π Lecture 29 β Interpersonal and Group Process Approaches
π Overview: This lecture explores how process consultants can help groups function more effectively by understanding interpersonal dynamics, member roles, decision-making processes, and group norms. It emphasizes the consultant's role in facilitating group self-diagnosis rather than providing expert solutions, making it essential for organization development practitioners who work with teams.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture examines functional roles of group members including task-related and group-maintenance activities, group problem solving and decision making processes with examples of how premature rejection affects participation, group norms and growth patterns, leadership and authority dynamics, basic process interventions at individual and group levels, when process consultation is appropriate, and research findings on its effectiveness.
π Lecture Summary
Functional Roles of Group Members
The process consultant must be keenly aware of the different roles individual members take on in a group. Both upon entering and while remaining in a group, the individual must determine a self-identity, influence, and power that will satisfy personal needs while working to accomplish group goals. Preoccupation with individual needs or power struggles can reduce the effectiveness of a group severely, and unless the individual can expose and share those personal needs to some degree, the group is unlikely to be productive. Therefore, the process consultant must help the group confront and work through these needs. Emotions are facts, but frequently they are regarded as side issues to be avoided. Whenever an individual, usually the leader, says to the group, "Let's stick with the facts," it can be a sign that the emotional needs of group members are not being satisfied and are being disregarded as irrelevant.
Two other functions need to be performed if a group is to be effective: (1) task-related activities, such as giving and seeking information and elaborating, coordinating, and evaluating activities; and (2) group-maintenance actions, directed toward holding the group together as a cohesive team, including encouraging, harmonizing, compromising, setting standards, and observing. Most ineffective groups perform little group maintenance, and this is a primary reason for bringing in a process consultant.
The process consultant can help by suggesting that some part of each meeting be reserved for examining these functions and periodically assessing the feelings of the group's members. As Schein points out, the basic purpose of the process consultant is not to take on the role of expert but to help the group share in its own diagnosis and do a better job in learning to diagnose its own processes. It is important that the process consultant encourage the group not only to allocate time for diagnosis but to take the lead itself in trying to articulate and understand its own processes. Otherwise, the group may default and become dependent on the supposed expert.
π Definition β Process Consultant: An individual who helps groups understand and improve their own interpersonal and group processes, focusing on facilitating the group's self-diagnosis rather than providing expert solutions.
Group Problem Solving and Decision Making
To be effective, a group must be able to identify problems, examine alternatives, and make decisions. The first part of this process is the most important. Groups often fail to distinguish between problems (either task-related or interpersonal) and symptoms. Once the group identifies the problem, a process consultant can help the group analyze its approach, restrain the group from reacting too quickly and making a premature diagnosis, or suggest additional options.
π Example: A consultant processed a three-hour taped meeting and discovered that premature rejection of a suggestion severely retarded the group's process. After one member's suggestion was quickly rejected by the manager, he repeated it several times over the next hour, each time receiving quick rejection. During the second hour, this member became quite negative, opposing most other ideas. Toward the end of the second hour, he brought up his proposal again, and it was thoroughly discussed and finally rejected for reasons he accepted. During the third hour, this person became one of the most productive members of the group. It was not until his first suggestion had been thoroughly discussed (even though finally rejected) that he became a truly constructive member.
Once the problem has been identified, a decision must be made. One way is to ignore a suggestion (someone offers another before the first is discussed). A second method is decision by authority (giving power to the person in authority). Sometimes decisions are made by minority rule (the leader arriving at a decision and turning for agreement to several people who will comply). Silence is frequently regarded as consent. Decisions also can be made by majority rule, consensus, or unanimous consent. The process consultant can help the group understand how it makes its decisions and the consequences of each decision process, as well as help diagnose which type may be most effective in a given situation.
Group Norms and Growth
When a group works together over time, it develops group norms or standards of behavior about what is good or bad, allowed or forbidden, right or wrong. There may be an explicit norm that group members are free to express their ideas and feelings, while the implicit norm is that one does not contradict the ideas or suggestions of certain group members (usually the more powerful ones). The process consultant can be very helpful in assisting the group to understand and articulate its own norms and to determine whether those norms are helpful or dysfunctional. By understanding its norms and recognizing which ones are helpful, the group can grow and deal realistically with its environment, make optimum use of its own resources, and learn from its own experiences.
