six overall objectives common to most T-groups?
- How does Process Consultation differ from the doctor-patient model of consulting?
- What are the four cells of the Johari Window, and what does each represent?
- How can a manager use observation, identification, and interruption analysis to improve group communication?