đ Lecture 37 â Quality Circles: Employee Involvement
đ Overview: This lecture explores two major employee involvement approaches: Quality Circles and High-Involvement Organizations (HIOs), culminating in Total Quality Management (TQM). It examines how these parallel structures and comprehensive design systems enhance employee participation, productivity, and organizational performance, particularly through the lens of Japanese management practices and their adaptation in the United States.
đď¸ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with Quality Circles, their Japanese origins and American adaptation, structure (members, leaders, facilitators, steering committees), and a detailed case study at H.E.B Grocery Company showing mixed results. It then covers High-Involvement Organizations (HIOs) with their comprehensive design features including structure, job design, information systems, career systems, training, rewards, personnel policies, and physical layout. Finally, it presents Total Quality Management (TQM) principles, characteristics, a case study at L.L. Bean, and a comparison of TQM and OD values.
đ Lecture Summary
Quality Circles: Employee Involvement
Quality circles (or âemployee involvement teamsâ) are small groups of employees who meet voluntarily to identify and solve productivity problems. Originally developed in Japan in the mid-1950s, they are a natural outgrowth of Japanese decentralized decision making and collective responsibility. By the early 1980s, some four thousand American companies had adopted quality circles, driven by the desire to emulate Japanese management practices and achieve quality improvements and cost savings.
However, implementing quality circles in the more autocratic, individualistic cultures of many American companies proves challenging compared to the Japanese philosophy of decentralized, collective decision making that nurtures this approach. đĄ Why this matters: The cultural context significantly affects the success of participative management interventions.
A typical quality circles program uses a parallel structure consisting of several circles, each with three to fifteen voluntary members sharing a common job or work area. Circles meet weekly for about one hour on company time. Members receive training in problem identification and analysis techniques, and apply these to identify, analyze, and recommend solutions to work-related problems. When possible, they implement solutions affecting only their work area without requiring higher management approval.
Each circle has a leader (typically the work area supervisor) who trains members and guides weekly meetings, setting the agenda and facilitating problem-solving. Facilitators coordinate activities of several circles, train leaders, help start circles, and keep upper management informedâthis role may be full-time. A steering committee serves as the central coordinator, composed of facilitators and representatives from major functional departments. The committee determines policies, procedures, and issues outside circle attention (such as wages and union contract topics), coordinates training, and guides program expansion.
đ Definition â Quality Circles: Small groups of employees who meet voluntarily to identify and solve productivity problems.
Application 8: Quality Circles at H.E.B Grocery Company
A quality circles program was implemented as a pilot project at a large warehouse of the H.E.B Grocery Company in Texas. The eighty-person, two-shift warehousing operation volunteered to adopt the program as part of a larger corporate strategy to increase employee involvement. All but four workers volunteered to be part of the pilot circles.
The program consisted of four circles of ten people each, representing a cross-section of workers. Circles met for two hours at two-week intervals. Periodic rotations occurred due to high participationâafter five months, twelve workers dropped out, several left, and twenty-nine new employees joined. Each circle had a worker-leader trained in communication techniques, group process, and problem-solving skills. Leaders formed a leader circle that met regularly to exchange ideas and coordinate the four circles. Supervisors served as resources, while corporate human resources department members served as facilitators. The department head and top managers formed the steering committee.
Researchers conducted a thorough evaluation comparing the warehouse department with a control group. Measures included survey data at three points (five months before, three months after, and ten months after program start), plus measures of productivity, absenteeism, and accidents collected at four-week intervals beginning one year before the program.
Results were mixed. The warehouse showed slightly more positive trends in productivityâproduction quantity increased slightly, while costs, absenteeism, labor expense, overtime, and accidents decreased slightly. Survey data showed warehouse employee attitudes changed little, but unexpectedly, control group attitudes suffered regarding feeling informed, being involved in decision making, and receiving feedback from supervisors. The researchers concluded the circles program might have buffered warehouse employees during a workload disruption.
However, interview and observational data revealed more negative findings. Initial months saw activity and improvement suggestions (equipment maintenance, reduced warehouse congestion, damage prevention). After several months, attendance waned as members found it difficult to identify significant issues within their sphere of influence. Supervisors admitted circles were draining time and energy. A second flurry of activity after member rotation also subsided as members became frustrated with slow implementation, difficulty of systematic problem solving, and failure of the program to affect their jobs. As workload increased, management allowed circles to become inactive.
Participants felt they accomplished something worthwhile and enjoyed the circles. Non-participants or dropouts felt the program never dealt with significant issues and showed marked worsening of attitudes. Supervisors felt payback wasn't worth time spent. Human resources judged it a successful step toward employee involvement.