π Definition β Group Norms: Standards of behavior developed by a group over time that define what is considered good or bad, allowed or forbidden, right or wrong within that group.
Leadership and Authority
A process consultant needs to understand processes of leadership and how different leadership styles can help or hinder a group's functioning. The consultant can help the leader adjust his or her style to fit the situation. An important step is for the leader to gain a better understanding of his or her own behavior and the group's reaction to that behavior. It also is important that the leader become aware of alternative behaviors. For example, after gaining a better understanding of his or her assumptions about human behavior, the leader may do a better job of testing and perhaps changing those assumptions.
Basic Process Interventions
For each of the five interpersonal and group processes described, a variety of interventions may be used. In broad terms, these are aimed at making individuals and groups more effective.
Individual Interventions: These are designed to help people be more effective or to increase the information they have about their "blind spot" in the Johari Window. Before process consultants can give individual feedback, they must observe relevant events, ask questions to understand issues fully, and make certain feedback is given in a usable manner. Guidelines for effective feedback include: the giver and receiver must have consensus on the receiver's goals; the giver should emphasize description and appreciation; the giver should be concrete and specific; both giver and receiver must have constructive motives; the giver should not withhold negative feedback if relevant; the giver should own observations, feelings, and judgments; and feedback should be timed when both are ready.
Group Interventions: These are aimed at the process, content, or structure of the group. Process interventions sensitize the group to its own internal processes and generate interest in analyzing them, including comments about relationships, problem solving and decision making, and identity and purpose of the group. Content interventions help the group determine what it works on, including comments about group membership, agenda setting, interpersonal issues, and conceptual inputs. Structural interventions help the group examine stable and recurring methods it uses to accomplish tasks, including methods for dealing with external issues, goal determination, strategy development, responsibility assignment, and relationships to authority.
π Definition β Johari Window: A model for understanding interpersonal awareness and feedback, where the "blind spot" represents information about oneself that others know but the individual does not.
When Is Process Consultation Appropriate?
Process consultation, a general model for helping relationships, has wide applicability in organizations. Because PC helps people and groups own their problems and diagnose and resolve them, it is most applicable when: (1) the client has a problem but does not know its source or how to resolve it; (2) the client is unsure of what kind of help is available; (3) the nature of the problem is such that the client would benefit from involvement in its diagnosis; (4) the client is motivated by goals the consultant can accept; (5) the client ultimately knows what interventions are most applicable; and (6) the client is capable of learning how to assess and resolve their own problem.
Results of Process Consultation
Although process consultation is an important part of organization development and has been widely practiced, only modest research addresses its effect on improving group work accomplishment. The few studies have produced little hard evidence of effectiveness. Research findings on process consultation are unclear, especially regarding task performance.
Three difficulties arise in measuring performance improvements: (1) most process consultation is conducted with groups performing mental tasks (e.g., decision making), and outcomes are difficult to evaluate; (2) process consultation is often combined with other interventions in ongoing OD programs, making it difficult to isolate its impact; and (3) much research uses people's perceptions rather than hard performance measures as the index of success.
Kaplan's review examined published studies in three categories: reports where process intervention is the causal variable but performance is measured inadequately; reports where performance is measured but process consultation is not isolated as the independent variable; and research where process consultation is isolated as the causal variable and performance is adequately measured. The review suggests that process consultation has positive effects on participants according to self-reports of greater personal involvement, higher mutual influence, and group effectiveness. However, very little research clearly demonstrates that objective task effectiveness was increased.
Application 5: Process Consultation at Action Company
This application, often told by Ed Schein, involves the senior management team of a large, innovative high-technology organization (Action Company). The executive committee meetings featured long and loud discussions where members interrupted each other constantly, got into shouting matches, drifted off subject, and moved between agenda points without clear decisions. Initially, the process consultant made "expert" interventions, asking the group to consider consequences of interrupting each other. The group agreed to do better but returned to the same pattern within ten minutes.
π‘ Why this matters: The consultant discovered he was imposing his own beliefs about what an ideal team should look like. This group had different shared assumptions β they were trying to arrive at the "truth," assuming that truth was revealed in ideas that could withstand argument and debate.