Observations suggested reasons the program died: group functioning did not improve, systematic problem-solving techniques were not followed, implementation was delayed in bureaucratic channels (creating perceptions of low management commitment), and active participants became disenchanted with jobs and sought supervisory ranks. Some members felt inadequately compensated for generating money-saving ideas.
The researchers concluded the program was successful as a pilot projectâthe company learned about the level of commitment and energy required to sustain such programs and continued experimenting with other approaches, holding more realistic expectations. The rigorous and contradictory assessment measures strongly suggest research on quality circles must go beyond glowing testimonials to include whether programs effect valued individual and organization outcomes.
High-Involvement Organizations
High-involvement organizations (HIOs) create organizational conditions that support high levels of employee participation. Unlike parallel structures that do not alter the formal organization, in HIOs almost all organization features are designed jointly by management and workers to promote high involvement and performanceâincluding structure, work design, information and control systems, physical layout, personnel policies, and reward systems.
đ Definition â High-Involvement Organizations (HIOs): Organizations where almost all features are designed jointly by management and workers to promote high levels of employee participation and performance.
Features of High Involvement Organizations
HIO design features are congruent and mutually reinforcing. Employees have considerable influence over decisions, supported by extensive training in problem-solving techniques, plant operation, and organizational policies. Both operational and issue-oriented information is shared widely and easily obtained. Rewards are tied closely to unit performance and knowledge/skill levels.
Key HIO design elements include:
Organization Structure: Flat, lean structures push scheduling, planning, and controlling toward the shop floor. Mini-enterprise, team-based structures oriented to common purpose help focus participation. Participative structures (work councils, union-management committees) allow workers to influence direction and policies.
Job Design: Jobs with high discretion, task variety, and meaningful feedback enhance involvement. Self-managed teams encourage responsibility through cross-training and job rotation.
Information System: Open systems tied to jobs or work teams provide necessary information for meaningful participation. Goals and standards set participatively provide commitment and motivation.
Career System: Different tracks for advancement with counseling help employees plan long-term development. Open job posting makes employees aware of development opportunities.
Selection: Realistic job previews provide information about working in HIO situations. Team involvement in selection oriented to potential and process skills facilitates a participative climate.
Training: Heavy commitment to knowledge and skills for effective participation, including economic education and interpersonal skill development. Peer training is emphasized as valuable adjunct to formal training.
Reward System: Open information about rewards, skill-based rewards, gain sharing or ownership, flexible benefits, all-salaried workforce, and egalitarian perquisites.
Personnel Policies: Participatively set policies encouraging stability of employment provide strong commitment from employees.
Physical Layout: Designs supporting team structures and reducing status differences reinforce egalitarian climate. Safe and pleasant working conditions provide environment conducive to participation.
These design features are mutually reinforcingâthey send a message that people are important, respected, valued, capable of growing, and trusted. They motivate and focus organizational behavior in strategic directions, leading to superior effectiveness and competitive advantage.
Total Quality Management
Total quality management (TQM) is the most recent and comprehensive approach to employee involvement, along with HIOs. Also known as âcontinuous process improvementâ and âcontinuous quality,â TQM grew from manufacturing quality control and represents a long-term effort to orient all organizational activities around quality. Quality is achieved when organizational processes reliably produce products and services that meet or exceed customer expectations.
đ Definition â Total Quality Management (TQM): A philosophy and set of guiding principles for continuous improvement based on customer satisfaction, teamwork, and empowerment of individuals, applying human resources and analytical tools to focus on meeting or exceeding customer needs.
Like HIO designs, TQM increases workers' knowledge and skills through extensive training, provides relevant information, pushes decision-making power downward, and ties rewards to performance. When successful, TQM is aligned closely with business strategy and attempts to change the entire organization toward continuous quality improvement.
Characteristics of TQM
TQM has several common principles:
- Organization-wide: TQM takes place in production, accounting, HR, marketing, sales, and all other areas.
- CEO and top management support: Everyone operates under TQM with reward systems ensuring continual support.
- Three or more years duration: Significant resource allocation for training is crucial. Motorola developed a University teaching in 27 languages, allocating at least 1.5% of budget to education, requiring minimum 40 hours training per year per employee, supporting âsix sigmaâ quality (99.9997% perfection).
- Ingrained corporate value: Continuous improvement penetrates culture and values.
- Partnership with customers and suppliers: Products/services must meet or exceed customer expectations.
- Everyone has a customer: The next person on the production line, another department, or external purchaser are all customers.
- Reduced cycle time: Focus on doing jobs faster for products, services, and support functions.
- Techniques range in scope: Including statistical quality control, job design, empowerment, self-managed work teams.
- Do it right the first time: Quality is built in at every stage, not obtained by rejecting products at end of production line.
- Organization values and respects everyone: Includes customers, suppliers, employees, owners, community, and environment (stakeholders).
- No single formula works for everyone: What succeeded at one company may not work at another.
Application 9: Total Quality Management at L.L. Bean
L.L. Bean, a Maine-based mail-order company, had a reputation for superior customer service dating back to 1912 founder Leon Leonwood Bean. Chairman Leon Gorman applied for the Malcolm Baldridge National Quality Award in 1988 (first year in service category). Despite reputation, L.L. Bean won no awardâno award was given in service category that year.
The Baldridge feedback prompted Bean to examine its quality culture. While customer service was âworld class,â the committee thought the firm was not achieving customer satisfaction productively. Bean relied on a âno-questions askedâ guarantee-based approach rather than ensuring things happened right the first time. A story illustrated this: a customer service representative drove a canoe to a customer in New Yorkâexemplary service, but the order had been placed in time to be shipped properly.
The diagnostic information also revealed Bean needed more employee involvement. Despite implementing quality circles ten years earlier, decision making had usually taken place at a high level.
Based on feedback, the organization defined âtotal qualityâ (TQ) as âmanaging an enterprise to maximize customer satisfaction in the most efficient and effective way possible by totally involving people in improving the way work is done.â
Bean spent approximately ten months training three thousand employees. All salaried employees received three days of TQ training, then hourly workers received one day. Senior executives trained first so each level could support total quality as the next level learned.
Human resources explored ways to change infrastructure for greater employee involvement. Because L.L. Bean is a service organization, decisions influencing quality occur every time a customer calls phone centersâso frontline, customer-contact employees needed to be knowledgeable and empowered, requiring new managerial roles aimed at involving employees.
Seventy members formed seven cross-functional teams. One team defined the manager's role as coach and developer. Another created a feedback instrument linking managers' compensation to improvements in behaviors like being âaspiring and focused, ethical and compassionate, customer focused and aligned, effective and efficient, challenging and empowering, open and innovating, and rewarding and developing.â
Employee involvement paid dividends. In manufacturing, a manager shut down a work line despite productivity pressures to teach workers how a shoe is costed outâemployees found enough savings that day to pay for all department training for the entire year. In another case, stockers and pickers swapped jobs temporarily and realized there was no reason for packaging itemsânow pickers simply roll carts directly onto trucks.
Human resources reengineered from functional structure to customer-oriented organization, with service teams supporting major divisions with process improvement, health and safety, employee relations, and training.
Through all changes, customer satisfaction remained high and job satisfaction increased more than 12%. Although only halfway through its TQ intervention, L.L. Bean experienced increased profitability, return on sales, and return on equity.
TQM and OD Have Similar Values
TQM and OD share certain values: both are system-wide, depend on planned change, believe in empowerment and involvement, are self-renewing and continuous, base decision-making on data-based activities, and view people as having inherent desire to contribute meaningfully.
However, differences exist. Some OD practitioners argue their core values differ and caution against OD practitioners assuming the role of âquality management expert.â The OD practitioner enters as a neutral party, resisting advocacy of any particular change method, viewing problems as having varied causes with no predefined solutions. The TQM consultant, in contrast, views organization problems as having TQM solutions.
TQM can be applied as one change methodology alongside other interventions. TQM is more likely to be successful when combined with employee involvementâthe two are complementary, and the impact of either is diminished by the absence of the other.
â Key Takeaways
The lecture presents a progression from parallel structures (Quality Circles) to comprehensive organizational redesign (HIOs) to organization-wide philosophy (TQM). Quality circles, while popular, often fail due to lack of management commitment, bureaucratic delays, and insufficient problem-solving skillsâas demonstrated by the H.E.B case. High-Involvement Organizations require mutually reinforcing design features across structure, job design, information systems, training, rewards, and physical layout. TQM represents the most comprehensive approach, requiring organization-wide commitment, customer focus, continuous improvement, and employee empowermentâas shown by L.L. Bean's transformation. TQM and OD share core values of empowerment and data-based decision making, but OD practitioners must remain neutral rather than advocating predetermined solutions.
đ§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key structural components of a quality circles program, and what roles do leaders, facilitators, and steering committees play?
- According to the H.E.B Grocery Company case study, what factors contributed to the gradual death of the quality circles program?
- List at least six design features of High-Involvement Organizations (HIOs) and explain how they are mutually reinforcing.
- What are the key principles or components of Total Quality Management (TQM)?
- How did L.L. Bean use feedback from the Malcolm Baldridge National Quality Award to transform its approach to quality and employee involvement?