Once understanding this premise, the consultant worked within the group's assumptions rather than imposing his beliefs. He went to the flipchart and wrote down main ideas as they emerged. Then, instead of punishing the group for "bad" behavior, he looked for opportunities to turn conversation back to the person with the idea, saying "John, you were trying to make a point. Did we get all of that?" This combination of interventions focused the group on ideas that were about to be lost, resurrecting them for fair consideration. The lesson: until the process consultant understood what the group really was trying to do, he could not focus on the right processes or intervene helpfully.
β Key Takeaways
The process consultant's primary role is to facilitate group self-diagnosis rather than serve as an expert solving problems for the group. Groups perform both task-related activities (giving information, coordinating, evaluating) and group-maintenance actions (encouraging, harmonizing, compromising), with ineffective groups typically neglecting maintenance functions. Premature rejection of ideas can severely damage group effectiveness, as demonstrated in the three-hour meeting example where a member became negative until his suggestion received thorough discussion. Effective feedback must follow specific guidelines including consensus on goals, concreteness, constructive motives, and proper timing. The Action Company case demonstrates the critical lesson that consultants must understand the group's actual operating assumptions β in this case, that truth emerges through intense debate β before they can intervene helpfully rather than imposing their own beliefs about ideal group behavior.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main functions that need to be performed for a group to be effective, and which one is typically neglected in ineffective groups?
- In the taped meeting example, what happened to the member whose suggestion was repeatedly rejected, and what finally allowed him to become productive?
- What are three different methods of decision making in groups, and how can a process consultant help with this process?
- What three types of group interventions exist, and what does each focus on (process, content, or structure)?
- What was the key lesson the process consultant learned from working with Action Company's executive committee about intervening in groups?
π Lecture 30 β Interpersonal and Group Process Approaches
π Overview: This lecture explores third-party interventions, a key OD approach for resolving conflicts between people within organizations. It explains the episodic nature of conflict, strategies for resolution, and the specific techniques and roles of third-party consultants, using the case of Balt Healthcare Corporation as a real-world example.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and purpose of third-party intervention in OD, distinguishing between substantive and interpersonal conflict. It introduces an episodic model of conflict, detailing four control and resolution strategies. The lecture then provides specific tactical choices for facilitating conflict resolution, including data gathering, context setting, and the consultant's role, and concludes with a detailed application case study.
π Lecture Summary
3. Third-Party Interventions
Third-party intervention focuses on conflicts between two or more people within the same organization. Conflict is inherent in groups and organizations and can arise from differences in personality, task orientation, perceptions, and competition for resources. It is important to note that conflict is neither good nor bad per se; it can enhance motivation and innovation but also disrupt necessary task interactions. This intervention is used when conflict significantly disrupts work relationships.
Third-party intervention varies based on the issues underlying the conflict:
- Substantive issues: work methods, pay rates, conditions of employment. Interventions often involve labor-management disputes through arbitration and mediation, or "alternative dispute resolution" (ADR). These are generally not considered part of OD practice.
- Interpersonal issues: personalities and misperceptions. OD has developed approaches to help parties interact directly, facilitating diagnosis and resolution of the conflict.
π Definition β Third-party intervention: A conflict resolution approach used by a neutral consultant to help disputing parties interact directly to diagnose and resolve interpersonal conflicts that disrupt work relationships.
Third-party consultation cannot resolve all conflicts, nor should it. Many conflicts are not severe or may burn out. Managers may resolve conflicts unilaterally when under time pressure or when disputants won't work together in the future.
An Episodic Model of Conflict:
Interpersonal conflict often occurs in iterative, cyclical stages known as episodes. Issues may be latent until something triggers the conflict, bringing it into the open (overt conflict). Because of negative consequences, the unresolved disagreement becomes latent again, and the cycle continues.
Figure 39: A cyclical Model of Interpersonal Conflict (depicts a cycle: Latent Issues β Trigger β Overt Conflict β Consequences β Latent Issues).
Conflict has both costs and benefits. Unresolved conflict can proliferate and expand, and overt conflict may be a symptom of a deeper problem.
The episode model identifies four strategies:
1. Prevent the ignition of conflict: Arrive at a clear understanding of triggering factors and avoid or blunt them. Example: senior management warning research and production managers that conflict will not be tolerated during new product introductions. This may drive conflict underground but can provide a temporary cooling-off period.
2. Set limits on the form of the conflict: Constrain conflict through informal gatherings, exploring options, or setting rules and procedures. Example: a rule that union officials can only resolve grievances at weekly grievance meetings.
3. Help parties cope differently with consequences: The third-party consultant helps devise coping techniques, such as reducing dependence on the relationship, ventilating feelings to friends, or developing additional emotional support. These methods reduce costs without resolving underlying issues.
4. Eliminate or resolve the basic issues: This is the most obvious and straightforward objective but often the most difficult to achieve.
Facilitating the Conflict Resolution Process:
Walton identified factors and tactical choices to help third-party consultants achieve productive dialogue:
- Mutual motivation to resolve the conflict
- Equality of power between the parties
- Coordinated attempts to confront the conflict
- Relevant phasing of identifying differences and searching for integrative solutions
- Open and clear forms of communication
- Productive levels of tension and stress
Tactical choices for the third-party consultant:
1. Diagnosis (Data Gathering): Usually through preliminary interviewing and group-process observations. This provides understanding of the nature and type of conflict, personalities, conflict styles, issues, and participants' readiness.
2. Context of Intervention: Consider the neutrality of the meeting area, formality of the setting, appropriate meeting time, and careful selection of attendees.
3. Role of the Consultant: The role depends on diagnosis of the situation. Roles include:
- Initiating the agenda for the meeting
- Acting as a referee
- Reflecting and restating issues and differing perceptions
- Giving and receiving feedback
- Helping individuals diagnose issues
- Providing suggestions or recommendations
- Helping parties diagnose underlying problems
π‘ Why this matters: The third-party consultant must be highly sensitive, recognize that some tension is normal but too much can be dysfunctional, and must be seen as neutral and unbiased. They must have professional expertise in third-party intervention.
Application 6: Conflict Management at Balt Healthcare Corporation
Background: Pete (general manager, traditional/formal management style) and Dan (manager of an experimental e-commerce group, open/collaborative style) were assigned to work together in the IT department of Balt Healthcare Corporation. Senior management believed Pete's operational expertise would complement Dan's design skills.
Conflict: Pete provided lukewarm support, refused to assign resources, and made it difficult for Dan to access hardware. Dan felt sabotaged and complained to senior management. There was a history of conflict between the two.
Intervention Attempt: Marilyn, the VP, asked an OD specialist to help. The OD specialist met with Pete and Dan separately and identified:
- Different management styles
- Different work processes (routine vs. unpredictable/creative)
- Lack of advance notice from Dan's team
Recommended Strategies: The OD specialist recommended direct confrontation, purchasing new equipment, and mandating cooperation. Marilyn rejected purchasing equipment due to no budget and lacked confidence in facilitating the needed leadership. She agreed to facilitate a direct process with written agreements but failed to follow through, never meeting both parties together. She sent inconsistent messages and began supporting Pete while criticizing Dan.
Outcome: Dan withdrew, productivity suffered, he became hostile and bitter. He took a leave of absence on Marilyn's advice, left the organization, and his project was left without a leader. Pete stayed, but staff were upset his behavior went unquestioned. The organization lost respect for Marilyn and suffered losses in productivity and morale.
π‘ Why this matters: This case demonstrates how poor follow-through, lack of neutrality, and inconsistent messages from a leader can derail conflict resolution and cause worse outcomes than the original conflict.
β Key Takeaways
Third-party intervention is a core OD skill for resolving interpersonal conflicts that disrupt work relationships, focusing on helping parties interact directly to diagnose and resolve issues. The episodic model shows that conflict often follows a cyclical pattern of latency, trigger, and overt behavior, with strategies ranging from controlling the conflict to resolving its underlying causes. Effective third-party consultants must skillfully gather data, set a neutral context, and adopt an appropriate role (truly neutral and expert) to facilitate productive dialogue. The Balt Healthcare case tragically illustrates that lack of follow-through, inconsistent behavior, and loss of neutrality by a leader can worsen conflict, destroy projects, and damage organizational morale. Ultimately, the goal is not to eliminate all conflict but to manage it constructively while recognizing that unresolved conflict can proliferate, expand, and conceal deeper problems.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is third-party intervention and when is it primarily used in OD?
- Distinguish between substantive and interpersonal conflict. Which type does OD typically address?
- Describe the "episodic model of conflict" and name all four conflict resolution strategies derived from it.
- List at least three of the seven ingredients that facilitate productive conflict resolution dialogue.
- In the Balt Healthcare case, what were the three errors that Marilyn and the OD specialist made that led to the failed intervention?
π Lecture 31 β Team Building
π Overview: This lecture examines the concept of team building as a major OD intervention for improving organizational effectiveness. It explores different types of interdependence in teams, various team-building activities, and the processes involved in developing effective work groups. Understanding team dynamics is essential because most organizations rely on teams to coordinate complex tasks and achieve productivity goals.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining teams and teamwork, then explains three types of interdependence (pooled, sequential, and reciprocal) using sports analogies from cricket, football, and basketball. It presents a case study of Starbucks' team-based culture, discusses the need for team building in natural and temporary work teams, and categorizes team-building activities into three types: those relevant to individuals, those oriented to group operations and behavior, and those affecting the group's relationship with the rest of the organization. The lecture concludes with an overview of the team building process.
π Lecture Summary
4. Team Building
A team is a group of individuals with complementary skills who depend upon one another to accomplish a common purpose or set of performance goals for which they hold themselves mutually accountable. Teamwork is work done when members subordinate their personal prominence for the good of the team. Members of effective teams are open and honest with one another, there is support and trust, a high degree of cooperation and collaboration, decisions are reached by consensus, communication channels are open and well developed, and there is a strong commitment to the teamβs goals. Almost 80% of all companies have some type of team-based, employee involvement program in place.
π Definition β Interdependence: situations where one personβs performance is contingent upon how someone else performs.
The lecture uses sports analogies to illustrate types of interdependence:
- Cricket is a game of pooled interdependence where team member contributions are somewhat independent of one another. Players are separated on a large field, not all involved actively in every play, and they come to bat one at a time.
- Football involves sequential interdependence. A flow of players and first downs are required to score. Players are closer to each other than in cricket, and there is greater interdependence. Players are grouped functionally (offense and defense) and the two groups do not contact one another, but all players are involved in every play.
- Basketball exhibits the highest degree of interdependence. Players are closely grouped together, the team moves together on the court, every player may contact any other player, roles are less defined than in football, and all players are involved in offense, defense, and trying to score.
One major OD technique, termed team building or team development, is used for increasing the communication, cooperation, and cohesiveness of units to make them productive and effective. Team building is an intervention where the members of a work group examine such things as their goals, structure, procedures, culture, norms, and interpersonal relationships, to improve their ability to work together effectively and efficiently.
OD in Practice: A Cup of Coffee at Starbucks Howard Schultz, founder and chairperson of Starbucks Coffee Company, uses language like "collaborative," "teams," "empowerment," "empathize," and "vision." Starbucks has over 7,500 stores in 36 countries with over 25 million visitors weekly. The company's six-point mission statement lists number one as "Provide a great work environment and treat each other with respect and dignity." The overriding philosophy is "Leave no one behind." New employees receive 24 hours of in-store training, higher-than-average salaries, and benefit packages. All employees working more than 20 hours a week receive stock options and full health-care benefits. Starbucks employees show an 82% job-satisfaction rate compared to a 50% rate for all employees, and the company has the lowest employee turnover rate of any restaurant or fast-food company.
Need for Team Building
Work teams may be of two basic types:
- Natural work team β people come together because they do related jobs or because of the structure of the organizations design.
- Temporary task team β groups meet for limited periods to work on a specific project or problem and disband after they solve it.
Need for team building varies with situation. The problems that inhibit effective operation include lack of clear objectives, interpersonal differences or conflicts, ineffective communication, difficulty in reaching group decisions, and inappropriate power and authority levels in the group.
Team Building
Team building refers to broad range of planned activities that help a group improve the way they accomplish tasks and help group members enhance interpersonal and problem-solving skills. Effective approach to team building involves:
- Team-Building Activities
- Team Building Process
- The Managerβs Role in Team Building
- When is Team Building Appropriate?
- Results of Team Building
Team-Building Activities
A team is a group of interdependent people who share a common purpose, have common work methods, and hold each other accountable. Factors affecting outcomes of team-building activities include: the length of time allocated to the activity, the teamβs willingness to look at the way in which it operates, the length of time the team has been working together, and the teamβs permanence. Results can range from comparatively modest changes in operating mechanisms (e.g., meeting more frequently) to deeper changes (e.g., modifying behavior patterns, developing greater openness and trust).
Team-building activities can be classified as: (1) activities relevant to one or more individuals; (2) activities specific to the groupβs operation and behavior; and (3) activities affecting the groupβs relationship with the rest of the organization.
Activities Relevant to One or More Individuals
People come into groups with varying needs for achievement, inclusion, influence, and belonging. Almost all team-building efforts result in members gaining a better understanding of how authority, inclusion, emotions, control, and power affect problem solving. These activities provide information so people have a clearer sense of how their needs can be supported, giving members a choice about their level of involvement and commitment.
π Example: In one team, the leader had predetermined actions for each agenda item despite presenting them for discussion. Members felt frustrated by their inability to influence decision making. During team building, they gave specific examples of manipulation, and the boss indicated willingness to be challenged about preconceived decisions, resulting in increased trust and willingness to engage in problem-solving.
Sometimes team building generates pressures on individual members, such as requests for higher task performance. These requests could have negative results unless accompanied by agreement for further one-to-one negotiations among team members.
Activities Oriented to the Groupβs Operation and Behavior
The most common focus is behavior related to task performance and group process. In an effective team, task behavior and group process must be integrated with each other and with the needs of the people. Team-building activities often begin by clarifying the teamβs purpose, priorities, goals, and objectives. Groups spend time finding ways to improve mechanisms that structure their approach to workβdiscussing meeting agenda creation, efficiency of key work processes, or strategies for lowering costs. Groups often examine their communications patterns and determine ways to improve them.
Another issue is effective use of time. The group may examine present planning mechanisms, introduce better ones, and identify ways to use skills and knowledge more effectively. As the group develops, it becomes more aware of the need for action plans and better self-diagnosis. Groups examine problem-solving techniques, and as teams mature, they broaden diagnostic efforts to include interpersonal styles and their impact. Throughout this process, group norms become clearer, and the team becomes more willing to take risks. A spirit of openness, trust, and risk taking develops.
Activities Affecting the Groupβs Relationship with the Rest of the Organization
As the team gains better self-understanding and becomes better able to diagnose and solve its own problems, it focuses on its role within the organization. The team may perceive a need to clarify its organizational role and consider how this role can be improved or modified. Sometimes the team recognizes a need for more collaboration with other parts of the organization and tries to establish working parties or project teams that cross boundaries.
π‘ Why this matters: As the team becomes more cohesive, it usually exerts stronger influence on other subsystems. This is one area where team building can have negative effectsβa highly cohesive team may increase isolation from other groups, leading to intergroup conflict. The process consultant must help the group understand its role, develop diagnostic skills, and examine alternative action plans so that inter-group tensions do not expand.
Team Building Process
Managing a team involves more than supervising people. Managers must bring a divergent group of people together to work on a common project. Since no one person can possess all the knowledge necessary to analyze and solve todayβs complex problems, teams are used to bring together the required expertise. The nature of work groups makes team development interventions probably the single most important and widely used OD activity.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that team building is the most widely used OD intervention, defined as planned activities that help groups improve task accomplishment and enhance interpersonal skills. The three types of interdependenceβpooled (cricket), sequential (football), and reciprocal (basketball)βdetermine how closely team members must work together. Team-building activities fall into three categories: those affecting individuals, those oriented to group operations and behavior, and those affecting the group's organizational relationships. The team building process clarifies goals, improves communication patterns, diagnoses problem-solving techniques, and fosters openness and trust, but must be managed carefully to prevent team isolation and intergroup conflict.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of interdependence illustrated by cricket, football, and basketball, and how do they differ?
- What are the two basic types of work teams, and how do they differ in purpose and duration?
- What are the three categories of team-building activities, and what does each focus on?
- What potential negative effect can result from a team becoming too cohesive during team building?
- According to the lecture, why is team development considered the single most important and widely used OD activity?